Essential Guide to Letters of Recommendation for IMG Residency Success

Understanding the Role of Letters of Recommendation in Preliminary Medicine for IMGs

For an international medical graduate (IMG) applying to a Preliminary Medicine (prelim IM) year, letters of recommendation (LORs) can make the difference between landing interviews and getting filtered out. Because many IMGs come from unfamiliar schools and different health systems, program directors rely heavily on strong, specific, and credible letters to gauge clinical performance, communication skills, and readiness for U.S. training.

In a crowded applicant pool—especially for transitional and prelim spots—well‑crafted residency letters of recommendation can:

• Validate your clinical competence in a U.S. context
• Demonstrate that you can function on a busy inpatient medicine service
• Show you are reliable, professional, and “low‑risk” to hire for one intensive year
• Highlight your potential for categorical medicine or another advanced specialty

This IMG residency guide focuses specifically on how to get strong LOR support as an IMG targeting a Preliminary Medicine position. We’ll cover who to ask for letters, how many you need, what they should say, and how to overcome common IMG‑specific challenges.

---

How Many Letters You Need — And What Kind

Most Preliminary Medicine programs follow general ERAS and NRMP expectations, with 3 letters as the standard and 4 as the maximum. Always check each program’s website for exact requirements, but the following framework fits most prelim IM applications.

Core Numbers

• Total letters to upload: 3–4
• Letters actually assigned per program via ERAS: Typically 3, sometimes 4 if program allows

For a strong prelim IM application, an IMG should aim for:

• 2–3 clinical Internal Medicine letters (inpatient strongly preferred)
• 0–1 letter from another core specialty (e.g., surgery, emergency medicine, or a research PI, only if very strong and relevant)

If you’re also applying to an advanced specialty (neurology, anesthesiology, radiology, etc.), you may need separate specialty‑specific letters. However, this article focuses on the Preliminary Medicine year letters.

Prioritization for IMGs

Because many IMGs have limited U.S. exposure, U.S. clinical experience (USCE) letters are usually more influential than exclusively home‑country letters. A common strong portfolio for an IMG prelim applicant:

1. Letter 1: U.S. inpatient Internal Medicine attending who directly supervised you
2. Letter 2: Another U.S. IM attending (ward, ICU, or night float)
3. Letter 3: U.S. or home‑country medicine attending with long‑term knowledge of your work
4. Optional (Letter 4): Research or subspecialty mentor who can speak in depth about your professionalism, academic potential, or clinical research relevance

If you lack multiple U.S. letters, we’ll cover strategies later to still build a competitive set.

---

Who to Ask for Letters of Recommendation (And Who Not To)

Knowing who to ask for letters can be more important than almost anything else in your LOR strategy. For a Preliminary Medicine year, you’re applying to a single intense year of mostly inpatient medicine. Program directors want reassurance that you can handle heavy service, communicate well, and function like a PGY‑1 on day one.

Ideal Letter Writers for Prelim Medicine

1. U.S. Internal Medicine Attendings (Inpatient)
These are the gold standard.

Prefer:

• Ward (hospitalist) attendings
• ICU or step‑down unit attendings
• Night float attendings who saw you manage cross‑cover or admissions

They should have:

• Worked with you for at least 2–4 weeks
• Directly observed your clinical skills and interactions
• Some familiarity with U.S. residency expectations

2. Subspecialty Internal Medicine Attendings (U.S.)
If you lack multiple general medicine ward letters, a subspecialty (e.g., cardiology, GI, heme/onc, nephrology) attending can also be strong if:

• You had meaningful inpatient exposure (consults, co‑management, or unit teams)
• They can speak to your reasoning, follow‑through, and professional behavior

3. Home‑Country Internal Medicine Faculty (If Strong and Detailed)
Especially valuable if:

• They’ve known you for years (e.g., mentor, department head, residency supervisor)
• Can describe your progression, reliability, and independent practice
• Write in clear English with specific examples

These letters help show long‑term consistency and maturity, particularly for IMGs with prior training overseas.

