Essential Guide to Letters of Recommendation for US Citizen IMGs in TY Programs

Why Letters of Recommendation Matter So Much for a US Citizen IMG in a Transitional Year

For a US citizen IMG (American studying abroad), letters of recommendation (LORs) are one of the single most powerful parts of your transitional year residency application. Program directors know that your transcript, exam scores, and school reputation vary widely across international schools. Strong, specific letters from credible US clinicians help them answer three questions:

1. Can you function safely on Day 1 of residency?
2. Will you work hard, be reliable, and fit into a team?
3. Are your skills and potential comparable to US medical graduates?

In a competitive and often opaque process, especially for a transitional year (TY) program, excellent letters can push your application from “maybe” to “interview.” Transitional year spots attract applicants from every specialty (radiology, anesthesiology, dermatology, PM&R, etc.), and programs need residents they can trust to cover diverse services. That’s exactly what your letters should demonstrate.

For an American studying abroad, this makes LOR strategy a top priority—not an afterthought.

In this guide, you’ll learn:

• What kind of letters TY programs value most
• Who to ask for letters (and who not to)
• How to get strong LOR rather than generic ones
• Timing, logistics, and ERAS details
• Strategies if you lack US clinical experience (USCE)
• Scripts and templates you can adapt today

---

Understanding Transitional Year LOR Expectations as a US Citizen IMG

Transitional year residency is unique: it’s a one‑year, broad-based clinical training experience often used as a preliminary year before categorical specialties. That shapes what programs want to see in your letters.

What Transitional Year Programs Look for in LORs

Across TY programs, letters are most impactful when they clearly speak to:

• Clinical competence across multiple settings
  • History-taking, physical exam, differential diagnosis
  • Ability to manage common inpatient and outpatient issues
• Work ethic and reliability
  • Shows up on time, stays until the work is done
  • Owns responsibilities and follows through
• Teamwork and communication
  • Works well with nurses, residents, attendings, and other staff
  • Communicates clearly with patients and families
• Adaptability and teachability
  • Responds well to feedback, improves over time
  • Handles steep learning curves in new rotations
• Professionalism
  • Honest, respectful, ethical, with good bedside manner
  • No red flags or professionalism concerns

Because transitional year residents rotate through internal medicine, surgery, emergency medicine, and often electives, programs prefer letters that portray you as a solid, all-around clinician. They want to know you will not struggle on basic wards.

Why LORs Are Especially Critical for a US Citizen IMG

As an American studying abroad, you’re competing with:

• US MD and DO seniors
• Non-US IMGs with strong USCE and research
• Prior-year graduates reapplying

Your international school name and grades may be harder for US program directors to interpret. Strong US-based letters help:

• Calibrate your level: “This student performs like my average US MD senior” is gold.
• Counteract bias: Not all PDs are familiar with foreign curricula; a respected US clinician vouching for you carries weight.
• Show that you’ve succeeded in US healthcare environments: A key differentiator for US citizen IMGs.

If you’re a US citizen IMG targeting a transitional year, you should think of your letters as your primary credibility documents in the US system.

---

Who to Ask for Letters of Recommendation (and Who to Avoid)

Choosing who to ask for letters is just as important as how you ask. The best strategy for a transitional year balances clinical relevance, US credibility, and depth of relationship.

Ideal Letter Writers for Transitional Year Applicants

1. US Clinical Attending Physicians (Highest Priority)
   Especially from:

   • Internal Medicine (ward or sub-I)
   • Surgery or surgical subspecialties
   • Emergency Medicine
   • Family Medicine or Pediatrics (for broad clinical skills)

   These letters demonstrate your performance in the same environment where you’ll be training.

2. Program Directors or Clerkship Directors

   • Internal medicine or surgery clerkship directors in the US
   • Transitional year program directors if you did an audition/sub-I rotation
   • Department education leaders who observed you clinically

   Their titles carry extra weight, and PDs understand what residency readiness looks like.

