Step Score Strategy for DO Graduates: Psychiatry Residency Guide

Understanding Step Scores in the Psychiatry Match as a DO Graduate

For a DO graduate aiming for psychiatry, your Step and COMLEX scores matter—but they are only one part of a bigger story. Psychiatry remains relatively friendly to DO applicants, and many programs value the strengths DO graduates bring: strong clinical skills, holistic perspective, and often excellent communication.

However, the landscape has changed with:

• USMLE Step 1 becoming Pass/Fail
• Increased competitiveness in psychiatry
• More MD and international graduates applying

A smart Step score strategy for a DO graduate in psychiatry must:

• Understand how programs interpret USMLE and COMLEX
• Address low Step or COMLEX scores directly
• Optimize Step 2 CK and Level 2-CE performance
• Leverage every other part of your application to offset test weaknesses

This article focuses on practical strategies tailored to:

• DO graduates with mixed or low Step/COMLEX performance
• Applicants wondering how to optimize a Step 2 CK strategy
• Those concerned about being a low Step score match candidate in psychiatry

You can absolutely match psychiatry as a DO with less-than-ideal scores—if you approach this strategically and early.

---

How Programs View DO Applicants, COMLEX, and Step Scores in Psychiatry

1. DO vs MD in Psychiatry: Where You Stand

Psychiatry continues to have:

• A substantial proportion of DO residents in many programs
• Program directors who are open to DO training backgrounds
• Growing recognition of osteopathic principles as particularly relevant to mental health and holistic care

What this means for a DO graduate:

• You are not at a categorical disadvantage in psychiatry.
• Your USMLE/COMLEX testing profile will be important but not necessarily decisive.
• Your narrative, letters of recommendation, and clinical performance can strongly compensate.

2. COMLEX vs USMLE: Do You Need Both?

For DO graduates, the question is often: “Is COMLEX alone enough, or do I also need USMLE Step 1 and/or Step 2 CK?”

General patterns in psychiatry:

• Many community and some university-affiliated psychiatry programs accept COMLEX alone.
• A growing number of academic/university psychiatry programs strongly prefer or require USMLE (often Step 2 CK if Step 1 wasn’t taken or is Pass/Fail).
• Some program filters on ERAS are set around USMLE scores only, which may unintentionally disadvantage DOs without USMLE.

If you have only COMLEX:

• Target programs that explicitly accept COMLEX alone.
• Email programs where it’s unclear and ask if COMLEX-only applicants are considered equitably.
• Use your personal statement and letters to highlight strengths other than test scores.

If you have both COMLEX and USMLE:

• Programs often anchor on your USMLE scores if available.
• COMLEX is still relevant, especially for programs with DO-heavy leadership or strong osteopathic affiliations.
• Ensure consistency: if there’s a big discrepancy (e.g., average COMLEX but low USMLE), be ready to explain briefly if asked.

3. Impact of Step 1 (Pass/Fail) on a DO Graduate

With Step 1 now Pass/Fail, differences between DO and MD applicants have shifted:

• Programs now lean more heavily on:
  • Step 2 CK
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE
  • Clerkship grades
  • Narrative evaluations and letters
• A Pass on Step 1 is necessary, but no longer stratifies applicants numerically.
• For DO applicants, this makes Step 2 CK strategy absolutely critical if you choose to take it.

If you did not take Step 1 (USMLE):

• You can still be competitive for many psychiatry programs.
• Prioritize a strong Step 2 CK (if taken) and strong COMLEX Level 2-CE performance.
• Emphasize clinical excellence and psychiatry-specific experiences to demonstrate readiness.

---

Step 2 CK Strategy for DO Graduates Targeting Psychiatry

Because Step 1 is now Pass/Fail, Step 2 CK has become the primary standardized academic metric for many programs, including psychiatry. As a DO graduate, this holds whether or not you already have a COMLEX transcript.

1. Should a DO Take Step 2 CK?

Use this framework:

Take Step 2 CK if:

• You want to be considered by university/academic psychiatry programs, especially in competitive metros.
• Your COMLEX Level 1 score is modest or borderline, and you need a stronger data point to show improvement.
• You are worried about being a low Step score match candidate and want to demonstrate an upward trend.

