Mastering Pre-Match Communication for OB GYN Residency Success

Understanding Pre-Match Communication in OB GYN

Pre-match communication in OB GYN residency—everything that happens between you and programs after your application is submitted and before the Match lock date—can feel confusing, high-stakes, and at times ethically gray. You may hear phrases like “pre-match offers,” “early commitment,” or “silent programs,” and wonder what’s allowed, what’s risky, and how to advocate for yourself without crossing lines.

This guide focuses specifically on pre-match communication for Obstetrics & Gynecology applicants and aims to help you:

• Understand what kinds of communication are common and permissible
• Respond effectively to interest from programs
• Avoid match violations and ethical missteps
• Use communication strategically to support (but not manipulate) your rank list

While the principles are grounded in NRMP rules and ACOG/CREOG culture as of 2024, always confirm with your Dean’s office, specialty advisors, and the most recent NRMP and specialty-specific guidelines.

---

1. The Landscape: What “Pre-Match Communication” Really Means

Pre-match communication refers to any contact between you and residency programs after ERAS submission and before the Match, outside of the formal NRMP process. In OB GYN, this typically falls into several stages:

1. Post-application, pre-interview
2. During and shortly after interviews
3. Post-interview, pre-rank list certification
4. Late-cycle “quiet phase” before the Match

1.1 Why OB GYN Is Particularly Sensitive to Pre-Match Dynamics

OB GYN is a moderately competitive specialty and has several features that make pre-match communication especially charged:

• Smaller world, tight networks: Program directors (PDs), clerkship directors, and faculty often know each other. Word travels.
• High emphasis on “fit”: Programs care deeply about teamwork, resilience, and commitment to women’s health; they may try to gauge this through informal communication.
• Growing applicant volume: With more applicants per spot, some programs may feel pressure to signal interest early to secure top candidates.
• Heightened professionalism expectations: OB GYN involves high-stress clinical environments, patient advocacy, and sensitive care scenarios—your communication style is viewed as a direct marker of your professionalism.

1.2 NRMP Rules You Must Know

You are bound by NRMP Match Participation Agreement rules. Key points relevant to pre-match communication:

• No commitments outside the Match for NRMP-participating OB GYN programs (U.S. categorical programs in OB GYN almost universally participate in the Match).
• No program can ask you to reveal your rank list or require a commitment.
• You may express interest or intent, but you cannot make binding promises.
• No coercion or pressure is allowed (e.g., “You must tell us we’re #1 to stay ranked at our program”).

Violations can lead to NRMP investigation and serious consequences (for both applicant and program). Memorize this framing:

“I can’t make or request any commitments outside the Match, but I’m happy to share my strong interest.”

---

2. Types of Pre-Match Communication You’ll Encounter

2.1 Before Interviews: Signals, Emails, and Clarifications

Before you step into an interview room, common pre-match communication scenarios include:

• Acknowledgment emails: Automated “We received your application” messages.
• Interview invitations: Your first real individualized contact.
• Waitlist or “hold” notices: Indicating continued consideration.
• Program-initiated interest emails: Sometimes from programs you rotated at or with strong institutional ties.
• Applicant-initiated updates: You reaching out with publications, Step 2 scores, or major life changes.

What’s appropriate from you?

• Brief, professional replies accepting or declining interviews.
• Occasional, concise update emails for significant new information (Step 2 CK score, major publication, ACOG poster, change in couples match status).
• Clarifying questions about interview logistics (dates, virtual vs in-person, second looks).

What to avoid:

• Overly frequent emails (“Just checking in again…” every week).
• Asking about your exact rank position.
• Implying you’re ready to commit before you understand the program.

2.2 During the Interview Season: Real-Time Signals

Once interviews start, pre-match communication shifts:

• Thank-you emails from applicants.
• “We were impressed with you” emails from programs.
• Occasional calls or personalized notes from PDs or faculty (especially if you did an away rotation or sub-I there).
• Invitations for virtual or in-person second looks.

