Step Score Strategy for DO Graduates Pursuing Orthopedic Surgery Residency

Understanding the Step Score Landscape for DO Applicants in Orthopedic Surgery

Orthopedic surgery remains one of the most competitive specialties in the Match, and for a DO graduate the bar can feel even higher. Program directors still lean heavily on board scores (USMLE and COMLEX) when screening applications, and the transition of Step 1 to Pass/Fail has only partially changed that reality.

To build a winning Step score strategy as a DO graduate targeting orthopedic surgery, you must understand:

• How programs interpret Step and COMLEX scores
• How much weight Step 2 CK now carries
• What to do if you have a low Step score but still want an ortho match
• How to present your academic profile in the strongest way possible

This article focuses on practical, high-yield strategies tailored specifically to DO graduates planning an orthopedic surgery residency, including those navigating a low Step score match scenario.

Where DO Graduates Stand in Ortho

Several structural realities impact DO applicants:

• Fewer orthopaedic programs historically interview DOs compared with MDs.
• Some programs require USMLE scores even for DOs; others accept COMLEX alone but still prefer USMLE.
• A significant proportion of DOs who successfully match into orthopedic surgery either:
  • Took and did well on USMLE Step 2 CK, and
  • Showed very strong orthopedic engagement (rotations, research, letters, SIG leadership, etc.).

None of this means you are at a fundamental disadvantage as a DO graduate, but it does mean that your Step score strategy has to be more deliberate and data-driven than the average applicant’s.

---

Step 1 vs Step 2 CK: What Matters Now for Ortho Applicants

With Step 1 now Pass/Fail, the Step 2 CK strategy for DO graduates has become the centerpiece of the testing plan. For those who took Step 1 before it went Pass/Fail, the dynamic is slightly different, especially if you’re dealing with a lower Step 1 score.

How Programs Use Step Scores

Program directors typically use Step-related metrics in three ways:

1. Initial Screen / Cutoffs

   • Some ortho programs post explicit minimum Step 2 CK or COMLEX Level 2-CE cutoffs.
   • Other programs use soft thresholds, such as auto-screening out significantly below-average scores.

2. Relative Competitiveness

   • Among applicants who clear the cutoff, higher Step 2 CK (and COMLEX) scores offer a measurable boost.
   • A strong Step 2 CK can partially “rescue” a mediocre Step 1 score.

3. Risk Assessment

   • Programs worry about in-training exam performance and board pass rates.
   • A low Step or Level 2 score can make them hesitant, unless there is clear evidence of upward trend and strong clinical performance.

Typical Score Expectations in Orthopedic Surgery

Exact numbers vary year to year and by program, but in general:

• Highly competitive ortho programs: Often see successful applicants clustered in the upper ranges of Step 2 CK (e.g., well above national mean).
• Mid-tier and community-based programs: May have a wider score range and put greater emphasis on fit, letters, and rotation performance.
• DO-friendly programs: Sometimes prioritize demonstrated orthopedic interest and clinical excellence over absolute top-tier board scores, but they still want to know you can pass boards easily.

For DO applicants, strong Step 2 CK + strong COMLEX Level 2-CE is one of the clearest ways to show academic readiness and compete with MD applicants.

---

Building a Step 2 CK Strategy as a DO Graduate Targeting Ortho

If you’re a DO graduate, your Step 2 CK strategy is your most powerful controllable academic lever—especially if your Step 1 or Level 1 is average or below the ortho norm.

1. Decide Early: USMLE Step 2 CK vs COMLEX Only

As a DO graduate interested in orthopedic surgery, in most cases you should:

• Take USMLE Step 2 CK
• And sit for COMLEX Level 2-CE as required for your DO degree and licensure.

Reasons:

• Many allopathic (formerly ACGME-only) ortho programs strongly prefer or require USMLE.
• USMLE Step 2 CK gives PDs a direct metric to compare you with MD applicants.
• COMLEX scores alone may limit the breadth of programs you can realistically target.

Exception:
If you already have very strong COMLEX scores and do not plan to apply broadly to highly competitive university ortho programs, you might be able to rely on COMLEX only—but this usually narrows options. When in doubt, err on the side of taking Step 2 CK.

2. Map Your Timeline Backward from the Application Cycle

A carefully timed Step 2 CK is crucial:

• Goal: Have a strong Step 2 CK score available when ERAS opens and programs download applications.
• For the regular timeline:
  • Aim to take Step 2 CK by late June or early July of the application year.
  • That gives you time for:
    • Score reporting (usually 2–4 weeks)
    • Adjusting your strategy based on the result (program list, backup plans, away rotation emphasis).

