Mastering Pre-Match Communication for Anesthesiology Residency Success

Understanding Pre-Match Communication in Anesthesiology

Pre-match communication in anesthesiology residency has become more nuanced and closely scrutinized in recent years. Applicants, faculty, and program directors must all navigate expectations around contact before the match, including thank-you notes, “love letters,” and the increasingly sensitive topics of pre-match offers, early commitment, and program communication before match.

For anesthesiology applicants, this period—typically from the first interview invitation through the rank list deadline—can feel confusing and high-stakes. You’re trying to demonstrate genuine interest without violating NRMP (National Resident Matching Program) rules or coming across as disingenuous or desperate.

This guide breaks down what pre-match communication is, how it works in anesthesiology specifically, what is and is not allowed under NRMP rules, and how to strategically, ethically, and confidently communicate with programs.

---

1. The Landscape: What Counts as Pre-Match Communication?

Pre-match communication includes any interaction between you and a residency program that occurs between application submission and the release of Match results. In anesthesiology, this typically spans:

• ERAS application submission → Interview invites
• Interview season → Rank list submission
• Post-interview → Pre–rank list anxiety phase

Common types of pre-match communication:

• Initial outreach from programs
  • Interview invitations
  • Scheduling, logistics, technical instructions
  • Pre-interview “meet and greet” invitations
• Applicant-to-program communication
  • Thank-you emails after interviews
  • Updates (new publications, Step scores, honors)
  • Clarifying questions about curriculum, call structure, or case volume
  • Expressions of interest or “you are my #1” style letters
• Program-to-applicant updates
  • Interview reminders
  • Second-look or open house invitations
  • General updates or newsletters
  • Rarely: communication about how much they “like” you

What is not allowed:

• Binding pre-match offers or pressure to commit to ranking a program in a certain way
• Asking for or disclosing specific rank order lists
• Any coercive or misleading statements about ranking or commitment

Although anesthesiology is not a field that commonly uses true “pre-match” contracts (outside of special cases like military or certain non-NRMP programs), the idea of “early commitment” still exists informally in the form of strong mutual interest and communication. You’ll often see this in the form of:

• A program hinting they will “rank you highly”
• An applicant stating that a program is their “top choice”
• Conversations about “fit” and long-term plans

Understanding this difference—between legal/NRMP-defined pre-match offers and informal expressions of interest—is critical.

---

2. NRMP Rules and Ethical Boundaries: What’s Allowed vs. Risky

Before you decide how to communicate, you need to know the rules that govern the anesthesia match and all specialties in the NRMP.

2.1 Key NRMP Principles

The NRMP’s guidelines on communication apply directly to anesthesiology residency programs and applicants. The most relevant points:

1. No soliciting ranking information

   • Programs cannot ask you how you will rank them.
   • You are not required to tell any program how you plan to rank them.

2. No requiring or pressuring commitments

   • Programs may not require or solicit a statement that you will rank them first.
   • You may not be asked to commit to a program before the match (“If we rank you #1, will you rank us #1?”).

3. Voluntary, non-binding communication is allowed

   • You may voluntarily tell a program that you intend to rank them highly or even #1.
   • Programs may tell you that you are a competitive candidate or that they intend to rank you highly.
   • None of these statements are legally or contractually binding.

4. Honesty is expected

   • Both applicants and programs should avoid misleading statements.
   • You should not tell multiple programs they are your “#1” choice if that’s not true.

2.2 Risky Behaviors to Avoid

To stay safe in the anesthesia match:

• Don’t:

  • Ask, “Where will I be on your rank list?”
  • Tell multiple programs, “You are my absolute #1” when that’s untrue.
  • Imply that you will rank a program highly to gain an advantage, if you know you won’t.
  • Pressure a program with ultimatums (e.g., “If you tell me where I am on your list, I’ll rank you #1”).

• Programs should not:

  • Say or imply: “You must tell us we’re your #1 to be ranked highly.”
  • Ask you to sign anything suggesting you won’t rank other programs above them.
  • Offer pre-match positions outside of clear, declared non-NRMP arrangements.

If you encounter clear pressure or a potential violation, you can document it and, if needed, contact the NRMP for confidential guidance.

---

3. Strategic Communication Before and After Interviews

Pre-match communication isn’t just about rules; it’s about strategy. Thoughtful, professional contact can help programs understand your interest and clarify fit—especially in a competitive anesthesiology residency market.

3.1 Before the Interview: Reaching Out or Waiting?

In anesthesiology, unsolicited pre-interview outreach (cold emails to PDs or coordinators before receiving an invitation) rarely leads directly to interviews, but it can be appropriate in some situations:

Appropriate reasons to email before invitations:

• You have a strong geographic or institutional connection not obvious on your application (e.g., spouse’s job location, long-term ties to the city).
• A technical or ERAS problem may have impacted your application.
• You are applying from a non-US school or non-anesthesia specialty and want to clarify eligibility.

