Mastering Physician Contract Negotiation in Psychiatry: Essential Guide

Navigating physician contract negotiation in psychiatry is just as critical as surviving internship or the psych match itself. Your employment contract will determine not only your attending salary, but also your workload, call responsibilities, non-compete restrictions, and long-term career flexibility.

Whether you are signing your first job out of a psychiatry residency or fellowship, or renegotiating as an experienced attending, understanding the fundamentals of employment contract review and negotiation can dramatically improve your financial security and day-to-day job satisfaction.

This guide walks you through the process step-by-step, tailored specifically to psychiatry.

---

Understanding the Context: Why Psychiatry Contracts Are Different

Psychiatry is in a unique position in today’s physician job market:

• High demand, limited supply: There is a well-documented shortage of psychiatrists in the U.S. Many regions—especially rural areas and community mental health settings—are desperate for psychiatrists.
• Rapid growth of telepsychiatry: Remote work options, multi-state licensure, and flexible practice models create leverage and new risks (e.g., complex non-competes and IP clauses).
• Diverse practice settings: Psychiatrists can work in academic centers, community hospitals, CMHCs, private practices, correctional psychiatry, consult-liaison, telehealth-only groups, and hybrid models—each with very different contract norms.
• Broad variation in clinical workload: A “1.0 FTE” psychiatry position might mean 10–12 patients per day in one setting or 25+ short med checks in another. This affects burnout risk and your sense of control.

Because of these dynamics, psychiatry residents and fellows often have more bargaining power than they realize—yet many sign contracts they barely understand, shaped more by fear of losing the offer than by informed choice.

Why negotiation matters, especially in psychiatry

A well-negotiated contract can:

• Protect you from unsafe patient loads and unrealistic productivity targets
• Safeguard your ability to moonlight or build a future private practice
• Prevent overly restrictive non-compete and non-solicit clauses
• Ensure fair compensation relative to your region and subspecialty
• Secure support for CME, supervision, and licensure that align with your professional goals
• Reduce burnout by clarifying call, documentation expectations, and time for admin work

A poorly negotiated contract can tie you to a job that undermines your well-being—and make it legally and financially painful to leave.

---

Step 1: Preparing to Negotiate – Before You See a Contract

Your contract negotiation strategy should begin before any document shows up in your inbox.

Clarify your priorities

Before you start applying or interviewing, list your top 5–7 priorities. Examples for psychiatry might include:

• Clinical focus: Inpatient vs outpatient, C/L, emergency psychiatry, addiction, geriatric psych, child and adolescent, or a mix
• Patient volume and visit length: E.g., “I don’t want >16 scheduled patients per day,” or “I want at least 60 minutes for new patients and 30 minutes for follow-ups.”
• Call responsibilities: Frequency, type of call (in-house vs at-home, tele call), and compensation
• Location and lifestyle: Commute, remote options, flexibility for childcare or personal responsibilities
• Academic vs purely clinical work: Protected time for teaching, research, or administration
• Future plans: Building a private practice, telepsychiatry side work, subspecialty practice

Rank these. When you get to actual negotiations, this ranking helps you decide what to push hardest on and where you’re willing to compromise.

Research the market for psychiatry residency grads and attendings

For strong physician contract negotiation, you need to know what’s “normal” in your field:

• Salary benchmarks
  Look at:
  • MGMA and AAMC data (if you have institutional access)
  • Specialty-specific reports from professional organizations (APA, AACAP, etc.)
  • State medical societies and regional surveys
  • Talk to recent graduates from your psychiatry residency or fellowship about offers they received

Consider:

• Region (urban vs rural)

• Practice type (academic, hospital-employed, private, telepsychiatry group)

• Subspecialty (e.g., child/adolescent, addiction, forensics often pay differently)

• Workload norms
  Ask:

  • How many new patient and follow-up slots are expected per day/week?
  • Typical RVU targets for psychiatrists in that system?
  • Support staff available (psych NPs, therapists, social work, case management)?

Start building your “negotiation mindset”

Psychiatrists, especially new grads, often fear negotiation will make them seem “difficult.” In reality:

• Negotiation is expected in physician employment.
• You are not asking for a favor; you are clarifying mutual expectations.
• With the psychiatry workforce shortage, you likely have more leverage than you think.

