Mastering Pre-Match Communication: A Guide for MD Graduates in Clinical Informatics

Understanding Pre-Match Communication in Clinical Informatics

For an MD graduate residency applicant interested in clinical informatics, pre-match communication sits at the intersection of professionalism, strategy, and ethics. You’re communicating with programs about training opportunities that blend clinical care, data science, and health IT training—often in environments where both residency tracks and a clinical informatics fellowship may coexist.

In this context, “pre-match communication” means any contact you have with programs before the NRMP® Match (or equivalent matching system) runs:

• Emails with program directors (PDs), associate program directors, or coordinators
• Conversations at interviews, second looks, or virtual open houses
• Follow-up notes expressing interest or sending updates
• Informal networking via mentors, conferences, or professional organizations

Because clinical informatics is a small, highly networked specialty, how you communicate before the Match can significantly influence:

• Whether you’re seen as a good fit for a combined residency + informatics trajectory
• Whether a program can envision you in future roles (e.g., chief resident, clinical informatics pathway leader, or future clinical informatics fellowship recruit)
• How confident a program feels about ranking you highly

At the same time, there are clear rules: the NRMP Match Participation Agreement, institutional policies, and professional ethics all place boundaries around pre-match offers, early commitment, and program communication before match. Your goal is to stand out as an informed, enthusiastic, and honest candidate—without crossing any lines.

This article walks you through:

• The rules and realities of pre-match communication for MD graduates
• How clinical informatics interests change the conversation
• Concrete email templates and talking points
• Red flags and pitfalls to avoid

---

Rules of Engagement: What’s Allowed, What’s Not

Before discussing strategy, you must be clear about the ground rules. As an MD graduate from an allopathic medical school, most of your residency applications will go through ERAS® and the NRMP® Match (or SOAP® if needed). Many clinical informatics–oriented paths (e.g., IM or EM residency with informatics tracks, or eventual clinical informatics fellowship) will still be tied to Match rules.

NRMP and Ethical Constraints

Most programs participating in the allopathic medical school match are bound by strict guidelines. While details can evolve, core principles are stable:

Programs may:

• Contact you before and after interviews to:
  • Offer interviews
  • Provide information about their program
  • Answer questions
  • Gauge your interest
• Express that they are “very interested” or that they “plan to rank you highly” (though some programs avoid specifics)

Programs may not ethically:

• Ask you how you will rank them compared to other programs
• Pressure you for a verbal commitment
• Offer guaranteed positions outside of Match if they have agreed to participate in Match for that track
• Ask you to disclose where else you have interviewed or your rank list order (more than very broad questions, like “what region are you aiming for?”)

You, as the applicant, may:

• Express genuine interest, including saying:
  • “You are my top choice”
  • “I intend to rank your program very highly” or even #1 (if true)
• Communicate updates (new publications, projects, leadership roles)
• Ask clarifying questions about curriculum, informatics opportunities, call schedule, culture, etc.

You should not ethically:

• Misrepresent your level of interest or intent
• Claim a program is your #1 choice if that isn’t true
• Try to negotiate pre-match offers when the program is in the NRMP Match (unless there is a formal, allowed pre-match pathway that’s transparently separate and compliant with NRMP rules)

Where Pre-Match Offers and Early Commitment Actually Show Up

True pre-match offers and early commitment agreements more commonly appear in:

• Systems or tracks not participating in NRMP (e.g., certain independent non-NRMP programs, off-cycle positions, some international or military pathways)
• Certain fellowships (including some clinical informatics fellowship positions), which may use non-NRMP processes, rolling offers, or local interviews

For a standard MD graduate residency path (e.g., internal medicine, pediatrics, emergency medicine, pathology) that leads later to a clinical informatics fellowship, you are usually not negotiating a pre-match offer for residency itself. Instead, your “pre-match” decisions are more about:

• Signaling high interest
• Demonstrating fit for informatics-oriented training
• Building a relationship that makes a program feel comfortable ranking you highly

In some academic centers with strong clinical informatics footprints, discussions might also touch on future informatics pathways, such as:

• Dedicated informatics tracks or longitudinal curricula during residency
• Protected research time in health IT training, data science, or EHR optimization
• Internal pipelines to their clinical informatics fellowship

You are not committing to the fellowship pre-match, but your demonstrated commitment to informatics can shape how programs see your future trajectory.

