Strategic Guide for DO Graduates with Low Step Scores in Pediatrics

Understanding the Challenge: Low Scores as a DO Applicant in Pediatrics

For a DO graduate interested in pediatrics, a low Step 1 score or below average board scores can feel like a major barrier. The pediatrics residency landscape is increasingly competitive, and many DO students worry that their COMLEX or USMLE performance will close doors.

The reality is more nuanced. Pediatrics remains one of the more DO-friendly specialties, and many programs value the osteopathic philosophy, hands-on training, and strong patient-centered skills that DO graduates bring. Matching with low scores is absolutely possible—if you are strategic, honest with yourself, and proactive in building the rest of your application.

This guide focuses on low Step score strategies for DO graduates specifically targeting pediatrics residency and the peds match. You’ll learn how to:

• Put your scores in context as a DO graduate
• Compensate for a low Step 1 or COMLEX Level 1 with targeted strengths
• Design a smart application list and timeline
• Communicate effectively about your scores without sounding defensive
• Maximize your chances on interview day and on rank lists

Throughout, remember: your board scores are one data point, not your entire story.

---

Step 1: Honestly Assess Your Scores and Overall Profile

Before you can build a strategy, you need a clear view of where you stand—not just that you have a “low score,” but what that means in context.

What Counts as a “Low” Score in Pediatrics?

Definitions vary by year, but some general benchmarks:

• USMLE Step 1 (for those with a numeric score)
  • “Low”: usually < 215–220
  • “Below average”: roughly 215–225 range
• USMLE Step 2 CK
  • “Low”: < 230
  • “Below average”: ~230–240 range

For DO graduates:

• COMLEX Level 1 / Level 2-CE
  • “Low”: below roughly 450–475, depending on cycle
  • “Below average”: 475–500 range

Programs vary significantly. Some highly competitive academic pediatrics residency programs might use cutoffs; others (particularly community-based and DO-friendly programs) will review your application more holistically.

DO-Specific Considerations

As a DO applicant, you should ask yourself:

1. Did you take USMLE in addition to COMLEX?

   • If yes: programs will usually look at USMLE for comparison across applicants.
   • If no: many pediatrics programs accept COMLEX only, but some may still strongly prefer USMLE.

2. Are your scores improving or declining?

   • A low Step 1 but significantly improved Step 2 CK / COMLEX Level 2-CE is a favorable pattern.
   • A decline between Level 1 and Level 2 is more concerning and needs explanation and mitigation.

3. How do your scores align with the rest of your application?
   Consider:

   • Clinical grades (especially core pediatrics)
   • Dean’s letter/MSPE comments
   • Research and scholarly activity
   • Pediatric-related experiences
   • Letters of recommendation

Build a Concrete Profile Snapshot

Create a one-page summary for yourself. For example:

• Step 1: 210 (numeric) or Pass (if P/F)
• Step 2 CK: 228
• COMLEX Level 1: 445
• COMLEX Level 2-CE: 495
• Clinical grades: Honors in Pediatrics, High Pass in IM and FM, Pass in Surgery
• Research: 1 pediatric case report submitted, 1 poster at regional conference
• Leadership: Pediatric interest group officer, community outreach for children
• Red flags: Shelf failures, leaves of absence, professionalism concerns? (list honestly)

This snapshot becomes the foundation for your strategy: where your weaknesses are, where you can compensate, and what needs explanation.

---

Step 2: Build a Targeted, Realistic Pediatrics Application Strategy

With low or below average board scores, your odds improve dramatically when your application strategy is tailored and realistic. That includes program selection, application volume, and timing.

1. Apply Broadly (But Not Randomly)

For a DO graduate with a low Step 1 score, a competitive but smart application volume for pediatrics might be:

• 45–70 pediatrics programs as a baseline
• Higher end (60–80) if you have multiple risk factors (low scores plus red flags, few peds connections, or limited geographic flexibility)

Focus on:

• Community-based and community-academic hybrid programs
• DO-friendly residencies (look for current or recent DO residents on their website)
• Programs that explicitly state they accept COMLEX only

Be more cautious with:

• Highly research-intensive, top-10 children’s hospitals
• Programs with published strict score cutoffs far above your range
• Programs with historically low DO representation

Use tools like FREIDA, program websites, and alumni/advisor input to create a balanced list.

