Step Score Strategy for Non-US Citizen IMGs in Preliminary Surgery Residency

Understanding the Role of Step Scores in Preliminary Surgery for Non-US Citizen IMGs

For a non-US citizen IMG aiming for a preliminary surgery residency, USMLE Step scores are often the first—and sometimes harshest—filter. But they are not the entire story. Programs use them to rapidly screen hundreds of applications, especially in surgery where the applicant pool is competitive and time-pressured.

Key realities you must understand upfront:

• Step 1 is now Pass/Fail
  Programs can no longer use a Step 1 numerical cutoff. But your Step 1 performance (especially if taken before the change or if you failed once) still matters as a signal of exam readiness and reliability.

• Step 2 CK has become the main numeric metric
  For preliminary surgery, your Step 2 CK strategy is central. A strong Step 2 CK score can:

  • Compensate partially for weak or borderline Step 1 history
  • Differentiate you from other IMGs
  • Demonstrate clinical reasoning strength for a surgical environment

• Non-US citizen IMG status adds extra filters
  Even if you are a strong foreign national medical graduate, programs may:

  • Limit the number of visa candidates they sponsor
  • Prefer US clinical experience and letters
  • Use even higher informal Step 2 CK thresholds for non-US citizen applicants

• Prelim surgery is both an entry point and a test
  A preliminary surgery year can:

  • Give you US clinical, operative, and research experience
  • Lead to categoricals (but only for a small fraction)
  • Function as a “one-year chance” to prove yourself, especially if you have a low Step score match profile

Your Step score strategy must therefore be:

1. Data-driven: based on your current scores and timing
2. Targeted: specific to surgery and preliminary positions
3. Integrated: combined with research, USCE, and program selection

The rest of this article will walk you step-by-step through building that strategy.

---

How Programs Actually Use Step Scores for Preliminary Surgery

Understanding how program directors think about Step scores helps you set realistic goals and tactics.

1. The Screening Reality

For many general surgery programs, the first pass over applications is mechanical:

• Automatic filters often include:
  • Step 2 CK minimum (commonly 230–240 for categoricals; prelim may be slightly lower but still competitive)
  • Number of attempts on any Step exam
  • YOG cutoffs
  • Visa sponsorship limitations

For a non-US citizen IMG, a strong Step 2 CK is often necessary just to stay in the pile.

While exact cutoffs are rarely published, some common patterns for prelim surgery:

• Programs that are IMG-friendly may:

  • Consider non-US citizen IMGs with Step 2 CK in the 220s if other factors are strong (research, USCE, strong letters, connections).
  • Be more flexible for prelim surgery residency spots than for categorical.

• More competitive academic programs may:

  • Expect Step 2 CK ≥ 235–240 even for prelims
  • Still rarely consider candidates with multiple Step failures

2. Step Scores as Risk Markers

Programs see Step scores as indicators of:

• Test-taking reliability: Will you pass ABSITE, future boards, and in-training exams?
• Resilience and discipline: Did you improve from Step 1 to Step 2 CK?
• Red flags: Multiple attempts, large score drops, or failure without remediation story

For a candidate with a low Step score match profile, your goal is to:

• Minimize perceived risk (e.g., no additional exam failures)
• Show a clear upward trend from Step 1 to Step 2 CK
• Pair lower scores with overcompensation in other domains (research, surgical exposure, professionalism)

3. Prelim vs Categorical Score Expectations

Important distinctions:

• Categorical surgery:

  • Highly competitive
  • Many US MD seniors applying
  • Programs can afford to be strict with Step thresholds

• Preliminary surgery year:

  • Often used to fill call schedules and service needs
  • Includes a mix of:
    • Dedicated surgical prelims
    • Transition-year residents (categorical in other fields)
  • More open to IMGs, especially those with:
    • Strong work ethic
    • Good evaluations from previous clinical roles

Program directors may be more open to a foreign national medical graduate in a prelim spot if:

• You have solid Step 2 CK (even if not stellar)
• You show clear commitment to surgery
• Your application signals you will be a reliable, hard-working resident

---

Strategic Planning: Step 1 and Step 2 CK for the Non-US Citizen IMG

Your exact strategy depends on where you are in the process and what your exam record already looks like.

A. If You Have Not Taken Step 1 Yet (Uncommon but Possible)

If you are early in your training and Step 1 is still ahead:

• Treat Step 1 as:
  • A foundation builder for Step 2 CK
  • A professionalism metric (avoid failures at all costs)
• Since it’s Pass/Fail:
  • Aim to pass on first attempt, not to “scrape by”
  • Use Step 1 prep to identify weak basic science areas that will resurface in CK

For surgery-focused IMGs:

• Pay extra attention to:
  • Physiology (hemodynamics, shock)
  • Anatomy (especially abdominal, thoracic, vascular)
  • Pathology fundamentals

The main Step 1 strategy: no failures, no extensions, no excuses. This becomes part of your narrative as a stable, low-risk candidate.

