Essential Guide for US Citizen IMGs Researching Preliminary Surgery Residency

Choosing where to apply is one of the most strategic decisions you’ll make as a US citizen IMG interested in a preliminary surgery year. Unlike categorical general surgery, prelim surgery residency positions have unique dynamics, risks, and opportunities. A smart, systematic program research strategy can dramatically improve your chances of matching and setting yourself up for future success—whether you want to eventually secure a categorical surgery position, transition to another specialty, or strengthen your profile for a later match.

This guide walks you step‑by‑step through how to research residency programs in preliminary surgery as an American studying abroad, with specific attention to the realities of being a US citizen IMG.

---

Understanding the Role of a Preliminary Surgery Year

Before you dive into evaluating residency programs, you need absolute clarity on why you’re pursuing a preliminary surgery year. Your goals directly shape how you should research and rank programs.

What Is a Preliminary Surgery Residency?

A prelim surgery residency is:

• A 1-year non-categorical position in general surgery (or related surgical fields)
• Often filled by:
  • Applicants seeking to convert to a categorical general surgery position
  • Future surgical subspecialty fellows (e.g., urology, orthopedics, neurosurgery) who need a surgery-based intern year
  • Applicants who want US clinical experience and strong letters to reapply in surgery or another specialty

Crucially, prelim surgery is not guaranteed to convert into a categorical spot. Many programs rarely, if ever, offer this chance.

Common Goals for US Citizen IMGs

As a US citizen IMG or an American studying abroad, you might be considering a preliminary surgery year to:

• Gain US-based surgical experience and strong letters of recommendation
• Improve your competitiveness for a future categorical surgery match
• Transition into a different specialty (e.g., anesthesiology, radiology, internal medicine) with a stronger foundation
• Fulfill the required clinical year for certain advanced positions (e.g., in radiology or PM&R, depending on pathway)

Being clear on your primary goal helps you prioritize what matters most when evaluating residency programs—for example:

• If your top goal is a future categorical surgery spot, you’ll prioritize:

  • Programs with a track record of converting prelims to categorical
  • Robust surgical case volume and operative exposure
  • Mentorship and advocacy for prelims

• If your goal is switching to another specialty, you’ll look for:

  • Strong internal medicine or multidisciplinary teams
  • Opportunities to rotate or interact with other specialties
  • Program directors receptive to helping prelims transition

Write this down explicitly before you begin your program research strategy.

---

Building Your Program List: Where and How to Start

Successful program research starts with a broad, organized list that you progressively refine. As a US citizen IMG, you should be intentional but also realistic and comprehensive.

Step 1: Use Official Databases and Directories

Begin with standardized, reliable sources:

• FREIDA (AMA Residency & Fellowship Database)

  • Filter by:
    • Specialty: “Surgery – Preliminary” (or related labels)
    • Location (states/regions you’ll consider)
  • Note:
    • Number of prelim spots per year
    • Program type (university, community, hybrid)
    • Affiliated categorical positions

• ERAS / AAMC Program Lists (current application cycle)

  • Confirm which preliminary surgery programs are actually participating in ERAS this year
  • Cross-check program names and codes with FREIDA

• NRMP Results and Data (prior years)

  • Review annual NRMP reports, especially:
    • Fill rates for preliminary surgery
    • Proportion of IMGs matching in prelim surgery
  • This helps you gauge competitiveness and realistic expectations.

Create a spreadsheet and add columns for:

• Program name
• City, state, region
• Program type (university, community, hybrid)
• Number of prelim positions
• Accepts/has matched IMGs? (Y/N or Unknown)
• Requires ECFMG at time of application? (for non-US citizen IMGs; less relevant if you are a US citizen, but still worth noting)
• Notes / initial impressions

Step 2: Filter for US Citizen IMG Friendliness

As a US citizen IMG, you have some advantages (no visa requirement) but still face “IMG” bias at some programs. When researching residency programs, look for evidence that a program is reasonably open to IMGs.

