Crafting Strong Letters of Recommendation for Med Psych Residency

Letters of recommendation (LORs) carry significant weight in applications for med psych residency programs. For combined medicine psychiatry residency—where programs are explicitly looking for evidence of excellence in two disciplines—your letters become even more critical. They offer program directors a direct, narrative assessment of your clinical skills, professionalism, and potential to thrive in a dual-training environment.

This guide walks you through everything you need to know about residency letters of recommendation for Medicine-Psychiatry: who to ask, how to get strong LORs, what program directors actually look for, and how to avoid common pitfalls.

---

Understanding the Role of Letters of Recommendation in Med-Psych

Letters of recommendation are one of the most influential components of your application for medicine psychiatry combined residency programs. While your scores, grades, and CV provide quantitative data, LORs provide the context and story behind those numbers.

Why LORs Matter So Much in Combined Programs

For med psych residency, selection committees are looking for:

• Clear evidence that you can function at a high level in both Internal Medicine and Psychiatry
• Proof of adaptability—moving between inpatient wards, consult services, and psychiatric units
• Demonstrated emotional intelligence, communication skills, and teamwork
• A track record of professionalism and reliability

Letters are uniquely suited to:

• Provide specific examples of you caring for patients across medical and psychiatric dimensions
• Demonstrate that attendings trust you with complex, vulnerable patients
• Reinforce that your interest in combined training is sincere and informed, not just a last-minute decision

In a relatively small and tight-knit specialty like Medicine-Psychiatry, a strong, specific letter can be a major differentiator.

How Many Letters Do You Need?

Always confirm requirements on:

• Each program’s website
• ERAS (or relevant application portal)
• Your Dean’s Office or advising office recommendations

Typical patterns:

• Most combined med-psych residency programs: 3 letters (some allow 4)
• Common expectations:
  • At least one letter from Internal Medicine
  • At least one letter from Psychiatry
  • One flexible letter (IM, Psych, Subspecialty, Research, or a strong longitudinal mentor)

Some programs may strongly prefer:

• 2 medicine + 1 psychiatry, or
• 2 psychiatry + 1 medicine

To stay safe, aim for:

• 4 total letters in ERAS:
  • 2 Internal Medicine (including at least one from a core/clerkship or sub-internship)
  • 1 Psychiatry (preferably core clerkship or psych sub-I)
  • 1 additional (your strongest remaining option: research, chief resident, another clinical, or longitudinal mentor)

This allows you to customize which 3–4 letters you assign to each program, depending on their preferences.

---

Who to Ask for Letters: Building a Balanced, Strategic Set

Understanding who to ask for letters is central to how to get strong LOR for med psych residency. You don’t just want “good” letters—you want strategic letters that show the right blend of your clinical strengths.

Core Principles for Choosing Letter Writers

Prioritize attendings who:

1. Directly observed your clinical work

   • Wrote your clerkship evaluation
   • Supervised you in clinic, inpatient, or consults
   • Worked with you closely on a sub-I or acting internship

2. Know you beyond a single shift

   • Ideally, at least 2–4 weeks of consistent interaction
   • Can comment on growth, reliability, and follow-through

3. Can speak to BOTH competence and character

   • Clinical reasoning, efficiency, and knowledge
   • Teamwork, empathy, ethics, and professionalism

4. Understand or support your interest in combined training

   • Will articulate why you are well-suited for medicine psychiatry combined programs

Essential Letters for Med-Psych Applicants

For a strong med psych residency application, try to secure:

1. A Strong Internal Medicine Letter (Core or Sub-I)

This is foundational. You want:

• An inpatient or outpatient Internal Medicine attending who:
  • Saw you manage day-to-day care
  • Noticed your thoroughness and reliability
  • Can vouch for your readiness for PGY-1 level responsibilities

Ideal sources:

• IM Sub-Internship or Acting Internship attending
• Core IM clerkship teaching attending
• Ward or clinic attending who supervised you for at least 2–4 weeks

What this letter should highlight:

• Your clinical reasoning with complex medical patients
• Your ability to manage tasks and follow through under pressure
• Professionalism, documentation, and work ethic

2. A Strong Psychiatry Letter

You also need clear, convincing evidence that you are serious about Psychiatry and can thrive in behavioral health settings.

