Mastering Physician Contract Negotiation in Emergency Medicine: A Guide

Physician contract negotiation is one of the most consequential steps you’ll take as you transition from residency to independent practice in emergency medicine. The EM match may determine where you train, but your first attending contract will shape how you live, practice, and grow over the next several years—and often far beyond that.

This guide is designed for EM residents, fellows, and early-career attendings who want a clear, practical roadmap for understanding and negotiating physician contracts in emergency medicine. We’ll cover not only salary, but also schedule, liability, restrictive covenants, and the less obvious details that make or break job satisfaction.

---

Understanding the Landscape: EM Jobs and Contract Types

Before you can negotiate effectively, you need to understand what you’re actually being offered. Emergency medicine employment structures are more varied than many other specialties.

Common Practice Models in Emergency Medicine

1. Hospital-employed model

   • You are an employee of a hospital or health system.
   • Often W-2 employment, with institutional benefits (health insurance, retirement, CME, etc.).
   • May have more bureaucracy but potentially more stability and robust benefits.
   • You may be covered under the hospital’s malpractice policy.

2. Democratic/physician-owned group (independent group practice)

   • Group of EM physicians contracts with a hospital to staff the ED.
   • Possible partnership track, often 1–3 years as an employee before becoming an owner.
   • Income can be higher once a partner; more control over scheduling and departmental decisions.
   • More variability in governance and transparency—you must ask detailed questions.

3. Corporate/Contract Management Group (CMG)

   • Large national or regional company contracts with hospitals to staff EDs.
   • Typically W-2 or 1099 arrangements; benefits vary widely.
   • Often more standardized contracts; less individual negotiation room, but still possible around certain terms (schedule, sign-on, location, etc.).
   • May involve multiple hospital sites under one employer.

4. Academic emergency medicine

   • Employed by a university or academic medical center.
   • Lower base salary compared to many community jobs, but with:
     • Teaching and research opportunities
     • Academic titles and promotion tracks
     • Potential protected time for education/research
   • Compensation may include incentives tied to RVUs, teaching, or research productivity.

5. Locums tenens

   • You work as an independent contractor (usually 1099) at multiple sites for temporary assignments.
   • Higher hourly rate, but no typical benefits; you handle your own taxes, retirement, disability, and malpractice (sometimes provided by the locums company).
   • Excellent for flexibility or testing different practice environments.

Common Contract Structures

• W-2 employee

  • Taxes withheld by employer.
  • Employer provides benefits (health, retirement match, CME, etc.).
  • Often eligible for unemployment, worker’s comp.
  • More straightforward for new graduates.

• 1099 independent contractor

  • You receive gross pay with no taxes withheld.
  • Must pay your own self-employment taxes and manage quarterly estimates.
  • Need to arrange your own benefits (health insurance, retirement, disability).
  • Often higher hourly pay but with higher personal administrative and financial burden.

Understanding whether your “offer” is W-2 vs 1099, and how that interacts with your goals, is essential before starting any physician contract negotiation.

---

Core Components of an Emergency Medicine Contract

An employment contract review should focus on more than just the advertised hourly rate. EM work is intense and shift-based; many quality-of-life issues are buried in the fine print.

1. Compensation: Base, Productivity, and Incentives

Key elements:

• Base pay

  • For EM, this is often quoted as:
    • Hourly rate (e.g., $230/hr)
    • Annual salary for a defined number of clinical hours (e.g., $380,000 for 1,400 clinical hours/year)
  • Confirm:
    • Expected number of hours or shifts per month
    • Whether this is guaranteed or subject to change

• Productivity-based compensation

  • Commonly RVU-based, patient-per-hour, or collections-based.
  • Ask:
    • What is the RVU rate?
    • What is the average RVU/hour for current physicians?
    • Is there a guaranteed minimum during your first year?
  • In busy EDs, productivity can significantly augment your income—but high volume may also mean higher burnout risk.

• Shift differentials and premiums

  • Nights, weekends, and holidays may pay more.
  • Examples:
    • +$10–$20/hour for nights
    • Holiday premiums or bonus pay
  • Confirm whether these are written into the contract or “subject to change.”

• Bonuses

  • Sign-on bonus: May be paid upfront or in installments. Pay attention to “repayment obligations” if you leave early.
  • Quality/metric bonus: Based on door-to-doc time, left-without-being-seen rate, patient satisfaction, etc.
  • Retention bonus: Paid for staying a certain number of years.

