Essential Interview Questions for DO Graduates in Preliminary Surgery Residency

Understanding the Preliminary Surgery Interview for DO Graduates

For a DO graduate, the prelim surgery residency interview can feel uniquely high-stakes. You may be navigating both the dynamics of a one-year preliminary surgery year and lingering misconceptions about osteopathic training. Programs want to know: Will you be safe, hard-working, and adaptable enough to handle a demanding surgical service for a year—and will you reflect well on their program?

This article focuses on common interview questions for a DO graduate pursuing a preliminary surgery residency, with a strong emphasis on behavioral interview medical questions, how to structure your answers, and how to subtly but effectively advocate for your osteopathic background.

We’ll cover:

• How prelim surgery interviews differ from categorical surgery
• Core “classic” questions (including “Tell me about yourself”)
• Behavioral and situational questions you’re likely to encounter
• Questions specific to DO graduates and osteopathic training
• Smart questions you should ask the program
• A brief FAQ

---

The Context: DO Graduate in a Preliminary Surgery Year

Before diving into specific residency interview questions, it helps to understand what programs are really assessing during a prelim surgery residency interview.

What Programs Want in a Preliminary Surgery Resident

Compared with categorical residents, prelims are often:

• Filling service and call needs
• Coming from more diverse backgrounds (e.g., DO, IMGs, career-changers)
• Aiming for future surgical specialties (e.g., ENT, urology, neurosurgery, radiology, anesthesia) or categorical general surgery spots

Programs often focus on whether you will:

1. Be reliable and low-drama
   • Show up on time, complete notes, return pages, follow through.
2. Handle heavy workload and stress
   • Long hours, high-acuity patients, emotional cases.
3. Work well in a team
   • Communicate clearly with residents, attendings, and nursing.
4. Respond well to feedback and hierarchy
   • Accept direction from seniors and learn quickly.
5. Represent the program professionally
   • With patients, consultants, and other services.

As a DO graduate, you’ll also sometimes be implicitly evaluated for:

• Your comfort working in predominantly MD environments
• How you present and defend your osteopathic background without sounding defensive
• Your understanding of ACGME and osteopathic recognition, if relevant

A strong approach is to treat every major question as a chance to demonstrate stability, teachability, and team-mindedness.

---

Classic Residency Interview Questions (and How to Answer Them)

These are versions of questions asked in nearly every osteopathic residency match interview—especially in surgery. Your answers should be polished but not robotic.

1. “Tell me about yourself.”

This is often the first and most important question. It sets the tone and is your chance to frame your story as a DO graduate pursuing a preliminary surgery year.

Goals:

• Provide a concise narrative: who you are, where you’re from, why medicine, why surgery, why prelim.
• Signal that you are grounded, mature, and focused.
• Briefly highlight what differentiates you as a DO graduate (e.g., holistic perspective, early hands-on training).

Structure (2–3 minutes max):

1. Background (origin, relevant personal context)
2. Path to medicine and osteopathic school
3. Path to surgery and reasoning for a prelim year
4. Key strengths you bring to a surgical team

Example (adapt this, don’t memorize):

“I grew up in a small town in Ohio and was drawn to medicine early after seeing how limited access to surgical care affected my community. I chose osteopathic medical school because the holistic approach and strong emphasis on physical diagnosis aligned with how I wanted to care for patients.

During my third-year rotations, my surgery clerkship stood out— I loved the intensity of the OR, the need for precise teamwork, and the immediacy of helping patients in crisis. I’m pursuing a preliminary surgery residency because I want a rigorous surgical year to strengthen my clinical and operative fundamentals while I continue to explore general surgery and surgical subspecialties.

I bring a strong work ethic, clear communication style, and a DO background that emphasizes person-centered care and physical exam skills. I’ve consistently been someone my teams rely on to keep the list organized, follow up on tasks, and remain calm during busy call nights. I’m excited about the opportunity to contribute meaningfully to your team this year.”

Notice that this answer subtly integrates the keyword phrase “preliminary surgery residency” and reinforces that you have a focused, realistic goal.

---

2. “Why surgery?” and “Why a preliminary surgery year?”

Programs want to see that you understand what you’re getting into and that your choice of a preliminary surgery year is intentional—not just a fallback.

For “Why surgery?” focus on:

• Specific experiences that made surgery resonate with you
• Features of surgical practice you genuinely enjoy
• Traits you have that match the field (decisiveness, manual skills, teamwork)

For “Why prelim?” be honest but strategic:

Common scenarios:

• You’re applying to a surgical subspecialty (e.g., ENT, neurosurgery) and using a prelim surgery residency as a bridge.
• You hope to convert to a categorical surgery spot.
• You want robust surgical exposure before deciding long-term.

