Essential Guide to Pre-Match Communication for DO Graduates in Residency

Understanding Pre-Match Communication as a DO Applying to Preliminary Medicine

Pre-match communication can feel like the gray zone of the osteopathic residency match process—especially for DO graduates interested in a Preliminary Medicine (prelim IM) year. You’re told not to break NRMP rules, but you also keep hearing “stay in touch,” “express interest,” and “let programs know you’d rank them highly.”

As a DO graduate, you may also be wondering whether expectations differ from MD applicants, how to position a preliminary medicine year within your long-term plan, and how to handle potential pre-match offers or early commitment pressures.

This guide will walk you through:

• What counts as pre-match communication (and what doesn’t)
• How it differs for preliminary medicine compared to categorical programs
• How DO graduates can communicate strategically and professionally
• What to do if you sense strong interest, but no explicit offer
• How to avoid crossing NRMP boundaries while still advocating for yourself

Throughout, we’ll focus on real-world phrases, timing, and email templates you can adapt immediately.

---

1. The Landscape: Pre-Match Communication in the NRMP Era

Before crafting emails or scheduling calls, you need the basic rules and norms.

1.1 What “Pre-Match Communication” Actually Means

In the context of the osteopathic residency match and the unified NRMP system, “pre-match communication” refers to any contact between you and a program after you have applied, typically:

• Before interviews (e.g., “We received your application…” emails)
• After interview invitations
• After the interview but before rank lists are certified
• Occasionally, after rank list certification but before Match Day (less common and often minimal)

These interactions can be:

• Program-initiated: Updates, expressions of interest, interview invitations, follow-up questions
• Applicant-initiated: Thank-you emails, updates, letters of interest/intent, clarifying questions

Key point: Pre-match communication is not inherently wrong or against NRMP rules; it’s how you communicate that matters.

1.2 NRMP and Ethical Boundaries

Both you and programs must follow NRMP’s Match Communication Code of Conduct. While you don’t need to memorize every clause, you should understand the “big red lines”:

• Programs cannot:

  • Ask you how you intend to rank them
  • Require a commitment from you before the match
  • Tell you that you are “ranked to match” in a way that implies a binding guarantee
  • Pressure you into early commitment or pre-match offers outside the NRMP (if they participate in the Match)

• You cannot:

  • Make false claims about how you will rank programs
  • Harass or pressure programs for matching guarantees
  • Sign any contract that conflicts with your match agreement

However, it is allowed (and expected) that:

• You express genuine interest in programs
• Programs tell you they are “very interested” in you or that you are “ranked highly”
• You update programs with additional information (grades, COMLEX/USMLE scores, LORs, etc.)
• You ask reasonable questions, including about how a prelim IM year fits with your long-term specialty goals

1.3 Why Pre-Match Communication Matters More for Prelim Medicine

For preliminary medicine positions, there are some distinct dynamics:

1. Shorter relationship window:
   You’re committing to a one-year position, which means:

   • Programs want interns who are hardworking, adaptable, and team-oriented—even if you’re leaving after one year.
   • You want a program that will prepare you well for your advanced specialty (e.g., anesthesia, radiology, neurology).

2. Linkage with advanced positions:
   If you’re a DO graduate applying to an advanced specialty (e.g., an advanced anesthesia spot) plus a prelim IM year, your communication might span:

   • The advanced program
   • Multiple prelim medicine programs

3. Competition and flexibility:
   Some prelim IM positions are extremely competitive (especially at academic centers), while others are more accessible. Thoughtful pre-match communication can:

   • Elevate you from “average” to “memorable”
   • Clarify your seriousness about a given location or program

---

2. Strategy Before You Hit “Send”: Goals, Priorities, and Positioning as a DO

2.1 Clarify Your Own Priorities First

Effective pre-match communication starts with knowing what you want. Ask yourself:

• Is my preliminary medicine year my highest priority, or is my advanced specialty the main driver?
• Am I location-flexible, or are there geographic constraints (family, partner, visa issues)?
• Am I using prelim IM as:
  • A bridge to a clearly defined advanced field (e.g., anesthesia)
  • A way to strengthen my internal medicine foundation while I reapply?
  • A backup plan in case categorical IM or another specialty doesn’t pan out?