Negotiation tip: When comparing offers, normalize to an effective hourly rate:
Total annual compensation (salary + average bonus) ÷ total expected clinical hours.

This gives you a more realistic comparison and helps in attending salary negotiation across different structures.

2. Clinical Hours, Shifts, and Scheduling

Scheduling terms are especially critical in emergency medicine.

Key points to clarify:

• Number of clinical hours/month or year

  • New graduates may see “1.0 FTE” defined as 12–14 shifts/month of 8–12 hours each.
  • A 1.0 FTE can mean:
    • 12 x 12-hour shifts (144 hrs/month), or
    • 16 x 8-hour shifts (128 hrs/month).
  • Small differences add up to major lifestyle and compensation impact.

• Shift length and mix

  • 8-, 9-, 10-, or 12-hour shifts.
  • Are there swing shifts or fast-track shifts?
  • Do you have different responsibilities (e.g., only fast track vs main ED)?

• Nights, weekends, and holidays

  • How many nights per month?
  • Any caps on consecutive night shifts?
  • Holiday coverage expectations (major vs minor holidays, rotating systems).

• Scheduling flexibility

  • Self-scheduling vs scheduler-controlled.
  • Advance notice: Do you submit preferences 1–2 months ahead?
  • Ability to trade shifts with colleagues.

• Protected non-clinical time

  • For academic EM: protected time for teaching, administration, research.
  • For leadership roles: dedicated administrative hours (paid or unpaid).

Red flag: Vague language like “typical schedule consistent with departmental needs” without numeric caps can lead to unpredictable workloads. Ask for specific ranges written into the contract or at least into an accompanying offer letter.

---

Risk, Liability, and Restrictive Covenants

Emergency medicine carries unique medicolegal and career-mobility considerations. Thoughtful employment contract review should always include these elements.

1. Malpractice Coverage and Tail Insurance

Questions to ask:

• What type of malpractice policy is provided?

  • Claims-made: Covers you only while the policy is active. When you leave, you typically need tail coverage to protect against future claims for past care.
  • Occurrence: Covers any event that occurred during the policy period, regardless of when the claim is filed. No tail needed.

• Who pays for tail coverage if needed?

  • Tail insurance can cost 150–250% of the annual premium—easily tens of thousands of dollars.
  • Possibilities:
    • Employer fully pays tail (ideal).
    • Cost shared (e.g., prorated by years of service).
    • Physician fully responsible (least favorable upon departure).
  • Confirm in writing who is responsible and under what circumstance.

• Coverage limits

  • Typical EM malpractice limits might be $1 million per claim / $3 million aggregate, but this varies.
  • Ensure limits are adequate for your region and setting.

Negotiation angle: If an employer will not budge on salary, ask if they will cover tail coverage or increase malpractice limits as part of your physician contract negotiation.

2. Non-Compete Clauses (Restrictive Covenants)

Non-competes can significantly restrict where you can practice if you leave.

Common features:

• Geographic radius

  • e.g., 10–30 miles from your primary practice site or any site within the group.
  • For EM, this can effectively remove every ED in an entire metro area.

• Duration

  • Frequently 1–2 years post-employment.

• Scope

  • Restricting your ability to practice emergency medicine, urgent care, telemedicine, or even related fields.

Considerations in EM:

• If you’re training or moving to a city where you have long-term roots (family, spouse’s job, kids in school), a strict non-compete may be unacceptable.
• Some states limit or ban physician non-competes altogether, but enforcement varies and the legal landscape changes—especially with recent regulatory attention. Always check current state law with a healthcare attorney.

Negotiation strategies:

• Reduce geographic radius.
• Limit the number of sites covered (e.g., only the primary ED, not every hospital under the corporate umbrella).
• Shorten the duration.
• Narrow the scope (e.g., noncompete applies only to full-time EM practice, not urgent care or telehealth).
• Ask to remove the non-compete entirely if you’re joining a rural or hard-to-recruit area.

3. Termination Provisions: How You Can Leave—and How They Can Fire You

Termination clauses deserve careful scrutiny.

Types of termination:

• Without cause termination

  • Either party can end the agreement with notice (e.g., 60–90 days).
  • This is critical protection for you; avoid contracts that only allow the employer to terminate without cause.
  • Confirm whether any repayment obligations (sign-on bonus, relocation) are triggered.

