Strategies for DO Graduates with Low Step Scores in Boston Residency

Understanding Low Step Scores as a DO Graduate in Boston

As a DO graduate aiming for residency in Boston or greater Massachusetts, having a low Step 1, Step 2 CK, COMLEX Level 1, or Level 2 score can feel like a major barrier. But a low or below average board score does not automatically end your chances at Boston residency programs or other strong Massachusetts residency opportunities—especially if you are strategic, realistic, and proactive.

In this guide, we’ll focus on:

• What “low scores” mean in the current landscape
• How DO graduates can still be competitive in the osteopathic residency match and NRMP Match
• Specific strategies tailored to Boston-area programs
• Ways to compensate for a low Step 1 score or below average board scores
• Actionable steps and timelines to improve your match odds

This article is written specifically for a DO graduate in or targeting Boston, but most strategies apply broadly to DO applicants across the country.

---

1. Reframing “Low Scores”: What You’re Really Dealing With

Before you plan, you need a clear, honest understanding of what “low” means for your situation and your target specialty in the Boston and Massachusetts residency market.

1.1 What Counts as a “Low” Step or COMLEX Score?

Because Step 1 is now pass/fail, programs often focus more heavily on:

• USMLE Step 2 CK
• COMLEX Level 2-CE

A low score usually means:

• Step 2 CK:

  • Below ~230 is often considered “below average” for competitive academic programs.
  • Below ~215–220 starts to raise concerns in many specialties, especially at university-affiliated programs in cities like Boston.

• COMLEX Level 2-CE:

  • Below ~500 is often “below average” for more competitive programs.
  • Below ~450 may be viewed as low, especially for academic IM, EM, anesthesia, and certain surgical specialties.

However, context matters:

• Some community Massachusetts residency programs are more flexible.
• DO-friendly specialties (FM, IM, psych, peds, PM&R, neuromuscular, some community EM) may be more forgiving of a low Step 1 score or below average board scores if the rest of your application is strong.

1.2 The Boston and Massachusetts Residency Context

Boston is dense with highly academic institutions: Harvard, BU, Tufts, UMass, BIDMC, MGH, BWH, and large community systems like Lahey, Newton-Wellesley, and others across Massachusetts.

In this environment:

• Top-tier academic programs: Tend to use Step 2/Level 2 filters aggressively.
• Community-based and hybrid programs: Often value clinical performance, letters of recommendation, and fit more than just board metrics.
• Osteopathic-friendly programs: Some Massachusetts residency programs have a strong history of training DO residents and may be more willing to consider a DO graduate with lower scores, particularly in primary care.

Your strategy needs to recognize that not all Boston residency programs are equally score-sensitive. Instead of thinking “Boston or bust,” think in tiers:

• Boston academic centers (highest competition)
• Boston-area community and hybrid programs
• Massachusetts-wide community programs and smaller systems

---

2. Strategic Self-Assessment: Specialty, Scores, and DO Identity

Your next step is to align your numbers, goals, and strengths.

2.1 Choosing or Adjusting Your Specialty with Low Scores

Some specialties are less forgiving of low scores than others, especially in Boston:

• Highly competitive specialties (orthopedics, dermatology, plastic surgery, neurosurgery, ENT):

  • Extremely challenging with low Step 2 or COMLEX 2 scores, particularly for DO graduates in Boston.
  • Success is not impossible but typically requires: strong research, home institution advocacy, extraordinary networking, often multiple years of preparation.

• Moderately competitive specialties (EM, anesthesia, radiology, PM&R):

  • Low scores are a problem but can sometimes be offset by high-quality SLOEs, strong letters, targeted away rotations, and solid clinical performance.
  • DO applicants must be especially strategic about choosing DO-friendly and community-heavy programs.

• More DO-friendly/primary care specialties (FM, IM, psych, peds, neurology, PM&R in some settings):

  • Boston and Massachusetts residency programs in these areas may consider applicants with below average board scores if other parts of the application stand out.