B. If You Already Have a Step 1 Result

1. Step 1 Pass on First Attempt

For those with Pass/Fail:

• Programs only see “Pass” and the date:
  • You are not harmed by a “lower pass” vs “high pass”
  • Your Step 2 CK performance becomes the key differentiator

For those with older numerical Step 1 results:

• High Step 1 (e.g., ≥240–245):

  • Leverage it in your narrative: “strong test-taker”
  • But you still need a consistent Step 2 CK (within ~10–15 points ideally)

• Moderate Step 1 (e.g., 220–235):

  • Very common for IMGs
  • You can still be competitive for prelim surgery if:
    • Step 2 CK shows improvement (e.g., jumps into mid-high 230s+)
    • You have solid surgical letters and research

• Low Step 1 (e.g., below ~220) or multiple attempts:

  • You are in a low Step score match risk group
  • Your strategy must focus on:
    • Very strong Step 2 CK (clear improvement)
    • Powerful narrative: what changed in your preparation and life
    • Targeted applications to programs historically open to IMGs

2. Step 1 Failure

A Step 1 failure is not an absolute stop, but it is a serious red flag, especially for surgical specialties.

Your recovery strategy must include:

• Clear remediation story:

  • Concrete changes you made (tutoring, new resources, schedule restructuring)
  • Objective improvement in practice scores
  • Successful Step 2 CK (on first attempt)

• No further exam failures:

  • Failing Step 2 CK after a Step 1 failure essentially closes most surgical doors.

• Honest but focused explanation in your application:

  • Avoid long excuses; emphasize:
    • Identified weaknesses
    • How you addressed them
    • Demonstrated improvement

Programs may still consider you for a preliminary surgery residency if they see:

• Evidence of resilience and self-awareness
• Strong US-based clinical performance
• Excellent work-ethic letters from surgeons

C. Designing a Step 2 CK Strategy Specifically for Surgery

As a non-US citizen IMG aiming for a preliminary surgery spot, your Step 2 CK strategy should be more aggressive and structured than for less competitive paths.

1. Score Targeting

While no score guarantees interviews, realistic tiers:

• Highly competitive for prelim surgery (especially at academic centers):

  • Step 2 CK ≥ 245–250+
  • Strong research and USCE to match

• Solid competitive range (many prelim programs will review):

  • Step 2 CK 235–244
  • Particularly good if Step 1 was weaker and this shows clear improvement

• Borderline but still possible for some IMG-friendly prelims:

  • Step 2 CK 220–234
  • Must be supported by:
    • Exceptional USCE
    • Strong letters from US surgeons
    • Possibly strong home-country surgical experience

Below ~220:
You are in a challenging low Step score match situation for surgery. You must treat everything else in your profile as “must be outstanding” and strongly consider parallel planning (e.g., prelim medicine, research year, or alternative specialties).

2. Preparation Timeline

For a foreign national medical graduate, you often juggle visa, finances, and time zone constraints. A robust plan might look like:

• Dedicated prep time: 3–5 months full-time (or 6–8 months part-time)
• Weekly structure:
  • 5–6 days of intensive study
  • 1 day for rest, review, and planning
• By prep milestones:
  • Month 1–2: content consolidation + early question blocks
  • Month 3–4: primarily question-based learning + timed blocks
  • Final 4–6 weeks: full-length practice exams + refinement

3. Resource Strategy

A focused, high-yield approach works best:

• Core resources:

  • One comprehensive review (e.g., a popular Step 2 CK notes-style book)
  • A single high-quality Qbank (UWorld or equivalent) done at least once, aiming for:
    • 70%+ correct overall (not mandatory, but a good benchmark)
    • Thorough review of all explanations, not just answers

• Exam-specific practice:

  • NBME practice exams
  • Official practice forms if available

Always use your practice scores to time your real exam:

• Do not rush to take Step 2 CK if NBME scores are still below your minimum target range.
• If your practice scores plateau in the low 220s, reconsider timing or even overall specialty strategy.

---

Applying with Low or Moderate Step Scores: Maximizing Your Prelim Surgery Chances

Even if your scores are not ideal, a thoughtful application strategy can significantly improve your odds.

