Essential Guide to Physician Contract Negotiation in Family Medicine

Physician contract negotiation is one of the most consequential steps you will take as you transition from family medicine residency to your first attending role—and again each time you change jobs or renew an agreement. Your choices now can impact your income, schedule, geographic freedom, and even your long‑term career satisfaction.

This guide walks you through how to approach physician contract negotiation in family medicine with the same intentionality and thoroughness you bring to patient care.

---

Understanding the Landscape: Why Family Medicine Contracts Are Unique

Family medicine occupies a distinctive place in the healthcare system. That reality shapes how your contracts are written and what leverage you have in negotiation.

The current environment in family medicine

A few big themes influence the family medicine residency to attending transition and the FM match pipeline:

• High demand for primary care in most regions, especially non-urban and suburban areas
• Growing use of value-based care (quality metrics, panel size, risk contracts)
• Expanded care settings: outpatient clinics, urgent care, FQHCs, rural health clinics, academic centers, concierge models, telemedicine
• Increased use of advanced practice providers (APPs) and team-based care

These factors generally work in your favor: employers need family physicians. That increases your negotiating leverage—if you use it strategically.

Common employment models in family medicine

Understanding who employs you helps predict your contract structure, compensation, and flexibility:

1. Hospital-employed / health system-employed

   • Often standardized contracts, less flexibility on base terms
   • RVU-based productivity is common
   • Robust benefits and infrastructure, but sometimes more bureaucracy
   • Non-competes and call requirements can be significant

2. Large multispecialty or primary care groups

   • More likely to have productivity and/or partnership tracks
   • Some flexibility in customizing schedules and roles
   • Compensation may include quality and patient satisfaction incentives

3. Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) / Community health centers

   • Often mission-driven, may qualify for loan repayment (NHSC, state programs)
   • Salaries can be lower than private systems, but benefits and loan forgiveness may offset
   • Non-competes may be more lenient or absent
   • Emphasis on underserved populations and broader scope of practice

4. Academic family medicine

   • Lower base salary than private systems but more stability and defined career ladders
   • Emphasis on teaching, research, curriculum design, and leadership
   • Protected time for non-clinical work is a key part of negotiation

5. Independent or small group private practice

   • Greater flexibility and entrepreneurial opportunity
   • May have partnership options or buy-in tracks
   • Income can be more variable; you may shoulder more financial risk

Your negotiation strategy should be tailored to the structure and incentives of the setting you’re considering.

---

Core Components of a Family Medicine Employment Contract

Before you can negotiate, you need to know what, exactly, you’re negotiating. A thorough employment contract review focuses on the following components.

1. Job description and clinical expectations

Scope of practice should be explicit:

• Outpatient only, or any inpatient, OB, or newborn care expectations?
• Telemedicine, urgent care, nursing homes, or home visits?
• Expected procedures (e.g., joint injections, skin procedures, IUD insertion, vasectomy)?
• Supervision of NPs or PAs, including signing off charts and collaborative agreements

Look for clarity on:

• Clinic sessions per week (e.g., 8–10 half-day sessions)
• Expected patient volume (e.g., 18–22 patients/day vs 24–28+)
• New vs established patient mix
• Expectations around quality metrics, patient satisfaction scores, and care management tasks (inbox, refills, portal messages)

Actionable tip: Push for specific language:

• Instead of “full-time schedule with reasonable productivity,” ask for:
  • “Ten half-day clinic sessions/week, with a target of 18–22 patients per day during the first year, increasing only by mutual agreement.”

2. Compensation structure

A family medicine attending salary negotiation is not just about the base number. You need to understand how the entire compensation package works.

Typical components:

• Base salary: Guaranteed amount, often for the first 1–2 years
• Productivity: Commonly measured by RVUs (wRVUs) or collections
• Quality incentives: Tied to metrics like preventive care, chronic disease management, readmissions
• Signing bonus: Upfront incentive to join
• Relocation assistance: Often structured as a forgivable loan
• Loan repayment: From employer, external programs (NHSC), or both

For family medicine:

• New graduates in many regions see guaranteed base salaries plus later transition to RVU or hybrid models.
• Rural and underserved areas may offer higher initial salary, large signing bonuses, or more generous loan repayment.