If you already have a low Step 1 score and a marginal Step 2 or Level 2-CE, you may need to:

1. Reassess specialty competitiveness honestly.

2. Consider dual-apply strategies, e.g.:

   • EM + IM or FM
   • Anesthesia + IM
   • Radiology + Transitional Year + IM/FM back-up

3. Prioritize DO-friendly and community-based programs over the most elite Boston residencies.

2.2 Leveraging Your DO Background

As a DO graduate:

• You have unique strengths in holistic care, OMT, and primary-care oriented training.
• Programs in Massachusetts with a strong primary-care mission or osteopathic recognition may value this.

Use your DO identity strategically:

• Highlight osteopathic philosophy in your personal statement, especially for family medicine, internal medicine, PM&R, and some psych programs.
• Seek osteopathic faculty or DO alumni in Boston or New England as mentors.
• Where possible, take both COMLEX and USMLE (if not already done). Many Boston programs remain more familiar with USMLE; having both can partially mitigate concerns about lower scores if the narrative is that you challenged yourself.

---

3. Application Tactics to Overcome Below Average Board Scores

Once you understand your context, your focus is on compensation strategies: building strengths in other areas to offset your low Step 1 score or weak Step 2/COMLEX.

3.1 Clinical Rotations and Audition Rotations in Boston

Strong clinical performance can significantly soften the impact of poor scores.

Actions:

• Aim for honors or top evaluations in your core rotations and sub-internships.

• If possible, schedule sub-internships/audition rotations in Boston or nearby Massachusetts residency programs:

  • Community hospitals in the Boston metro area (e.g., BIDMC-affiliated community sites, Lahey, Newton-Wellesley, Cambridge Health Alliance, St. Elizabeth’s, etc., depending on specialty).
  • UMass and other university-affiliated community programs across the state.

• During rotations, focus on:

  • Reliability: be early, prepared, and thorough.
  • Ownership: act like an intern within your scope.
  • Enthusiasm: especially for bread-and-butter cases.
  • Professionalism: respond well to feedback; be easy to work with.

These rotations can generate high-impact letters of recommendation that explicitly say you function at or near intern level—hugely important for matching with low scores.

3.2 Letters of Recommendation: Your Most Powerful Offsetting Tool

For a DO graduate with low scores seeking Boston residency programs, letters can make or break your application.

Aim for:

• 3–4 strong letters, ideally including:
  • 1–2 from faculty in your chosen specialty who know you well.
  • At least 1 from a program director, clerkship director, or associate program director if possible.
  • For EM: SLOEs from ACGME programs.

Tips to maximize letter strength:

• Ask directly: “Do you feel you can write me a strong letter of recommendation?”
• Provide letter writers with:
  • Your CV
  • Personal statement draft
  • Score reports (with a short explanation if needed)
  • Specific points you hope they might highlight (work ethic, clinical reasoning, growth).

Requests for letters should happen early—ideally within 1–2 weeks of completing a strong rotation.

3.3 Personal Statement and Application Narrative

Your personal statement and ERAS experiences can help reframe your low board performance without making excuses.

Do not:

• Blame others or externalize wholly.
• Spend most of your statement focused on the score.

Do:

• Briefly acknowledge the issue if it’s likely to be a concern, especially if there’s a clear explanation (illness, family crisis, learning disability, test anxiety with documented support).

• Emphasize growth and trajectory, e.g.:

  • “Although my Step 1 score was below what I had hoped, it prompted me to reassess my study strategies and seek mentorship. By Step 2 CK, I had implemented a structured plan and improved significantly in both my comprehension and test performance.”

• Highlight concrete strengths:

  • Longitudinal clinical work
  • Leadership, QI projects, tutoring
  • Research (especially at Boston institutions, if any)
  • Commitment to patient-centered, osteopathic care.

3.4 Targeted Program Selection: Where to Apply in Boston and Massachusetts

With low Step scores, your program list matters as much as your documents.

General principles:

• Apply broadly—especially outside core Boston academic centers.
• Include:
  • Community-based Massachusetts residency programs
  • Programs in nearby New England states (Rhode Island, New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont, Connecticut)
  • DO-friendly programs historically matching osteopathic graduates with a range of scores.

For Boston-specific strategy:

• Identify DO-friendly Boston residency programs by:

  • Checking past resident lists on program websites: note how many DOs are present.
  • Talking with DO mentors who know New England programs.
  • Using match data from your school’s GME or advising office.

