The Ultimate Guide to Timing Your Job Search in Orthopedic Surgery

Understanding the Timeline: When Orthopedic Surgeons Should Start the Job Search

Orthopedic surgery residents and fellows often ask the same question: “When should I start my job search?” In a specialty with a competitive physician job market, evolving reimbursement models, and growing consolidation, your timing can strongly influence your options, leverage, and long-term career satisfaction.

The key challenge is that there’s no single universal date circled on the calendar. Instead, the “right” time depends on:

• Whether you’re going straight into practice after residency vs. doing a fellowship
• Your subspecialty (e.g., sports, spine, joints, trauma, hand, pediatrics, oncology)
• Geographic preferences and flexibility
• Academic vs. private practice vs. hospital-employed targets
• Visa status and personal/family factors

This guide breaks down optimal job search timing in orthopedic surgery from PGY-3 all the way through attending life, with practical, stepwise recommendations.

We’ll cover:

• How early to start exploring the ortho job market
• A year-by-year (and later, month-by-month) timeline
• Fellowship vs. direct-to-practice timing differences
• When to sign a contract—and when to hold off
• How timing affects leverage, pay, and lifestyle
• Post-residency and attending job search strategies

Whether you’re still in orthopedic surgery residency, mid-fellowship, or already on your first attending contract, this roadmap will help you approach the ortho match to practice transition thoughtfully and strategically.

---

Big Picture: How the Orthopedic Job Market Really Works

Before the calendar details, it helps to understand a few structural realities of the physician job market in orthopedic surgery:

1. Hiring Cycles Are Longer Than You Think

Most orthopedic groups and hospital systems:

• Plan hiring needs 12–24 months in advance
• Move slowly with approvals, budgeting, and admin sign-off
• May take 3–9 months from first contact to signed contract
• Often want new hires to start aligned with fiscal years or academic cycles (e.g., July 1)

This means that waiting until spring of your final year to start your attending job search can drastically narrow your choices, especially in desirable locations or competitive subspecialties.

2. Geography and Subspecialty Dramatically Affect Timing

In general:

• Rural / underserved areas

  • Start looking: later acceptable
  • Often recruit aggressively and early
  • More flexibility and faster offers

• Major metro / high-demand cities

  • Start looking: earlier required (sometimes 18–24 months out)
  • Intensely competitive; groups may “fill” years in advance

• High-volume and saturated subspecialties (sports, spine, adult reconstruction in top cities)

  • Earlier timing gives you access to the few high-quality positions that open

• Highly specialized niches (orthopedic oncology, complex pediatrics, tumor/spine hybrids)

  • Fewer jobs overall → you must start early and cast a wide net

3. The Market Is Consolidating

Compared with 10–15 years ago, the current orthopedic surgery physician job market is:

• More consolidated: large health systems, multi-specialty groups, and private equity-backed ortho groups
• More structured: standardized compensation models, RVU plans, and non-compete clauses
• Less ad-hoc: fewer informal “handshake” jobs; more formal recruitment pipelines

This makes planning, timing, and due diligence critical. You rarely “stumble into” the perfect opportunity late in PGY-5.

---

Year‑by‑Year Roadmap: From Mid-Residency to First Attending Job

Think of your job search not as a single event, but as a multi-year process that gradually shifts from exploration to action.

PGY‑2 to Early PGY‑3: Foundation and Exploration

You’re not signing contracts yet—but this is the ideal time to:

1. Clarify Career Direction

   • Identify interests: sports, spine, joints, trauma, hand, foot & ankle, pediatrics, oncology, shoulder & elbow, etc.
   • Ask: “Do I see myself in academics, private practice, or hospital-employed work?”
   • Reflect on preferences: urban vs. suburban vs. rural; call tolerance; trauma vs. elective-heavy.

2. Strengthen Your CV

   • Get involved in subspecialty research or QI projects.
   • Go to national meetings (AAOS, subspecialty societies) and start networking.
   • Seek mentors in both academic and private practice environments.

3. Learn the Landscape

   • Informally browse job boards (AAOS, subspecialty societies, large recruitment firms).
   • Talk to senior residents/fellows about when they started their job search and what worked.