3. Subspecialty Attendings (If Clinically Focused)

   • Cardiology, GI, anesthesia, radiology, etc., if they supervised you directly in a clinical role
   • Particularly useful if your TY is linked to a categorical program (e.g., radiology) and the letter connects your skills to that pathway.

4. Home-Country or International Attendings (Supplemental)

   • If they can compare you favorably to US students and you have a long-standing relationship
   • More valuable if they have US or UK training or academic affiliations

Who to Avoid as Primary Letter Writers

• Non-clinical basic science professors
  • Unless they know you extremely well and can speak to your professionalism and work ethic in depth, and you absolutely need an extra letter.
• Family friends or personal physicians
  • Even if they’re US doctors, these are seen as biased and not objective.
• Very senior faculty who barely know you
  • A dean or department chair who spent one half-day with you is usually less helpful than a staff attending who worked with you for 4 weeks.
• Non-physician letters (e.g., from nurses, PAs, PhDs)
  • Can be powerful as supplemental narrative, but they should not replace physician LORs on ERAS.

How Many Letters Do Transitional Year Programs Expect?

Most TY programs accept 3–4 letters. A strong setup for a US citizen IMG might be:

• 1 letter from US Internal Medicine attending or PD (core or sub-I)
• 1 letter from US Surgery/EM/Family Medicine attending
• 1 letter from another US clinician who supervised you closely (any core specialty)
• Optional: 1 additional letter (international attending, research mentor, or subspecialty letter)

Always check each program’s ERAS listing, but 3 strong clinical letters are usually sufficient.

---

How to Get Strong LOR (Not Just Generic) as a US Citizen IMG

The single most important rule about residency letters of recommendation: a bland letter hurts you more than no letter. Programs read hundreds of letters, and they recognize vague, copy‑paste phrases immediately.

You want letters that are:

• Specific – concrete examples of your behavior and performance
• Comparative – where you stand among peers
• Enthusiastic – clear support for your residency potential

Here’s how to make that happen.

Step 1: Be Intentional About Your Clinical Rotations

To get strong LOR, you first need the right settings:

• Prioritize US clinical experience (USCE) in core fields:
  • Inpatient internal medicine
  • General surgery
  • Family medicine or pediatrics
  • Emergency medicine
• When possible, choose sites that:
  • Have residency programs or strong ties to academic centers
  • Give you direct attending and resident contact
  • Evaluate you formally (evaluations you can share with letter writers)

If you’re an American studying abroad, plan your final year so that your US rotations occur 6–12 months before you apply, giving time to build relationships and request letters.

Step 2: Signal Early That You’ll Need a Letter

Near the start of a rotation, briefly tell attendings you’re hoping to apply to a transitional year:

“I’m a US citizen IMG, and I’ll be applying to transitional year programs this fall. If I perform well on this rotation, I’d be very grateful to be considered for a letter of recommendation later on.”

This does two things:

• Signals to them to watch you closely
• Sets the expectation that you’re aiming for a strong evaluation

It also subtly reminds them that you take this rotation seriously.

Step 3: Perform Like a Future Intern

Letter writers are most comfortable going out on a limb for students who look “intern-ready.” Focus on behaviors that translate directly into strong narrative comments:

• Be early, never just “on time.”
• Volunteer for admissions, procedures, and follow-ups.
• Know your patients cold – vitals, meds, labs, imaging, social context.
• Ask for feedback mid-rotation and show visible improvement.
• Help the team: write drafts of notes (if allowed), call consults under supervision, update families.

When attendings see you functioning like a junior resident, their letters naturally include phrases like “already performing at the level of an intern” – a huge plus.

Step 4: Choose Who to Ask Based on Strength, Not Just Prestige

You want letters from people who can say, “I saw this student every day and here’s what they did,” not “I vaguely remember them, they were fine.”

Ask yourself:

• Who saw me on busy inpatient days, not just in clinic once a week?
• Who watched me handle difficult patients or challenging situations?
• Who has already given me positive direct feedback?