• Be realistic about:

  • The chance of matching at flagship programs like MGH, BWH, BIDMC, etc., with low Step 1 and 2 scores. These may be reach options; don’t rely on them.

Apply to a mix of program tiers:

1. Reach programs: A few academically oriented Boston residencies where you have some connection (research, rotations, mentors).
2. Target programs: Community and hybrid Boston-area or Massachusetts residency programs where your profile is around their typical DO resident.
3. Safety programs: DO-heavy and community-based programs—sometimes outside Boston—that have historically matched applicants with lower scores.

---

4. Improving the Rest of Your Application: Concrete Steps and Timelines

Even after scores are locked, you can meaningfully improve your odds of matching with low scores through deliberate actions.

4.1 Timeline Planning: When You’re 12–18 Months from Match

If you’re a DO student or very recent DO graduate:

12–18 months before Match:

• Clarify specialty choice using rotations, mentors, and honest feedback.

• If you haven’t taken Step 2 CK/COMLEX Level 2-CE yet:

  • Make this a top priority.
  • Consider dedicating 6–8 dedicated study weeks with:
    • Question banks (UWorld, COMBANK/COMQUEST)
    • NBME/Self-assessment exams and COMSAEs
  • If Step 1 was low, aim to demonstrate improvement on Step 2/Level 2.

• Begin networking with Boston and Massachusetts residency programs:

  • Attend virtual open houses.
  • Reach out politely to program coordinators and residents.
  • Ask your school’s faculty if they have contacts at Massachusetts residency programs.

Goal: Show an upward trend and start building relationships.

4.2 Before and During Application Season (6–9 Months Before Match)

At this stage:

• Finalize program list with the broad and diversified strategy above.
• Polish CV and ERAS experiences—focus on outcomes:
  • “Led a QI project that reduced medication errors by 20% over 6 months.”
• Secure letters of recommendation early.
• For interview prep:

  • Practice explaining low scores in a short, non-defensive way, then pivot back to your strengths:

    “During my preclinical years, I underestimated how much I needed to adapt my study methods to high-stakes exams, which reflected in my Step 1 result. I took that as a signal to change my approach. For Step 2, I started using daily question blocks, regular self-assessments, and sought faculty advice—this helped me improve both my score and my day-to-day clinical reasoning. On rotations, attendings have consistently noted my reliability and growth, which I’m proud of.”

4.3 After Interviews: Signaling Interest and Ranking Wisely

When you have interviews—especially at Boston residency programs:

• Send personalized thank-you emails that:

  • Mention something specific discussed in the interview.
  • Reinforce your fit with the program’s mission.

• If a Massachusetts residency is truly your top choice:

  • It’s acceptable (and can be helpful) to tell one program they are your top choice, clearly and honestly, if you mean it.

When ranking:

• Avoid over-ranking only high-prestige Boston programs if your interviews were limited.
• Give strong consideration to community and DO-friendly programs where you felt welcomed and understood.

---

5. Backup Plans and Risk Management for DO Graduates with Low Scores

Having a strong Plan A is essential—but so is risk management, especially when matching with low scores.

5.1 Consider a Transitional or Preliminary Year

For some specialties or in the event of a near-miss match:

• A transitional year or preliminary year (IM or surgery) can:
  • Provide additional US clinical experience.
  • Offer new opportunities for letters and networking.
  • Let you demonstrate your capabilities beyond your test scores.

If you pursue this route:

• Be sure to discuss with mentors how a prelim/transitional year fits into long-term plans.
• Choose programs that have a track record of helping residents move on to categorical positions.

5.2 If You Don’t Match: SOAP and Reapplication

If you go unmatched:

• SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) can still yield strong training spots, often in IM, FM, psych, and peds.
• For a Boston-focused DO graduate:
  • Be prepared to broaden geographic preferences dramatically in SOAP.
  • Focus on gaining residency training first; you may have opportunities to return to Massachusetts later in your career.

If planning to reapply:

• Use the gap year to:
  • Work in a clinical research or research assistant role, ideally in Boston if possible.
  • Gain US clinical exposure (observerships, externships).
  • Improve your application narrative, LORs, and professional maturity.

5.3 Mental Health, Resilience, and Support

Low scores and match uncertainty are emotionally draining. Especially in a competitive market like Boston:

• Maintain peer and mentor support networks.
• Consider counseling resources or wellness services.
• Recognize that scores are one metric, not your worth as a physician.

