Mastering Letters of Recommendation for OB GYN Residency Success

Understanding the Role of Letters of Recommendation in OB GYN

For an MD graduate aiming for an OB GYN residency, letters of recommendation (LORs) are not just a checklist item—they’re one of the most heavily weighted components of your application. Program directors consistently rank residency letters of recommendation among the top factors in the allopathic medical school match, often on par with your MSPE, clerkship grades, and USMLE scores.

In obstetrics and gynecology specifically, LORs help programs answer three critical questions:

1. Can we trust you with our patients?
   They look for evidence of sound clinical judgment, reliability, and professionalism in high-stakes, time-sensitive situations (e.g., labor and delivery emergencies).

2. Will you function well on a busy, team-based service?
   OB GYN residency is demanding, with long hours, call, and emotionally charged encounters. Letters should show that you’re resilient, collaborative, and communicative.

3. Are you truly committed to obstetrics and gynecology?
   The obstetrics match is increasingly competitive. Programs want reassurance that you understand the realities of the field and are genuinely invested, not just “trying it out.”

Because LORs provide narrative context—stories, examples, and comparative judgments—they can push a borderline application into interview territory or, conversely, raise serious red flags. For an MD graduate residency applicant in OB GYN, strategically planning who to ask for letters, how to get strong LORs, and how to time everything is essential.

---

How Many OB GYN Letters You Need—and Which Types Matter Most

Most OB GYN programs will specify their preferences on ERAS or program websites, but common expectations for an MD graduate applying to OB GYN are:

• Total number of letters to upload to ERAS: Up to 4
• Letters typically required for OB GYN programs:
  • 2–3 letters from OB GYN faculty
  • 1 letter may be from another core specialty (often internal medicine, surgery, or family medicine) or a department chair letter, if required

When you strategize your letters, think in terms of roles:

1. Core OB GYN Clinical Letter (or two)

   • From faculty who supervised you on your OB GYN core clerkship, sub-internship (sub-I), AI, or acting internship.
   • Demonstrates your performance in the bread-and-butter environment where residents will work: L&D, OR, triage, gynecology service, outpatient clinics.

2. Subspecialty OB GYN Letter (if available)

   • From a faculty member in MFM, REI, Gyn Onc, Urogynecology, or a specialized clinic.
   • Shows depth of interest and performance in more advanced or nuanced clinical settings.

3. Chair or Program-Level Letter (if requested)

   • Some allopathic medical school match environments still expect a “Chair’s letter” from OB GYN.
   • This may be partly a composite letter informed by multiple faculty evaluations, or directly authored by the chair based on your interaction and record.

4. Non-OB GYN Clinical Letter

   • Especially helpful if it highlights transferrable skills: procedural competence, communication with vulnerable populations, or managing acutely ill patients.
   • Internal medicine, surgery, emergency medicine, and family medicine are common.

Key principle: A strong, specific letter from a non-OB GYN attending is usually more valuable than a generic, lukewarm letter from an OB GYN faculty who barely knows you. Strength and specificity beat title and specialty.

---

Who to Ask for Letters: Building the Right Recommender Team

Understanding who to ask for letters—and who to avoid—is crucial to your strategy.

Ideal OB GYN Letter Writers

Prioritize attendings who:

• Directly supervised you clinically on OB GYN services (L&D, gynecology wards, OR, continuity clinics, sub-I).
• Have observed you over a meaningful time frame (at least 2–4 weeks).
• Can comment on your growth, not just a snapshot encounter.
• Are familiar with residency-level expectations and the obstetrics match landscape (program directors, clerkship directors, sub-I directors, fellowship-trained attendings).

High-yield examples:

• The attending who watched you manage multiple labors overnight and saw you stay calm and organized under pressure.
• The gynecologic surgeon you scrubbed with who saw your procedural learning curve, your pre-op and post-op patient management, and your OR professionalism.
• The clerkship or sub-I director who received consistent positive feedback from residents about your work ethic and team contribution.

Choosing Non-OB GYN Letter Writers Strategically

When you add a non-OB GYN LOR, it should reinforce universal competencies:

• An internal medicine attending who can attest to your thoroughness, longitudinal patient care, and handoff quality.
• A surgery attending emphasizing your operative skills, sterile technique, and comfort in the OR—highly relevant to an OB GYN residency.
• A family medicine or pediatrics attending who saw your rapport with patients, especially in women’s health or prenatal care contexts.