What this might look like (brief and focused):

Dear Dr. Smith,

I am an anesthesiology residency applicant (ERAS ID: 12345678) currently completing my fourth year at X School of Medicine. I grew up in [City] and my partner is beginning a fellowship at [Institution] this summer, so [Program Name] is my top geographic priority.

I wanted to briefly express my strong interest in your program, particularly your focus on regional anesthesia and simulation-based education. I would be grateful for consideration for an interview if my application is still under review.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

Keep in mind:

• One concise email per program is enough.
• Many programs do not respond; that’s not a negative judgment of you.
• Focus your efforts on strengthening your application and preparing for interviews rather than mass emailing.

3.2 After the Interview: Thank-You Notes and Targeted Follow-Up

Most anesthesiology programs are accustomed to post-interview thank-you notes. Some explicitly discourage them, others are neutral. If a program tells you “no thank-you emails,” follow that instruction.

General thank-you note principles:

• Send within 48–72 hours.
• Email each interviewer individually, if possible (coordinator emails are fine if that’s how communication is structured).
• Be specific: mention a case, topic, or discussion that stood out.
• Keep it short (1–2 small paragraphs).

Example:

Dear Dr. Patel,

Thank you for taking the time to speak with me during my interview at [Program Name] on November 15. I especially appreciated our conversation about how your residents gain early autonomy in the main OR while still having robust faculty support.

Our discussion reinforced my impression that [Program Name] offers an ideal environment for developing into a confident anesthesiologist, and I would be excited to train in a program that values both education and patient safety so highly.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

Follow-up with program leadership (PD or APD):

• One concise email after the interview expressing interest is reasonable.
• If the program is a top choice, you can hint at that (without overcommitting).

For example:

[Program Name] is one of the programs I am most excited about, and I will be strongly considering it near the top of my rank list.

You do not need to declare a final #1 choice early in the season if you are still comparing programs.

---

4. “Love Letters,” Early Commitment, and Ranking Strategy

This is where much of the anxiety around pre-match communication in anesthesiology lies: how and when (or whether) to tell a program they are your top choice.

4.1 Should You Send a “You’re My #1” Email?

You are allowed to tell a program they are your #1 choice. The questions to ask yourself:

1. Is this genuinely true?

   • You should decide this only after:
     • Completing all or most interviews
     • Carefully comparing curriculum, location, culture, and lifestyle

2. Will it realistically change anything?

   • Some programs factor expressed interest into their ranking.
   • Others explicitly ignore “love letters” to avoid bias.
   • You often won’t know which type your program is.

3. Are you comfortable if they don’t match with you?

   • You cannot rely on their response to determine your rank list.
   • You must still rank programs in your true order of preference.

If you choose to send this kind of email, keep it honest and restrained:

Dear Dr. Lopez,

After completing my interviews this season and carefully considering my options, I wanted to let you know that I intend to rank [Program Name] as my top choice in the upcoming anesthesiology residency match. The combination of high-acuity cases, strong mentorship in regional anesthesia, and the supportive culture I observed during my interview day makes your program the best fit for my training and career goals.

Thank you again for the opportunity to interview. Regardless of the outcome, I remain very grateful for the chance to learn more about your program.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

Key points:

• Avoid asking, “Where will I be on your list?”
• Don’t ask them to confirm reciprocal #1 ranking.
• Don’t send similar messages to multiple programs.

4.2 Communicating “High Interest” Without Overpromising

If a program is in your top few but not clearly #1, you can express strong interest in more general terms:

Phrases that work:

• “One of my top choices”
• “A program I am strongly considering near the top of my list”
• “A program where I would be thrilled to match”

Phrases to avoid if not strictly true:

• “My absolute top choice”
• “I will definitely rank you #1”
• “I’m committed to matching here”

Example:

[Program Name] remains one of my top choices, and I would be thrilled to train there if given the opportunity.

This strikes the right balance between honest enthusiasm and ethical transparency.

4.3 How Programs May Respond (or Not)

Programs vary widely in their communication style:

• Some will respond with a polite but neutral note (“Thank you; we enjoyed meeting you as well”).
• Some will explicitly say they cannot comment on ranking.
• Some will say, “We will rank you highly” or “We hope to work with you next year.”
• Some will not respond at all, due to high volume or internal policies.

Do not interpret lack of response as disinterest or rejection; anesthesiology programs often receive hundreds of emails in a short period.

Most importantly: Do not change your rank list based on program communication alone. The NRMP algorithm favors your true preferences; trying to game it based on perceived program interest usually hurts you.

---

5. Special Situations: Couples Match, Categorical vs. Advanced, and Non-NRMP Programs

Pre-match communication can become more complex when your path isn’t straightforward.

5.1 Couples Match in Anesthesiology

In Couples Match, pre-match communication can be used to clarify your situation and reaffirm fit.

