Step Score Strategy for DO Graduates Pursuing Vascular Surgery Residency

Understanding the Step Score Landscape for DO Applicants in Vascular Surgery

Vascular surgery is one of the most competitive surgical subspecialties, and for a DO graduate, the pathway can feel even narrower—especially if your Step scores are not where you hoped. Yet every cycle, DO graduates successfully match into integrated vascular surgery residency programs, including those who would consider themselves “low Step score” applicants.

This article focuses on Step score strategy—how to interpret your performance, how to optimize remaining exams, and how to build an application that makes program directors say “yes” despite numbers that aren’t perfect.

We’ll specifically address:

• How vascular surgery programs view Step 1 and Step 2 CK in 2025 and beyond
• What “low Step score” realistically means in this specialty
• Strategic game plans for different Step score profiles (high, mid, low, and mixed)
• DO-specific tactics to compete in the osteopathic residency match environment
• Actionable Step 2 CK strategy for applicants who need a rebound score

Throughout, we’ll focus on your situation as a DO graduate targeting vascular surgery and position your scores within the bigger picture of a strong application.

---

How Vascular Surgery Programs View Step Scores Today

Even though Step 1 is now pass/fail, scores (where available) and pass status still matter, particularly in a competitive field like vascular surgery.

The Role of Step 1 for DO Graduates

If you took USMLE Step 1 when numeric scoring was still active:

• Competitive integrated vascular programs often historically preferred Step 1 in the 240–250+ range.
• A lower score doesn’t eliminate you, but it increases the importance of:
  • Step 2 CK
  • Vascular exposure and letters of recommendation
  • Research and academic productivity

If you only have COMLEX Level 1 or you took Step 1 as pass/fail:

• Many vascular programs now explicitly require or strongly prefer USMLE scores, but some are COMLEX-friendly.
• With pass/fail, the emphasis has shifted toward:
  • Step 2 CK (and Level 2-CE)
  • Clerkship performance and clinical evaluations
  • Vascular surgery rotations and sub-internships

Key idea: For many program directors, Step 1 now functions as a baseline screen (“Did they pass?”) rather than the final word. What you do on Step 2 CK—and how you frame your narrative—matters more than ever.

Step 2 CK: The Primary Objective Metric

Vascular surgery is a demanding, technical specialty that requires strong medical knowledge and clinical reasoning. As a result, Step 2 CK has become the central standardized metric.

Typical patterns:

• Many successful vascular surgery applicants have Step 2 CK scores in the 250+ range.
• Strong osteopathic candidates may succeed with mid-230s to 240s if the rest of their application stands out (research, letters, rotations).
• A low Step score match is still possible below those ranges, but it requires a deliberate, data-driven strategy and a strongly differentiated application.

For DO graduates, Step 2 CK often serves as:

• Proof of being competitive with MD peers
• Reassurance that any weaker earlier performance (e.g., Step 1 or Level 1) does not define your long-term capabilities

If your Step 2 CK is still ahead of you, it becomes your primary leverage point.

USMLE vs COMLEX: What Matters in Vascular Surgery

As a DO graduate, you may have:

• COMLEX only
• COMLEX + USMLE Step 1
• COMLEX + USMLE Steps 1 and 2

For vascular surgery residency, especially in ACGME-accredited integrated vascular programs, USMLE scores often carry more weight because:

• PDs are more familiar with USMLE scoring distributions.
• National benchmarks and filters are built on USMLE data.

That said, many programs now state they accept COMLEX-only applicants, and some are historically more DO-friendly (e.g., programs with osteopathic faculty, prior DO matches, or inclusive mission statements).

Strategic implication: If you’re still early (e.g., MS2–3) and serious about an academic vascular career, taking USMLE Step 2 CK in addition to COMLEX Level 2-CE frequently strengthens your application—especially if you can do well on it.

---

Defining a “Low Step Score” in Vascular Surgery

The phrase “low Step score match” is relative. For vascular surgery, the bar is high, but not absolute. Think in bands rather than fixed cutoffs.

Approximate Score Bands for Vascular Surgery Aspirants

These are rough conceptual bands, not rigid rules, and can shift slightly year to year:

• High scores (Very competitive):
  • Step 2 CK: 250+
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE: >640–650
• Upper mid-range (Competitive):
  • Step 2 CK: 240–249
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE: 610–640
• Lower mid-range (Viable with strengths elsewhere):
  • Step 2 CK: 230–239
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE: 580–610
• Low for vascular surgery (Needing a strategic boost):
  • Step 2 CK: <230
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE: <580

These ranges are more stringent than for many other specialties because vascular is small and competitive.

