Academic vs Private Practice: A Guide for DO Graduates in EM-IM

Understanding Your Unique Position as a DO EM-IM Graduate

As a DO graduate completing or considering an Emergency Medicine–Internal Medicine (EM-IM) combined residency, you occupy a powerful but nuanced niche in the job market. You can practice:

• Pure emergency medicine
• Pure internal medicine (hospitalist or outpatient)
• A blended emergency medicine internal medicine role
• Subspecialty fellowship (e.g., critical care, toxicology, ultrasound, palliative care)
• Hybrid arrangements (e.g., EM shifts plus academic medicine career activities such as research or teaching)

The central career decision many DO graduates face after an osteopathic residency match in EM-IM is whether to pursue:

• Academic medicine (university or teaching hospital–based), or
• Private practice (community or independent group–based), or
• A hybrid model that leverages aspects of both.

This article unpacks that decision in depth for the EM-IM DO graduate, focusing on lifestyle, compensation, career growth, identity as an osteopathic physician, and long-term strategy in choosing career path medicine.

---

Core Differences: Academic vs Private Practice for EM-IM

Before diving into the specifics for a DO graduate residency pathway, it helps to outline the typical contrasts between academic and private practice environments.

Academic Medicine: Big-Picture Features

Academic medicine generally refers to working in a university-affiliated or teaching hospital with formal roles in:

• Teaching residents, fellows, and medical students
• Research (clinical, educational, quality improvement, or bench)
• Scholarly activity (presentations, publications, curriculum design)
• Institutional service (committees, leadership roles, program development)

For an EM-IM graduate, this might mean:

• Splitting time between the ED and inpatient internal medicine service
• Supervising residents and students on both sides
• Engaging in quality projects (e.g., sepsis initiatives, transitions of care between ED and wards)
• Developing EM-IM–specific curricula (e.g., for combined programs or EM residents rotating on medicine)

Academic centers are usually:

• Large, tertiary or quaternary hospitals
• Often safety-net institutions with complex, underserved populations
• Rich in subspecialist support (ICU, cardiology, hepatology, etc.)
• Structured with clear promotion tracks (Instructor → Assistant Professor → Associate Professor → Professor)

Private Practice: Big-Picture Features

Private practice (or community practice) in EM-IM can mean:

• Working for a contract management group (CMG) or independent group in the ED
• Joining a hospital-employed or multispecialty group as an internist or hospitalist
• Building a hybrid role with ED shifts plus outpatient IM clinic
• Participating in limited teaching (e.g., APPs, students, or residents in community programs), but with less formal academic infrastructure

Private practice settings are:

• Often community or regional hospitals, sometimes without residency programs
• Highly focused on clinical productivity and efficiency
• Governed by RVUs, shift coverage, patient satisfaction, and throughput
• Less structured around academic promotion, but sometimes more flexible in schedule and location

In reality, many DO graduates in EM-IM blend both worlds: academic hospitalist plus community ED shifts, or academic EM plus moonlighting in private IM groups. Still, understanding the core differences will help you design a career that fits your goals.

---

Academic Medicine Career Path for the DO EM-IM Graduate

Why Academic Medicine Appeals to EM-IM Physicians

Your combined training naturally positions you to thrive in academic settings. Common reasons DO graduates choose academic medicine include:

1. Love of Teaching
   If you enjoy explaining clinical reasoning, debriefing complex cases, or guiding bedside procedures, academic EM-IM can be deeply satisfying. You might:

   • Run an ED-based ultrasound workshop
   • Lead morning report on chest pain evaluation
   • Precept inpatient teams as the attending
   • Teach osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) for musculoskeletal complaints in the ED or on wards

2. Intellectual Variety and Complexity
   Academic centers see rare diseases and complicated multi-morbidity. An EM-IM physician can:

   • Manage the crashing decompensated cirrhotic in the ED
   • Then follow that same patient on the hepatology or ICU service
   • Lead multidisciplinary discussions on care transitions and disposition

3. Formal Academic Medicine Career Development
   Academic institutions typically offer:

   • Faculty development workshops (teaching, feedback, leadership)
   • Protected time for research or QI
   • Support for conference attendance and CME
   • Clear promotion criteria based on teaching evaluations, publications, and committee work

4. Alignment with DO Philosophy
   Many academic departments now strongly value holistic care, patient-centered communication, and wellness—areas where DO physicians often feel naturally aligned. You can also advocate for osteopathic principles in curriculum and patient care.

