Low Step Score Strategies for DO Graduates Pursuing Surgery Residency

Understanding Your Starting Point as a DO Graduate with Low Scores

Applying for a prelim surgery residency as a DO graduate with a low Step 1 score or below average board scores can feel daunting, but it is far from impossible. Many applicants with similar profiles match into a preliminary surgery year, use it as a launchpad, and ultimately find successful, fulfilling careers in surgery or other specialties.

Before you can build an effective strategy, you need a clear understanding of:

• How your exam performance compares to typical surgery applicants
• How PDs (program directors) interpret low scores
• The specific dynamics of the osteopathic residency match for preliminary positions
• The unique role of a prelim surgery residency in your long‑term plan

What “Low Step Score” Means in Your Context

“Low” is relative and depends on your goals. For categorical general surgery, scores tend to skew higher; for preliminary surgery, there is more variability. In broad terms:

• Step 1 (for cohorts with numeric scores): Below ~215–220 is often considered “low” for surgical fields.
• Step 2 CK: Below ~230–235 may be “below average” for surgery applicants, though many programs have more flexible thresholds for prelim slots.
• COMLEX‑USA: Below average Level 1/2 scores (e.g., <480–500) can raise concerns, but many programs are familiar with DO scoring and focus on clinical performance and trends.

What matters most:

• Trend: Improvement from Step 1 → Step 2 or Level 1 → Level 2 can partly offset earlier weaknesses.
• Context: Any documented reasons (illness, family crisis, test anxiety) presented professionally in your application.
• Consistency: Strong clerkship grades, good shelf scores, and strong letters can counterbalance weaker board performance.

The Good News About Preliminary Surgery Programs

Prelim surgery positions typically have:

• More flexibility in score cutoffs than categorical surgery spots
• A mix of applicants: reapplicants, those exploring surgery, IMGs, and DO graduates
• A focus on clinical work ethic, reliability, and team fit over pure test metrics

This means that matching with low scores is realistic if you present a compelling, strategically constructed application and apply broadly.

---

Strategic Mindset: Clarifying Your Goals for a Prelim Surgery Year

Before crafting your application strategy, you must be crystal clear about why you’re pursuing a preliminary surgery year.

Common Goals for a Preliminary Surgery Year

1. Bridge to Categorical General Surgery

   • Aim: Convert to a categorical slot at the same institution or elsewhere after a strong prelim performance.
   • Focus: Show you are already functioning like a categorical intern in terms of work ethic, reliability, and technical growth.

2. Pathway to Another Surgical Specialty

   • Examples: Orthopedic surgery, urology, ENT, plastics, neurosurgery.
   • Reality: Very competitive; a prelim surgery year mainly shows surgical exposure and resilience, but you must pair it with strong networking and research.

3. Exploratory Year to Clarify Interest in Surgery

   • Use case: Unsure between medicine vs surgery, but want to test yourself in a surgical environment.
   • Risk: Demanding year; you must still treat it like a high-stakes audition.

4. Strengthening Application for Non‑Surgical Fields

   • Some applicants do a prelim surgery year, then pivot to anesthesiology, EM, radiology, IM, etc.
   • Advantage: You gain strong letters and a reputation for work ethic, which can impress across specialties.

Your personal goal shapes how you frame your narrative, whom you approach for letters, how you choose programs, and what you prioritize during the year.

How Being a DO Graduate Changes the Calculus

As a DO applicant in surgery:

• Some programs are extremely DO-friendly; others rarely take DOs.
• Your COMLEX scores must be presented clearly; if you also have USMLE scores, emphasize any relative strengths.
• Osteopathic training often emphasizes hands‑on patient care—use this to your advantage, highlighting early clinical responsibility and bedside skills.

Your strategy should prioritize DO-friendly prelim surgery programs and those with a track record of training osteopathic graduates in categorical slots, even if that’s not where you start.

---

Building a Competitive Application with Low Scores

Even with low Step or COMLEX scores, you can build a compelling file by emphasizing other strengths and strategically addressing your weaknesses.

1. Make Step 2 / COMLEX Level 2 Your Redemption Exam

If you haven’t taken Step 2 CK or Level 2 yet, this is your single most powerful academic lever.