When Step Scores Become a Red Flag

Scores can raise concerns when:

• Multiple exams are low or show a downward trend (e.g., 225 Step 1 → 215 Step 2 CK).
• There are exam failures (Step, Level, or shelf failures) without a clear narrative of growth and improvement.
• Low Step 2 CK is paired with weak clerkship performance or poor letters of recommendation.

However, a single modest score—particularly if followed by improvement—rarely dooms your application if the rest of your file shines.

You’re not your score. But you need a plan so that your scores are not the only thing PDs see.

---

Tailored Step Score Strategies for Different Applicant Profiles

Your strategy depends on where you are in training and what your current score profile looks like. Below are realistic playbooks for various DO scenarios.

Scenario 1: DO with Strong Steps (Or Strong Step 2 CK)

Profile:

• Step 2 CK: 245–255+ (and/or high Level 2-CE)
• Step 1: pass (or solid score)
• Interested in academic or high-volume vascular centers

Step Score Strategy:

1. Use scores as a door-opener, not your entire brand.

   • You’ll likely clear most score filters.
   • Focus equally on vascular research, leadership, and strong sub-I performance.

2. Target a balanced list of integrated vascular programs.

   • Include both highly academic and mid-tier programs.
   • Don’t overreach with only top 10–15; competitiveness is multifactorial.

3. Leverage your scores in letters and personal statement indirectly.

   • Example: “My performance on Step 2 CK reflects a sustained dedication to clinical reasoning and patient-centered care developed during my core rotations…”

4. Still do not neglect COMLEX if required.

   • If you’re mid-DO school, ensure Level exams are consistent with your USMLE profile.

Takeaway: High scores give you options; they don’t replace the need to demonstrate fit and commitment to vascular surgery.

---

Scenario 2: DO with Average Step 1, Strong Step 2 CK (Rebound Story)

Profile:

• Step 1: Pass or modest score (if numeric)
• Step 2 CK: High (e.g., 240–250+)
• COMLEX: Similar pattern, with Level 2 stronger

This is a high-value profile for a DO applicant: improvement over time.

Step Score Strategy:

1. Highlight the upward trajectory.

   • Mention this briefly in your personal statement or MSPE if appropriate:
     • “While my earlier standardized exams were average, I systematically addressed my gaps, which is reflected in my Step 2 CK performance. This growth mindset mirrors how I will approach vascular surgery training.”

2. Study narrative > study excuses.

   • Do not over-explain Step 1.
   • Focus on what changed: schedule structure, question-based learning, early identification of weak systems.

3. Use your Step 2 CK as evidence you can thrive in a demanding specialty.

   • Ask letter writers (especially vascular or surgery faculty) to speak to your clinical reasoning and work ethic, connecting that to your recent exam performance.

4. Apply broadly but with confidence.

   • You are now competitive for many integrated vascular programs.
   • Combine this with strong sub-Is and vascular research.

Takeaway: An average Step 1 followed by an excellent Step 2 CK is a powerful comeback story and highly respected in competitive programs.

---

Scenario 3: DO with Strong Step 1, Lower Step 2 CK

Profile:

• Step 1: High or above average
• Step 2 CK: Drop or below expected range
• You’re concerned the downward trajectory will cause doubt.

Step Score Strategy:

1. Perform aggressive damage control on everything else:

   • Shelf exams
   • Clinical evaluations
   • Surgical rotations
   • Letters of recommendation

2. If time allows and there is a significant discrepancy, consider:

   • Taking CK early enough to allow retake before applications only if:
     • You have a clear, addressable cause (e.g., improper prep, illness).
     • There is a realistic chance of a substantial score increase.
   • However, in most residency timelines, retake opportunities are limited. Discuss with your dean and an advisor who knows vascular competitiveness.

3. Frame Step 2 CK as a learning experience.

   • In your narrative, emphasize how you adjusted your strategies afterward (for rotations, reading habits, question banks).

4. Use your strong Step 1 as an anchor.

   • PDs often see this as evidence that you can succeed in knowledge-heavy training; they may view the lower CK as an outlier if the rest of the file is strong.

Takeaway: You must convincingly show that the lower Step 2 CK is not representative of your real clinical performance or potential.

---

Scenario 4: DO with Low Step Scores (Step 1 and Step 2 CK)

Profile:

• Step 1: Just passed or numeric score clearly below competitive ranges
• Step 2 CK: Below ~230 or Level 2-CE below ~580
• Still strongly motivated for vascular surgery

This is where a true “low Step score match” strategy becomes essential.