Ways to assess this:

• Program’s current and recent residents

  • Visit the residency website: many list residents’ medical schools.
  • Look for:
    • Inclusion of Caribbean, Eastern European, Asian, or other international schools
    • Presence of US citizen IMGs or Americans studying abroad (often clear from biographies)

• NRMP and program-specific data

  • Some programs list their percentage of IMGs or sample schools.

• Word of mouth / online forums

  • Use resources like Reddit (r/medicalschool, r/IMGreddit), SDN, or IMG-specific communities.
  • Search: “Program Name preliminary surgery IMG” or “Program Name US citizen IMG.”

Label each program in your spreadsheet:

• “Historically IMG-friendly”
• “Some IMGs”
• “Primarily US grads”

This doesn’t mean you cannot apply to competitive programs—but it helps you distribute risk and effort wisely.

Step 3: Geographic and Lifestyle Considerations

Location influences everything: competition level, cost of living, support network, and future opportunities.

Ask yourself:

• Where can you realistically live and thrive for a year—financially and emotionally?
• Are you willing to apply broadly to less competitive regions (Midwest, South, some rural areas) where US citizen IMGs may have better chances?
• Do you prefer:
  • University hospitals in big cities
  • Community hospitals with closer-knit teams
  • Hybrid programs with university affiliation and community workload

Add columns for:

• Region desirability (High / Medium / Low for you personally)
• Cost of living (approximate—big city vs smaller city/town)
• Proximity to family/support network

---

Deep-Dive: How to Evaluate Preliminary Surgery Programs

Once you’ve built a broad list, the next step is to evaluate residency programs in depth. For a preliminary surgery year, you must look beyond generic factors and ask very targeted questions.

1. Track Record of Supporting Prelims

This is the most critical element for many applicants.

Key questions:

• Do prelims ever become categorical?

  • Look for:
    • Website statements like “Prelim residents are considered for categorical positions when available.”
    • Alumni lists that show prelims moving into categorical spots (either at that institution or elsewhere).

• What happens to prelims after the year ends?

  • Does the program highlight where prelims go (e.g., categorical surgery, anesthesia, radiology, other specialties)?
  • If a program never mentions prelim outcomes, that can be a warning sign.

During interviews (or via email if appropriate), ask directly:

• “In the last 3–5 years, how many preliminary surgery residents have transitioned into categorical surgery, either in your program or elsewhere?”
• “How does your program support prelim residents seeking categorical or other specialty positions?”

Document answers clearly in your spreadsheet.

2. Program Culture and Attitude Toward Prelims

In some programs, prelims are fully integrated and valued; in others, they’re treated as “service-only” residents with minimal support. As a US citizen IMG, you cannot afford to spend a year in a place that gives you little educational value or advocacy.

Look for:

• How prelims are described on the website

  • Are prelims mentioned in the same breath as categoricals?
  • Are their rotations, expectations, and educational benefits clearly outlined?

• Resident wellness and inclusivity

  • Check if prelims are:
    • Included in didactics and simulation labs
    • Supported in mentorship or advising programs
    • Acknowledged in resident profiles

Red flags:

• Websites that barely mention prelims beyond a single sentence
• No resident list for prelims, or an obvious separation from categorical residents
• Online reports (reviews, forums) describing prelims as “scut machines” or “invisible”

3. Clinical Exposure and Case Volume

As an aspiring surgeon or future specialist, the educational and operative experience you gain during your preliminary year is crucial.

Consider:

• Case mix and volume

  • Does the program serve as a trauma center?
  • What types of surgeries are most common (bread-and-butter general surgery vs complex oncologic cases, transplant, etc.)?
  • Will you get meaningful hands-on experience, or just floor and call duties?

• Responsibility level for prelims

  • Do prelims take call similarly to categorical interns?
  • Are prelims allowed to scrub on cases regularly?
  • Are there any restrictions on ICU, trauma, or specialty rotations?

If possible, find rotation schedules or block diagrams online. Look for:

• Number of dedicated OR months
• Rotations in ICU, trauma, night float, and off-service rotations (e.g., vascular, SICU, emergency)

For future categorical surgery applicants, programs where prelims have real operative exposure are especially valuable, both for skills and letters.

