Essential Strategies for DO Graduates with Low Step Scores in Med-Peds

Understanding the Challenge: Low Scores as a DO Applying to Med-Peds

Applying to Medicine-Pediatrics (Med-Peds) with a low Step 1 score or below-average board scores can feel intimidating, especially as a DO graduate. But a low numerical score does not automatically mean you won’t match. Many DO graduates successfully secure a med peds residency spot each year despite imperfect exam performance.

The key is to understand:

• How program directors interpret low scores
• Where DO graduates often face extra scrutiny
• What specific actions you can take—now—to offset weaker metrics

In this guide, we’ll focus on practical strategies tailored to:

• DO graduate residency applicants
• Those aiming for the osteopathic residency match or the combined NRMP match
• Applicants targeting the medicine pediatrics match specifically
• Individuals matching with low scores (e.g., low Step 1, weak COMLEX, or below-average Step 2 CK)

By the end, you should have a concrete, step-by-step plan to improve your chances of matching Med-Peds, even with less-than-ideal board performance.

---

How Program Directors View Low Scores in Med-Peds

Med-Peds is competitive, but not in the same way as dermatology or plastic surgery. It’s a small specialty with fewer programs and positions, meaning every application stands out—positively or negatively. As a DO graduate with a low Step 1 score, it helps to understand what Med-Peds program directors typically think when they see your file.

1. Scores Are a Screening Tool, Not the Whole Story

Most programs use board scores for initial screening, especially if they receive hundreds of applications for a handful of spots. Your Step 1, Step 2 CK, and COMLEX scores help them quickly:

• Meet institutional minimums
• Identify risk for board failure during residency
• Estimate your likely success on ABIM and ABP exams

However, once your application is past the initial filter, the context matters a lot:

• Was there an upward trend from Step 1 to Step 2?
• Did you remediate or repeat a course and then excel afterward?
• Do your clinical evaluations contradict the low test score (e.g., “Top 10% student”)?

Many Med-Peds PDs value maturity, adaptability, and longitudinal commitment as much as numerical metrics.

2. DO vs MD: How Much Does It Matter?

With the single accreditation system, most internal medicine, pediatrics, and med peds residency programs are now experienced with DO graduates. Still, a DO graduate residency candidate may face:

• Less familiarity from some allopathic-heavy academic centers
• Assumptions (sometimes unfair) when COMLEX is the primary score
• Additional scrutiny if you have only COMLEX and no USMLE scores

For Med-Peds, DO graduates often match strongly, especially at community-based academic programs, former AOA programs, and institutions with a history of training DOs. Your DO degree is not the problem; rather, the combination of DO status and low scores may place you under more careful review.

3. Where Low Scores Hurt the Most

For the medicine pediatrics match, low scores can especially harm you when:

• Applying to highly academic, research-heavy Med-Peds programs
• Applying with multiple failures (e.g., Step 1 fail + Step 2 fail)
• Lacking any offsetting strength (research, strong letters, leadership, etc.)

Your strategy should be to:

1. Minimize the visible risk (e.g., strong Step 2 or Level 2, no new red flags).
2. Maximize positive differentiators that matter to Med-Peds: continuity, underserved care, complex chronic disease, and cross-disciplinary thinking.

---

Academic Recovery: Turning Low Scores Into a Manageable Weakness

You can’t change your Step 1 score, but you can change the narrative around it. Program directors aren’t only looking at the number; they’re asking: What does this say about how this applicant will perform going forward?

1. Step 2 CK and COMLEX Level 2: Your Redemption Exams

If you have a low Step 1 score or Level 1 score, the single most powerful countermeasure is a noticeably stronger Step 2 CK/Level 2 performance.

Concrete targets (these aren’t hard cutoffs, but directional):

• If your Step 1 was below average (e.g., in the 210s before pass/fail), aim for Step 2 CK in the mid/upper 220s–230s+ or better.
• If your COMLEX Level 1 was low, focus on Level 2 being at least 50–100 points higher, if possible.
• Avoid failing or needing extended time for Step 2/Level 2—those will be harder to explain.

Actionable strategies:

• Treat Step 2/Level 2 as a fresh start, not just another hurdle.
• Use a strict 6–8 week dedicated study period, if your schedule allows.
• Prioritize high-yield resources (UWorld, COMBANK/COMQUEST, NBME practice tests, structured schedule).
• Create a study accountability system: weekly score tracking with a mentor, advisor, or trusted peer.

