Navigating Career Choices: Academic vs Private Practice for DO Graduates

As a DO graduate in a preliminary surgery year, you’re in a uniquely complex position. You’re balancing the demands of a surgically intense year, planning your next match cycle, and already being asked:

“Do you see yourself in academic surgery or private practice?”

Even if you haven’t locked in a categorical surgery spot yet—or you’re not sure you even want to—understanding the academic vs private practice landscape now will help you make smarter choices about your rotations, mentors, research, and future applications.

This article breaks down how these two major paths differ, what they mean specifically for a prelim surgery residency graduate, and how to align them with your long‑term goals in medicine as a DO.

---

Understanding Your Starting Point as a DO in a Preliminary Surgery Year

Before diving into academic vs private practice, it’s important to be clear about where you are in training and how that shapes your options.

What a Preliminary Surgery Year Really Is

A preliminary surgery residency (usually 1 year) is:

• Non-categorical: You’re not guaranteed progression to PGY-2 in surgery.
• Often used as:
  • A stepping stone to a categorical general surgery spot (via re-application or internal transfer).
  • A required year for certain specialties (e.g., interventional radiology, anesthesiology, urology at some institutions).
  • A structured clinical year if you’re uncertain about ultimate specialty.

Compared to categorical residents, prelims often have:

• Less job security beyond PGY-1.
• High service responsibilities (floor work, consults, cross-coverage).
• Fewer built-in protections for research or career development unless you create those opportunities yourself.

DO-Specific Considerations

As a DO graduate:

• You may have had fewer home-institution academic surgery opportunities during medical school.
• Some surgery departments (though less than in the past) may still show subtle bias or lower familiarity with DO training.
• On the flip side, many DOs have strong clinical skills, patient rapport, and flexibility—qualities valued in both academic medicine careers and community-based private practice.

Why Academic vs Private Practice Matters Even Now

Even though you might feel far from a final career decision, your prelim year choices can set you up for both:

• An academic medicine career (teaching, research, grants, leadership)
• Or a private practice path (clinical productivity, business, autonomy)

Decisions you make this year can impact:

• Letters of recommendation (from research-focused vs clinically focused attendings)
• Research output and academic CV strength
• Exposure to community vs tertiary/quaternary academic centers
• Where and how you network for your next position or match

---

Academic Surgery: Structure, Lifestyle, and Fit for DO Prelim Graduates

Academic surgery is more than “working at a university hospital.” It is a complete career identity centered on clinical care, teaching, and scholarship.

What Is an Academic Medicine Career in Surgery?

An academic surgeon typically practices at:

• University hospitals
• Teaching hospitals affiliated with medical schools
• Major tertiary or quaternary centers with fellowship programs

Core components usually include:

1. Clinical Care

   • Often subspecialized (e.g., surgical oncology, colorectal, transplant).
   • Referral patterns skew toward complex or rare pathology.
   • Multidisciplinary tumor boards, conferences, and advanced procedures are common.

2. Teaching

   • Medical students (including DO/MD and rotating students).
   • Residents (prelims and categoricals) and fellows.
   • Formal teaching: lectures, simulation, workshops.
   • Informal teaching: OR instruction, intraoperative decision-making, daily rounds.

3. Research and Scholarship

   • Clinical outcomes studies, QI projects, translational research, or basic science.
   • Writing manuscripts, presenting at conferences, sometimes pursuing grants.
   • In some positions, research productivity is essential for promotion and tenure.

4. Administration and Leadership

   • Program leadership (APD, PD).
   • Committees (M&M, quality, diversity and inclusion, curriculum).
   • Hospital and departmental decision-making roles.

Pros of an Academic Surgery Pathway

For a DO prelim graduate considering academic vs private practice, academic surgery offers:

• Structured Teaching Environment

  • If you enjoy teaching peers and junior learners, you’ll find it central to your role.
  • Great fit if you valued OMT teaching, osteopathic principles, and mentoring as a DO student.

• Research and Innovation

  • Access to databases, statisticians, and research staff.
  • More opportunities to publish—critical if you aim for promotion, national presence, or specialized fellowships.

• Complex Case Mix

  • High acuity, tertiary referrals, advanced procedures.
  • Exposure to cutting-edge techniques and clinical trials.

• Academic Identity and Influence

  • Opportunities to influence guidelines, participate in national societies, and help shape the next generation of surgeons.

