Maximize Your Residency Success: Expert LOR Request Strategies

Residency Applications are highly competitive, and your Letters of Recommendation (LORs) are among the most influential components of your file. Strong, detailed LORs can validate your achievements, contextualize your performance, and help selection committees envision you as a resident in their program.

This guide expands on practical, evidence-informed LOR Strategies to help you:

• Choose the right recommenders
• Time and structure your requests
• Provide materials that make writing easier
• Maintain professionalism and foster long-term Professional Development

By the end, you’ll know exactly how to request powerful Letters of Recommendation that strengthen your Medical Career trajectory.

---

Understanding the Role of LORs in Residency Applications

Letters of Recommendation do far more than “check a box.” For many program directors, they are one of the most heavily weighted parts of the ERAS application.

What Residency Program Directors Look for in LORs

Most programs use LORs to answer three core questions:

1. Can you do the work?

   • Clinical reasoning and diagnostic skills
   • Ability to manage patient care safely
   • Performance in high-pressure or complex situations

2. How do you work with others?

   • Professionalism and reliability
   • Teamwork and communication
   • Receptiveness to feedback, teachability

3. Who are you as a person and future colleague?

   • Integrity and ethics
   • Empathy and bedside manner
   • Resilience, initiative, and commitment to the specialty

Key Elements of a Strong Residency LOR

Programs prefer letters that are:

• Specific – Contain concrete examples, not generic praise
• Comparative – Place you in context (e.g., “top 10% of students I’ve worked with”)
• Specialty-Relevant – Address skills and attributes valued in that field
• Personalized – Clearly written by someone who knows you, not a form letter

A well-constructed LOR can distinguish you from applicants with similar board scores and grades by showcasing how you perform in real clinical environments and how you fit into a team.

---

Strategic Planning: Who, When, and How Many Letters

Thoughtful planning around your LORs is critical. Start early and think strategically about who can best advocate for you.

Choosing the Right Recommenders

Not all letters carry the same weight. Consider:

1. Clinical Supervisors (Core for Most Applicants)

These are often your most impactful letters, especially from:

• Attending physicians who directly supervised you on core or sub-internship rotations
• Faculty from rotations in your chosen specialty
• Service chiefs or clerkship directors who know your performance well

Ideal if they can describe:

• Your clinical skills and progression
• How you functioned on the team
• Specific patient encounters or challenges you handled

Example:
If applying to Internal Medicine, a letter from an attending on your IM sub-internship who saw you handle complex cases, lead presentations, and coordinate care can be extremely powerful.

2. Academic Faculty and Research Mentors

Especially useful if they can speak to:

• Your scholarly productivity and research skills
• Critical thinking, curiosity, and persistence
• Your potential for academic or subspecialty careers

These letters are particularly valuable for applicants targeting academic programs or research-heavy specialties.

3. Long-Term Mentors

Mentors who have known you across multiple years or roles (e.g., faculty advisor, longitudinal clinic preceptor) can:

• Highlight your longitudinal growth
• Speak to your character, professionalism, and resilience
• Connect your experiences to your long-term Medical Career goals

Balancing Your LOR Portfolio

Most programs require 3–4 Letters of Recommendation. A common mix might be:

• 2–3 letters from your chosen specialty (e.g., Internal Medicine for IM residency)
• 1 letter from another clinical area or a research/longitudinal mentor

Always check each program’s specific LOR requirements or preferences (e.g., at least 2 from the specialty, 1 from a department chair, etc.).

---

Building Relationships Before You Need a Letter

The strongest Letters of Recommendation come from people who know you well, have seen you over time, and genuinely want to support your success.

Start Early in Medical School or During Clinical Years

Don’t wait until ERAS season to think about LORs. Instead:

• Identify potential mentors during rotations

  • Show initiative, curiosity, and reliability
  • Ask for feedback and act on it
  • Volunteer for presentations or extra responsibilities when appropriate

• Stay in touch over time

  • Send brief updates on your progress or achievements
  • Ask occasional career questions
  • Express genuine interest in their work or field

This builds familiarity and makes it much easier to request a letter later.

Demonstrate Consistent Professionalism

Your conduct day-to-day strongly influences how people write about you. Be:

• Punctual and prepared
• Reliable in following through on tasks
• Respectful to all staff and patients
• Proactive in seeking learning opportunities

Recommenders often comment on professionalism and teamwork—areas where inconsistency can seriously weaken a letter.

Ask Early for “Future Letters”

If you had a particularly strong rotation or research experience:

“Dr. Patel, I’ve really valued working with you this month and the feedback you’ve given me. Would you feel comfortable writing me a strong letter of recommendation for residency when the time comes?”