In OB GYN, it’s increasingly common for programs to either:

• Adopt a no post-interview communication policy, or
• Allow only limited, standardized communication to protect fairness.

Be sure to check each program’s stated policy (often in the interview invitation or website). Violating a program’s specific policy—even if NRMP doesn’t forbid it—can hurt your standing.

2.3 Late Season: Expressions of Interest & “Love Letters”

As rank list deadlines approach, some applicants and programs will cautiously approach the line of “expressed preference”:

• Program emails like:

  • “You are ranked highly on our list.”
  • “We believe you’re an excellent fit for our program.”
  • “We hope you strongly consider ranking us.”

• Applicant emails like:

  • “I plan to rank your program highly.”
  • “I am ranking your program #1.”

NRMP “Discourages” rather than strictly forbids these “love letters,” but lying or coercive language is prohibited. Honesty and consistency are crucial—both ethically and reputationally.

---

3. Pre-Match Offers and Early Commitment: What They Are and How to Respond

While true “pre-match offers” are rare in U.S. OB GYN categorical programs participating in the NRMP, similar dynamics can emerge under different names:

• “We’d love to know you’ll rank us #1.”
• “If you rank us highly, you’ll be competitive for a spot.”
• “We strongly encourage you to commit to our program.”

3.1 Pre-Match Offers vs. Strong Interest

Pre-match offer (not allowed in NRMP OB GYN programs):
A program explicitly offers you a residency position outside the Match or requires a binding commitment (written or verbal) before Match Day. Example:

“If you agree not to rank other programs, we’ll guarantee you a PGY-1 spot.”

Strong interest (allowed with caveats):
A program indicates they value you and hope you’ll rank them highly, without making guarantees, asking for commitments, or circumventing the Match. Example:

“You will be ranked highly on our list; we hope you’ll consider us strongly.”

In practice, some language blurs these lines. When unsure, discuss with your Dean or advisor, and remember: You are never obligated to give up the protections of the Match.

3.2 Responding to Pressure for Early Commitment

If a program seems to be pushing for early commitment or asking inappropriate questions, you’ll want to:

1. Stay calm and polite.
2. Reassert NRMP rules without confrontation.
3. Keep your options open.

Sample responses to common pressure scenarios:

Scenario A: “Will you rank us #1?”

“Under NRMP rules, I can’t make or discuss ranking commitments, but I can tell you that I’m very interested in your program and had a great experience on interview day.”

Scenario B: “We want to know if we’re your top choice before we rank our list.”

“I really appreciate your interest. Because of Match guidelines, I need to keep my rank decisions private, but I can say that your program is one I’m strongly considering.”

Scenario C: Explicit pre-match offer (rare but serious):

“I’m concerned that this may conflict with NRMP policies, which require the Match process for residency positions. I’m very interested in your program, but I want to be sure we both stay within the Match rules.”

Then immediately:

• Document the communication (save emails, write down call details).
• Contact your Dean’s office or an NRMP advisor.

3.3 International Context and Non-NRMP Pathways

If you’re considering non-NRMP tracks (e.g., some military positions, certain non-U.S. or non-ACGME programs), pre-match offers or early commitment discussions may be normal and legal. For OB GYN applicants:

• Clarify which positions participate in the NRMP and which do not.
• Understand that accepting a non-NRMP pre-match position may make you ineligible for some NRMP pathways or require withdrawal.
• Always get clear, written confirmation of job terms, duration, salary, and training recognition.

---

4. Communicating Strategically: Emails, Calls, and Second Looks

4.1 Email Etiquette for OB GYN Applicants

Email is the primary channel for program communication before the Match. Aim for messages that are:

• Brief (150–200 words)
• Specific (mention at least one concrete program feature)
• Professional in tone and formatting

Post-interview thank-you email template (OB GYN-specific):

Subject: Thank You – OB GYN Interview on [Date]

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

Thank you very much for the opportunity to interview at the [Program Name] OB GYN residency. I especially appreciated our discussion about [e.g., the program’s approach to resident autonomy in L&D, your global women’s health initiatives, the dedicated MIGS training, etc.].