How to communicate:

• Let programs know you are in the Couples Match and what your partner’s specialty is.
• You do not need to share your exact rank combinations or your partner’s program list.
• You can explain geographic constraints or priorities.

Example:

As part of the Couples Match, I will be coordinating my anesthesiology rank list with my partner, who is applying in internal medicine. We are both very interested in training in [City/Region], and your program represents one of our top options in the area.

This helps programs understand that:

• You may need to rank more local options.
• Your final rank list may be influenced by your partner’s opportunities.

5.2 Categorical vs. Advanced Anesthesiology Positions

Some anesthesiology residencies offer:

• Categorical positions (PGY-1 + anesthesia years)
• Advanced positions (start at PGY-2; you must secure a prelim/transitional year separately)

Pre-match communication can clarify:

• Your flexibility (e.g., categorical vs. advanced).
• Your existing prelim/TY offers or preferences.

Email example:

I am applying to both categorical and advanced anesthesiology positions. While I would be excited about either pathway at [Program Name], I wanted to express that I have a strong preference for completing all of my training at a single institution if possible, which makes your categorical track especially appealing.

This gives the program context without implying any rank commitments.

5.3 Non-NRMP or Pre-Match Style Positions

Rarely, anesthesiology applicants may encounter:

• Non-NRMP positions (e.g., some military, certain special tracks, or outside the US).
• Programs that historically offered “pre-match” style contracts (less common now in standard US anesthesia programs).

In these cases:

• Read all policies carefully.
• Clarify in writing what is binding and what is not.
• Be transparent with your home institution advisors.
• If the position is within NRMP, it cannot be offered as a binding pre-match contract.

---

6. Practical Communication Templates and Best Practices

To make this actionable, here are concise guidelines and examples you can adapt.

6.1 General Best Practices

• Professional tone: Treat every email like a mini-interview.
• Brevity: Aim for 150–250 words per message.
• Specificity: Reference 1–2 concrete aspects of the program.
• Timing:
  • Thank-you emails: within 2–3 days of the interview.
  • Interest updates: after you’ve completed most interviews.
  • Final “#1” letter (if used): after you finalize your own rank list.

6.2 Common Email Types and Suggested Structures

1. Post-interview thank-you to PD

• Subject: “Thank you – [Your Name], Anesthesiology Interview on [Date]”
• Paragraph 1: Thanks + specific highlights from interview day.
• Paragraph 2: Brief statement of interest + alignment with your goals.
• Closing: Professional sign-off.

2. Update email (e.g., new publication or score)

Dear Dr. [PD Last Name],

I hope you are doing well. I wanted to share a brief update since my interview at [Program Name] on [Date]. My recent research project on [brief topic] was accepted for publication in [Journal Name]. This work has further solidified my interest in pursuing a career in anesthesiology with a focus on [subspecialty/area, if applicable].

I remain very enthusiastic about the possibility of training at [Program Name] and appreciate your continued consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

3. “High interest” email (non-#1 but top tier)

Dear Dr. [PD Last Name],

As interview season comes to a close, I wanted to thank you again for the opportunity to learn more about [Program Name]. The combination of strong clinical training, early exposure to complex cases, and the supportive resident culture I observed has kept your program among my very top choices for anesthesiology residency.

I would be thrilled to train at [Program Name] if given the opportunity.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]

4. True “#1” letter
(See example in Section 4.1.)

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Do I have to send thank-you emails to every anesthesiology program I interview with?

No, you are not required to send thank-you emails, and some programs explicitly prefer not to receive them. However, a brief, professional email is generally acceptable and can leave a positive impression, as long as you follow each program’s stated preferences. If a program says, “No post-interview communication, please,” respect that.

2. Will telling a program they are my #1 significantly increase my chances of matching there?

It might help at the margins for some programs, but it is not a guarantee and should not be relied upon. Some programs factor expressed interest into their ranking; others ignore these communications entirely. You should send such a message only if it is truthful and only after you’ve made your own decision. Always build your rank list in your true order of preference, independent of what you think programs will do.

3. Can a program ask me how I will rank them or request an early commitment?

Under NRMP rules, programs should not ask you to disclose your specific rank order or require you to commit to ranking them in a particular way. You are allowed to volunteer information about your preferences, but you should never feel coerced. If you feel pressured or if a program appears to violate these rules, document the interaction and consider discussing it with your dean’s office or contacting the NRMP for guidance.

4. How often is too often to email a program before the match?

In most cases, 1–3 well-timed emails per program across the whole season is sufficient:

• One post-interview thank-you.
• Possibly one update (if you have meaningful new information).
• Possibly one final “interest” or “#1” email near the end of the season. Avoid frequent check-ins or “just wanted to see where I stand” messages; they add little value and risk annoying busy faculty and coordinators.

---

Thoughtful, honest pre-match communication can support your success in the anesthesiology residency match, but it cannot substitute for a strong application and authentic self-assessment. Know the rules, communicate professionally, and always let your true preferences guide your final rank list.