• Aim for clear improvement relative to Step 1/Level 1.
  • Example: Step 1 = 208, Step 2 = 232 tells PDs you can adapt and grow.
• Prioritize high‑yield surgical and internal medicine content—these are heavily tested and directly relevant.
• Consider a structured study schedule with:
  • A question bank (e.g., UWorld) completed at least once
  • Timed, random blocks to simulate exam conditions
  • Daily review of incorrects with focused remediation

Apply after you have a solid Step 2/Level 2 score, if timing allows. A strong improvement can pull your application out of auto-screen rejections.

2. Maximize Surgical Rotations and Sub‑Internships

With below average board scores, your clinical performance becomes your primary currency.

Key strategies:

• Choose DO‑friendly academic or large community programs for sub‑Is (sub‑internships).
• Treat each rotation like a month‑long interview:
  • Be early, prepared, and visible
  • Know your patients cold (labs, imaging, plans)
  • Volunteer for cases, floor work, and consults
• Ask for formative feedback early:
  • “Dr. Smith, I’m very interested in surgery and want to perform at the level of your strongest students. Are there 1–2 specific things I can do better this week?”
• Request letters from surgeons who have seen you:
  • Take call
  • Operate repeatedly
  • Manage complex patients
• Make sure they can comment explicitly on:
  • Your work ethic
  • Your response to feedback
  • Your team skills and humility
  • Your technical trajectory (even as a student)

These letters can easily outweigh concerns about low Step scores.

3. Construct a Coherent Personal Narrative

Program directors want an intern who:

• Shows up
• Does the work
• Learns quickly
• Does not cause problems

Your personal statement and interview answers must:

• Acknowledge low scores briefly and maturely, if needed:
  • “My Step 1 performance does not reflect my true capabilities. Since then, I have significantly improved my study strategies, as evidenced by my Step 2 score and strong clinical evaluations.”
• Highlight your clinical strengths:
  • Hands-on patient management
  • Procedural interest
  • Ability to work under pressure and long hours
• Clarify your goal for the prelim year:
  • If aiming for categorical surgery: be honest but not entitled
  • If open to other paths: show you understand the realities and still respect surgery deeply

Avoid blaming others, making excuses, or over‑explaining test performance. Acknowledge, reframe, and pivot to strengths.

4. Optimize ERAS and Letters for a DO Prelim Surgery Applicant

ERAS application essentials:

• List both USMLE and COMLEX scores (if you have them) clearly.
• Use the “Most Meaningful Experiences” to highlight:
  • Surgical rotations
  • Longitudinal clinical work
  • Quality improvement, leadership, or research (if present)
• Emphasize resilience and team orientation over vague “passion for surgery.”

Letters of Recommendation (LOR):

• Aim for at least 2 letters from surgeons, ideally:
  • From your sub‑Is or home general surgery service
  • From DO‑friendly or academic sites where you performed well
• A third letter can be:
  • From a medicine attending who saw you manage complex inpatients
  • From a program director or clerkship director who knows your overall performance

What makes a letter powerful for someone matching with low scores:

• Explicit contrast: “While not the strongest test taker, Dr. X is one of the best clinically performing students I have supervised.”
• Concrete examples: describing specific cases, long hours, or difficult situations you handled.

5. Use the MSPE / Dean’s Letter Strategically

Your school’s MSPE can sometimes provide:

• Context about your academic struggles
• Evidence of consistent improvement
• Comments from multiple rotations reinforcing your clinical strengths

If you had significant life events impacting performance, work with your dean’s office to ensure it is fairly and professionally described.

---

Targeting Programs Wisely as a DO with Below Average Scores

Where you apply matters as much as how you present yourself. For DO graduates seeking a prelim surgery residency, strategy is critical.

1. Prioritize DO‑Friendly Programs and Systems

Look for programs that:

• Have current or recent DO residents in categorical or prelim surgery roles
• Are affiliated with osteopathic‑friendly hospitals or former AOA programs
• Are located in regions with historically higher DO representation (e.g., Midwest, parts of the South)

How to identify them:

• Program websites (check resident lists)
• FREIDA and residency explorer tools
• Networking through alumni from your DO school
• Reaching out politely to current or former DO residents via email or LinkedIn

2. Cast a Very Wide Net for Prelim Surgery

With low Step scores, you cannot afford a narrow strategy.