Key questions to ask:

• What is the expected total compensation at 1, 2, and 3 years, based on average performance of current physicians?
• What are the RVU or productivity targets, and what happens if you don’t meet them?
• Are there ramp-up protections during the first 6–12 months when your panel is building?
• Are quality bonus metrics accessible and realistically achievable in your setting?

---

3. Schedule, call, and work–life balance

In family medicine, your schedule and call responsibilities are as important as your salary.

Elements to clarify:

• Clinic hours and days (evenings? weekends?)
• Start/stop times, time blocked for admin work, lunch breaks
• Call structure:
  • Telephone only vs in-person
  • Frequency (e.g., 1:6, 1:8, or covering an entire group)
  • Whether call is paid or included in salary
  • Inpatient call vs outpatient call
• Expectations for same-day slots, walk-ins, or urgent care coverage
• Holiday coverage and how it is rotated

Actionable tip: Ask for your sample weekly schedule in writing along with clinic templates. You want to know:

• How many 15-min or 20-min slots you’ll have
• Whether you have protected time for inbox, labs, and refills
• Whether precepting residents or teaching students replaces, not adds to, your clinical load

4. Benefits and professional support

Beyond salary, benefits can substantially impact your overall value and quality of life:

• Health, dental, and vision insurance (premiums, deductibles, family coverage)
• Retirement plans (401k/403b match, pension, vesting schedule)
• Disability and life insurance
• Malpractice insurance: occurrence vs claims-made; who pays for tail coverage?
• CME allowance and time: typical for FM is 3–5 days/year and $2,000–$4,000
• Licensing fees, board certification fees, professional memberships
• Parental leave, FMLA, and other forms of paid leave
• Support staff: ratio of MAs/RNs per physician, scribes, care coordinators, behavioral health integration

Strong support staff and integrated care teams can make a 20-patient day feel manageable, whereas poor support can make a 16-patient day feel crushing.

5. Restrictive covenants: Non-compete and non-solicitation

Non-compete clauses can significantly affect your future options, especially if you want to stay in the same city or region.

Review carefully:

• Geographic radius (e.g., 5–20 miles)
• Duration (e.g., 12–24 months)
• Scope (all clinical work vs just primary care vs specific sites)
• Whether it applies to telemedicine, urgent care, or other roles
• Whether non-compete still applies if you are terminated without cause

For family medicine physicians, a wide non-compete in a metro area may effectively lock you out of most viable primary care jobs.

Actionable tip: A common negotiation goal is to:

• Narrow the radius
• Shorten the duration
• Limit the restriction to specific clinic locations you actually worked in
• Exempt termination without cause from triggering the non-compete

---

A Step-by-Step Strategy for Physician Contract Negotiation

Negotiation is a skill that can be learned. You don’t need to be confrontational; you do need to be prepared, clear, and confident.

Step 1: Do your homework

Before entering negotiations, anchor yourself in real market data:

• Use MGMA or other compensation reports if available (often via mentors or your employer’s HR disclosures).
• Talk to recent graduates of your family medicine residency about their offers.
• Connect with colleagues at local systems to understand:
  • Typical base salary ranges
  • Common RVU targets
  • Call coverage norms
  • Sign-on bonuses and loan repayment amounts

Consider:

• Cost of living in that region
• Urban vs rural differences
• Competition among employers (more competition = more leverage)

Step 2: Clarify your priorities

You rarely get everything you want. Decide what matters most:

Common priorities for new family physicians:

• Minimum acceptable base salary or total compensation
• Schedule and maximum clinic hours or patient volume
• Geographic flexibility (therefore minimized non-compete)
• Loan repayment vs higher salary
• Protected time for teaching, leadership, or procedures
• Path to partnership, leadership, or academic promotion

Rank your “must haves,” “strong wants,” and “nice to haves.” This helps you make tradeoffs intentionally instead of on the spot.

Step 3: Get a professional employment contract review

Given the complexity and long-term consequences, consider a physician contract review by:

• A healthcare attorney experienced in physician contracts
• A physician-focused contract review service

They can help you:

• Identify red flags (e.g., overly broad non-compete, one-sided termination clauses)
• Translate legal language into practical implications
• Suggest specific alternative wording or clauses

This is particularly important for physician contract negotiation involving:

• Complex productivity models
• Ownership or partnership tracks
• Equity or profit-sharing
• Unique call or coverage arrangements

The cost is often a fraction of the revenue difference you can gain by negotiating effectively.

