Ultimate Guide to Researching Preliminary Medicine Programs for US Citizen IMGs

Understanding the Unique Position of a US Citizen IMG in Preliminary Medicine

As a US citizen IMG (American studying abroad or graduate of a foreign medical school), researching preliminary medicine residency programs requires a very deliberate strategy. Preliminary Internal Medicine (prelim IM) spots are limited, highly variable in quality, and often misunderstood—even by applicants.

Before you start building lists and spreadsheets, you need clarity on three things:

1. Why you’re pursuing a preliminary medicine year
2. How prelim IM differs from categorical IM
3. What being a US citizen IMG means for your program research strategy

Why You’re Pursuing a Preliminary Medicine Year

Common reasons US citizen IMGs choose a preliminary medicine year:

• You are applying (or plan to apply) to advanced specialties:
  • Neurology
  • Anesthesiology
  • Radiology (diagnostic or IR)
  • PM&R
  • Radiation Oncology
  • Dermatology (less common, but possible)
• You want US clinical experience in an ACGME-accredited program to:
  • Strengthen a future categorical IM application
  • Show program directors you can perform in a US setting
• You need a bridge year to improve your application:
  • Time to retake/strengthen Step 2 CK performance
  • Time to gain US letters of recommendation
  • Time to improve research or scholarly output

Your reason will shape how you research residency programs, what you prioritize, and which programs make sense for you.

Prelim IM vs Categorical IM: Key Differences

Preliminary IM:

• 1-year position (PGY-1 only)
• No guaranteed continuation to PGY-2 in the same program
• Designed as a foundation year for advanced specialties or as a transitional year
• Fewer formal mentorship and long-term career development pathways

Categorical IM:

• 3-year core residency (PGY-1 to PGY-3)
• Structured curriculum leading to board eligibility in Internal Medicine
• More emphasis on career development, fellowship preparation, and continuity clinics

When you research programs, you must confirm if they offer prelim IM positions specifically and whether those positions are:

• Linked to a particular advanced specialty, or
• Stand-alone, open to anyone (including US citizen IMGs)

What Being a US Citizen IMG Means for Program Research

As a US citizen IMG, you:

• Do not need visa sponsorship, which removes a major barrier many programs have with non-US citizen IMGs.
• Still face competition and screening filters based on:
  • USMLE scores
  • Year of graduation
  • Type and recency of clinical experience
  • Perceptions about non-US medical schools

This combination is actually an advantage if you target programs intelligently. Many programs that are “IMG-friendly” for non-citizens are even more open to US citizen IMGs.

Your program research strategy should explicitly look for:

• Programs that accept IMGs regularly
• Programs that maximize training value in a single year
• Programs that believe in the prelim track and don’t treat prelims as disposable service labor

---

Step 1: Clarify Your Goals and Constraints Before Researching

You cannot research effectively until you define what “right” means for you.

A. Clarify Your Primary Goal for the Preliminary Medicine Year

Ask yourself:

1. Is this prelim IM year mainly to:

   • Fulfill a requirement of an advanced specialty you’re already matching into or reapplying to?
   • Strengthen your candidacy for future categorical IM?
   • Keep you in the US system while you figure out your long-term path?

2. How important are the following to you?

   • Strong inpatient medicine training
   • Reputation and name recognition
   • Fellowship exposure or networking
   • Mentorship and letter-writing culture
   • Lifestyle and location
   • Cost of living

Your priorities influence how to research residency programs and which filters to apply.

B. Be Honest About Your Application Profile

Before you dive into evaluating residency programs, take stock of:

• USMLE Step 1 (P/F) context and Step 2 CK score
• Any attempts or failures
• Year of graduation (YOG) and time since graduation
• Level of US clinical experience (USCE):
  • Sub-internships
  • Externships
  • Observerships
• Research and publications (if any)
• Strength and number of US letters of recommendation

This self-assessment tells you:

• Which competitiveness tier you should realistically focus on
• Where to allocate more or fewer applications
• Whether you need to broaden your search to less competitive regions or community programs

---

Step 2: Build a Structured Program Research Strategy

You should treat program research like a project, not casual browsing.

