Essential Strategies for Non-US Citizen IMG with Low Step Scores in Surgery

Understanding the Realities: Low Scores, Preliminary Surgery, and Visa Status

For a non-US citizen IMG, a low Step score can feel like a door slamming shut. When you add the complexity of visa sponsorship and interest in a preliminary surgery residency, it can seem even more discouraging. But a low score does not automatically end your path to the operating room.

This article focuses on strategies specifically for foreign national medical graduates aiming for a preliminary surgery year in the United States while dealing with:

• A low Step 1 score or below average board scores
• Non-US citizenship (requiring visa sponsorship)
• Limited or no US clinical experience
• Interest in surgery but unsure about categorical vs preliminary pathways

We’ll walk through realistic, evidence-informed, and actionable steps you can take to:

• Offset low scores with strengths in other parts of your application
• Identify prelim programs more likely to consider non-US citizen IMG candidates
• Improve your match odds even if you are matching with low scores
• Use a preliminary surgery year as a platform for your longer-term career goals

Before diving into strategy, align your expectations:

• Prelim surgery is more attainable than categorical surgery for an IMG with low scores, but it is still competitive.
• Visa needs (especially H-1B) can significantly limit options; flexibility on visa type (e.g., J-1) generally improves chances.
• Many prelim spots go unfilled each year and are later offered in SOAP—this can be an opportunity for you.

The goal is not to pretend scores don’t matter; they do. The goal is to make your entire profile stronger than your numbers suggest.

---

Step Scores in Context: How Bad Is “Low” and What Does It Mean for You?

What is a “low” Step score for surgery?

While exact cutoffs vary, in the context of surgery:

• Step 1 (if numeric):
  • Competitive surgery programs often prefer >235–240
  • A low Step 1 score is generally <220, and <210 is a significant concern
• Step 2 CK:
  • Strong surgical applicants often score >245
  • Below ~230 is usually considered below average board scores for surgery-track applicants

For non-US citizen IMGs, expectations can be even higher at competitive academic centers. However, preliminary surgery year positions frequently have more lenient thresholds than categorical positions—especially in community programs.

How programs actually use scores

Programs use scores to:

1. Screen: Automatic filters (e.g., Step 2 CK ≥ 220, attempts = 1)
2. Estimate risk of failing boards in residency
3. Compare at scale when they have thousands of applications

This means:

• If you pass Step exams on the first attempt, even with low scores, you are far better off than with multiple failures.
• A strong Step 2 CK improvement compared to a low Step 1 is powerful evidence of growth and resilience.

Actionable score-based strategies

1. Maximize Step 2 CK

   • If Step 1 is low, Step 2 CK becomes your redemption exam.
   • Aim for at least 15–20 points higher than Step 1 to show a strong upward trajectory.
   • Delay ERAS submission slightly rather than applying with a poor Step 2 CK.

2. Address failures and very low scores directly

   • Use the ERAS “Additional Information” section to briefly explain major disruptions (health, family crisis, war, etc.) that affected performance—focus on insight and improvement, not excuses.
   • Highlight recent academic successes (Step 3, in-training exams, recent coursework) to show your current ability.

3. Consider taking Step 3 early (if eligible)

   • A passed Step 3 can reassure programs that you are lower risk and increase chances for visa sponsorship (especially H-1B).
   • This strategy is particularly valuable for a non-US citizen IMG who needs to stand out beyond scores.

---

Targeting the Right Programs: Where a Non-US Citizen IMG with Low Scores Has a Chance

The single most underappreciated factor for matching with low scores is program selection. As a foreign national medical graduate chasing a prelim surgery residency, your list must be extremely strategic.

1. Understand prelim vs categorical dynamics

• Categorical general surgery:

  • Direct path to completing residency and boards.
  • Significantly more competitive.
  • Many academic programs rarely rank non-US citizen IMGs with low scores.

• Preliminary surgery year:

  • Typically 1 year of mostly surgical rotations.
  • Can lead to:
    • Transition into a categorical spot (if available)
    • Entry into surgical subspecialties with different tracks (e.g., anesthesia, radiology, PM&R)
    • Strengthening your CV for re-application or different specialties (EM, internal medicine, etc.)
  • Often used to fill service needs; some programs are more open to IMGs, including those with lower scores.

