Ace Your Preliminary Surgery Residency Interview: A Guide for US Citizen IMGs

As a US citizen IMG (American studying abroad), landing a preliminary surgery year in the U.S. can be both a strategic career move and an emotionally intense process. Your interview performance is often the deciding factor—especially for prelim surgery residency positions where programs must judge your potential quickly and efficiently.

This guide breaks down common residency interview questions you’ll face as a US citizen IMG applying to preliminary surgery, explains what programs are really assessing, and provides structured sample answers you can adapt.

---

Understanding the Preliminary Surgery Interview Landscape

Preliminary surgery positions are unique. Programs know that many prelims:

• Intend to reapply to categorical general surgery or another specialty
• May be using the year to strengthen their application (USMLE scores, letters, U.S. experience)
• Come from varied backgrounds, including many US citizen IMGs and other IMGs

Because of this, interviewers focus heavily on:

• Reliability and work ethic: Will you show up, work hard, and be dependable?
• Team compatibility: Will you get along with categorical residents and faculty?
• Professionalism under pressure: How do you handle high‑stress, high‑volume environments?
• Future plans: How does a prelim surgery residency fit into your long‑term strategy?

Your status as a US citizen IMG (American studying abroad) brings additional questions:

• Why did you attend medical school abroad?
• How have you adapted back to the U.S. system?
• Are you committed enough to succeed in a demanding prelim surgery year?

You’ll see these themes repeatedly in both traditional and behavioral interview medical questions.

---

Core Traditional Questions You Must Master

These are standard questions you will almost certainly encounter. For each, you’ll find what’s being assessed and an answer framework tailored to US citizen IMGs targeting a preliminary surgery year.

1. “Tell me about yourself.”

This is almost always the opening question. Programs use it to quickly form a mental picture of you and see how you communicate.

What they’re assessing:

• Organization and clarity of communication
• Professional identity and maturity
• How you frame the “US citizen IMG / American studying abroad” story
• Whether your narrative aligns with a surgical, high‑workload environment

Framework (2–3 minutes):

1. Present: Who you are now (med school, current activities, strengths)
2. Past: Key experiences that led you to surgery/prelim year
3. Future: Your career goals and why this program fits

Sample structure (adapt to your story):

“I’m a US citizen IMG who completed medical school at [X University] in [Country]. I grew up in [City/State], and before medical school I studied [major] at [undergrad]. During my clinical years abroad, I gravitated toward fast‑paced, procedure‑heavy rotations, and I sought out additional exposure in general surgery and critical care.

Recognizing the importance of understanding the U.S. system, I arranged multiple U.S. clinical experiences, including a sub‑internship in general surgery at [Hospital], where I learned how much I value team‑based care, high standards, and direct feedback. Those experiences solidified my interest in pursuing surgery and showed me the realities of surgical training in the U.S.

My long‑term goal is to become a [e.g., academic general surgeon / trauma surgeon / surgical subspecialist], and I see a preliminary surgery year as an opportunity to prove myself clinically, contribute to the team, and continue building the foundation for a categorical position.”

Prepare and rehearse this answer until it’s fluent but not robotic. This is the foundation for many follow‑up questions.

---

2. “Why surgery?” / “Why preliminary surgery?”

For prelim positions, you have to address both: why surgery as a field, and why a prelim surgery residency specifically.

What they’re assessing:

• Genuine understanding of surgical life (not TV‑style romanticization)
• Insight into what makes you suited to it
• Realistic, honest reasons for choosing a preliminary surgery year

Key points to hit:

• Exposure to surgery (specific rotations, mentors, cases)
• Traits you possess that fit surgery (work ethic, manual skills, decisiveness, team orientation)
• Why prelim surgery makes sense in your career plan

Example outline:

• Start with early spark or moment
• Move to concrete experiences confirming interest
• End with how prelim fits your trajectory

Sample talking points:

“My interest in surgery started during my core surgical rotation abroad, where I was struck by how immediately surgical decisions and technical skill impacted patient outcomes. What kept me in surgery, though, was not just the operating room—it was the continuity: seeing patients pre‑op, post‑op, and in follow‑up, and being responsible for their entire trajectory.

I pursued additional surgical electives, both at my home institution and in the U.S., including [specific rotation]. I found that I thrived in environments that demanded early mornings, high volumes, and clear communication with nurses and residents. My attendings often commented on my reliability, attention to detail in notes and orders, and my calm approach when managing multiple tasks at once.

