Essential IMG Residency Guide: Master Pre-Match Communication in PM&R

Understanding Pre-Match Communication in PM&R for IMGs

For an international medical graduate (IMG) pursuing Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (PM&R), pre-match communication can feel confusing, high-stakes, and—at times—ethically risky. Programs may send enthusiastic emails, hint at ranking you highly, or even explore early commitment. You may wonder: Is this a pre-match offer? Can I discuss this? How should I respond without harming my chances or violating rules?

This IMG residency guide will walk you through:

• What “pre-match communication” means specifically in PM&R
• How pre-match and early commitment systems differ (NRMP vs non-NRMP)
• What is allowed—and what is not—under NRMP rules
• How to communicate effectively with programs before the Match
• How to recognize, handle, and safely respond to pre-match offers, especially as an IMG

The focus is on the physiatry match, but most principles apply broadly.

---

1. The Landscape: Match Rules, PM&R, and IMGs

Before discussing strategies, you must understand the framework that governs residency offers and communication.

1.1 Match vs. Pre-Match: Key Definitions

Match (NRMP):
Most PM&R residency programs participate in the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP). Applicants and programs submit rank lists, and a computer algorithm pairs them. Programs cannot make binding offers outside the Match if they participate.

Pre-match communication:
Any interaction between you and a program before rank lists are due—emails, phone calls, virtual or in-person interviews, follow-up thank-you notes, or informal chats. This can range from purely informational to very suggestive of interest.

Pre-match offer / early commitment:
A pre-match offer is a residency position offered outside the NRMP Match algorithm, often with an expectation of early commitment. This can be:

• Formal: A contract or letter to sign for a specific PGY position
• Informal but explicit: “If you commit to us now, we will reserve a spot for you”

For NRMP-participating programs, such explicit early commitment arrangements are prohibited and can be an NRMP violation.

1.2 PM&R and the Physiatry Match: What IMGs Should Know

Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation is moderately competitive and increasingly popular. IMGs can and do match into PM&R, but:

• A limited number of programs are IMG-friendly
• Visa sponsorship (J-1/H-1B) plays a major role in selection
• Many PM&R programs are smaller and may place high value on “fit” and long-term commitment

As a result, programs may try to gauge your interest early and may push the boundaries of pre-match communication—especially if you’re an IMG they’re strongly considering.

1.3 NRMP and ERAS Basics Related to Pre-Match Communication

Key principles that apply to program communication before the Match:

• No coercion: Programs cannot require a statement or rank order commitment as a condition of interviewing or ranking you.
• No binding early offers: Programs in NRMP may not offer positions outside the Match for the same start date.
• No pressure for ranking disclosures: Programs cannot ask you where they rank on your list.
• Applicants are also bound: You cannot solicit or accept alternative binding offers from NRMP-participating programs for that Match cycle.

For IMGs, these rules still apply even if you’re unfamiliar with the U.S. system. Claiming “I didn’t know” will not protect you from potential NRMP violations if you knowingly enter early commitments with NRMP-participating programs.

---

2. Types of Pre-Match Communication You’ll Encounter

Pre-match communication varies greatly across programs and even individual faculty. Recognizing patterns helps you respond appropriately.

2.1 Routine, Low-Stakes Communication

Examples:

• Interview invitations and scheduling emails
• Instructions for virtual or in-person interview days
• Follow-up requests for documents (USMLE scores, ECFMG status, visa information)
• Automated or generic update messages

How to respond:

• Professional, timely, and concise replies
• No need to express rank intentions or commitment
• Use these interactions to demonstrate reliability and strong communication skills

---

2.2 Interest-Expressing but Non-Binding Messages

These are often sent after interviews or near the end of interview season. Examples:

• “You are a very strong candidate for our program.”
• “We will rank you highly.”
• “We hope you will strongly consider us.”

Key points:

• Common in PM&R and other specialties
• Often intentionally vague to avoid NRMP violations
• Not a guarantee of ranking position or Match result

Safe response approach (example):

Dear Dr. [Name],

Thank you very much for your kind message and for the opportunity to interview at [Program Name].

I truly enjoyed meeting the faculty and residents and learning more about your strengths in [e.g., neurorehabilitation, MSK, longitudinal continuity clinics]. I particularly appreciated [specific detail].

I remain very interested in [Program Name] and believe it would be an excellent fit for my career goals in Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation.

Sincerely,
[Your Name], MD

This expresses genuine interest without making ranking promises.

