Mastering Common Interview Questions for DO Graduates in Orthopedic Surgery

Orthopedic surgery residency interviews are among the most competitive and high‑stakes experiences a DO graduate will face. Beyond board scores and rotation evaluations, your success often hinges on how effectively you answer common residency interview questions—especially behavioral and situational ones.

This guide focuses on common interview questions for DO graduates in orthopedic surgery, how to answer them strategically, and how to navigate subtle challenges DO applicants often face in an MD‑dominated field. You’ll find examples, frameworks, and sample answers tailored to the osteopathic residency match environment and to the current unified ortho match landscape.

---

Understanding the Orthopedic Surgery Residency Interview Landscape as a DO

Orthopedic surgery is highly competitive, and as a DO graduate, you bring unique strengths—hands‑on training, holistic patient care perspective, and often robust clinical exposure. At the same time, you may still encounter:

• Subtle bias or curiosity about your DO degree
• Questions about board choices (COMLEX vs. USMLE)
• Assumptions about your operative exposure or research background

Interviewers will rarely be overtly negative, but their residency interview questions may be designed to probe:

• Your clinical judgment and maturity
• Your grit, resilience, and ability to handle long hours
• Your alignment with the culture of their orthopedic department
• How you collaborate within high‑functioning surgical teams
• How your DO background fits into their program’s training model

Most interviews mix:

1. Traditional questions (e.g., “Tell me about yourself”)
2. Behavioral interview medical questions (e.g., “Tell me about a time you made a mistake with a patient.”)
3. Situational/ethical questions (e.g., “What would you do if you saw a resident cutting corners in the OR?”)
4. Program‑ and specialty‑specific questions (e.g., “Why orthopedic surgery?” “Why our program?”)

The key is not to memorize exact answers, but to prepare structures, stories, and themes that you can flexibly apply to similar questions.

---

Core Personal Questions: Your Story, Identity, and Motivation

These early questions set the tone. As a DO candidate, they are also a chance to establish credibility and confidence from the very first minute.

1. “Tell me about yourself.”

This is almost guaranteed. It’s not casual chit‑chat; it’s your 30–60 second pitch.

Goals:

• Present a clear, professional narrative
• Highlight your path to orthopedic surgery
• Subtly reinforce the strengths of your DO training
• Set up themes they can ask more about (research, leadership, service)

Simple structure (Past → Present → Future):

1. Past: Where you’re from, key formative experiences, why medicine
2. Present: DO school, major interests, research, sub‑internships
3. Future: Why ortho, what kind of surgeon/trainee you aim to be

Example (DO‑specific, condensed):

I grew up in a small town in Ohio in a family that owned a hardware store, so from an early age I enjoyed working with my hands and solving practical problems. In college I studied kinesiology and volunteered with a high school football team, where seeing athletes recover from injuries sparked my interest in musculoskeletal medicine.

I chose osteopathic medical school because I valued the emphasis on holistic care and the musculoskeletal system. During my third‑year rotations, I was drawn to orthopedic surgery for the combination of biomechanics, anatomy, and the ability to restore function in a very tangible way. I pursued away rotations in sports and trauma, completed research on outcomes after ACL reconstruction, and I’ve been active in tutoring junior students in anatomy and OMM.

Long term, I see myself as a community‑focused orthopedic surgeon with a strong interest in sports medicine, working in a program that values teaching, team‑based care, and mentorship. That’s what attracted me to your residency.

Practice this answer aloud until it’s natural—but not robotic.

---

2. “Why orthopedic surgery?”

This question is central in any orthopedic surgery residency interview and almost always comes early.

Common pitfalls:

• Overly generic answers (“I like working with my hands”)
• Focusing solely on sports injuries or your personal ACL tear
• Not showing understanding of the realities: call, trauma, long hours

Stronger elements to include:

• Exposure: Specific clinical moments/rotations that convinced you
• Fit: The type of thinking and environment where you thrive
• Reality check: Acknowledgment of the demands of the field
• Impact: How orthopedics aligns with your values and long‑term goals

Example points you might weave together:

• Enjoy problem‑solving and biomechanics
• Like immediate, tangible results of interventions
• Appreciate long‑term patient relationships (e.g., joint replacement follow‑up)
• Value team‑based care in the OR and trauma bay
• Understand lifestyle trade‑offs and are prepared for the workload

---

3. “Why did you choose a DO school?” / “How has your osteopathic training shaped you?”

Especially in the osteopathic residency match–era evolving into the unified match, DO candidates may still see this question.

