Choosing the Best Fellowship Programs in Emergency Medicine: A Guide

Evaluating fellowship programs in emergency medicine is one of the most strategic decisions you’ll make after residency. Whether you are pursuing ultrasound, critical care, administration, EMS, research, or another niche, the right fellowship can dramatically shape your skills, marketability, and long-term career satisfaction.

This guide walks you through a structured approach to assessing emergency medicine fellowship programs—how to compare them, what questions to ask, and how to decide which opportunities truly align with your goals.

---

Understanding the Role of Fellowships in Emergency Medicine

Before comparing programs, clarify why you’re pursuing fellowship at all and how it fits into your broader career path after emergency medicine residency.

Why EM Graduates Pursue Fellowships

Common reasons EM residents seek fellowship training include:

• Acquiring advanced technical or cognitive skills
  Examples:

  • Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS)
  • Resuscitation and critical care
  • Toxicology, EMS, or pediatric EM
  • Simulation and medical education

• Gaining a competitive edge in a crowded job market
  In many regions, having fellowship-level expertise can:

  • Distinguish you from other EM match graduates
  • Open doors to academic or leadership tracks
  • Support higher earning potential in certain niches (e.g., critical care, admin roles)

• Pursuing an academic or research-focused career
  Fellowships frequently:

  • Offer structured research time and mentorship
  • Provide resources for scholarly projects
  • Help you build a CV competitive for faculty roles

• Preparing for specific career settings
  For instance:

  • EMS fellowship for medical director roles
  • Wilderness or tactical EM for prehospital/field work
  • Administration/operations fellowships for ED leadership or system-level roles

Fellowship vs. Going Straight to Practice

Ask yourself:

• What will fellowship give me that I cannot realistically develop on my own in practice?
• Does my desired role (e.g., ICU attending, academic ultrasound director) truly require fellowship training?
• Am I willing to trade 1–2 years of attending-level income for additional training and potential long‑term benefits?

A clear understanding of your motivations will shape how you evaluate and compare fellowship programs—and help you focus your search on the best fellowship programs for your specific goals.

---

Step 1: Clarify Your Career Goals and Fellowship Focus

Before looking at specific programs, define what you want from your career and how fellowship fits in.

Identify Your Long-Term Career Vision

Think 5–10 years post-emergency medicine residency:

• Do you see yourself in:
  • Academic EM (clinical + teaching + research)?
  • Community practice with a niche focus (e.g., ultrasound director, ED operations)?
  • Critical care (mixed practice between ED and ICU)?
  • Leadership in hospital operations, quality/safety, or healthcare systems?
  • Prehospital / EMS or disaster medicine roles?
  • Special populations or environments, such as pediatric EM, wilderness medicine, or global health?

Write down specific goals, for example:

• “I want to be an academic ultrasound director at a tertiary care center.”
• “I want to split time between ICU and ED in a large teaching hospital.”
• “I want to be an EMS medical director for a large urban EMS system.”
• “I want to be a simulation and education leader in a residency program.”

Your long-term vision determines which type of fellowship is most appropriate and what program qualities are non‑negotiable.

Match Your Fellowship Type to Your Goals

Common EM fellowship categories include:

• Ultrasound / POCUS
• Emergency Medical Services (EMS)
• Medical Education / Simulation
• Pediatric Emergency Medicine (PEM)
• Critical Care (various tracks: IM-CCM, Anesthesia-CCM, Surgical CCM)
• Toxicology
• Global Health / International EM
• Administrative / Operations / Quality & Safety
• Research-focused fellowships
• Sports Medicine, Palliative Care, Wilderness/Tactical EM, and others

Each fellowship type offers different training environments, expectations, and career outcomes. For example:

• Critical care fellowships often require board eligibility through specific pathways (e.g., EM–CCM via internal medicine or anesthesia programs) and may place heavier emphasis on ICU time.
• Ultrasound fellowships are typically 1 year, heavily focused on scanning, teaching residents, and building a POCUS portfolio.
• EMS fellowships involve ride-alongs, system design, protocol development, and public safety collaborations.

Knowing your niche helps you narrow your search and conduct a meaningful fellowship program comparison.

---

Step 2: Core Criteria for Evaluating Fellowship Programs

Once you know your target fellowship type, you can systematically evaluate individual programs. Consider these domains:

1. Educational Structure and Curriculum

Review:

• Formal curriculum

  • Are there scheduled didactics specifically for fellows?
  • Is the curriculum written, structured, and updated regularly?
  • Are there clear expectations for clinical work, research, teaching, and administrative tasks?