Typical Roles and Schedules in Academic EM-IM

Academic EM-IM careers can be structured in several ways:

• Primarily EM with Medicine Time

  • 0.7–0.8 FTE in the ED
  • 0.2–0.3 FTE on inpatient medicine or observation units
  • Teaching residents and students in both environments

• Hospitalist with ED Responsibilities

  • Majority of shifts as academic hospitalist (day or night)
  • A limited number of ED shifts per month to keep EM skills sharp
  • Lead initiatives that bridge ED and inpatient care (readmission reduction, throughput projects)

• Subspecialty-Focused Academic Roles
  After combined EM-IM, some DO graduates pursue fellowships such as:

  • Critical care
  • Ultrasound
  • Palliative care
  • Toxicology
  • Health services research
  • Medical education / simulation

  This can lead to roles like ICU director, ED ultrasound director, or Director of Care Transitions, often with a mix of clinical service and protected academic time.

Pros of Academic Medicine for EM-IM DOs

1. Strong Teaching and Mentorship Environment
You’ll work alongside colleagues who value education. As a DO graduate residency–trained physician, you can:

• Mentor DO and MD residents on career decisions
• Model osteopathic approaches to communication and empathy
• Participate in EM-IM combined program design or leadership

2. Broader Non-Clinical Career Options
Academic settings open doors to:

• Program leadership (APD, PD, clerkship director)
• Department administration (Vice Chair, Chair, Medical Director)
• Institutional roles (GME committees, patient safety, quality)
• Regional and national leadership within EM and IM societies

3. Easier Entry into Research and Scholarship
While you don’t need to be R01-funded, you can:

• Publish case reports and QI projects
• Lead EM-IM–related research (e.g., high-utilizer pathways, ED-initiated chronic disease management)
• Present at national conferences (ACEP, SAEM, ACP, CHEST, SCCM)

4. Reputation and Network
Academic environments often give you:

• Access to subspecialty mentorship
• Strong institutional name recognition on your CV
• A pipeline for future opportunities (leadership roles, regional positions)

Cons of Academic Medicine for EM-IM DOs

1. Generally Lower Base Compensation
Academic positions often pay less than comparable private practice roles, especially in EM. You may see differences of:

• 10–30% lower overall compensation compared with high-volume community EM
• Similar or slightly lower compensation compared to hospitalist roles in private groups

This gap may be partially filled by:

• Benefits (retirement match, tuition benefits)
• Protected time (though that is “paid” via lower salary)
• Job stability

2. Promotion and Committee Burden
Success in academic medicine frequently requires:

• Serving on multiple committees
• Maintaining teaching evaluations and scholarly output
• Navigating promotion criteria that can be vague or shifting

For an EM-IM physician juggling two specialties, this can feel like double the meetings and expectations.

3. Less Control over Schedule and Practice Style
Academic schedules may be:

• Structured around resident coverage and educational needs
• Stacked with early mornings, late evenings, and occasional nights
• Influenced by institutional policies about documentation, throughput, and teaching requirements

4. Institutional Politics
Large academic centers can be bureaucratic:

• Slower change processes
• Complex hierarchies
• Sometimes conflicting priorities between EM and IM departments, especially for combined-trained faculty

---

Private Practice for EM-IM DO Graduates: Efficiency, Income, and Autonomy

Why Private Practice Appeals to EM-IM Physicians

For many DO graduates from an osteopathic residency match, private practice offers:

1. Higher Earning Potential (Especially in EM)
   Community EM groups and hospitalist programs often pay:

   • Higher hourly rates or RVU-based compensation
   • Productivity bonuses and shift differentials
   • Opportunity to pick up extra shifts

An EM-IM physician can monetize both skill sets by:

• Working a full-time EM job plus occasional hospitalist moonlighting
• Or vice versa, depending on local market needs

2. Clear Productivity Metrics
   You’re often measured based on:

• RVUs or patients per shift
• Throughput and documentation completion
• Basic patient satisfaction metrics

While demanding, this clarity can be refreshing compared to the diffuse expectations of academic promotion.

3. Streamlined Clinical Focus
   In many community roles:

• You spend almost all your time seeing patients
• Charting and billing are directly tied to your income
• You won’t be asked to publish or give grand rounds—unless you want to and create those opportunities informally

4. More Geographic Flexibility
   Community EM and IM jobs are widely available across:

• Suburbs
• Smaller cities
• Rural areas

If you want to live near family, enjoy a lower cost of living, or choose a specific lifestyle (mountains, beach, etc.), private practice often provides more options.