Your aims:

• Frame your DO choice as intentional and positive
• Highlight skills/values that make you a strong ortho resident
• Avoid sounding defensive or apologetic

Potential talking points:

• Emphasis on musculoskeletal system from day one
• Osteopathic philosophy: treating the whole person, not just an X‑ray
• Strong clinical skills from early hands‑on training
• OMM improving palpation, tissue feel, and physical exam
• Experience caring for under‑served communities

Example snippet:

Choosing a DO school was deliberate for me. I wanted a curriculum that emphasized the musculoskeletal system, hands‑on physical examination, and a holistic approach to patients. That background has made me particularly attuned to functional outcomes and the person behind the imaging, which I think is crucial in orthopedics, where we’re not just fixing a fracture—we’re returning someone to their life.

---

4. “What are your strengths and weaknesses?”

This classic appears in many residency interview questions lists because it reveals self‑awareness and maturity.

Strengths:

• Choose 2–3 strengths that matter in ortho:

  • Work ethic and reliability
  • Team communication
  • Manual dexterity and comfort with procedures
  • Resilience under stress
  • Curiosity and commitment to lifelong learning

• Provide a concrete example for each.

Weaknesses:

• Avoid red flags like “I procrastinate” or “I don’t work well with others.”
• Use a growth‑oriented weakness you have actively addressed, e.g.:
  • Initially over‑preparing and taking on too much → learning to prioritize and delegate
  • Being overly self‑critical → developing healthier feedback habits
  • Public speaking anxiety → seeking opportunities to present and improve

Framework:

1. State the weakness briefly
2. Provide a specific past example
3. Explain what you’re doing to improve
4. Describe current status and ongoing plan

This structure turns a potential liability into evidence of growth.

---

Behavioral and Situational Questions: Proving How You Work

Behavioral interview medical questions are anchored by phrases like “Tell me about a time when…” or “Give me an example of…”. They’re designed to predict future behavior from your past actions, and they are very common in the ortho match process.

Using the STAR Framework

Answer these questions with the STAR method:

• S – Situation: Brief context
• T – Task: Your role or responsibility
• A – Action: What you did (focus most here)
• R – Result/Reflection: Outcome and what you learned

Keep answers 2–3 minutes long and focused.

---

Common Behavioral Questions You Should Prepare For

1. “Tell me about a time you made a mistake with a patient.”

They want to see accountability, insight, and safety awareness, not perfection.

Key points:

• Choose a real but not catastrophic mistake (e.g., communication lapse, delay in follow‑up, near‑miss on orders that was caught).
• Show you took responsibility and acted promptly.
• Emphasize what systems or personal changes you implemented afterwards.

Example outline:

• S: ED rotation, misinterpreted the seriousness of a hand infection
• T: You were responsible for initial assessment and communication
• A: Re‑evaluated after noticing worsening signs, escalated care, involved senior early, documented clearly, updated patient
• R: Patient received timely surgical consult, improved; you changed your practice regarding hand infections and early consultation

---

2. “Tell me about a time you had a conflict with a team member.”

They want to know if you are difficult to work with or able to resolve conflict professionally.

Tips:

• Avoid blaming; use neutral language.
• Show you sought to understand, not just to win.
• End with a positive resolution and learning point.

Example scenarios:

• Disagreement with a nurse about pain control orders
• Miscommunication with a co‑student about dividing tasks on a rotation
• Friction with a senior resident over feedback or expectations

Focus on how you: listened, clarified expectations, communicated calmly, and prioritized patient care.

---

3. “Describe a time you were under significant stress and how you handled it.”

Orthopedics involves long hours, night call, trauma cases, and high stakes. Interviewers want evidence that you cope productively, not by shutting down or becoming irritable.

Possible examples:

• Multiple critically ill patients during a busy call night
• Overlap of exams, research deadlines, and rotation responsibilities
• Managing a personal challenge (ill family member) while maintaining performance

Highlight:

• Time‑management strategies
• Seeking appropriate help or delegation
• Maintaining safety and professionalism
• Healthy coping strategies (exercise, debriefing, mentorship)

---

4. “Tell me about a time you showed leadership.”

Interviewers are looking for potential future chief residents and faculty.

Examples tailored to DO graduates:

• Leading an anatomy or OMM peer‑teaching group
• Organizing an orthopedic interest group event or skills workshop
• Coordinating a quality‑improvement project on a rotation
• Serving as team captain in sports or a major role in a community organization

Link your leadership to concrete outcomes (e.g., improved clinic flow, better education, enhanced patient safety).

---

Situational and Ethical Scenarios

These are “What would you do if…” questions. They assess your judgment and ethical compass.

Common orthopedic‑related scenarios:

1. You witness a resident breaching sterile technique in the OR and not addressing it.

   • Focus on patient safety, hierarchy navigation, and respectful communication.

