Effective Strategies for US Citizen IMGs with Low Step Scores in EM-IM

Understanding the Challenge: Low Step Scores and EM-IM as a US Citizen IMG

Emergency Medicine–Internal Medicine (EM-IM) combined programs are small, selective, and attract strong applicants. Being a US citizen IMG and carrying a low Step 1 score or below average board scores adds another layer of difficulty—but it does not automatically end your chances.

As an American studying abroad (Caribbean or other international school), you have several advantages: English fluency, cultural familiarity with US healthcare, and often US clinical experience. Your challenge is to offset the numerical weakness and demonstrate to programs that:

1. Your low score is not a predictor of residency performance.
2. You have a clear, sustained commitment to emergency medicine internal medicine.
3. You bring distinct value—work ethic, maturity, and experience—to a small, high-intensity combined program.

This article breaks down specific, actionable strategies for matching EM-IM with low scores, including how to choose programs, present your narrative, leverage clinical experiences, and build a realistic but ambitious application plan.

---

How EM-IM Programs View Low Step Scores

Understanding how PDs (program directors) think is the foundation for any strategy, especially when matching with low scores.

1. What “Low” Means in this Context

By “low Step score” or “below average board scores,” most programs mean:

• Step 1: Below the old national mean (roughly < 220 back when it was scored) or fail on first attempt
• Step 2 CK: < 230–235, especially if EM/IM averages are ~240+
• COMLEX: Scores that are significantly below the average for matched EM or IM residents

If you had a Step 1 failure, or multiple attempts on Step 2, you’re in a higher-risk category in the eyes of PDs. But EM-IM programs increasingly look beyond Step 1, especially now that it’s pass/fail, and care more about:

• Step 2 CK performance trend
• EM and IM clinical grades
• SLOEs (Standardized Letters of Evaluation) from EM rotations
• Letters from IM faculty
• Professionalism and resilience

2. The Special Case of EM-IM Combined Programs

EM-IM positions are limited and often at academic centers. These programs need residents who:

• Can handle high patient volume and cognitive load
• Tolerate long work hours and night shifts
• Communicate clearly across disciplines
• Commit to five years of training

Consequently, EM-IM PDs may be more selective, but they also often appreciate:

• Non-traditional paths (prior careers, global health, research)
• Applicants with strong work ethic and grit
• Those who can articulate why combined EM-IM (and not just EM or IM alone)

A below average Step score is a concern, but many PDs have seen low-scoring students become excellent residents, especially when they show growth, insight, and strong clinical evaluations.

3. The US Citizen IMG Factor

As a US citizen IMG, you have some advantages compared with non-US IMGs:

• No visa sponsorship issues
• Usually higher English proficiency and cultural familiarity
• Often more flexible regarding location and program type

However, program directors know that US citizen IMGs can be “hidden gems” or can carry significant academic risk. Your application must clearly communicate that you are reliable, coachable, and past the hurdle that caused low scores.

---

Academic Recovery and Testing Strategy After a Low Step Score

If your scores are already in, your goal is to stabilize the narrative and prove that the weakness is in the past. If you still have exams ahead, your goal is damage control and trend reversal.

1. Step 2 CK as Redemption

For many US citizen IMGs, Step 2 CK becomes the most important number in the file.

If your Step 1 is low or you had a fail attempt:

• Aim for at least 15–20 points higher than your Step 1 (if numeric)
• Use dedicated, structured resources:
  • UWorld (complete at least one full pass, ideally 1.5–2 passes)
  • NBME practice exams to track progression
  • Anki or another spaced repetition system for weak areas
• Create an 8–12 week schedule with daily goals, including:
  • 40–80 questions/day with detailed review
  • Daily mixed systems (mirrors real test)
  • Weekly self-assessments to ensure upward trend

If you’ve already taken Step 2 CK and the score is also low, your strategy shifts from redemption by numbers to holistic reinforcement: strong clerkship grades, strong SLOEs, and a tightly reasoned personal narrative.

2. Explaining a Low Score vs. Making Excuses

Many US citizen IMGs struggle with how much to say about a low Step score.