4. Research Mentors (Selective Use)
A research PI can be powerful if:

• Your research is in Internal Medicine or a closely related field
• They also supervised you clinically (even partly)
• They can speak to your work ethic, reliability, and communication, not just data skills

For a Prelim Medicine year, a pure bench‑research letter is usually supportive rather than core. Use it as a third or fourth letter, not your primary clinical reference.

Who Not to Ask (Or Use Very Carefully)

1. Residents or Fellows as Primary Authors
Most programs expect attending‑level letters. A senior resident can draft input, but the final signer should be:

• An attending physician
• Ideally with an institutional title (program director, clerkship director, division chief, etc.)

2. Non‑Clinical Supervisors for a Clinical Year
For a clinical prelim IM spot, letters from:

• Language teachers
• Non‑medical employers
• Volunteer coordinators outside healthcare

…may be less impactful. Use them only if they know you extremely well and you lack other options, and even then, as a supplemental (4th) letter.

3. Famous But Vague Letter Writers
A department chair or dean who barely knows you and writes a generic letter hurts more than it helps. Name recognition cannot replace detailed, personalized endorsement.

---

What Makes a Strong Letter for a Prelim Medicine Applicant

Beyond who writes the letter, program directors care about what the letter actually says. Programs read hundreds of applications; they know the difference between generic praise and a genuine endorsement.

Core Elements of a Strong Prelim IM Letter

A strong LOR for a Preliminary Medicine year should:

1. Confirm level and setting of supervision

   • “I supervised Dr. X directly for four weeks on the inpatient general medicine service.”
   • Clarifies that the writer truly observed your clinical work.

2. Describe your clinical responsibilities

   • Admissions, daily notes, handoffs, cross‑coverage, procedures, discharge planning, etc.
   • Program directors want to see responsibilities similar to what an intern handles.

3. Comment on key competencies relevant to prelim IM

   • Clinical reasoning and differential diagnosis
   • Work ethic and reliability, especially overnight and during high‑volume days
   • Communication with patients, nurses, and consultants
   • Teamwork and receptiveness to feedback
   • Professionalism and integrity

4. Include specific, concrete examples

   • “Dr. Y recognized early signs of sepsis and escalated care appropriately…”
   • “On a weekend with 12 admissions, Dr. Y maintained composure, organized patient data efficiently, and ensured safe sign‑out.”

5. Compare you to peers

   • “Among the international medical graduates I have worked with in the last five years, Dr. Z ranks in the top 5%.”
   • Comparative language is extremely valuable, especially for IMGs.

6. Explicitly recommend you for residency

   • “I strongly recommend Dr. X without reservation for a Preliminary Medicine residency position.”
   • Avoids any ambiguity about whether you can function at intern level.

Unique Points Helpful for IMG Applicants

Letters for IMGs applying to a prelim IM year are especially valuable when they address:

• Adaptation to the U.S. healthcare system

  • Navigating EMR, order entry, documentation, insurance considerations
  • Collaborating effectively with interdisciplinary teams

• Communication in English

  • Clarity in presenting patients, writing notes, and counseling patients
  • Ability to build rapport despite cultural or language differences

• Visa or onboarding considerations (indirectly)

  • No need to mention visa type directly, but assurance of professionalism and reliability lowers perceived risk.

Red Flags in Weak Letters

Weak or damaging letters often include:

• Vague generalities without detail (“hard‑working, very nice”)
• Short length (e.g., half‑page template letters)
• Faint praise or hedging (“with further supervision, may develop into…”)
• Backhanded comments on language, punctuality, or professionalism

If a faculty member seems hesitant, it’s safer not to request a letter from them.

---

How to Get Strong LORs as an IMG: Step‑by‑Step Strategy

This is the heart of the IMG residency guide: strategically planning your rotations and interactions to generate strong, credible letters for a Preliminary Medicine year.

1. Plan Rotations With Letters in Mind

If you’re arranging U.S. clinical experience (USCE):

• Prioritize inpatient Internal Medicine rotations

  • At academic or teaching hospitals if possible
  • At institutions that regularly host IMGs and understand their context

• Schedule them 4–6 months before application deadlines

  • So letters are ready by September/October
  • Allow time for faculty to observe sustained performance

For those already in the U.S. (e.g., research scholars, observers):

• Negotiate hands‑on or closely supervised roles where attending physicians can truly evaluate your skills. Pure observerships make strong letters harder, but not impossible, if you’re proactive and involved.