2. An attending pressures you to perform a task you don’t feel competent to do.

   • Emphasize patient safety, honesty about limits, willingness to learn under appropriate supervision.

3. A patient insists on returning to sport before you feel it’s safe post‑op.

   • Discuss shared decision‑making, education, clear risk communication, documentation.

For each, show that you:

• Center patient safety
• Respect team dynamics but aren’t afraid to speak up
• Communicate clearly and professionally
• Understand documentation and institutional policies

---

Orthopedic‑Specific and Technical Questions: Showing You Understand the Field

Orthopedic programs may test your specialty awareness more than some other fields. While they don’t expect you to function as a PGY‑4, they do expect:

• Basic understanding of common conditions and workflows
• Awareness of subspecialties and what attracts you
• Insight into the realities of life in an orthopedic surgery residency

1. “Why our program?”

You must tailor this answer to each program. Generic responses are easy to spot.

Research ahead:

• Case volume and mix (trauma, joints, sports, pediatrics, spine)
• Academic vs. community emphasis
• Hospital catchment area and patient population
• Research infrastructure, simulation labs, didactics
• Culture: mentorship, operative autonomy, resident well‑being

Tie these to your goals as a DO graduate:

Your program’s high trauma volume and early operative exposure align with my goal to develop strong fundamental surgical skills. I also appreciate your commitment to teaching—residents describe close mentorship with attendings, which is something I valued in my osteopathic training. Finally, your work with underserved urban and rural patients fits with my long‑term aim to practice in a community that may otherwise have limited access to specialized orthopedic care.

---

2. “Which subspecialty are you interested in?” (and “How will you keep an open mind?”)

It’s fine to have interests (sports, trauma, joints, peds), but programs also want residents who won’t close doors prematurely.

• Mention 1–2 areas you’re particularly drawn to
• Explain what aspects you enjoy (e.g., acute trauma resuscitation, long‑term outcomes in joint replacement, biomechanics of sports injuries)
• Acknowledge that you’re early in training and value broad exposure

---

3. “Tell me about a patient who made you want to pursue orthopedics.”

Prepare a specific clinical story that illustrates:

• The impact of orthopedic care on function and quality of life
• Your role in the patient’s care (student level is fine)
• What you learned about the specialty, team, or patient experience

Avoid sharing identifying details, and focus on reflection, not just the medical facts.

---

4. “How comfortable are you with call, long hours, and physically demanding work?”

For an orthopedic surgery residency, this is crucial. They’re evaluating:

• Realistic expectations
• Evidence that you’ve already experienced demanding rotations
• Your ability to maintain performance and professionalism despite fatigue

You might say you’ve:

• Managed overnight trauma call as a sub‑I
• Maintained focus in long cases
• Developed routines to protect your sleep and mental health when possible
• Reflected on lifestyle trade‑offs and still feel committed to the specialty

---

Addressing DO‑Specific Concerns and Common “Red Flag” Questions

As a DO graduate, you may encounter additional lines of questioning about training, exams, and perceived differences from MD applicants.

1. “Did you take the USMLE? Why or why not?”

Be honest and non‑defensive.

• If you took it and did well: briefly state your score range, then pivot to how this demonstrates your preparation for a rigorous program.
• If you didn’t take it:
  • Explain you focused on COMLEX as your primary licensure exam.
  • Emphasize strong clinical evaluations, sub‑I performance, research, and letters that further validate your capabilities.

Reassure them that you’re well‑prepared to handle the knowledge and testing demands of residency.

---

2. “How do you think your DO background will influence you as an orthopedic surgeon?”

This is a chance to differentiate yourself positively.

You might mention:

• Increased attention to function, pain, and the patient’s broader life context
• Comfort with physical exam and palpation, making you more precise with non‑operative care and pre‑/post‑op assessments
• Communication style emphasizing patient understanding and shared decision‑making
• Experience in under‑resourced clinical settings, useful for community orthopedic practice

---

3. “Can you explain this gap/low score/leave of absence?”

If applicable, be prepared.

Guidelines:

• Be brief, factual, and honest.
• Own what is yours to own without oversharing.
• Pivot quickly to what you learned and how you corrected course.

Example:

During my second year I struggled with time management and ended up underperforming on my first standardized exam. I met with faculty, developed a structured study schedule, and sought peer mentors. Since then, my performance has been consistently strong, as reflected in my third‑year evaluations and board scores. It was a humbling experience, but it pushed me to build more disciplined habits that I’ve carried into my clinical work.

Programs care less about the mistake than about your trajectory and insight.

---

Practical Preparation Strategies for DO Applicants in Ortho

Knowing the questions is only half the battle; you must perform well under pressure on interview day.