A strong letter from a community hospital attending who worked closely with you is better than a lukewarm note from a famous professor who barely knows you.

---

How to Ask for Residency Letters of Recommendation (Scripts and Strategy)

Knowing who to ask for letters is one thing; asking in a way that leads to a strong letter is another. As a US citizen IMG, you should be especially deliberate here.

When to Ask for the Letter

The best times:

• End of the rotation (last week), when your performance is fresh in their minds
• Or 1–2 weeks after if you’ve stayed in touch and they’re still engaged

Avoid waiting months; memory fades and letters become generic.

Key Phrase: “Strong Letter of Recommendation”

You should explicitly ask whether they can write a strong letter. This gives them an easy way to decline if they don’t feel they can support you enthusiastically.

Example script (in person or via email):

“Dr. Smith, I’ve really appreciated the chance to work with you on this rotation. I’m a US citizen IMG applying to transitional year residency programs this cycle. Based on what you’ve seen of my performance, would you feel comfortable writing a strong letter of recommendation for my residency applications?”

If they say “yes,” you can proceed. If they hesitate or say something like “I can write a letter,” without the word “strong,” consider asking someone else. A neutral letter is a liability.

What to Provide Your Letter Writers

Make their job easy and your letter better by giving them a letter packet:

• Updated CV
• ERAS personal statement (or at least a draft)
• USMLE/COMLEX scores (if you’re comfortable sharing, often recommended)
• Summary of your performance on the rotation, including:
  • Number and types of patients seen
  • Specific cases you handled
  • Any positive feedback they gave you (reminds them of moments they can write about)
• Your specialty and career goals
  • Even for a transitional year, mention whether you’re ultimately aiming for radiology, anesthesiology, derm, etc.
• ERAS letter request form with clear instructions and deadlines

You can also include a short “LOR highlights” sheet: 5–7 bullet points of things they might mention (work ethic, leadership moment, complex patient you handled). This is not writing your letter for them; it’s helping them remember details.

How to Handle ERAS and LoR Portals

Most residency letters of recommendation are submitted through the ERAS LOR portal. General steps:

1. In ERAS, create a LOR entry (add letter writer name, title, contact).
2. Indicate whether you waive your right to see the letter (you almost always should; programs trust waived letters more).
3. Generate and save the ERAS LOR request form (PDF).
4. Send the form to your letter writer via email, with your materials attached.
5. Gently remind them 2–3 weeks before your submission deadline.

If you’re applying to both TY and categorical programs, you can reuse letters across applications and assign different combinations per program in ERAS.

Following Up Without Being Annoying

Attendings are busy; sometimes they simply forget. A polite, concise reminder is appropriate:

Subject: Gentle Reminder – Letter of Recommendation for Transitional Year Applications

Dear Dr. Smith,
I hope you’re doing well. This is a friendly reminder about the letter of recommendation for my transitional year residency applications. My target ERAS submission date is [date], and it would be very helpful to have the letter uploaded by then.

I’ve reattached my CV and personal statement for your convenience.

Thank you again for your time and support.
Best regards,
[Your Name]

One or two reminders are acceptable; more than that risks tension.

---

Special Considerations for US Citizen IMGs: Gaps, Limited USCE, and Nontraditional Paths

Not every American studying abroad has a perfect, linear path. If you have limited USCE, older graduation date, or gaps, you can still build a strong LOR strategy.

If You Have Minimal or No US Clinical Experience

Programs strongly prefer US letters, but if you don’t have them yet:

1. Prioritize arranging USCE immediately

   • Observerships, hands‑on electives, sub‑internships, or externships
   • Even a 4–8 week block in internal medicine or family medicine can generate a strong letter

2. Use international letters wisely

   • Choose attendings who:
     • Worked with you over a long period
     • Understand US training expectations
     • Are willing to compare you to US trainees if they’ve worked with any

3. Explain your context in your personal statement and interviews

   • Briefly address why USCE is limited and what you’ve done to adapt to US standards.

