Choosing Between Academic and Private Practice as a DO Graduate in General Surgery

Understanding Your Career Fork in the Road

As a DO graduate in general surgery, the years of premed, osteopathic medical school, and the grueling general surgery residency have all built toward one major question: What kind of surgeon do you want to be—and where?

For many DO graduates, especially those who may have had to be more strategic in navigating the osteopathic residency match or ACGME-accredited programs, the decision between academic vs private practice can feel high-stakes and confusing.

This article will walk you through:

• What academic and private practice surgery actually look like day to day
• How compensation, lifestyle, and job security differ
• How being a DO graduate can shape your opportunities and strategy
• How to align each path with your goals in research, teaching, and clinical work
• Concrete steps to evaluate and choose the best fit for your general surgery career

Throughout, we’ll focus specifically on the general surgery residency graduate who is a DO, acknowledging both the unique strengths and occasional barriers you might face.

---

Defining the Practice Models: Academic vs Private Practice

Before comparing pros and cons, it’s crucial to be precise about what “academic” and “private” actually mean. They’re not always as clear-cut as they sound.

What Is Academic General Surgery?

Academic general surgery typically means employment by a:

• University hospital or medical school
• Major academic medical center
• Large teaching hospital with residency and/or fellowship programs

Key characteristics:

• Primary missions:

  1. Patient care
  2. Teaching (students, residents, fellows)
  3. Research (clinical, translational, or basic science)

• Common components of your week:

  • Operating room days with residents and medical students
  • Teaching conferences (M&M, grand rounds, journal club)
  • Academic meetings and committee work
  • Time for research, QI projects, or curriculum development
  • Inpatient consults and specialty clinics

• Employment structure:

  • Salary-based, often with RVU productivity incentives
  • Benefits through the university or hospital
  • Titles like Assistant Professor, Associate Professor, Professor

For a DO general surgery graduate, an academic position can also be a strong platform to show that osteopathic surgeons belong in high-level academic medicine careers, including leadership roles, research, and program development.

What Is Private Practice General Surgery?

Private practice is more varied than academic surgery, and can include:

1. Independent group practice

   • Surgeon-owned or shareholder model
   • You are an owner or partner (eventually)
   • Emphasis on productivity and business acumen

2. Hospital-employed community practice

   • Employed by a non-academic hospital system
   • Many responsibilities mirror private practice, but without ownership

3. Large multispecialty group

   • Employed by a physician group that contracts with hospitals
   • Can feel like private practice but with corporate infrastructure

Key characteristics:

• Primary missions:

  1. Efficient, high-quality patient care
  2. Practice growth and financial stability
  3. Community presence and referral relationships

• Common components of your week:

  • High-volume clinical work (OR, clinic, call)
  • Less formal teaching (maybe students, but often no residents)
  • Minimal research pressure unless you choose to pursue it
  • Business and administrative tasks (especially in independent groups)

This path often appeals to DO graduates who want autonomy, a robust operative experience, and faster income growth after years of training.

---

Day-to-Day Life: How Work Actually Feels in Each Setting

Clinical Work and Case Mix

Academic Medicine (General Surgery)

• Case complexity: Tends to skew more complex—advanced oncologic cases, complex hepatobiliary procedures, re-operations, unusual or rare diseases.
• Subspecialization: More likely to be highly specialized (e.g., surgical oncology, MIS, HPB, foregut, colorectal).
• Residents and fellows:
  • You’ll operate with trainees, which can be deeply rewarding but also time-consuming.
  • Cases may proceed more slowly because they’re educational as well as therapeutic.
• Clinic:
  • Typically structured and staffed with advanced practice providers (PA/NP).
  • Referral-based, with many complex cases funneled to you from community surgeons.

Private Practice (General Surgery)

• Case mix:
  • Broad, bread-and-butter general surgery: hernias, gallbladders, appendectomies, simple oncologic cases, endoscopies, sometimes trauma (depending on hospital).
  • At some hospitals, you may do very advanced cases—but less often than in a quaternary academic center.
• Operative autonomy:
  • You are the primary operating surgeon; there may be minimal or no trainees.
  • Cases can move faster; more turnover means higher volume.
• Clinic:
  • Emphasis on efficiency: shorter visits, higher volume.
  • Strong focus on referral relationships with primary care and other specialties.

