Mastering Letters of Recommendation for Your Internal Medicine Residency

Why Letters of Recommendation Matter So Much for Internal Medicine

For an MD graduate applying to an internal medicine residency, letters of recommendation (LORs) can significantly influence your IM match outcome. Programs use your scores, transcripts, and personal statement to understand your academic profile—but residency letters of recommendation tell them how you actually function on the wards.

In the allopathic medical school match, especially for internal medicine residency, program directors consistently rank LORs as a top factor when deciding whom to interview and how to rank candidates. For MD graduates who may have:

• A middle-of-the-road Step score
• A gap year or nontraditional path
• Slightly weaker grades in the pre-clinical years

…a set of strong, specific LORs can reassure programs that you can perform at the level of a successful IM resident.

This article will walk you through, in detail:

• Who to ask for letters (and who not to)
• How to get strong LORs that truly help your application
• What a powerful internal medicine letter actually says
• How many letters you need and how to assign them
• How to manage timing, logistics, and communication professionally

Throughout, we’ll emphasize practical steps you can start acting on immediately.

---

Understanding the Role of LORs in the IM Match

A good way to think about letters: they answer the question every program director has about you—“What will this applicant actually be like on my inpatient team?”

What Programs Look for in IM Letters

Strong IM residency LORs usually address:

• Clinical reasoning and medical knowledge
  • Can you gather and synthesize information?
  • Do you build thoughtful differential diagnoses?
• Work ethic and reliability
  • Do you follow up on tasks?
  • Are you timely with notes, orders, and communication?
• Teamwork and communication
  • How do you work with residents, nurses, and other staff?
  • Do patients feel heard and respected?
• Professionalism
  • Do you accept feedback and improve?
  • Are you trustworthy with sensitive information and tasks?
• Trajectory and potential
  • Are you functioning at or above the level expected of a graduating MD?
  • Do you show potential to be a high-performing internal medicine resident?

Letters are less about flowery adjectives and more about specific, credible examples that show you are safe, dependable, and teachable.

MD Graduate vs. DO or IMG Considerations

As an MD graduate from an allopathic medical school, you may get a slight “home field” advantage—many IM programs are very familiar with MD curricula and evaluation systems. But your letters still need to:

• Come from people who supervised your clinical work directly
• Be clearly enthusiastic and supportive
• Show readiness for residency responsibilities

For an MD graduate residency application, an average letter from a prestigious name is far less helpful than a detailed, specific letter from a faculty member who knows you well and can speak to your day-to-day performance.

---

Who to Ask for Letters (and Who to Avoid)

“Who to ask for letters” is one of the most important—and most misunderstood—parts of LOR strategy. The central rule:

Choose writers who have directly observed your clinical performance in internal medicine or closely related settings, and who genuinely support you.

Ideal Letter Writers for Internal Medicine

For IM residency, the strongest letter set for an MD graduate typically includes:

1. Core Internal Medicine Faculty (Inpatient or Outpatient)

   • Attending physicians who supervised you on IM wards, ICU, or continuity clinic.
   • They can describe how you functioned in a role similar to an intern.

2. Sub-Internship / Acting Internship (AI) Attendings

   • These letters are often heavily weighted.
   • They’ve seen you taking near-intern-level responsibility, managing patients, and presenting to teams.
   • If you have done an internal medicine sub-I or acting internship, that attending is usually a top priority.

3. Program or Clerkship Leadership

   • Internal Medicine Clerkship Director
   • Site Director or Sub-I Director
   • Vice Chair for Education or similar
     They may have a broad view of your performance, including grades, narratives, and professionalism across rotations.

4. Subspecialty IM Faculty (e.g., Cardiology, GI, Pulm/Crit, Endocrine)

   • Especially valuable if they can comment on core IM skills and ward performance, not just narrow procedural tasks.
   • This is particularly useful if you completed a robust elective where you managed complex inpatients.

How Many Letters Do You Need?