You are applying in a niche where service needs and reliability matter as much as exam scores.

2. Prioritize community and mid-tier university programs

For a non-US citizen IMG with a low Step 1 score:

• Focus heavily on:

  • Community-based programs
  • Smaller university-affiliated programs
  • Hospitals known to be IMG-friendly, especially in internal medicine or other specialties (suggests openness to IMGs overall).

• De-emphasize (unless you have a strong internal connection):

  • Top-tier academic programs
  • Elite research-heavy departments
  • Programs explicitly stating they do not sponsor visas

3. Research visa policies meticulously

As a foreign national medical graduate, visa support can be more limiting than scores. Strategies:

• Use program websites and FREIDA to check:

  • J-1 only (most common; more open to IMGs)
  • H-1B possible (usually requires Step 3 and clean attempts)
  • No visa sponsorship – remove from your list.

• If you are flexible to accept J-1, your pool of possible programs greatly increases.

• If you must have H-1B, budget additional time and money for Step 3 and accept that your target list will be much smaller.

4. Leverage data and match outcomes

Use tools and approaches such as:

• FREIDA search + filters:

  • Surgery programs with preliminary positions
  • IMG percentage >10–20% across any specialty in that institution

• Program websites:

  • List of current residents: look for IMGs, especially non-US citizens
  • Explicit statements like “We accept ECFMG-certified applicants and sponsor J-1 visas”

• Practical example
  Suppose your Step scores are:

  • Step 1: 213 (first attempt)
  • Step 2 CK: 230 (first attempt)

  As a non-US citizen IMG needing J-1:

  • You would prioritize:
    • Community-based prelim surgery positions in the Midwest, South, and less urban coastal areas
    • Hospitals that have IMGs in internal medicine and family medicine
    • Programs that did not fill all prelim positions in recent years (often noted in SOAP reports / historical NRMP data).

5. Build a “tiered” program list

Structure your list roughly as:

• Tier 1 (reach but realistic)
  • Community or hybrid programs with moderate score filters, history of IMGs, J-1 sponsorship
• Tier 2 (core)
  • Majority of your applications
  • Mid-to-small hospitals, strong IMG presence, explicit prelim positions, sometimes less desirable geographic locations
• Tier 3 (safety, often SOAP-sensitive)
  • Hospitals that frequently offer unfilled prelim spots in SOAP
  • Programs with heavy service needs, more flexible on scores

Aim for broad application numbers: as a non-US citizen IMG with below average board scores, 80–120 applications for surgery prelim alone is not excessive, especially if prelim is your primary target.

---

Strengthening the Rest of Your Application: Turning Weak Scores into a Managed Risk

If numbers are your weakness, everything else must become a strength. Programs want safe, hardworking, reliable residents who can operate in a team—even if their Step score is not impressive.

1. US clinical experience (USCE) with a surgical flavor

For surgery, hands-on USCE is extremely valuable:

• Ideal experiences:
  • Sub-internships (Sub-I) or acting internships in surgery
  • Inpatient general surgery electives
  • Surgical ICU rotations
• If you cannot get surgery-specific USCE:
  • ICU, trauma, emergency medicine, or internal medicine admissions services also help demonstrate comfort with acute care.

If you already graduated and can’t do formal electives:

• Seek observerships or externships in surgical departments.
• Even short (4–8 week) experiences where you:
  • Attend rounds consistently
  • Present patients
  • Show reliability and work ethic
  • Build relationships for letters of recommendation

2. Letters of recommendation (LORs) that offset low scores

Strong, specific letters can partially neutralize concerns about metrics.

Aim for:

• At least 2 letters from US surgeons (if possible) who:

  • Have seen you manage real patients (or closely observed you in clinical settings)
  • Can comment on:
    • Work ethic
    • Clinical judgment
    • Teamwork and communication
    • Teachability and resilience

• 1 additional letter:

  • Another US faculty (even from a different specialty)
  • Or a senior faculty from your home institution (especially surgical)

Ask letter writers explicitly:

“Would you feel comfortable writing me a strong letter of recommendation for preliminary surgery?”