Ideal sources:

• Psychiatry core clerkship attending or preceptor
• Psych sub-I attending (inpatient, consults, or outpatient)
• Faculty with dual appointments or experience with integrated care

What this letter should highlight:

• Your comfort discussing sensitive, personal topics with patients
• Your ability to integrate medical and psychiatric perspectives
• Your insight, compassion, and nonjudgmental stance
• Any examples showing your interest in serious mental illness, psychosomatic presentations, or integrated care

3. A Third Letter that Adds Depth

This can come from:

• Another IM or Psych attending (solidifying your consistency across rotations)
• A combined med-psych or consult-liaison psychiatrist, if available
• A research mentor in a relevant field (e.g., integrated care, serious mental illness, substance use, population health)
• A longitudinal preceptor (e.g., continuity clinic, primary care, or behavioral health)

Choose the writer who can speak most strongly and specifically about you, even if they are not in IM or Psych, as long as you already have IM and Psych letters secured.

---

How to Get Strong LOR: Step-by-Step Strategy

Getting strong letters doesn’t start when you send an email—it starts on day one of the rotation. Program directors can usually tell when a letter is generic versus when it is written by someone who genuinely believes in your potential.

1. Perform with Intent on Key Rotations

On your core IM and Psychiatry rotations (and especially sub-Is):

• Show up early, stay engaged, and be reliable
• Ask for mid-rotation feedback:
  • “I’m aiming to apply to a medicine-psychiatry combined program and would really value your feedback on how I can perform at the level of a future intern.”
• Respond to feedback by visibly improving
• Volunteer for learning opportunities that show initiative:
  • Presenting on a topic relevant to a patient
  • Taking extra ownership of a complex patient
  • Following up on labs and imaging without being prompted

Attendings are more likely to write compelling residency letters of recommendation if they see you actively striving to grow.

2. Signal Your Interest in Med-Psych Early

Many faculty still may not fully understand what med psych residency entails. Early in the rotation:

• Share your interest:
  • “I’m considering combined Medicine-Psychiatry training because I’m drawn to caring for patients with both serious medical and psychiatric illness.”
• When relevant, demonstrate integrative thinking:
  • Ask about how medical issues affect psychiatric treatment and vice versa
  • Volunteer to follow patients with both high medical and psychiatric complexity

This makes it easier for attendings to frame your letter around why you are uniquely suited for medicine psychiatry combined training.

3. Choose the Right Moment and Right Wording

Ask for your letter:

• Toward the end of the rotation, when they’ve seen your full performance
• Or soon after the rotation ends, while you’re still fresh in their memory

How to ask in person (ideal):

“Dr. X, I’ve really appreciated working with you these past few weeks. I’m applying to Medicine-Psychiatry combined residency programs and I was wondering if you would feel comfortable writing me a strong letter of recommendation.”

Including the word “strong” matters. If they hesitate or say they can only write a “standard” letter, thank them and consider other options. A lukewarm letter can hurt you more than help.

If in-person is not possible, a well-structured email works (see below).

4. Provide a Helpful “Letter Packet”

To help your letter writer remember specifics and tailor the letter to med psych residency, send them:

• Updated CV
• Personal statement draft (even if still in progress)
• Unofficial transcript if appropriate
• A brief paragraph about:
  • Why you’re choosing medicine psychiatry combined residency
  • What you hope they can highlight based on your work with them
• Reminder of:
  • Rotation dates
  • Specific patients/cases you worked on together
  • Any presentations or projects you did on that rotation
  • ERAS due date and upload instructions

You can frame it as:

“To make your life easier, I’ve attached my CV, a draft of my personal statement, and a short summary of my experiences on your service. Please feel free to ignore this if you don’t find it helpful.”