Actionable Tip: Create a running “career notebook” (digital or paper) with three lists:

• Preferred regions/cities
• Practice types you find appealing (and why)
• Deal-breakers (e.g., >1-hr commute, every-other-night call, heavy trauma late in career)

PGY‑3 to Early PGY‑4: Fellowship Decision and Market Awareness

The fellowship decision and job search timing are deeply linked.

1. Decide on Fellowship vs. Direct-to-Practice

   • Most new orthopedic surgeons complete at least one fellowship.
   • In some markets, general ortho jobs are still available, but subspecialty training often improves:
     • Marketability
     • Starting salary and long-term earning potential
     • Job flexibility and geographic options

2. Understand How Fellowship Affects Job Search Timing

   • If you will go directly into practice after residency:
     • You should target serious job search activity by mid-PGY-4
   • If you do a fellowship:
     • You’ll start your attending job search during fellowship, not residency
     • But you still benefit from early networking and understanding the market now

3. Light Networking with Purpose

   • Attend conferences with intent: talk to faculty from other institutions, private groups, and hospital reps.
   • Use this time to gather market intel:
     • What are typical call structures?
     • How quickly can new surgeons build a practice?
     • How saturated is your subspecialty in a given city?

PGY‑4 to PGY‑5: If You’re Going Straight into Practice

If you plan to enter the workforce right after residency, your timeline is earlier than those pursuing fellowship.

Approximate timeline:

• 18–24 months before graduation

  • Begin serious market research: location, practice type, salary ranges
  • Start updating CV, LinkedIn (if you use it), and personal statement (if relevant)
  • Attend AAOS and subspecialty meetings with a focus on potential employers

• 12–18 months before graduation

  • Proactively contact groups in target locations
  • Respond to recruiter outreach more selectively
  • Schedule informal calls and site visits

• 9–12 months before graduation

  • Aim to have multiple active conversations and at least a few offers under development
  • Begin contract negotiations and legal review

• 6–9 months before graduation

  • Reasonable window to sign a contract
  • Later signing is possible, especially in rural or high-need areas, but your choice set narrows

For most residents going straight into practice, starting the attending job search in earnest by early PGY‑4 is ideal.

---

Job Search Timing for Fellows: The Most Common Pathway

Because most orthopedic surgeons now pursue fellowship training, the fellowship-to-attending transition deserves special focus.

Fellowship Year: A Compressed and Critical Window

You will often be expected to:

• Learn advanced surgical skills
• Build subspecialty independence
• Network and engage with subspecialty societies
• Conduct or complete research
• And run a full attending job search—all within 12 months

That’s why you cannot afford to delay.

When to Start Job Search During Fellowship

A practical guideline:

• 3–6 months before fellowship begins

  • Light exploration: define target regions and practice models
  • Reach out to mentors about contacts in those areas

• Fellowship Month 1–3

  • Set up your CV and references
  • Attend early conferences and signal your interest in graduating positions
  • Answer: Academic vs. private practice vs. hospital-employed?

• Fellowship Month 3–6 (often the sweet spot)

  • Begin active job search:
    • Reach out to private groups and hospital systems in your target areas
    • Engage with recruiters (selectively)
    • Schedule initial phone calls and virtual interviews

• Fellowship Month 6–9

  • Go on in-person site visits
  • Narrow your top 3–5 options
  • Engage in contract negotiations, have attorneys review contracts

• Fellowship Month 9–12

  • Finalize and sign your contract
  • Arrange licensure, credentialing, malpractice, and relocation details

In many cases, prime jobs are essentially “spoken for” between Month 3–9 of fellowship, especially in popular cities or subspecialties. Starting your attending job search after January of your fellowship year (for a July start) is possible but often limiting.

