Choosing Between Academic and Private Practice as a DO Graduate in Vascular Surgery

Understanding Your Options as a DO Graduate in Vascular Surgery

As a DO graduate finishing (or soon completing) a vascular surgery residency—whether a traditional fellowship after general surgery or an integrated vascular program—you face one of the most important early career decisions: academic vs private practice.

Both paths can lead to a rewarding, high-impact career, and both are fully open to DO graduates. But they differ in culture, expectations, compensation structure, and long‑term opportunities. The “right” choice depends much more on your values, personality, and goals than on your degree.

This guide breaks down what DO graduates in vascular surgery should know about:

• How academic and private practice settings actually work in day-to-day life
• Pros and cons of each environment
• How the decision interacts with your osteopathic residency match history and CV
• Practical steps to explore and test each path before signing a contract
• How to keep doors open if you’re still unsure about choosing a career path in medicine

---

1. Big Picture: What “Academic” and “Private Practice” Really Mean

Academic Vascular Surgery

In an academic vascular surgery residency or faculty position, you typically work at:

• University hospitals
• Large tertiary/quaternary referral centers
• Teaching hospitals with residents, fellows, and medical students

Core features:

• Tripartite mission: clinical care, teaching, and research
• Educational role: supervising residents and fellows in the OR, ICU, clinic, and call
• Research expectations: anything from occasional case reports to running trials or labs
• Academic promotion system: titles like Assistant, Associate, or Full Professor
• Often more complex, referral-heavy case mix, including advanced endovascular and open procedures

For a DO graduate, academics can also be a space where your osteopathic identity—emphasis on holistic care, communication, and systems thinking—can enrich teaching and patient-centered care models.

Private Practice Vascular Surgery

In private practice, you might work in:

• Independent vascular surgery groups
• Multi-specialty groups (e.g., vascular + cardiology)
• Hospital-employed or health-system-employed positions (sometimes called “private-like” practice)
• Office-based labs (OBLs) and ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs)

Core features:

• Primary focus is clinical productivity and service
• Revenue typically tied closely to your own or group productivity (RVUs, collections, or hybrid)
• Variable involvement with teaching and research (often less, but not always zero)
• Greater emphasis on efficiency, business awareness, and access to care in the community

As a DO graduate, you’re on completely equal footing in this arena; referring providers and hospitals typically care far more about your outcomes, access, and collaboration than about MD vs DO.

---

2. Academic Medicine Career: Structure, Lifestyle, and Fit

Typical Weekly Life in Academic Vascular Surgery

Although schedules vary widely by institution, a stereotypical assistant professor role may look like:

• 2–3 days/week in the OR (open and endovascular)
• 1–2 days/week in clinic
• Protected time for research, teaching prep, and academic committees
• Participation in morbidity & mortality (M&M), grand rounds, journal clubs
• Rotating call with a larger group, often with resident or fellow in-house or home backup

On a given day, you might:

• Lead an EVAR or complex limb salvage case while teaching a senior resident the technical steps
• Break down a difficult perioperative complication with your trainee at the end of the day
• Review manuscripts or work on an IRB submission during academic time
• Present at a regional or national meeting (SVS, VEITH, etc.) a few times a year

Advantages of Academic Vascular Surgery for DO Graduates

1. Teaching and Mentoring

   • If you were drawn to education during your osteopathic residency match journey, academics lets you keep teaching central to your career.
   • You can explicitly mentor DO medical students and residents, strengthening DO visibility in vascular surgery.

2. Complex Case Mix and Subspecialization

   • Large centers often receive the sickest, most complex referrals:
     • Thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysms
     • Advanced peripheral arterial disease with limb salvage teams
     • Complex endovascular interventions
   • Early exposure to cutting-edge technology (branched/fenestrated devices, novel stents, hybrid ORs).

3. Research and Innovation Opportunities

   • Ideal if you want to be involved in clinical trials, outcomes research, health services work, or device development.
   • You can build a scholarly niche—e.g., limb preservation in underserved populations, dialysis access outcomes, or health equity in vascular care.

4. Academic Career Progression and Visibility

   • Titles (Assistant/Associate Professor) and promotion pathways can help you build a public profile.
   • Easier to gain leadership roles in societies, guideline panels, and national education.

5. Relative Stability and Infrastructure

   • Salary-based compensation with benefits and institutional support staff.
   • Often robust support services: vascular lab, advanced imaging, multidisciplinary clinics, APP teams.

