Strategies for DO Graduates with Low Step Scores in Denver Residency

Residency applicants often whisper about low Step scores as if they’re a permanent barrier. For a DO graduate in Denver—or hoping to train in Denver—this can feel especially stressful, given the competitive nature of Colorado residency programs. Yet every cycle, applicants with a low Step 1 score, below average board scores, or even a failed attempt successfully match into solid programs, including in Colorado.

This article focuses on realistic, practical strategies for DO graduates in the Denver area (or targeting Denver) who are worried about matching with low scores. The emphasis is on what you can still control now—how to position yourself, how to use Denver-specific advantages, and how to present your application so that programs see you as more than a number.

---

Understanding What “Low Step Score” Means in Today’s Match

Before you can build a strategy, you need a clear picture of where you stand.

What counts as a “low score”?

In residency-speak, “low score” is relative. For DO graduates, we’re usually talking about:

• USMLE Step 1 (pre-pass/fail era): Scores significantly below national mean or any fail
• USMLE Step 2 CK: <220–225 often raises concern for more competitive specialties or university programs
• COMLEX-USA Level 1 and 2-CE: Scores that are:
  • Below the national mean (around 500)
  • Near or below 450–475 for moderate-competitive fields
  • Any failure or multiple attempts

If your scores are in these ranges, your file likely triggers extra scrutiny or screens at many programs—especially academic centers.

Impact of Step 1 now that it’s pass/fail

Many DO graduates think pass/fail Step 1 removes the problem. It does not for three key reasons:

1. Legacy numeric scores still matter if you took Step 1 before the change.
2. Step 2 CK and COMLEX Level 2-CE are now more heavily weighted as objective metrics.
3. Programs still care about pattern: multiple attempts, big score drops, or inconsistent performance are red flags.

If your Step 1 was low, you must treat Step 2 CK/Level 2-CE as your redemption exam and build your story around growth, resilience, and improvement.

Special considerations for DO graduates

As a DO grad, you carry both advantages and challenges:

Advantages:

• OMM/OMT training can be an asset, especially in primary care and some Denver-area community programs.
• Many programs—particularly in Colorado and the Mountain West—have strong histories of training DOs.
• Holistic review is more seriously applied to DO applicants in many community and primary care–focused programs.

Challenges:

• Some academic programs still prefer or are more familiar with MD transcripts, though this is improving.
• Not all Denver residency programs are equally comfortable interpreting COMLEX—some still “prefer” or “require” USMLE.

Understanding this landscape helps you target the right programs and adjust your strategy accordingly.

---

How Denver and Colorado Programs Evaluate Applicants With Low Scores

You’re not just applying “somewhere.” You’re applying in a specific region with its own patterns. Let’s look at Denver residency programs and broader Colorado residency considerations for DO graduates with low scores.

Types of Denver-area programs

1. Academic/University-affiliated

   • Examples: University of Colorado–affiliated residencies, large tertiary centers in Denver and Aurora
   • Typically more competitive, with higher score thresholds
   • More research emphasis, more sub-specialty exposure

2. Community-based / community-university hybrids

   • Many front-range hospitals (Denver metro, Aurora, Lakewood, Westminster, etc.)
   • Often more open to DO applicants and more flexible with scores, if the rest of the application is strong

3. Primary-care–focused programs (IM, FM, Pediatrics)

   • Many are mission-driven: serving underserved populations, rural/urban communities
   • More likely to adopt holistic review and to value community service, leadership, and fit

How Colorado programs screen low scores

While each program is different, several patterns are common:

• Score cutoffs still exist, especially in university programs:

  • Some internal Medicare compliance or GME rules lead to “soft” or “hard” cutoffs.
  • For borderline applicants, strong letters, ties to Colorado, and rotations in Denver can help override an initial screen.

• Preference for Step 2/COMLEX Level 2 performance:

  • If your Step 1 or Level 1 is low, but Step 2/Level 2 is significantly higher, many PDs see this as:
    • Improved test-taking
    • Better clinical application of knowledge
  • For Denver, this is particularly important: programs often receive many applications and use Step 2 filters to thin the pool.

• Ties to Colorado / Denver really matter:

  • Growing up in Colorado, undergrad or med school in the region, family in Denver, or long-term commitment to stay can strongly help borderline candidates.
  • Many Denver programs know retention is better when residents have local ties.