Example angle:

“I’m pursuing a preliminary surgery year because I want intensive, hands-on training in surgical decision-making, perioperative management, and emergency care. Long-term, I’m interested in [general surgery / a surgical subspecialty], and I see this year as a way to deepen my clinical foundation, prove I can thrive in a demanding environment, and contribute meaningfully to a surgical service. I understand the hours and expectations that come with a prelim surgery year and I’m prepared for that.”

Avoid: “I just want to do something surgical this year” or “I didn’t match categorical so I had to do something.” You can acknowledge not matching, but quickly pivot to what you plan to gain and contribute.

---

3. “Why our program?”

Your answer should show:

• You’ve done real research.
• You understand how prelims are integrated (or sidelined).
• You know how this program fits your goals.

Elements to include:

• Case volume and pathology
• Culture of teaching and feedback
• Integration of prelims into teams and conferences
• Opportunities for research or subspecialty exposure
• Location/family/support considerations

Example:

“I’m drawn to your prelim surgery residency because prelims here seem fully integrated into the clinical teams and conferences, rather than being separate. The high operative volume in trauma and emergency general surgery would give me broad exposure early, and your residents consistently describe a supportive culture where seniors and attendings are approachable and invested in teaching. As a DO graduate, I also appreciate that you’ve trained residents from both DO and MD backgrounds successfully. It feels like a place where I could work hard, learn a lot, and add real value to the service.”

---

4. “What are your strengths and weaknesses?”

For strengths, emphasize qualities vital in a busy surgical service:

• Reliability and follow-through
• Efficient task management
• Calm under pressure
• Clear communication
• Willingness to ask for help appropriately

For weaknesses, choose something real but improvable, and show a concrete plan you’ve used to improve. Avoid clichés like “I care too much” or “I’m a perfectionist” unless you can ground them in specific behavioral changes.

Example weakness:

“Early in third year, I tended to take on too many tasks without clarifying priorities, which sometimes led to delays in completing less urgent work. After feedback from my senior, I started using a more structured task list with clear time estimates and checking in with the senior at key points to confirm what needed to be done first. I’ve become more efficient and better at communicating about time-sensitive tasks. I still work on this, but my evaluations now often mention my organization as a strength.”

---

High-Yield Behavioral Interview Questions in Surgery

Many programs increasingly use a behavioral interview medical approach: asking about past experiences as a predictor of future performance. These are often framed as:

• “Tell me about a time when…”
• “Give me an example of…”
• “Describe a situation where…”

Use the STAR method:

• Situation – Brief context
• Task – Your responsibility
• Action – What you did
• Result – Outcome and what you learned

1. Teamwork and Communication

Common questions:

• “Tell me about a time you had a conflict with a team member. How did you handle it?”
• “Describe a time when you had to work with a difficult colleague.”
• “Tell me about a time you received critical feedback.”

Example framework (conflict with a team member):

• Situation: Busy inpatient rotation; disagreement with another student or resident.
• Task: Maintain patient care and team functioning.
• Action: You sought clarification, communicated respectfully, and prioritized patient safety.
• Result: Improved communication and working relationship, plus reflection on your own communication style.

Key themes to highlight:

• Respect for hierarchy but willingness to speak up for patient safety.
• Ability to de-escalate and collaborate.
• Emotional control in tense situations.

2. Handling Stress and High Workload

Preliminary surgery is notorious for long hours and heavy service loads. Expect questions like:

• “Tell me about a time you were overwhelmed. What did you do?”
• “Describe the most stressful clinical situation you’ve faced.”
• “How do you cope with fatigue and maintain performance?”

Your answers should show:

• Situational awareness: you recognized early that you were getting overwhelmed.
• Use of systems: lists, checklists, calling for help when appropriate.
• Healthy coping: brief breaks, debriefing, support systems, but not substance use or denial.

Example:

“On my surgery clerkship, we had an unusually heavy census plus post-op add-ons. I realized I was losing track of minor tasks, so I created a prioritized to-do list on rounds and double-checked with the intern about what needed to be done urgently versus what could wait. I also made a point to step away for a five-minute reset when I felt myself getting frazzled. By organizing my work and communicating more proactively, I was able to complete my tasks and avoid missing critical items. It reinforced for me how important structured workflow and early communication are, especially in a busy surgical environment.”

3. Dealing with Mistakes and Near-Misses

Programs need to know you can own and learn from errors.