Resilience is attractive to programs; many PDs appreciate applicants who have faced and overcome adversity.

---

6. Boston-Specific Opportunities and Networking Tips for DO Graduates

To maximize your chances in the Boston and Massachusetts residency landscape with low scores, use every regional advantage you can.

6.1 Building Local Connections

If you are already in or near Boston:

• Attend local grand rounds, conferences, and CME events open to trainees.

• Join or attend meetings of state organizations, such as:

  • Massachusetts Osteopathic Society (if available) or related osteopathic groups.
  • Specialty-specific state chapters (e.g., ACP Massachusetts, AAFP chapters, APA state chapters).

• Introduce yourself politely to faculty and residents:

  • Short conversations and a follow-up email can open doors to shadowing, QI projects, or mentorship.

6.2 Research and Scholarly Activity in Boston

Boston is rich with research opportunities. Even if your scores are low, demonstrating scholarly engagement can significantly enhance your competitiveness.

Options include:

• Volunteer in research labs at:
  • Harvard-affiliated hospitals
  • BU, Tufts, UMass, or other local institutions
• Focus on:
  • Clinical research
  • Quality improvement
  • Medical education projects

Even case reports, small retrospective studies, or conference posters add value. For DO graduates, having work done in Boston-based institutions shows commitment to the region and can catch the eye of local programs.

6.3 Showing Commitment to Massachusetts and the Community

Programs want to know: Will this applicant stay and thrive here?

Show regional commitment by:

• Highlighting any ties to Massachusetts or New England (family, school, long-term residence, partner’s job).
• Discussing your interest in the patient populations served by Boston and Massachusetts residency programs—urban underserved, immigrant communities, or rural populations in central/western MA.
• Engaging in community service locally, such as free clinics, homeless outreach, or school health education.

When interviewers believe you are likely to stay, they may be more willing to look past low scores if you otherwise fit well.

---

FAQs: Low Step Score Strategies for DO Graduates in Boston

1. Can I match into a Boston residency program with a low Step 1 or Step 2 score as a DO graduate?

Yes, it’s possible, especially in more DO-friendly and community-based Boston or Massachusetts residency programs. Highly competitive academic programs may be difficult with low scores, but strong clinical performance, excellent letters, compelling narrative, and demonstrated regional commitment can significantly improve your chances in other Boston-area and Massachusetts programs.

2. Should I still take USMLE Step 2 CK if I already have COMLEX as a DO graduate with low scores?

If you’re targeting Boston residency programs or academic centers in Massachusetts, taking USMLE Step 2 CK is often beneficial, even if scores may not be stellar. Many PDs are more familiar with USMLE, and having both exams shows you were willing to meet the common standard. However, balance this with your realistic performance—don’t rush into Step 2 CK unprepared; a second low score can be more harmful than not taking it.

3. How many programs should I apply to if I have below average board scores?

Most DO applicants with low scores should apply broadly:

• For primary care fields (FM, IM, peds, psych): often 40–70+ programs across multiple states, including Boston and Massachusetts residency programs but not limited to them.
• For more competitive specialties: often 60–100+, plus a serious backup specialty if advised by mentors.

Your school’s advising office can help refine numbers based on your specific profile and specialty.

4. How do I explain my low Step score during residency interviews?

Keep your explanation brief, honest, and growth-focused. For example:

“My Step 1 score does not reflect my current abilities. Early in medical school, I struggled with test-taking strategy and time management. I sought help from faculty, changed my study methods, and focused on consistent practice questions. Since then, my clinical evaluations and performance on Step 2 and Level 2-CE have improved, and attendings have noted my strong clinical reasoning and reliability. I’ve learned from the experience and am confident in my capacity to manage the workload and exams in residency.”

Then pivot to emphasizing your clinical strengths, work ethic, and fit with the program.

---

By approaching your situation with clear-eyed realism and careful strategy, you can absolutely remain competitive for the osteopathic residency match—even in a high-demand region like Boston. Low scores are a challenge, not a full stop. With the right mix of program selection, networking, clinical excellence, and a strong personal narrative, you can still build a successful residency path in Massachusetts and beyond.