Academic vs. Private Practice vs. Hospital-Employed Timing

• Academic jobs

  • Can open early, often with multiple layers of approval
  • May have longer interview and negotiation sequences
  • Best to start exploring by early fellowship, especially for prestigious programs

• Private practice (orthopedic groups)

  • Some recruit a year or more in advance
  • Others hire opportunistically if a partner leaves or demand surges
  • You gain leverage by contacting them early when they haven’t “anchored” on a specific candidate

• Hospital-employed or large health systems

  • Often have slow HR-driven processes
  • Approvals can take months; background checks and credentialing add more time
  • Starting no later than Month 6 of fellowship is advisable

---

Month‑by‑Month Countdown: The Final Year Before Practice

Once you are within 12 months of your intended start date, your timing needs to be more structured.

Below is a countdown template you can customize whether you’re a finishing resident (no fellowship) or a fellow nearing the end of training.

12 Months Out

• Clarify non-negotiables:

  • Geographic regions
  • Practice model (academic, private, employed)
  • Rough call expectations and lifestyle

• Update your CV and prepare:

  • A brief professional bio
  • A one-page “case mix” summary if relevant (especially for subspecialty jobs)

• Begin broad outreach:

  • Email practice administrators and department chairs in your desired areas
  • Register with 1–3 reputable physician recruiters (avoid being over-represented or “shopped” too widely)
  • Attend national meetings and explicitly mention you’re seeking a position for the upcoming cycle

9–10 Months Out

• First wave of phone/virtual interviews
• Start prioritizing:
  • Top 5–7 geographic/practice type combinations
• Ask detailed questions about:
  • Volume expectations
  • Call schedule
  • Partnership track or promotion metrics
  • Onboarding support (marketing, referrals, OR time)

6–9 Months Out

• Complete on-site visits for serious prospects

• Compare:

  • Case mix and growth potential
  • Culture and mentorship
  • Support for building a subspecialty niche

• Begin receiving initial offers:

  • Compensation structure (MGMA benchmarking, RVUs, collections, base + bonus)
  • Contract terms (non-compete, tail coverage, partnership buy-in, call pay)

• Engage an attorney with physician contract experience—early enough to negotiate meaningfully.

3–6 Months Out

• You should have a signed contract or be in final negotiation with at least one viable option.
• Use this time to:
  • Complete state licensure applications
  • Start hospital credentialing and payer enrollment
  • Arrange relocation logistics if you’re moving

Waiting to sign within <3 months of graduation is occasionally unavoidable, but you risk:

• Fewer choices and weaker leverage
• Compressed licensing and credentialing timelines
• Delayed start dates and lost income

---

How Timing Affects Leverage, Pay, and Lifestyle

Your timing in the attending job search has direct consequences for:

1. Negotiating Power

Starting early (e.g., Month 3–6 of fellowship):

• You evaluate multiple offers side by side
• You can credibly say: “I’m considering several positions in [region], here’s what I’m seeing elsewhere.”
• Employers are less desperate, but also less anchored—they may be more willing to adjust:
  • Base salary
  • RVU thresholds
  • Call expectations
  • Signing bonuses, relocation assistance

Starting very late (e.g., Month 10–12 of fellowship):

• Some of the best openings may already be filled
• Employers know you have less time, which can reduce your leverage
• You may accept suboptimal terms because you feel pressured

2. Geographic Flexibility

If you insist on a very narrow geographic area (e.g., one major city or even one side of town):

• You need to start earlier
• You must be prepared to wait longer, potentially work in a nearby area first, or accept trade-offs:
  • Lower pay
  • More call
  • Less ideal case mix

If you are geographically flexible, you can:

• Start a bit later
• Leverage rural or mid-sized city opportunities, which often:
  • Pay more
  • Offer quicker path to volume and partnership
  • Provide significant signing bonuses or loan repayment

3. Career Trajectory and Burnout Risk

Poorly timed or rushed decisions can lead to:

• Joining a group that doesn’t support your subspecialty
• Mismatched call or trauma expectations
• Toxic culture or lack of partnership transparency

This, in turn, can drive:

• Early burnout
• Rapid job changes within the first 1–3 years
• Financial and professional disruption

Thoughtful timing helps you align your first attending role with your long-term goals, not just your immediate need for a paycheck.

---

Post‑Residency and Mid‑Career: When to Start Your Next Job Search

The question of when to start your job search doesn’t end once you sign your first contract. Many orthopedic surgeons change jobs within their first few years for better fit, pay, or location.