4. Education, Mentorship, and Letters of Recommendation

Your preliminary surgery year should strengthen your candidacy, not just occupy 12 months.

Look for:

• Didactic and conference structure

  • M&M conferences, grand rounds, journal clubs
  • Simulation labs or skills labs for suturing, laparoscopy, etc.
  • Regular teaching by faculty and senior residents

• Formal mentorship

  • Is there a designated faculty advisor for each prelim resident?
  • Are there structured evaluation and feedback processes?

• Letters of recommendation (LORs)

  • Do faculty commonly write strong letters for prelims?
  • Do previous prelims from the program have success stories you can identify (via alumni lists or networking)?

Programs that openly talk about helping prelims secure good next steps (categorical, other specialties, fellowships) are particularly valuable.

5. Schedule, Workload, and Support

Burnout in a heavy-service prelim surgery year is real. You want a program that challenges you but does not destroy you.

Evaluate:

• Call schedule and duty hours

  • Are there night float systems?
  • Does the program have a reputation (online or via word-of-mouth) for chronic duty hour violations?

• Support services

  • Physician wellness programs
  • Access to counseling, mental health services
  • Meal stipends, on-call rooms, parking, etc.

You only have one PGY-1 year; you want to emerge more capable, not completely exhausted and disillusioned.

---

Strategic Considerations Specific to US Citizen IMGs

As an American studying abroad or a US citizen IMG, you occupy a unique middle ground: no visa issues, but still perceived as an IMG by many programs. Use that to your advantage while being realistic about hurdles.

Advantage: No Visa Requirement

Programs that avoid IMGs mainly due to visa sponsorship concerns may be more open to US citizen IMGs. When researching residency programs, look for:

• Programs that state:
  • “We do not sponsor visas” or
  • “We only accept citizens or permanent residents”

These may be more accessible for you than for non-US citizen IMGs. You can prioritize such programs in your application strategy.

Challenge: Perceptions of Training Quality

Some programs may still be skeptical about international schools—especially if they are unfamiliar with yours.

Mitigation strategies:

• Emphasize USMLE scores, clinical performance, research, and any US clinical experience (USCE) you have.
• Target programs that already have residents from:
  • Your school
  • Similar Caribbean or international schools

When evaluating, note:

• “Has residents from my school or region” (Yes/No)
• “Familiar with Caribbean/IMG schools” (Yes/No)

Building a Tiered Application Strategy

Develop a program research strategy that categorizes programs into tiers based on competitiveness and fit:

• Tier 1 – Reach

  • Academic powerhouses in major cities, high volume, prestigious names
  • Limited IMG presence
  • Apply if you have very strong scores, research, or connections

• Tier 2 – Realistic targets

  • Mid-range university-affiliated or strong community programs
  • Some history of US citizen IMGs or IMGs in general
  • Reasonable expectations for supportive education and letters

• Tier 3 – Safety / back-up

  • Community programs, smaller cities, regions with lower competition
  • More open to IMGs and prelims
  • May have heavier service, but can still provide clinical exposure and letters

Aim for a balanced distribution across these tiers, depending on your profile.

---

Putting It All Together: A Practical Workflow

Here is a step-by-step, actionable framework for how to research residency programs in preliminary surgery as a US citizen IMG:

Step 1: Clarify Your Goals (30–60 minutes)

Write down:

• Primary goal of your preliminary surgery year
• Back-up plans (e.g., switch to anesthesiology, internal medicine)
• Geographic and lifestyle boundaries (where you will and will not go)

Step 2: Build a Master List (1–2 days)

Using FREIDA, ERAS, and NRMP:

• Identify all preliminary surgery programs
• Enter them into a spreadsheet
• Record location, program type, number of prelim positions

Step 3: First-Pass Filtering (1–3 days)

For each program:

• Check website for:
  • Prelim positions description
  • Number of slots
  • Basic information on curriculum
• Mark:
  • IMG friendliness level (based on resident list, known info)
  • Rough competitiveness (location, reputation)
  • Whether they accept US citizen IMGs or have in the past

Remove programs that:

• Do not match your basic location/visa/fit criteria
• Have zero documentation about prelim positions (unless they are highly desirable for another reason)