Expect:

• “Tell me about a time you made a mistake.”
• “Describe a time you missed something important.”
• “Tell me about a clinical situation you wish you had handled differently.”

Guidelines:

• Choose something real but not catastrophic (e.g., delayed lab follow-up, incomplete note, missed recalcitrant vital sign).
• Emphasize immediate transparency, corrective action, and learning.
• Avoid blaming others; acknowledge your role.

4. Professionalism and Difficult Interactions

Sample questions:

• “Tell me about a time you had to give bad news or discuss a difficult topic with a patient or family.”
• “Describe a time when you saw something unprofessional. What did you do?”
• “Have you ever been in a situation that challenged your ethics? How did you respond?”

Your responses should show:

• Respectful communication, especially with distressed patients/families.
• Awareness of professional standards and institutional policies.
• Willingness to seek guidance from seniors/attendings when needed.

---

DO-Specific and Osteopathic-Focused Questions

As a DO graduate going through the osteopathic residency match or ACGME surgery match, you may face explicit or subtle questions about your background.

1. “Why did you choose an osteopathic medical school?”

This is an opportunity to positively frame your training.

Possible elements:

• Interest in holistic care and biomechanics
• Desire for strong clinical/physical exam training
• Program fit and mentorship at your DO school

Example:

“I chose an osteopathic school because the emphasis on holistic, patient-centered care and the musculoskeletal system matched how I approach medicine. Our curriculum had a strong focus on physical diagnosis and early clinical exposure, which I’ve found very valuable on rotations. That background has helped me think broadly about patients’ functional status and recovery, which is especially relevant in surgery.”

2. “How has your DO training prepared you for surgery?”

Highlight:

• Early and extensive clinical contact with patients
• Emphasis on structural/functional relationships and rehab considerations
• Experience with hands-on skills and manual dexterity
• Adaptability from working across varied clinical environments

You can note OMM/OMT where appropriate, but don’t over-focus on manipulative techniques in a surgical interview unless asked.

3. “Do you plan to use OMT in your surgical practice?”

For many prelim surgery residency programs, they simply want to know if you’re realistic.

Balanced answer:

“My primary focus in a surgical setting will be on operative and perioperative care. That said, my OMT background influences how I assess patients’ musculoskeletal function, pain, and mobility. In some non-acute settings, gentle techniques may be appropriate adjuncts, but I understand that in the OR and perioperative environment, standard surgical and medical management will be my primary tools.”

4. Subtle Bias and How to Respond

You may encounter veiled questions along the lines of:

• “Do you feel at a disadvantage compared with MD graduates?”
• “Do you think your training was equivalent to MD programs?”

Stay composed and factual. Emphasize:

• Your clinical performance and evaluations
• Your success on standardized exams
• The value-added aspects of your DO education
• Your adaptability in mixed DO/MD environments

Avoid sounding defensive; redirect to your competence, work ethic, and learning mindset.

---

Surgery-Specific and Scenario-Based Questions

Beyond behavioral questions, expect targeted questions related to surgical thinking, communication, and the realities of a prelim surgery residency.

1. “Walk me through how you would pre-op a patient for surgery.”

They want to see your systematic approach. Even as a prelim, you should outline:

• Confirm indication and surgical plan
• History (comorbidities, medications, allergies)
• Physical exam, especially airway, cardiac, pulmonary, operative site
• Labs and imaging as appropriate
• NPO status, anticoagulation management
• Informed consent (risks/benefits/alternatives)
• Coordination with anesthesia and nursing

You’re not expected to be fully independent, but you should show organized thinking and awareness of safety.

2. “How do you handle a situation when you disagree with your senior about a patient’s care?”

Focus on:

• Respect for hierarchy, but responsibility to patient safety
• Private clarification and discussion
• Escalation only when truly necessary, done calmly and respectfully

Example approach:

“I would first ask to clarify the reasoning behind their plan, to be sure I fully understand it. If I still had serious concerns, I’d respectfully share my perspective and any data that supports it, making clear that my goal is patient safety. If the issue remained unresolved and I believed there was a significant risk to the patient, I’d consider involving the attending in a non-confrontational way, but I’d be very careful about tone and timing. In most cases, I’ve found that simply asking for clarification resolves the disagreement.”

3. “How would you handle a nurse who calls you repeatedly about a patient you feel is stable?”

They’re testing professionalism and interprofessional respect.

Answer should include:

• Acknowledging the nurse’s perspective and bedside proximity.
• Going to see the patient rather than dismissing calls.
• Communicating clearly about what findings would prompt escalation.
• Documenting if appropriate and updating the team.