Messaging in your application:
If Step 2 shows clear improvement, explicitly highlight this in your personal statement or MSPE addendum:

“While my Step 1 performance did not reflect my capabilities, I made substantial changes to my study strategies and time management. My Step 2 CK and COMLEX Level 2 scores demonstrate my ability to integrate complex material and succeed under pressure.”

2. Handle Fails and Remediations Proactively

If you had a Step 1 fail or a COMLEX failure, do not ignore it and hope no one notices. In Med-Peds, where continuity, trustworthiness, and reflection are valued, how you own the setback is crucial.

What program directors want to see:

• Insight into why it happened (test-taking anxiety, illness, misjudged prep—briefly and honestly)
• Concrete changes you made (study plan, mental health support, time management, practice exams)
• Evidence that the pattern did not continue (e.g., strong Level 2/Step 2, strong clerkship grades)

Where to address it:

• A concise, mature paragraph in your personal statement
• A brief comment in your dean’s letter/MSPE (if your school includes this)
• Optional: a short note in the ERAS “Additional Information” section

Avoid over-apologizing or emotional over-sharing; keep it professional and forward-looking.

3. Maximize the Rest of Your Academic Record

Program directors weigh your clinical performance very heavily in Med-Peds:

• Honors or high passes in Internal Medicine and Pediatrics clerkships
• Strong performance in sub-internships (especially Med-Peds, IM, or Peds)
• Narrative comments praising teamwork, reliability, and patient communication

If your board scores are weak, try to make your grade transcript your strength:

• Aim to honor your Med-Peds, IM, or Peds sub-I if possible.
• Ask attendings for written mid-rotation feedback and implement suggestions to improve evaluations.
• If you’re still on rotations, actively request high-yield learning opportunities (presentations, leading patient discussions, QI projects).

---

Building a Med-Peds-Focused Profile That Outshines Your Scores

In Med-Peds, your “fit” matters. The specialty attracts applicants who are thoughtful, team-oriented, and committed to caring for complex patients across the lifespan. This gives you room to stand out based on who you are and what you’ve done, not only your numeric metrics.

1. Prioritize Strong, Targeted Letters of Recommendation

For a DO graduate with below average board scores, outstanding letters can be game-changing. Aim for 3–4 letters including:

• At least one from an Internal Medicine faculty
• At least one from a Pediatrics faculty
• Ideally one Med-Peds faculty if available (from Med-Peds clinic, rotation, or sub-I)

If your school doesn’t have a Med-Peds department, consider:

• Away rotations or audition rotations at Med-Peds programs
• Longitudinal clinic with a Med-Peds physician in community practice
• Virtual or in-person mentorship from a Med-Peds physician who knows your work

What a powerful letter looks like:

• Concrete examples: “Took ownership of complex patients, followed through on all tasks.”
• Comparative language: “One of the top students I have worked with in the past X years.”
• Endorsement for Med-Peds specifically: “I believe they will thrive in a Med-Peds residency.”

To earn such letters, you must act like a junior resident on your clinical rotations: show up early, know your patients thoroughly, and contribute meaningfully to the team.

2. Demonstrate a Genuine Med-Peds Identity

Many applicants say they are “undecided between IM and Peds.” As a Med-Peds applicant, you should instead show a coherent story about why the combined specialty fits you.

You can build this narrative even with low scores:

• Involvement in free clinics that care for both adults and children
• QI or research projects focused on transitions of care, chronic illnesses, or underserved populations
• Longitudinal interest in areas where Med-Peds shines:
  • Cystic fibrosis
  • Sickle cell disease
  • Congenital heart disease
  • Childhood-onset diabetes or rheumatologic disease
  • Complex care and disability medicine

Don’t just list activities; tie them together in your personal statement and interviews:

“Throughout medical school, I’ve found myself drawn to patients whose illnesses cross traditional age boundaries. Working with young adults with congenital heart disease in clinic highlighted the unique role Med-Peds physicians play in bridging pediatric and adult systems.”

3. Strategic Use of Away Rotations (Auditions)

Away rotations can be particularly powerful for DO graduate residency applicants in Med-Peds, especially if you’re aiming for programs that might otherwise screen you out based on scores.