If they hesitate, it is better not to use that letter.

3. Personal statement: owning your narrative

For a non-US citizen IMG with low Step scores, a generic personal statement is a wasted opportunity. Use it to:

• Acknowledge your scores indirectly through a growth story:
  • Discuss an early struggle with standardized tests and how you addressed it
  • Emphasize your improvement (Step 2 CK, Step 3, clinical performance)
• Explain why prelim surgery is the right path:
  • Genuine interest in surgery
  • Willingness to work hard in a demanding environment
  • Clarity about your long-term vision (categorical surgery, a related field, or a bridge to another specialty)

Stay factual, humble, and optimistic—never defensive or blaming.

4. CV optimization: highlight every signal of reliability

Emphasize activities that reassure surgeons that you will show up, work hard, and support the team:

• Extended clinical experiences with consistent attendance
• Leadership roles (class rep, chief intern at home hospital, etc.)
• Teaching or tutoring roles (especially exam-related, which show mastery despite low early scores)
• Quality improvement projects or audits in surgical settings
• Any research, even small projects or case reports, related to:
  • General surgery
  • Trauma
  • Critical care

Order your CV so that the most relevant and impressive items appear early.

---

Application & Interview Tactics: Maximizing Your Visibility Despite Low Scores

1. Apply early and completely

For a prelim surgery residency, timing still matters:

• Submit ERAS as early as possible once your Step 2 CK is in a respectable range, even if not perfect.
• Ensure:
  • ECFMG certification status is clear or in progress
  • All LORs are uploaded and assigned
  • Personal statement tailored to surgery (and a second version tailored to prelim-track if needed)

Late or incomplete applications are an easy rejection, especially for a non-US citizen IMG.

2. Strategic communication with programs

Polite, targeted communication can help you stand out:

• Email the program coordinator or program director:
  • Brief introduction (name, school, non-US citizen IMG, visa needs)
  • One or two lines highlighting your strengths despite low scores (strong Step 2 CK or Step 3, solid surgery USCE, strong LORs)
  • Clear indication of genuine interest in preliminary surgery year at their program and willingness to work hard

Example (adapt for your facts):

Dear Dr. [PD Last Name],

My name is [Name], a non-US citizen IMG from [Country], applying to your preliminary surgery program. While my Step 1 score is below average, I significantly improved on Step 2 CK and recently passed Step 3. During my recent general surgery observership at [Hospital], I received strong feedback on my work ethic and team contribution.

I am particularly drawn to your program’s strong operative exposure and supportive environment for prelim residents. I would be very grateful for consideration of my application.

Sincerely,
[Name, AAMC ID]

Do not spam programs; focus on those where you have specific reasons to be interested.

3. Interview performance: the “low scores” conversation

You should expect some version of:

“I see your Step scores are a bit lower than average for surgery. Can you tell me about that?”

Answer with:

1. Ownership – No blaming, no excuses
2. Reflection – What you learned
3. Evidence of improvement – Concrete changes
4. Reassurance – Current readiness

Example:

In my early medical years, I underestimated how different US-style standardized tests are from my home exams. I didn’t structure my preparation well for Step 1, and my score reflects that. Since then, I changed my approach significantly: I used NBME practice tests, scheduled focused review blocks, and sought mentorship from prior test-takers. As a result, my Step 2 CK score improved by 17 points, and I passed Step 3 on my first attempt.

More importantly, in clinical rotations—especially in surgery and critical care—I’ve consistently performed at a high level. I’m confident that my current habits and clinical foundation will allow me to handle the demands of your training program.

4. Present yourself as a “safe investment” for a prelim spot

Program directors for prelim surgery worry less about board pass rates and more about:

• Will this resident:
  • Show up reliably for call and cases?
  • Work well within a demanding team?
  • Adapt quickly to the hospital system and documentation?
  • Avoid major professionalism problems?