If you are:

• Retaking (after a fail or extremely low score):

  • Coordinate with your dean’s office and an advisor to ensure you retest with adequate preparation time, even if it delays your timeline slightly. A significantly improved score can offset the concern of a prior failure.

• Taking Step 2 CK late (August/September):

  • Some programs may not see your score before initial screening.
  • If you expect a strong score, consider not submitting ERAS until after your score posts, or ask mentors whether to add a note in your application that Step 2 CK is pending with a targeted date.

3. Designing a High-Yield Step 2 CK Study Plan

For a DO graduate heading into ortho, Step 2 CK is not just about passing—it is your academic branding. Approach it with a deliberate plan:

Core Resources (pick, don’t hoard):

• A comprehensive Step 2 CK review resource (e.g., a major review book or video series).
• A high-quality Qbank (UWorld is the most commonly used).
• NBME Step 2 CK practice exams for benchmarking.
• For DOs: COMLEX Level 2-CE–specific practice questions to cover OMM and COMLEX-style stems.

Study Structure (example for 8–10 weeks full-time):

1. Weeks 1–2: Foundation + Diagnostic

   • Take a baseline NBME and/or UWorld assessment.
   • Identify weak systems (e.g., cardiology, renal, infectious disease, psychiatry).
   • Review high-yield topics systematically while integrating 40–60 Qbank questions/day.

2. Weeks 3–6: Intensive Qbank + Targeted Review

   • Increase to 60–80 questions/day in timed, random blocks.
   • Actively annotate missed concepts into a concise notebook or digital document.
   • For DOs, schedule at least 2–3 sessions/week on OMM and COMLEX-style questions.

3. Weeks 7–8: Simulation + Fine-Tuning

   • Take 1–2 additional NBME practice exams.
   • Work on:
     • Time management
     • Endurance for full exam length
     • Specific high-yield weaknesses revealed by practice tests

4. Final 7–10 Days: Polishing

   • Focus heavily on missed Qbank questions and your notebook.
   • Reduce overall volume to avoid burnout; prioritize sleep and exam-day readiness.

Step 2 CK Strategy Points:

• Use timed, random blocks early to mimic real exam conditions.
• Track performance by system and concept, not just overall percentage.
• Revisit OMM efficiently: you don’t need to master every minutia, but you must be comfortable with core principles and pattern recognition for Level 2-CE.

4. Establishing a Step 2 CK Strategy for a Low or Borderline Step 1

If you already have a low Step 1 score (or relatively weaker COMLEX Level 1) and are worried about competitive specialties, your Step 2 CK strategy should be designed explicitly to show an upward trend:

• Set a clear score target: above national mean at minimum, and ideally closer to the range of matched ortho applicants.
• Consider a longer prep window (e.g., 10–12 weeks) if Step 1 was weak due to poor foundational knowledge.
• Seek early help: faculty, residents, or academic support offices to identify and fix gaps.
• Be ruthless about fixing test-taking issues (e.g., rushing, anxiety, misreading questions), not only content gaps.

Upward trajectory (e.g., low Step 1 but significantly higher Step 2 CK / Level 2-CE) is a powerful signal to programs that your earlier performance is not your ceiling.

---

Low Step Score Match Strategy: When Your Numbers Aren’t Ideal

Many DO applicants interested in orthopedic surgery carry at least one academic blemish: a low Step score, a COMLEX failure, or both. While this makes the path harder, it does not automatically rule out an orthopedic surgery residency—especially if your strategy is realistic and multi-layered.

1. Honestly Define “Low” in the Orthopedic Context

For orthopedic surgery, “low” should be defined relatively, not absolutely:

• A score below common ortho thresholds may be considered low even if it’s technically a passing score or near the national average.
• A single failure (Step or COMLEX) raises concern but can be mitigated with:
  • Strong subsequent scores
  • Strong clinical evaluations
  • A compelling narrative of growth and improvement.

2. Crafting a Recovery Narrative

Programs care less about your mistake and more about your pattern:

Your application should clearly communicate:

• What happened (briefly, without oversharing or making excuses)
• What changed (study approach, life circumstances, support systems)
• Evidence that the new pattern is stable:
  • Improved Step 2 CK / COMLEX Level 2
  • Strong shelf exams on surgery and orthopedics
  • Excellent clinical evaluations and letters.

This narrative can show up indirectly through:

• Deans’ letter (MSPE) or school commentary
• Personal statement (if relevant, use 1–2 concise paragraphs, not the whole essay)
• Strong letters that explicitly mention your growth, reliability, and resilience.