If they say yes, you can:

• Make a note of it (including their email and specific strengths they observed)
• Circle back during application season with a formal, organized request

If they hesitate, that’s useful information. You may want to prioritize other recommenders.

---

Timing and Logistics: When and How to Request LORs

When to Request Letters

Aim to request letters:

• 3–4 months before your ERAS submission deadline, or
• Within a few weeks of finishing a rotation while your performance is fresh in their mind

For early deadlines (e.g., early match specialties), adjust your timeline accordingly.

How Many People to Ask

If programs require 3–4 letters, consider:

• Identifying 5–6 potential recommenders in case someone is unable to complete the letter on time or declines
• Prioritizing those who:
  • Know you well
  • Work in your desired specialty
  • Can provide detailed, specific commentary

---

Crafting a Professional, Compelling LOR Request

Your request is a reflection of your professionalism and communication skills. A clear, respectful, and well-organized message makes it easier for your recommender to say yes—and to write a strong letter.

Step-by-Step Structure for Your LOR Request

You can adapt this structure for email, in-person, or virtual requests.

1. Open with Respect and Gratitude

Begin by acknowledging their time and your previous work together.

Example:

Dear Dr. Smith,
I hope you’re doing well. I wanted to thank you again for the opportunity to work with you on the Internal Medicine service this spring. I learned a great deal from your teaching on clinical reasoning and patient communication.

2. Clearly State Your Purpose

Be direct and specific that you are requesting a strong letter of recommendation.

Example:

I am applying to Internal Medicine residency programs this cycle and would be honored if you would consider writing a strong letter of recommendation on my behalf.

Using the word “strong” encourages honest feedback. If they’re not comfortable writing strongly supportive letters, they may say so—and that’s helpful for you.

3. Explain Why You’re Asking Them

Briefly connect the dots between your shared experiences and why you value their perspective.

Example:

During my rotation with you, I appreciated your feedback on my presentations and clinical decision-making, especially around managing complex patients on the inpatient service. Because you observed me closely in a setting similar to residency, I believe you can best comment on my readiness for Internal Medicine training.

4. Share Your Specialty and Program Focus

If you have a specific specialty or type of program in mind, include it.

Example:

I am particularly interested in academic Internal Medicine programs with strong emphasis on teaching and underserved patient care. Your perspective as a clinician-educator working with diverse populations would be extremely valuable to programs reviewing my application.

You don’t need to list programs by name unless they ask, but you can if you have a short, targeted list.

5. Provide Supporting Materials (Make It Easy for Them)

Attach or offer:

• Your updated CV
• A draft of your personal statement
• A brief summary of your work with them (key cases, projects, or responsibilities)
• Any program-specific instructions (e.g., standard letter format for some specialties)

Example:

To make this as easy as possible, I’ve attached my current CV and a draft of my personal statement. I’m also happy to send a brief summary of specific patients and cases we managed together during the rotation, if that would be helpful.

6. Include Clear Logistics and Deadlines

Mention:

• Where the letter will be uploaded (e.g., ERAS)
• Your target date for submission
• Any official deadlines or specialty-specific timelines

Example:

Letters are submitted directly through the ERAS system. My goal is to have all letters uploaded by September 10th so my application is complete when programs begin reviewing files.

7. Offer to Meet or Talk

This shows respect and gives them a chance to ask questions or learn more.

Example:

If it would be helpful, I would be grateful for the opportunity to meet briefly—either in person or via Zoom—to discuss my goals for residency and answer any questions as you consider this request.

8. Close with Sincere Thanks

End with appreciation, regardless of whether they accept.

Example:

Thank you very much for considering my request and for all the teaching and mentorship you’ve already provided. I’m truly grateful for your support during my training.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[AAMC ID, if applicable]

---

Follow-Up, Reminders, and Thank You Notes

Once you’ve requested the letter, managing communication respectfully is crucial.

How to Follow Up Without Being Pushy

If you haven’t heard back in 7–10 days, send a brief, polite follow-up.

Follow-Up Email Example:

Dear Dr. Smith,
I hope you’re doing well. I wanted to gently follow up on my recent email regarding a letter of recommendation for my residency application. I completely understand how busy you are, and I appreciate your time and consideration.

Please let me know if there is any additional information I can provide that would be helpful.

Thank you again,
[Your Name]

If they agreed but the letter is not yet submitted and your target date is approaching, send a deadline reminder 2–3 weeks before, then again 5–7 days before if needed.

Tracking Your Letters

Use a simple spreadsheet or note to track:

• Recommender name and contact
• Date requested
• Date they accepted (if applicable)
• Target completion date
• Date submitted/confirmed in ERAS

This helps you stay organized and avoid last-minute surprises.