Teaching, Research, and Scholarship

Academic General Surgery

• Teaching responsibilities:

  • Daily intraoperative teaching
  • Bedside and clinic teaching
  • Formal lectures, simulation sessions, skills labs
  • Participation in program evaluation and curriculum development

• Research opportunities:

  • Access to statisticians, IRBs, databases, sometimes grant offices
  • Expectation (formal or informal) to produce scholarly output—papers, presentations, QI projects, or clinical trials.
  • Chances to mentor residents and medical students (including DOs) on research projects.

Private Practice General Surgery

• Teaching:
  • May teach rotating students or occasionally residents (if your hospital has affiliations).
  • Teaching is usually informal and not structurally rewarded.
• Research:
  • Possible but self-driven: retrospective chart reviews, participation in multi-center registries, quality-improvement initiatives.
  • Less likely to get protected time or institutional support unless you’re tied to a teaching hospital or system that encourages it.

If you envision a future in academic medicine career paths—Division Chief, Program Director, Chair, or national society leadership—academic surgery generally provides the clearer runway.

Administrative and Non-Clinical Work

Academic Surgery:

• Committee work: clinical pathways, quality improvement, promotions, diversity and inclusion, curriculum committees.
• Program responsibilities: interviews, resident evaluations, ACGME documentation, recruitment.
• Conference travel: representing your institution at national meetings.

Private Practice Surgery:

• Business operations: contracts, negotiating with hospitals and insurers, revenue cycle, malpractice issues, partnership agreements.
• Marketing: building your practice brand, community talks, referring physician dinners.
• Practice management: supervising staff, scheduling, and operational decisions (especially as partner or owner).

Consider your comfort level with hospital politics vs business decisions—both settings have politics, but in different flavors.

---

Compensation, Lifestyle, and Job Security

These factors often drive the initial “academic vs private practice” debate, especially after a long and underpaid training period.

Compensation Structures

Academic Medicine

• Base salary + incentive:
  • Base salary often lower than private practice for the first several years.
  • Bonuses or raises tied to RVUs, teaching, or academic productivity.
• Non-monetary benefits:
  • Tuition discounts for family (in some institutions)
  • More robust retirement plans in some university systems
  • Protected time for research or academic interests
  • Proximity to cutting-edge technology and sub-specialized colleagues

Private Practice

• Higher earning potential:
  • Especially in high-volume, well-managed practices.
  • Income may scale directly with your productivity (RVUs, collections, or profit-sharing).
• Partnership track:
  • After 2–5 years, you may become a partner and share in profits, ancillary revenues (endoscopy, imaging, ownership in surgical centers).
• Variability:
  • Income can fluctuate with local market, payer mix, and the health of the practice.

A realistic expectation: for most general surgeons, median lifetime earnings are generally higher in private practice than in pure academic positions, but this must be weighed against your personal interests in teaching, research, and lifestyle.

Lifestyle: Hours, Call, and Flexibility

Academic Surgery:

• Hours can be long, but often more predictable structure:
  • Scheduled OR days, clinic days, academic days.
  • Call may be busy—especially at a Level I trauma or tertiary center—but is shared among more faculty.
• Academic time may give some flexibility for:
  • Attending conferences, specialty courses
  • Developing non-clinical projects like education or QI

Private Practice Surgery:

• Highly dependent on:
  • Number of partners
  • Local hospital coverage agreements
  • Trauma level and case mix in your region
• Early years:
  • Often longer hours, more call, and pressure to build your referral base.
  • Over time, as the group grows or you gain seniority, your schedule may stabilize.
• Potential for more direct control over your clinic and OR schedule—especially as a partner or owner.

Job Security and Marketability

Academic Medicine:

• Pros:
  • Steady institutional paycheck.
  • Stronger protection against market downturns.
  • Tenure or long-term contracts in some settings.
• Cons:
  • Dependent on institutional politics, funding, and departmental priorities.
  • Shifts in leadership can affect your role and support for your interests.