2. Show Letter‑Worthy Behaviors Every Day

Attendings are more likely to write impactful letters when you:

• Consistently arrive early and prepared
• Volunteer for admissions and follow‑ups
• Present logically with clear assessment and plan
• Follow through on tasks (labs, consults, documentation)
• Proactively ask for feedback and show you apply it

Your goal is to make it easy for them to remember you as reliable, safe, and teachable.

3. Signal Early That You Hope for a Letter

Halfway through a rotation, say something like:

“I’m planning to apply for a Preliminary Medicine residency as an IMG this year. If I continue to perform well, would you feel comfortable writing me a strong letter of recommendation?”

This does three things:

1. Gives the attending a chance to decline early if they can’t be strong
2. Signals that letters matter to you, so they may observe you more closely
3. Allows you to adjust if they seem hesitant (you can seek other writers during the same period)

If they respond positively (“Yes, I’d be happy to”), continue working at a high level and ask them later for the letter formally.

4. Provide a Helpful “Letter Packet”

When you request the letter, make it easy for the writer to advocate effectively. Share:

• Your updated CV
• Personal statement draft (even if still evolving)
• ERAS photo (so they remember you)
• Summary of your work with them
  • Rotation dates, services, and any notable cases
• Your career goals
  • E.g., “I’m applying for a Preliminary Medicine year, then Neurology categorical,” or “I ultimately hope to match categorical Internal Medicine.”

You can also gently remind them of specific examples:

“During our rotation, I particularly appreciated your feedback on my presentations and your support during the high‑admission weekend; these moments were important in my growth and might be useful examples for the letter.”

This is not “writing your own letter” — it’s giving context so they can write a richer one.

5. Respect Confidentiality (Waive Your Right to View)

In ERAS, you’ll choose whether to waive your right to see each letter. Programs and faculty strongly prefer that applicants waive access, which signals:

• You trust the writer
• The letter is more likely to be candid

If you suspect a letter might not be strong enough to waive rights, it’s better to select a different letter writer.

6. Follow Up Politely and Early

Faculty are busy. To ensure your letters are completed on time:

• Request the letter at least 4–6 weeks before you need it uploaded
• Send a gentle reminder 1–2 weeks before your internal deadline
• Include your ERAS LOR request link and clear instructions

Sample follow‑up email:

Dear Dr. [Name],

I hope you’re doing well. This is a friendly reminder about the letter of recommendation for my Preliminary Medicine residency application. ERAS opens for program review on [date], so I’m hoping to have all letters uploaded by [date].

I’ve re‑attached my CV and personal statement for convenience.

Thank you again for your support and mentorship.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

---

Special Challenges and Solutions for IMGs

IMGs face several unique obstacles in building strong residency letters of recommendation. With planning, you can often mitigate these.

Challenge 1: Limited or Observership‑Only U.S. Clinical Experience

If your U.S. time is mainly observership:

Solutions:

• Be extremely engaged:
  • Ask to help with presentations, literature searches, and progress note drafts
  • Participate in case discussions and sign‑outs
• Request letters from attendings who’ve seen you consistently on rounds and teaching sessions
• Combine this with strong home‑country letters highlighting your independent clinical responsibilities

When the writer describes your initiative and growth within the constraints of an observership, the letter can still be compelling.

Challenge 2: Long Gap Since Graduation or Clinical Practice

Program directors worry about clinical “rust” when there are gaps. Letters can counter this by:

• Emphasizing how quickly you adapted to clinical work after a break
• Highlighting continuing medical education, research, or telemedicine experience
• Describing your maturity, professionalism, and motivation

Make sure at least one letter writer is aware of your timeline and can frame it positively.

