Choosing Between Academic and Private Practice in Emergency Medicine-IM

Understanding Career Paths in EM-IM: Why This Decision Matters

For physicians trained in combined Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine (EM IM combined), the transition from residency to early career brings a pivotal question: academic vs private practice. Both paths offer rewarding opportunities in emergency medicine internal medicine practice, but they differ significantly in daily work, expectations, compensation, and long‑term growth.

Because EM-IM physicians are uniquely versatile—comfortable in the ED, ICU, and inpatient wards—the choice of setting can profoundly shape how you use your dual training. This article focuses on the post-residency and job market phase, specifically for those in EM-IM who are choosing a career path in medicine and weighing:

• Academic medicine career
• Hybrid academic–community roles
• Pure private practice
• Non-traditional or portfolio careers

We’ll look at how each environment affects:

• Scope of clinical practice
• Lifestyle and schedule
• Teaching and research
• Compensation and job security
• Long-term professional development

By the end, you should have a realistic framework for deciding whether an academic medicine career or private practice vs academic route best fits your EM-IM skills, values, and goals.

---

Defining Academic and Private Practice in EM-IM

Before comparing, it helps to clarify what “academic” and “private practice” actually mean in the EM-IM context.

What Is an Academic Medicine Career in EM-IM?

An academic position is usually based at:

• A university-affiliated hospital
• A major teaching hospital with residency programs
• A safety-net or county hospital with strong educational missions

Key features:

• Tripartite mission: Clinical care, teaching, and scholarship/research
• Faculty appointment: Instructor, Assistant/Associate Professor, or Professor
• Educational roles: Supervising residents and medical students in the ED and on inpatient/consult services
• Research/administrative time: Often “protected time” for research, QI, education, or leadership
• Promotion and tenure: Advancement based on a combination of clinical excellence, teaching, scholarship, and service

For EM-IM physicians, academic roles may include:

• Split clinical time between ED and hospital medicine/ICU
• Core residency or fellowship faculty (EM, IM, EM-IM, critical care, ultrasound, etc.)
• Leadership in combined EM-IM or EM-critical care pathways
• Educational roles such as clerkship or program director

What Does Private Practice Look Like for EM-IM?

Private practice in the EM-IM space typically means working for:

• An independent emergency medicine or hospitalist group
• A large contract management group (CMG)
• A physician-owned group staffing community EDs and hospitals
• A hospital-employed group that is not heavily academic

Key features:

• Clinical work as the primary focus
• Little to no formal expectation for teaching or research (though informal education often happens)
• Compensation more closely tied to productivity (RVUs, shifts, or bonus structures)
• Greater variation in scheduling models and autonomy
• Fewer committee and academic obligations

For EM-IM physicians, private practice may look like:

• Pure emergency medicine work at community EDs
• Pure hospital medicine or ICU work
• A self-negotiated combination of ED and inpatient shifts if a group or hospital values your dual skill set
• Leadership roles in operations, quality, or group management rather than academic promotion

---

How Work Actually Feels: Daily Life in Academic vs Private Practice

Clinical Workload and Case Mix

Academic EM-IM

• Case mix: Often higher acuity, more complex patients, especially at tertiary or quaternary centers.
• Teaching impact:
  • Slower pace at times due to teaching and documentation review.
  • You may see fewer patients personally but handle more complex decision-making.
• Dual practice opportunities:
  • More likely to have formalized roles where you split time (e.g., 60% ED, 40% inpatient or ICU).
  • Easier to maintain procedural skills in both domains (intubations, central lines, LPs, etc.).
• Consultation and resources:
  • Readily available subspecialty support, advanced imaging, and procedures.
  • Robust critical care, cardiology, neurology coverage, which can improve care but reduce autonomy in some decisions.

Private Practice EM-IM

• Case mix:
  • Varies widely by community—some are high-acuity regional centers; others are lower-acuity, high-volume EDs or general medical floors.
• Flow and pace:
  • Often faster throughput expectations; metrics like door-to-doc time, length of stay, and RVUs per hour may be emphasized.
• Dual practice feasibility:
  • Many positions are pure EM or pure IM; using both skill sets may require negotiation or seeking out unique groups that value EM-IM versatility.
  • In smaller hospitals, your broad skill set may be crucial—handling boarding ICU patients in the ED or stepping into hospitalist roles in staffing crises.
• Autonomy:
  • In community settings, you may make more definitive decisions before transfer or consultation, especially when resources are limited.