Your answers affect:

• Which programs you put most effort into communicating with
• How you describe your goals to prelim medicine PDs
• How transparent you are about your advanced specialty intentions

2.2 As a DO Graduate: Anticipate and Address Subtle Concerns

Many DO graduates now match successfully into prelim and categorical IM, but perceptions still vary between programs. Pre-match communication is your chance to proactively highlight:

• Your COMLEX performance (and USMLE if taken)
• Comfort with:
  • EBM (evidence-based medicine)
  • High-acuity inpatient care
  • ICU exposure or interest (if relevant)
• Your adaptability to both osteopathic and allopathic training environments

Example positioning statement for email or interview:

“As a DO graduate, I’ve been trained with a strong foundation in whole-person care and physical diagnosis, and I’ve actively sought out high-acuity inpatient experiences to prepare for a rigorous preliminary medicine year. I’m confident I can contribute meaningfully to your ward teams from day one.”

This reassures programs that you understand expectations in a busy prelim IM year and are not viewing it as a “throwaway” year.

2.3 Decide Your Communication Tiers

To avoid sending generic, low-yield messages, rank your prelim IM programs into tiers:

• Tier 1: Top-choice prelim programs

  • Strong geographic fit or key backup to your advanced specialty
  • You would be genuinely excited (not just “fine”) to match there

  Actions:

  • Targeted post-interview thank-you notes
  • Thoughtful letter of interest (and possibly one letter of intent to a single top-choice program)
  • Occasional, meaningful updates (e.g., new publication, leadership role)

• Tier 2: Programs you like but are less critical
  Actions:

  • Standard thank-you email
  • Possibly one brief interest/update email closer to rank list deadlines

• Tier 3: Safety or “acceptable” options
  Actions:

  • Thank-you email if interviewed
  • No extra communication unless something changes that makes them more appealing (e.g., partner gets a job nearby)

This prioritization keeps you focused and prevents communication burnout—for you and for programs.

---

3. Concrete Tactics: What to Say, When to Say It, and How

3.1 Before Interviews: Can You Email Programs?

In general, cold emails before an interview are low yield for prelim IM positions, unless:

• You have a genuine, specific connection:
  • Rotated at their hospital or affiliate
  • Have a mentor or faculty member who knows the PD personally
  • Are couples matching and your partner already has strong ties there

If you choose to reach out pre-interview:

• Keep it brief and specific
• Avoid sounding entitled (e.g., “I would like to know when you will offer me an interview”)

Example pre-interview email for a DO graduate:

Subject: DO Applicant with Interest in Preliminary Medicine at [Program Name]

Dear Dr. [Program Director Last Name],

My name is [Your Name], a DO graduate from [Your School] applying to your Preliminary Medicine program this cycle. I completed my third-year core internal medicine rotation at [Relevant Hospital], where I worked closely with [Faculty Name], who spoke very highly of your program’s training environment.

As a future [intended advanced specialty, if applicable], I am particularly interested in a rigorous, inpatient-heavy prelim year that emphasizes autonomy and close resident-faculty collaboration. I wanted to briefly express my interest and share that I would be very excited to interview with your program if given the opportunity.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name], DO
AAMC/NRMP ID: [ID]

Don’t send mass versions of this to 50 programs. Use it selectively where a real connection exists.

3.2 After the Interview: Thank-You Emails That Actually Help

Most programs don’t “score” thank-you emails, but they do help:

• Reinforce your interest
• Clarify misconceptions
• Keep your name recognizable when rank lists are made

Basic structure:

1. Greeting and gratitude
2. One or two specific details you appreciated
3. Brief restatement of your interest
4. Polite closing

Example:

Subject: Thank You – Preliminary Medicine Interview on [Date]

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

Thank you for the opportunity to interview with the Preliminary Medicine program at [Program Name] on [Date]. I appreciated our discussion about how your interns gain early autonomy on the wards while still having close supervision.

As a DO graduate aiming for a strong clinical foundation before pursuing [advanced specialty, if applicable], I feel your program’s emphasis on high-volume inpatient medicine and supportive teaching aligns very well with my goals. I would be excited to train with your team.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name], DO

Keep it to a single, well-written paragraph or two.

3.3 Letters of Interest vs. Letters of Intent

Understanding the difference is essential to ethical program communication before match:

• Letter of Interest

  • Signals: “I’m very interested in your program.”
  • Non-binding, flexible, can be sent to several programs.

• Letter of Intent

  • Signals: “I intend to rank your program #1.”
  • Ethically, you should send this to only one program in a given track (e.g., one prelim IM program if you truly intend to rank it #1 for prelim positions).

For preliminary medicine as a DO graduate, a balanced approach might be:

• Send letters of interest to 2–4 top prelim programs
• Send one letter of intent to your true #1 prelim choice (if you’re certain)

Sample letter of interest:

Subject: Continued Interest in [Program Name] Preliminary Medicine

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I hope you are doing well. I wanted to follow up on my interview with the [Program Name] Preliminary Medicine program on [Date] to reiterate my strong interest.