---

Step 4: Approach the conversation strategically

When the initial offer arrives:

1. Express appreciation and enthusiasm for the opportunity, if you’re genuinely interested.
2. Ask for time (typically 7–14 days) to review the contract with an advisor.
3. Prepare a concise list of 3–6 specific points you want to negotiate.

How to phrase requests constructively:

• Instead of: “This salary is too low.”
• Try: “Based on my research on family medicine compensation in this region, including MGMA benchmarks and discussions with colleagues, I was expecting a base in the range of X–Y. Is there flexibility to adjust the base salary closer to that range, or to enhance the sign-on bonus or loan repayment to make the total package more competitive?”

Focus on:

• Data and norms, not emotion
• Your value and fit with their needs
• Long-term relationship, not a one-time win

Step 5: Negotiate beyond just the number

Especially in family medicine, you can often improve non-salary terms that dramatically affect your daily life:

Examples:

• Lower panel size targets or reduced daily patient caps
• Extended ramp-up period with guaranteed salary while panel builds
• Commitment to scribe support after reaching a defined volume threshold
• Additional CME funds for procedures you’ll bring to the practice
• Defined protected time for quality improvement, leadership, or teaching
• Narrowed non-compete radius and term
• Clear documentation that telemedicine outside of their patients is allowed if it doesn’t conflict with your schedule

Family medicine physicians frequently underestimate the long-term benefit of negotiating for realistic workload and professional development time.

Step 6: Get all changes in writing

Verbal assurances are not enough. Any change you negotiate must:

• Be reflected in the final written contract or an amendment
• Be specific (numbers, timelines, conditions)
• Match what you understand before you sign

Examples of details to get in writing:

• “Quality bonus targets will not be applied for the first 12 months of employment.”
• “Non-compete will be limited to a 5-mile radius from the primary clinic site and will not apply in the event of termination without cause.”
• “Physician will receive 0.1 FTE of protected administrative time each week for quality improvement work, during which no clinic sessions will be scheduled.”

---

Critical Red Flags in Family Medicine Contracts

While not all problematic clauses are deal-breakers, some should trigger serious reconsideration or more intensive negotiation.

1. Vague or open-ended workload expectations

Red flags:

• “Full-time schedule as determined by employer”
• “Reasonable call” without defining frequency or compensation
• “Productivity as consistent with other physicians” without stating actual RVU or visit targets

Why it matters: This can lead to scope creep—more sessions, more call, more inbox work—with no additional compensation.

2. One-sided termination clauses

• Without cause termination allowed only by the employer, not the physician
• Extremely long notice periods (e.g., 180 days) for you but not for them
• Automatic penalties for leaving early without prorated forgiveness

You want the ability to exit a bad fit without being trapped for years.

A more balanced structure:

• Both parties can terminate without cause with equal notice (e.g., 60–90 days)
• Any sign-on or relocation bonus structured as a forgivable loan that prorates over time (e.g., forgiven monthly over 24–36 months)

3. Broad non-compete restrictions

Especially concerning:

• Large radius (e.g., 25+ miles) in a dense metro area
• Multi-year duration (over 24 months)
• Applies to any practice of medicine, not just family medicine
• Still applies even if you are terminated without cause

Discuss with your attorney whether these are enforceable in your state and negotiate reductions.

4. Unclear malpractice and tail coverage provisions

Major risk points:

• Claims-made policy with no clear statement on who pays for tail coverage
• Tail responsibility placed entirely on you, even if they terminate you without cause

Tail coverage can cost tens of thousands of dollars. Clarify:

• Type of malpractice coverage (occurrence vs claims-made)
• Who pays for tail coverage and under what circumstances

5. Unrealistic productivity expectations

Be wary if:

• RVU target is above the national median for family medicine without strong support and ramp-up period
• Compensation heavily relies on productivity without guaranteed base during the first year
• You’re joining a practice with chronic access issues, high turnover, or limited support staff

Ask to see:

