Essential Guide: Strong Letters of Recommendation for EM-IM Residency

Understanding the Role of Letters of Recommendation for Caribbean IMGs

For a Caribbean IMG aiming for an Emergency Medicine–Internal Medicine (EM-IM) combined residency, your letters of recommendation (LORs) can be the difference between landing interviews and being filtered out. Programs know less about your school than about U.S. allopathic schools, so they lean heavily on trusted voices—physicians they know or institutions they respect—to interpret your clinical performance.

LORs matter even more if you:

• Attended a Caribbean medical school with variable name recognition
• Have an uneven academic record or USMLE scores that are average or slightly below target programs
• Are applying to a competitive combined specialty like EM-IM, in addition to categorical emergency medicine internal medicine applications

Program directors consistently rank residency letters of recommendation among the most important factors for interview offers. For Caribbean medical school residency applicants, strong, credible LORs:

• Validate your clinical skills and professionalism
• Confirm that you can perform at the level of U.S. seniors
• Address any red flags or contextualize your training background
• Show that you’ve worked in U.S. clinical environments and can function in the healthcare system where you’ll train

If you’re at a school like SGU, Ross, AUC, or another Caribbean program, your SGU residency match (or other school’s match outcomes) will partially depend on the quality and specificity of your letters. Numbers get you past screens; letters convince people you’re safe, reliable, and worth interviewing.

This article walks you step-by-step through how to get strong LORs, who to ask for letters, and how to tailor them to EM-IM combined training as a Caribbean IMG.

---

What Makes a Strong Residency Letter of Recommendation?

Before you start asking, you need to understand what “strong” actually looks like in the eyes of EM-IM program directors.

1. Specific, Behavior-Based, and Personalized

Generic praise (“hard-working, team player”) without specifics is weak. Strong letters:

• Describe what you did (e.g., “led an ACLS resuscitation under supervision”)
• Provide concrete examples (e.g., “managed 8–10 ED patients at a time during peak hours”)
• Compare you to peers (e.g., “among the top 10% of students I’ve supervised in the past 5 years”)

Vague:

“The student did well on the rotation and was pleasant to work with.”

Strong:

“She independently formulated differential diagnoses for complex patients, then refined them after feedback. Her presentations were concise, organized, and at the level of a strong sub-intern.”

Actionable takeaway: When you think about how to get strong LOR, you should be aiming for letters with details and comparisons, not just adjectives.

2. From the Right People (and Institutions)

For Caribbean IMGs, who signs your letter can significantly affect how it’s weighted. Ideal letter writers:

• Are EM or IM faculty at U.S. teaching hospitals
• Have an academic role (Program Director, APD, Clerkship Director, Department Chair, Core Faculty)
• Have a history of training or working with residents
• Are familiar with EM or IM residency expectations

A thoughtful letter from a community preceptor can still be very helpful, but a Program Director’s or Clerkship Director’s letter from a known institution often carries more weight.

3. Clear Endorsement and No “Hidden Red Flags”

Program directors read between the lines. Weak phrases include:

• “I expect the applicant will do fine”
• “The student completed the rotation without issues”
• “I recommend without reservation for some residency programs”

Stronger language:

• “I give my strongest recommendation for EM-IM combined training”
• “I would be thrilled to have this applicant as a resident in our program”
• “I recommend this student without any reservations for residency in Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine”

4. Aligned With Your Specialty

Because you’re targeting EM-IM combined training (and/or separate EM IM combined applications like categorical EM and categorical IM), your letters should:

• Speak to both acute-care skills (ED pace, procedures, rapid decision-making) and longitudinal care (ward management, chronic disease, continuity, complex medical issues)
• Mention your interest in both emergency medicine internal medicine training paths
• Highlight adaptability across multiple settings (ED, wards, ICU)

Example specialty-appropriate statement:

“He excelled in our busy ED, but also demonstrated the patience and thoroughness necessary for complex internal medicine patients—qualities that are ideal for a career in Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine.”

---

Who to Ask for Letters as a Caribbean IMG Applying to EM-IM

One of the most strategic decisions is who to ask for letters. This is especially critical for Caribbean medical school residency applicants whose clinical experiences may be spread across multiple sites.