Teaching and Mentorship

Academic Setting

• Teaching is central: supervising EM, IM, EM-IM, and transitional year residents, as well as students.
• Formal roles:
  • Didactic teaching, simulation, journal clubs, M&M conferences.
  • Curriculum development for EM-IM tracks or critical care rotations.
• Feedback and evaluation:
  • Regularly assessing learners; participating in CCC (Clinical Competency Committee) and recruitment (interview days).
• Mentorship:
  • You’re both a mentor (to trainees) and a mentee (with senior faculty guiding your academic growth).
• Impact:
  • Strong platform for influencing future EM and IM practice and building an educational portfolio.

Private Practice

• Limited formal teaching:
  • Some community sites host occasional students or residents, but expectations are lower.
• Informal teaching:
  • Educating nurses, APPs, and colleagues in new protocols or clinical updates.
• Fewer academic committee obligations:
  • Allows more time for pure clinical practice but fewer structured mentorship opportunities and less exposure to academic networks.

Work–Life Balance and Scheduling

This varies widely by institution and group, but there are patterns.

Academic EM-IM

• Schedules often include:
  • A blend of days, evenings, nights, and weekends in ED and/or inpatient settings.
  • Protected administrative/academic time that is not clinical.
• Work–life balance:
  • Can be positive if protected time is real and clinical load is reasonable.
  • Can be challenging if “protected” time gets eaten by clinical coverage gaps or committee responsibilities.
• Flexibility:
  • Generally less flexible in shift trading than small private groups, but often more predictable annual scheduling.
• Family and personal time:
  • Many academic institutions support part-time or modified FTE arrangements, especially for junior faculty or those with caregiving responsibilities—though this is highly variable.

Private Practice EM-IM

• Scheduling models:
  • Pure shift work, often without non-clinical duties.
  • Greater flexibility in trading shifts, picking up extra work, or negotiating FTE.
• Work–life balance:
  • Can be excellent if you prefer “work hard, then fully off” without academic obligations.
  • May be more vulnerable to pressure to see more patients, pick up extra shifts, or respond to volume surges.
• Night and weekend burden:
  • Can be heavy in both settings, but in private groups you may have more leverage to adjust your schedule in exchange for financial trade-offs.

---

Compensation, Benefits, and Job Security

Salary and Income Potential

In general:

• Private practice tends to offer higher starting and mid-career compensation.
• Academic positions pay less in base salary but may offer non-monetary rewards (protected time, academic identity, institutional benefits).

Academic EM-IM

Typical features:

• Salary often standardized by rank and FTE.
• Modest RVU- or bonus-based incentives.
• Lower income than comparable private practice roles in many markets.
• Potential supplemental income from:
  • Fellowships or subspecialty clinical work (e.g., critical care, ultrasound).
  • Extra shifts or moonlighting opportunities (sometimes within the same health system).

Private Practice EM-IM

Typical features:

• Higher base or productivity-based compensation.
• Pay closely linked to:
  • Number of shifts worked or RVUs generated.
  • Night/weekend differentials or high-acuity coverage.
• Ownership and partnership:
  • In some physician-owned groups, opportunity to become a partner and share in group profits.
• Variability:
  • Market conditions, payer mix, and hospital contracts can cause significant income differences between regions.

Benefits and Perks

Academic

• Often strong institutional benefits:
  • Retirement plans with employer contribution, health and dental insurance, tuition benefits, loan repayment programs.
• Professional development:
  • Funding for conferences, educational courses, and CME.
• Stability of large institutions:
  • Less vulnerable to abrupt contract changes than some private groups.

Private Practice

• Variable benefits:
  • Some groups offer excellent benefits; others expect you to cover more personally.
• CME and professional development:
  • Sometimes more limited or negotiated individually.
• Tax and financial planning opportunities:
  • More room to optimize income through 1099/partnership structures, retirement vehicles, or side gigs.