• Accreditation and recognition

  • Is the fellowship accredited (e.g., ACGME or subspecialty society where applicable)?
  • If not accredited, does it follow national guidelines or recognized curricula (e.g., ACEP, SAEM resources)?
  • How do graduates fare in board/CAQ exams (if relevant)?

• Protected time

  • How much true non-clinical, protected time is provided?
  • Is it protected in practice—or often reclaimed by schedule gaps, call, or service needs?

Actionable tip: Ask current fellows, “What does a typical week look like for you—clinically and non-clinically?” Their answer will quickly reveal whether the curriculum is truly balanced as advertised.

2. Clinical Experience and Case Mix

Your fellowship should deepen, not dilute, your clinical skills. Analyze:

• Volume and acuity

  • Does the ED (or ICU/prehospital environment) have sufficient patient volume and high-acuity exposure?
  • For niche fellowships (PEM, EMS, toxicology, global health), does the program’s case mix align with your learning goals?

• Breadth of pathology

  • Are you seeing diverse patient populations (pediatric, geriatric, socioeconomically diverse)?
  • Are there specialized services (trauma center, transplant center, burn unit, ECMO, etc.) that enhance learning?

• Supervision and autonomy

  • Will you function mostly as a junior attending, as a fellow, or a mix?
  • In critical care or PEM, how autonomous are fellows in decision-making?

Example: In an ultrasound fellowship, ask:

• How many scans does the average fellow complete annually?
• Are fellows credentialed across multiple applications (cardiac, FAST, lung, vascular access, nerve blocks, advanced echo)?

3. Mentorship and Faculty Support

Strong mentorship is often the most important predictor of fellowship satisfaction and success.

Ask:

• Who will be your primary mentor(s)?

  • How many fellows are they already supervising?
  • Do they have time and interest in your specific niche (e.g., global ultrasound, ECMO, EMS research)?

• Mentor track record

  • Have prior fellows published, presented nationally, or moved into roles you aspire to?
  • Do faculty members hold regional or national leadership roles in your subspecialty?

• Culture of support

  • Are fellows encouraged to pursue independent ideas?
  • How approachable are faculty? This is often easiest to assess during interviews and informal socials.

Tip: During your interviews, ask current fellows, “Who do you go to when something big is on your mind—career-wise or project-wise?” Listen not only to who they name, but whether they sound genuinely supported.

4. Research and Scholarly Opportunities

For many emergency medicine physicians, fellowship is the main bridge into an academic career.

Consider:

• Research infrastructure

  • Is there a dedicated research office, coordinator, or statistician?
  • Are there ongoing projects where you can plug in and produce work quickly?

• Expectations

  • Are you required to complete a capstone project, manuscript, or quality improvement initiative?
  • Are conference presentations (SAEM, ACEP, SCCM, NAEMSP, AIUM, etc.) encouraged and funded?

• Output of prior fellows

  • Do former fellows have first-author publications?
  • Have they won grants, research awards, or society positions?

Actionable tip: Request a list of recent fellow publications and presentations. This is one of the clearest objective measures of scholarly productivity.

5. Career Outcomes and Alumni Network

How well does the fellowship help you launch the career you want?

Examine:

• Alumni job placements

  • Where are graduates working now?
  • Are they in roles that resemble your own goals (e.g., ED-ICU hybrid job, ultrasound director, EMS medical director)?

• Leadership roles

  • Have alumni become division chiefs, fellowship directors, residency program leaders, or system-level admins?

• Networking and society involvement

  • Are fellows and alumni connected through national societies (ACEP, SAEM, SCCM, NAEMSP, etc.)?
  • Does the program send fellows to national meetings annually?

If you’re choosing among “top” or best fellowship programs, their alumni track record is often what sets them apart.

---

Step 3: Comparing Programs Side-by-Side

Even among strong options, there can be significant differences. A structured fellowship program comparison will help you make a rational decision rather than relying on vague impressions.

Create a Comparison Grid

Build a spreadsheet or table with rows for each program and columns for:

• Location and setting
• Type and length of fellowship
• Clinical load (hours/week, night shifts, weekend frequency)
• Non-clinical / protected time
• Procedural or technical volume (e.g., scans per month, ICU procedures)
• Research expectations and support
• Salary and benefits
• Moonlighting opportunities
• Mentorship strength
• Alumni placements
• Program culture/fit (subjective, but important)

Scoring each category (e.g., 1–5) can help clarify trade-offs between programs.