Downsides and Challenges of Academic Practice

1. Compensation May Lag Behind High-Volume Private Practice

   • Academic salaries are often lower than high‑productivity private practice roles (though some top systems are now competitive).
   • “Soft money” expectations for research time can create pressure to obtain grants or maintain RVU targets.

2. Administrative and Academic Pressure

   • Committee work, documentation, quality metrics, and academic requirements (publications, teaching evaluations, promotion portfolios).
   • Time spent on tasks that do not directly translate into clinical income.

3. Less Control Over Your Schedule and Practice Design

   • OR time allocations, clinic templates, and call schedules often more standardized and less negotiable.
   • Institutional policies may be slow to change (e.g., to support new office-based procedures).

4. Promotion Timelines and Expectations

   • In some environments, you’ll feel pressure to hit publication or grant “benchmarks” that may be hard to meet while building a young clinical practice.

Who Typically Thrives in Academic Vascular Surgery?

As a DO graduate, you might be a great fit if:

• You get genuine satisfaction from teaching residents and fellows, not just tolerating it.
• You enjoy asking research questions: “Why are our limb salvage outcomes different in this population?”
• You like multidisciplinary interaction (cardiology, interventional radiology, nephrology, endocrine, wound care) and big-system problem solving.
• You’re comfortable with some trade-off of income and autonomy for academic freedom, mentorship, and complex case exposure.

---

3. Private Practice Vascular Surgery: Structure, Lifestyle, and Fit

What Private Practice Really Looks Like

“Private practice” is not one uniform model. Consider four common variations:

1. Traditional Independent Group

   • Several vascular surgeons own the practice, share expenses, and distribute profit.
   • You may start as an associate with a partnership track.
   • Greater entrepreneurial upside but also more business risk.

2. Multi-Specialty or Cardiovascular Group

   • Shared branding and resources with cardiology, CT surgery, or general surgery.
   • Built-in referral network but also internal competition for procedures and cath/OR time.

3. Hospital-Employed Model

   • You are salaried by a health system, often with RVU and quality bonuses.
   • Often marketed as “private practice-like” with less true ownership risk.
   • Can combine stability of employment with a focus on clinical volume.

4. Office-Based Lab (OBL) / ASC-Centric Practice

   • Emphasis on minimally invasive arterial and venous interventions in office-based suites.
   • Potentially high financial upside but under intense scrutiny for appropriate indications and quality.

Day-to-Day in Private Practice

Typical components:

• High-volume clinic with new consults and post-op care
• OR days at one or more hospitals; potentially cases at an ASC or OBL
• Call shared with a small group—frequency may be higher than large academic groups
• Business activities: reviewing financial reports, managing staff issues, negotiating with reps or hospital administration (for partners and senior surgeons)

In a thriving private vascular group, you might:

• Run 40–50 patient clinics several days a week
• Perform office-based interventions (e.g., endovenous ablations, angiograms)
• Move multiple cases through the OR efficiently in a single day
• Develop a reputation as “the vascular doc” for a region, with robust referral streams from PCPs and podiatrists

Advantages of Private Practice for DO Graduates

1. Higher Income Potential

   • Particularly in high-demand regions with limited competition.
   • Productivity-based models reward efficiency and volume.
   • Partnership and OBL/ASC ownership can significantly increase long-term compensation.

2. Greater Autonomy and Practice Design

   • You can influence staffing, scheduling, clinic workflows, and service lines.
   • More flexibility to shape your choosing career path in medicine around specific patient populations (e.g., limb salvage center, venous disease).

3. Community Presence and Long-Term Relationships

   • You may become the long-standing vascular expert in a region, seeing generations of the same families.
   • Strong emphasis on long-term outpatient follow-up and continuity.

4. Faster Decision-Making

   • Less bureaucratic delay for implementing new procedures or workflows.
   • Local group consensus often more nimble than a large academic committee structure.

Downsides and Challenges of Private Practice

1. Business and Administrative Burden

   • Understanding payer mix, collections, overhead, credentialing, and contracts.
   • Personnel management: hiring, firing, dealing with staff turnover.
   • Regulatory and compliance pressures, especially for OBLs and ASCs.

2. Pressure for Clinical Volume and Productivity

   • Fixed costs mean idle clinic or OR time is expensive.
   • May feel tension between patient-centered care and financial viability (e.g., scheduling shorter visits, optimizing case mix).

3. Potential Isolation from Academic Networks

   • Fewer built-in opportunities for formal teaching, research, and national academic leadership.
   • Requires extra effort to stay tightly connected to national societies and new evidence.