The combination of strong surgical training, supportive faculty, and emphasis on [e.g., reproductive justice, community women’s health, family planning] makes [Program Name] a place where I could see myself thriving and contributing to the team.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name], MS4
[Medical School]
AAMC ID: [xxxxxxx]

Update email example (for significant achievements):

Subject: Application Update – OB GYN Residency Applicant [Your Name]

Dear Dr. [Last Name] and the Selection Committee,

I am writing to share a brief update to my application. Since submitting my ERAS materials, my manuscript titled “[Title]” has been accepted for publication in [Journal Name]. The project examines [briefly, e.g., disparities in prenatal care access among underserved populations].

This work has further solidified my commitment to a career in Obstetrics & Gynecology focused on [e.g., health equity, family planning, maternal-fetal medicine]. I remain very interested in [Program Name] and appreciate your continued consideration of my application.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Medical School]
AAMC ID: [xxxxxxx]

Limit such updates to 1–2 per program unless they explicitly invite more.

4.2 When (and Whether) to Call Programs

Phone calls from applicants are rarely necessary and can sometimes feel intrusive.

Reasonable reasons to call:

• Clarify interview logistics if instructions are unclear and email response has not come.
• Emergencies (illness, severe weather) impacting your in-person or virtual attendance.
• Rare, advisor-approved situations (e.g., couples match coordination after discussion with mentors).

Things you should not call about:

• Asking “How high am I ranked?”
• Repeatedly checking your status pre- or post-interview.
• Trying to lobby for a higher rank position.

If you must call, keep it short, polite, and logistical.

4.3 Second Looks in OB GYN: Value and Risks

Second looks—additional, usually informal visits to a program after your interview—are variable across OB GYN:

• Some programs encourage structured second looks, often virtual.
• Others explicitly discourage them to avoid disadvantaging students with financial or time constraints.
• Many insist second looks do not affect ranking, though reality may be nuanced.

Consider a second look if:

• You’re genuinely torn between 1–3 programs and need first-hand comparison.
• You want to better understand call structure, L&D culture, or resident life.
• The program offers a clearly optional second look day with group sessions.

Avoid or think twice if:

• The program pressures you (“Serious applicants come for a second look”).
• You can’t afford it financially or schedule-wise.
• You’re just going because others are, not because you need more data.

When you attend, treat it like a low-key interview day: be punctual, professionally dressed (usually business casual), engaged, and respectful.

---

5. Honest Signals: Telling Programs How You’ll Rank Them

One of the most confusing parts of pre-match communication is deciding whether to tell a program it is your #1 choice or that you’ll “rank them highly.”

5.1 What You’re Allowed to Say

You may:

• Tell a program: “I’m ranking you #1” — if it’s true.
• Tell multiple programs: “I will rank your program highly” — because that is intentionally vague.
• Share specific reasons for your interest (case volume, culture, geography, subspecialty exposure).

You may not:

• Ask programs: “Where am I on your rank list?”
• Pressure programs for reciprocal statements (“If I rank you #1, will you rank me #1?”).
• Lie about your rank intentions.

Honesty is essential not only ethically but also practically:

• PDs and faculty talk across programs and years.
• Your reputation as a future colleague starts now.
• If you tell multiple places they’re #1, it will eventually be noticed.

5.2 Strategic Approaches for OB GYN Applicants

A reasonable strategy for OB GYN applicants is:

1. Identify your true #1 program after you’ve done your rank list work.
2. If that program allows post-interview communication and doesn’t discourage it:
   • Send one brief, specific, honest email stating it is your top choice.
3. For other programs you like:
   • You can express continued strong interest without ranking language:
     • “Your program remains one of my top choices for OB GYN training.”
     • “I remain very enthusiastic about the possibility of training at [Program].”

Sample “you’re my #1” email (if program allows):

Subject: Continued Interest – Ranking [Program Name] #1

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I wanted to sincerely thank you again for the opportunity to interview at the [Program Name] OB GYN residency. After carefully reflecting on my interviews and goals, I have decided to rank [Program Name] as my number one choice in the Match.