• Relative Stability

  • Salary may be “lower ceiling” than high-end private practice, but income is often more predictable and buffered from market swings.

Challenges of Academic Surgery

The trade-offs often include:

• Lower Earning Potential (on average)
  Particularly compared to high-volume private practice or physician-owned groups.

• Higher Pressure to “Produce” Academically

  • Publish or perish mentality in some departments.
  • Pressure to obtain grants, present at major meetings, and maintain scholarly output—on top of clinical duties.

• Bureaucracy and Institutional Politics

  • Promotion processes, committee work, and administrative layers.
  • Slower operational changes due to large institutional structures.

• Teaching and Supervision Load

  • Taking time to teach residents and students can slow you down in clinic and OR.
  • Not everyone enjoys constant learners in the room.

Academic Surgery for DOs: Myths vs Reality

• Myth: DO graduates can’t succeed in academic surgery.
  Reality: Many DOs hold academic leadership positions. But you may need to be more deliberate about:

  • Building a robust academic CV (research, presentations, QI).
  • Seeking mentors who value osteopathic backgrounds.
  • Choosing institutions with a track record of DO-inclusive hiring and promotion.

• Myth: You must do basic science to be an academic surgeon.
  Reality: Many successful academic surgeons focus on:

  • Clinical outcomes research
  • Quality improvement
  • Health services research
  • Education scholarship

Actionable Steps During Your Prelim Year if You’re Leaning Academic

1. Align Yourself with Academic Mentors

   • Identify attendings with titles like “Program Director,” “Vice Chair of Research,” or “Division Chief.”
   • Ask for guidance on academic career paths early in the year.

2. Get On at Least One Research or QI Project

   • Even a small retrospective chart review can lead to a poster or publication.
   • Aim for a tangible product (abstract, manuscript) by mid-year to include in future applications.

3. Take a Teaching Role

   • Offer to help orient new interns or medical students.
   • Lead informal teaching sessions on call nights.
   • Ask attendings if you can present at M&M or didactics.

4. Leverage the Osteopathic Perspective

   • Highlight your skills in holistic care, communication, and primary care understanding.
   • In interviews for academic positions, frame your DO background as a strength in patient-centered, whole-person surgical care.

---

Private Practice Surgery: Structure, Lifestyle, and Fit for DO Prelim Graduates

Private practice surgery is highly variable but is generally more clinical volume and business focused with fewer formal academic expectations.

What Does “Private Practice” Actually Mean in Surgery?

Private practice can take several forms:

1. Independent Group Practice

   • Physician-owned; multiple surgeons share overhead, call, and business responsibilities.
   • May operate at one or more community hospitals.

2. Single-Specialty or Multi-Specialty Groups

   • General surgery group or broader surgical/medical groups.
   • Often contract with hospitals or health systems for coverage.

3. Employed by a Hospital or Health System (Community-Based)

   • Technically “employed,” but not heavily academic.
   • Focused on providing local surgical services without major research/teaching infrastructure.

4. Hybrid Community-Academic Roles

   • Community surgeon with some teaching of residents rotating off-site.
   • Occasional involvement in research or student teaching, but not central.

Core Features of Private Practice

• Primary Emphasis on Clinical Productivity

  • RVUs and case volume drive income.
  • Efficiency and business acumen matter.

• Variable Teaching Involvement

  • You may still teach residents/students, especially if your hospital has a community-based program.
  • But formal academic promotion expectations are usually minimal.

• Business and Operational Focus

  • Negotiating contracts, developing a referral base, optimizing OR block time.
  • Overseeing staff, marketing, and finances if part-owner.

• Case Mix

  • Often a broad general surgery practice (hernia, gallbladder, colon, appendectomy, basic oncologic cases).
  • May have subspecialty emphasis depending on local demand and your training.

Pros of Private Practice Surgery

When thinking about private practice vs academic, many are drawn to private practice for:

• Higher Potential Earnings

  • Especially in busy, well-managed practices and underserved markets.
  • Income is more closely tied to productivity.

• More Control Over Practice Style

  • You can influence scheduling, OR preferences, staffing, and clinic flow.
  • Some groups allow flexibility around part-time or phased retirement arrangements.

• Less Formal Pressure for Research

  • You can still participate in clinical trials or QI, but it’s usually optional.
  • More focus on honing surgical skill and efficiency.