Reasonable explanations include:

• Acute illness around the time of the exam
• Family emergency or caregiving responsibilities
• Significant personal crisis or mental health challenge
• Documented test-taking or learning differences

Poor explanations or red flags include:

• Blaming the exam for being “unfair” or “not reflective of real medicine”
• Blaming your school, faculty, or “bad questions”
• Long, emotional narratives that overshadow your growth

Strategy:
Use your personal statement or the “Additional Information” section of ERAS to briefly:

1. Acknowledge the low score or failure.
2. State objective context (if relevant).
3. Emphasize specific actions you took to improve:
   • Changed study strategies
   • Sought tutoring/academic counseling
   • Implemented time management or wellness strategies
4. Highlight improved outcomes (if any): stronger shelf exams, Step 2, or clinical evaluations.

Keep it factual, concise, and forward-looking. The message: “I struggled, I learned, and I did something about it.”

3. Leveraging Shelf Exams and Clinical Evaluations

If your board scores are weak, clerkship performance becomes crucial evidence of your capacity.

For EM-IM, key rotations include:

• Emergency Medicine core or sub-internship
• Internal Medicine core and sub-I
• ICU, cardiology, and other high-acuity rotations

Actions you can take:

• Aim for Honors or High Pass in EM and IM, and ask preceptors explicitly how to achieve that.
• Request mid-rotation feedback and directly ask, “What can I do to perform at the level of a strong EM-IM applicant?”
• Keep copies of strong narrative comments for your own records; they often appear in letters and MSPE.

If your school has NBME shelf exams, consistent above-average shelf scores can partially offset a low Step 1 or borderline Step 2 CK. Mention improvements or strong shelves in your MSPE or dean’s letter when possible.

---

Building a Standout EM-IM Application as a US Citizen IMG

With limited EM-IM spots and low scores, your application must be tightly engineered to show you belong in this demanding combined specialty.

1. Clarify Your EM-IM “Why”

Programs will assume you are also considering EM alone or IM alone. To stand out for EM-IM, your “why” must be:

• Specific, not generic (“I like procedures and continuity” is not enough)
• Based on real experiences from clinical work
• Clearly integrated into your long-term career goals

Examples of strong EM-IM motivations:

• You enjoy resuscitation and stabilization, but also want to manage complex chronic disease and follow patients longitudinally (e.g., heart failure, COPD, diabetes).
• You envision a hybrid career: ED shifts combined with ward attending, ICU work, or outpatient internal medicine.
• You want to lead ED observation units, hospital medicine quality projects, or ED–inpatient transitions of care.

In your personal statement:

• Describe specific patients whose care spanned the ED and inpatient service.
• Show how you enjoyed both acute decision-making and longitudinal thinking.
• Tie your interest to themes like systems-based practice, continuity, and complex comorbidities.

2. Optimize EM and IM Letters (SLOEs and Traditional LORs)

As a US citizen IMG, letters carry extra weight. PDs use them to answer: “Can I trust this applicant to function safely and grow quickly in our system?”

For EM-IM, aim for:

• 2 EM SLOEs (Standardized Letters of Evaluation) from:
  • Academic EM rotations at US institutions
  • EM sub-internships or audition rotations
• 2 IM-focused letters, ideally from:
  • IM sub-internship attendings
  • Inpatient IM rotation faculty
  • IM program director or clerkship director if possible

Tips to maximize letter strength:

• Rotate at institutions with EM-IM programs if you can. Even if you don’t rotate directly at the EM-IM site, within-network rotations may help.
• Let letter writers know your narrative:
  • You are a US citizen IMG with below average scores.
  • You seek a letter that speaks to your clinical judgment, reliability, work ethic, and resilience.
• Ask directly: “Do you feel you can write a strong, supportive letter for my EM-IM application?” If hesitant, seek another writer.

Strong SLOEs can outweigh low scores, especially if they explicitly compare you favorably to US MD graduates.

3. Crafting Your Personal Statement and ERAS Content

For someone matching with low scores, your written materials are not just formalities—they are tools to reframe your candidacy.