A prelim surgery residency makes sense for me because I want to build the strongest possible surgical foundation, continue developing my operative and perioperative skills, and demonstrate my ability to function at the level of an intern in the U.S. system. I understand that prelim positions can be demanding and may not guarantee a categorical spot, but I’m prepared to work hard, learn as much as I can, and contribute meaningfully to the team.”

---

3. “Why did you go to medical school abroad?” (US citizen IMG–specific)

As an American studying abroad, you should expect this question in some form.

What they’re assessing:

• Your decision‑making process and maturity
• Whether there were red flags (academic, legal, personal) driving the choice
• How you view your IMG journey—defensive vs. reflective and constructive

How to answer:

• Be honest but strategic
• Emphasize opportunity, intentionality, and growth
• Avoid blaming or sounding resentful

Example framework:

“As a U.S. citizen, I explored both U.S. and international options. Ultimately, I chose [School] because it offered [small class sizes, strong clinical exposure, English‑language curriculum, early hands‑on experience, etc.]. At the time, it was a viable pathway to becoming a physician that aligned with my academic profile and financial or personal considerations.

Training abroad challenged me to adjust to a new healthcare system, language, and culture, which forced me to become resourceful and adaptable. I had to actively seek out opportunities, advocate for myself, and make sure I was on track for U.S. residency requirements.

I recognize that coming back as a US citizen IMG means I need to prove myself, and that’s exactly what I’ve focused on through [USMLE performance, U.S. clinical rotations, research, or other experiences]. Those experiences have prepared me to function effectively in a U.S. prelim surgery residency.”

---

4. “Why our program?” (Prelim‑specific angle)

Programs can sense generic answers immediately. You must demonstrate real knowledge of their preliminary surgery year structure.

Research in advance:

• Number of prelim spots and their typical outcomes
• Whether prelims get OR time vs. mostly floor work
• Formal didactics, simulation, and mentorship arrangements
• Success stories of prior prelims (match into categorical or other specialties)

Sample strategy:

1. Start with 1–2 program‑specific features.
2. Connect these to your goals and needs as a US citizen IMG.
3. Highlight that you understand what a prelim year entails.

Example:

“I’m particularly interested in your program for several reasons. First, your preliminary surgery year offers structured exposure not only to general surgery but also to ICU and subspecialty services, which is crucial for building a strong clinical foundation. When I spoke with your current prelim residents, they mentioned that they are treated as integral members of the team, with real responsibility and access to the OR.

Second, the program’s track record of helping prelims transition to categorical positions—both within surgery and in other fields—shows me that you invest in your prelims and provide honest mentorship. As a US citizen IMG, I value that kind of support as I continue to prove myself in the U.S. system.

Finally, the patient population and case mix here—particularly your trauma and acute care surgery volume—align with my interest in acute surgical care and my goal of becoming a broadly competent surgeon.”

---

5. “What are your career goals?” / “Where do you see yourself in 5–10 years?”

As a prelim applicant, you must acknowledge the uncertainty while still communicating direction.

What they’re assessing:

• Realistic expectations about categorical positions
• Commitment to surgery vs. keeping an open mind
• Whether you’ve thought beyond “just getting a spot”

Options for framing:

• Committed to surgery, but flexible about path:

  “My primary goal is to pursue a career in surgery, ideally in [general/trauma/another subspecialty]. I recognize that the path from a prelim to categorical spot can vary, and I’m open to opportunities both within this institution and elsewhere. Regardless of the exact route, in 10 years I see myself as a board‑certified surgeon working in [academic/community] practice, involved in [teaching, research, quality improvement].”

• Exploring surgical and related fields:

  “I’m strongly drawn to surgical practice and acute care, and I’m also interested in fields that closely interface with surgery, such as anesthesiology or critical care. I see this preliminary year as a way to solidify my clinical skills, confirm my long‑term fit in surgery or a surgical‑adjacent specialty, and put myself in the best position to secure a categorical position.”

Avoid sounding like you see the prelim year as a “backup plan” or “holding pattern.” Focus on growth, contribution, and building a foundation.

---

Behavioral Interview Questions: What Programs Really Want to See

A behavioral interview medical format is increasingly common in surgery. These questions usually start with:

• “Tell me about a time when…”
• “Give me an example of…”
• “Describe a situation where…”

Use the STAR method:
Situation – context;
Task – your role;
Action – what you did;
Result – outcome + what you learned.