4. Variable Call Burden and Work-Life Balance

   • Small groups may shoulder heavy call, at least early on.
   • Negotiating coverage and vacation can be complex, especially before partnership.

Who Typically Thrives in Private Practice?

You might be well-suited if:

• You like autonomy and control over how your day is structured.
• You gain satisfaction from building a practice, marketing it, and watching it grow.
• You’re comfortable blending clinical excellence with business-minded decision-making.
• You want maximal earning potential and are willing to accept some risk and hustle to get there.

---

4. Key Factors for DO Graduates When Choosing Academic vs Private Practice

4.1 Impact of Being a DO Graduate

In modern vascular surgery, MD vs DO makes far less difference than it did a decade ago, particularly since the single accreditation system merged AOA and ACGME pathways. For your DO graduate residency background:

• Hiring: Most chairs and group leaders care about your skills, outcomes, and references, not your degree letters.
• Academics: Strong CVs with research, presentations, and good recommendations can earn DO graduates highly competitive academic positions.
• Perception: Rare pockets of bias persist, but real-world performance quickly eclipses any initial preconception.

Instead of worrying about your degree, focus on:

• Robust case log and technical proficiency
• Evidence of professionalism and teamwork
• Solid letters from respected vascular surgeons
• Any academic or leadership accomplishments during training

4.2 Clinical Interests and Case Mix

Ask yourself:

• Do you want mostly complex tertiary care (e.g., aortic disease, advanced PAD, re-do cases)?

  • More likely in academic or large referral centers.

• Are you drawn to high-volume bread-and-butter vascular surgery with a strong outpatient focus (carotids, dialysis access, venous disease, peripheral interventions)?

  • Common in private practice and community settings.

• Do you care about limb preservation in underserved communities, rural outreach, or public health aspects?

  • Either path can support this, but academics may offer research infrastructure; private practice may allow nimble community partnerships.

4.3 Teaching and Research Appetite

• How often do you picture yourself instructing trainees during cases, giving lectures, or designing curricula?

  • If the answer is “weekly,” academics likely fits better.

• Do you find yourself generating research questions or enjoying manuscript writing or data analysis?

  • If yes, consider academic or hybrid roles.

• If you mostly want to operate and see patients, with minimal interest in formal teaching or research, private practice may align better.

4.4 Lifestyle, Location, and Family Considerations

• Academic jobs cluster around urban or large metropolitan areas with major medical schools.
• Private practice roles may be more available in suburban and rural markets, often with high clinical need.
• Consider:
  • Your partner’s career options and children’s schooling
  • Proximity to extended family
  • Desired call frequency and vacation time

Lifestyle trade-offs can be significant. Some academic jobs are extremely busy; some private practices are more controlled. Judge roles individually rather than by stereotype.

4.5 Long-Term Career Flexibility

Think in 10–20 year horizons:

• If you’re strongly interested in national leadership, guideline development, or major society roles, an early career in academics helps build the CV and connections.
• If you see yourself eventually owning a practice or OBL, learning the business side early in a private role can set you up for success.
• Transitioning from academics → private is common; private → high-level academic can be harder but is definitely possible, especially if you stay involved in societies and quality initiatives.

---

5. Practical Steps to Explore and Decide: From Residency to First Contract

5.1 Use Residency and Fellowship Wisely

During your vascular surgery training—especially in an integrated vascular program—intentionally explore both worlds:

• Academic Exposure

  • Participate in research projects and quality improvement.
  • Teach junior residents and medical students; ask if you can give didactic talks.
  • Attend national meetings, present posters or talks, and network with academic faculty.

• Private Practice Exposure

  • Seek out community rotations or electives with private vascular surgeons.
  • Ask explicitly about their business models, referral patterns, and daily workflows.
  • Shadow them in clinic and any office-based lab settings.

Keep a running list of what energizes vs drains you in each environment.

5.2 Networking and Mentorship

Build a mentor “board of directors” that includes:

• At least one academic vascular surgeon (preferably involved in training programs)
• At least one private practice vascular surgeon (community-based or in a multi-specialty group)
• Ideally, a DO vascular surgeon who understands the nuances of being a DO graduate

Ask targeted questions:

• “What do you wish you had considered more carefully when choosing your first job?”
• “What are the hidden positives/negatives of your practice model?”
• “If you could switch now to academic/private, would you? Why or why not?”

5.3 Evaluating Job Offers: Academic vs Private

When reviewing offers, go beyond salary headlines.