Consider NOT taking Step 2 CK (or be cautious) if:

• Your COMLEX performance is already weak, and you are not prepared to substantially improve your test-taking.
• You can build a realistic and satisfying program list of COMLEX-friendly psychiatry programs.
• You’re short on time and resources to meaningfully prepare—and a rushed, low Step 2 CK might hurt more than help.

When in doubt, discuss with:

• Your school’s academic advisor or dean’s office
• A trusted psychiatry mentor who understands current match dynamics

2. Target Score Mindset for Psychiatry

Psychiatry is less score-driven than surgical or derm specialties, but numbers still matter for screening.

While exact targets vary by year and applicant pool, a practical approach:

• “Safe”/Comfortable Zone for Many Psychiatry Programs:

  • Step 2 CK: Around or somewhat above national mean (exact mean varies by year)
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE: At or above national mean

• Lower but Still Viable Zone:

  • Step 2 CK: Below mean but passed on first attempt
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE: Modestly below mean
  • Supported by strong:
    • Psychiatry letters
    • Clinical performance
    • Personal statement
    • Program fit

• High-Risk Zone (requires strategic mitigation):

  • Step 2 CK or COMLEX Level 2-CE failures
  • Very low Step 2 CK compared with your peers
  • Multiple board exam attempts

If you’re in the lower zones, your strategy becomes:

1. Avoid additional low scores (no “data flooding” with unprepared retakes).
2. Use a focused, evidence-based study plan for any remaining exams.
3. Overcompensate in other parts of your application.

3. Practical Step 2 CK Study Strategy for DO Psychiatry Applicants

You don’t need a perfect score—you need a solid, upward-trending score that reassures program directors. Consider this structured plan:

A. Diagnose Your Starting Point

• Review COMLEX Level 1 performance:
  • Which systems and disciplines were weak?
  • Were there patterns (fatigue, timing, anxiety)?
• Take a baseline NBME for Step 2 CK (if planning to take it) at least 10–12 weeks before exam date.

B. Build a DO-Specific Resource Stack

1. Primary Question Banks

   • UWorld Step 2 CK (non-negotiable if taking Step 2 CK)
   • COMBANK or COMQUEST for COMLEX-focused practice (if still taking Level 2-CE)

2. High-Yield References

   • Online Med Ed or similar for core internal medicine, neurology, OB/GYN, pediatrics
   • Psych-specific:
     • A dedicated psychiatry shelf review resource (e.g., case-based book or question set)
     • DSM-5 criteria familiarity for core disorders

3. Timing and Scheduling

   • Plan 8–12 dedicated study weeks if possible.
   • Daily structure:
     • 40–60 UWorld questions/day in timed, mixed mode
     • 1–2 hours of focused review on weak topics
     • Regular, timed practice exams every 2–3 weeks

C. Prioritize Psychiatry-Relevant Domains Even though Step 2 is broad, for a psychiatry residency, programs like to see:

• Strong performance in:
  • Neurology
  • Psychiatry
  • Internal medicine (especially geriatrics, chronic disease, substance use)
• Comfortable handling of:
  • Psychopharmacology
  • Toxicology
  • Delirium vs dementia vs primary psychosis

As you review UWorld, tag psychiatry and neuro questions for re-review. This shows up on score reports as subject strengths.

D. Avoid Common Pitfalls

• Don’t cram: Cramming leads to inconsistent performance and often a disappointing Step 2 CK score.
• Don’t ignore your DO exams: If you still need COMLEX Level 2, balance prep—there are stylistic test differences (e.g., OMM, question style).
• Don’t test “just to have a score”: A very low Step 2 CK may close more doors than no Step 2 CK score at all.

---

Matching Psychiatry with Low or Borderline Step/COMLEX Scores: A Strategy Playbook

Being in the low Step score match category does not end your psychiatry goals, but it demands a more deliberate approach.

1. Reframing Your Application Narrative

You must answer silently for each program: “Why should we trust this applicant to handle psychiatry training despite lower test scores?”