Below are common behavioral questions tailored to prelim surgery residency interviews.

1. “Tell me about a time you made a mistake.”

They’re not looking for perfection. They’re evaluating your honesty, insight, and response to error.

Strong answer components:

• Clear acknowledgment of a real (but not disastrous) mistake
• Immediate actions to correct it and protect the patient
• Communication with team and reflection for future prevention

Example scenario ideas:

• Miscommunication on patient orders
• Delay in following up a lab result
• Confusion over a dressing/wound care instruction

Highlight:

“What I learned from this experience was…”

Then connect to how you practice now.

---

2. “Describe a time you had a conflict with a team member. How did you handle it?”

Surgical teams are hierarchical and high‑stress. Programs want to know you can manage conflict professionally.

For US citizen IMGs, examples might involve:

• Communication challenges with staff due to differences in training systems
• Disagreement with another student/intern over patient management
• Navigating cultural or language differences during your international training

Key points:

• Avoid blaming or character attacks
• Focus on listening, clarifying expectations, and finding a solution
• End with a positive or at least constructive resolution

---

3. “Tell me about a time you worked under significant pressure.”

Prelim surgery interns often carry heavy floor workloads. Interviewers want reassurance you won’t meltdown or become unsafe.

Use a story that highlights:

• Multiple competing priorities (e.g., cross‑covering several unstable patients)
• How you prioritized tasks (sickest first, time‑sensitive tasks, delegation)
• Communication with seniors and nursing
• Emotional self‑regulation and follow‑through

Example framing:

“During my sub‑internship at [U.S. hospital], I was covering [X] patients on the surgical service when two patients deteriorated at the same time…”

Then show how you:

• Used objective data (vitals, labs, physical exam)
• Called for help appropriately
• Documented and followed up

---

4. “Give an example of a time you received critical feedback. What did you do with it?”

Prelim interns receive a lot of feedback, some of it blunt. Programs need residents who respond constructively.

Strong approach:

• Choose feedback that isn’t trivial (not “I was told to write neater notes”)
• Demonstrate genuine self‑reflection
• Show concrete changes you made and how they improved your performance

For US citizen IMGs, common feedback themes:

• Communication style in the U.S. context (directness, closed‑loop communication)
• Clinical documentation in Epic/Cerner
• Efficiency and prioritization on rounds

End with: “Now, I actively do X, Y, Z to prevent that issue and I welcome feedback.”

---

US Citizen IMG–Specific Concerns and Questions

As a US citizen IMG / American studying abroad, certain topics will come up more often. Anticipate and prepare for them.

1. “How have you prepared to transition into the U.S. clinical environment?”

Programs worry about IMGs struggling with:

• EHR systems
• Interdisciplinary team structure
• U.S. documentation and billing requirements
• Cultural communication norms with staff and patients

Answer with specifics:

• U.S. clinical electives/sub‑internships
• Observerships that later became more hands‑on experiences
• Independent learning on EHR, code status discussions, informed consent, etc.

Demonstrate that you’re not naïve to U.S. practice.

---

2. “You’ve had some time between graduation and now—what did you do?”

Many US citizen IMGs have “application years” or gaps. You must explain them clearly.

Acceptable activities:

• Research (surgical or related)
• Additional U.S. clinical experiences
• USMLE preparation or retakes
• Teaching, tutoring, or clinical work abroad
• Family or health issues (if comfortable sharing, framed professionally)

Focus on productivity, learning, and staying close to clinical medicine.

---

3. “How will you handle the potential uncertainty of a prelim year?”

Programs need to know you understand the stakes but won’t crumble under pressure.

Key elements:

• Acknowledge reality (no guarantee of categorical position)
• Show you have a plan: networking, performance, research, regular meetings with PD
• Emphasize that regardless of outcome, you’ll maximize the year’s value

Example language:

“I understand that a preliminary surgery year is intense and that there is no guaranteed categorical spot. I’ve thought carefully about this and I’m prepared to approach the year with the mindset of: work hard, learn as much as possible, build strong relationships, and be proactive in seeking feedback and opportunities. I plan to work closely with mentors and the program leadership to understand realistic pathways—whether in surgery or related specialties—and I’m committed to giving my best effort regardless of the uncertainty.”