3. Maximizing Non-Score Strengths

In a low Step score match situation for ortho, your strategy must be to overwhelm the score concern with excellence elsewhere:

Key leverage points:

• Away Rotations (Audition Rotations)

  • Do 2–3 orthopedic surgery away rotations at DO-friendly programs.
  • Treat them like on-the-job interviews:
    • Show up early, stay late.
    • Be proactive, helpful, and teachable.
    • Ask for feedback and act on it quickly.
  • Aim for at least 1–2 A-level rotation performance letters that explicitly advocate for you.

• Letters of Recommendation (LORs)

  • Prioritize LORs from orthopedic surgeons who:
    • Know you well clinically
    • Are willing to write strong letters (ask explicitly)
    • Can speak to your work ethic, operative potential, and improvement over time.

• Research and Scholarly Work

  • Engage in orthopedic-related research (even retrospective chart reviews, QI projects, case reports).
  • Your goal is to show consistent orthopedic interest and academic curiosity, not just score-chasing.
  • Try to achieve at least:
    • A few abstracts/posters at regional or national orthopedic meetings, or
    • A publication (case report or original research).

• Leadership and Fit

  • Highlight leadership roles (Orthopedic Interest Group, sports medicine events, volunteer work with athletes, etc.).
  • Programs want residents who are teammates as well as technicians; evidence of leadership and collaboration matters.

4. Strategic Program Selection

With a low Step score, program selection becomes critical:

Prioritize:

• Historically DO-friendly ortho programs
• Programs at institutions where DO faculty or leadership exist
• Community-based or hybrid university–community programs
• Newer orthopedic surgery programs where competition may be slightly lower initially.

Avoid:

• Overloading your list with ultra-competitive university programs that historically rarely interview DOs, even with high scores.
• Programs stating explicit minimum USMLE cutoffs above your score (unless you have strong internal connections).

Use data wisely:

• Review FREIDA, program websites, and alumni match lists from your school.
• Ask recent DO graduates who matched ortho which programs actually interviewed them.
• Build a list that is broad enough (often 60–80+ applications for a low-score ortho strategy) but still realistic.

---

Step Score Strategy Beyond Exams: Integrating Scores into Your Overall Application

A successful orthopedic surgery match as a DO graduate is never just about numbers. Your Step score strategy must integrate with your overall application story: who you are, where you’ve been strong, and how you’ll fit into a surgical team.

1. Aligning Your Application Story with Your Scores

Think of your Step scores and COMLEX scores as data points, not your identity. The rest of your application should reinforce:

• Reliability: Show through clerkship evaluations, consistent work history, and letters.
• Surgical mindset: Detail early exposure to orthopedics, hands-on skills, and enthusiasm for operative care.
• Grit and resilience: Especially important if you’re coming from a low Step score match angle; you want PDs to know you handle setbacks and still deliver.

Use your:

• Personal statement to:

  • Highlight your genuine motivation for orthopedic surgery.
  • Briefly, if needed, address early academic difficulties and the steps you took to improve.

• ERAS experiences to:

  • Showcase depth in orthopedic-related volunteer work, research, and leadership.
  • Emphasize continuity—this is not a “panic pivot” into ortho.

2. The Role of Step 1 in the New Era

For DO graduates:

• If your Step 1 is Pass/Fail only, then:

  • Programs will lean much more heavily on Step 2 CK and COMLEX Level 2.
  • Your Step 2 CK strategy is paramount.

• If you have a numeric Step 1:

  • A high Step 1 is still helpful but less determinative than before.
  • A low Step 1 can be mitigated by:
    • A strong Step 2 CK
    • Upward trend on COMLEX
    • Strong performance on surgery/orthopedic rotations.

Regardless, do not let a low Step 1 paralyze you. Instead, channel your energy into a disciplined Step 2 CK and Level 2 preparation plan and a strong clinical record.

---

Practical Examples: Applying These Strategies in Real Life

To make these concepts more concrete, consider three brief composite scenarios (details altered for anonymity).

Example 1: DO Graduate with Average Scores, Strong Clinical Performance

• Profile:

  • COMLEX Level 1: Just above passing
  • USMLE Step 1: Not taken
  • COMLEX Level 2: Slightly above national mean
  • Step 2 CK: Near national mean
  • Strong surgery clerkship honors; excellent ortho elective evaluations

• Strategy:

  • Focus on away rotations at DO-friendly, community-oriented ortho programs.
  • Secure 3 strong letters from orthopedic surgeons who can speak to work ethic and teamwork.
  • Apply broadly (~70+ programs), emphasizing DO-friendly sites.
  • Use personal statement to highlight early challenges but strong clinical growth.