Best practices:

• Choose 1–2 away rotations at Med-Peds programs where:

  • They have a track record of taking DOs
  • Your Step 1/COMLEX is near their usual cut-offs, even if a bit low
  • Their priorities align with your strengths (underserved care, community focus, global health, etc.)

• Approach the rotation as a month-long interview:

  • Be reliable, prepared, and humble
  • Show interest in both medicine and pediatrics services, not just one side
  • Ask for feedback mid-rotation and adjust
  • If appropriate, ask directly for a letter near the end:

    “I’m very interested in Med-Peds and have appreciated working with you. Would you feel comfortable writing a strong letter of recommendation on my behalf?”

An excellent performance on an away rotation can overshadow low Step scores in some program directors’ eyes.

---

Application Strategy: Program Selection, Application Volume, and Messaging

A thoughtful application strategy is critical for matching with low scores. It’s not only about who you are; it’s about where and how you apply.

1. Be Strategic With Program Selection

Not every Med-Peds program is equally reachable with low Step 1 or below average board scores, especially as a DO graduate. To maximize your osteopathic residency match or NRMP success:

Focus your list on:

• Programs with a history of taking DOs
• Community-based academic or university-affiliated community programs
• Former AOA programs that are now ACGME-accredited
• Programs in regions where DOs are more common (Midwest, parts of the Northeast, some Southern states)
• Programs that specifically emphasize:
  • Primary care
  • Underserved populations
  • Community health
  • Continuity clinics and complex care clinics

Be cautious with:

• Highly research-heavy, top-tier academic programs with historically few DOs
• Programs that explicitly list Step 1 cut-offs you fall significantly below
• Programs that do not accept COMLEX without USMLE, if you only took COMLEX

2. How Many Programs to Apply To?

With low Step 1 or below average scores, you should generally apply more broadly than someone with stronger metrics.

For Med-Peds, where programs are fewer, many applicants already apply widely. As a DO with low scores, consider:

• Applying to the majority of Med-Peds programs that are realistic and DO-friendly
• Strongly considering dual-application:
  • Med-Peds plus Categorical Internal Medicine
  • Or Med-Peds plus Categorical Pediatrics

Dual-application is a very effective safety strategy. You can still shape your career similarly (e.g., combined practice, hospitalist work with both adult and pediatric exposure, or fellowship) even if you don’t match Med-Peds.

3. Crafting a Personal Statement That Addresses Weakness Without Centering It

Your personal statement shouldn’t revolve around your low Step score—but it also shouldn’t ignore significant red flags.

Structure suggestion:

1. Opening: A patient story or experience that illustrates why you are drawn to Med-Peds (not just “I like adults and kids”).
2. Development: Specific experiences that show your longitudinal interest, resilience, and growth (e.g., continuity clinic, complex care, underserved populations).
3. Addressing scores (if needed): One concise, reflective paragraph on any significant academic issue:
   • Take responsibility
   • Briefly explain context
   • Emphasize what changed and how your later performance reflects that
4. Closing: Your goals and what you’re looking for in a Med-Peds residency, with an emphasis on fit (teaching, continuity, underserved care, etc.).

Make sure the tone is forward-looking and confident, not apologetic or defensive.

4. Optimize Every Other Element of ERAS

With weaker board scores, everything else must be polished:

• CV:

  • List leadership, volunteer work, and projects in clear, outcome-oriented language.
  • Highlight continuity or longitudinal activities (multi-year commitments).

• Experiences section: Use action verbs and specific outcomes:

  • “Led a QI project that reduced no-show rates in pediatric clinic by 15%.”
  • “Coordinated follow-up care for adult patients with congenital heart disease transitioning from pediatric to adult services.”

• Photo: Professional, friendly, and appropriate—this impacts first impressions.

• Timing:

  • Submit your ERAS on day 1 of submission opening.
  • Make sure all letters and transcripts are ready as early as possible.

---

Interview and Rank List: How to Match With Low Scores

Once you’ve earned interviews, your scores become less central. Now, your goal is to leave programs thinking: “I would love to work with this person for 4 years.”

1. Mastering the “Low Scores” Question

You will likely be asked about your low Step 1 score or below average performance. Have a polished, honest answer ready.