Private Practice:

• Pros:
  • More sites to choose from nationwide—especially in community hospitals.
  • Ability to move or join another group if one practice dissolves or becomes untenable.
• Cons:
  • Vulnerable to local competition, payer changes, or hospital consolidations.
  • Ownership brings risk: if the practice underperforms, your income and equity may suffer.

---

The DO Perspective: Unique Considerations for Osteopathic Surgeons

As a DO graduate entering general surgery, you may bring distinct strengths—and also face certain perceptions—that shape your choosing career path in medicine.

How Being a DO Interacts with Academic Medicine

Barriers are shrinking, but not gone.

• The single accreditation system has integrated former osteopathic programs into ACGME accreditation, leveling the field for many DO graduates.
• Nonetheless, some highly competitive academic centers and fellowships may still show a preference for MD applicants in subtle ways (prior recruitment patterns, faculty biases, etc.).

Your advantages as a DO:

• Training that emphasizes whole-person care, communication, and patient rapport, which can be an asset in both teaching and complex surgical decision-making.
• Many DOs have strong backgrounds in community medicine and adaptability, making them excellent mentors and educator-clinicians.
• Increasing visibility of DO surgeons in prominent academic roles—Division Chiefs, Program Directors, national society leaders—creates a growing network of role models and allies.

If you’re a DO who wants a robust academic medicine career, consider:

• Completing residency and/or fellowship in a well-recognized ACGME program with strong research and teaching infrastructure.
• Building an academic CV early:
  • Case reports, QI projects, retrospective studies during residency.
  • Presentations at regional and national meetings.
  • Formal involvement in teaching medical students and junior residents.

How Being a DO Fits into Private Practice

In private practice, DO vs MD often matters far less than:

• Your clinical reputation
• Your technical skill and outcomes
• How well you communicate with patients and referring providers

Community hospitals and group practices are often staffed by a diverse mix of MDs and DOs. Referral patterns are typically driven by:

• Responsiveness and availability
• Perceived quality and bedside manner
• Willingness to take complex or urgent cases

As a DO surgeon in private practice, you can also bring:

• Comfort with high patient interaction and holistic discussions about surgery, risk, and recovery.
• A natural fit for community outreach, which supports practice growth.

---

Aligning Each Path with Your Long-Term Goals

This decision isn’t just about your first job after general surgery residency; it’s about your trajectory 5, 10, and 20 years out.

If You Love Teaching and Want to Shape Future Surgeons

Academic practice often makes the most sense if you:

• Feel energized working with residents and students, even when it slows down the day.
• Enjoy breaking down complex procedures and clinical decisions into teachable steps.
• Want to eventually become:
  • Program Director
  • Clerkship Director
  • Fellowship Director
  • Skills lab or simulation center leader

Best academic environments for you:

• Departments that explicitly value osteopathic graduates and feature DO faculty in visible roles.
• Programs where you can gain protected time for education scholarship and curriculum development.

If You’re Drawn to Research or Innovation

Academic surgery is typically more supportive if you:

• Want to contribute to clinical trials, guidelines, or device development.
• See yourself leading QI initiatives beyond a single hospital.
• Aspire to become an investigator, not just a user, of new surgical techniques.

Look for:

• Institutions with strong clinical research infrastructure (biostatistics, IRB support, databases).
• Mentors who are active in research and willing to include you in projects.
• A clear expectation of protected academic time written into your contract.

If You Prioritize Autonomy, Income Growth, and Community Impact

Private practice may be the better fit if you:

• Value operational control over your practice: scheduling, case selection, clinic flow.
• Are comfortable (or eager) to engage in the business side of medicine.
• Want to rapidly grow a high-volume, broad-based general surgery practice.
• Are drawn to being the go-to surgeon in a community setting, where your work has visible day-to-day impact.

Within private practice, you’ll still make choices:

• Group size and culture: Small tight-knit group vs large multispecialty organization.
• Hospital type: Rural community hospital, suburban regional center, or non-academic urban facility.
• Service lines: Trauma, bariatrics, endoscopy, oncologic surgery, acute care surgery.