Your narrative should:

• Show clear, enduring interest in psychiatry:
  • Longitudinal involvement (e.g., psychiatry interest group, research, volunteer work in mental health)
  • Rotations and electives in psychiatry, ideally with strong evaluations
• Demonstrate growth and resilience:
  • Improvement from Level 1 to Level 2, or from Step 1 (if numeric) to Step 2 CK
  • Professionalism, self-awareness, and insight into prior test performance

In your personal statement, you can briefly (1–2 sentences) acknowledge academic struggles, but:

• Do not focus your entire essay on explaining scores.
• Emphasize what you learned and how you improved your habits, not excuses.

2. Targeted Program Selection for DOs with Lower Scores

To maximize chances in the osteopathic residency match landscape (now integrated with NRMP), you need a smart program list.

Prioritize:

• Programs that:
  • Have a history of matching DO graduates consistently.
  • List COMLEX as acceptable or equivalent to USMLE.
  • Do not post rigid numeric cutoffs that you clearly don’t meet.
• Geographic regions:
  • Where you have ties (family, prior training, residence).
  • With historically more DO-friendly environments (often Midwest, some Southern states, some community-based programs).

Avoid overloading on:

• Ultra-competitive, research-heavy, big-name academic centers that state:
  • Preferences for high Step scores.
  • Minimal DO representation in current residents.
  • No mention of COMLEX or DOs in their recruitment materials.

Actionable step:
Create a 3-tiered list:

• Tier 1 (Reach): Strong academic psychiatry programs that accept DOs and have some history of DO residents.
• Tier 2 (Target): University-affiliated and high-quality community programs with evident DO representation.
• Tier 3 (Safety): Programs with substantial DO presence, community focus, and no strict score cutoffs.

Aim for a robust application volume if scores are low:

• Often 40–60+ programs in psychiatry, adjusted by your specific score profile and other strengths.

3. Maximizing Clinical Rotations and Letters

When boards are not a strength, your clinical story must shine.

Focus on:

• Psychiatry core rotation performance:
  • Honors or top evaluations if possible.
  • Strong narrative comments emphasizing empathy, communication, and reliability.
• Sub-internships / Away rotations in psychiatry:
  • Especially at programs you might rank highly.
  • Treat these as month-long interviews: punctual, engaged, professional.

For letters:

• Aim for 2 strong psychiatry letters, ideally from:
  • A program director or clerkship director in psychiatry.
  • A faculty psychiatrist who supervised you closely.
• Ensure letter writers:
  • Know your clinical skills well.
  • Can comment positively on professionalism, teachability, and growth.
  • Are aware of your exam story and can frame it as not defining your capabilities.

4. Strengthening the Rest of Your Application

To counterbalance weaker metrics:

• Research and scholarly activity (not mandatory, but helpful):

  • Case reports in psychiatry.
  • Quality improvement or education projects related to mental health.
  • Posters at local or national psychiatric conferences (e.g., APA, regional meetings).

• Mental health advocacy and service:

  • Volunteer work at crisis centers, community mental health clinics, or support groups.
  • Demonstrated long-term involvement rather than last-minute additions.

• Evidence of professionalism and leadership:

  • Roles in student organizations, especially psychiatry interest groups or wellness/mental health initiatives.
  • Committee work, peer tutoring, or mentoring roles.

Programs often choose between:

• Applicant A: Higher scores but minimal commitment to psychiatry.
• Applicant B: Modest scores but deeply engaged, clinically strong, and obviously passionate.

Psychiatry programs, more than many others, often choose Applicant B.

---

Interview and Post-Interview Strategy with Imperfect Step Scores

Once you reach the interview stage, your Step score matters far less. You’re now being evaluated as a potential colleague.

1. Preparing for Questions About Scores

You may or may not be asked about low or failed scores directly. If you are:

Use a concise, honest framework:

1. Own it briefly:
   “I struggled with standardized exams early on, and my Step/COMLEX score reflects that.”
2. Explain without making excuses:
   Mention 1–2 contributing factors (e.g., poor study strategy, overcommitted schedule) without blaming others.
3. Highlight growth and corrective action:
   “I met with academic support, changed my study structure, and my performance on subsequent exams and clinical rotations improved.”
4. Pivot to strengths:
   Emphasize clinical feedback, patient rapport, or improved later scores.

Avoid:

• Long, emotional narratives about the unfairness of the exam.
• Over-disclosure of personal health issues unless directly relevant and thoughtfully framed.

