Ultimate Guide to Pre-Match Communication for DO Graduates in Pediatrics

Pre-match communication is one of the most confusing parts of the residency application process—especially for a DO graduate entering pediatrics. You’ll hear about “pre-match offers,” “early commitment,” and questions about “how much communication is too much” before Match Day. For osteopathic applicants, this feels even higher stakes when you’re navigating both MD and DO-friendly pediatrics residency programs.

This guide breaks down what pre-match communication really means in pediatrics, how it applies to DO graduates, and how you can use it strategically—without violating NRMP rules or hurting your chances in the peds match.

---

Understanding Pre-Match Communication vs. Pre-Match Offers

Before thinking about what to say to programs, it’s essential to separate communication from commitment.

1. What “Pre-Match Communication” Really Is

Pre-match communication refers to any interaction between you and residency programs before the official Match results are released, including:

• Emails between you and program leadership (PDs, APDs, coordinators)
• Phone calls or Zoom follow-ups after interviews
• Thank-you notes and update letters
• Signals of interest you send to a program
• Clarifying questions about ranking, culture, schedule, etc.

These are common, expected, and often helpful in pediatrics. Most programs anticipate some level of applicant communication during and after the interview season.

2. What “Pre-Match Offers” and “Early Commitment” Mean

A pre-match offer or early commitment historically meant:

• A program offers a residency position outside of the Match
• The applicant informally or formally agrees to accept before Match Day

In the era of a unified ACGME accreditation system and widespread NRMP participation, most categorical pediatrics residency positions (especially at ACGME-accredited institutions) are filled through the Match, not by separate “pre-match offers.”

As a DO graduate, you may still hear about:

• Some community programs or special tracks that historically offered pre-match positions
• Off-cycle or unexpected openings that might be offered outside the Match
• Confusion left over from the pre-single-accreditation era when some osteopathic programs did not participate in NRMP

Today, most pediatrics positions you want as a DO graduate will be under NRMP rules, which limit what both you and the program can do or say regarding commitments.

---

NRMP Rules and Ethics for DO Graduates in Pediatrics

Understanding the rules is critical before engaging in any program communication before the match.

1. What the NRMP Allows

Under NRMP policy, both applicants and programs may:

• Express interest, enthusiasm, or appreciation
• Ask or answer factual questions about the program or your application
• Provide non-binding indications of ranking plans (e.g., “we are very interested in you” or “you are a highly ranked candidate”)
• Receive thank-you notes and updates from applicants
• Have post-interview conversations for clarification

2. What the NRMP Forbids

Both parties may not:

• Ask for or require a commitment to rank:
  • “Will you rank us first?”
  • “If we rank you highly, will you rank us highly?”
• Ask you to reveal your exact rank list:
  • “Where are we on your rank list?”
  • “Are we in your top 3?”
• Make binding promises:
  • “If you rank us first, you will match here”
  • “We guarantee you a position if you commit”
• Offer or accept a residency position outside of the Match when the program participates in NRMP for that position
• Use pressure, ultimatums, or coercive language

This applies equally to MD and DO applicants.

3. How This Affects DO Graduates Specifically

As a DO graduate in pediatrics, you may:

• Apply to a mix of formerly-osteopathic and historically-allopathic pediatrics programs
• Encounter programs less familiar with DO degrees, or more familiar and very DO-friendly
• Hear about “pre-match offers” from older residents or forums based on pre-merger training systems

In practice today:

• Almost all ACGME pediatrics programs use the NRMP Match
• A program that still sounds like it’s offering a “pre-match” may:
  • Be discussing a non-NRMP position (e.g., off-cycle slot, non-categorical track, or special circumstance), or
  • Be using outdated language for strong interest, not an actual early contract

When in doubt, ask explicitly—politely—whether the position is participating in the NRMP Match for this cycle.

---

Strategic Communication Before the Match: Step-by-Step

Once you know the rules, the next question is how to communicate effectively without seeming pushy or inappropriate. This section walks you through each stage of the pediatrics residency application cycle with specific guidance for a DO graduate.

1. Before You Apply: Setting Up a Strong Communication Strategy

Even before ERAS opens, smart preparation can make later communication easier.

• Clarify your pediatrics story as a DO

  • Why pediatrics? Why as an osteopathic physician?
  • How has OMT or osteopathic principles shaped your approach to children and families?
  • What unique DO training experiences (OPP lab, community rotations, rural care) will resonate with peds programs?

• Identify DO-friendly pediatrics programs

  • Look at current and recent residents: are DOs represented?
  • Read program websites and social media for explicit encouragement of DO applicants
  • Ask current residents (especially DOs) about the culture and how DOs are perceived

• Build a short, clear “elevator pitch” you can adapt for emails and interviews:

  • Who you are as a DO graduate
  • Why pediatrics is your specialty
  • What specific strengths you bring to their program

This foundation will make all future communication more authentic and consistent.

2. Pre-Interview Communication: When and How to Reach Out

Before you get an interview invitation, your communication should be selective and purposeful.