Job Security and Market Dynamics

Academic Medicine

• Often more stable:
  • University or large health system employment tends to be more secure.
• Risks:
  • Budget cuts, restructuring of departments, or loss of funding for certain programs.
• Promotion:
  • Academic promotion can be slow, but job loss is less tied to short-term metrics.

Private Practice

• Contract-based risks:
  • Loss or turnover of hospital contracts can destabilize group employment.
• Market trends:
  • Consolidation, CMG competition, and payer pressures can affect compensation and staffing.
• Performance metrics:
  • Greater pressure to meet productivity and satisfaction targets to remain valuable.

---

Academic vs Private Practice: Long-Term Growth and Professional Identity

Academic Promotion and Scholarly Work

Academic EM-IM

If you choose an academic medicine career, you’ll encounter formal expectations such as:

• Scholarship:
  • Original research, QI projects, educational innovation, case series, or review articles.
• Teaching portfolio:
  • Documented resident and student teaching, evaluations, and curriculum involvement.
• Service:
  • Committees, leadership positions, program development (e.g., EM-IM track, sepsis protocols).

Career paths might include:

• Program leadership: Assistant/Associate Program Director, Program Director for EM, IM, or combined EM-IM.
• Medical education: Clerkship director, simulation director, vice chair of education.
• Research: Principal investigator on EM critical care, sepsis, resuscitation, or health services projects.
• Hospital leadership: ED medical director, chief of hospital medicine, associate CMO.

The identity you develop is often: “I’m an academic EM-IM physician who practices clinically and advances education or research.”

Professional Growth in Private Practice

Private practice offers different but equally valid growth paths:

• Operational leadership:
  • Site medical director, regional director, quality improvement lead, throughput champion.
• Business and group leadership:
  • Partner, board member, or shareholder in the physician group.
• Clinical excellence:
  • Becoming the “go-to” clinician for complex cases, sepsis protocols, or critical care management in community settings.
• System-level roles:
  • Chair of ED/hospital committees, involvement in EMS medical direction, or telemedicine leadership.

Your identity may be: “I’m a high-performing EM-IM clinician who leads operations and quality in a community system.”

How EM-IM Training Fits into Each Path

In Academic Medicine:

• EM-IM training is often highly valued:
  • You can teach across departments and bridge silos.
  • You’re well suited for programs that blend ED and inpatient/ICU rotations.
• Unique roles:
  • Core faculty for EM-IM or EM-critical care fellows.
  • Liaison between ED and inpatient services for throughput and boarding issues.
• Added training:
  • Many EM-IM academics pursue fellowships (critical care, ultrasound, medical education, administration, informatics) to strengthen their niche.

In Private Practice:

• EM-IM can be your “superpower”:
  • You can cover ED, hospitalist, or even ICU shifts in smaller systems.
  • You may be invaluable during surges (e.g., holidays, pandemics, staffing shortages).
• Negotiation leverage:
  • You can propose custom roles—e.g., 0.7 FTE ED, 0.3 FTE hospitalist to reduce burnout while still earning competitively.
• Geographic flexibility:
  • Many smaller communities especially value physicians who can handle both EM and IM responsibilities.

---

Choosing a Career Path in Medicine: A Practical Decision Framework for EM-IM

Step 1: Clarify Your Core Motivators

Ask yourself:

• Do I feel energized by teaching and influencing trainees?
• Am I curious about research, QI, or innovation in EM and IM?
• How important is maximizing income vs having protected time for non-clinical work?
• Do I prefer high-acuity, resource-rich centers or broader autonomy in leaner environments?
• Where does my long-term vision point: chair/program director or group leader/owner?

Write down your top 3–5 priorities. This will anchor your decision.

Step 2: Shadow or Moonlight in Both Settings

If possible during senior residency or fellowship:

• Academic moonlighting:
  • Extra ED or hospitalist shifts at your training institution or another teaching site.
• Community/private practice moonlighting:
  • Shifts at regional EDs or hospitals to experience different pace, expectations, and team structures.

Pay attention to:

• How each environment feels after a string of shifts.
• Your sense of satisfaction from teaching vs purely clinical work.
• How administration and leadership interact with frontline staff.