• With cause termination

  • Usually for:
    • Loss of licensure or DEA registration
    • Exclusion from Medicare/Medicaid
    • Gross misconduct, fraud, or criminal activity
  • Ensure “cause” is defined clearly, not vaguely (“behavior detrimental to the group”).

• Automatic termination triggers

  • Loss of hospital privileges
  • Termination of the group’s contract with the hospital (very relevant in EM where contracts change hands)

Key questions:

• What happens if the group loses the ED staffing contract?
• Are you guaranteed employment with the incoming group?
• Is there severance pay for sudden contract loss?

Red flag: One-sided termination clauses (employer can terminate you at will, but you have no right to leave without cause) or extremely short notice periods that disrupt continuity of income.

---

Benefits, Career Growth, and Quality-of-Life Terms

Beyond pay and liability, your contract should support a sustainable, rewarding career in emergency medicine.

1. Benefits Package

Compare benefits carefully between offers; a higher salary with poor benefits may be worse than a slightly lower salary with robust benefits.

Common benefit components:

• Health, dental, vision insurance

  • Employer vs employee premium share.
  • Family coverage costs.

• Retirement plans

  • 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b).
  • Employer match or profit-sharing (e.g., 4–10% of salary).
  • Waiting periods before becoming eligible.

• Disability insurance

  • EM is physically and cognitively demanding; own-occupation disability is valuable.
  • Clarify whether coverage is short-term, long-term, and whether you should supplement individually.

• Life insurance

  • Typically 1–2x salary; may be minimal.

• CME and licensing

  • Annual CME allowance (e.g., $2,000–$5,000).
  • Paid CME days.
  • Coverage for:
    • State licenses
    • DEA fees
    • Board certification and recertification
    • Society memberships (ACEP, SAEM, etc.)

• Relocation assistance

  • Direct payment vs reimbursement.
  • Repayment obligations if you leave before a specified time.

2. Career Development and Academic Opportunities

Especially important if you’re interested in leadership, education, or research:

• Leadership pathways

  • Is there a path to medical director, assistant director, or committee roles?
  • Is leadership training or mentorship offered?

• Teaching opportunities

  • For community sites with EM residency programs, clarify:
    • Teaching responsibilities
    • Protected time
    • Any teaching stipends

• Research support (for academic EM)

  • Protected research time.
  • Access to statisticians, IRB support, and grant offices.

3. Workplace Environment and Support

Many contract elements indirectly speak to your day-to-day work life:

• APP coverage

  • How many PAs/NPs cover each shift?
  • How is supervision structured?
  • Are you responsible for signing all charts?

• Scribe or documentation support

  • Scribe availability can significantly affect throughput and burnout.

• ED volume and acuity

  • Annual ED visits.
  • Trauma designation.
  • Admit rate.

• Boarding and throughput

  • Chronic boarding can dramatically affect job satisfaction and burnout.
  • Ask: How are ED boarding and throughput handled? Any metrics or support systems?

Negotiation tip: While you can’t rewrite hospital operations in a contract, you can ask for modifications that help with sustainability: shift type mix, max shift load, protected time, or phased ramp-up as a new attending.

---

How to Approach Physician Contract Negotiation Step by Step

With all these moving parts, how do you actually conduct an effective attending salary negotiation and overall contract discussion?

Step 1: Gather Information and Benchmark

Well before signing anything:

• Ask peers and recent graduates what they’re seeing for:
  • Hourly rates
  • FTE expectations
  • Non-compete norms in your region
• Use:
  • Specialty societies (ACEP compensation reports, EMRA resources)
  • MGMA or other benchmark data if available
• Understand market differences:
  • Urban academic centers vs suburban community EDs
  • Rural underserved areas (often pay more, with generous incentives)

Step 2: Prioritize Your Values

Clarify what matters most to you:

• Maximum income vs schedule flexibility?
• Academic involvement vs pure clinical work?
• Long-term location stability vs willingness to move?
• Partnership opportunity vs immediate W-2 security?

Rank your priorities so you know what to push hardest on, and what you can compromise on.

Step 3: Obtain a Written Offer Before Deep Negotiation

Before detailed back-and-forth:

• Ask for:
  • A written offer letter, or
  • A draft of the full contract
• Do not rely on verbal promises; anything that matters must ultimately appear in writing.