2.3 Thinly Veiled Ranking Discussions

Sometimes programs test boundaries with more direct language:

• “If we ranked you to match, would you rank us to match?”
• “We are planning to rank you very highly. Where are we on your list?”
• “Are we your top choice?”

Be aware: Asking for your specific rank order is discouraged by NRMP. However, it still happens.

How to respond:

You must balance honesty, professionalism, and self-protection.

Option 1 – Emphasize strong interest but avoid rank numbers:

Thank you for your message and for considering me for your program. I am very interested in [Program Name] and believe it would be an outstanding place for my PM&R training. I am still finalizing my rank list but I can say that [Program Name] will be ranked very highly.

Option 2 – If they explicitly ask “Are we #1?”:

You are not obligated to disclose. You can say:

I greatly appreciate the interest you have shown in my application. At this time, I am still in the process of carefully finalizing my rank list. I can assure you that [Program Name] is one of my top choices, and I would be very excited to train there.

This protects you from making a verbal commitment that you may not wish to honor later.

2.4 Explicit or Implicit Pre-Match Offers

For NRMP-participating PM&R programs, explicit pre-match offers are unusual—but not impossible. These might look like:

• “We would like to offer you a position if you agree to withdraw from the Match.”
• “We can reserve a position for you if you commit to us today.”
• “You do not need to rank us, we will take you outside of the Match.”

Red flags for an NRMP violation if this is an NRMP program:

• Mention of “withdrawing from the Match”
• Any request for early binding commitment
• Written or verbal “contract” for the same training year covered by the Match

If you encounter this from an NRMP-participating PM&R program, be cautious and seek guidance from:

• Your medical school advisor or dean’s office
• The ECFMG/ERAS advisor for IMGs
• NRMP Helpdesk (anonymously if desired)

---

3. Early Commitment Systems vs. The Match: What IMGs Need to Know

The term “pre-match” can be confusing because it is sometimes used in different ways in different regions and systems.

3.1 Non-NRMP or Separate Matching Systems

Some positions, especially transitional years, preliminary years, or non-ACGME or non-NRMP programs, might have:

• Independent application processes
• Non-match positions (e.g., out-of-Match PM&R prelim years in some states, though rare)
• Institutional contracts not covered by NRMP rules

For these, “pre-match offers” may be legally and ethically acceptable, but they must not conflict with any agreements you have made under NRMP or other centralized matching services.

As an IMG, you must ask:

1. Is this position part of NRMP Match?
2. If yes, are we allowed to sign anything before Match Day? (Usually no.)
3. If no, does this impact my ability to participate in the NRMP Match?

3.2 Early Commitment in PM&R: How Common?

In PM&R in the U.S.:

• Most categorical and advanced PM&R positions are NRMP-based
• True early commitment “pre-match offers” are therefore relatively uncommon
• More often, you will encounter strong interest statements rather than formal offers

However, individual programs or affiliated prelim/TY years may have non-NRMP components, especially at smaller community hospitals. Always clarify the structure of the PGY1 + PM&R years.

---

4. Practical Strategies for Effective Pre-Match Communication

Now that you understand the landscape, here’s how to actively manage communication before the Match in a way that boosts your chances without crossing any lines.

4.1 Foundation: Professional Communication Skills

As an IMG, every email, Zoom call, or brief conversation is part of your application. Programs are evaluating:

• English language clarity
• Cultural and professional communication style
• Reliability and responsiveness

General tips:

• Reply to program emails within 24–48 hours
• Use a professional email address (e.g., firstname.lastname.md@…)
• Use clear subject lines: “Thank you – [Your Name], PM&R Interview on [Date]”
• Use proper salutations and closings (“Dear Dr. [Last Name]”, “Sincerely”)
• Proofread carefully; ask a friend or mentor if needed

4.2 Thank-You Emails After PM&R Interviews

Most programs do not require thank-you notes, but they can reinforce your interest and highlight “fit.” As an IMG, they also show your familiarity with U.S. professional norms.

Structure:

1. Subject line – “Thank you for the PM&R interview – [Your Name]”
2. Greeting – “Dear Dr. [X]” or “Dear Dr. [Last Name]”
3. Gratitude – Thank them for their time and the opportunity
4. Specific connection – Mention something you discussed
5. Fit and interest – One or two sentences about why you like the program
6. Professional closing – “Sincerely,” or “Best regards,” + full name, credentials

Example:

Dear Dr. Nguyen,

Thank you very much for the opportunity to interview at the [Hospital Name] PM&R residency program on January 18. I appreciated learning more about your strong inpatient neurorehabilitation service and the emphasis on interdisciplinary teamwork.