Highlight:

• Experiences with long hours and shift work (internship, night float, ICU rotations)
• Examples of teamwork under pressure (trauma codes, OR emergencies, high-volume wards)
• Situations where you handled feedback and steep learning curves constructively

---

Using a Preliminary Surgery Year Wisely: Planning Beyond the Match

Securing a preliminary surgery year with low Step scores is not the endpoint; it is a bridge. As a non-US citizen IMG, your strategy must include what comes after the prelim year.

1. Paths after a prelim surgery year

Common trajectories include:

1. Transition to categorical general surgery

   • Rare but possible, especially if:
     • The same program has an unfilled categorical spot
     • You become a top-performing prelim resident
     • Faculty advocate strongly on your behalf

2. Match into another surgical field

   • Anesthesiology, radiology, PM&R, or other fields may value:
     • Surgical exposure
     • Teamwork in acute settings
     • Strong evaluations from surgeons

3. Switch to a different specialty

   • Internal medicine, EM (in some cases), or other specialties
   • Your prelim year proves your readiness for US training even if your final field changes.

2. Maximizing your prelim year impact

If you get a prelim spot despite low scores, treat the year as a 12-month audition:

• Be the most reliable resident on the team:

  • Arrive early, leave late when needed
  • Volunteer for difficult tasks and extra cases

• Seek meaningful feedback and act on it:

  • Ask senior residents and attendings for specific ways to improve
  • Implement their feedback and let your growth be visible

• Document your performance:

  • Request mid-year and end-of-year letters that explicitly:
    • Compare you favorably to categorical residents
    • Mention work ethic, surgical skills, and professionalism

These letters can be game-changers when you later apply for categorical positions or other specialties.

3. Parallel planning and mental health

Balancing the realities:

• Odds of converting a prelim surgery position into a categorical surgery seat are not high, especially for a non-US citizen IMG with low initial scores.
• You should:
  • Be honest with yourself about backup plans (e.g., other specialties)
  • Maintain mental resilience—surgical prelim years are physically and emotionally demanding
  • Build a support network: co-residents, mentors, and peers from your home country

Approach your prelim year with two simultaneous goals:

1. Excel where you are
2. Continuously position yourself for the next step, whatever shape it takes.

---

FAQs: Low Step Score Strategies for Non-US Citizen IMG in Preliminary Surgery

1. As a non-US citizen IMG with a low Step 1 score, is it realistic to aim for preliminary surgery?

Yes, it can be realistic, especially if:

• Your Step 2 CK is stronger or shows improvement
• You have no exam failures and are ECFMG certified
• You target community and mid-tier academic programs that sponsor visas (especially J-1)
• You strengthen the rest of your application with strong USCE and LORs

It is less realistic to expect a direct categorical position in surgery at top academic centers, but a preliminary surgery year is an attainable goal with a smart strategy.

2. Should I apply to both categorical and prelim surgery positions if I have below average board scores?

Often, yes:

• Apply to a limited number of categorical programs where you have a realistic shot (IMG-friendly, moderate score thresholds, known to sponsor visas).
• Apply more broadly to prelim surgery residency spots, where score filters may be less strict.
• If surgery is your true passion, you can use a prelim spot as a way to show your capabilities and plan your next move.

3. How many programs should I apply to as a foreign national medical graduate with low scores?

There is no perfect number, but as a non-US citizen IMG with low Step scores, consider:

• 80–120+ applications to surgery (combined categorial + prelim), with the majority being prelim and community-based programs.
• If budget allows, a broader list improves your odds, since many programs use rigid score filters and some will not review your application regardless of other strengths.

4. Can a strong Step 2 CK or Step 3 compensate for a very low Step 1 score?

It can certainly mitigate the impact, especially if:

• You improved by a substantial margin (e.g., 15–20+ points)
• You passed all exams on the first attempt
• You have strong LORs and clinical evaluations that confirm your current competence

For some programs, a stellar Step 2 CK or completed Step 3 may convince them to overlook a low Step 1, particularly for preliminary surgery year positions where board-pass risk is less central than service needs.

---

By approaching the process strategically—optimizing exams you can still influence, selecting the right programs, strengthening your application narrative, and using a prelim year as a launchpad—you can remain a competitive candidate for prelim surgery even as a non-US citizen IMG with low Step scores.