If You Have a Gap After Graduation

Programs worry about “clinical rust.” You can partially offset this through LORs:

• Ask recent supervisors (clinical or research) to:
  • Emphasize that you’ve remained clinically engaged
  • Describe any ongoing patient contact, teaching, or academic work
  • Comment on your readiness to jump back into full-time clinical work

Even research mentors can be useful if they emphasize professionalism, reliability, and how you would function within an academic department.

If You’re Ultimately Aiming for Another Specialty

Many US citizen IMGs use a transitional year residency as a bridge into:

• Radiology
• Anesthesiology
• Dermatology
• Ophthalmology
• PM&R
• Neurology

Your letters can acknowledge this without hurting your TY chances. In fact, it’s often a positive if framed correctly:

• They should state you are:
  • Committed to being an excellent intern
  • A good team player regardless of ultimate specialty
  • Capable across general medicine, surgery, and emergency settings

A good letter might say, “Although she is ultimately interested in radiology, I have no doubt she will be a strong, reliable intern in any transitional year program.”

---

Putting It All Together: A Sample LOR Strategy for a US Citizen IMG Applying TY

Imagine you’re a US citizen IMG who completed:

• 8 weeks US Internal Medicine (inpatient)
• 4 weeks US Family Medicine (outpatient)
• 4 weeks US General Surgery
• Several core rotations abroad

A solid LOR plan could be:

1. Letter #1 – US Internal Medicine Attending (inpatient)

   • Describes you managing 6–8 patients per day
   • Highlights your notes, presentations, differential diagnoses
   • Comments that your performance was similar to a US MD senior

2. Letter #2 – US Family Medicine Preceptor

   • Focuses on outpatient continuity, communication skills, patient education
   • Highlights your empathy and professionalism

3. Letter #3 – US General Surgery Attending

   • Addresses your work ethic, resilience on long days, comfort in acute care situations
   • Notes that you learned quickly and operated well in a team

4. Optional Letter #4 – International Internal Medicine Professor

   • Knows you for 2+ years, can comment on long-term growth and consistency

You would assign the three US letters to virtually all transitional year programs and add the international letter for programs allowing 4 letters, especially if it’s very strong.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. How many letters of recommendation do I really need for transitional year programs?

Most TY programs expect 3 letters and allow up to 4. As a US citizen IMG, aim for:

• At least 2–3 US clinical letters
• Preferably from core specialties (IM, surgery, EM, FM, pediatrics)

You don’t get extra points for sheer number; 3 excellent letters are more valuable than 4 mediocre ones.

2. Is it okay if my letters are not transitional year-specific?

Yes. Transitional year programs don’t require TY‑specific letters. They want to see:

• Clear evidence of clinical competence and reliability
• Strong performance in broad-based clinical settings

Letters from internal medicine, surgery, emergency medicine, or family medicine that highlight your intern-readiness are perfectly appropriate.

3. Should I ask my letter writers to mention that I’m a US citizen IMG?

They don’t need to label you as an “IMG,” but it can be helpful if they:

• Clearly state you completed your medical education abroad
• Explicitly compare you to US-trained students if they have that frame of reference
• Emphasize that you successfully adapted to US clinical norms and workflows

Your own application materials (ERAS, personal statement) will clarify your status as an American studying abroad.

4. What if I suspect a letter might not be strong—should I still use it?

If you have any reason to believe a letter is lukewarm or negative, do not assign it. Program directors would rather see 3 strong letters than 4 mixed ones. That’s why the “strong letter” phrasing when you ask is critical; if the writer seems unsure, politely thank them and seek another writer.

---

By approaching residency letters of recommendation strategically—knowing who to ask for letters, how to get strong LOR, and how to present yourself as an intern-ready American studying abroad—you significantly improve your chances of matching into a high-quality transitional year residency. For a US citizen IMG, your letters are not just supporting documents; they are your strongest advocates inside every program’s selection committee discussion.