Practice saying phrases like:

• “Based on my research and the current market for psychiatry, I was expecting…”
• “To prevent burnout and maintain high-quality patient care, I’d need…”
• “I’m very interested in this position. I’d like to discuss a few contract terms to see if we can find a mutually beneficial arrangement.”

---

Step 2: Key Components of a Psychiatry Employment Contract

Once you receive a draft, employment contract review should be systematic. Every psychiatry contract should be carefully examined for the following sections.

1. Compensation structure

Psychiatry pay can be:

• Straight salary
  Common in academic centers, CMHCs, VA systems. Predictable and stable, but may be lower than private or RVU-based work.

• Base salary + RVU or productivity bonus
  Common in hospital-employed or large group practices. You’ll see:

  • Base salary (guaranteed, often for 1–3 years)
  • RVU threshold (e.g., bonus if you exceed X RVUs/year)
  • Bonus formula (e.g., $X per wRVU above threshold)

• Pure productivity or collections-based
  Common in some telepsychiatry outfits and private groups. Riskier for new grads.

Key questions to answer:

• What is my expected total compensation based on realistic patient volumes?
• How long is the guaranteed salary period before transitioning to full productivity?
• How are RVUs credited for consults, therapy, collaborative care, or administrative work?

If possible, ask for recent examples of actual psychiatrist earnings in this department or group, not just theoretical models.

2. Workload, schedule, and call

For psychiatry, workload definitions are often vague. Insist on clarity:

• Clinic schedule

  • Number of half-days or sessions per week
  • Minimum visit lengths for new patients vs follow-ups
  • No-show policies and whether they still count toward productivity

• Patient panel size
  Particularly critical for outpatient roles. Ask what a full panel looks like and what support exists for high-need populations.

• Call expectations

  • Frequency (e.g., 1:6 weekends, 1:8 weeknights)
  • In-house vs home call; tele-call vs in-person
  • Type of call (admissions, consults, on-call for psych ED, crisis line)
  • Call compensation (stipend, RVUs, or part of base salary?)

• Inpatient vs outpatient mix
  Defined proportions if it’s a hybrid role.

You can negotiate:

• Reduced call or buyout options (e.g., higher salary offset by no call)
• Protected time for charting, care coordination, or supervision

3. Benefits and professional support

Compare benefits alongside salary; lower pay with strong benefits may still be competitive.

Common elements:

• Health, dental, vision, life, and disability insurance
• Retirement contributions (401k/403b match or pension)
• CME allowance and days (especially important for board-certified psychiatrists)
• Licensing, DEA, board certification, and professional dues coverage
• Malpractice insurance (claims-made vs occurrence; tail coverage responsibility)
• Paid time off (vacation, sick, holidays), and whether CME days are separate

In psychiatry, also pay attention to:

• Support staff: Access to therapists, social workers, case managers, and nursing support dramatically affects your workload and burnout risk.
• Team structure: Collaborative care models, integrated primary care, or solo outpatient practice each require different skill sets.

4. Contract length, termination, and notice

Key concepts:

• Term (duration): Often 1–3 years with automatic renewal.
• Without-cause termination: Either party can end the contract with written notice (commonly 60–180 days). Shorter notice gives you more flexibility.

Make sure:

• Notice periods are symmetrical (employer and physician have the same requirement).
• Termination for cause is narrowly defined and includes due process when appropriate.

5. Restrictive covenants: non-compete and non-solicitation

This is often the most important part for psychiatrists, particularly those planning private practice or telepsychiatry on the side.

Common elements:

• Non-compete: Restricts where and how you can practice after leaving (e.g., within 10–30 miles of any clinic site for 1–2 years).
• Non-solicitation: Prevents you from taking patients, referring providers, or staff with you to a new practice for a specified period.

In psychiatry, non-competes can be especially problematic because:

• Patient relationships are longitudinal and therapeutic continuity matters.
• You may be essentially locked out of an entire city or region where you have roots and family.

What to look for:

• Geographic radius: Smaller is better (3–10 miles vs 30–50+).
• Duration: 1 year is typical; 2+ years is more restrictive.
• Scope: Should be limited to your specialty and specific clinical sites, not entire hospital systems or telehealth across multiple states.

You can negotiate:

• A narrower radius
• Fewer covered locations (only where you actually work)
• Exemptions for telepsychiatry or specific patient populations

In some states, physician non-compete clauses are limited or not enforceable—ask a lawyer familiar with physician contract negotiation in your state.