1. Building a “Compensation Profile”

Programs may be willing to overlook weaker scores if you shine in other areas. For a non-US citizen IMG, especially with low Step score match risk, prioritize:

• US Clinical Experience (USCE) in surgery:

  • Observerships, externships, sub-internships where possible
  • Aim for hands-on roles if legal and available (e.g., sub-I as a visiting student)
  • Seek opportunities to:
    • Present cases
    • Write notes (if permitted)
    • Participate in M&M or journal clubs

• Strong letters from US surgeons:

  • At least 2–3 letters from:
    • Attending surgeons
    • Program directors
    • Surgical department heads
  • Ask them to highlight:
    • Work ethic
    • Teamwork
    • Reliability and punctuality
    • Ability to handle long hours and stress

• Surgical research and productivity:

  • Retrospective studies, case reports, chart reviews
  • Quality improvement projects in surgery
  • Posters or oral presentations at meetings of:
    • ACS
    • SAGES
    • Local or national surgical societies

• Evidence of professionalism and grit:

  • Long-term commitments (e.g., >6 months research roles)
  • Consistent involvement in surgical interest groups
  • Documented reliability in recommendation letters

2. Targeting Programs Strategically

As a non-US citizen IMG, you must be particularly strategic:

• Focus on programs that:

  • Have previously matched IMGs in general or prelim surgery
  • Explicitly sponsor visas (J-1, and if possible H-1B)
  • Are community-based, hybrid community-academic, or safety-net hospitals

• Use tools and data:

  • NRMP’s “Charting Outcomes in the Match” for surgery and IMGs
  • Program websites, resident rosters, and alumni lists
  • ERAS filters for visa sponsorship
  • Online forums cautiously (verify information independently)

• Apply broadly:

  • It’s common for non-US citizen IMGs to apply to 80–120+ general surgery programs, including:
    • A mix of categorical and prelim spots if financially possible
    • A large number of prelim-only positions if your primary goal is a preliminary surgery year

3. Writing a Narrative that De-emphasizes Scores

Your personal statement and interviews should not obsess over numbers. Instead:

• Emphasize:

  • Longstanding interest in surgery
  • Concrete experiences confirming your career choice
  • Your understanding of what a real surgical lifestyle entails

• If scores are low or Step 1 had a failure:

  • Address briefly and professionally:
    • What happened
    • What you learned
    • How your subsequent performance (Step 2 CK, clinical rotations) shows improvement
  • Then pivot quickly back to your strengths and current competence

• Avoid:

  • Long defensive paragraphs about exams
  • Blaming external factors without demonstrating responsibility and growth

---

Using a Preliminary Surgery Year as Part of a Long-Term Strategy

For many foreign national medical graduates, a preliminary surgery residency is not the final goal but a strategic step toward:

• A categorical surgery position (via future reapplication)
• Another competitive specialty (e.g., radiology, anesthesiology) after US clinical exposure
• A combined clinical–research path in academic surgery

Your Step score strategy must be aligned with how you plan to use this prelim year.

1. If You Aim to Transition to Categorical Surgery

Programs will look beyond scores and evaluate your performance as a resident:

• During your prelim year, work to:

  • Earn exceptional in-training evaluations
  • Show initiative in the OR and on wards
  • Volunteer for research and QI projects
  • Build close relationships with faculty who can later advocate for you

• Your Step scores:

  • Still matter for new applications
  • But can be somewhat overshadowed by:
    • Strong in-program letters
    • Excellent ABSITE performance
    • Real-world proof that you function at or above the level of current categoricals

If your scores are lower, ABSITE becomes crucial:

• Treat it like another Step Exam
• Study systematically from early in the year
• A strong ABSITE result can convince PDs that earlier low scores were not representative of your current capacity

2. If You Intend to Pivot to Another Specialty

If surgery is your stepping stone into US training:

• Focus your Step 2 CK and future Step 3 performance on the requirements of your target specialty:
  • For example, anesthesiology, radiology, or EM will each have different expectations
• Use prelim surgery to:
  • Enhance your CV with US supervised clinical experience
  • Obtain strong letters about your clinical acumen and reliability
  • Demonstrate adaptability and resilience

Your low Step score match profile might be more acceptable in certain specialties if offset by:

• US training year
• Standardized test improvement (Step 2 CK > Step 1, Step 3 passed on first attempt)
• Strong interpersonal and teamwork evaluations

3. Visa and Timing Considerations

As a non-US citizen IMG, always factor visa issues into your Step and prelim plans:

• J-1 visa:
  • Most common for prelim surgery
  • Usually requires USMLE Step 1 + Step 2 CK + ECFMG certification
• H-1B visa:
  • More restrictive, often requires Step 3 before starting residency
  • Not all programs sponsor H-1B

Plan your exam timeline so that by the time you start residency you have:

• Step 1 (Pass)
• Step 2 CK (score reported)
• ECFMG certification (including OET or equivalent, as applicable)
• Optionally, Step 3 if aiming at H-1B–sponsoring programs

---

Practical Action Plan for Non-US Citizen IMGs Targeting Preliminary Surgery

To consolidate everything into an actionable approach, here is a structured roadmap.