1. Build a Personal “Story Bank”

List 8–10 experiences you can reuse across different behavioral questions:

• A challenging patient encounter
• A conflict you resolved
• A time you showed leadership
• A mistake or near‑miss
• A demanding call or rotation
• A teaching/mentoring experience
• A meaningful ortho case that inspired you

Outline each story using STAR and practice telling them in 2–3 minutes. Many different behavioral interview medical questions can be answered with the same few well‑chosen stories.

---

2. Practice “Tell me about yourself” and 3–4 Core Questions Out Loud

Record yourself answering:

• “Tell me about yourself.”
• “Why orthopedic surgery?”
• “Why our program?” (tailored to 2–3 example programs)
• “What are your strengths and weaknesses?”

Refine content, pacing, and clarity. Ask a mentor or recent ortho resident to listen and provide feedback.

---

3. Prepare Questions to Ask the Program

At the end of almost every interview, you’ll be asked if you have questions. Asking thoughtful, specific questions shows genuine interest and preparation.

Potential questions:

• “How does your program balance operative autonomy with supervision, especially in junior years?”
• “What differentiates residents who thrive here from those who struggle?”
• “How does the program support resident research in orthopedic topics?”
• “Can you describe how DO and MD residents have integrated in your program?”

Avoid overly basic questions easily answered on the website.

---

4. Manage Non‑Verbal Communication and Professional Presence

• Dress conservatively and professionally (dark suit, simple grooming).
• Maintain eye contact, nod, and lean slightly forward when listening.
• Avoid sounding overly rehearsed; aim for conversational professionalism.
• For virtual interviews:
  • Test lighting, camera, and internet beforehand.
  • Frame yourself at eye level with a neutral background.
  • Look at the camera when speaking to simulate eye contact.

---

5. Post‑Interview Reflection and Notes

Immediately after each interview:

• Jot down:
  • Who you met
  • Specific cases, conversations, or program features you liked
  • Any concerns or red flags
• These notes will help with:
  • Thank‑you messages (if you choose to send them)
  • Rank list decisions
  • Avoiding mixing up programs in follow‑up communication

---

FAQs: Common Questions from DO Graduates Applying to Orthopedic Surgery

1. As a DO graduate, do I need to tailor my answers differently than MD applicants?

The core principles of strong answers are the same, but as a DO you should:

• Be ready to briefly address your choice of osteopathic training and, if relevant, exam strategy (COMLEX/USMLE).
• Highlight osteopathic strengths—manual skills, holistic patient focus, adaptability in diverse clinical settings.
• Anticipate subtle concerns and address them confidently without sounding defensive.

Your goal is to present yourself not as “a DO trying to fit into an MD world,” but as a well‑trained future orthopedic surgeon who happens to be a DO.

---

2. How can I stand out in orthopedic surgery residency interviews?

You stand out by combining:

• Clear, authentic narrative: A compelling “tell me about yourself” with a coherent path to orthopedics.
• Excellent behavioral responses: Real stories showing resilience, teamwork, and maturity.
• Program‑specific insight: Concrete knowledge of each program’s strengths and culture.
• Professional humility: Confidence without arrogance; eagerness to learn.
• Demonstrated commitment to ortho: Sub‑Is, research, electives, and mentorship in the field.

Technical brilliance alone rarely distinguishes candidates; communication and self‑awareness often do.

---

3. What if I’m asked a question I truly don’t know how to answer?

It’s acceptable to take a brief pause, gather your thoughts, and say:

“That’s a great question; let me think about a good example.”

Then:

• Use STAR if it’s behavioral.
• If you lack a direct experience, choose the closest analogous situation and explain what you’d do based on your current level and values.
• Avoid rambling; keep answers structured and honest.

Programs value thoughtful, honest reasoning more than perfection.

---

4. How should I answer if they ask where else I’m interviewing or how I’ll rank them?

These can be uncomfortable. A safe, professional approach:

• Avoid naming specific programs unless you’re comfortable doing so.
• Emphasize genuine interest without making promises that conflict with NRMP rules.

Example:

I’m fortunate to be interviewing at several programs that I’m very excited about. I can say that your program is one I’m strongly considering because of [specific reasons]. After I complete all my interviews, I’ll take time to reflect carefully on fit, training opportunities, and culture before finalizing my rank list.

---

Preparing thoroughly for common interview questions for DO graduates in orthopedic surgery will not only help you answer effectively, but also reduce anxiety and allow your authentic personality and passion for orthopedics to shine through. With structured practice, honest self‑reflection, and a clear understanding of what programs seek, you can navigate the ortho match process with confidence and professionalism.