---

Step 3: How to Approach the Negotiation Conversation

Once you’ve done your employment contract review and identified concerns, it’s time to negotiate.

Get expert help: physician-focused contract review

For anything beyond the simplest offer, strongly consider:

• A healthcare attorney with experience in physician contract negotiation
• Or a physician contract review service that understands psychiatry specifically

They can:

• Flag red-flag clauses (e.g., overly broad non-competes, one-sided termination terms)
• Help you prioritize what to negotiate
• Suggest alternative wording or counterproposals

This is usually a one-time cost that can pay off many times over in salary, flexibility, and reduced risk.

Decide your negotiation strategy

You generally have more leverage:

• When there’s clear psychiatry shortage in the area
• If you’re willing to go to another employer or location
• If you have specialized training (e.g., C&A, addiction, ECT, TMS)

Common strategies:

1. Compensation-first: Focus on base pay, bonus structure, and signing incentives, then workload.
2. Lifestyle-first: Focus on schedule, call, patient volume, and non-compete, accepting slightly lower salary if necessary.
3. Risk-mitigation: Emphasis on tail coverage, termination terms, non-compete, and telepsychiatry flexibility.

Language you can use

Negotiate using clear, collaborative language:

• “I appreciate the offer and am excited about this role. To make this work long-term, I’d like to discuss a few points in the contract.”
• “Given current psychiatry market data and my subspecialty training, I was expecting a base salary closer to $X. Is there flexibility on that number?”
• “For outpatient psychiatry, 20+ follow-up patients daily can affect care quality and burnout. Would you be open to capping at 14–16 per day or adjusting visit lengths?”
• “The current non-compete radius of 30 miles from any system site is wider than I can agree to. Could we narrow this to 10 miles from my primary clinic location and limit it to one year?”

Approach it as problem-solving, not confrontation.

What is usually negotiable vs less negotiable

Often negotiable:

• Base salary and signing bonus
• Relocation assistance
• Call expectations and compensation
• Patient volume expectations
• Non-compete scope and duration
• CME funds and time
• Start date and moving expenses

Less negotiable (but still worth clarifying):

• Core benefits structure in large organizations
• Institutional policies (e.g., malpractice carrier choice, EMR, certain HR policies)
• Some academic promotion or tenure processes

Be prepared to walk away

The most powerful negotiation tool is the ability not to accept an offer. If a contract contains:

• A non-compete that would lock you out of an entire metropolitan area
• No tail coverage in a claims-made policy, with no reasonable buyout option
• Unsafe workloads without adequate support

You may be better off declining the job—even if it delays your first attending paycheck.

---

Step 4: Special Considerations for Psychiatry

Certain aspects of psychiatry practice introduce additional contract issues that are easy to overlook.

Telepsychiatry and multi-state practice

Telepsychiatry has exploded, especially since COVID. Contracts may include:

• Multi-state licensure requirements: Who pays for licenses, renewals, and prescribing software?
• Geography in non-compete clauses: Some employers try to restrict telepsychiatry in broad regions or entire states.
• Home office and equipment: Stipends for equipment, secure internet, and privacy measures.

Clarify:

• How you’re compensated for no-shows and late cancellations
• Expectations for camera-on vs phone-only visits
• Requirements for being within state lines for certain sessions
• On-call or back-up duties across time zones

Academic psychiatry and hybrid roles

For academic positions:

• Define protected time for teaching, supervision, research, and admin.
• Ensure that expectations for RVUs vs academic work are realistic and documented.
• Ask how promotions work and whether clinical productivity outweighs other activities.

Many psychiatrists now have hybrid roles (e.g., 0.6 FTE at a hospital + 0.4 FTE telepsychiatry or private practice). Contracts must:

• Not prohibit reasonable moonlighting, especially if outside regular hours
• Clearly define what counts as “competing” with your employer

Psychiatric subspecialties

Subspecialists (C&A, addiction, forensic, geriatric, C/L) should pay attention to:

• Whether compensation reflects market scarcity for their subspecialty
• Expectations for general psychiatry vs subspecialty work
• Additional call duties specific to their field

You can negotiate to ensure that your contract aligns with your intended subspecialty practice, not just generic psychiatry.