The program’s strong surgical training, early exposure to high-risk obstetrics, and commitment to [e.g., reproductive justice and community women’s health] align perfectly with the physician I hope to become. I was especially impressed by the camaraderie among residents and the supportive faculty culture I observed on interview day.

Regardless of the Match outcome, I am grateful for the chance to have gotten to know your program. Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Warm regards,
[Your Name]
[Medical School]
AAMC ID: [xxxxxxx]

Send this once, near the time you certify your list, not multiple times.

---

6. Professionalism, Red Flags, and Protecting Yourself

Pre-match communication in OB GYN isn’t just about strategy; it’s also a test of professionalism, boundaries, and ethics—on both sides.

6.1 Red Flags in Program Communication

Take note if a program:

• Pressures you to reveal ranking specifics or to commit.
• Makes disparaging comments about other programs or applicants.
• Violates its own stated communication policy.
• Uses sexist, racist, or discriminatory language in any communication.
• Ignores your reasonable, respectful questions or emergencies.

These aren’t automatically deal-breakers, but they are important data points when building your rank list.

6.2 Red Flags in Applicant Behavior (to Avoid)

From the program’s perspective, red flags can include:

• Over-communication: Repeated emails/calls without new content.
• Inconsistent statements: Telling multiple programs they’re your #1.
• Unprofessional tone: Sloppy emails, informal language, or lack of addressing titles (“Hey,” “Hi guys”).
• Boundary issues: Showing up uninvited at the hospital or contacting faculty via personal social media.

Remember: OB GYN residency directors value maturity, reliability, and emotional regulation. Your communication style is a direct window into those traits.

6.3 When and How to Involve Your Advisors

Loop in your Dean, specialty advisor, or a trusted OB GYN mentor when:

• You believe a program may have violated NRMP rules or is pressuring you.
• You’re not sure whether to send a “#1 choice” email.
• You feel unsettled by a conversation or email and want a second opinion.

Provide them with specific details and exact language used by the program so they can give informed advice.

---

FAQs about Pre-Match Communication in OB GYN

1. Is it ever okay to accept a pre-match offer for an OB GYN residency?

For NRMP-participating OB GYN programs in the U.S., you should not accept pre-match offers that bypass the Match. Almost all standard OB GYN categorical positions go through the obstetrics match process, and binding agreements outside that framework are violations. Non-NRMP or international positions are a separate category, but accepting one may require you to withdraw from the Match. Always discuss such offers with your Dean or advisor first.

2. Will sending “thank-you” or “I’m very interested” emails help my chances?

Thoughtful, professional emails can help confirm your interest and professionalism, but they will not magically overcome large application gaps. Many programs value them as a sign of courtesy; some state they do not factor them into rank decisions. Use them to:

• Reiterate your fit for OB GYN and that specific program
• Highlight one or two aspects that particularly resonated
• Maintain professionalism in all interactions

Avoid sending multiple repetitive emails or writing long, emotional letters.

3. Can I tell more than one OB GYN program that I’m ranking them #1?

You should not. While NRMP doesn’t explicitly police this, it is considered unethical and dishonest. PDs frequently talk across programs, and being caught in a contradiction can damage your reputation. You may tell multiple programs that they are among your top choices or that you will “rank them highly,” but you should reserve the explicit “I’m ranking you #1” for one program—and only if that’s truly your plan.

4. What should I do if a program asks how I will rank them?

You are not required to reveal your rank list, and programs should not pressure you to do so. A safe, professional response is:

“I’m still finalizing my rank list, but I can say that I’m very interested in your program and appreciate the opportunity to have interviewed here.”

You can choose to be more specific if you truly want to and it aligns with your strategy, but you should not feel obliged. If a program’s questioning feels coercive, document it and discuss with your Dean or advisor.

---

Navigating pre-match communication in OB GYN is about balancing honesty, advocacy, and professionalism. Use each email, call, and conversation as an opportunity to demonstrate the kind of physician—and colleague—you intend to be: thoughtful, respectful, and grounded in integrity.