Appropriate reasons to email before interview offers

You might email a program if:

• You have a strong, specific connection:
  • You completed a rotation, sub-I, or research there
  • You have geographic ties (family, spouse/partner, prior training)
• You are a DO graduate concerned about being overlooked at a program with fewer DO residents, and you have a compelling reason for interest
• You need to update a significant change in your application:
  • New USMLE/COMLEX score
  • New publication or major leadership role
  • Change in graduation status or visa

What to say (and what not to say)

A strong pre-interview email from a DO graduate in pediatrics might:

• Briefly introduce you
• Reference a real connection to the program
• Highlight one or two key strengths (peds-relevant)
• Reaffirm your enthusiasm
• Avoid asking outright for an interview

Example (pre-interview interest email)

Dear Dr. [Program Director’s Last Name],

My name is [Name], a fourth-year DO student at [School] applying to pediatrics this cycle. I am reaching out to express my strong interest in [Program Name]. As someone who completed my third-year pediatrics core rotation in [city/region], I’m particularly drawn to your program’s emphasis on [e.g., community outreach, underserved populations, or specific track].

As a DO applicant, I’ve greatly valued the osteopathic approach to whole-child and family-centered care, especially during my rotations in [brief example]. I am excited by how well that aligns with the culture and training described on your website.

Thank you for your time and for considering my application. I would be very grateful for the opportunity to interview at [Program Name].

Sincerely,
[Full Name], DO Candidate
AAMC/ERAS ID: [ID]

This communicates interest and identity as a DO graduate in pediatrics without asking for special treatment or pressuring the program.

3. Post-Interview Communication: Thank-You Notes and Updates

Once interviews begin, program communication before match is most active. This is the period where thoughtful emails can support your candidacy.

Thank-you emails: Necessary or optional?

Pediatrics as a specialty tends to be relationship-oriented and collegial, and many programs still appreciate thank-you notes. They are not required, but they:

• Reinforce your interest
• Allow you to highlight specific parts of the interview day
• Show professionalism and courtesy

Keep them:

• Short (1–2 paragraphs)
• Personalized (mention specific conversation points)
• Free of promises or rank talk

Post-interview update letters

You may send one or two meaningful updates if:

• You have new achievements: publication, poster, award, leadership position
• You completed a substantial new clinical experience in pediatrics
• There is a change in your application (e.g., improved Step/COMLEX score)

For DO graduates, an update letter is also a good chance to:

• Reaffirm your commitment to pediatrics
• Highlight osteopathic strengths (holistic family care, communication, musculoskeletal exam skills) as they relate to pediatrics

Again, avoid explicit rank language like “I will rank you first” in an early or mid-season update. Save any strong ranking statement for one final communication if you choose to send it (see below).

---

Signaling Interest, “Love Letters,” and Rank Order Nuances

This is the most emotionally charged part of program communication before the match—what many applicants call the “love letter” phase.

1. Should You Tell a Program They Are Your #1?

The NRMP explicitly allows applicants to express how they plan to rank programs, as long as:

• It is not required by the program
• It is not contingent on a promise by the program
• It is truthful (you must not misrepresent your intentions)

As a DO graduate entering pediatrics, you may decide to tell one program they are your top choice if:

• You have interviewed there
• You genuinely plan to rank them #1
• You are comfortable following through even if another attractive option appears later

This can matter more for borderline candidates or in small to mid-sized peds programs, where individual applicant enthusiasm sometimes influences final rank list discussion.

2. How to Phrase a “Top Choice” Email

A well-crafted email near the end of interview season might say:

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

Thank you again for the opportunity to interview at [Program Name]. After completing my interviews this season and reflecting on where I see myself training, I wanted to share that [Program Name] is my top choice for pediatrics residency.

As an osteopathic graduate, I am particularly drawn to your program’s emphasis on [e.g., holistic, family-centered care; continuity clinic; advocacy; community pediatrics], which aligns closely with my training and values. I felt a strong connection with your residents and faculty and can clearly see myself growing as a pediatrician in your environment.

Regardless of the outcome, I am grateful for the chance to have met your team and to have learned more about [Program Name].

Sincerely,
[Name], DO
ERAS ID: [ID]

Key points:

• Clear, honest statement: “is my top choice”
• Roots that statement in specific reasons
• No conditions or pressure
• Does not ask how the program will rank you

3. Communicating Strong Interest Without Saying “#1”

If you like a program a lot but are not certain it’s your top choice—or you already told another program they are #1—you can still express enthusiasm:

Phrases that are typically acceptable:

• “I will be ranking [Program Name] very highly.”
• “Your program is among my top choices.”
• “I can easily see myself training at [Program Name] and would be thrilled to match there.”

Do not:

• Tell more than one program they are your absolute #1.
• Use language that implies a binding commitment outside the Match.

Ethically, your words must match your actual rank order list.

---

Special Considerations for DO Graduates in the Pediatrics Residency Match

Because the peds match is generally DO-friendly, you’re starting from a good position—but there are still specific issues to consider.