For the allopathic medical school match in internal medicine:

• ERAS allows up to 4 LORs per program.
• Most IM programs expect 3 letters, but 4 strong letters is perfectly acceptable.
• A common strategy:
  • 2 letters from core IM (ward or sub-I) attendings
  • 1 letter from IM leadership or a subspecialty IM attending
  • Optional 4th: research mentor or another strong IM/sub-I attending

If you’re an MD graduate with significant IM research, one letter from a research mentor can be helpful, but at least 2–3 letters must be clinically focused.

---

Who to Avoid Asking

To maximize your IM match chances, avoid letters that add little signal:

1. Faculty who barely know you

   • If you only worked with them for a day or they remember you vaguely, the letter will be generic and weak.

2. Highly prestigious faculty with minimal direct contact

   • A “name” letter that just repeats your CV is far less valuable than a detailed, concrete letter from a “regular” attending.

3. Non-physician writers (unless extraordinary circumstance)

   • Nurses, PAs, or non-clinical supervisors can provide great feedback in real life, but residency programs strongly prefer physician evaluators.

4. Old or outdated letter writers

   • If someone only worked with you in your first year of clinical rotations and you’ve grown substantially since, that letter may not reflect your current skill level.

5. Mixed-enthusiasm or hesitant writers

   • If anyone hesitates when you ask, or seems lukewarm, do not push them. You need strong, supportive letters—not polite but neutral ones.

---

How to Get Strong LOR: Strategy and Step-by-Step Process

If you’re wondering how to get strong LOR instead of generic ones, your planning needs to start during your internal medicine rotations, not just at the end.

Step 1: Perform with Letters in Mind (Without Being Performative)

During your IM clerkship or sub-I:

• Show up early, stay engaged.
• Know your patients thoroughly—labs, imaging, overnight events, crucial meds.
• Be proactive:
  • Offer to write notes
  • Volunteer to present new admissions
  • Follow up on consults and pending results
• Ask for feedback mid-rotation:
  • “Dr. Smith, I’m very interested in an internal medicine residency. Could you share any feedback on how I’m doing and what I could improve?”

Faculty are more likely to write strong residency letters of recommendation when they remember you as:

• Prepared
• Responsive to feedback
• A good teammate
• Someone who clearly wants to grow

Step 2: Identify Potential Letter Writers Early

During or immediately after each relevant rotation, ask yourself:

• Did this attending see me consistently for at least 2–4 weeks?
• Did I present multiple patients to them directly?
• Did they comment positively on my performance?
• Do I sense they liked working with me?

If the answer is yes, bookmark them mentally as a potential letter writer for your internal medicine residency application.

Step 3: Ask Clearly and Professionally

When the time comes (typically near the end of your rotation or during the application season), approach your potential writer:

In person or via email:

“Dr. Lopez, I’ve really appreciated working with you on the wards this month. I’m applying to internal medicine residency this fall as an MD graduate, and I was wondering if you’d feel comfortable writing a strong letter of recommendation on my behalf?”

That phrase—“strong letter of recommendation”—is important. It gently gives them an “out” if they are not enthusiastic.

If they hesitate or say something like, “I can write a letter if you need one,” without clearly affirming, consider that a warning sign and look for another writer.

Step 4: Provide Supporting Materials

Once they agree, make it easy for them to write a strong, detailed letter. Offer a brief packet (sent as a courteous email):

• Updated CV
• Personal statement draft (even if not final)
• Photo (so they recall you clearly)
• ERAS letter ID/instructions
• Bullet list of:
  • Rotations you did with them (dates)
  • Reminders of specific patients/cases you handled
  • Any feedback they gave you that you incorporated
  • Your career interests (e.g., general IM, hospitalist, fellowship goals)

You might write something like:

“To help with your letter, I’ve attached my CV and personal statement. I’ve also listed a few patients and moments from our rotation that were especially meaningful to me and might be helpful examples for your letter.”