A. Start with Broad Databases and Filters

Use a combination of tools:

• AMA FREIDA (primary)
• Residency Explorer
• NRMP Program Directory
• Program websites and past NRMP Match Data

Filter first by:

• Specialty: Internal Medicine – Preliminary (not categorical)
• Location preferences (broad at first: region rather than city)
• Programs that offer prelim slots in the most recent cycle

Export or copy this into a spreadsheet with basic columns:

• Program name
• State / city
• University or community
• Number of prelim spots
• Approximate fill rate (from NRMP/Residency Explorer)
• Presence of advanced specialties you care about (e.g., neurology, radiology, anesthesia)

This becomes your master list.

B. Define Research Tiers: Must-Have vs Nice-to-Have

Divide your filters into:

Must-Have Criteria (deal-breakers):

• Accepts US citizen IMGs / IMGs in general
• Offers ACGME-accredited prelim IM positions every year
• Does not explicitly exclude IMGs or require US medical school graduation
• Provides enough inpatient exposure (no extremely light or non-traditional prelim track)
• Reasonable duty hour policies, no dangerous reputation (e.g., chronic violations, major ACGME citations)

Nice-to-Have Criteria (priority but flexible):

• Presence of your target advanced specialty at the same institution
• Strong history of graduates going into advanced positions or fellowships
• Location preference (coastal vs Midwest vs South, urban vs rural)
• Resident wellness initiatives, reasonable call schedule
• Availability of electives tailored to your career goals
• Cost of living that won’t bankrupt you

As a US citizen IMG, you can usually be firm on must-haves, but more flexible on nice-to-haves.

---

Step 3: How to Research Residency Programs in Depth

Once you have a broad list, you move into qualitative evaluation. Here is a systematic process tailored to a US citizen IMG aiming for preliminary medicine.

A. Check IMG-Friendliness and US Citizen IMG Relevance

For each program, investigate:

1. Past Match Data / Program Website

   • Do they show current or past residents from:
     • Caribbean schools
     • Other international schools
   • Are there prelim residents visible, or only categorical?

2. Residency Explorer / FREIDA Data Points

   • Percentage of US MD vs DO vs IMG residents
   • Whether IMGs are accepted at all
   • Average USMLE Step 2 CK score ranges (if listed, or inferred from competitiveness)

3. Red Flags for IMGs

   • Website language like “We only consider graduates of LCME-accredited US and Canadian schools”
   • “We do not sponsor visas” is not a problem for you as a US citizen, but if they also rarely list IMGs, it may still indicate low IMG-friendliness.

Result: Label each program as:

• IMG-friendly
• IMG-possible but limited
• Not IMG-friendly

As a US citizen IMG, you should heavily target at least some IMG-possible academic programs in addition to clearly IMG-friendly community programs.

B. Evaluate the Quality of the Prelim IM Experience

You want a prelim year that provides solid training, not just service work. Evaluate:

1. Rotation Structure

   • How many months of:
     • General medicine wards
     • Night float
     • ICU
     • Electives
   • Is the preliminary medicine year curriculum identical to the categorical interns’ first year, or are prelims excluded from certain rotations?

2. Educational Culture

   • Are prelims included in:
     • Morning report
     • Noon conference
     • Grand rounds
   • Any mention of dedicated teaching or simulation sessions?

3. Prelim-Specific Status

   • Do they state the role of prelims clearly?
   • Are prelims treated as full members of the resident team, or as “extra hands”?

Look for explicit statements like:

“Our preliminary interns participate in the same core inpatient rotations and educational curriculum as our categorical interns.”

This is highly desirable.

C. Assess Fit with Your Career Path

If you already have or are targeting a specific advanced specialty, use that to refine your program research strategy.

Example: You’re an American studying abroad applying in Neurology with a required prelim year

You should ask:

• Does this hospital have a Neurology residency?
• Do preliminary medicine interns rotate on or interact with Neurology services?
• Do Neurology program directors know and work with the IM prelims?
• Have previous prelims from this program successfully matched into Neurology (same or elsewhere)?

You can often find this by:

• Reading resident bios on Neurology or Anesthesia department pages
• Checking if they list interns who did their preliminary medicine year at the same institution
• Searching PubMed or institutional pages for collaborative work between IM and your target specialty

---

Step 4: Sources of Information and How to Use Them Effectively

A. Program Websites: What to Look For

On each program’s website, focus on:

• Current residents page:

  • Are prelims listed separately?
  • Do you see IMGs, Caribbean graduates, or foreign medical schools?