1. Self-Assessment

Understand your starting point:

• Step 1 status:
  • Pass/Fail, numerical score if applicable, attempts
• Step 2 CK status:
  • Score, attempts, date taken or planned
• Other factors:
  • YOG
  • US clinical experience
  • Surgical research and publications
  • Visa needs

Create a brief profile:

“Non-US citizen IMG, YOG 2020, Step 1 Pass (2022), Step 2 CK 232 (first attempt), 3 months US surgical observership, 1 accepted case report, needs J-1 visa.”

This will guide your target program range and application strategy.

2. Step 2 CK (or Step 3) Optimization

If Step 2 CK is not yet taken or is borderline:

• Decide if you have room to:
  • Delay the exam to improve practice scores
  • Retake only if absolutely necessary (and allowed) with a realistic shot at significant improvement
• If already taken and low:
  • Focus on:
    • Strengthening ABSITE and clinical performance during prelim year
    • Compensatory strengths (research, letters, work ethic)
  • Consider Step 3 later to demonstrate improvement, but do not rush into it unprepared

3. Application Strategy for Prelim Surgery

• Apply to a broad mix of:

  • Prelim-only programs
  • Programs that typically have unfilled prelim positions after the main Match

• Prepare:

  • A surgery-focused personal statement
  • A second, slightly adapted version if you also apply prelim medicine as a backup

• Monitor:

  • ERAS program updates on visa policies
  • NRMP list of unfilled programs for SOAP if needed

4. During the Prelim Year

Maximize the value of the opportunity:

• Be known as:

  • The resident who shows up early, stays late
  • Calm under pressure
  • Reliable with notes, handoffs, and follow-up tasks

• Academically:

  • Start ABSITE prep early
  • Join at least one research project
  • Present at least once (case, M&M, or journal club)

• Networking:

  • Let your PD and mentors know your long-term goals
  • Ask for targeted advice: whether they see you fitting as a categorical surgery candidate or better suited elsewhere

---

FAQ: Step Score Strategy for Non-US Citizen IMGs in Preliminary Surgery

1. I am a non-US citizen IMG with a Step 2 CK score of 225. Do I still have a chance at a prelim surgery residency?
Yes, you may still have a chance, especially at more community-based or IMG-friendly programs. To optimize your chances:

• Apply widely to prelim-only positions
• Strengthen US clinical experience in surgery
• Secure strong letters from US surgeons
• Highlight any research, QI work, or home-country surgical experience
  Recognize that this is a low Step score match profile for surgery, so you should also consider parallel options (e.g., prelim medicine, research year).

2. How important is Step 2 CK compared to Step 1 for preliminary surgery now that Step 1 is Pass/Fail?
Step 2 CK has become the primary numeric metric in residency selection, especially in surgery:

• It reflects your clinical reasoning and readiness for surgical decision-making
• Many programs use informal Step 2 CK thresholds for initial screening
• A strong Step 2 CK can partially compensate for a weaker Step 1 history
  For a non-US citizen IMG, a well-planned Step 2 CK strategy is essential.

3. If I have a Step 1 failure but passed on the second attempt, should I still apply for prelim surgery?
You can still apply, but you must:

• Acknowledge the failure briefly and professionally
• Show clear improvement with a solid Step 2 CK score (ideally ≥230)
• Provide strong US-based clinical performance and letters
  Programs may be more open to you for a preliminary surgery year than for categorical, especially if your subsequent performance clearly demonstrates growth and reliability.

4. Can a strong prelim surgery year help overcome low Step scores for a future categorical spot?
Yes, to a degree. A strong prelim year can:

• Provide excellent US-based evaluations
• Allow you to achieve a good ABSITE score
• Generate powerful letters from surgeons who have worked with you closely
  While your Step scores will still appear on future applications, sustained excellence in a US training environment can convince some program directors that earlier low scores are less relevant than your demonstrated performance as a resident.

---

By treating your exams as part of a broader, integrated strategy—and not as the sole determinant of your future—you can significantly improve your chances of securing a preliminary surgery residency as a non-US citizen IMG, even if your Step 1 score residency profile or Step 2 CK results are not perfect.