After reflecting on all of my interviews, I continue to be particularly impressed by your program’s combination of high-acuity clinical exposure, supportive resident culture, and the flexibility you offer for those pursuing advanced specialties. As a DO graduate planning to train in [advanced specialty, if applicable], I believe your program would provide an ideal foundation for my career.

I remain very enthusiastic about the possibility of joining your team and will be ranking your program highly on my rank list.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name], DO

Sample letter of intent (only if you truly mean it):

Subject: Letter of Intent – [Program Name] Preliminary Medicine

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I hope this message finds you well. I am writing to express my sincere gratitude for the opportunity to interview with the [Program Name] Preliminary Medicine program on [Date].

After careful consideration of all the programs where I have interviewed, I am pleased to share that I intend to rank [Program Name] as my #1 choice for my preliminary medicine year. The combination of your program’s strong inpatient training, commitment to teaching, and supportive resident community makes it my top preference.

As a DO graduate, I am excited about the opportunity to contribute to your team and to grow under your program’s mentorship. Thank you again for your consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name], DO

Avoid implying that your letter of intent is a contract—it isn’t. But you should treat your statement as an ethical commitment.

---

4. Handling Signals, Interest, and the Temptation of “Pre-Match Offers”

4.1 Reading Between the Lines: What Program Emails Mean (and Don’t Mean)

Programs may send:

• Generic “We enjoyed meeting you and think you would be a great fit” messages
• More personalized “You remain one of our top candidates” emails
• Very strong “We will be ranking you very highly” statements

Key interpretation principles:

• Generic messages: Assume they were sent to many applicants. Do not alter your rank list solely based on them.
• Personalized, specific messages: Indicate genuine interest but are not guarantees.
• Even if a program says, “We are ranking you to match,” NRMP still explicitly warns that no outcome is guaranteed.

Your response should be warm but neutral, for example:

Thank you for your kind note. I truly appreciated the opportunity to meet your team and will give your program strong consideration when I finalize my rank list.

Avoid asking, “Does this mean I will match there?” or pressing them for more details—they can’t provide guarantees.

4.2 “Pre-Match Offers” and “Early Commitment” in the NRMP Era

In the current unified Match, true pre-match offers (in the sense of “sign this contract and you’re locked in before Match Day”) are uncommon among ACGME-accredited internal medicine programs that participate in the NRMP. If a program participates in the Match, they are not supposed to:

• Offer you a position outside the Match
• Ask you to withdraw from NRMP in return for a guaranteed seat

If you ever receive communication that sounds like:

“If you withdraw from the Match and sign this contract, we can guarantee you a spot…”

You should:

1. Verify whether the program is NRMP-participating.
2. Discuss with a trusted advisor, dean’s office, or GME support.
3. Consider contacting NRMP for guidance if it clearly violates policy.

For most DO graduates in preliminary medicine, “early commitment” pressure is more subtle and might sound like:

• “We really hope you rank us highly.”
• “We would be thrilled if you came here.”
• “We strongly encourage you to consider us as your first choice.”

You are not obligated to respond with your exact rank order, and you should not feel pressured to promise anything you aren’t sure about.

4.3 Balancing Honesty, Strategy, and Self-Advocacy

You want to be both honest and strategic. Principles to follow:

• Don’t lie about your rank list.
  You can say, “I will be ranking your program highly” if that is true—even if it’s not #1.

• Reserve “#1” language for only one program in that track (e.g., prelim IM).

• Focus on fit, not flattery.
  Instead of, “Your program is the best in the country,” say:

  “Your emphasis on high-acuity inpatient rotations and strong resident camaraderie aligns closely with my goals for my preliminary year.”

• For prelim IM, be explicit that you respect the role of the preliminary year:

  “I understand the demands of a busy prelim medicine year and am committed to being a reliable, hard-working intern who supports the categorical residents and the team.”

---

5. Advanced Tips: DO-Specific Considerations, Couples Match, and Red Flags

5.1 As a DO Applicant: When (and How) to Bring Up COMLEX/USMLE

If:

• You have only COMLEX and the program traditionally prefers USMLE
• You are a DO with strong COMLEX scores but average USMLE

Then, pre-match communication can help you clarify.

Examples:

• Before an interview (if concerned about screening policies):

  “I wanted to briefly mention that while I have not taken the USMLE, I earned a COMLEX Level 1 score of [XXX] and Level 2-CE score of [XXX], and I have excelled in my internal medicine rotations.”

• After an interview, to reassure them:

  “Thank you again for the opportunity to share my experiences as a DO graduate. I hope my performance on the wards and COMLEX scores demonstrate my readiness for a rigorous internal medicine intern year.”