• Apply to a large number of prelim surgery programs (often 60+ is reasonable, depending on finances).
• Include:
  • University‑affiliated community programs
  • Large community hospitals with active surgical services
  • Safety programs in less competitive geographic regions

Do not limit yourself to “name‑brand” institutions; excellent training and conversion opportunities often exist at mid‑tier or strong community programs.

3. Include Non‑Surgical Backup Plans

If your primary goal is surgical exposure, but you need to ensure a match, consider:

• Ranking some prelim medicine or transitional year programs as backup.
• Identifying non‑surgical specialties that are more DO-friendly and less board‑score‑driven (e.g., family medicine, some IM programs, PM&R, certain community EM programs).

This is especially important if your Step 1 and Step 2 scores are both low and there is no upward academic trend.

4. Use Geographic and Personal Ties

Programs are more willing to take a chance on a borderline applicant if:

• You have strong ties to the area (grew up there, family there, spouse’s job, prior rotation).
• You can articulate why you plan to stay long‑term in that region.

Mention this consistently:

• In your ERAS geographic preferences
• In your personal statement (tailored versions if you can)
• In emails and interviews

---

Excelling in Interviews and During the Prelim Surgery Year

Securing interviews is half the battle; nailing them and then maximizing your prelim year is what truly shifts your trajectory.

1. Owning Your Story in Interviews

Expect to be asked:

• “Can you tell us about your exam performance?”
• “Why are you specifically applying to a prelim surgery residency?”
• “What are your long‑term goals: categorical surgery or something else?”

How to respond effectively:

1. Be honest but concise about low scores.

   • “I struggled with standardized exams early on, partly due to inefficient study strategies. After Step 1, I worked closely with our academic support team, adjusted my approach, and improved significantly by the time I took Step 2.”

2. Redirect attention to your strengths.

   • “My clinical rotations, particularly on general surgery and ICU, showed me I can thrive in demanding, high‑acuity settings. My attendings noted my reliability and ability to function at an intern level.”

3. Express respect for the prelim role.

   • “I understand that a preliminary surgery spot is not a guaranteed pathway to a categorical position. My goal is to contribute fully as an intern, earn strong evaluations, and then reassess my options with my mentors’ guidance.”

Avoid:

• Oversharing personal drama unless it directly impacted your scores and is relevant, brief, and well‑framed.
• Complaining about unfair exams, faculty, or school policy.
• Sounding like you view a prelim year as “just a stepping stone” without recognition of its responsibilities.

2. Demonstrating DO Strengths: Bedside Skills & Teamwork

As a DO graduate, lean into your strengths:

• Emphasize whole‑patient care, communication, and empathy.
• Give examples:
  • “On my surgical rotation, I often took extra time to explain post‑op expectations to patients and families, which improved adherence and reduced anxiety.”
• Highlight your ability to manage pain, functional status, and rehab—areas that matter greatly in surgical care.

PDs often value a prelim intern who:

• Is easy to work with
• Communicates clearly
• Treats patients and staff with respect
• Needs minimal hand‑holding after initial orientation

3. Once You Match: Turning Your Prelim Year into a Springboard

The prelim year is your live audition. Even with low Step scores, a stellar year can open doors.

Key principles:

1. Show up early, every day.

   • Pre-round ahead of your senior
   • Have vitals, labs, and overnight events on your list

2. Become “the reliable intern.”

   • Return pages quickly
   • Close loops (labs ordered, consults called, family updated)
   • Document thoroughly and accurately

3. Seek high‑yield operative experiences.

   • Ask to scrub whenever possible
   • Learn basic skills: knot tying, suturing, chest tubes, central lines (as permitted)
   • Read about upcoming cases the night before

4. Ask for feedback and mentorship.

   • Identify a few attendings or seniors who believe in you
   • Meet periodically to discuss performance and future planning
   • Let them know your aspirations (categorical surgery, other fields, etc.)

5. Build a reputation across services.

   • ICU, trauma, vascular, night float—wherever you are, be consistent
   • Staff talk; a good word from the ICU attending can influence the entire department’s perception of you.