5. Follow Up Professionally (Without Nagging)

Faculty are busy and sometimes forget. Plan to:

• Ask once in person (if possible)
• Follow up with one email 2–3 weeks later if not uploaded
• Send a gentle reminder 1–2 weeks before ERAS deadlines if still pending

Always include:

• A clear subject line (e.g., “Med-Psych Residency LOR – Gentle Reminder & ERAS Deadline Approaching”)
• The ERAS due date
• A polite tone expressing appreciation for their time

If a letter still doesn’t appear and the deadline is truly imminent, it may be necessary to have a backup letter ready from another attending.

---

Content and Structure of Effective Med-Psych LORs

While you won’t write your own letters, understanding what makes them strong helps you select writers and provide them with what they need.

What Program Directors Look For

Strong letters for medicine psychiatry combined residency typically:

1. Speak to both medical and behavioral dimensions
   Even if written by an IM or Psych attending, the best letters show your ability to think across domains.

2. Contain specific, behavioral examples
   Not just “hard-working” and “compassionate,” but:

   • “On our service, they took consistent ownership of a patient with uncontrolled diabetes and comorbid schizophrenia, coordinating with multiple teams to optimize both insulin management and adherence to antipsychotic therapy.”

3. Compare you to peers in a meaningful way

   • “Among the 40 students I’ve supervised in the last five years, they are in the top 5–10% in clinical reasoning and team collaboration.”

4. Address professionalism and reliability

   • Timeliness, ethical behavior, documentation, teamwork, respectful interactions with staff

5. Demonstrate alignment with the demands of a med psych residency

   • Handling complex, high-need patients
   • Emotional resilience
   • Comfort in uncertain or ambiguous clinical situations

Examples of Strong Med-Psych-Relevant Content

Some phrases or concepts that are particularly valuable for med-psych:

• “Integrates medical and psychiatric formulations when presenting patients”
• “Shows unusual insight into how trauma, substance use, and chronic disease intersect”
• “Remained calm and supportive during a patient’s acute psychotic episode while also monitoring for medical decompensation”
• “Naturally gravitates toward patients with complex psychosocial factors rather than avoiding them”
• “Demonstrated leadership in coordinating interprofessional care for a patient with severe heart failure and co-occurring depression and alcohol use disorder”

If a faculty member asks you for talking points, you can provide examples like these (based on your actual behavior, of course).

---

Practical Logistics: Timing, Waivers, and Common Pitfalls

Even with strong relationships and performance, logistical missteps can weaken your letter strategy. Attention to detail here is part of presenting as a ready-for-residency professional.

Optimal Timeline for Requesting and Collecting LORs

For a typical June–September application cycle:

• Late MS3 / Early MS4 (or equivalent)

  • Identify key rotations and potential letter writers.
  • Perform with LORs in mind on IM and Psych rotations.

• 4–6 months before ERAS opens

  • Ask your strongest faculty from IM and Psychiatry for letters.
  • Consider which additional mentor/attending will write your third or fourth letter.

• 2–3 months before ERAS submission

  • Ensure letters have been uploaded or send polite reminders.
  • Confirm you have at least one IM, one Psych, and one additional strong letter available.

• Before final submission

  • Double-check that all letters are correctly assigned to each med psych residency program.

Waiving Your Right to See the Letter

In most residency application systems, you will be asked whether to waive your right to view the letter.

• Best practice: Waive your right to see the letter.
• Why:
  • Program directors often interpret waived letters as more honest and candid.
  • Non-waived letters can raise questions about whether the writer might have self-censored.

You should still ask writers ahead of time if they can provide a strong letter; that is your quality control step.