• Curriculum page:

  • Specific prelim IM track description
  • Sample rotation schedule for prelims
  • Any unique tracks (e.g., “Preliminary Internal Medicine for Neurology majors”)

• Benefits and salary page:

  • Salary and cost-of-living context
  • Housing assistance, meal allowances, parking fees

• Message from the Program Director or Chiefs:

  • Tone toward education vs service
  • Emphasis on mentorship, wellness, and support

B. NRMP, FREIDA, and Residency Explorer

Use these for numbers and trends:

• Number of prelim positions offered and filled
• Historical match fill patterns
• Size of the program (bigger programs may have more prelim spots but also more service needs)
• Program type (university, university-affiliated community, or pure community)
• Any report of ACGME citations or program changes

For a US citizen IMG, university-affiliated community programs often offer a good balance of:

• IMG-friendliness
• Teaching quality
• Exposure to advanced specialties

C. Social Media and Resident-Led Content

Research:

• Program Twitter/X, Instagram, or LinkedIn
• Resident-led Q&As, blogs, or “day in the life” features

Look for:

• How residents talk about workload and support
• Whether prelims are visible and included in residents’ stories
• Diversity of the resident class (presence of IMGs, Caribbean grads, etc.)

Always treat social media as supplemental, not the core of your evaluation.

---

Step 5: Direct Outreach and Hidden Information

Some of the most important information about evaluating residency programs cannot be found on websites—it comes from direct contact.

A. Emailing Program Coordinators Strategically

Program coordinators can clarify:

• Whether IMGs are considered and how often they are interviewed
• Whether they currently have or recently had prelim IMGs
• Any application filters (YOG cutoffs, Step 2 CK minimums, required USCE)

Example email template (adapt wording to your style):

Subject: Inquiry Regarding Preliminary Internal Medicine Positions for US Citizen IMG

Dear [Coordinator Name],

My name is [Your Name], a US citizen international medical graduate from [School Name], preparing to apply for a preliminary internal medicine position in the upcoming Match. I am particularly interested in [Program Name] and would be grateful if you could clarify a few points:

1. Does your program consider US citizen IMGs for preliminary internal medicine positions?
2. Do preliminary interns participate in the same core clinical and educational curriculum as categorical interns?
3. Are there any minimum USMLE Step 2 CK or year-of-graduation criteria that applicants should be aware of?

Thank you very much for your time and assistance.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
AAMC ID: [if available]

This shows professionalism and gives you actionable information.

B. Networking Through Alumni and Advisors

As an American studying abroad, use:

• Your medical school’s alumni network
• US rotation preceptors and attendings
• Former graduates who matched into prelim IM or advanced specialties

Ask them:

• Which programs were supportive to them as IMGs
• Whether their prelim year prepared them for advanced training
• If they’d recommend or avoid specific programs

Real-world opinions are very valuable, especially when official data are limited.

C. Virtual Open Houses and Information Sessions

Attend program-sponsored virtual events to:

• Observe the culture: Who speaks more—faculty or residents?
• Ask carefully phrased questions:
  • “How do you see the role of preliminary interns in your program?”
  • “Do prelims have opportunities to participate in quality improvement or research?”
  • “How do you support prelim interns who are reapplying to advanced specialties?”

Take notes immediately after each session to document impressions for later comparison.

---

Step 6: Comparing and Prioritizing Programs

You now have a broad list, detailed information, and impressions. The next step is to rank programs in tiers before you even think about interview season.

A. Build a Scoring System

Create a simple scoring rubric out of 10 or 20 points, broken down by your priorities. For a US citizen IMG in prelim medicine, an example:

1. IMG-Friendliness (0–3)

   • 0 = No IMGs visible, exclusion language
   • 1 = Rare IMGs, unclear attitude
   • 2 = Regular IMGs at least in categorical track
   • 3 = Consistent IMGs and open language

2. Prelim Curriculum Quality (0–4)

   • 0–1 = No clear prelim curriculum, seems service-heavy
   • 2 = Standard inpatient rotations but limited electives
   • 3 = Good mix of wards, ICU, and electives for prelims
   • 4 = Thoughtful curriculum, prelims integrated with categoricals

3. Alignment with Career Goals (0–4)

   • 0–1 = Misaligned, no relevant advanced specialties or mentorship
   • 2 = Some overlap but limited direct relevance
   • 3 = Strong exposure to your field (e.g., neurology, radiology)
   • 4 = Clear pathway and track record of placing prelims in your target field

4. Location & Logistics (0–3)

   • Cost of living
   • Proximity to family/support
   • Safety and environment

5. Support, Culture, and Wellness (0–3)

   • Resident testimonials
   • Social media and website emphasis on wellness
   • Reasonable call structure

You don’t need a perfect system; you need a consistent one.