• Outcome:

  • Modest number of interviews, but excellent performance on away rotations leads to a match at a community-based ortho program with a record of training DOs.

Example 2: DO Graduate with Low Step 1, Strong Step 2 CK

• Profile:

  • USMLE Step 1: Below typical ortho ranges
  • COMLEX Level 1: Similar pattern
  • USMLE Step 2 CK: Substantial jump, now well above mean
  • COMLEX Level 2: Strong
  • Some orthopedic research and conference presentations

• Strategy:

  • Highlight upward trend in both Step 2 and Level 2.
  • Have letters explicitly address the applicant’s growth, improved study habits, and consistent performance on the wards.
  • Target a mix of mid-tier academic programs with DO faculty plus robust community programs.
  • For the ortho match, powerfully emphasize resilience and improvement, not just raw numbers.

• Outcome:

  • Multiple interviews; programs acknowledge Step 1 concern but are reassured by Step 2 and strong clinical/research portfolio.
  • Successful match at a mid-sized academic orthopedics program.

Example 3: DO Graduate with a Board Failure

• Profile:

  • Initial Step 1 failure, passed on second attempt with low score
  • COMLEX Level 1: Pass on first attempt
  • Step 2 CK: Near mean; Level 2 slightly above mean
  • Strong away rotation reviews and strong LORs

• Strategy:

  • Use personal statement and dean’s letter to briefly address the failure (e.g., poor initial preparation strategy, corrected with structured plan and tutoring).
  • Show a track record of reliable performance since: no further exam issues, excellent clerkship grades, solid surgery/ortho evaluations.
  • Apply aggressively and very DO-focused, with particular emphasis on programs known to weigh clinical performance heavily.

• Outcome:

  • Fewer interviews, but candidate is highly ranked at a DO-friendly ortho program where attendings saw their performance firsthand during an away rotation.
  • Matches successfully.

These examples illustrate that while Step and COMLEX scores matter deeply for orthopedic surgery, they are not destiny. A clear, evidence-based Step score strategy combined with targeted program selection and strong clinical performance can still lead to an ortho match as a DO graduate—even with imperfect numbers.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a DO graduate, do I really need to take USMLE Step 2 CK for orthopedic surgery?

For most DO graduates aiming for orthopedic surgery, yes, you should strongly consider taking Step 2 CK in addition to COMLEX Level 2-CE. Many orthopedic programs either prefer or require USMLE scores to compare candidates directly. Relying only on COMLEX can significantly limit the number of programs that will seriously consider your application, especially more competitive or academic institutions.

---

2. How high does my Step 2 CK need to be to match into orthopedic surgery as a DO?

There is no single magic number, but in general:

• Higher Step 2 CK scores provide clear advantages, particularly when competing with MD applicants.
• Scoring at or above the national mean is often a minimum target; stronger programs see applicants significantly above this.
• If your Step 1 or COMLEX Level 1 is low, aim for a substantial improvement on Step 2 CK and Level 2-CE to demonstrate an upward trend.

However, remember that scores alone do not guarantee an ortho match; away rotations, letters, research, and program fit are also critical.

---

3. Can I still match orthopedic surgery with a low Step score or a board failure as a DO?

It is possible, but more challenging. To give yourself a realistic chance:

• Excel on subsequent exams (Step 2 CK, COMLEX Level 2-CE) to show improvement.
• Perform at a very high level on orthopedic away rotations and secure strong LORs.
• Apply broadly to DO-friendly and community-based programs.
• Use your application to provide a brief, honest explanation and emphasize what has changed (study strategy, support systems, time management).

You may also want a parallel backup plan (e.g., categorical surgery, transitional year) if your score profile is significantly below typical ortho ranges.

---

4. How should I explain a low Step score in my application without sounding defensive?

Keep your explanation:

• Brief and factual: 2–4 sentences at most if in your personal statement.
• Non-defensive: Avoid blaming others; focus on your own learning and growth.
• Forward-looking: Emphasize the concrete steps you took afterward and the successful results (higher Step 2 CK, strong clinical performance, more structured study habits).

The goal is to acknowledge the concern, show insight, and then redirect attention to your consistent, improved performance since that time.

---

By understanding how programs interpret Step and COMLEX scores, designing a deliberate Step 2 CK strategy, and integrating your test performance into a broader orthopedic surgery narrative, you can significantly strengthen your chances of a successful orthopedic surgery residency match as a DO graduate—even if your path includes a low Step score or early missteps.