Step Score Strategy for DO Graduates Pursuing General Surgery Residency

Understanding the Step Score Landscape for DOs Targeting General Surgery

General surgery is one of the more competitive specialties, and as a DO graduate you face an additional layer of scrutiny—especially around board scores. The good news: a strategic approach to your Step 1 and Step 2 CK performance, combined with osteopathic strengths, can create a compelling application even without “perfect” numbers.

In the current residency environment, program directors increasingly use Step scores as:

• An initial screening tool (especially Step 2 CK)
• A surrogate marker of test-taking ability and knowledge base
• A way to compare applicants from different schools, including DO vs MD

For a DO graduate aiming for the surgery residency match, you need a tailored Step score strategy that:

1. Maximizes your performance on Step 2 CK (and COMLEX Level 2-CE).
2. Mitigates any weaknesses (Step 1 pass, low score, or no USMLE).
3. Highlights your unique strengths as an osteopathic applicant.
4. Aligns your exam timing with audition rotations and ERAS.

This guide will walk you through how to think about Step scores as a DO graduate in general surgery, including tactics for:

• Target score ranges
• Step 2 CK and COMLEX Level 2-CE planning
• What to do if you already have a low Step score
• Integration with away rotations, letters, research, and the osteopathic residency match (via ACGME programs open to DOs).

---

Section 1: What General Surgery Programs Expect from DO Applicants

How Programs Use Step Scores in General Surgery

Even with Step 1 now pass/fail, scores still carry weight through:

• Step 2 CK (numeric, now heavily emphasized)
• COMLEX Level 2-CE (for osteopathic students)
• Historical data on your Step 1 if you took it before it went pass/fail

Program directors in general surgery often:

• Use score cutoffs to narrow large applicant pools.
• Look more closely at DO applications to ensure:
  • Demonstrated objective performance (USMLE preferred by many, though not all programs).
  • Ability to handle the cognitive load of a busy residency.

Typical Score Expectations (Approximate)

These are broad, approximate ranges based on recent match data and PD survey trends; individual programs vary:

• Highly competitive academic general surgery programs

  • Step 2 CK: Often > 250 expected for serious consideration.
  • DO applicants are more competitive if they have research/strong letters on top of that.

• Mid-range university or strong community programs

  • Step 2 CK: Many successful applicants land in 240–250+ range.
  • DO applicants with strong clinical performance and solid letters can be very competitive here.

• Community or smaller academic-affiliated programs

  • Step 2 CK: Competitive applicants often in the 230–240+ range.
  • Strong DO applicants with good fit, strong rotations, and solid interview performance can match here even with scores in the low–mid 230s, sometimes lower if everything else is excellent.

Remember: these are not hard rules. A slightly lower score with an outstanding application can beat a higher score with a weak narrative. But they give you a target to aim for and help you understand where your Step 2 CK strategy needs to land.

The Additional Hurdle for DO Graduates

As a DO graduate:

• Some programs still prefer or require USMLE scores, especially in general surgery.
• Others are fully comfortable with COMLEX-only applicants.
• However, in a competitive field like general surgery, having USMLE Step 2 CK on file unlocks more programs and reduces the risk of auto-screen rejection.

Action point:
If you haven’t yet graduated and are still planning your exam path, seriously consider taking USMLE Step 2 CK in addition to COMLEX Level 2-CE, especially if your goal is a university-affiliated general surgery program.

---

Section 2: Crafting a Step 2 CK Strategy as a DO Targeting General Surgery

Why Step 2 CK Is Now Your Critical Exam

With Step 1 pass/fail, Step 2 CK has become the most important standardized metric for:

• General surgery program directors
• Screening committees
• Selection for interviews

For DO graduates, Step 2 CK serves two major purposes:

1. Comparability: It puts you on the same scoring scale as MD applicants.
2. Redemption or confirmation: It can compensate for a low Step score earlier in training (e.g., a low Step 1 or lower COMLEX Level 1).

A strong Step 2 CK:

• Signals that you’re ready for the knowledge demands of a general surgery residency.
• Can significantly elevate your competitiveness, even if other parts of your record are average.

Defining Your Target Score Ranges

Use these Step 2 CK strategy tiers as a general guide:

• Aspirational excellence (250+)

  • Highly competitive for many academic general surgery programs.
  • Particularly impactful for DO candidates—helps overcome DO bias at some institutions.