---

How to Decide: A Structured Approach for DO General Surgery Graduates

Step 1: Clarify Your Core Values

Ask yourself:

• Do I gain energy from teaching and mentorship, or do I feel drained by it?
• Do I want my name on publications and guidelines, or is that a low priority?
• Am I comfortable with a slightly lower starting salary if it means I can teach and do research?
• How much risk and responsibility am I willing to take on in terms of business ownership?

Write down your top 3–5 non-negotiables for your career—for example:

• “Operate at least 2–3 full days a week.”
• “Be meaningfully involved in training residents.”
• “Avoid business management as much as possible.”
• “Maximize my earning potential to support family and financial goals.”

Then match these with the typical patterns of academic vs private practice.

Step 2: Seek Real-World Exposure During Residency

During your general surgery residency (or fellowship):

• Electives:
  • Spend time at both a large academic center and a community or private practice setting if your program allows.
• Mentors:
  • Identify at least one academic surgeon and one private practice surgeon (preferably DOs) and ask them to walk you through their weeks.
• Conferences and Networking:
  • Attend national meetings (ACS, SAGES, specialty societies) and talk to both academic and community surgeons about their paths.

For DO graduates, aligning with mentors who understand your background and goals can be especially valuable for candid advice and opportunities.

Step 3: Analyze Job Offers Objectively

When offers start coming in:

• For academic positions, scrutinize:

  • Protected time: How many hours/week are truly non-clinical?
  • Expectations: How many papers, talks, or grants are expected?
  • Promotion criteria: What does it take to advance from Assistant to Associate Professor?
  • Support: Administrative help, access to research staff, grant support.

• For private practice positions, examine:

  • Compensation structure: Base, RVU rate, collections percentage, partnership buy-in.
  • Call schedule: Frequency, compensation for extra call, backup support.
  • Case mix: Bread-and-butter vs complex cases, trauma coverage requirements.
  • Governance: Who makes decisions? How transparent are finances?

Step 4: Remember It’s Not Always Permanent

An important perspective: you are not locked in forever.

• Academic surgeons sometimes transition to private practice when they want less committee work or higher income.
• Private practice surgeons sometimes move to academic positions later, especially if they’ve built strong reputations and want to teach or focus on subspecialty work.

However, transitions are easier if:

• You maintain professional society involvement and a network across both worlds.
• You keep your CV active—presentations, local QI projects, leadership roles.
• You remain flexible geographically and open to hybrid roles (like community-based faculty positions tied to academic centers).

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a DO graduate, is it harder to get an academic general surgery job?

It can be slightly more challenging at a few elite or historically MD-dominated institutions, but overall, the environment is changing. With the unified ACGME accreditation and more DOs in academic leadership, many centers value clinical excellence and teaching ability over degree initials. Your residency/fellowship pedigree, research experience, letters of recommendation, and interview performance matter more than DO vs MD at most institutions.

2. Can I do research and teach if I choose private practice?

Yes, but it requires more self-motivation and often less institutional support. You might:

• Collaborate with an affiliated academic center on registry or multicenter projects
• Participate in quality-improvement initiatives at your hospital
• Teach medical students who rotate through your hospital or clinic

However, if you want substantial protected time and a promotion pathway based on scholarship, academic surgery is usually the better fit.

3. Which path pays more: academic or private practice general surgery?

On average, private practice general surgeons earn more, particularly after the first few years and especially in partnership-track or owner roles. Academic salaries are often lower but come with non-financial benefits like research support, teaching opportunities, and academic prestige. That said, high-productivity academic surgeons with leadership roles can still earn very competitive incomes.

4. Can I switch from academic to private practice (or vice versa) later?

Yes. Many surgeons make one or more major career transitions. Moving from academic to private practice is often straightforward if you maintain a strong clinical reputation. Moving from private practice to academic roles is also possible, particularly if you’ve stayed engaged in teaching, QI, or professional society activities. Building and maintaining a strong CV and network keeps both doors open.

---

Choosing between academic vs private practice as a DO graduate in general surgery is less about right vs wrong and more about fit—with your personality, strengths, and long-term goals. By understanding the realities of each environment, leveraging your osteopathic training, and staying honest about what motivates you, you can build a fulfilling surgical career in whichever arena you choose.