• Closer Community Integration

  • Strong ongoing relationships with referring PCPs and community specialties.
  • Opportunity to build a recognizable community presence.

Challenges of Private Practice

• Business Risk and Responsibility

  • In independent practices, you share overhead, malpractice, staff salaries, and startup costs.
  • Practice viability depends on payer mix, referral patterns, and local competition.

• Less Academic Infrastructure

  • Fewer resources for research, limited access to large databases.
  • Harder to remain on the cutting edge without self-initiated CME and conferences.

• Potential for Heavy Call Burden

  • Especially in smaller communities or understaffed hospitals.
  • You may cover multiple hospitals or be on home call frequently.

• Limited Formal Teaching Opportunities (Depending on Site)

  • If you love structured teaching, private practice may not fully satisfy that, unless you’re affiliated with a residency or medical school.

Private Practice for DOs: Strategic Considerations

As a DO graduate:

• Private practice groups and community hospitals are often highly receptive to DO surgeons, especially if:
  • You communicate well with patients.
  • You collaborate smoothly with staff and referring providers.
• You may face less emphasis on pedigree (school name) and more on:
  • Operative skill
  • Reliability
  • Community reputation

---

Comparing Academic vs Private Practice for DOs Coming from a Prelim Surgery Year

This is where choosing career path medicine becomes more concrete. Let’s compare head-to-head in domains that matter for you.

1. Training Pathways After a Preliminary Surgery Residency

Your prelim year gives you a strong surgical foundation but doesn’t guarantee a categorical spot. From here, you might:

• Reapply for categorical general surgery (academic or community).
• Pivot into other specialties (e.g., anesthesia, radiology, EM, IM, PM&R), using your prelim year as a completed intern year.
• Consider non-surgical fields but leverage your surgical exposure.

Academic Orientation:

• Categorical positions at university-based academic centers.
• Fellowships (e.g., surgical oncology, MIS, trauma/critical care) that often lead to academic roles.

Private Practice Orientation:

• Community-based categorical surgery programs.
• General surgery completion followed by immediate community practice or a private practice-friendly fellowship (e.g., MIS/bariatrics, colorectal, breast surgery).

2. Lifestyle and Workload

Academic:

• Heavy clinical load + teaching + research.
• Schedules may involve more evening work for charting, writing, and preparing lectures.
• Night call and weekends, often shared with fellows and residents.

Private Practice:

• Heavy clinical load with revenue pressure.
• Admin/business tasks layered on top of clinical work.
• Call frequency varies by group size and local geography.

The prelim surgery year itself tends to resemble an academic workload (long hours, high call, intense service). Don’t assume academic surgery will always be as grueling; post-training it may balance out differently, but both paths are demanding.

3. Intellectual and Educational Environment

If you thrive on:

• Case conferences, grand rounds, specialty boards.
• Collaborative care with subspecialists.
• Constant involvement with learners.

You’re naturally aligned with an academic medicine career.

If you prefer:

• Direct clinical care with minimal layers of bureaucracy.
• Fewer formal meetings and committees.
• Building a practice around patient relationships and community reputation.

You may lean toward private practice.

4. Long-Term Flexibility

It is easier to move from academic → private practice later than the reverse. Why?

• Academic roles often strongly value:
  • Established research track record.
  • Continuous academic engagement post-training.
• Private practice recruiters care more about:
  • Board certification.
  • Operative skill.
  • Professionalism and interpersonal skills.

As a DO prelim graduate, if you think you might want academic surgery long-term, protect that option by:

• Getting involved in at least some research.
• Maintaining an updated CV with academic activities.
• Choosing fellowships and jobs that keep you in touch with the academic world.

---

Practical Steps: How to Use Your Prelim Year to Clarify and Strengthen Your Path

You don’t need to decide today if you’ll retire as a division chief at a university or a partner in a private group. But you should use this year intentionally.

1. Seek Exposure to Both Environments

• If your current prelim program is academic:

  • Ask to rotate at affiliated community hospitals when possible.
  • Talk to community surgeons about their practice patterns and lifestyle.

• If your program is more community-based:

  • Ask attendings with past academic backgrounds to describe their experiences.
  • Attend nearby academic conferences or departmental grand rounds if allowed.