I was especially impressed by the integration of EMG training early in residency and the robust mentorship structure you described for residents interested in academic physiatry. As an international medical graduate with a strong interest in neurorehabilitation and electrodiagnostics, I believe your program would be an excellent environment for my professional growth.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name], MD
ECFMG Certified

Do:

• Send within 24–72 hours
• Tailor to each program
• Correct any misunderstandings or add one key point (briefly)

Don’t:

• Repeatedly state “I will rank you #1”
• Attach long CVs, publications, or excessive files
• Use overly casual tone

4.3 Update Letters and Letters of Intent

Update letter:
Sent when you have a meaningful addition to your application:

• New USMLE Step 3 result
• New publication or poster in PM&R
• Additional U.S. clinical experience or physiatry observership
• Changed visa status (e.g., now ECFMG certified, Step 3 passed for H-1B eligibility)

Letter of intent:
A specific communication stating that a program is your top choice and that you intend to rank them first.

Key points:

• Letters of intent are not binding legally or within NRMP.
• However, ethically, if you say “I will rank you #1,” you should follow through.
• You should only send one true letter of intent to your genuine first-choice program.

Example (Letter of Intent for your top-choice PM&R program):

Dear Dr. [Program Director],

I would like to thank you again for the opportunity to interview at the [Program Name] Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation residency program. After completing all of my interviews and carefully reflecting on my experiences, I have decided that [Program Name] is my top choice for residency training.

I will be ranking [Program Name] as my number one choice in the upcoming NRMP Match. The program’s strengths in [e.g., spinal cord injury rehabilitation, musculoskeletal medicine, or prosthetics & orthotics], its collaborative environment, and commitment to supporting international medical graduates align perfectly with my professional goals and values.

It would be an honor to contribute to and learn from your team as a resident. Thank you very much for your consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Name], MD
ECFMG Certified
AAMC ID: [Number]

4.4 Handling Program-Initiated “Check-Ins”

Late in the season, some programs may email or call to “check in,” especially with strong IMG candidates they are seriously considering.

These may include questions like:

• “Are you still interested in our program?”
• “Do you have any remaining questions about training here?”
• “Have you made any decisions about your rank list?”

Goals for your response:

• Reassure them of your interest
• Clarify any logistic issues (visa, Step 3, etc.)
• Avoid detailed rank disclosures if you’re not comfortable

Sample approach:

Thank you for reaching out. I remain very interested in the [Program Name] PM&R residency and continue to view it as one of my top choices. I especially appreciate [brief, specific program feature].

At this point, I am finalizing my rank list and would be very excited to match at your program. I have no additional questions at this time, but I am grateful for the opportunity to be considered.

---

5. Recognizing and Responding to Problematic Pre-Match Situations

IMGs are sometimes more vulnerable to pressure because programs may assume they are unfamiliar with the NRMP rules or more desperate for any offer. You must be able to identify problematic behaviors.

5.1 Red-Flag Behaviors from Programs

Potential problems include:

• Direct requests for ranking information:

  • “Tell us exactly where we are on your list.”
  • “Send us a screenshot of your rank list.”

• Conditional statements:

  • “If you tell us we are #1, we will rank you to match.”
  • “We only rank applicants who promise to rank us highly.”

• Explicit pre-match offers (NRMP programs):

  • “Sign this early contract and withdraw from the Match.”
  • “We will guarantee a spot if you commit now.”

• Visa-related pressure:

  • “Because you need a visa, we must know that you will definitely come here.”

5.2 How to Respond Safely

If a program crosses boundaries, your priority is to:

1. Stay professional
2. Avoid direct conflict if possible
3. Protect yourself from entering into an NRMP violation

Example of deflecting ranking pressure:

I appreciate your interest in my application. In keeping with NRMP guidelines, I prefer not to discuss the specifics of my rank order list, but I can say that your program is one of my very top choices, and I would be very enthusiastic about the opportunity to train there.

If offered a pre-match contract by an NRMP program:

• Do not sign anything immediately
• Politely request time to review
• Seek guidance from:
  • Your home or supporting institution
  • An advisor experienced with residency Match
  • NRMP support (can be anonymous)

If necessary, you can respond:

Thank you for your generous offer and for your confidence in me as a candidate. My understanding is that [Program Name] participates in the NRMP Match, and I am committed to following NRMP policies. I will continue in the Match process and submit my rank list accordingly. I remain very interested in your program and appreciate the opportunity to be considered.