2. Understand and Use DO-Friendly Filters

When planning your peds match strategy:

• Check if the program:
  • Lists DOs among current or recent residents
  • States “USMLE required” vs “COMLEX accepted”
  • Is affiliated with a DO medical school or has osteopathic recognition

Ask your school’s graduate medical education (GME) office or pediatrics department if they maintain a list of programs where DO graduates have matched successfully, especially with below average board scores.

3. Time Your Application Strategically

With a low Step 1 score, your Step 2 CK/COMLEX Level 2-CE becomes critical. Ideal timing:

• Have Step 2 CK / Level 2-CE completed and reported by ERAS opening, especially if:
  • Step 1 or Level 1 is low or just passing
  • Step 1 is pass/fail and you need a strong numeric metric

If you underperform on Step 2 as well:

• Apply early anyway—waiting generally hurts more than helps.
• Consider a post-submission update if you later improve with additional achievements (publications, strong sub-I evaluations).

4. Consider a Transitional Year or Preliminary Options Only Selectively

Some applicants with very low scores consider a transitional or preliminary year. In pediatrics:

• This can help build a track record of strong clinical performance, but
• It does not guarantee a future categorical pediatrics spot, and
• You’ll spend an extra year and additional costs.

This path makes the most sense if:

• You significantly improve your performance in a clinical setting, and
• Your faculty and PDs can strongly advocate for you later.

For most DO graduates with low but passing scores, a focused reapplication strategy (if needed) is preferable to automatically defaulting to a transitional year.

---

Step 3: Compensate for Low Scores with High-Impact Strengths

Programs understand that not every excellent resident had stellar exam performance. Your mission is to prove you’ll be a safe, reliable, and outstanding pediatrics resident despite lower board scores.

A. Dominate Your Pediatrics Rotations and Sub-Internships

Clinical performance is the strongest way to counterbalance a low Step 1 score, especially for a DO graduate in pediatrics.

Aim for:

• Honors or top evaluations in core pediatrics
• A pediatrics sub-internship (acting internship) with:
  • Strong evaluations
  • Direct observation by attendings who can write detailed letters
  • Participation in sign-out, notes, and basic resident-level responsibilities

Actionable tips:

• Arrive early, leave late, and know your patients in detail.
• Read every day about your patients’ conditions (using Harriet Lane, Nelson’s, or evidence-based guidelines).
• Ask for feedback early in the rotation:
  • “I know standardized exams aren’t my strength, so I’m working hard to show that clinically. What can I do this week to function more like a strong intern on this team?”

B. Secure Powerful Letters of Recommendation (LoRs)

For applicants matching with low scores, LoRs often make or break the peds match outcome.

You want at least:

• 2 strong letters from pediatricians (ideally including a chair, PD, or a well-known faculty member in your region)
• 1 additional letter from another core field (IM, FM, or subspecialty) who can attest to your work ethic and reliability

Stronger letters describe:

• Specific clinical scenarios you handled well
• Evidence of growth, resilience, and teachability
• Explicit commentary that mitigates your low scores (e.g., “Although [Name]’s board scores are below our typical average, on the wards their performance has been consistently among the strongest of our students.”)

Ask directly and professionally:

“Given that my Step scores are below average, I’m hoping to offset that with strong clinical performance and letters. Do you feel you can write me a strong, supportive letter for pediatrics residency?”

You want honesty here; a lukewarm letter is worse than no letter.

---

Step 4: Tell a Coherent Story—Personal Statement, MSPE, and Explaining Scores

A low Step 1 score (or any below average board scores) becomes much less damaging if they fit into a credible, growth-oriented narrative.