Recommended Letter Mix for EM-IM Applicants

While exact expectations vary by program, a typical strong LOR portfolio for EM-IM would include:

• 2 Emergency Medicine letters
• 2 Internal Medicine letters
• At least 1–2 letters from U.S. academic teaching hospitals
• At least 1 letter from a faculty member with a title (PD, APD, Clerkship Director, etc.)

You won’t upload all letters to every program—you’ll choose which to assign—but having a strong pool gives you flexibility.

EM-Specific Letters

Ideal writers:

• EM Program Director or Associate Program Director from a U.S. residency
• EM Clerkship Director from a major teaching hospital
• Core EM faculty at an institution with a residency program

If possible, at least one of your EM letters should be from a site with an EM residency. For EM-IM combined programs, a PD letter or standardized EM letter (if used at your site) is very valuable.

IM-Specific Letters

Ideal writers:

• Internal Medicine Program Director or Associate PD
• IM Clerkship Director or Sub-I Director
• Hospitalist with a significant teaching role

For EM-IM applications, at least one strong IM letter showing your performance on wards or ICU is important—this reassures programs that you’re truly committed to both parts of the combined training.

Prioritizing Your Rotations and Letter Writers

As a Caribbean IMG, your rotation choices often determine who you can ask for letters. Prioritize:

1. U.S. core and elective rotations at teaching hospitals with residency programs
2. Audition/Sub-I rotations in EM or IM at target or similar institutions
3. Rotations where you can work closely with attendings, not just residents

If you’re early in your clinical years, plan with letters in mind:

• For EM: try to arrange at least one rotation at a site with an ACGME-accredited EM residency.
• For IM: secure at least one inpatient medicine rotation with strong teaching faculty and residents.

How to Decide Who to Ask for Letters

When deciding who to ask for letters, consider:

• Did this attending see you often (not just once or twice)?
• Did they directly observe your clinical reasoning, presentations, and patient care?
• Did you receive positive mid-rotation or end-of-rotation feedback?
• Do they seem supportive and approachable?
• Are they in a position of authority (PD, APD, clerkship leader, core faculty)?

If you’re uncertain, ask directly:

“Do you feel you know my work well enough to write a strong letter of recommendation for my EM-IM residency applications?”

This gives them a respectful exit if they can’t be strongly supportive—and protects you from lukewarm letters.

---

How to Get Strong LOR: Step-by-Step Strategy for Caribbean IMGs

Caribbean IMGs often need to be more intentional and proactive about letters than U.S. MD seniors. Here’s a structured approach tailored to your situation.

Step 1: Plan Early (Before Rotations Begin)

• Map out your target specialty (EM-IM) and likely backup options (EM, IM, or both).
• Identify 3–4 rotations that are prime opportunities for strong letters (e.g., EM core, EM elective, IM core, IM sub-I).
• Clarify each site’s policy on letters—do they use standardized forms for EM? Do they require you to request through a coordinator?

Create a personal LOR timeline that aligns with ERAS deadlines so you’re not rushing in August/September.

Step 2: Stand Out Clinically on Key Rotations

To earn letters that say more than “average,” you must perform at a high level. Focus on:

• Reliability: Arrive early, stay late when appropriate, follow through on tasks.
• Ownership: Take responsibility for “your” patients (within supervision limits).
• Communication: Give concise, organized presentations; keep the team updated.
• Work ethic: Volunteer for admissions, procedures, and new patients.
• Feedback-seeking: Ask early, “How can I improve?” and show visible progress.

In EM, specifically:

• Demonstrate comfort with rapid histories, focused exams, and concise plans.
• Show that you can prioritize sick vs. not-sick and think in differentials, not just diagnoses.

In IM, specifically:

• Show you can manage complex, multi-morbid patients and think longitudinally.
• Demonstrate thoroughness, follow-up on labs, and organized notes.

Faculty notices growth. A narrative like “She actively sought feedback and showed rapid improvement” is extremely powerful in a letter.

Step 3: Express Your Specialty Interest Clearly

If you’re aiming for EM-IM, your evaluators need to understand that you’re not undecided—you’re intentionally pursuing combined training.

Examples of what to say:

• On EM rotations: “I’m applying to EM-IM combined residency because I love acute care but also want continuity and complex medical management.”
• On IM rotations: “I’m drawn to EM-IM because it integrates the diagnostic and longitudinal aspects of IM with the procedural and high-acuity environment of EM.”