DO-specific factors in Denver

Denver and Colorado residency programs vary in their comfort with DO graduates. Some patterns:

• Many primary care and community hospitals are DO-friendly, regularly taking DO residents and often having DO faculty.
• University-affiliated or sub-specialty programs may:
  • Prefer USMLE scores even for DOs
  • Be more selective with below average board scores

If you are a DO graduate with low scores hoping to stay in Denver, this means:

• You must be more strategic.
• You should strongly consider a broader geographic application list beyond Denver and Colorado as your backup.
• You’ll need to actively highlight your DO training and how it fits each program’s mission.

---

Academic Repair: Concrete Steps to Offset a Low Step or COMLEX

Even if your Step 1 score or Level 1 performance is already set, you can still significantly change how programs see you by what you do next.

1. Crush Step 2 CK and COMLEX Level 2-CE

If you haven’t taken Step 2/Level 2 yet, this is priority number one.

Goals:

• Show clear improvement over previous scores
• Demonstrate that your low Step 1 or Level 1 was an outlier, not your ceiling

Action plan:

• Diagnostic self-assessment early

  • Take a practice NBME or COMSAE roughly 3–4 months before your planned exam date.
  • If your predicted score is still low, postpone the exam (within reason) and extend your dedicated study time.

• Treat Step 2/Level 2 as a full-time job

  • 8–10 weeks of focused prep if your foundation is weaker or your Step 1/Level 1 score was low.
  • Use high-yield, question-based resources:
    • UWorld Step 2 Qbank (even for DOs, it’s invaluable)
    • COMBANK or COMQUEST for Level 2-CE
  • Prioritize:
    • Clinical reasoning
    • High-yield systems (cardio, pulm, neuro, OB/GYN, peds, psych, ID)

• Track progress weekly

  • Use a simple spreadsheet: date, Qbank blocks done, % correct, notes on weak areas.
  • Aim for upward trends; if stagnant, adjust strategy (tutor, different study schedule).

Target narrative:
“Early on, I struggled with standardized tests (e.g., Step 1/Level 1), but I recognized this and changed my approach. My Step 2/Level 2 scores reflect that growth and now align with my clinical performance.”

Programs in Denver will pay attention to that upward trend.

2. Use clerkship grades and clinical evaluations to your advantage

For DO graduates with a low Step 1 score or below average board scores, clinical excellence becomes your currency.

Focus on:

• Honors or high-pass in core rotations related to your target specialty:
  • For IM: internal medicine, ICU, sub-I
  • For FM: family medicine, internal medicine, pediatrics, OB
  • For EM: emergency medicine, surgery, internal medicine
• Strong comments in evaluations:
  • “Hardworking,” “reliable,” “strong team player,” “excellent clinical reasoning,” “respected by nurses and staff”

How this helps in Colorado residency programs:

• Many Denver programs have smaller resident classes and tight-knit teams. They value:
  • Reliability
  • Work ethic
  • Collegiality
• Excellent clinical evaluations help reassure PDs that your test scores do not reflect your real-world performance.

3. Address any exam failures strategically

If you have a failed Step or COMLEX attempt, you must:

• Never hide it. PDs will see it.
• Prepare a brief, honest, non-defensive explanation you can use in:
  • Your personal statement (if relevant)
  • Interviews (if asked)

Example framing:

“During my early preparation for COMLEX Level 1, I underestimated how important structured, question-based practice was. After my initial failure, I changed my study strategy completely—working with a faculty advisor, doing daily timed questions, and setting up a strict schedule. These changes led to a clear improvement on my subsequent exams and more importantly, translated into stronger clinical performance on rotations.”

Aim for: own the mistake → show growth → show improved results.

---

Building a Denver-Focused Application Strategy With Low Scores

With your academic repair plan underway, the next step is to build an application strategy that maximizes your chances of matching—even with below average board scores.

1. Be realistic but not defeatist about specialty choice

Some combinations are tough:

• Low Step 1 score + low Step 2 + DO + aiming for very competitive specialties (Derm, Ortho, ENT, Neurosurgery) in Denver = extremely low probability.

If you’re set on a very competitive specialty with low scores, consider:

• A broader geographic footprint beyond Denver and Colorado.
• Potential transitional or preliminary years as stepping stones.
• Honest conversations with advisors who know the specialty’s current competitiveness.

That said, many specialties remain realistic for DO graduates with low scores, especially when paired with strong clinical performance:

• Family Medicine
• Internal Medicine
• Pediatrics
• Psychiatry
• OB/GYN (depending on how low the scores are and the rest of your file)
• Some community Emergency Medicine programs

Denver has programs in many of these fields, but the number of positions is limited. So a Colorado residency target should be part of a national strategy, not your only plan.