Do not script their letter, but giving them concrete examples helps them be specific and credible.

---

What Makes an IM Letter Actually Strong?

Understanding what a powerful internal medicine letter looks like can help you shape your request and your own performance.

Key Features of a Strong IM LOR

1. Clear and unambiguous support

   • Phrases like:
     • “I recommend her without reservation for internal medicine residency.”
     • “He is among the top 10% of students I have worked with in the last five years.”
   • Avoid faint praise like “nice,” “pleasant,” or “hardworking” without context.

2. Specific clinical examples

   • Concrete stories about:
     • How you managed a complex CHF or sepsis patient
     • How you followed through on a challenging discharge plan
     • How you handled a difficult conversation with a patient/family
   • These stories show programs you’ve dealt with real IM challenges.

3. Comparative statements

   • Program directors pay attention when writers compare you to peers:
     • “At the level of an intern in terms of responsibility and reliability.”
     • “In the top 10–20% of students at our institution.”

4. Descriptions of growth and teachability

   • “She actively sought feedback and showed clear improvement in her notes and presentations over the month.”
   • This matters because interns learn rapidly on the job—showing that you respond constructively to feedback is critical.

5. Alignment with your stated goals

   • If you want to be a hospitalist or apply for cardiology fellowship later, a letter that says:
     • “He has the curiosity and clinical reasoning that will serve him well as a future academic internist.”
   • This tells programs you’re thinking ahead and have realistic ambitions.

Red Flags in Weak or Damaging Letters

You never see your letters (if you waived the right, which you should), but be aware that some patterns raise concern:

• Vague or purely descriptive (“He did what was asked of him.”)
• No clinical examples
• No comparative language (“average,” “adequate,” “solid”)
• Backhanded compliments (“With more experience, she might become…”)
• Inconsistencies with your MSPE or transcript (e.g., implying professionalism concerns)

The best protection against weak letters is to:

• Choose writers who clearly support you
• Ask explicitly for a “strong” letter
• Provide them with material that reminds them of your best moments

---

Timing, Logistics, and Common Scenarios for MD Graduates

Knowing the mechanics of how to handle LORs is just as important as knowing who to ask.

When to Request Letters

For the typical ERAS timeline:

• Early Spring of MS4 / MD graduate year

  • Identify target letter writers.
  • Confirm with those you worked with most recently.

• Late Spring to Early Summer

  • Officially request letters from each writer.
  • Provide ERAS instructions, CV, and personal statement draft.

• Before ERAS Opens for Submission (usually September)

  • Aim to have all letters uploaded by early to mid-September at the latest.
  • This ensures they are in your allopathic medical school match applications when programs start reviewing.

If you are a true MD graduate (not a current student) taking a gap year, you should:

• Maintain contact with your IM mentors.
• If your prior letters are more than 1–2 years old, consider asking for updated letters that reference your ongoing clinical or research work.

How to Handle ERAS Letter Assignments

In ERAS:

• Create entries for each letter writer.
• Generate unique Letter IDs for them.
• Send them the PDF with instructions.

You can assign different combinations of letters to different programs, but for internal medicine:

• Most programs are fine with the same set of 3–4 letters.
• Prioritize:
  • IM ward/sub-I attendings
  • IM leadership/subspecialty faculty
  • Research mentor (if it adds genuine strength)

Ensure each letter is correctly labeled (e.g., “Internal Medicine – Wards,” “Sub-I,” “Cardiology Elective,” “Research”).

MD Graduate with Research Heavy Profile

If you have significant research—especially in internal medicine or a subspecialty—one research LOR can strengthen your case if:

• The mentor knows you well
• Can comment on:
  • Your work ethic
  • Your analytical and critical thinking skills
  • Your teamwork on research teams
• Ideally also mentions what they know of your clinical potential

But remember: research letters are supplementary, not a substitute for strong clinical IM letters.

Following Up Without Being Pushy

Faculty are busy; benevolent reminders are often necessary.