B. Create Tiers: Reach, Target, and Safety

Based on your USMLE scores, YOG, and research:

• Reach programs

  • More competitive academic centers
  • Strong national reputation
  • Historically fewer IMGs, but you’re a strong applicant (high Step 2 CK, strong US letters)

• Target programs

  • Mid-range academic or academic-affiliated community programs
  • Regular IMGs, good training, moderate competitiveness

• Safety programs

  • Community-based, more IMG-heavy
  • Possibly less name recognition but high acceptance likelihood

As a US citizen IMG, you should not skip safety programs, even if you are competitive. Prelim positions are limited and can fill quickly.

---

Step 7: Common Pitfalls US Citizen IMGs Should Avoid

Pitfall 1: Treating All Prelim IM Programs as the Same

Preliminary medicine years vary dramatically:

• Some are well-structured, with strong teaching and mentorship.
• Others are primarily service jobs with minimal support.

Always evaluate:

• Curriculum
• Integration with categoricals
• Resident feedback (when accessible)

Pitfall 2: Ignoring Future Plans

If you want to pursue categorical IM later, choose a prelim program where:

• The faculty write strong letters
• You can showcase your skills on inpatient wards
• You can get exposure to fellowship-level services (ICU, cardiology, etc.)

If you are doing a prelim as a bridge to neurology, radiology, anesthesia, etc., prioritize institutions with those specialties in-house.

Pitfall 3: Over-Focusing on “Big Names”

Name recognition helps, but for a single-year prelim, training quality, culture, and support may matter more than prestige. A smaller program where attendings know you well may provide better letters and advocacy for your advanced or categorical applications.

Pitfall 4: Not Accounting for Cost of Living and Financial Stress

A prelim year is only 12 months, but:

• You’ll have moving costs, board exam costs, ERAS fees, and matching costs
• Lower cost-of-living areas can reduce financial stress significantly

Factor this into evaluating residency programs, especially if you have loans or family obligations.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a US citizen IMG, do I have a significant advantage when applying to prelim IM compared to non-US citizen IMGs?

Yes. Because you do not require visa sponsorship, many programs that are hesitant to sponsor visas are more open to US citizen IMGs. However, you are still evaluated critically on:

• USMLE scores (especially Step 2 CK)
• Year of graduation
• US clinical experience
• Strength of letters of recommendation

You should still build a broad and balanced program list, including IMG-friendly community and academic programs.

2. Should I prioritize programs that also have my target advanced specialty (like Neurology or Anesthesiology)?

If you already know your target field, it is usually wise to prioritize programs that house that specialty, because:

• You can build relationships with attendings in that department
• Easier access to specialty-specific letters and mentorship
• Better continuity if you match there for your advanced position

However, you should not completely exclude strong prelim IM programs that lack your specialty, especially if they have:

• Excellent teaching
• Strong track record of sending grads to good advanced programs

3. How many prelim IM programs should I research and apply to as a US citizen IMG?

Numbers vary by competitiveness, but many US citizen IMGs applying prelim medicine:

• Research 40–60 programs in detail
• Apply to 25–40 prelim IM programs, depending on:
  • Step 2 CK performance
  • Strength of application
  • How many advanced programs they’re also applying to

If your profile has red flags (low scores, older YOG, limited USCE), it is safer to research and apply to more programs.

4. Can a strong preliminary medicine year help me get into a categorical IM spot later?

Yes—if you choose the right kind of prelim program and perform well. A strong prelim year can:

• Provide high-quality US letters of recommendation
• Demonstrate your ability to handle US clinical workload and systems
• Allow you to network with IM leadership and program directors

Some prelim programs may consider their top prelims for open PGY-2 categorical positions, but this should never be assumed; always ask about:

• Internal pathways
• Historical examples of prelims transitioning to categorical IM, either locally or elsewhere

---

By approaching your search with a structured program research strategy—grounded in your career goals, honest self-assessment, and targeted evaluation of IMG-friendliness and training quality—you can dramatically increase your chances of matching into a preliminary medicine year that truly positions you for long-term success as a US citizen IMG.