5.3 Ethical Considerations for IMGs

Even if you feel under pressure, remember:

• The NRMP Protects applicants from coercion.
• Lying or sending conflicting letters of intent (“You are my #1”) to multiple programs is unethical and can damage your reputation.
• Your future professional credibility in a relatively small field like physiatry is more valuable than any single program.

---

6. Tailored Advice for IMGs Targeting PM&R

Finally, some specialty-specific and IMG-specific strategies to improve your overall communication and pre-match positioning.

6.1 Emphasize PM&R-Focused Experience and Commitment

Programs want to see that you truly understand and are committed to physiatry, especially if your medical education abroad had limited exposure.

In your communication (emails, interviews, thank-you letters):

• Highlight PM&R electives, observerships, or shadowing, especially in the U.S.
• Emphasize rehabilitation-related research, QI projects, or volunteering (e.g., stroke rehab, spinal cord injury support, prosthetics clinics).
• Connect your background with program strengths (e.g., “My experience in neurorehabilitation aligns with your strong SCI and TBI services”).

This reinforces your authenticity and can make programs more likely to:

• Rank you higher
• Engage positively in pre-match communication

6.2 Be Clear About Visa Status and Steps

Uncertainty about visas can limit an IMG’s chances. Use pre-match communication strategically to clarify and reassure:

• Mention ECFMG certification status in email signatures.
• Indicate your USMLE Step 3 status, especially if programs sponsor H-1B and this is a requirement.
• If you are flexible for J-1 or H-1B, state so if asked (honestly).

This helps programs feel more comfortable ranking you and reduces their perceived “risk” in the physiatry match.

6.3 Use Advisors and Senior IMGs Strategically

Before responding to complex pre-match scenarios, seek advice from:

• Faculty mentors in PM&R
• Former IMGs who matched into PM&R
• Institutional GME offices or ECFMG counselors

Have them review:

• Your letters of intent
• Your response to any questionable program communications
• Any proposed paperwork outside the normal NRMP process

Prevention is far better than attempting to fix an NRMP complaint later.

6.4 Organizing and Tracking Communication

During interview season, you may interact with 20–50+ programs. Keep a simple, structured log:

Columns to track:

• Program name & type (categorical vs advanced)
• IMG/visa friendliness (J-1, H-1B)
• Interview date
• People you met (PD, APD, key faculty, residents)
• Key strengths of each program
• Whether you sent thank-you email + date
• Any later program-initiated contact and your response
• Final ranking impression (personal notes, not for sharing)

This will help you:

• Remember details to reference in follow-up emails
• Prioritize where to send targeted letters of intent or letters of strong interest
• Avoid sending confusing or contradictory messages to the wrong program

---

FAQs: Pre-Match Communication for IMGs in PM&R

1. Can a PM&R program ask me where I will rank them?

They may ask, but NRMP discourages programs from pressuring applicants for detailed rank information. You are not required to disclose your exact ranking. It is acceptable to answer more generally, such as: “You are one of my top choices and I would be very excited to match at your program.”

---

2. Is it okay to tell more than one program they are my ‘top choice’?

You should not tell multiple programs that they are your clear #1 if it is not true. A single, honest letter of intent to your genuine first choice is appropriate. For other programs you like, you can say “ranked highly” or “among my top choices” without promising #1.

---

3. What should I do if a program offers me a position before Match Day?

First, determine if the program is part of the NRMP Match.

• If it is an NRMP program, offering you a binding pre-match position for that same year is likely an NRMP violation. Do not sign anything immediately; seek guidance and consider contacting NRMP.
• If it is not an NRMP position (e.g., some non-match prelims), you can consider it, but you must understand how accepting might affect your participation in the Match and your long-term PM&R plans.

---

4. As an IMG, do I need to write thank-you emails after every PM&R interview?

They are not mandatory, but they are strongly recommended, especially for IMGs. Thank-you emails allow you to reinforce your interest, demonstrate professionalism, and correct any misunderstandings. Keep them concise, program-specific, and professional.

---

By understanding the rules and nuances of pre-match communication, you can navigate the physiatry match more confidently. As an international medical graduate pursuing PM&R, your goal is to project professionalism, genuine interest, and integrity—qualities that will stand out to program directors and help you build a strong, enduring reputation in the field of rehabilitation medicine.