• Strong competitiveness (240–249)

  • Solid for many mid-tier university and strong community programs.
  • With strong letters, research, and surgical exposure, this range can open a lot of doors.

• Viable but needs strong application (230–239)

  • Still reasonable for many community and some academic-affiliated programs.
  • You must lean heavily on: auditions, strong MSPE/comments, letters, and a sharp personal statement.

• Below 230 (low Step score match territory)

  • Matching general surgery is not impossible but becomes significantly more challenging.
  • Requires a highly strategic approach, careful program selection, and often a broader parallel plan (e.g., prelim surgery spots, backup specialties).

Timeline Planning: When to Take Step 2 CK

For a DO graduate (or rising DO MS3/MS4) targeting the surgery residency match, timing is everything.

Ideal timing strategy:

1. Complete core clerkships (especially Internal Medicine, Surgery, and Pediatrics) before Step 2 CK.
2. Aim to take Step 2 CK by late June–July of the year before you apply.
   • This allows your score to be available by ERAS opening (September).
   • It also lets you use your score when contacting programs and planning audition rotations.

If you are worried about a low score:

• Consider taking SLIGHTLY later (July/August) if you need extra prep time.
• But avoid:
  • Testing so late that the score isn’t back for initial screens.
  • Taking it in a rush with inadequate prep; a poor score is much harder to overcome than a slightly delayed one.

Building a High-Yield Study Plan

For a DO graduate, a combined USMLE/COMLEX approach works well.

Core resources for Step 2 CK:

• UWorld Step 2 CK QBank (non-negotiable core)
• NBME practice exams to calibrate your score
• A high-yield text or video series (e.g., Online MedEd, Step-Up to Medicine, etc.) for weak areas

For integration with COMLEX Level 2-CE:

• Add a COMLEX-specific QBank (e.g., COMBANK or COMQUEST) for OMM and COMLEX-style questions.
• Use a short daily OMM review (tables, high-yield manipulative techniques, viscerosomatic levels).

Suggested structure (10–12 weeks of focused dedicated time, adaptable):

Phase 1 (Weeks 1–3): Foundation & Assessment

• 40 questions/day UWorld (timed, random).
• Daily review and annotation.
• One NBME or UWorld self-assessment to gauge starting point.
• Daily 20–30 min OMM/COMLEX review if you’re taking Level 2-CE.

Phase 2 (Weeks 4–8): Intensive Practice

• 60–80 UWorld questions/day (or split across two sessions).
• Identify weak systems (e.g., cardiology, GI, surgery) and dedicate 2–3 evenings per week to focused review.
• Take an NBME or UWSA every 2 weeks to track progress.
• Start integrating surgery-specific topics: trauma, peri-op management, wound healing, fluids/electrolytes.

Phase 3 (Weeks 9–10/12): Refinement & Exam Readiness

• Prioritize mixed blocks + review of incorrect questions.
• Pass through your marked questions and weak topics.
• Final NBME/UWSA 7–10 days before your exam to fine-tune timing and confidence.

If you are already out of school (DO graduate):

• Carve out structured daily blocks of 4–6 hours.
• Treat your study schedule like a job; avoid low-yield, unfocused review.

---

Section 3: Strategies if You Have a Low Step Score (or No Step 1 Score Advantage)

Many DO graduates worry about a low Step score match outcome. Whether it’s:

• A low Step 1 (for those who took it numerically),
• A borderline Step 2 CK attempt,
• Or lower-than-ideal COMLEX scores,

you still have viable strategies.

Scenario 1: Low Step 1, Strong Step 2 CK

If you have:

• Step 1: low (or just a pass, if older score)
• Step 2 CK: significantly higher (e.g., 15–20+ points above your Step 1 range)

Then emphasize in your application:

• Your upward trajectory: “I matured, refined my study strategies, and improved substantially.”
• This can reassure programs and show that your low Step 1 was not due to inherent difficulty with standardized tests.

Application tips:

• Mention briefly (if needed) in your personal statement how you learned from Step 1, but keep it forward-looking.
• Highlight honors in core clerkships and strong narrative comments in your MSPE.
• Ask letter writers to comment on your clinical reasoning and reliability, not just operatory skills.