---

Strategic Pre-Match Communication for MD Graduates in Clinical Informatics

With rules clear, the question becomes: How do you use pre-match communication thoughtfully? For an MD graduate with an interest in clinical informatics, you want to use every interaction to:

1. Highlight your informatics-oriented skill set and mindset
2. Clarify how their program will support you (and how you will contribute)
3. Communicate your level of interest while staying honest and professional

Timing and Channels: When to Communicate

You typically have several “windows” for program communication before the Match:

1. Initial Application Period (Before Interview Invites)

   • You usually do not email programs just to “remind” them you applied, unless there’s a compelling new update or you have a strong established connection (e.g., you completed a sub-internship there).
   • Exception: If a program explicitly encourages contact from informatics-interested candidates, brief outreach can make sense.

2. After Receiving an Interview Invite (Pre-Interview)

   • You may reply to confirm, ask logistical questions, and occasionally reference your informatics interest if relevant (e.g., asking if you’ll meet with informatics faculty).

3. Immediately Post-Interview (Within 24–72 Hours)

   • This is standard thank-you note timeframe.
   • For informatics-interested applicants, this is a key opportunity to:
     • Reiterate your interest in clinical informatics
     • Reference specific faculty, projects, or IT initiatives you’d like to join

4. Pre-Rank List / Post-Interview Season

   • You can send a brief, focused “interest” email to your top 1–3 programs.
   • For your true #1, you may explicitly say they are your top choice, if you mean it.
   • For clinical informatics, this is where you also highlight how their health IT training environment specifically matches your career goals.

What to Communicate: Content Priorities for Informatics-Oriented Applicants

For a standard MD graduate residency applicant, content may focus on clinical training, location, and culture. As a clinical informatics–oriented candidate, you should layer in:

• Specific informatics experiences

  • Examples: EHR optimization projects, quality improvement using health data, database or R/Python work, app development, telemedicine workflows, CDS tools, data visualization, or health policy/standards (HL7, FHIR).

• Future informatics goals

  • Interest in a clinical informatics fellowship
  • Long-term plan: clinical practice (e.g., hospitalist, ED physician, internist) + system-level informatics leadership
  • Desire to contribute to EHR configuration, governance, or clinical decision support committees during residency

• Concrete contributions you can make to the program

  • Joining or helping initiate projects on:
    • Reducing alert fatigue
    • Optimizing order sets
    • Improving data capture for quality metrics
    • Enhancing patient portals or telehealth workflows

Tone and Length: Professional, Polite, and Purposeful

• Aim for short, targeted emails: 1–3 concise paragraphs.
• Avoid sounding entitled (“I expect to be placed in your informatics track”) or overly casual.
• Use clear subject lines, such as:
  • “Thank you – [Program Name] IM Interview, Clinical Informatics Interest”
  • “Follow-up: MD Graduate with Clinical Informatics Focus – [Your Name]”

---

Practical Examples: Emails and Talking Points

To make this actionable, here are sample structures you can adapt. Do not copy verbatim; customize for your voice and situation.

Post-Interview Thank-You with Informatics Emphasis

Subject: Thank you – [Program Name] Interview and Clinical Informatics Opportunities

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

Thank you for the opportunity to interview at [Program Name] on [date]. I appreciated our discussion about how your residents engage with [EHR optimization, quality dashboards, or specific informatics initiative discussed]. The integration of clinical informatics into day-to-day patient care was especially compelling.

As an MD graduate with prior experience in [briefly mention: e.g., building a sepsis alert dashboard in Epic, conducting a data-driven QI project, working on a telemedicine workflow], I’m particularly excited about the chance to contribute to projects like [specific project or committee mentioned during interview]. Your program’s environment offers exactly the type of health IT training that aligns with my long-term goal of pursuing a clinical informatics fellowship and combining bedside care with systems-level improvement.