Typical Roles and Schedules in Private Practice EM-IM

Emergency Medicine–Dominant Role

• Employed by a CMG, independent democratic group, or hospital-employed EM group
• Shifts: 12–14 eight- to twelve-hour shifts per month, mix of days/swings/nights
• Patient mix: higher volume, more bread-and-butter EM with occasional critical care
• Formal teaching limited, though you may work with APPs or occasional residents

Hospitalist / Internal Medicine–Dominant Role

• Employed by hospitalist group or multispecialty practice
• Schedule: 7-on/7-off, or 5-on/5-off; days, nights, or swing roles
• Opportunity to be the “go-to” for complex inpatient cases due to EM background
• May help manage ED-to-inpatient transitions or observation units

Hybrid Community Roles

Some systems design positions specifically for EM-IM physicians:

• Split timeshare between ED and inpatient service
• Provide cross-coverage in critical access hospitals
• Lead rapid response or code teams across the hospital

Pros of Private Practice for EM-IM DOs

1. Higher Compensation and Faster Debt Paydown

For many DO graduates with significant loans, the financial argument is strong:

• Higher base salary at community EM
• Extra shifts translate into direct income
• Ability to aggressively pay down educational debt or invest early

2. Operational Autonomy

While there are still corporate or hospital policies, you may:

• Have greater say in your schedule (especially in smaller groups)
• Negotiate tailored positions (e.g., mostly days, limited nights, part-time plus locums)
• Choose whether to participate in administration or stick to pure clinical work

3. Less Academic Pressure

If your main passion is clinical practice and you’re less interested in:

• Research
• Publications
• Grand rounds and teaching conferences

then private practice can be emotionally less taxing.

4. Speed and Efficiency

Private practice environments often strive to:

• Minimize unnecessary bureaucracy
• Streamline workflows
• Implement changes more quickly than large academic centers

For some EM-IM physicians, this means less frustration and more time practicing medicine.

Cons of Private Practice for EM-IM DOs

1. Limited Structured Academic Growth

You can still teach and perform QI in private practice, but:

• There are usually fewer built-in mentorship channels
• No formal academic promotion ladder
• Fewer resources for funded research

If you dream of becoming a program director or department chair in a major academic center, a purely private practice career may make that route more complex (though not impossible).

2. Corporate and Financial Pressures

Especially in EM:

• Contract changes, buy-outs, or loss of hospital contracts can destabilize groups
• Productivity expectations can feel relentless
• Physician autonomy can be affected by corporate or hospital decisions about staffing, APP utilization, and coverage

3. Variable Job Security

Depending on the market:

• Some groups have stable long-standing contracts
• Others are at risk when hospitals rebid EM or hospitalist contracts

As an EM-IM physician, your dual skill set is a buffer, but vetting group stability is critical.

4. Fewer Formal Academic Connections

If you later decide to move into academic medicine, it can be harder to:

• Demonstrate recent teaching or scholarly activity
• Rebuild an academic network
• Compete for faculty positions at highly academic institutions without prior academic track record

---

Choosing Career Path in Medicine: Decision Framework for DO EM-IM Graduates

To choose between academic medicine and private practice vs academic hybrid options, you’ll need to align your values, financial needs, and long-term goals.

Step 1: Clarify Your Primary Motivators

Ask yourself:

• Do I feel most fulfilled teaching and mentoring, or seeing high volumes of patients efficiently?
• How important is maximizing income during the first 5–10 years after training?
• Do I want to build an academic medicine career (titles, promotion, national leadership) or primarily be a clinician?

Write down your top 3 drivers (e.g., teaching, geographic flexibility, financial independence) and rank them.

Step 2: Analyze Your Lifestyle Priorities

Consider:

• Shift work tolerance: Nights, weekends, and holidays in EM; longer admitted service stretches with IM.
• Family commitments: Partner’s job, children, elder care, community ties.
• Geographic priorities: Are you open to relocating for a top academic EM-IM program, or do you need/want to stay in a specific town?

Academic jobs may cluster in large cities with teaching hospitals. Private practice positions are more widely distributed.

Step 3: Map Short-Term vs Long-Term Goals

Short-term (0–5 years):

• Aggressively pay down debt?
• Build your EM-IM procedural and clinical confidence?
• Try different practice environments (locums, hybrid roles)?

Long-term (10–20+ years):

• Aim for department leadership?
• Envision a portfolio career (clinical work + education + administration)?
• Intend to scale back shifts and focus on non-clinical work later?

Academic roles may be better for building long-term non-clinical careers; private practice can accelerate financial stability, giving you freedom later.

Step 4: Leverage Your EM-IM Advantage

As a DO EM-IM graduate, your combined training is a strategic asset in both academic and private practice environments:

• In academics: You can become the bridge between ED and inpatient medicine, lead complex care initiatives, and champion continuity.
• In private practice: You can fill multiple coverage gaps (ED, hospitalist, ICU coverage in smaller hospitals), making you highly marketable.

Use this flexibility intentionally:

• You might start in high-paying EM private practice to rapidly pay down loans, then transition to academic hospitalist or academic EM-IM hybrid.
• Or begin in academic EM-IM to build a CV and then negotiate a well-compensated community leadership job.