Scenario 2: Low Step 2 CK as a DO General Surgery Applicant

If your Step 2 CK is lower than desired (e.g., < 230), you are firmly in low Step score match territory and must be strategic.

Action steps:

1. Maximize every non-score domain

   • Strong letters from surgeons who know you well.
   • Excellent performance on sub-internships / audition rotations.
   • Evidence of work ethic, “coachability,” and team orientation.

2. Refine your program list

   • Prioritize:
     • Community and smaller academic-affiliated general surgery programs.
     • Programs with a history of taking DOs.
   • Use resources like FREIDA and program websites to identify:
     • Proportion of DO residents.
     • Whether USMLE is required or COMLEX is accepted.

3. Consider prelim surgery as a bridge

   • A preliminary general surgery position can:
     • Give you a year of experience.
     • Allow you to earn powerful in-house letters.
     • Sometimes convert into a categorical spot if a position opens.
   • But be aware: this path is stressful and not guaranteed; treat it as a backup, not your primary goal.

4. Frame your narrative

   • Own your score without making excuses.
   • Emphasize your clinical strength, ability to handle long hours, and dedication to surgery.
   • Highlight any research or quality improvement that shows persistence and attention to detail.

Scenario 3: COMLEX-Only DO Graduate

If you took only COMLEX and did not take USMLE:

• You can still match general surgery, but your program options are narrower.
• Some programs will screen out applicants without USMLE numbers.

Optimization strategies:

• Excel on COMLEX Level 2-CE (high 500s–600+ region is helpful for more competitive programs).
• Look for programs that:
  • Explicitly say “COMLEX accepted” or have current DO residents.
  • Are more DO-friendly, often in regions with osteopathic schools.

If you are still early enough:

• Consider taking USMLE Step 2 CK even if you already took Level 2-CE.
• You will need a tailored prep plan, but your COMLEX prep provides a strong base.

---

Section 4: Integrating Step Scores with the Rest of Your General Surgery Application

Your Step 1 and Step 2 CK scores are only part of your story. For a DO graduate, the combined picture is what determines your success in the surgery residency match.

Aligning Exam Timing with Rotations and Letters

Optimal sequence for rising DO MS3/MS4:

1. Third-year core rotations: Build strong clinical basics; get on surgeons’ radar.
2. Take Step 2 CK after core rotations, before sub-Is.
3. Sub-internships (sub-Is) / audition rotations in general surgery:
   • Schedule 1–3 rotations at programs where you’d be happy to match.
   • Aim for at least one home sub-I and one away rotation if possible.
4. Secure letters from:
   • At least one general surgeon (ideally a program director or chair).
   • Someone who has directly supervised you in the OR or on the wards.

If your Step 2 CK is strong:

• You can confidently share your score during auditions.
• Programs may see you as an especially competitive DO candidate.

If your Step 2 CK is weaker:

• Rely even more heavily on exemplary performance during rotations.
• Demonstrate that you are a high-yield colleague: early, prepared, dependable, and eager to learn.

Using Research and Scholarly Activity as a Force Multiplier

General surgery programs value:

• Research in surgery, trauma, critical care, oncology, or related fields.
• Quality improvement projects or case reports with your name as author.

If your Step scores are average or modest:

• Research can tip the balance in your favor, especially at academic programs.
• For DO graduates, research also signals comfort in academic environments.

Practical tips:

• Start early: join projects at your home institution or regional centers.
• Even smaller projects (retrospective reviews, case reports, QI projects) matter if done well and presented at meetings.
• Highlight these in ERAS under research experiences and posters/publications.

Crafting a Coherent Narrative

Your narrative should connect:

• Why you chose general surgery.
• How you prepared intellectually (Step 2 CK strategy, clinical work).
• How you’ve demonstrated resilience and growth, especially if you overcame a low Step score.
• What you bring as a DO graduate: holistic perspective, OMM background when relevant (e.g., pain management, MSK issues), and often strong interpersonal skills.

Use your:

• Personal statement to tell this story succinctly and honestly.
• Interviews to reinforce your enthusiasm, insight into surgical life, and self-awareness.

---

Section 5: Program Selection and Match Strategy for DO Graduates in General Surgery

Your Step scores directly influence your residency list strategy. Optimizing your osteopathic residency match approach for general surgery means matching your profile to realistic tiers.