This helps your letter writers:

• Frame your strengths in both EM and IM contexts
• Explicitly mention EM-IM in the letter (which strongly supports your application narrative)

Step 4: Ask at the Right Time

The best time to ask is:

• Near the end of the rotation, while your performance is fresh
• After you’ve had some positive feedback or a summative evaluation

You can say, for example:

“Dr. Smith, I’ve really valued working with you this month. I’m applying to Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine combined programs this cycle. Would you feel comfortable writing a strong letter of recommendation for my residency applications?”

Be direct and respectful. If they hesitate, thank them and consider someone else.

Step 5: Provide a Helpful Letter Writer Packet

Make it as easy as possible for them to write a personalized, strong letter. Your packet can include:

• Updated CV
• ERAS personal statement (or at least a draft)
• USMLE scores and transcript (if you’re comfortable sharing)
• Brief paragraph on why EM-IM specifically
• List of programs or types of programs you’re targeting
• Bullet-point reminders of cases or interactions you had with them (e.g., “the DKA patient we admitted together,” “the septic shock resuscitation in ED,” “my QI project presentation”)

For EM-IM, include a short note like:

“I’m applying to EM-IM combined programs because I enjoy high-acuity decision-making and procedures in the ED while also valuing the long-term management of complex medical conditions. I hope your letter can comment on my performance in acute care settings and my ability to manage complex internal medicine issues.”

Step 6: Gently Follow Up and Track Your Letters

• Ask early enough—ideally 4–6 weeks before you need the letter uploaded to ERAS.
• Send a polite reminder 1–2 weeks before the target date if it’s not uploaded.
• Use ERAS to track when letters are received and assigned.

Always be courteous—your reputation travels quickly, and you may apply to their program.

---

Tailoring Your LOR Strategy Specifically for EM-IM as a Caribbean IMG

EM-IM combined programs are relatively few and highly competitive. As a Caribbean IMG, you must be strategic in how you use your letters to reinforce your story.

Emphasize Dual Strengths: Acute and Longitudinal Care

In conversations with potential letter writers, you can gently shape what they emphasize:

• In EM letters, ask them to highlight:

  • Your performance in high-acuity situations
  • Your poise under pressure
  • Your communication with consultants and inpatient teams
  • Your interest in the internal medicine aspects of ED patients (e.g., complex comorbidities)

• In IM letters, ask them to highlight:

  • Your ability to manage complex, multi-system disease
  • Your thoroughness and follow-through
  • Your clinical reasoning and diagnostic thinking
  • Any situations where you handled acutely decompensating patients on the wards or ICU

You’re not writing the letters for them, but you can provide a short note or bullet list gently suggesting areas they might comment on.

Addressing the Caribbean School Context

Many programs are familiar with Caribbean medical schools and the SGU residency match data or match outcomes from similar schools. But letters still must:

• Demonstrate that you function at or above the level of U.S. seniors
• Show that any perceived disadvantages (e.g., limited home institution EM exposure) are offset by strong clinical performance

Some attendings may be willing to explicitly mention this, for example:

“Although he trained at a Caribbean medical school, his clinical performance is on par with, or better than, many U.S. medical students I have supervised. He quickly adapted to our system and functioned as a sub-intern on our team.”

Statements like this help neutralize any unconscious bias about Caribbean medical school residency applicants.

Using Letters Across EM-IM, EM, and IM Applications

Many EM-IM applicants also apply to:

• Categorical EM
• Categorical IM
• Or both, in addition to EM-IM combined programs

To make your letters maximally versatile:

• Ask writers to reference Emergency Medicine or Internal Medicine (or both) in the body of the letter, but avoid naming specific programs unless absolutely needed.
• Some letters can explicitly say “Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine,” which is ideal for combined programs and still acceptable for many EM-only or IM-only programs.
• Assign letters strategically:
  • For EM-IM programs: 1–2 EM letters + 1–2 IM letters that mention or support EM-IM.
  • For EM programs: EM-heavy letters plus IM letters emphasizing acute care and teamwork.
  • For IM programs: IM letters plus EM letters focusing on complex medical management and professionalism.

Common Pitfalls Caribbean IMGs Should Avoid

1. All letters from Caribbean or non-U.S. sites

   • Try hard to obtain at least 2 U.S. clinical letters from teaching hospitals.