Thank you again for your time and consideration. I would be honored to train at [Program Name].

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name], MD
AAMC ID: [if applicable]

Post-Interview Interest Email to Top Programs

Subject: Strong Interest in [Program Name] – Clinical Informatics-Focused Applicant

Dear Dr. [PD Last Name],

I hope you are well. I wanted to reiterate my strong interest in [Program Name] after our interview on [date]. The combination of rigorous clinical training and robust clinical informatics infrastructure, including [mention data warehouse, analytics team, EHR governance, or informatics track], stands out among the programs I’ve seen.

Since our interview, I have [brief update: submitted a manuscript on an informatics project, presented a health IT quality improvement poster, implemented a new EHR-based protocol, etc.]. These experiences have reinforced my goal of training in a residency environment where I can continue to grow as both a clinician and an informatics-focused physician.

[Optional if truly #1]: I want to be transparent that [Program Name] is my top choice, and I intend to rank your program first. I believe my background in [very brief highlight] and my commitment to clinical informatics would allow me to contribute meaningfully to your residents’ informatics efforts.

Thank you for your continued consideration.

Best regards,
[Your Full Name], MD

How to Communicate About Pre-Match and Rank-Order Topics

You might be asked indirectly about your preferences. Examples and safe responses:

Program question: “Where does our program fit among places you’ve seen?”

• You can say:
  • “I’ve been very impressed by several programs, but your integration of clinical informatics and resident involvement in EHR and data projects makes you one of my top choices.”

Program question: “Are you planning to stay in this region?”

• You can say:
  • “I’m open geographically, but I’m particularly drawn to programs that offer strong informatics opportunities. Your institution’s health IT infrastructure and clinical informatics faculty make staying in this region very appealing.”

Avoid disclosing detailed rank order; instead, emphasize fit and enthusiasm grounded in specifics about informatics and training.

---

Red Flags, Pitfalls, and How to Protect Yourself

Pre-match communication can occasionally cross boundaries, especially in a small field like clinical informatics where personal relationships and informal conversations are common. You need to know what to watch out for.

Red Flag #1: Pressure for a Verbal Commitment

If a program says something like:

• “If you tell us we’re your #1, we can guarantee you’ll match here.”
• “You need to commit now so we can move forward.”

This is problematic. No program can truly guarantee a Match outcome, and tying verbal commitments to ranking decisions is ethically questionable.

How to respond diplomatically:

“I’m very interested in your program and grateful for your enthusiasm. I’m still in the process of completing my interviews and will submit a rank list that reflects my priorities and the best fit for my career goals, particularly in clinical informatics. I want to be honest and fair in that process.”

Red Flag #2: Requests for Detailed Rank List Information

If asked directly:

• “Where are we on your rank list?”
• “Who are you ranking above or below us?”

You’re not obligated to answer. You can respond:

“I’m still finalizing my rank list and want to make sure I weigh all the important factors carefully, including informatics opportunities, mentorship, and clinical training. I can say that I’m very enthusiastic about [Program Name] and could see myself thriving here.”

Red Flag #3: Informal Pre-Match Offers in a Matched Program

If you’re in a pathway that clearly participates in the NRMP Match but someone hints at a side-door arrangement (e.g., “We might be able to secure your spot early if you agree verbally now and withdraw other interviews”), this is a serious concern. Document such interactions and, if needed, seek private guidance from:

• Your medical school’s dean or advisor
• The GME office at your institution
• The NRMP support channels (if you believe rules are being violated)

Red Flag #4: Over-Promising Your Own Intentions

Be careful not to overstate your commitment. Saying “I’ll definitely rank you #1” but then changing your mind later is technically not illegal but is ethically problematic and can damage your reputation, especially in a small field like clinical informatics where people often cross paths later (e.g., during fellowship, at informatics conferences, or in industry).

If you’re enthusiastic but uncertain, use phrases like:

• “I plan to rank your program very highly.”
• “You are one of my top choices, especially due to your focus on clinical informatics and health IT training.”

This is honest, positive, and non-binding.