---

Smart Questions You Should Ask Programs

Your questions at the end of the interview matter. They show you understand the realities of a preliminary surgery year and are thinking practically.

Topics to consider:

1. Role and Integration of Prelim Residents

• “How are prelim residents integrated into your teams compared with categorical residents?”
• “Do prelims participate fully in didactics, M&M, and simulation training?”
• “What types of rotations are typical for prelim residents here?”

2. Culture and Support

• “How does the program support residents during especially challenging rotations or periods of high stress?”
• “Can you describe the typical relationship between prelims and categorical residents?”

3. Outcomes After the Prelim Year

• “What have your recent prelim graduates gone on to do—categorical positions, fellowships, other specialties?”
• “Are there opportunities for prelims to be considered for categorical positions if they become available?”

4. Practical Details and Autonomy

• “How is operative experience allocated between prelim and categorical residents?”
• “What level of responsibility can a prelim realistically expect in the OR and on the wards?”

These questions demonstrate that you understand the prelim surgery residency is a demanding, time-limited opportunity and that you are seriously evaluating program fit.

---

Putting It All Together: Preparation Strategy for DO Graduates

To excel in your osteopathic residency match interviews for a preliminary surgery residency, build a focused preparation plan:

1. Write out and refine your answers to:
   • “Tell me about yourself”
   • “Why surgery?” and “Why a preliminary surgery year?”
   • “Why our program?”
   • 2–3 strengths and 1–2 weaknesses
2. Prepare 6–8 behavioral examples using STAR:
   • Team conflict
   • Handling stress/overload
   • Receiving critical feedback
   • Making or witnessing a mistake
   • Difficult patient/family interaction
   • Ethical or professionalism challenge
3. Anticipate DO-specific questions and practice confident, non-defensive answers.
4. Review basic surgical and perioperative concepts so that scenario-based questions don’t catch you off guard.
5. Practice aloud:
   • With peers, advisors, or mentors (ideally with surgical experience)
   • In front of a mirror or recorded on video for self-review
6. Develop a list of thoughtful questions for each program, tailored to prelim-specific issues.

By the time you’re answering residency interview questions in front of a panel, you want your responses to feel like polished stories—not memorized scripts.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a DO graduate, am I at a disadvantage applying for a preliminary surgery residency?

You may encounter more scrutiny of your training background at some programs, but many surgery programs have trained DO graduates successfully. Your best strategy is to:

• Demonstrate strong clinical performance and solid letters.
• Highlight your holistic training and hands-on experience.
• Show that you function well in mixed DO/MD environments.
• Address any standardized exam or transcript issues proactively if asked.

Programs largely care whether you’ll be a reliable, hardworking, team-oriented prelim, not just your degree letters.

2. How is a preliminary surgery year different from a categorical surgery position?

A preliminary surgery year:

• Is typically a 1-year contract without guaranteed continuation.
• Often includes more off-service or service-heavy rotations.
• May offer variable OR exposure depending on the program.
• Is frequently used as a bridge to categorical surgery or other specialties (e.g., anesthesia, radiology, urology).

A categorical position:

• Is a multi-year track aimed at completing full general surgery training.
• Usually prioritizes long-term development, research, and leadership roles.

In interviews, show you understand these differences and are entering the prelim surgery residency with realistic expectations.

3. Should I mention that I hope to obtain a categorical spot after my prelim year?

Yes, but with nuance. Many prelims hope to transition to categorical positions; it’s not a secret. You can say:

• You are open to a categorical spot if it becomes available and you’re a good fit.
• Your immediate commitment is to give your best to the team during this one-year role.
• You understand there is no guarantee of conversion.

Avoid sounding entitled to a categorical slot; focus on earning opportunities through performance.

4. What if I’m asked a residency interview question I truly don’t know how to answer?

Admit uncertainty briefly, then pivot to your thinking process:

• “I haven’t encountered that exact scenario, but here’s how I’d approach it…”
• Use core principles: patient safety, communication, escalation to seniors, and use of protocols.
• For non-clinical questions, take a short pause, gather your thoughts, and then structure your response with the STAR method if applicable.

Interviewers often value honesty and reasoning more than perfect recall. Showing you can think aloud in a structured, safety-focused way is exactly what they want in a prelim resident.

---

By anticipating these common interview questions for a DO graduate in preliminary surgery and preparing clear, structured, and authentic responses, you position yourself as a mature, dependable applicant ready for the intensity of a prelim surgery year—and for the next steps in your surgical career.