4. Preparing for the Next Application Cycle (If Needed)

If your goal is to transition into a categorical position:

• Start early—by mid‑PGY‑1, talk to your PD honestly:
  • “I would like to be considered for any categorical positions here or elsewhere. What would I need to demonstrate this year to be competitive?”
• Request updated letters from faculty who see you as an intern.
• If your program has internal conversion opportunities, be explicit that you are interested, but remain humble and realistic.

If you pivot to another specialty:

• Use your prelim year to:
  • Gather strong letters emphasizing work ethic and clinical skill
  • Develop a focused research or quality improvement project if time allows
  • Network with departments you might join (e.g., anesthesiology, IM, EM)

---

Putting It All Together: A Step‑by‑Step Action Plan

For a DO graduate with low Step scores targeting a prelim surgery residency, here is a consolidated roadmap:

1. Academic Optimization

   • Retake or complete Step 2 CK / Level 2 with focused preparation
   • Aim to show clear improvement versus Step 1 / Level 1
   • If exams are done, shift effort to strengthening clinical and supporting elements

2. Clinical Excellence

   • Prioritize surgery sub‑Is at DO‑friendly or mid‑tier academic/community programs
   • Treat every rotation as an interview; seek feedback and act on it
   • Secure 2+ strong, specific surgery letters

3. Application Strategy

   • Build a concise, honest personal statement acknowledging low scores only as needed
   • Emphasize clinical performance, resilience, and team orientation
   • Apply broadly to prelim surgery programs, with geographic flexibility
   • Include a realistic backup plan (prelim medicine or less competitive specialties) if risk is high

4. Targeted Program Selection

   • Identify DO‑friendly programs via alumni, resident lists, and networking
   • Highlight geographic ties wherever you have them
   • Be open to community and less “name‑brand” institutions with robust surgical volume

5. Interview Execution

   • Prepare 2–3 polished answers explaining exam performance, your interest in surgery, and your goals
   • Showcase DO strengths: bedside skills, holistic care, communication
   • Demonstrate humility, work ethic, and respect for the prelim role

6. Prelim Year Performance

   • Over‑deliver on reliability, work ethic, and patient care
   • Build relationships with attendings, seniors, and program leadership
   • Seek mentorship and clarity on categorical or alternative pathways
   • Collect updated letters and plan early for the next match cycle, if needed

With persistence, strategic planning, and consistent performance, matching with low scores into a preliminary surgery year is achievable, and that year can become a powerful platform for your long‑term career.

---

FAQ: Low Step Score Strategies for DO Graduates in Preliminary Surgery

1. As a DO with a low Step 1 score, should I still take USMLE Step 2 CK if I already have COMLEX Level 2?
If you are targeting surgery or a prelim surgery residency, Step 2 CK can help. Many surgical programs are more comfortable with USMLE metrics, and a strong Step 2 CK score that improves on your Step 1 performance can partially offset earlier concerns. However, if your practice scores are significantly below passing, discuss the risk–benefit with an advisor before committing.

2. Can a prelim surgery year realistically lead to a categorical general surgery spot for someone with below average board scores?
Yes—but not guaranteed. Conversion is most likely if:

• You perform exceptionally well clinically
• Your program has a history of taking prelims into categorical positions
• You build strong relationships and receive robust advocacy from faculty
  Even if you don’t convert at your home institution, a glowing intern‑year performance can strengthen your application to other programs.

3. How many prelim surgery programs should I apply to with low scores as a DO graduate?
There is no universal number, but many applicants in your situation apply to 50–80+ prelim surgery programs, depending on budget and geographic flexibility. The lower your scores, the more you should broaden your list—especially to DO‑friendly and community‑based programs—and consider adding some non‑surgical backups.

4. Will my low scores follow me forever, even if I do well in a prelim year?
Your scores will always be part of your record, but their significance decreases over time if you demonstrate:

• Strong performance in a demanding prelim surgery year
• Excellent letters from surgical attendings
• Professionalism, reliability, and clinical competence
  For many PDs, how you function as an intern carries more weight than how you performed on a test years earlier—especially if you have clearly grown and delivered when it mattered most.