A. Your Personal Statement: Highlight Growth, Not Excuses

Your personal statement for a pediatrics residency should focus primarily on:

• Why pediatrics fits you
• Pivotal experiences with children and families
• Your values: communication, advocacy, empathy

If you discuss low scores, keep it brief, factual, and framed around growth. Avoid lengthy justifications. A simple approach:

• One short paragraph acknowledging the data point
• Clear description of what changed
• Evidence of improvement

Example:

“My Step 1 score does not reflect my current knowledge or capabilities. During that period, I struggled with time management and test anxiety, and I did not yet have an effective study structure. Since then, I’ve developed a more disciplined approach, sought faculty mentorship, and significantly improved my performance on clinical exams and Step 2. The feedback from my pediatrics rotations, sub-internship, and shelf exams better represents the physician I am becoming.”

You don’t have to mention your exact score; programs can see it. Focus on what you learned and how you changed.

B. Collaborate with Your Dean’s Office on the MSPE

The MSPE (Dean’s letter) may mention difficulty or trends. Meet with your dean or advisor and be candid:

• Explain contextual factors, if relevant and legitimate (major illness, family emergency), without over-dramatizing.
• Emphasize what you did proactively afterward:
  • Remediation courses
  • Study skills coaching
  • Wellness changes

If the school supports you, they can frame your story as one of resilience and improvement rather than unexplained underperformance.

C. Prepare a Concise, Direct Explanation for Interviews

You will likely be asked:
“Can you tell me about your Step scores?” or
“I noticed a discrepancy between Level 1 and Level 2—what happened?”

Have a prepared, 3-part answer:

1. Owning it:

   • “I’m glad you asked. Those scores were disappointing to me and don’t reflect my capabilities.”

2. What went wrong (brief, non-dramatic):

   • “I underestimated the need for structured question practice and had poor test-taking strategies.”

3. What you changed and how you improved:

   • “I met with academic support, created a detailed question-based study schedule, and worked on managing anxiety. On subsequent exams and on clinical rotations, you can see the results—my performance improved, and my evaluations have consistently highlighted my clinical reasoning and reliability.”

Avoid blaming others or mentioning vague emotional reasons without a concrete change in behavior.

---

Step 5: Optimize Every Other Part of Your Pediatrics Application

When you can’t change your scores, your best move is to over-deliver everywhere else.

A. Show Deep Commitment to Pediatrics

Programs want residents who genuinely love caring for children.

Demonstrate this through:

• Longitudinal pediatric involvement:
  • Free clinics, school-based health programs, camps for kids with chronic illness
  • Child life collaboration, school talks on health topics
• Research or quality improvement related to:
  • Asthma, obesity, vaccine rates, developmental screening, social determinants of health
• Leadership roles:
  • Pediatrics or family medicine interest group
  • Advocacy projects (e.g., child nutrition, safety, mental health)

In your application, explicitly connect your experiences to why you’ll be a strong pediatrician.

B. Strengthen Your Academic and Research Footprint (Even Late)

Even if you are close to application season, you can still:

• Join a case report or retrospective chart review with a pediatrics faculty member.
• Help with data entry or literature reviews for an ongoing project.
• Present a poster at a regional or institutional conference (virtual or in-person).

These activities not only decorate your CV; they also provide faculty mentors who can advocate for you during the peds match.

C. Consider Away Rotations / Audition Rotations Strategically

For DO graduates with lower scores, well-chosen away rotations can significantly increase your chances:

• Choose 1–2 programs where:
  • DOs are represented among residents
  • Your school or faculty have existing connections
  • You could realistically see yourself ranking them highly

On the rotation:

• Function at (or close to) intern-level responsibility.
• Be proactive but not overbearing.
• Ask directly for feedback and, if appropriate, a letter.

Many programs heavily weight performance of rotators when deciding whom to interview and rank, especially if there are concerns about board scores.

---

Step 6: Interview and Rank List Strategy for the Peds Match

You’ve put in the work; now you need to seal the deal during interviews and on your rank list.