Tiers of Programs and How to Target Them

Think about programs in three broad categories:

1. Top-tier academic university programs

   • Often associated with med schools, major research centers.
   • Generally have higher Step 2 CK expectations, more research.
   • May favor MDs with extensive research portfolios.
   • As a DO, you’re more competitive here with:
     • Step 2 CK in high 240s–250+.
     • Research, particularly with publications/presentations.
     • Strong letters from academic surgeons.

2. Mid-tier university-affiliated / hybrid programs

   • Solid training, variable research expectations.
   • More open to DOs with strong all-around applications.
   • These can be excellent targets for DOs with:
     • Step 2 CK in the mid 230s–240s.
     • Strong rotations and letters.
     • Some research or QI, even if modest.

3. Community and smaller academic-affiliated programs

   • Often DO-friendly, especially if located near osteopathic schools.
   • Great training, sometimes with less emphasis on research.
   • As a DO, you may be very competitive here if:
     • Step 2 CK is in the 230s (or even slightly lower with strong clinical performance).
     • You show commitment to the region or program type.
     • Your letters clearly endorse your work ethic and team fit.

How Many Programs to Apply To

For DO graduates in general surgery:

• With strong scores (e.g., Step 2 CK ≥ 245):
  40–60 programs may be adequate, depending on the rest of your profile.
• With moderate scores (230–244):
  60–80 programs to build a broad and realistic list.
• With low Step scores (< 230):
  Consider 80+ programs, including:
  • DO-friendly community programs.
  • Some prelim general surgery programs (as a backup).
  • Possibly a parallel plan in a less competitive specialty if your primary goal is to match somewhere categorical.

Always cross-reference:

• Current or past DO residents at a program.
• Program websites for “USMLE required” vs “COMLEX accepted” language.
• Geographic preferences and where you have regional ties.

---

FAQs: Step Score Strategy for DO Graduates in General Surgery

1. As a DO graduate, do I really need to take USMLE Step 2 CK for general surgery?

You can technically match with COMLEX-only scores, but for general surgery:

• USMLE Step 2 CK is strongly recommended.
• It opens more programs, particularly academic and university-affiliated ones.
• Many programs still prefer or require USMLE numbers for easy comparison.

If you’re early enough in training and serious about general surgery, incorporating Step 2 CK into your plan is one of the highest-yield decisions you can make.

2. What Step 2 CK score should I aim for as a DO who wants a general surgery residency?

Aim for:

• 250+ if you’re targeting top-tier academic programs and want to overcome DO bias decisively.
• 240–249 for solid competitiveness at many university-affiliated and strong community programs.
• 230–239 can still be viable, especially with strong rotations, letters, and research.

If you land below 230, you will need to:

• Be very realistic with your program list.
• Rely more heavily on auditions, letters, and fit.
• Consider prelim and/or a backup specialty as part of your low Step score match strategy.

3. How can I recover from a low Step 1 or Step 2 CK as a DO applicant to general surgery?

Recovery strategy:

• Crush Step 2 CK if Step 1 was low (show an upward trend).
• If Step 2 CK is also low:
  • Focus on exemplary performance on general surgery rotations and sub-Is.
  • Secure strong, specific letters from surgeons.
  • Apply broadly, with an emphasis on DO-friendly and community programs.
  • Consider preliminary general surgery positions and/or backup specialties.
• Make sure your personal statement and interviews:
  • Acknowledge growth without making excuses.
  • Highlight your resilience, work ethic, and genuine commitment to surgery.

4. How important are COMLEX scores if I also take USMLE?

For general surgery:

• USMLE Step 2 CK usually carries more weight for screening.
• That said, COMLEX scores still matter:
  • They reflect your performance across osteopathic standards.
  • Some DO-heavy or osteopathic-affiliated programs will look at them closely.
• Poor COMLEX performance with strong USMLE can raise questions, but many programs will focus on your USMLE Step 2 CK for comparison.

In practice:

• Treat both exams seriously.
• Use your USMLE performance as your primary leverage in the broader pool, and COMLEX as a supporting metric, especially for DO-friendly programs.

---

By pairing a deliberate Step score strategy with strong clinical performance, targeted program selection, and a clear narrative, you can position yourself competitively as a DO graduate pursuing general surgery. Your scores matter—but they’re one part of a larger, carefully constructed application that you can still shape, even if your testing journey hasn’t been perfect.