2. Target DO-friendly and holistic-review programs

When you’re matching with low scores, the program list is everything.

What to look for:

• Programs that:
  • Clearly list COMLEX accepted (not “USMLE required”)
  • Have a history of taking DO residents (check current resident rosters on websites)
  • Emphasize community service, primary care, or underserved populations
  • Refer to “holistic review” or “adversity” in their PD statements

Practical steps for Denver/Colorado:

• Make a spreadsheet of:
  • All Denver residency programs in your target specialty
  • All Colorado residency options statewide (e.g., Colorado Springs, Fort Collins, Greeley, Pueblo, Grand Junction)
• For each program, note:
  • DO residents currently in training?
  • Stated COMLEX/USMLE policy?
  • Mission/values (e.g., rural health, underserved, academic, research-heavy)?

Use this to prioritize where your low Step score is least likely to be a deal-breaker.

3. Use away rotations and Denver ties strategically

For DO graduates with low scores, face time is often more powerful than a number.

If you’re still in medical school or in a pre-residency year:

• Apply for away rotations in Denver or across Colorado at:
  • Community programs likely to take DOs
  • University-affiliated programs if you have reasonably competitive Step 2/Level 2
• On rotation:
  • Be present, engaged, and prepared.
  • Show up early, stay late when appropriate.
  • Help the team in small but visible ways (notes, follow-up calls, patient education).

Goal:
Turn a low-scoring, unknown name on a spreadsheet into a trusted student that attendings and residents will advocate for.

If you already live or trained in Denver:

• Highlight long-term ties to Colorado:
  • “I grew up in Colorado and plan to build my career here.”
  • “My family and support system are in Denver.”
• Denver programs care about retention; this can help outweigh a low score when they compare borderline candidates.

---

Optimizing Your Application: Personal Statement, Letters, and Interviews

When your numbers are not your strength, everything else must be deliberately excellent.

1. Craft a focused, honest personal statement

Your personal statement should not be a rehash of your CV. It should explain, connect, and humanize.

Key goals for low-score applicants:

• Explain any big outliers (if necessary) briefly, without making them the centerpiece.
• Emphasize your clinical strengths, resilience, work ethic, and fit with the program’s mission.
• Connect yourself specifically to Denver and Colorado residency if that is your priority.

Example points to include:

• A specific patient or rotation in Colorado that shaped your career goals.
• Experiences that show your commitment to underserved or diverse populations in Denver.
• How your osteopathic training (e.g., OMT, whole-person approach) fits with primary care or community programs in the region.

Avoid long, detailed explanations of Step score struggles; 1–2 sentences is usually enough. Focus on “who you are now and what you bring”, not “what went wrong.”

2. Secure targeted, high-impact letters of recommendation

For DO graduates with low scores, letters can change the conversation in selection meetings.

Prioritize letters from:

• Faculty who directly supervised you clinically and can:
  • Speak to your clinical reasoning
  • Describe your reliability and team orientation
  • Compare you favorably to peers
• Program directors, clerkship directors, or chiefs who:
  • Understand the specialty
  • Can say “I would be happy to have this student in my program”

Strategic moves:

• If you can rotate in Denver residency programs:

  • Aim to earn at least one letter from a Denver-based attending in your target specialty.
  • This not only shows you’re known in the region but suggests some degree of “local endorsement.”

• If you’ve had academic struggles:

  • At least one letter should mention how you overcame challenges and now perform at a high level despite earlier stumble.

3. Master the interview narrative

Once you land interviews, your job is to reframe your application in real time.

Expect variants of:

• “Can you tell me about your board scores?”
• “I see you had a difficult time with Step 1/COMLEX—what happened?”

Use a three-part structure:

1. Briefly state the challenge

   • “During my early test preparation, I didn’t yet have effective strategies for large standardized exams, and my Step 1/Level 1 score reflected that.”

2. Describe specific changes you made

   • “I met with faculty mentors, changed to a question-based approach, and structured my time much more strictly. I also took additional practice exams to calibrate my performance.”

3. Highlight improved outcomes and ongoing habits

   • “Those changes are reflected in my improved Step 2/Level 2 performance and in my strong clinical evaluations. I continue to use those strategies now—pre-reading before shifts, active recall, and seeking feedback.”