Step Score Strategy:

1. Reality-check your specialty choice—but don’t give up blindly.

   Candidly ask:

   • Are you absolutely committed to vascular surgery (patient population, lifestyle, call)?
   • Could you be deeply fulfilled in a related or overlapping field (general surgery with vascular fellowship, interventional radiology, critical care, or a less competitive surgical specialty)?

   If the answer is yes, vascular is still your primary goal, proceed—but with maximum strategy and backup planning.

2. Double down on everything non-score:

   • Vascular exposure:

     • Multiple vascular electives
     • A high-impact vascular sub-internship where attendings know you well
     • Participation in vascular call, clinics, endovascular cases

   • Letters of recommendation:

     • Aim for 2–3 letters from vascular or vascular-friendly surgeons who can emphatically vouch for your clinical excellence, technical promise, and work ethic.
     • Strong narrative letters can offset weaker numbers.

   • Research and scholarship:

     • Case reports, quality improvement projects, retrospective studies with vascular faculty
     • Present at vascular or surgical society meetings (SVS, regional trauma/vascular societies)

   • Personal branding:

     • Emphasize resilience, hands-on skill, and patient-centered devotion.
     • Your story should show that you thrive in intense, high-acuity environments despite not being a test-taking superstar.

3. Apply extremely broadly.

   • Every integrated vascular program where your profile is even marginally plausible.
   • Prioritize:
     • DO-friendly programs
     • Newer or smaller integrated vascular programs
     • Programs with a track record of taking non-traditional paths (older grads, IMGs, DOs, career changers)

4. Strong backup plan: Categorical General Surgery

   • Apply simultaneously and robustly to general surgery residency:
     • Prefer programs with a known vascular presence, vascular fellowships, or high vascular case volume.
   • This pathway can lead to:
     • Vascular surgery fellowship after a solid general surgery residency.
   • Many vascular surgeons followed this path—even today.

5. Explore gap year options if you’re early enough.

   For students not yet in the match:

   • A dedicated research year with a vascular lab
   • Publications, posters, and full immersion in vascular culture
   • Potential to significantly strengthen your application beyond numbers

Takeaway: Low scores require aggressive non-score excellence, broad applications, and realistic backup planning, often via general surgery.

---

Step 2 CK Strategy for DO Graduates Targeting Vascular Surgery

If Step 2 CK is still ahead—or if you’re in the prep window—you have a crucial opportunity to shape your narrative. A well-planned Step 2 CK strategy can turn an average applicant into a strong one, and a concerning Step 1 into a redemption story.

1. Timing Step 2 CK for Maximum Impact

For vascular surgery:

• Aim to take Step 2 CK early enough that:
  • Scores are available before ERAS submission.
  • You have at least 6–8 dedicated weeks (if possible) for focused prep.
• Coordinate with:
  • Core clerkships (avoid taking it right after your most demanding rotation, like surgery, without recovery time).
  • COMLEX Level 2-CE schedule to avoid burnout.

If Step 1 performance was weaker:

• Consider taking Step 2 CK slightly later in clerkships:
  • So you can build clinical knowledge and test-taking stamina.
  • Use early rotations, especially IM and surgery, to cement UWorld-style reasoning.

2. Evidence-Based Study Approach

For a strong Step 2 CK in the context of vascular surgery ambitions:

1. Primary QBank (e.g., UWorld) – 2 passes if possible

   • Treat UWorld as a learning tool, not just an assessment.
   • Annotate high-yield concepts, especially:
     • Vascular pathologies (PAD, aneurysms, dissections, DVT/PE, vasculitis)
     • Critical care and perioperative medicine
     • Renal, cardiac, and endocrine comorbidities common in vascular patients

2. NBME and UWSA exams as checkpoints

   • Take baseline NBME early in dedicated to calibrate expectations.
   • Use serial practice exams to:
     • Identify weak systems
     • Decide when you’re close to your target range

3. Focused high-yield resources

   • Concise Step 2 CK review books or online systems-based outlines
   • Past shelf notes from medicine, surgery, and EM
   • Online question banks that emphasize complex cases

4. Test-taking skill honing

   • Practice pacing: you must be able to sustain focus for multiple long blocks.
   • Use “test-day simulations” at least twice: same wake time, same breaks, same number of blocks.