A. Interview Day: What Matters Most for Low-Score Applicants

With low Step 1 or COMLEX scores, programs are looking for reassurance about:

• Your reliability and work ethic
• Your teachability and insight into your past difficulties
• Your fit with the team and love for pediatrics

Practical advice:

• Have 2–3 patient stories ready that showcase:
  • Compassion with a child or family
  • Handling a difficult or emotionally charged situation
  • Demonstrating attention to detail and follow-up
• Practice answering score-related questions with a friend, mentor, or mock interviewer.
• Communicate energy and enthusiasm without sounding desperate:
  • “I’m genuinely excited about pediatrics and your program specifically because…”

B. Subtly Reassuring Programs About Academic Risk

Without overfocusing on scores, you can subtly reassure interviewers by mentioning:

• Self-directed reading you do regularly
• Study systems you now use to maintain knowledge
• How you prepared for and succeeded in later clinical exams or in-service exams (if applicable)

Example:

“On my sub-internship, I created a daily reading habit tied to my patients’ problems. That has helped me solidify knowledge far better than before, and my shelf exam performance improved as a result.”

C. Crafting a Smart Rank Order List

When ranking programs for the pediatrics residency match:

1. Rank by genuine preference, not by where you think you’re “most likely” to match—NRMP algorithms favor applicant preference.
2. Still, maintain breadth on your list:
   • Include a solid number of DO-friendly and community-leaning programs.
3. Include at least a few programs where:
   • You have personal connections (mentors, alumni, or prior rotation).

Don’t self-eliminate by under-ranking programs that you’d be happy to train at because their reputation isn’t “perfect.” As a DO graduate with low scores, a solid, supportive pediatrics residency can launch you into an excellent career, regardless of pedigree.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I match into pediatrics with a low Step 1 score as a DO graduate?

Yes. Pediatrics is relatively DO-friendly, and many programs consider applicants holistically. A low Step 1 (or COMLEX Level 1) reduces options but does not eliminate your chances. Your best moves are to:

• Excel in clinical rotations, especially pediatrics
• Improve Step 2 CK / Level 2-CE performance if possible
• Secure strong, specific letters of recommendation
• Apply broadly and strategically to DO-friendly and community-focused programs

Many residents in pediatrics today matched successfully despite initially matching with low scores.

2. Should I take USMLE if I’m a DO with only COMLEX and low scores?

If you have not yet taken USMLE and your COMLEX scores are already low or borderline, adding a potentially low USMLE score may not help—and could hurt. However:

• If you are early enough and believe you can significantly outperform your COMLEX on USMLE, it may be worth considering, especially for more competitive academic programs.
• If you are close to application season and uncertain, it is usually safer to focus on maximizing Step 2/Level 2 and clinical performance rather than rushing into USMLE.

Discuss your specific numbers and circumstances with your school’s advisor or a trusted mentor.

3. Does doing a pediatrics research year help overcome low scores?

A dedicated research year can help, but it’s not the right choice for everyone. It is most useful if:

• You are aiming for academic or research-heavy programs.
• You can produce tangible outcomes: publications, posters, strong mentorship relationships.
• You have time and financial support to take the extra year.

For many DO applicants with low scores, a targeted approach—strong rotations, letters, and a broad, well-constructed rank list—may achieve a peds match without requiring a full research year.

4. What if I go unmatched in pediatrics as a DO with low scores?

If you go unmatched:

1. Participate in SOAP and consider:

   • Unfilled pediatrics programs
   • Related fields (family medicine with strong pediatrics exposure)

2. Meet with your dean/advisors to review:

   • Application list breadth
   • Strength of letters and personal statement
   • Interview performance and any red flags

3. Consider a structured plan for reapplication:

   • Additional clinical experience or a preliminary/transitional year
   • Improved Step 2/Level 2 performance if still pending
   • Building more pediatric involvement or scholarship

Many applicants successfully match on a second attempt with a stronger, more strategic approach.

---

Low Step 1 or COMLEX scores are not the end of your pediatrics dream as a DO graduate. By owning your weaknesses, showcasing your strengths, and crafting a disciplined, honest, and strategic application, you can give programs compelling reasons to see beyond the numbers and see you as the pediatric resident—and future pediatrician—you are ready to become.