5.2 Couples Match and Preliminary Medicine

If you’re participating in the Couples Match, pre-match communication gains another layer:

• Programs understand that your rank list is partly dependent on your partner’s matches.
• You can briefly explain this without oversharing:

“My partner and I are participating in the Couples Match, and we are both targeting positions in the [Region] area. For my preliminary medicine year, [Program Name] remains one of my top choices due to its combination of strong training and proximity to programs where my partner has also interviewed.”

Avoid suggesting that your only interest in a program is geography; always mention features of their training environment.

5.3 Spotting Red Flags in Program Communication

Be cautious if you notice:

• Disrespectful remarks about DO graduates or osteopathic training
• Pressure to disclose your exact rank list order
• Attempts to circumvent the Match process
• Inconsistent messaging from different faculty about work hours, support, or expectations

Your communication strategy should include protecting yourself. If something feels off:

• Ask clarifying questions (e.g., about support systems, supervision, or resident well-being).
• Discuss concerns with trusted faculty or recent alumni.
• Remember: you are interviewing programs as much as they are interviewing you.

---

6. Putting It All Together: A Timeline for Pre-Match Communication

Here’s a practical timeline tailored to a DO graduate applying to Preliminary Medicine (with or without an advanced specialty):

September–October (Application Submission)

• Ensure ERAS shows your DO credentials clearly and proudly.
• Optional: limited, targeted pre-interview outreach to 1–3 programs where you have strong ties.
• Focus on:
  • Polishing your personal statement
  • Coordinating with letter writers who can specifically vouch for your inpatient medicine abilities

October–January (Interview Season)

• For each prelim IM interview:

  • Within 48–72 hours: Send a concise thank-you email to the PD and (optionally) key faculty.
  • Make notes after each interview about:
    • Strengths/weaknesses of the program
    • Culture and resident support
    • How well it aligns with your goals

• Continue to monitor email for interest signals:

  • Save all communication in an organized folder.
  • Don’t over-interpret generic messages.

Late January–February (Pre-Rank List Period)

• Decide on your top tier prelim programs.

• Send:

  • Letters of interest to 2–4 programs that you’re strongly considering.
  • One letter of intent to your true #1 prelim IM program (if you feel certain).

• Provide any meaningful updates (e.g., new publication, honor, or significant evaluation).

• If you’re a DO graduate with:

  • Only COMLEX scores: Consider a brief, reassuring note about your performance and clinical readiness, especially to programs that have historically been less familiar with DO applicants.

Late February–Early March (After Rank List Certification)

• Communication typically decreases.
• If you receive an unexpected program email:
  • Reply politely and briefly.
  • Do not attempt to adjust your rank list based on last-minute communication if it clashes with your true preferences.

---

FAQs: Pre-Match Communication for DOs in Preliminary Medicine

1. As a DO graduate, do I need to “work harder” on pre-match communication than MD applicants for prelim IM?
You don’t need to be louder or more aggressive, but thoughtful, professional communication can help dispel biases about osteopathic training. Focus on demonstrating:

• Strong clinical preparation for inpatient medicine
• Solid COMLEX (and/or USMLE) performance
• Clear understanding of and respect for the demands of a prelim IM year

Quality matters more than volume.

---

2. Can I tell more than one Preliminary Medicine program they are my “top choice”?
You can tell several programs they are among your top choices or that you will “rank them highly.” However, you should only identify one program as your clear #1 in a “letter of intent.” Anything else risks being unethical if programs later compare notes or you misrepresent your intentions.

---

3. Do programs actually change their rank list based on thank-you emails and letters?
Most programs claim pre-match communication doesn’t drive big rank changes, but:

• Personalized, genuine emails can reinforce positive impressions.
• Strong letters of intent may tip decisions between similarly ranked applicants.
• Poorly written or excessive emails can hurt your professional image.

Assume that communication has modest but real influence—enough to justify doing it well, but not enough to supersede your interview performance and application strength.

---

4. How do I balance communication with both my advanced specialty and my preliminary medicine programs?
Treat them as parallel but coordinated processes:

• For your advanced specialty: Emphasize your long-term career fit and specialty alignment.
• For your preliminary medicine programs: Emphasize your readiness to work hard, learn quickly, and contribute as an intern, even if your advanced specialty is different.

You can be transparent that prelim IM is part of your long-term plan while still conveying that you will fully commit to the one-year role and be a dependable member of the medicine team.

---

By understanding the rules, clarifying your own priorities, and communicating strategically, you can navigate pre-match communication as a DO graduate in Preliminary Medicine with confidence—advocating for yourself while fully respecting NRMP guidelines and professional ethics.