---

Step 5: After Signing – Re-Negotiation and Career Growth

Your first psychiatry contract is not your last. Many physicians renegotiate once they establish themselves in a practice.

Set a timeline for re-evaluation

Look for:

• Contract terms that allow annual salary review and bonus recalculation.
• Opportunities for promotion, leadership, or medical directorships with associated stipends.

If the contract is silent on raises, you can still initiate a structured conversation after 1–2 years, especially if:

• You’ve exceeded RVU targets or taken on additional responsibilities.
• The market for psychiatrists has become even more competitive in your area.

Attending salary negotiation for renewals

Approach renewal like a new negotiation:

• Gather updated salary benchmarks for psychiatrists in your region and subspecialty.
• Document your clinical productivity, leadership roles, teaching, and quality metrics.
• Prepare a clear, evidence-based request:
  “Based on my current RVUs, additional responsibilities as inpatient unit director, and current market data, I’d like to discuss adjusting my base salary to…”

If your employer won’t adjust compensation or workload after good-faith efforts, it may be time to explore other opportunities—with a more informed approach to your next contract.

---

Practical Examples: Common Psychiatry Contract Scenarios

Example 1: New grad, community outpatient job

Offer:

• $250,000 base, 3-year contract, no RVU bonus
• 1:4 weekend call, home call
• Patient load: 20–24 follow-ups/day, 60-minute new evals
• Non-compete: 25 miles from any clinic owned by the system for 2 years

Negotiation goals:

• Lower patient volume (e.g., max 16–18/day)
• Narrow non-compete radius and duration
• Signing bonus or relocation funds

Potential outcome:

• Base salary increased to $265,000
• Patient cap set at 18/day
• Non-compete reduced to 10 miles from primary clinic for 1 year
• $10,000 signing bonus with 2-year forgiveness period

Example 2: Telepsychiatry contract

Offer:

• 70% of collections, independent contractor
• Must hold licenses in 5 states (physician pays)
• Non-compete: no telepsych in those 5 states for 2 years after leaving

Risks:

• You may shoulder licensing and compliance costs
• Overly broad non-compete might restrict future remote work

Negotiation targets:

• Company pays for new and renewal licenses
• Clear minimum expected volume and support for cancellations
• Non-compete limited to patients seen through that platform, not entire states

---

FAQs: Psychiatry Physician Contract Negotiation

1. When should I start thinking about contract negotiation during residency?

Begin early in your PGY-3 year (or PGY-5 for fellows) to:

• Clarify your priorities (location, subspecialty, lifestyle)
• Learn basic physician contract negotiation concepts
• Talk to recent graduates about their offers and what they’d do differently

You’ll typically start receiving offers during the latter half of residency; being prepared ahead of time helps you avoid rushed, poorly informed decisions.

2. Do I really need a lawyer for my first psychiatry contract?

You don’t have to, but it’s strongly recommended for:

• Complex employment agreements, multi-site or multi-state roles
• Contracts with non-competes, RVU-based pay, or unusual clauses
• Telepsychiatry positions or private group partnerships

Look for a healthcare attorney or contract review service that regularly works with physicians. The cost is usually modest compared to the potential financial and professional impact of the contract.

3. How much can I realistically negotiate as a new attending?

As a psychiatrist, often more than you think. You may not transform a position entirely, but you can typically negotiate:

• A higher base salary or signing bonus
• Improved call schedule or call compensation
• More reasonable patient volume or visit length
• Narrower non-compete terms
• Enhanced CME funds, relocation assistance, or start date

You’re more likely to succeed if your requests are well-researched, specific, and tied to quality of care and long-term retention, not just higher pay.

4. What are the biggest red flags in a psychiatry employment contract?

Common red flags include:

• Very broad non-compete (large radius, multi-year, or entire health systems or states)
• No tail coverage with a claims-made malpractice policy and no clear plan for who pays
• Vague or excessive patient volume expectations with no cap
• One-sided termination clauses heavily favoring the employer
• Prohibitions on any outside work, including telepsychiatry or academic activities, without reasonable cause

If you see these, pause and seek expert advice before signing.

---

Negotiating your first (or next) psychiatry attending contract is not about being demanding; it’s about building a sustainable, ethical, and rewarding career. Understand your value, know the market, get help when needed, and approach every physician contract negotiation as a structured, thoughtful process—not a rushed formality.