---

High‑Yield Tips for Answering Residency Interview Questions Effectively

Beyond individual questions, your overall approach will determine how strong an impression you make.

1. Build a Coherent Personal Narrative

All your answers—from “tell me about yourself” to behavioral examples—should support a consistent narrative:

• You are reliable, hard‑working, and coachable.
• You’ve intentionally chosen a prelim surgery residency as a growth step.
• Being a US citizen IMG has made you resourceful and adaptable, not bitter or defensive.

Interviewers will remember themes more than details. Make sure your themes are deliberate.

2. Customize for Each Program

Even if the core of your answers stays the same, customize:

• Specific features in “Why our program?”
• Local patient population and case mix you’re excited about
• Any prior connection (elective, mentor, research)

Programs can instantly detect “copy‑paste” answers.

3. Practice Behavioral Questions Out Loud

Written notes aren’t enough. To excel in behavioral interview medical formats:

• Write bullet‑point outlines (not scripts) for 6–8 core stories:
  • Mistake
  • Conflict
  • Leadership
  • Working under pressure
  • Working with a difficult patient/family
  • Giving or receiving feedback
  • Going above and beyond
• Practice aloud with a friend, mentor, or via mock interviews.
• Time yourself: 1.5–2 minutes per story.

4. Anticipate Common Red‑Flag Questions

Depending on your application, be ready for:

• USMLE failures or low scores
• Extended time in medical school
• Significant gaps or career changes

For each, your framework should be:

1. Briefly acknowledge what happened (no excuses).
2. Explain what you did to address it.
3. Emphasize what’s changed and evidence of improvement.

Programs are more comfortable with past issues if you demonstrate insight and growth.

5. Prepare Thoughtful Questions to Ask Them

At the end, when they ask, “Do you have any questions for us?” avoid generic questions easily answered on their website.

High‑yield questions for a prelim surgery year:

• “How are prelims integrated into the surgical teams on call and in the OR?”
• “What support do prelims receive in terms of mentorship and career guidance?”
• “Can you share examples of where prior prelims have matched after their year here?”
• “How does feedback work for interns? How often and in what format do we receive it?”

These show that you understand the prelim structure and are serious about growth.

---

FAQs: Preliminary Surgery Interviews for US Citizen IMGs

1. Are the residency interview questions different for prelim surgery vs. categorical surgery?

The core questions (e.g., “tell me about yourself”, “why surgery?”, “why our program?”) are similar, but prelim surgery residency interviews often emphasize:

• Your long‑term goals and how a prelim year fits
• Your understanding of the uncertainty around prelim positions
• Your resilience and ability to handle a high‑workload, sometimes less‑glamorous role

Expect more questions about your plans after the prelim year and your openness to different career paths.

2. As a US citizen IMG, will I be asked more about my medical school and training abroad?

Yes, you likely will. As an American studying abroad, interviewers will want to understand:

• Why you chose to go abroad
• How your training compares to U.S. standards
• How you’ve prepared for practicing in the U.S.

Prepare clear, confident explanations. Frame your IMG status as a source of adaptability, cultural competency, and initiative rather than as a deficit.

3. How should I address low USMLE scores or a prior failed attempt during the interview?

Be straightforward, brief, and focused on growth:

• Acknowledge the result without making excuses.
• Explain contributing factors only if relevant (e.g., personal circumstances, initial lack of understanding of exam style).
• Emphasize what you changed (study methods, resources, time management) and how that led to improvement in subsequent exams or clinical performance.

Programs care less about the number itself and more about whether you’ve demonstrated recovery and progression.

4. How can I show that I’m serious about contributing, even though I may not stay at the program long‑term?

Emphasize that:

• You understand prelim interns are vital to the functioning of the surgical service.
• You are committed to delivering excellent patient care during your time there.
• You value teamwork, continuity of care, and leaving a positive impression regardless of where you match later.

Use examples from rotations where you fully engaged and contributed, even in short‑term or visiting roles. Programs want prelims who behave like long‑term team members, not short‑term visitors.

---

Focusing your preparation on these common interview questions and tailoring your responses to your identity as a US citizen IMG aiming for a preliminary surgery year will significantly improve your performance. With a coherent narrative, well‑practiced behavioral stories, and clear understanding of the prelim pathway, you can walk into your interviews ready to demonstrate exactly why you belong on a U.S. surgical team.