2. Network Strategically for the Next Match or Job Cycle

For an osteopathic residency match or re-match into a categorical spot:

• Academic Goal:

  • Seek letters from academic attendings known in your desired specialty.
  • Highlight your research and teaching in your personal statement.

• Private Practice Goal:

  • Collect letters from high-volume community surgeons who can attest to your work ethic, clinical judgment, and technical growth.
  • Emphasize your reliability, team leadership, and efficiency on your CV.

3. Build a CV That Works in Either Direction

Even if you’re leaning one way, create a hybrid-strength CV:

• Include:
  • Case log highlights (early operative exposure, specific procedures).
  • Research or QI projects (even small ones).
  • Teaching roles (student orientation, informal lectures).
  • Leadership (chief prelim, committee member, wellness initiatives).

This gives you more leverage whether you apply for academic positions, community categorical spots, or non-surgical specialties.

4. Reflect Honestly on What Energizes You

During your prelim year, regularly ask yourself:

• When am I most engaged—on service, in the OR, teaching, or talking about data/research?
• Do I feel inspired after conferences and grand rounds, or drained?
• Does the idea of “publish or perish” motivate me or repel me?
• Do I enjoy thinking about billing, efficiency, and the business of medicine, or would I rather focus purely on clinical and academic questions?

Keep a brief monthly reflection log. Over time, patterns will emerge that steer you confidently toward academic vs private practice.

5. Consider Geography and Personal Life Goals

• Academic centers are typically in larger cities or regional hubs.
• Private practice opportunities may be more abundant in:
  • Suburbs
  • Smaller cities
  • Rural areas

Think ahead about:

• Partner’s career options
• Proximity to family
• Cost of living
• Where you see yourself raising a family or building community connections

---

Summary: Making an Informed, Flexible Choice

As a DO graduate in a preliminary surgery residency, you’re under pressure to think about the future while just trying to survive the present. You don’t need a rigid 20-year plan—but you do need a direction.

• Academic Surgery is ideal if you:

  • Enjoy teaching, research, and complex referrals.
  • Want an identity in academic medicine with opportunities for leadership and scholarship.
  • Are comfortable with potentially lower peak earnings but higher institutional stability and intellectual engagement.

• Private Practice Surgery fits if you:

  • Prefer maximizing clinical work and income potential.
  • Are interested (or at least tolerant) of the business side of medicine.
  • Want more direct control over your practice, with less formal academic pressure.

Use this prelim surgery year to intentionally explore mentors, environments, and career models. Whether you ultimately pursue an academic medicine career or a purely private practice path, your DO background and surgical training can support a fulfilling, impactful professional life.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a DO graduate in a prelim surgery spot, is academic surgery realistically achievable?

Yes. Many DO surgeons hold academic positions and leadership roles. To improve your chances:

• Seek research and QI projects during your prelim year.
• Obtain strong letters from academic surgeons.
• Target categorical programs and fellowships with a known history of supporting DOs.
• Be ready to articulate how your osteopathic training enriches your approach to surgical care and education.

2. Will choosing private practice close the door on academic opportunities forever?

Not necessarily, but it can make re-entry into pure academic roles more difficult if you:

• Don’t stay engaged in any scholarly work.
• Lack teaching experiences or academic affiliations.

However, hybrid roles exist:

• Community surgeons with teaching appointments.
• Surgeons participating in multi-center trials or registries.
• Hospital-employed surgeons at academic-affiliated community sites.

If you think you might want to return to academics later, maintain at least some teaching or scholarly activity and attend professional society meetings.

3. How should I frame my prelim surgery year when applying to future positions or specialties?

Emphasize:

• High clinical volume and responsibility.
• Rapid acquisition of procedural and acute care skills.
• Adaptability and resilience under pressure.
• Examples of teamwork, leadership, and communication.

If you pivot out of surgery, your prelim year demonstrates strong general medical and procedural foundations that can be attractive to fields like anesthesia, EM, radiology, or critical care.

4. What if I’m undecided between academic vs private practice—how do I keep both paths open during my prelim year?

Focus on a balanced portfolio:

• Participate in at least one research or QI project (academic credibility).
• Build strong clinical evaluations and operative experience (private practice appeal).
• Seek mentors from both academic and community backgrounds.
• Attend professional meetings or local conferences to network broadly.

By the end of your prelim year, you’ll have more data about what environment genuinely fits you—and you’ll be prepared to pivot toward either academic surgery or private practice without having closed key doors.