Step 5: Talk to EM-IM DOs 5–10 Years Ahead of You

Seek out:

• DO graduates who chose academic EM-IM and ask about promotions, compensation, work–life balance
• DO physicians in community EM or hospitalist roles and ask why they stayed or left
• People who switched from one track to the other—what triggered the change?

Their real-world perspectives will be more valuable than job postings alone.

---

Practical Job-Search and Contract Tips for EM-IM DO Graduates

Targeted Search Strategies

• For Academic Positions

  • Look at universities with EM-IM combined residencies or strong EM and IM departments.
  • Search for job listings under both “Emergency Medicine” and “Hospitalist/Internal Medicine.”
  • Highlight your EM-IM training and osteopathic background as strengths for teaching holistic care and transitions of care.

• For Private Practice Positions

  • Explore regional EM groups, multi-hospital systems, and hospitalist organizations.
  • Market yourself as “two physicians in one”: able to flex between ED and inpatient needs.
  • Ask about willingness to design a hybrid role if one is not advertised.

Evaluate Each Offer with EM-IM in Mind

Ask specific questions:

• Clinical Mix:

  • What percentage of my time will be in the ED vs IM?
  • Will my EM-IM training be actively utilized or mostly underused?

• Support and Resources:

  • Is there backup in the ED? ICU? Subspecialists?
  • For academics: Is there protected time for teaching/QI/research?

• Compensation and Benefits:

  • Base salary, bonuses, RVU/shift expectations
  • Loan repayment options, sign-on bonuses
  • Retirement contributions, disability insurance, malpractice tail coverage

• Career Growth:

  • In academics: promotion criteria, expected scholarly output, mentorship structures
  • In private practice: opportunities for leadership (site director, regional director), ownership tracks, or partnership

Plan for Flexibility

Your first job is not your last job. Especially as a DO EM-IM graduate, you have cushion to pivot:

• You can move from EM-heavy to IM-heavy or vice versa
• You can shift from pure private practice to hybrid academic–community roles
• You can pursue additional training (e.g., critical care) to reshape your options

Build portable skills: excellent documentation, interpersonal communication, leadership, and teaching—even in private practice, you can maintain a portfolio of educational and QI activities that keeps academic doors open.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a DO graduate in EM-IM, will I face barriers entering academic medicine compared to MDs?

Most modern academic EM and IM departments are DO-friendly, especially in EM where DO representation is strong. Key factors that matter more than degree type are:

• Your clinical performance and references
• Demonstrated interest in academics (teaching, QI, research) during residency
• Fit with departmental culture and needs (e.g., bridging EM and IM, ICU interest)

If you trained at a solid EM-IM program with some scholarly activity, you should be competitive for academic roles.

2. Can I start in private practice and later switch to academic medicine?

Yes, but it helps to be intentional:

• Maintain a teaching portfolio: precept students, lead CME talks, participate in QI.
• Attend and present at conferences when possible.
• Keep connections with your training program; offer remote lectures or mentorship.

When ready to switch, highlight your private practice experience as evidence of high clinical volume, efficiency, and breadth—an asset in academic teaching.

3. Is doing an additional fellowship necessary for an academic medicine career?

Not strictly necessary, especially in EM and IM where many clinician-educators are non-fellowship trained. A fellowship is more important if you want to:

• Hold a highly specialized role (critical care, toxicology, ultrasound)
• Focus heavily on research or procedural subspecialties
• Compete for major leadership positions at top academic centers

For a straightforward academic clinician-educator in EM-IM, strong teaching skills, QI involvement, and modest scholarship can be enough.

4. How should I think about work–life balance when comparing academic vs private practice?

Both pathways can support or undermine balance, depending on specifics:

• Academic EM-IM:

  • Pros: more control over non-clinical time, built-in variety, collegial teaching environment
  • Cons: lower pay, expectations for activities outside clinical time (email, committees, prep)

• Private Practice EM-IM:

  • Pros: more direct control over total hours, higher pay per hour, simpler role definition
  • Cons: higher pressure for productivity, more night/weekend shifts especially early on, contract volatility

Instead of assuming one path is always “better” for lifestyle, evaluate each specific job: schedule, culture, expectations outside clinical hours, and how leadership truly treats physician wellness.

---

Academic vs private practice for a DO graduate in Emergency Medicine–Internal Medicine is not a binary choice; it’s a spectrum. Your combined EM-IM training and osteopathic background give you uncommon flexibility to design a career that blends clinical care, teaching, scholarship, and leadership in proportions that evolve over time. Approach the decision systematically, stay curious about alternatives, and remember that your first step after residency is just one chapter in a long, adaptable medical career.