Sending Thank You Notes

After you know the letter has been submitted:

• Send a personalized thank you email or handwritten note
• Mention how much their support means to you
• Consider updating them later with your interview or Match results

Post-Submission Example:

Dear Dr. Smith,
I wanted to thank you sincerely for submitting a letter of recommendation on my behalf. I truly appreciate the time and effort it takes to write these letters and support students during the residency application process.

I’m very grateful for your mentorship and the opportunity to learn from you. I’ll be sure to update you as the Match process unfolds.

With gratitude,
[Your Name]

Maintaining these connections is valuable for your long-term Professional Development and career.

---

Making Your LORs as Strong as Possible (Without Writing Them Yourself)

Your role is not to write your own letter, but you can absolutely shape what your recommenders have to work with.

Provide a Helpful “LOR Packet”

Consider giving each recommender:

• CV (highlighting clinical, research, leadership, and volunteer experiences)

• Personal statement draft (so they understand your narrative and goals)

• Bullet-point summary of work with them:

  • Dates and setting of rotation/project
  • Specific responsibilities (e.g., managed your own patient list, presented at morning report)
  • Memorable cases or tasks where you demonstrated initiative or growth

• Key strengths you hope they might address, such as:

  • Clinical reasoning and judgment
  • Work ethic and reliability
  • Teamwork and communication
  • Interest and fit for the specialty

You are not dictating their content; you’re simply jogging their memory and making it easier to be detailed and specific.

Highlighting Growth and Responsiveness to Feedback

Program directors value growth mindset—students who can take feedback, improve, and adapt.

You might remind a recommender of moments like:

• How your presentations improved after feedback
• How you changed your approach to patient interviews
• How you learned from a challenging case or error

This encourages letters that not only describe your skills, but also your trajectory.

Specialty-Specific Considerations

Some fields have particular norms:

• Emergency Medicine: Standardized letters (SLOEs) are often preferred or required; follow departmental processes.
• Surgery: Value letters that emphasize grit, teamwork in the OR, and ability to handle long, demanding days.
• Psychiatry: Appreciate comments on empathy, communication, and ability to work with vulnerable populations.

Research the expectations for your specialty and discuss them with mentors when selecting and briefing your recommenders.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Residency LORs

1. How many Letters of Recommendation should I request for residency?

Most programs require 3–4 Letters of Recommendation, but the exact number varies:

• Many categorical programs accept up to 4 letters in ERAS
• Some specialties (e.g., EM with SLOEs) have more specific expectations

It’s wise to:

• Check each program’s website for detailed LOR requirements
• Aim to secure at least 4 solid letters, so you can tailor which ones you assign to each program if needed

2. Who should I prioritize if I don’t have many strong options?

If you feel you lack “big-name” faculty:

• Prioritize attendings who know you well over those with prestigious titles who barely interacted with you
• Choose people who:
  • Directly observed your clinical work
  • Can comment on your reliability, professionalism, and growth
  • Are willing to write a “strong” letter

A detailed, invested letter from a lesser-known faculty often carries more weight than a short, generic letter from a famous name.

3. What if a potential recommender doesn’t know me very well?

You can still ask, but be strategic:

• Request a meeting (in-person or virtual) to discuss your goals and experiences
• Provide a robust LOR packet (CV, personal statement, summary of interactions, highlights)
• Ask them honestly if they feel able to write you a strong and specific letter

If they hesitate or seem uncertain, thank them for their honesty and consider asking someone else. You want enthusiastic advocates, not neutral or lukewarm letters.

4. Is it appropriate to remind recommenders of key points I’d like them to mention?

Yes, as long as it’s framed as helpful background, not instructions.

You might say:

“To support your letter, I’ve included a brief summary of our work together and some aspects of my performance that I hope programs will understand about me, such as my interest in underserved care and my growth in clinical reasoning.”

You are not telling them what to write; you are:

• Jogging their memory
• Making it easier to be specific
• Helping them align their letter with your overall narrative

5. Can I see my recommendation letter before it’s submitted?

This depends on:

• Your institution’s policies
• The individual recommender’s preference
• Whether you choose to waive your right to view the letter in ERAS

Most advisors recommend waiving your right to view letters, as programs often interpret this as a sign that the letters are more likely to be candid and unbiased. If a recommender offers to share their letter with you, that’s up to them—but never pressure someone to do so.

---

Strong Letters of Recommendation do not happen by chance. They are the result of years of professional conduct, intentional relationship-building, and a thoughtful, respectful request process.

By identifying the right recommenders, giving them enough time, providing clear and organized supporting materials, and communicating professionally, you significantly enhance your residency application and strengthen your long-term Medical Career trajectory.