Personal Statement Priorities:

• Lead with patient care stories that show you thriving in acute settings and in longitudinal follow-up.
• Emphasize behaviors that PDs value in EM-IM:
  • Teamwork across specialties
  • Comfort with uncertainty and complex patients
  • Commitment to systems improvement and follow-through
• Briefly address academic struggles (if significant), then pivot to growth and what you offer now.

ERAS Application Details:

• In the experiences section, highlight:
  • Any EM or IM leadership roles (student societies, simulation teaching, interest groups).
  • Quality improvement projects, especially bridging the ED and inpatient services.
  • Research or scholarly activity—even small projects or posters—related to EM, IM, or education.

Emphasize longitudinal commitment: sustained involvement over time is far more compelling than a list of one-off activities.

---

Smart Program Selection and Application Strategy with Low Scores

You cannot control your past Step scores, but you can control where and how you apply. Strategy is critical.

1. Understanding the EM-IM Landscape

EM-IM combined programs are relatively few and often located at larger academic centers. For a US citizen IMG with low scores:

• Treat EM-IM programs as high-yield targets, but not your only pathway.
• Consider a dual-application strategy:
  • Apply to EM-IM programs where your profile fits.
  • Apply to categorical EM and/or categorical IM programs that are IMG-friendly and within realistic score ranges.

You might end up:

• Matching EM-IM (ideal outcome)
• Matching EM alone or IM alone (still an excellent path to a robust emergency or internal medicine career)

2. Reading Program Signals and Filters

Many programs use filters in ERAS based on:

• Step 1 and Step 2 CK scores
• Number of attempts
• Citizenship/visa status
• Graduation year cutoffs

As a US citizen IMG:

• You clear the visa sponsorship hurdle, which is significant.
• You must still navigate score filters. Some programs publicly share their minimal score cutoffs; others do not.

Actions:

• Check program websites and FREIDA for minimum score requirements.
• Email coordinators (politely and concisely) if not listed, asking:
  • Whether they consider US citizen IMGs.
  • Whether they have absolute minimum Step score cutoffs.
• Use your school’s match data or alumni network to identify programs that have previously interviewed or matched US citizen IMGs, especially with similar board profiles.

3. Application Volume and Distribution

With a low Step 1 score or overall below average board scores, your strategy should be:

• EM-IM programs: Apply to all programs that do not explicitly rule you out by criteria. The total number is small enough that this is feasible.
• Categorical EM:
  • Focus on community-based or university-affiliated community programs known to consider IMGs.
  • Balance reach, realistic, and safety programs.
• Categorical IM:
  • Include a strong set of community IM programs, especially those accustomed to taking US citizen IMGs and Caribbean grads.

Application numbers are personal, but many US citizen IMGs with low scores target:

• 10–20 EM-IM / EM combined-style or EM-track programs (if interested in EM alone)
• 25–40 categorical EM programs (depending on competitiveness)
• 20–30 categorical IM programs as a safety net

Aim for quality over sheer volume, but err on the higher side if your scores are well below national averages or you have multiple attempts.

4. Strategic Use of Away Rotations / Auditions

For US citizen IMGs, audition rotations can be game-changers.

Priorities:

• Secure at least one US EM rotation that offers SLOEs.
• If possible, rotate at:
  • A site with an EM-IM program
  • Or a major teaching hospital with strong EM and IM connections

During your rotation:

• Be reliable, early, and prepared at every shift.
• Volunteer for procedures while respecting scope and supervision.
• Show interest in both EM and IM aspects (e.g., follow up on patients admitted from your ED).
• Ask for mid-rotation feedback and implement it.

Remember: your performance on these rotations can genuinely override initial concerns about a low Step score.

---

Acing Interviews and Communicating Your Value

If you secure EM-IM interviews, you’ve cleared a major hurdle. Low scores will still be in the background, but now the focus shifts to fit, maturity, and clarity of goals.

1. Anticipate Questions About Your Scores and Background

Common questions for a US citizen IMG with low scores:

• “I noticed a discrepancy between your Step scores and your clinical comments—can you talk about that?”
• “Tell me about a time you faced a significant academic or personal challenge.”
• “What did you change in your study or work habits after your early struggles?”