Red Flags in Letter Writer Selection

Avoid or think twice about:

• Anyone who hesitates when you ask, or responds with “I can write you an acceptable letter” rather than “strong” or “enthusiastic” letter.
• Faculty who barely worked with you—a half-day in clinic rarely yields a strong LOR.
• Residents as primary authors. Residents may contribute input or a draft, but the official letter must be from an attending.
• Research mentors with minimal clinical exposure to you, unless you are emphasizing research for academic OB GYN or you need one strong research letter as a bonus.

Action step: As you go through rotations, actively track potential letter writers and rate them (for yourself) on:

• Time worked together
• Perceived impression of you
• Ability to describe you with specifics
• Connection to OB GYN

---

How to Get Strong LORs: From Daily Behavior to the Formal Ask

The best answer to how to get strong LORs starts long before you send an email request. It starts with how you show up on the wards, in the OR, and during night float.

1. Perform Like a Future Intern on OB GYN

Program directors want reassurance that:

• You show up early, prepared to pre-round and review charts.
• You volunteer for tasks and close the loop without needing to be chased.
• You communicate clearly with nurses, midwives, anesthesiologists, and consultants.
• You handle stress without snapping at staff or withdrawing.

Concrete behaviors that lead to strong letters:

• Offering to write admission notes and practice management plans before the team review.
• Asking for feedback midway through the rotation: “Is there one thing I can do better this week?” and acting on it.
• Taking ownership of a few patients, tracking their labs and imaging, and proactively updating the team.

Attending physicians remember students who act like early residents—dependable, curious, and safe.

2. Signal Interest in OB GYN Early and Clearly

If OB GYN is your target, let your team know:

• “I’m planning to apply to OB GYN residency and would really value feedback on how I’m doing compared to that level.”
• Ask OB GYN-specific questions: management of preeclampsia, recommendations on surgical skills, or how to handle counseling in difficult obstetric scenarios.
• Show up for departmental conferences, grand rounds, or morbidity & mortality (M&M) meetings when possible.

Demonstrating a genuine commitment can prompt faculty to pay more attention to your performance and think of you as “one of ours,” which often translates into more enthusiastic recommendations.

3. Build Longitudinal Relationships When Possible

For MD graduates, especially those staying at the same institution or returning for an away rotation, longitudinal exposure is gold:

• Do a sub-I or elective on the same service where you excelled during your core clerkship.
• Stay in touch with faculty after your rotation by:
  • Emailing an update about your plans.
  • Asking for advice on elective choices or research ideas.
• If involved in an OB GYN project (QI, case report, or research), maintain regular contact with the mentor—this gives them more substance to write about beyond “good student on rotation.”

Longitudinal relationships create letters that can say, “I have known Dr. Smith for 12 months across clinical and research settings,” which signals maturity and commitment.

---

The Right Way to Ask for OB GYN Letters of Recommendation

Once you have identified the right attendings, the next question is how and when to ask for letters so your writers can produce their best work.

Timing Your Requests

Aim to request letters:

• Near the end of your rotation (or sub-I), while your performance is fresh.
• At least 4–6 weeks before you need them uploaded to ERAS.
• For an OB GYN residency applicant, that usually means:
  • Asking between late spring and early fall of the application year.
  • Clarifying with each writer whether they can meet the ERAS opening/mid-September submission timeline.

If you did a sub-I in June or July, ask before you finish—don’t wait until September when attendings are overwhelmed with multiple requests.

Asking in Person (When You Can)

If you have the opportunity, a brief in-person ask is often best:

You:
“Dr. Lee, I’ve really appreciated working with you this month. I’m applying to OB GYN residency, and I was wondering if you’d feel comfortable writing a strong letter of recommendation for my application?”

This phrasing is important; it gives the attending a chance to decline politely if they can’t write a strong letter. You want enthusiastic writers, not reluctant ones.

If they respond positively, follow up with:

• “Thank you—that means a lot. I’ll send you an email with my CV, personal statement draft, and any other details that might help. Is there anything specific you’d like from me?”

Email Request Template (When In-Person Isn’t Possible)

Subject: Request for Letter of Recommendation for OB GYN Residency

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I hope you’re doing well. I had the privilege of working with you on the [OB GYN service/clinic/sub-I] from [dates]. I learned a great deal from your teaching about [specific example, e.g., intrapartum management, patient counseling, surgical technique], and I especially appreciated [specific feedback or support].