Keep the tone:

• Ownership, not blame
• Growth, not excuses
• Confidence, not defensiveness

Interviewers in Denver and elsewhere will often accept a low Step 1 score or below average board scores if they are convinced that:

• You’ve learned from it
• You’re a strong clinical performer
• You’ll be a professional, reliable resident who fits their program culture

---

Backup Plans and Risk Management for DO Graduates With Low Scores

Even with a strong strategy, a low Step 1 score or COMLEX score comes with risk. You must plan accordingly.

1. Apply broadly—geographically and program-wise

If your heart is set on Denver residency programs, absolutely apply and give yourself a shot. But if your scores are significantly below average:

• Apply to a wider geographic area: mountain states, Midwest, South, and community-heavy regions.
• Include a mix of program types:
  • Community vs. university
  • Urban vs. smaller city
  • Extra emphasis on DO-friendly institutions

Treat Denver and Colorado as a high-priority cluster, not your only cluster.

2. Have a realistic rank list strategy

When ranking:

• Avoid overloading your top ranks only with highly competitive Denver programs if:
  • Your scores and overall file are not aligned with their usual residents.
• Include enough programs where:
  • DOs are well represented
  • Holistic review is explicit
  • Your advisors believe you are solidly competitive

This approach may mean choosing training quality and match security over city preference in some rank slots—but it dramatically lowers the risk of not matching at all.

3. Contingency if you don’t match

If you are a DO graduate with low scores and unfortunately go unmatched:

Immediate steps (SOAP):

• Work closely with your school’s advisors or mentors during SOAP.
• Prioritize:
  • Unfilled prelim or transitional years
  • Primary care programs
  • DO-friendly residencies anywhere

Longer-term strategy if still unmatched:

• Consider:
  • A preliminary year (IM, surgery) to build clinical credibility and secure strong new letters.
  • A research year in your target specialty, ideally at a DO-friendly academic center.
  • Master’s or additional training only if it clearly boosts your competitiveness (not always necessary).

In all cases, emphasize:

• Ongoing clinical exposure
• Steady professional development
• Clear, honest narrative about your path when you reapply

---

FAQs: Low Step Score Strategies for DO Graduates in Denver

1. Can I match into a Denver residency program with a low Step 1 score as a DO graduate?

Yes, it’s possible, but it depends on how low, your Step 2/COMLEX Level 2 performance, and the strength of the rest of your application. Many Denver and Colorado residency programs practice holistic review, especially in primary care and community-focused specialties. You improve your odds by:

• Showing clear score improvement on later exams
• Excelling in clinical rotations and secure strong letters
• Demonstrating genuine ties or commitment to Denver/Colorado

You should still apply broadly outside Denver as part of a risk-balanced strategy.

2. Should I take the USMLE if I already have COMLEX scores and they’re low?

If you’re a DO graduate with only COMLEX and below average board scores, the decision is nuanced:

• If you are targeting university or academic programs in Denver or Colorado that strongly prefer USMLE, then a solid Step 2 CK score could help you—but only if you’re confident you can do well.
• If your test-taking challenges persist and you’re likely to score low again, taking USMLE may add another weak data point, which can hurt more than help.

Discuss this decision with advisors who:

• Know your performance trajectory
• Understand your target specialty and the Colorado landscape

3. How important are Denver or Colorado ties if my scores are low?

Very important. For borderline applicants, local ties can be the difference between:

• Being screened out vs. offered an interview
• Being seen as a “flight risk” vs. a “likely to stay” candidate

If you have ties (grew up in Colorado, family in Denver, prior work/hospital exposure in the region), make them explicit in your personal statement and ERAS application. If not, consider rotations in Colorado and long-term professional involvement in the region as ways to build a genuine connection.

4. Are there particular specialties in Colorado more open to DO graduates with low scores?

Yes. While each program is unique, DO graduates with low scores are generally more competitive in:

• Family Medicine
• Internal Medicine (especially community-based)
• Pediatrics
• Psychiatry
• Select OB/GYN and community EM programs

These fields often value:

• Commitment to patient-centered care
• Community service
• Long-term fit with local populations

Denver and wider Colorado have multiple programs in these specialties that regularly accept DO residents, especially those who demonstrate strong clinical performance, professionalism, and a clear commitment to practicing in the region.

---

A low Step 1 score, COMLEX struggle, or below average board scores do not define your potential as a physician—nor do they automatically exclude you from Colorado residency or Denver residency programs. With a focused academic repair plan, a Denver-aware application strategy, and a clear, growth-focused narrative, you can give programs a compelling reason to look beyond your numbers and see the physician you’re becoming.