2. Letters from non-physicians or unrelated specialties

   • Use research mentor letters only as extra, not core clinical letters—especially if they’re not EM or IM.

3. Late or missing letters

   • In a compressed application timeline, delayed letters can mean missed interview offers.

4. Over-reliance on a single “big name” letter

   • One big name with little personal knowledge is weaker than multiple specific, detailed letters from people who know you well.

---

Practical Tips to Strengthen Your LORs as a Caribbean IMG

Tip 1: Ask for Feedback Before You Ask for a Letter

Mid-rotation, ask:

“I’m hoping to pursue EM-IM. How am I doing so far compared to other students at my level? Are there areas I should focus on improving?”

If the response is strongly positive, that’s a good potential letter writer. If it’s mixed, use the feedback to improve and consider asking someone else.

Tip 2: Show Your Commitment Beyond the Minimum

On key EM and IM rotations:

• Volunteer for scholarly or QI projects.
• Attend conferences, morbidity and mortality (M&M), and journal clubs.
• Ask if you can give a short presentation on an EM or IM topic.

Then, remind your letter writer of this in your packet:

“I also appreciated the chance to present on septic shock management at the resident conference.”

Tip 3: Be Transparent About Your Application Strategy

Many Caribbean IMGs apply broadly. When you ask for letters, you can say:

“My primary interest is EM-IM combined programs, but I’m also applying to some categorical EM and IM programs. If you can, it would be helpful for the letter to comment on my suitability for both emergency medicine and internal medicine.”

This helps them write a flexible letter that works across your different application targets.

Tip 4: Don’t Ghost Your Letter Writers

After letters are uploaded:

• Send a sincere thank-you email.
• Update them when you receive interviews or match.
• Let them know the outcome of your match—faculty appreciate hearing where you end up.

This keeps doors open if you need future letters (e.g., fellowship, job) and maintains your professional network in the U.S.

---

FAQs: Letters of Recommendation for Caribbean IMG in EM-IM

1. How many letters of recommendation do I need for EM-IM combined programs?

Most programs allow 3–4 LORs per application. For EM-IM combined programs, a strong setup is:

• 1–2 EM letters (ideally from academic EM faculty, PD, or Clerkship Director)
• 1–2 IM letters (from IM faculty, PD, or Clerkship Director)

Check each program’s website or ERAS listing to confirm requirements. Have at least 4 solid letters in total so you can mix and match across EM-IM, EM, and IM programs.

2. Are letters from my Caribbean medical school useful, or should I only use U.S. letters?

Letters from your Caribbean medical school can be useful if:

• They’re from faculty who know you very well
• They can comment on your professionalism, work ethic, and academic performance over time

However, for residency in the U.S., especially for a Caribbean medical school residency applicant, U.S.-based letters from clinical rotations in American teaching hospitals often carry more weight. Aim for at least 2–3 strong U.S. letters, and then add a trusted home-school letter if it’s truly strong and specific.

3. Should I waive my right to see my letters in ERAS?

Yes, you should almost always waive your right to view your letters. Program directors view waived letters as more honest and confidential. If you’re concerned about a weak or negative letter, that’s a sign you should not be asking that writer in the first place. Instead, clarify upfront:

“Do you feel you can write me a strong, positive letter for EM-IM residency?”

4. What if an attending offers to let me draft my own letter?

This is sometimes offered, especially at busy community or high-volume sites. It’s a delicate situation. If you’re asked to draft, you should:

• Be honest but positive, with specific examples of your performance
• Avoid exaggeration or unrealistic praise
• Emphasize attributes relevant to EM-IM (acute care, teamwork, longitudinal management, complex internal medicine)

However, ideally, faculty should write their own letters. If you feel uncomfortable, you can say:

“I’d be happy to provide you with my CV, personal statement, and bullet points summarizing my experience on the rotation to help with your letter.”

This encourages them to write it themselves using your supporting materials.

---

By understanding how to get strong LOR, who to ask for letters, and how to tailor them to emergency medicine internal medicine combined training, you can significantly strengthen your overall profile as a Caribbean IMG. Thoughtful, strategic letters that clearly endorse you for EM-IM—and show that you can thrive in both the ED and internal medicine wards—are one of the most powerful levers you control in the residency application process.