Weighing Clinical Load and Protected Time

A common pitfall: choosing a fellowship that feels more like a busy attending job with minimal added training.

Ask each program:

• How many clinical hours per month are required?
• What is the ratio of EM vs. specialty rotations (e.g., ICU rotations in CC fellowship, field vs. ED shifts in EMS fellowship)?
• When and how is protected time scheduled?

If Program A offers:

• 16–18 EM shifts per month, very limited research infrastructure
  and Program B offers:
• 8–10 shifts per month, dedicated research support, and robust mentorship

Program B may be better aligned with your academic career goals, even if A’s salary is higher.

Evaluating Financial and Lifestyle Considerations

Fellowship comes with significant financial opportunity cost. Consider:

• Stipend/salary

  • Is the salary PGY-4/PGY-5 level or closer to junior attending range?

• Moonlighting

  • Are fellows allowed to moonlight?
  • Are there internal opportunities within the system?
  • How tightly is moonlighting balanced against burnout and education?

• Cost of living

  • A lower-salary fellowship in a low-cost city may be more livable than a higher salary in a high-cost area.

• Work–life balance

  • Are schedules predictable enough to maintain relationships, family, and personal health?
  • Consider commute times and call responsibilities (especially in critical care, EMS, and toxicology).

---

Step 4: Program Culture, Fit, and Hidden Factors

Numbers, curricula, and prestige matter, but day-to-day experience is largely determined by culture and interpersonal dynamics.

Assessing Program Culture

During your interview and visit, look for:

• How fellows and residents interact with faculty

  • Is there psychological safety—do people feel comfortable asking questions and admitting uncertainty?
  • Do faculty seem burned out or genuinely engaged?

• Respect for fellow roles

  • Are you treated as cheap labor or as a developing subspecialist?
  • Are your educational needs prioritized during rotations?

• Interdepartmental relationships

  • In critical care fellowships, how do EM fellows fit into medicine or anesthesia-led ICUs?
  • In EMS, how is the relationship between EMS medical directors, EMTs/paramedics, and the ED?

Ask fellows and residents privately:

• “What would you change about this program if you could?”
• “How has the program responded when fellows raise concerns?”

Hidden Red Flags

Be attentive to:

• High fellow turnover or unfilled positions
  • A pattern of fellows leaving early or not renewing can be a warning sign.
• Over-reliance on fellows for service work
  • If fellows are shouldering disproportionate night shifts or “scutwork,” educational value may suffer.
• Lack of transparency
  • Evasive answers about clinical hours, moonlighting, or recent ACGME reviews should prompt further scrutiny.

Geographic and Personal Considerations

While not strictly academic, location and personal life constraints matter significantly:

• Are you or your partner tied to a specific region?
• Does the location offer the community, schools, or environment you want for the next 1–2 years?
• Will being closer to (or farther from) family support your well-being?

For many applicants, these “soft factors” are the tiebreaker between otherwise comparable programs.

---

Step 5: Application Strategy and Interview Approach

Once you’ve evaluated and identified target programs, align your application strategy with your strengths and goals.

Positioning Your Application After the EM Match

Your emergency medicine residency and EM match record demonstrate your baseline training. Fellowship programs will particularly focus on:

• Evidence of commitment to the subspecialty:
  • Electives, scholarly work, QI projects, leadership roles
• Letters of recommendation from subspecialty mentors
• Fit between your stated goals and what the program offers

Actions you can take before applying:

• Seek out related rotations or electives (e.g., ICU months, EMS week, ultrasound elective).
• Get involved in a small project or case series within your intended fellowship area.
• Attend national subspecialty meetings or section meetings (US, EMS, CC, etc.) if possible.

Key Questions to Ask on Interview Day

Prepare thoughtful, specific questions such as:

About curriculum and experience

• “What distinguishes your emergency medicine residency graduates who go through this fellowship from those who don’t?”
• “How has the fellowship curriculum evolved over the last few years in response to feedback?”

About mentorship and career outcomes

• “Can you tell me about where your last 5 fellows are now practicing?”
• “How do you match fellows with mentors, especially if interests diverge from the main program focus?”

About lifestyle and culture

• “How flexible is the schedule when significant personal events arise?”
• “What does the program do to support fellow wellness and prevent burnout?”

Having a consistent question set also helps you compare responses across programs.

Post-Interview Reflections

After each interview, document:

• Your gut reaction to the people and culture
• Concrete pros and cons
• Any lingering concerns or unanswered questions
• How well the program aligns with your top 3–5 career priorities

Revisit these notes before finalizing your rank list of fellowship offers.