When to Re-Evaluate Your Position

You should consider reassessing your role and the wider physician job market if:

• You’re approaching the end of a 3–5 year initial contract, especially one with:

  • Looming non-compete clauses
  • Partnership decisions
  • Significant changes in compensation terms

• Your group is undergoing:

  • Merger or acquisition (e.g., private equity buyout)
  • Leadership turnover
  • Sudden changes to call, work RVU targets, or ancillary distribution

• You feel persistent misalignment in:

  • Culture and values
  • OR block access
  • Subspecialty case mix

When to Start a New Attending Job Search

A reasonable rule of thumb:

• Start exploring 12–18 months before your current contract ends or any non-compete term becomes effective.

This allows time to:

• Understand your local and regional options
• Identify whether relocation is necessary due to non-compete restrictions
• Negotiate from a position of strength rather than panic

Tactical Steps for the Mid‑Career Search

• Quietly update your CV and discreetly signal to trusted colleagues that you’re open to new roles.
• Reconnect with mentors, fellowship directors, and residency contacts—they often know of unadvertised openings.
• Contact orthopedic-specific recruiters who understand:
  • Your subspecialty
  • Regional dynamics
  • Compensation trends for surgeons at your career stage

Knowing when to start job search as a mid-career attending is as much about protecting your leverage and family stability as it is about improving compensation.

---

Practical Do’s and Don’ts for Job Search Timing in Orthopedic Surgery

Do

• Start early:

  • Residents going directly into practice: serious search by mid-PGY‑4
  • Fellows: serious search by Month 3–6 of fellowship

• Use conferences strategically:

  • AAOS, subspecialty meetings, and regional conferences are prime networking grounds
  • Schedule short, intentional meetings with potential employers or mentors

• Engage mentors early:

  • Ask: “When do you recommend I start my search for my situation?”
  • Request introductions to their trusted contacts in your target areas

• Plan for licensure and credentialing delays:

  • Some states can take 3–6+ months for a new license
  • Hospitals and ASCs have variable timelines

Don’t

• Wait until winter of your final year to begin all outreach
• Assume that “something will come up nearby” if you have a very narrow geographic target
• Overcommit to recruiters who:
  • Push you aggressively toward one job
  • Don’t understand orthopedic-specific nuances
• Sign a contract without:
  • Comparing to at least a couple of other real options when possible
  • Having a physician contract attorney review it

---

FAQs: Job Search Timing in Orthopedic Surgery

1. When should I start my job search if I’m an orthopedic surgery resident going straight into practice?

If you are not doing a fellowship, you should begin your attending job search in earnest by early PGY‑4, about 18–24 months before graduation. By 9–12 months before graduation, you should be in active interviews and evaluating offers, aiming to sign a contract 6–9 months before your start date.

2. As an ortho fellow, when is the ideal time to secure my first attending job?

For most orthopedic surgery fellows, the ideal window to start serious outreach and interviews is Month 3–6 of fellowship. You should be going on site visits and negotiating offers by Month 6–9, and aim to sign your contract 3–6 months before the end of fellowship. Starting later can still work, but your options may be more limited, especially in high-demand areas.

3. How does my subspecialty affect job search timing?

Subspecialties like sports medicine, adult reconstruction, and spine in large metro areas can be quite competitive—start earlier and cast a wider geographic net. More niche fields (e.g., orthopedic oncology, complex pediatrics) have fewer total positions, so early outreach (even before fellowship) and broad geographic flexibility can be essential.

4. When should I start planning my next job search as an attending?

If you’re considering leaving a position or your initial 3–5 year contract is nearing its end, begin evaluating your options 12–18 months before any contract expiration or non-compete trigger. This timing gives you enough runway to explore the market, negotiate new terms (either where you are or elsewhere), and manage licensing, credentialing, and family logistics without rushing.

---

By approaching your orthopedic surgery residency and fellowship years with a clear, proactive strategy for job search timing, you position yourself to enter the physician job market with maximum choice, leverage, and alignment between your training, your career goals, and your life outside the OR.