Step 4: Deep-Dive Research (1–2 weeks, ongoing)

For remaining programs, dig deeper:

• Review rotation schedule and case exposure
• Look for any mention of:
  • Prelim-to-categorical transitions
  • Where prior prelims ended up
• Search online:
  • “[Program name] prelim surgery experience”
  • “IMG [Program name] surgery residency”
• Reach out (professionally) to:
  • Current or former residents via LinkedIn, alumni networks, or mutual connections
  • Your school’s alumni office for contacts at those institutions

Add detailed notes:

• Culture / attitudes toward prelims
• Education/mentorship quality
• Evidence of supporting career advancement

Step 5: Tier and Prioritize

Assign each program:

• A tier (1–3 or A/B/C) based on:
  • Competitiveness
  • Fit with your goals
  • IMG friendliness
• A priority score (e.g., 1–5) reflecting:
  • How excited you’d be to train there
  • How realistic it is you’ll get an interview

Plan your application volume accordingly, making sure to include:

• Enough “safety” programs that are realistic
• A reasonable number of “reach” programs if your metrics allow

Step 6: Reassess After Interviews

Your program evaluation is not done once applications are sent.

After each interview:

• Immediately jot down:
  • How they spoke about prelims and IMGs
  • The transparency of answers regarding outcomes and support
  • Your gut sense of culture, respect, and workload
• Update:
  • Tier or rank of that program on your list
  • Any red or green flags

When building your final rank list, lean heavily on:

• Evidence of support for prelims
• Cultural fit and mentorship
• Your long-term goals (categorical surgery vs other fields)

---

FAQs: Researching Preliminary Surgery Programs as a US Citizen IMG

1. As a US citizen IMG, should I only apply to prelim surgery programs that convert to categorical?

Not necessarily. Programs that occasionally convert prelims are ideal if your primary goal is categorical general surgery, but they are not the only valuable options.

Consider applying to a mix of:

• Programs with a known track record of converting prelims
• Strong training environments that:
  • Offer robust clinical exposure
  • Have good reputations
  • Provide excellent letters to help you match into categorical spots elsewhere or in another specialty

Your priority is not just conversion, but maximizing your growth and competitiveness over that year.

2. How can I tell if a program is truly IMG-friendly and not just saying so?

Look for objective evidence, not just friendly wording:

• Current or recent residents who are IMGs (check their medical schools)
• Alumni lists that include IMGs and show successful placements afterward
• Online testimonials from IMGs, especially US citizen IMGs
• Transparent interview and selection criteria (e.g., no stated bans on IMGs)

If a program’s website claims to welcome diversity but has no IMGs listed anywhere, treat it cautiously.

3. Is it worth emailing programs to ask about prelim-to-categorical opportunities?

Yes—if done professionally and selectively. It can yield important information not obvious on websites.

Guidelines:

• Email the program coordinator or director with a concise message
• Introduce yourself (US citizen IMG, school, graduation year)
• Ask 1–2 specific, respectful questions, such as:
  • “In recent years, have any preliminary surgery residents transitioned to categorical positions at your institution or elsewhere?”
  • “How does your program support prelim residents in pursuing categorical general surgery or other specialties?”

Use their reply to adjust your expectations and program ranking.

4. How many preliminary surgery programs should a US citizen IMG apply to?

The number varies by your competitiveness (scores, attempts, USCE, letters) and risk tolerance, but many US citizen IMGs target:

• 20–40+ prelim surgery programs if focusing heavily on surgery
• More if:
  • You have red flags (exam failures, long gaps, limited USCE)
  • You’re targeting highly competitive regions or academic centers

Combine this with a realistic mix of program tiers and consider dual-applying to another specialty if your long-term goal is flexible.

---

By approaching your search with a clear program research strategy, disciplined data gathering, and honest self-assessment, you can move beyond guesswork and anxiety. As a US citizen IMG pursuing a preliminary surgery residency, you are not just looking for any position—you are looking for the right environment to prove yourself, grow clinically, and open doors for the rest of your career. Use the tools and steps above to make informed, strategic decisions that align with both your short-term needs and long-term goals.