For Academic Positions:

• Protected time for research/education: is it real or on paper only?
• Expectations for promotion: publications, grants, teaching metrics
• Support: research coordinators, statisticians, APPs, vascular lab infrastructure
• Call schedule and case distribution among faculty
• Opportunities to mentor DO students or help build osteopathic pipeline programs

For Private Practice Positions:

• Compensation structure: base + RVU, collections %, partnership timeline, buy-in terms
• Payer mix in the region; referrer base stability
• Call schedule, weekend expectations, and backup support
• Non-compete clauses and geographic restrictions
• Support for CME, meetings, and potential teaching affiliations with DO schools

5.4 Contract Review and Negotiation

Regardless of setting, invest in:

• A health-care savvy attorney to review contracts
• Understanding the relative value of benefits (retirement match, disability, malpractice tail coverage, loan repayment)
• Negotiation around start-up support: equipment, staff, clinic templates, marketing

For DO graduates, consider negotiating for:

• Formal opportunity to affiliate with a DO medical school or residency for teaching, if that’s important to you.
• Flexibility to participate in osteopathic-focused conferences or pipeline initiatives.

5.5 Keeping Options Open if You’re Unsure

If you truly don’t know yet:

• Look for hybrid roles:
  • Community programs with residents but limited research expectations
  • Hospital-employed positions with some teaching and QI/committee work
• Stay active in professional societies (SVS, local surgical societies), present quality projects, and build a national reputation.
• Maintain at least a modest scholarly footprint (case reports, retrospective analyses) even in private practice if you think you might someday want academic roles.

---

6. Building a Sustainable and Fulfilling Career—Whichever Path You Choose

Whether you choose academic, private, or a hybrid, remember:

• Your first job does not have to be your forever job. Many vascular surgeons change settings in the first 5–10 years.
• Burnout is common in high-demand, procedural fields; prioritize groups and institutions that value surgeon wellness, collegiality, and appropriate support.
• Continue to evolve your practice: grow a subspecialty niche, adopt new technology wisely, and remain active in continuous learning.

For DO graduates in vascular surgery, the doors to both academic medicine and private practice are wide open. The real challenge is not whether you can do either, but which one aligns best with:

• The kind of daily work you enjoy
• The professional identity you want to build
• The life you envision for yourself and your family

By carefully exploring each environment, leveraging mentors, and critically evaluating job offers, you can make a deliberate, informed choice—and retain the flexibility to pivot as your interests and life circumstances evolve.

---

FAQs: Academic vs Private Practice for DO Graduates in Vascular Surgery

1. As a DO graduate, will I be at a disadvantage when applying for academic vascular surgery positions?
In most contemporary academic vascular surgery departments, performance matters far more than MD vs DO. A strong case log, good operative evaluations, solid letters of recommendation, research or quality projects, and engagement in teaching will carry more weight than your degree. A minority of programs or individuals may still hold outdated biases, but they are decreasing. Target programs where DO faculty are already present or where leadership explicitly values diversity of training backgrounds.

2. Can I transition from private practice to academic medicine later in my career?
Yes, though it can be more challenging than going the other way. To keep this door open:

• Stay involved in societies (SVS, regional surgical societies).
• Contribute to quality initiatives, registries, or local research.
• Publish case reports or outcomes data when feasible.
• Maintain relationships with academic colleagues.
  Academic departments looking to expand often value experienced surgeons with a track record of high-quality, efficient practice and community engagement.

3. How does compensation typically compare between academic and private vascular surgery?
Broadly, private practice (especially high-volume or ownership models) tends to offer higher earning potential, particularly after partnership or once an OBL/ASC is established. Academic salaries may start lower but include stability, benefits, and potentially loan repayment or relocation packages. However, some large academic centers now offer very competitive compensation, especially for busy service lines like vascular surgery. Always compare total compensation (including benefits, call pay, productivity bonuses, and retirement contributions), not just base salary.

4. What if I want to teach and do some research but also enjoy the autonomy of private practice?
You may thrive in a hybrid model:

• Hospital-employed roles with residency programs.
• Community-based teaching hospitals affiliated with DO and MD schools.
• Private groups that host residents or fellows for rotations and participate in registries like VQI.
  You can also pursue adjunct faculty appointments at nearby medical schools, supervise students in clinic or OR, and collaborate on research with academic partners—even while maintaining a primarily private practice identity. This hybrid approach can be ideal for DO graduates who value both autonomy and education.