3. Special Considerations for DO Students (USMLE + COMLEX)

Balancing dual exams:

• Overlap content: Use your Step 2 CK prep as your primary base for both exams.
• Before COMLEX Level 2-CE:
  • Add a COMLEX-style QBank to adapt to question style and OMM content.
• Try to avoid spacing the exams too tightly:
  • A common pattern:
    • Take Step 2 CK first (higher stakes for many vascular programs).
    • Then quickly adapt to COMLEX style with a shorter, targeted review.

4. Mental Health and Burnout Prevention

A high Step 1 score residency target and competitive specialty like vascular can lead to enormous pressure. But burnout is counterproductive to high-level performance.

• Set realistic daily goals for questions and review, not perfection.
• Maintain sleep, nutrition, and exercise as non-negotiables.
• Use mentors or advisors to help recalibrate expectations if practice scores plateau.

Remember: For vascular surgery, you’re training for a marathon professional life, not just winning a single exam.

---

DO-Specific Strategies in the Osteopathic Residency Match for Vascular Surgery

Beyond exam numbers, DO graduates face unique structural challenges—but also unique strengths.

1. Target Programs with a DO-Friendly Track Record

When building your list of integrated vascular programs:

• Look for:
  • Prior DO residents or fellows
  • DO faculty or leadership
  • Explicit language in program descriptions about DO inclusivity

You can often find this by:

• Reviewing current resident rosters and alumni lists
• Talking to upper-class DO students or grads who matched in surgical specialties
• Consulting your school’s GME or career advising office

2. Maximize the Value of Audition Rotations (Sub-Is)

Sub-internships are particularly important for DO graduates:

• They allow you to show, not tell that you can function at the level of an MD peer from any institution.
• They can override concerns about school “prestige” or COMLEX-only pathways.

Your goals during a vascular or surgery sub-I:

• Be the hardest-working, most reliable person on the team.
• Master fundamentals:
  • Pre-op and post-op orders
  • Vascular exam skills
  • Ankle-brachial index interpretation
  • Basic imaging interpretation (CT angiography, duplex ultrasound basics)
• Seek frequent feedback and implement it rapidly.
• Make it easy for attendings to write glowing letters: show longitudinal growth over the month.

3. Communicate Your Osteopathic Identity as a Strength

In your personal statement and interviews:

• Frame osteopathic training as:
  • Patient-centered
  • Holistic
  • Strong in continuity of care—critical for chronic vascular patients

You might say:

“My osteopathic background has shaped how I approach the vascular patient as a whole individual, integrating chronic disease management, functional status, and quality of life into decisions about revascularization, limb salvage, and long-term follow-up.”

This distinguishes you positively and reframes your DO status as an asset, not a liability.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a DO graduate, do I absolutely need USMLE scores for vascular surgery?

Not absolutely—but they significantly improve your chances for many integrated vascular programs. Some programs accept COMLEX-only applicants, especially those familiar with DO training. However, USMLE Step 2 CK (and Step 1 if taken when numeric) remains the most common comparative metric. If you’re early in training and serious about vascular surgery, strongly consider taking at least Step 2 CK.

---

2. What Step 2 CK score should I aim for to be competitive in vascular surgery?

Aim as high as realistically possible. Many successful applicants to integrated vascular surgery have Step 2 CK scores in the 250+ range. As a DO, 240s can be very competitive when paired with strong rotations, letters, and research. If you’re below the 230s, you’ll likely need to lean heavily on non-score strengths and consider robust backup plans in general surgery.

---

3. Can I match into vascular surgery with a low Step score?

Yes, but it is more challenging and requires an intentional low Step score match strategy:

• Strong vascular or surgical sub-internships
• Excellent letters of recommendation
• Demonstrated commitment to vascular surgery (research, electives, conference presentations)
• Broad application list, including DO-friendly and smaller programs
• A serious backup plan, usually categorical general surgery with an eye toward future vascular fellowship

Multiple applicants each year match with scores below traditional “cutoffs” because programs see them as outstanding clinicians and future surgeons.

---

4. If I don’t match into an integrated vascular program, is my vascular surgery dream over?

Not at all. The traditional pathway remains:

1. Match into a solid general surgery residency (5 years).
2. Build a vascular-focused CV:
   • Vascular rotations
   • Research with vascular faculty
   • Presentations and publications
3. Apply for a vascular surgery fellowship (2 years).

Many leaders in vascular surgery came through this route. If your Step scores limit your integrated prospects, this path can be an excellent and realistic long-term strategy.

---

By understanding how programs interpret your Step 1 score residency profile, optimizing your Step 2 CK strategy, and leveraging your strengths as a DO graduate in a competitive field, you can build a smart, resilient path toward a career in vascular surgery—whether through an integrated vascular program or the general surgery–to–fellowship route.