I am applying for OB GYN residency this upcoming match cycle and would be honored if you felt able to write a strong letter of recommendation on my behalf.

To assist, I have attached:

• My current CV
• A draft of my personal statement
• My ERAS letter of recommendation request form with instructions

If helpful, I can also provide a brief summary of the patients and cases we worked on together. ERAS will send you a link to upload the letter directly; my goal is to have all letters submitted by [target date, usually early–mid September].

Thank you very much for considering this. I appreciate your time and mentorship.

Best regards,
[Your Name], MD
[Medical School or Status, if graduated]
[Contact Information]

What to Provide Your Letter Writers

Help your recommenders write a detailed, tailored letter:

• Updated CV – highlight OB GYN-specific experiences (electives, research, QI projects, leadership in women’s health groups).
• Personal statement draft – shows your narrative and career goals; helps them align their letter with your story.
• ERAS cover sheet – with the Letter ID and instructions.
• Bullet-point “reminder sheet” summarizing:
  • Which rotations you worked with them on (dates, services).
  • Memorable cases or responsibilities (e.g., you led family meetings, ran a postpartum hemorrhage note, followed a complex Gyn Onc case).
  • Qualities you hope they can emphasize (teamwork, resilience, OR skills, etc.), without scripting their letter.

You can phrase it as:
“I’ve included a short summary of our time working together, in case it’s helpful as you recall specific examples.”

---

What Makes a Strong OB GYN Letter: Content Program Directors Look For

Not all letters are equal. Strong OB GYN residency letters of recommendation share common characteristics that program directors value.

Key Components of High-Impact OB GYN LORs

1. Clear Statement of Support

   • “I give Dr. Patel my highest recommendation for OB GYN residency.”
   • Weak alternative: “I am writing to support Dr. Patel’s application” (neutral, not strong).

2. Specific Clinical Examples

   • Descriptions of how you handled:
     • A busy L&D shift with multiple active labors.
     • A difficult patient encounter (e.g., fetal demise, disclosure of bad news).
     • Pre-op and post-op management of a surgical patient.
   • Concrete stories make your strengths memorable and credible.

3. Comparative Judgment

   • “Among the top 10% of students I have supervised in the past 5 years.”
   • “Above the level of an incoming intern in terms of responsibility and independence.”
   • OB GYN PDs want to know where you stand in relation to peers.

4. Assessment of Core Competencies

   • Clinical reasoning and medical knowledge.
   • Communication with patients and families across diverse backgrounds.
   • Teamwork and professionalism, including working with nurses, residents, midwives.
   • Work ethic, reliability, and receptiveness to feedback.

5. Comments Specific to OB GYN

   • Comfort with pelvic exams, sensitive topics (sexual health, pregnancy options).
   • Ability to handle emergencies calmly (shoulder dystocia, postpartum hemorrhage, non-reassuring fetal heart tracings).
   • Emotional resilience around perinatal loss or traumatic deliveries.
   • Interest in women’s health, reproductive justice, health equity (if applicable).

Red Flags and Weaknesses in Letters

Program directors are trained to read between the lines. Watch for:

• Faint praise: “completed all assigned tasks,” “on time and pleasant” without any superlatives or examples.
• Vague language: “good student,” “solid performance” with no specifics.
• Short, generic letters clearly used for multiple specialties.
• Veiled concerns: “would do well in a structured environment,” “may require additional supervision at first,” or “has potential” without direct endorsement.
• Typos or errors suggesting the writer did not take the letter seriously.

You cannot control the exact wording, but you can influence letter quality by choosing your writers carefully and giving them enough context and time.

---

Special Considerations: MD Graduates, Gaps, and Non-Traditional Paths

If you’re an MD graduate (not a current fourth-year), or you have an atypical path to OB GYN, you’ll need a slightly different strategy.

If You Have Already Graduated (Out of Medical School)

Programs want to know:

• What have you been doing since graduation?
• Are your clinical skills current and ready for OB GYN internship?