Step 4: Conduct a Professional Employment Contract Review

Strongly consider:

• Hiring an attorney experienced in physician contract negotiation

  • Preferably someone who regularly reviews emergency medicine contracts and understands EM-specific concerns.
  • They can identify:
    • Hidden risks
    • Unusual or unenforceable provisions
    • Market norms vs outliers

• Using a financial planner or accountant

  • Especially if you’re comparing W-2 vs 1099 roles.
  • To help you understand:
    • After-tax income
    • Value of benefits
    • Retirement and student loan planning implications.

Step 5: Negotiate Strategically and Professionally

When you’re ready to negotiate:

1. Express enthusiasm first

   • Reassure them that you’re genuinely interested in the position and hospital/system.

2. Bundle your requests

   • Instead of a long series of small asks, present a concise, prioritized list:
     • e.g., “I’d like to discuss base pay, tail coverage, and the non-compete radius.”

3. Use data

   • Reference regional benchmarks when discussing salary or FTE expectations.
   • For example:
     • “For EM in this region, I’ve seen offers in the range of $220–250/hr at similar-volume EDs. Is there flexibility to move closer to that range?”

4. Think beyond salary

   • If base pay is “capped,” look at:
     • Increased sign-on bonus
     • Loan repayment
     • Relocation assistance
     • Better tail coverage
     • Reduced non-compete radius
     • Improved schedule terms or FTE definitions

5. Stay collaborative, not adversarial

   • Use language like:
     • “Is there room to adjust…?”
     • “Would you be open to considering…?”
   • Avoid ultimatums unless you are prepared to walk away.

6. Get all final terms in writing

   • When you reach agreement on something verbally or by email, ensure it appears in the contract or an official addendum before signing.

Step 6: Know When to Walk Away

It may be time to step back if:

• The employer refuses to provide the full contract before your final commitment.
• You’re pressured to sign quickly without time for review.
• There are multiple major red flags:
  • Extreme non-competes
  • One-sided termination
  • You pay 100% of an expensive tail if they terminate you
• Communication feels evasive or disrespectful.

Emergency medicine is a high-demand specialty in many markets. If you are coming out of a strong emergency medicine residency, you have leverage—and you deserve a contract that allows you to practice safely and sustainably.

---

FAQs: Physician Contract Negotiation in Emergency Medicine

1. When should I start thinking about my first EM attending contract?

Begin exploring the job market and typical contract structures during your PGY-2 or early PGY-3 year (for a three-year program), or earlier for four-year programs. Actual interviewing and offers often happen 9–12 months before graduation. Starting early gives you time to compare multiple offers, conduct a thoughtful employment contract review, and avoid pressure to sign quickly.

2. Do I really need a lawyer to review my emergency medicine contract?

While it’s not legally required, it is strongly recommended. A healthcare attorney familiar with physician contract negotiation can:

• Identify risky clauses you might overlook.
• Explain non-compete implications in your state.
• Suggest negotiation strategies and language.
• Help you understand malpractice and tail coverage responsibilities.

The cost is usually small relative to the value of protecting your long-term income and career flexibility.

3. How much can I realistically negotiate as a new EM attending?

It depends on:

• Market competitiveness in your region.
• Type of employer (more flexibility in independent groups vs standardized corporate contracts).
• How urgently they need coverage.

You may see more room to negotiate on:

• Sign-on bonus
• Relocation assistance
• Schedule structure (nights, weekend load, FTE)
• Non-compete details
• Malpractice tail coverage

Base salary or hourly rate may have less flexibility in large systems, but it’s still worth asking—especially if you have multiple offers or unique training/skills (ultrasound, EMS, critical care, etc.).

4. What are the biggest red flags in an emergency medicine contract?

Common red flags include:

• Broad non-compete clauses (large geographic radius, long duration, multiple sites).
• One-sided termination rights (employer can terminate without cause; you cannot).
• You are fully responsible for expensive tail coverage, even if they terminate you or lose the hospital contract.
• Very vague scheduling language with no definition of FTE or maximum hours.
• Inflexible or opaque productivity formulas with no historical data on what current physicians actually earn.

If you see several of these together, proceed cautiously and consider seeking other opportunities.

---

Thoughtful, informed physician contract negotiation is as important to your future as a strong EM match was to your training. By understanding the structure of emergency medicine jobs, carefully reviewing each clause, and advocating for your professional and personal priorities, you can secure a contract that supports not only your income but also your longevity, satisfaction, and growth in this demanding and rewarding specialty.