2. Showcasing DO Strengths in Psychiatry

During interviews, lean into what makes you a strong DO graduate for psychiatry:

• Holistic, biopsychosocial perspective that aligns naturally with psychiatric care.
• Strong physical exam and general medicine skills—important for managing medical comorbidities in psych patients.
• Experience with OMT when appropriate (e.g., for chronic pain, headaches, somatic symptom disorders) as part of whole-person care.

Programs often appreciate DOs who can:

• Integrate physical and mental health care.
• Communicate well with multidisciplinary teams.
• Bring a patient-centered, empathetic approach.

3. Ranking Strategy for DO Applicants with Low Scores

When building your rank list:

• Rank based on fit and training quality, not just prestige.
• Consider:
  • Presence of supportive faculty and culture.
  • Openness about remediation or support for residents who struggle.
  • DO representation in current residents.
  • Program’s attitude toward wellness and mental health of trainees.

If you are a low Step score match candidate:

• Still rank all programs where you would be willing to train.
• Do not “punish” a program by ranking it low solely due to location if it is otherwise supportive and DO-friendly.
• Avoid trying to “game” the algorithm; list programs in the genuine order of your preference.

---

Putting It All Together: A Summary Strategy for DO Graduates Aiming for Psychiatry

1. Clarify your exam plan early:

   • Decide whether to take Step 2 CK based on your COMLEX history and target programs.
   • If taking Step 2 CK, treat it as your main academic demonstration of readiness.

2. Optimize scores without obsessing over perfection:

   • Aim for solid, not necessarily stellar, performance.
   • Use deliberate, evidence-based prep for Step 2 CK and Level 2-CE.

3. Counterbalance lower scores with strong psychiatry evidence:

   • Excellent clinical evaluations and sub-internships in psychiatry.
   • Multiple strong letters from psychiatrists.
   • Longitudinal mental health involvement, advocacy, or research.

4. Target programs strategically:

   • Identify DO- and COMLEX-friendly psychiatry residencies.
   • Build a well-distributed list of reach, target, and safety programs.

5. Emphasize growth, insight, and fit:

   • Briefly acknowledge, then move beyond scores in your narrative.
   • Show that you understand the realities of psychiatry training and are prepared for them.

Your Step and COMLEX scores are data points—not destiny. With a thoughtful Step 2 CK strategy, realistic program targeting, and an application that highlights your authentic commitment to psychiatry, a DO graduate can match successfully—even with low or borderline scores.

---

FAQs: Step Score Strategy for DO Graduates in Psychiatry

1. Can I match psychiatry with only COMLEX scores and no USMLE?
Yes. Many psychiatry programs consider COMLEX-only DO applicants, especially community and some university-affiliated programs. However, some highly competitive academic programs either require or strongly prefer USMLE scores. If your program list is heavily academic or in very competitive locations, Step 2 CK can broaden your options.

2. How bad is it to have a low Step 2 CK or COMLEX Level 2-CE score for psychiatry?
A low score is not ideal, but far from automatically disqualifying, especially in psychiatry. Programs will weigh:

• Whether you passed on the first attempt
• Your trend (improvement from Level 1/Step 1)
• Your clinical evaluations and letters
• Your overall fit and professionalism
  If you are in the low Step score match category, focus aggressively on clinical excellence, tailored program selection, and a strong interview performance.

3. Should I retake a failed or very low board exam attempt before applying to psychiatry?
If you failed an exam, you generally must pass before starting residency, and many programs prefer that you have passed before they rank you. If it’s a low but passing score, retaking is rarely an option and often not advisable. Instead, invest effort in making the next exam (e.g., Step 2 CK or Level 2-CE) as strong as possible, and bolster the rest of your application.

4. As a DO, do I need research to match into psychiatry, especially if my scores are not great?
Research is not mandatory for most psychiatry programs, and many successful DO matches have minimal or no research. However, small, achievable psychiatry-related projects (case reports, QI, posters) can help distinguish you and demonstrate academic curiosity—especially if your scores are modest. For DO graduates with low scores, even modest scholarly work can help show engagement and motivation, but it should not come at the expense of preparing adequately for Step 2 CK or clinical performance.