Prepare a short, non-defensive answer framework:

1. Briefly acknowledge the problem.
2. Offer concise context (if appropriate).
3. Emphasize what you changed and what you learned.
4. Point to improved outcomes: better shelves, Step 2, or strong evaluations.

Example:

“During Step 1 prep, I underestimated how much structured question-based practice I needed and I struggled with anxiety. My score was lower than what I’m capable of. After that, I worked with an academic counselor, created a rigorous UWorld schedule, and met weekly with a study coach. For Step 2 CK, I increased my practice scores by over 20 points, and my clinical rotations have been strong, especially in EM and IM, where attendings have commented on my clinical reasoning and reliability.”

2. Highlight Traits EM-IM Program Directors Want

On interview day, your task is to embody the traits that reassure PDs:

• Resilience: You’ve faced challenges and grown.
• Self-awareness: You know your strengths and limits.
• Work ethic: You’re ready for a 5-year combined program.
• Team orientation: You work well with nurses, co-residents, consultants.
• Communication skills: Clear, respectful, efficient.

Prepare examples that show:

• Managing multiple acutely ill patients in the ED.
• Following a complex patient from ED to the floor and reflecting on continuity.
• Participating in a QI project or system improvement effort.

3. Closing the Loop: Expressing Genuine Interest

EM-IM programs are small and want residents who are truly committed. Especially when matching with low scores, expressing interest meaningfully matters:

• Send specific, professional thank-you emails after interviews, referencing aspects of the program that resonate with your goals (e.g., ICU exposure, ED observation unit, research opportunities).
• If a program becomes your top choice, consider writing a clear but honest communication (while adhering to NRMP rules), such as:
  • “Your EM-IM program is my top choice, and I would be thrilled to train there,” if that is genuinely true.
• Avoid generic mass emails; authenticity is critical in small specialties.

---

FAQs: Low Step Score Strategies for US Citizen IMG in EM-IM

1. Can I realistically match EM-IM as a US citizen IMG with a low Step 1 score?

It’s possible but competitive. Your chances depend on:

• How low your scores are and whether there were failures
• How strong your Step 2 CK, clinical performance, and SLOEs are
• How targeted and realistic your program list is

Aim to maximize redemption signals (Step 2, SLOEs, clerkship honors) and apply broadly, including categorical EM and IM as parallel options.

2. Should I delay graduation or the Match to improve my chances?

Delaying can be reasonable if:

• You have not yet taken Step 2 CK and need focused time to significantly improve your score.
• You lack strong US clinical EM and IM rotations, especially SLOEs, and need an additional year to obtain them.

However, a delay without a clear, productive plan (research, rotations, exam prep) can create more questions. If you delay, make sure the added time leads to tangible improvements in your application.

3. How many EM-IM programs should I apply to if my scores are below average?

Since EM-IM programs are few, the usual advice is:

• Apply to every EM-IM program that:
  • Considers US citizen IMGs
  • Does not have strict score cutoffs that exclude you

Then supplement with a robust list of EM and/or IM programs where your profile fits. Use your school’s match history and alumni network to target IMG-friendly institutions.

4. Is it better to focus on categorical IM first and then try to transition to EM-IM later?

Transitioning into an EM-IM spot after starting IM is uncommon and uncertain. It’s more reliable to:

• Apply directly for EM-IM if that is your true goal.
• Also apply to categorical EM and IM as parallel tracks.

If you ultimately match in IM, you can still build an acute care–focused career (hospital medicine, ICU, urgent care) that overlaps significantly with EM practice. The key is to keep your core interest in acute care and complex internal medicine alive, even if the exact combined training doesn’t work out.

---

Being a US citizen IMG with below average board scores does not shut the door to a future in emergency medicine-internal medicine. It does mean you must be more deliberate, transparent, and strategic. By maximizing Step 2 performance, excelling in EM and IM rotations, securing strong SLOEs and letters, crafting a compelling EM-IM narrative, and building a broad but targeted program list, you can present yourself as a resilient, high-value candidate—numbers and all.