---

How Clinical Informatics Changes the Pre-Match Landscape

For an MD graduate focused on a general specialty (e.g., internal medicine) with an informatics interest, you’re not just choosing a place to train clinically—you’re choosing your informatics ecosystem.

Signals Programs Look For in an Informatics-Oriented Applicant

When you highlight your direction, programs with strong informatics offerings may look for:

• Evidence of durable interest

  • More than a single elective—projects, posters, publications, or leadership in health IT committees

• Ability to bridge clinical and technical worlds

  • You don’t have to be a software engineer, but showing comfort with data, workflows, and systems is valuable

• Professionalism and clarity in communication

  • Critical in informatics roles where you will negotiate between clinicians, IT, administration, and vendors

Your pre-match communication is effectively the first informatics “project” they see: Are you clear, concise, collaborative, and honest?

Leveraging Conferences and Networks

Clinical informatics is a field where networking matters:

• AMIA (American Medical Informatics Association) and other conferences
• Local hospital IT or data science collaboration groups
• Faculty who serve on national committees or EHR vendor advisory panels

When you meet potential program leaders in these spaces, take the same disciplined approach:

• Be transparent that you’re in the application or pre-match phase.
• Avoid conversations that could seem like back-channel rank negotiations.
• Focus on informational discussions: “What types of informatics projects do residents get involved in at your institution?”

If someone follows up by email, you can summarize your interest and, later, mention that you applied or interviewed, but keep the discussion informational and professional.

Positioning Yourself for a Clinical Informatics Fellowship

Even if you won’t apply to a clinical informatics fellowship until after or near the end of residency, your pre-match communication for residency can:

• Put you on the radar of informatics faculty early
• Help you identify programs with internal fellowship opportunities
• Highlight your long-term trajectory to leaders who value continuity

Programs often appreciate applicants who have a clear plan:

• “I want to develop a solid foundation in internal medicine and hospital operations during residency, while contributing to EHR and data projects, and then pursue a clinical informatics fellowship to prepare for a career as a CMIO or similar leadership role.”

This gives context to your interest and justifies your questions about health IT training, analytics infrastructure, and informatics curricula.

---

FAQs: Pre-Match Communication for MD Graduates in Clinical Informatics

1. Should I tell a program they’re my #1 choice if I’m not 100% sure yet?
No. Only tell a program they are your #1 if you are fully committed to ranking them first. In a tight-knit field like clinical informatics, misrepresenting your intentions can damage trust. If you’re very interested but undecided, say, “I plan to rank your program very highly” or “You are one of my top choices, especially because of your informatics opportunities.”

2. Is it okay to email a program about my clinical informatics interests before I get an interview invite?
Usually you should avoid “cold” emails solely to restate your application, unless:

• You have a genuine pre-existing connection (sub-internship, research collaboration, shared mentor), or
• The program openly invites contact from informatics-focused applicants.

If you do reach out, be brief, clearly reference your prior relationship or a specific posted interest in informatics, and avoid sounding like you’re lobbying for an invite.

3. Can I negotiate a pre-match offer for residency if I’m very strong in clinical informatics?
If the residency program participates in the NRMP Match, traditional pre-match offers are usually not allowed. Some non-NRMP tracks or institutions may have pre-match options, but these should be transparent, formal, and compliant with ethical guidelines. Never assume that strong qualifications justify trying to bypass the match. Instead, use your informatics background to strengthen your interview performance and communication.

4. How much should I emphasize clinical informatics versus core clinical training in my communications?
Programs want residents who are excellent clinicians first. Emphasize both:

• Make clear that you value robust clinical training and patient care.
• Then layer in how informatics will help you improve care quality, efficiency, and safety.

Balanced language might sound like: “My priority is to become an outstanding internist, and I see clinical informatics as a powerful way to extend that clinical impact at the system level.”

---

Thoughtful, ethical pre-match communication is one of your most powerful tools as an MD graduate targeting a residency that supports your clinical informatics ambitions. Use it to show programs who you are, what you bring, and how seriously you take both clinical excellence and health IT training—without ever stepping outside the boundaries of the Match.