Challenge 3: Language and Communication Concerns

As an IMG, your spoken and written English may be under extra scrutiny. Proactively:

• Ask faculty for direct feedback on your presentations and notes
• Practice patient counseling scripts and handoff language
• Request letters from attendings who’ve explicitly praised your communication

If a letter explicitly states, “Dr. X communicates clearly with patients and staff, with no concerns about language or cultural understanding,” that reassures programs.

Challenge 4: Applying Prelim While Also Targeting Another Specialty

Many IMG prelim applicants are also aiming for:

• Neurology
• Anesthesiology
• Radiology
• Ophthalmology
• PM&R

You may need:

• General IM‑focused letters (emphasizing your ability to function as an intern)
• Specialty‑focused letters (for your ultimate field)

When you talk with potential writers, be transparent:

“I’m applying to a Preliminary Medicine year and ultimately plan for Neurology. Would you be comfortable writing a letter that supports both — highlighting my readiness for an internal medicine internship and my potential in Neurology?”

Most faculty can tailor letters in a way that suits both contexts.

---

Putting It All Together: Example Letter Portfolios

Example 1: Strong IMG with Recent USCE

• Letter 1 (Primary):

  • U.S. academic hospitalist attending from 4‑week inpatient IM rotation
  • Detailed letter with specific examples, top‑tier ranking among peers

• Letter 2:

  • U.S. ICU attending from 2‑week critical care rotation
  • Emphasizes calm under pressure, rapid learning, and teamwork

• Letter 3:

  • Home‑country IM department head, supervised applicant during internship
  • Highlights long‑term reliability, procedures, and independent decision‑making

• Letter 4 (Optional):

  • Research mentor in cardiology (also saw applicant on consult service)

This portfolio is highly competitive for many prelim IM programs.

Example 2: IMG with Limited U.S. Experience

• Letter 1:

  • U.S. Internal Medicine attending from 4‑week observership
  • Describes active engagement, quick adaptation, and strong knowledge base

• Letter 2:

  • Home‑country IM residency program director
  • Details independent responsibilities, overnight call, and complex case management

• Letter 3:

  • Home‑country subspecialty IM attending (e.g., cardiology or nephrology)
  • Speaks to advanced clinical reasoning and patient rapport

• Letter 4 (Optional):

  • Long‑term research supervisor, emphasizing professionalism and perseverance

Though U.S. exposure is limited, detailed, credible letters can still present a strong narrative, especially if the rest of the application (scores, English fluency, personal statement) is aligned.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Do I really need U.S. letters of recommendation for a Preliminary Medicine year?

They are strongly preferred and often expected, especially at more competitive programs. At least one U.S. Internal Medicine letter is highly advisable for an IMG. However, if you have extensive clinical experience in your home country and detailed, credible letters from there, you can still be considered—particularly by community or IMG‑friendly programs.

2. Is it okay to use the same letters for both categorical IM and Preliminary Medicine applications?

Yes. Most categorical IM and prelim IM programs are comfortable with the same set of strong Internal Medicine clinical letters. Just make sure your writers recommend you broadly “for Internal Medicine residency” or “for a residency position,” rather than only for a categorical slot in one institution, unless that is your exclusive target.

3. Can I write my own letter and ask the attending to sign it?

You should not write your own LOR. Many institutions explicitly prohibit this. However, it is acceptable to provide:

• A summary of your work together
• Bullet points of achievements and memorable cases
• Your CV and personal statement

This supports the writer in creating an authentic letter in their own words.

4. How do I know if a letter writer will be strong enough?

Ask directly and respectfully:

“Would you feel comfortable writing me a strong letter of recommendation for Preliminary Medicine residency?”

If they hesitate, use neutral language, or condition their answer heavily (“I can provide a letter that confirms you rotated with us”), consider choosing another writer. A neutral or lukewarm letter can harm your application more than having fewer, truly enthusiastic letters.

---

Crafting a powerful letter of recommendation strategy as an international medical graduate applying to a Preliminary Medicine year requires active planning, clear communication, and professionalism. By choosing the right writers, demonstrating your abilities consistently, and supporting your letter writers with context and materials, you significantly increase your chances of convincing program directors that you are ready to excel as a prelim IM intern in the U.S. healthcare system.