Tailoring Letters for Categorical vs Combined Programs

Some applicants apply to:

• Medicine-Psychiatry combined residencies and
• Categorical Internal Medicine or Psychiatry programs

If that’s your strategy:

• Ask your letter writers if they are comfortable targeting the content broadly toward your overall strengths as a physician, with mention of your interest in integrated care.
• Alternatively, some writers may be willing to:
  • Write two versions (one focused on med psych residency, another framed for categorical IM or Psych). This is more work, so ask respectfully and only when clearly valuable.

You can then assign the most appropriate version to each program.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Over-reliance on research letters with limited clinical context

   • Research letters are valuable if they clearly speak to your clinical potential and teamwork—not just your statistics or bench skills.

2. Letters from people who barely know you

   • A well-known department chair who hardly interacted with you may write a vague letter that adds little value.

3. Too many letters from the same discipline without balance

   • For med psych residency, having 3 strong IM letters and no Psych letter (or vice versa) sends a confusing message.

4. Last-minute requests

   • Leads to rushed, generic, or delayed letters, which can harm your application.

5. Failure to communicate your med-psych interest

   • If your letter writers don’t know you’re targeting medicine psychiatry combined programs, they may not emphasize the integrative aspects of your skill set.

---

Final Tips: Putting It All Together for Medicine-Psychiatry

To make your letters work with the rest of your application:

• Ensure consistency between:
  • What your personal statement emphasizes
  • What your CV and experiences suggest
  • What your letters highlight
• Use your personal statement and ERAS experiences to reinforce:
  • Cases and stories your letter writers might mention
  • Longstanding interest in caring for complex, high-need, medically and psychiatrically ill populations
• When you interview, be prepared to:
  • Discuss your relationships with letter writers
  • Reflect on the rotations where you grew the most
  • Describe patients or experiences that shaped your med-psych trajectory

Strong, well-chosen residency letters of recommendation can make you stand out in a field where programs are searching for trainees with maturity, resilience, curiosity, and a deep commitment to integrated care. With deliberate planning—starting well before application season—you can assemble a set of LORs that truly reflect who you are and why you belong in Medicine-Psychiatry.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. How many Medicine and Psychiatry letters do I actually need for med psych residency?

Most medicine psychiatry combined programs expect at least:

• One letter from Internal Medicine
• One letter from Psychiatry
• One additional strong letter (often from IM, Psych, or a longitudinal/preclinical mentor)

Aim to have 4 total LORs in ERAS so you can:

• Always include both IM and Psych letters
• Add your strongest overall additional letter
• Adapt to specific program requirements

Always verify each program’s exact letter policy.

2. Is it better to get a letter from a big-name chair or someone who knows me well?

For med psych residency, specificity and authenticity outweigh name recognition. A well-known chair who barely knows you may produce a generic letter, which program directors see frequently and don’t weight heavily.

Prefer:

• An attending who directly supervised your clinical work
• Someone who can tell concrete stories about your behavior, growth, and patient care

A big-name letter is helpful only if that person truly knows you and can write in depth.

3. Can a research letter help my Medicine-Psychiatry application?

Yes—if your research mentor can:

• Talk about your intellectual curiosity, work ethic, and ability to work in teams
• Address your communication skills and professionalism
• Connect your research to integrated care, serious mental illness, or medically and psychiatrically complex populations, if applicable

However, do not substitute a research letter for required IM or Psychiatry clinical letters. Use it as a supplement, not a replacement.

4. What if I had a weaker performance on a key rotation—should I still ask that attending for a letter?

If you’re unsure:

1. Meet with the attending and ask for honest feedback about your performance.
2. If they express clear reservations or seem hesitant, it’s better to:
   • Thank them for their honesty
   • Seek a letter elsewhere
3. If you improved significantly during the rotation and the attending recognizes that growth, they may be able to write a nuanced but positive letter emphasizing your trajectory.

When in doubt, prioritize letter writers who can confidently describe you as ready for residency and well-suited for a demanding medicine psychiatry combined program.

---

By planning ahead, choosing your letter writers thoughtfully, and understanding what makes a letter compelling in this specialty, you can build a powerful LOR portfolio that supports a successful match into Medicine-Psychiatry.