• 1–2 weeks after your initial request

  • Send a polite email:
    • “I wanted to kindly check in about the letter of recommendation for my internal medicine residency application. Please let me know if there’s any additional information I can provide.”

• 1 month before ERAS submission

  • Another follow-up if still pending, emphasizing target date.

If they remain unresponsive close to deadlines, you may need to pivot to another writer—better to have a good letter on time than wait for a perfect one that never arrives.

---

Special Considerations for Internal Medicine Applicants

Balancing Home vs. Away Letters

For an MD graduate residency application in internal medicine, a typical pattern is:

• 2–3 letters from home institution faculty
• Optional 1 letter from an away rotation if:
  • You did a sub-I or formal IM rotation there
  • You hope to match there or in that region
  • The attending can compare you favorably to their own students

Away rotation letters are most helpful if they can say something like:

“Although she is visiting from another institution, she performed at the level of our top home students and would be an excellent fit for our internal medicine residency.”

Addressing Red Flags or Nontraditional Paths

If you have:

• A failed exam attempt
• A leave of absence
• A professionalism concern that was resolved

It can be helpful if at least one strong letter subtly addresses your growth and current reliability, for example:

“He had early challenges in medical school but has since demonstrated consistent reliability, strong teamwork, and professional maturity on our inpatient service.”

You should never ask a writer to hide or misrepresent anything, but you can share your story with them and discuss how you’ve grown, so they can speak authentically to your current readiness.

Aligning Letters with Your IM Career Goals

Even if you’re not certain about fellowship, you may lean toward:

• Cardiology
• Pulm/Critical Care
• Hematology/Oncology
• Primary Care / Hospital Medicine

Tell your letter writers your current interests. They don’t need to oversell it, but they can align their descriptions:

• “Given her compassion and communication skills, she would be especially well-suited for a career in outpatient internal medicine.”
• “His curiosity about complex hemodynamics suggests he may ultimately pursue a fellowship in cardiology, where his diagnostic skills will be an asset.”

This helps programs envision your long-term fit in their training environment.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. How many LORs do I actually need for internal medicine residency?

Most internal medicine residency programs expect three letters of recommendation, and ERAS allows you to upload and assign up to four per program. For an MD graduate residency application, a strong setup is:

• 2 letters from core internal medicine ward or sub-I attendings
• 1 letter from IM leadership (clerkship director, sub-I director) or a subspecialty IM attending
• Optional 4th from a research mentor or another strong IM attending

Always check individual program requirements, but this structure will be appropriate for the vast majority of IM programs.

2. Is it better to get a letter from a big-name specialist or from someone who knows me well?

For the IM match, it is almost always better to get a letter from someone who knows you well and supervised you closely rather than a big-name faculty member who only knows you superficially. A detailed, enthusiastic letter with concrete examples carries far more weight than a generic letter with a famous signature.

3. Should I waive my right to see my letters of recommendation?

Yes. Programs expect that applicants waive their right to see LORs. Waived letters are perceived as more candid and credible. When using ERAS, you’ll be asked if you waive this right—choose “yes.” This does mean you will not see the final text, but it increases the trust programs place in the content.

4. Can I reuse letters from a previous application cycle as an MD graduate?

Yes, but with caveats. If you are reapplying:

• Letters that are 1–2 years old and still reflect your current performance may be reused, especially if they are from strong IM rotations.
• However, programs may wonder what you’ve done since then. If you have engaged in new clinical work, research, or advanced training, it is ideal to obtain at least one updated letter that references your recent activities and confirms your ongoing readiness for residency.

---

Used thoughtfully, strong, specific letters of recommendation can significantly bolster your internal medicine residency application and help you stand out in the allopathic medical school match. As an MD graduate, you have the advantage of a well-recognized training background—pair that with carefully chosen, strategically requested LORs that clearly demonstrate your readiness for the next step, and you’ll give yourself the best possible chance for a successful IM match.