For MD graduates applying to OB GYN:

• Prioritize recent clinical letters whenever possible:
  • Observerships, clinical fellowships (non-ACGME roles), or hospital-based roles where attendings can evaluate your clinical thinking.
• If you are working in research only, consider:
  • Obtaining a research mentor letter that highlights your professionalism, reliability, and interaction with clinical teams if applicable.
  • Supplementing with older but strong clinical letters from the end of medical school, clearly dating the time frame.

In your personal statement and interviews, be ready to articulate why you are applying to OB GYN now and how you’ve maintained or refreshed your clinical readiness.

If You’re a Career Changer or Have a Gap

• Use letters to bridge the narrative gap:
  • A supervisor from a prior career (e.g., nursing, public health) can speak to work ethic and maturity, but you still need core physician-clinician letters.
• Ask one letter writer to explicitly address your professionalism, dependability, and adaptability across different roles or time frames.

IMGs or Those Without Strong Home OB GYN Departments

Even though this article focuses on MD graduates from allopathic programs, some principles apply broadly:

• If your home school’s OB GYN program is limited, consider:
  • Away rotations or visiting student rotations at other institutions.
  • Seeking letters from those away rotation attendings; these can carry significant weight.
• Make sure at least 2 letters come from US-based or system-similar OB GYN attendings, if you are applying to US allopathic programs.

---

Putting It All Together: A Step-by-Step LOR Action Plan for OB GYN Applicants

Use this as a roadmap through your application year:

1. Early MS3 / Start of Clinical Years

   • On every rotation, act like a potential letter writer is observing you.
   • Note attendings who supervise you closely and give you structured feedback.

2. During Your OB GYN Core Clerkship

   • Identify at least 1–2 attendings who see you often.
   • Ask for feedback mid-rotation and adjust.
   • If OB GYN emerges as your target specialty, say so explicitly.

3. During OB GYN Sub-I or Acting Internship

   • Target 1–2 strong OB GYN letters here.
   • Ask the best-fitting attendings near the end of the rotation.
   • Prepare your CV and a rough personal statement early.

4. Late Spring / Early Summer Before Application Season

   • Confirm your letter lineup:
     • 2–3 OB GYN faculty.
     • 1 non-OB GYN or chair letter as needed.
   • Send formal email requests and supporting materials.

5. Summer / Early Fall (ERAS Season)

   • Track which letters have been uploaded via ERAS.
   • Send gentle, respectful reminders a few weeks before deadlines if any letters are missing:
     • “I wanted to kindly check in and see if you might be able to submit the letter by [date]. I’m very grateful for your support.”
   • Finalize which letters you assign to OB GYN programs (usually 3–4, prioritizing OB GYN-specific ones).

6. Interview Season

   • Be prepared to discuss:
     • Your relationships with letter writers.
     • Cases or experiences they might have mentioned.
   • Occasionally, interviewers will reference comments from specific letters.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. How many OB GYN-specific letters do I really need?

For an OB GYN residency application, you should aim for at least two OB GYN-specific letters, and three if possible. Many programs are happiest when the majority of your letters are from OB GYN attendings, but having one strong non-OB GYN clinical letter (e.g., internal medicine or surgery) is perfectly acceptable and can round out your profile.

2. Is a department chair letter required for OB GYN residency?

Requirements vary by program. Some institutions or allopathic medical school match environments still strongly prefer or require a department chair letter, while others do not. If your school has a standard process for a Chair’s or departmental letter for MD graduate residency applicants, you should follow it. This letter is often based on a composite of your evaluations and may not replace the need for individual, detailed OB GYN faculty letters.

3. What if my strongest letter writer is not in OB GYN?

Use them. A strong, specific letter from another specialty is usually more impactful than a generic OB GYN letter. For example, a surgical attending who can attest to your OR skills and composure under pressure is highly relevant for OB GYN. Just ensure you still have at least two OB GYN faculty letters to demonstrate specialty-specific performance and commitment.

4. Can I see my letters of recommendation, or should I waive my right?

In ERAS, you can choose whether or not to waive your right to see each letter. Most program directors expect and prefer waived letters, as they are perceived to be more candid and honest. Unless there is a compelling reason not to, you should generally waive your right to view OB GYN residency letters of recommendation.

---

Well-chosen, well-timed, and well-supported letters of recommendation can significantly strengthen your OB GYN residency application. By understanding who to ask for letters, how to get strong LORs, and how to present your narrative as an MD graduate ready for obstetrics and gynecology, you position yourself to stand out in a competitive obstetrics match.