1. Addressing DO vs. MD Concerns in Communication

Some DO graduates worry about implicit bias or misunderstanding of osteopathic training. You can subtly address this in your communication:

• Emphasize that your osteopathic training enhances your pediatrics approach (whole-child perspective, family context, preventive care).
• Mention both COMLEX and USMLE if you completed both, or briefly clarify if you did not take USMLE but have strong COMLEX scores and solid pediatric clinical performance.
• Highlight community, continuity, or OMT experiences relevant to children with chronic conditions, sports injuries, or developmental concerns.

Avoid apologizing for being a DO; present it as a strength and part of your identity.

2. If a Program Mentions “Pre-Match” or “Early Commitment”

Occasionally, you might hear language like:

• “We would really like you here and might be able to work something out early.”
• “We don’t always go through the full Match process for every spot.”

Your response should be:

1. Clarify whether this specific position is in NRMP:

   • “Just to be sure I understand, is this position participating in the NRMP Match this year, or is it outside of the Match?”

2. If it is NRMP-participating, you should not sign any early contract for that position. You can respond with appreciative but non-committal language:

   • “Thank you very much for your enthusiasm and support. I’m very excited about the possibility of training at [Program Name] and will certainly reflect that in my rank list.”

3. If it is truly outside the Match (rare for standard categorical pediatrics positions), consult:

   • Your medical school advisor or dean’s office
   • A trusted faculty mentor
   • The NRMP policies (to ensure you don’t violate rules by accepting and then also participating in the Match for overlapping positions)

3. Handling Program Pressure or Discomfort

If a program asks:

• “Will you rank us first?”
• “Where will you rank us?”
• “Can you commit that you’ll come here if we rank you highly?”

You can respond by:

• Respecting NRMP rules
• Being polite but firm

Example response:

“I really enjoyed meeting your team and I’m very interested in your program. However, I’ve been advised not to share my specific rank order to keep the process fair and in line with NRMP guidelines. I can say that I will be making my list based on the best fit for my training and career in pediatrics, and your program is one I’m strongly considering.”

If pressure continues or you feel uncomfortable, document the interaction (date, time, what was said) and consider discussing it with your dean or advisor.

---

Putting It All Together: A Practical Communication Timeline

Here’s a simplified communication roadmap tailored for a DO applying to pediatrics:

August–September (Application Preparation)

• Identify DO-friendly pediatrics residency programs.
• Draft a template for pre-interview interest emails (customize per program).
• Prepare a concise DO-specific pediatrics narrative.

September–October (Application Submitted)

• Optional targeted pre-interview emails to a small number (3–8) of top-choice programs with strong ties/fit.
• No mass emailing; be selective.

October–January (Interview Season)

• For each interview: send brief, personalized thank-you emails within 48–72 hours.
• Mid-season: send 1–2 update letters if you have substantial new information.
• Maintain a private running rank list with pros and cons of each pediatrics residency.

Late January–February (Rank List Finalization)

• Decide honestly if there is a true #1 program.
• Send one “you are my top choice” email if you choose to do so.
• For other highly-ranked programs, you may send a brief note expressing strong continued interest.
• Stop making major communication changes once your rank list is certified unless there is a truly significant update.

March (Pre-Match Silence and Match Week)

• Avoid last-minute, anxious emails; trust your preparation.
• If unmatched, consider SOAP communication strategies (a separate, more structured process, with its own rules).

---

FAQs: Pre-Match Communication for DO Graduates in Pediatrics

1. As a DO graduate, do I need to communicate differently than MD applicants in the pediatrics residency match?

You don’t need a completely different strategy, but you should highlight your DO strengths more intentionally. Emphasize:

• Holistic, family-centered approach
• Strong communication and continuity care experiences
• OMT or osteopathic principles applied to pediatric patients (when relevant)

Your communication style (thank-you notes, updates, interest emails) should follow the same NRMP rules and professional norms as MD applicants.

2. Are pre-match offers still common in pediatrics for DO graduates?

For standard categorical pediatrics residency positions at ACGME-accredited programs, true “pre-match offers” are rare and often not permissible if the position is in NRMP. Most peds programs fill through the regular Match. If anyone offers an “early commitment,” clarify whether the position is inside or outside the NRMP. When in doubt, consult your dean or an advisor before agreeing to anything.

3. How many programs should I tell are my “top choice”?

Only one. Telling more than one program they are your definitive #1 is considered unethical and can damage your reputation if discovered. You may, however, tell multiple programs they will be “ranked highly” or that they are among your top choices, as long as those statements are honest.

4. Can pre-match communication actually change how a pediatrics program ranks me?

It can influence the discussion, especially in close calls. Thoughtful, professional communication may:

• Help program leadership remember you more clearly
• Reinforce your fit with their mission and culture
• Demonstrate your maturity, enthusiasm, and reliability

However, pre-match communication cannot overcome major application gaps (e.g., consistently poor clinical performance). Think of it as a way to strengthen an already competitive pediatrics application, not as a way to rescue a weak one.

---

By understanding NRMP rules, recognizing how “pre-match offers” really function in today’s system, and using clear, ethical communication, you can navigate program communication before the match with confidence. As a DO graduate entering pediatrics, your osteopathic background is an asset—your goal is to let programs see that through every interaction, from your first email to your final “top choice” message.