• Turnover rates
• How many physicians have met the productivity targets over the last 2–3 years
• Typical time to full panel for new physicians

---

Case Examples: Applying These Principles in Real Scenarios

Case 1: New graduate in a suburban health system

A PGY-3 finishing family medicine residency receives an offer:

• $215,000 base for two years, then RVU-based
• 10 half-day sessions/week, 22–24 patients/day expected
• 1:5 telephone call, unpaid
• 25-mile, 24-month non-compete
• $20,000 sign-on bonus, $10,000 relocation (forgivable over 3 years)

They negotiate:

• Present compensation data suggesting $230,000 base is more consistent with local FM rates.
• Ask to reduce daily patient expectation to 18–20 during first 12 months, with ramp-up to higher numbers only if mutually agreed.
• Request that call be limited to 1:7 and include modest additional compensation or reduced clinic the following day.
• Push to narrow non-compete to 10 miles and 12 months, and apply only if they voluntarily leave within 2 years.

Outcome:

• Employer agrees to $225,000 base, reduces non-compete to 10 miles and 18 months, and grants an 18–20 patient/day expectation for the first year with written language.
• No change to call compensation, but schedule after call is slightly lighter.

This physician has improved both financial and lifestyle terms without alienating the employer.

Case 2: Mission-driven FQHC offer

Another graduate is passionate about underserved care:

• Offer: $200,000 salary, 8 clinic sessions/week, 16–18 patients/day
• $5,000 CME, strong team-based care, on-site behavioral health
• Eligible for NHSC loan repayment (~$50,000 over 2 years)
• No non-compete

They negotiate:

• Ask for protected half-day/month for QI project leadership.
• Request modest increase in salary or an extra $5,000 in loan repayment support from the employer.

Outcome:

• Salary unchanged, but FQHC offers 0.1 FTE protected admin time and agrees to help with NHSC application and provide additional $5,000 employer-sponsored loan repayment annually.

Here, the physician prioritizes mission, loan repayment, and sustainable workload over chasing the highest possible base salary.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. When should I start thinking about physician contract negotiation during residency?

Ideally start:

• Late PGY-2 / early PGY-3: Clarify your goals (location, practice type, schedule).
• 6–12 months before graduation: Begin interviewing and gathering offers.

This timeline gives you room to:

• Compare multiple offers
• Conduct a thorough employment contract review
• Negotiate without feeling pressured to accept the first option

2. Is it normal to negotiate as a new family medicine graduate, or will I seem difficult?

Negotiation is expected. Most employers, especially hospitals and large groups, anticipate a physician contract negotiation phase. They may not move dramatically on base salary, but:

• Many will adjust sign-on bonus, loan repayment, schedule details, or non-compete terms.
• You will not seem “difficult” if you are professional, data-driven, and respectful.

Framing your requests around long-term fit and sustainability (rather than entitlement) is key.

3. Do I really need a lawyer to review my contract?

It’s not mandatory, but it’s strongly recommended, especially for your first job. A small investment in a professional employment contract review can:

• Identify serious red flags you might miss
• Suggest alternative language to protect you
• Clarify your obligations if you leave

If cost is a concern, prioritize a review for more complex contracts (RVU-heavy, partnership tracks, or restrictive non-competes). Some state medical societies or alumni networks may offer discounted or vetted services.

4. How does RVU-based compensation work in family medicine?

RVU (Relative Value Unit) compensation ties part of your pay to the “value” of services you bill:

• Each visit or procedure has an assigned wRVU.
• Your contract might guarantee a base salary plus a bonus for RVUs above a threshold, or fully shift to RVU-based pay after 1–2 years.

Critical questions:

• What is the RVU target, and how does it compare to national benchmarks?
• What is the conversion factor (dollars per RVU)?
• Are there ramp-up protections while you build your panel?
• What support exists (scribes, care managers) to sustain the volume required?

For family medicine, RVU targets should be realistic and supported by adequate staffing and scheduling.

---

Navigating physician contract negotiation in family medicine is not about squeezing every last dollar from an employer; it’s about crafting a sustainable, fair, and fulfilling practice environment. By understanding the key elements of contracts, doing your homework, seeking expert review, and negotiating thoughtfully, you set a strong foundation for a long, satisfying career as a family physician.