Step 3: Evaluate Specific Job Offers—not Just Labels

“Academic” and “private practice” are broad categories. Two “academic” jobs can feel completely different, as can two “private” roles.

When evaluating offers, ask:

Clinical expectations

• Number of shifts/clinical hours per month?
• Proportion of ED vs inpatient/ICU work?
• Night/weekend frequency?
• Expected patient volume and acuity?

Non-clinical expectations

• Academic: Specific expectations for teaching, research, committees, and metrics for promotion.
• Private: Administrative duties, involvement in quality projects, and meeting operational targets.

Support and culture

• Is the group collegial? Do they support EM-IM physicians using both skill sets?
• How is feedback handled? Are physicians included in decision-making?
• Is there mentorship—academic or operational?

Future flexibility

• Can you shift your balance of EM vs IM over time?
• Is there a pathway to leadership, partnership, or academic promotion?

Step 4: Consider Hybrid or “In-Between” Options

You do not need to lock yourself into a binary choice forever. Common hybrid paths include:

• Academic-clinician with outside moonlighting:
  • Hold a primary academic faculty position and maintain some community shifts for income and variety.
• Community hospital with academic affiliation:
  • Work in a community system that hosts residents/students, giving you some teaching without full academic obligations.
• Portfolio career:
  • Combine ED shifts, hospitalist shifts, telemedicine, and niche consulting or education projects.

Many EM-IM physicians evolve over time:

• Early career: More ED shifts, higher income focus.
• Mid-career: Move into academic leadership or administrative/operational roles.
• Late career: Flexible part-time roles, telemedicine, or niche consulting/teaching.

Step 5: Reassess Every Few Years

Your ideal environment may change:

• Life events (family, health, caregiving)
• Shifts in institutional leadership or group culture
• Burnout or evolving professional interests

Give yourself permission to adjust course—from private practice to academic, or vice versa. EM-IM training and broad clinical competence make transitions more feasible than in many other fields.

---

FAQs: Academic vs Private Practice in EM-IM

1. Is it hard to move from private practice to academic EM-IM later in my career?

It’s possible but requires planning. Academic programs often look for:

• Evidence of teaching or mentorship (even if informal).
• Participation in QI, research, or protocol development.
• Some scholarly output (presentations, publications, or educational products).

If you’re in private practice but may want to switch to academia later, keep:

• A record of your QI projects and protocols.
• Connections with academic colleagues (e.g., through national societies).
• Opportunities to teach (EMS, APPs, visiting students) and document that work.

2. How can I use both my EM and IM training in a private practice setting?

Options include:

• Joining a system that staffs both ED and hospitalist services and negotiating a split role.
• Seeking smaller hospitals where your versatility is an asset for ED, admissions, and ICU coverage.
• Proposing a position where you cover ED shifts plus daytime rapid response/ICU co-management or admitter roles.

Be explicit during job negotiations about your EM-IM training and ask, “How can my dual skill set best serve your system?”

3. Do I need a fellowship to have a successful academic career as an EM-IM physician?

Not strictly, but a fellowship can be highly beneficial, especially in:

• Critical care
• Medical education
• Ultrasound
• Administration/health systems
• Research/clinical trials

Fellowship training can provide:

• Focused expertise and protected time.
• A clearer academic niche.
• Stronger promotion potential.

However, many EM-IM physicians build robust academic careers based on clinical excellence, education, and QI without formal fellowship training.

4. Which path is better for work–life balance: academic or private practice?

Balance depends more on specific job structure and culture than on the category alone. In broad strokes:

• Academic: May offer protected time and institutional support, but includes additional teaching and committee responsibilities.
• Private practice: Often has clearer “on/off” boundaries and flexible scheduling, but productivity and staffing pressures can be intense.

The best approach is to ask detailed questions about schedules, expectations, and culture in each job—and, if possible, speak candidly with current EM-IM physicians at that site about their real day-to-day experience.

---

Choosing between academic vs private practice in Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine is less about which path is “better” and more about which aligns with your values, strengths, and evolving goals. Use your EM-IM versatility as leverage, gather real-world data from multiple practice settings, and remember that your decision is adaptable. Your career in EM-IM can—and likely will—evolve over time, and both academic and private environments can provide deeply meaningful, impactful work.