Framework:

1. Acknowledge briefly: “Yes, my Step 1 score was lower than I had hoped.”
2. Context (short): One or two sentences—avoid excessive excuses.
3. Actions taken: Emphasize what changed (study strategies, wellness, coaching, time management).
4. Outcome and growth: Point to improved Step 2/Level 2, clinical performance, or other successes.
5. Tie to residency: Explain how this makes you a more prepared, resilient resident.

Example:

“My Step 1 score doesn’t reflect my true capabilities. I underestimated how to effectively prepare for that style of exam and didn’t seek help early enough. Afterward, I met with our learning specialist, created a structured study plan, and completed multiple full-length practice exams. As a result, my Step 2 CK and Level 2 scores improved significantly, and my clinical supervisors have consistently commented on my preparation and reliability. Going through that experience taught me how to adapt quickly and how to proactively seek feedback—skills that I know will be critical in residency.”

2. Highlight Strengths That Matter for Med-Peds

In interviews, emphasize attributes that Med-Peds programs particularly value:

• Continuity orientation: Long-term follow-up, clinic-based experiences, or multi-year volunteering.
• Systems thinking: Understanding transitions of care and multidisciplinary teamwork.
• Adaptability: Comfort working with different age groups and complexity levels.
• Humility and teachability: Willingness to learn, seek help, and support the team.

Use specific stories to illustrate each trait. Vague claims (“I’m a hard worker”) are not as persuasive as concrete examples.

3. Ranking Strategy for Applicants With Low Scores

When building your rank list for the medicine pediatrics match:

• Rank programs in the true order of your preference. The algorithm favors applicants.
• Do not try to “game” the system by ranking safety programs first.
• If you dual-applied:
  • Rank all Med-Peds programs first in your true preference order.
  • Then follow with IM or Peds categorical programs you would genuinely attend and complete.

If you are deeply concerned about going unmatched, discuss with an advisor whether to include a small number of prelim IM or transitional year programs as a last-resort safety—but understand those do not guarantee a PGY-2 Med-Peds path.

---

FAQs: Low Step Score Strategies for DO Med-Peds Applicants

1. Can I match Med-Peds as a DO with a low Step 1 score?

Yes, it is absolutely possible. Many DO graduates with low Step 1 or below average board scores match successfully into Med-Peds each year. Your chances improve significantly if:

• Step 2/Level 2 shows clear improvement
• You have strong IM and Peds clinical evaluations
• You secure excellent letters (especially from Med-Peds, IM, and Peds faculty)
• You apply broadly and strategically, focusing on DO-friendly and community-based academic programs
• You consider dual-applying to categorical IM and/or Peds

2. Should I take USMLE if I already have COMLEX and low scores?

If you are early enough in your training and haven’t taken USMLE yet, it can sometimes help to have both COMLEX and USMLE, especially for university-based programs that prefer USMLE. However:

• If your COMLEX scores are already low, a weak USMLE score may not help and could add another concern.
• If you have not prepared adequately for USMLE-style questions, taking it under-prepared can hurt your application.

Discuss with your school’s advisor and consider your practice test performance before deciding. If you already have a full set of low USMLE scores, the focus should shift to Step 2 improvement and overall application strength, not adding more exams.

3. How many Med-Peds programs should I apply to with low scores?

There’s no universal number, but with low Step 1 or below average board scores, you should plan to apply broadly—often to nearly all Med-Peds programs that:

• Accept DOs
• Have no strict cutoffs far above your scores
• Align with your interests (community, underserved, academic-but-DO-friendly)

Many such applicants also dual-apply to Internal Medicine and/or Pediatrics to ensure a reasonable match probability. Your exact numbers should be individualized in consultation with a trusted advisor who knows your full profile.

4. Should I explain my low Step 1 score in my personal statement?

If your low Step 1 score is a single, modest weakness and your subsequent performance is strong, you may not need to explicitly address it. However, if you had:

• A Step 1 failure
• Multiple exam issues
• Or a large discrepancy between Step 1 and later performance

Then it is usually wise to briefly address the issue in your personal statement or ERAS additional information section. Keep it concise, honest, and focused on growth and improvement, rather than dwelling on the negative.

---

For a DO graduate with low Step scores targeting the medicine pediatrics match, success is less about perfection and more about strategy, self-awareness, and execution. By strengthening your clinical profile, leveraging strong mentorship and letters, applying smartly, and owning your story, you can significantly improve your chances of matching into a Med-Peds residency that fits you well.