---

Step 6: Special Considerations by Fellowship Type

Different EM fellowships have unique nuances you should include in your evaluation.

Ultrasound Fellowship

Focus on:

• Scan volumes and diversity (ED, ICU, procedural guidance, advanced echo)
• Role in resident and medical student education
• Opportunities to lead POCUS curriculum, workshops, or regional courses
• Access to advanced machines, handheld devices, and archiving software
• Pathways to credentialing and leadership positions post-fellowship

Critical Care Fellowship

Pay special attention to:

• Board eligibility pathway (IM-CCM, Anesthesia-CCM, Surgical CCM, etc.)
• ICU environments (medical, surgical, neuro, cardiac) and EM fellow integration
• Opportunities to maintain emergency department skills during training
• Post-fellowship hybrid ED–ICU job placement history
• Program culture toward EM-trained intensivists (especially in historically IM- or anesthesia-dominant environments)

EMS Fellowship

Evaluate:

• Size and complexity of EMS system(s) covered
• Opportunities for:
  • On-scene responses
  • Protocol development
  • QA/QI processes
  • Disaster planning and MCI drills
• Relationship with fire/police and municipal agencies
• Leadership roles graduates have obtained (e.g., agency medical directors)

Education/Simulation Fellowship

Consider:

• Formal training in education (e.g., certificate in medical education, master’s degree options)
• Simulation center capabilities and access
• Teaching responsibilities in the emergency medicine residency and medical school
• Support for educational research and curriculum design projects
• Outcomes of graduates in academic positions

Across all types, continually ask: “Does this program provide the training and network I need to get to my envisioned job in 5–10 years?”

---

Putting It All Together: Making Your Final Decision

When you reach the point of choosing among offers, revisit these fundamental questions:

1. Does this fellowship clearly advance my long-term career goals?
   Not just “Is this a great program?” but “Is this the right program for me?”

2. Will I have strong mentorship and support?
   This often matters more than prestige or name recognition.

3. Is the balance between clinical work, education, and scholarly activity appropriate?
   Beware of “fellowship in name only” positions that overemphasize service.

4. Does the program’s track record of alumni outcomes match what I want to do?
   Your likely trajectory will resemble that of recent graduates.

5. Can I realistically thrive—professionally and personally—in this location and culture for the next 1–2 years?

While many residents are anxious to secure what they perceive as the “best fellowship programs,” the optimal choice is the one that combines rigorous training, a supportive environment, and a clear bridge to your desired career.

---

FAQs About Evaluating Emergency Medicine Fellowship Programs

How many programs should I apply to for an EM fellowship?

It depends on the competitiveness of your chosen subspecialty and the strength of your application. Many applicants target 5–10 programs in more niche areas (e.g., ultrasound, EMS, education) and more in highly competitive fields (e.g., certain critical care pathways, top-tier PEM or toxicology programs). Consider casting a wider net if your geographic constraints are narrow or your CV is less robust.

Do I need a fellowship to have a successful EM career?

No. Many emergency physicians have highly satisfying careers without fellowship training. Fellowship is most valuable if you:

• Want a defined niche (e.g., ultrasound director, EMS medical director, intensivist)
• Aspire to an academic or research-heavy role
• Need additional training for a specific practice environment (e.g., ICU, PEM)

If your goals center on broad-based clinical emergency medicine in community practice, fellowship is optional, not mandatory.

How important is program prestige when choosing a fellowship?

Prestige can help with networking and early academic opportunities, but it is not the single deciding factor. Mentorship quality, program culture, and alignment with your goals usually matter more. A less “famous” program with strong mentorship and tailored opportunities can be a better choice than a big-name institution where you feel like surplus labor or lack support.

When should I start preparing for fellowship applications during residency?

Ideally:

• PGY-1/early PGY-2: Explore interests, do elective rotations in potential fellowship areas, attend related conferences or local meetings.
• Mid–late PGY-2: Narrow to 1–2 subspecialty interests, start small scholarly or QI projects, identify mentors.
• Early PGY-3 (or final year): Finalize CV, secure letters of recommendation, apply to programs according to their timelines.

Planning ahead allows you to build a cohesive narrative and demonstrate genuine commitment to your chosen field.

---

By taking a structured, reflective approach to evaluating emergency medicine fellowship programs—rather than chasing prestige or defaulting to the most convenient option—you position yourself for a career that is both impactful and personally fulfilling. Use the criteria and strategies in this guide to clarify your priorities, compare programs objectively, and confidently choose the fellowship that best supports your future.