Mastering Pre-Match Communication for US Citizen IMGs in Internal Medicine

Understanding Pre-Match Communication as a US Citizen IMG in Internal Medicine

For a US citizen IMG (American studying abroad), pre-match communication can be one of the most confusing—and important—parts of the internal medicine residency journey. You may hear terms like pre-match offers, early commitment, love letters, or program communication before match and not know what is appropriate, ethical, or strategically smart.

This article walks you step-by-step through:

• What pre-match communication actually is (and what it is not)
• How US citizen IMGs fit into the current IM match ecosystem
• How to handle emails, calls, and signaling interest without violating NRMP rules
• What to do if you receive a pre-match style “commitment” request
• Templates and practical phrases you can use right away
• How to avoid common mistakes that can harm your internal medicine residency prospects

The focus is specifically on internal medicine residency and on the realities for American citizens studying abroad.

---

1. The Landscape: Pre-Match, NRMP Rules, and US Citizen IMGs

1.1 What “Pre-Match” Means in 2025 and Beyond

Historically, many programs—especially in certain states—offered pre-match positions outside the NRMP Match. While some non-NRMP positions still exist, most ACGME-accredited internal medicine residency programs now fill through the NRMP Match.

When people say “pre-match” now, they usually mean:

• Pre-match communication: emails, calls, or letters between applicants and programs after the interview but before rank list submission.
• Pre-match offers or early commitment pressure: a program hinting or stating that if you rank them first, they will rank you highly, or trying to get you to declare a commitment before Match Day.

The NRMP calls this the “quiet period” of the Match and has clear rules about what is and isn’t allowed.

1.2 Key NRMP Rules You Must Know

You are expected to follow NRMP policies even as a US citizen IMG. The most relevant points:

• No binding commitments before the Match

  • You cannot promise to accept a position outside the Match if the program participates in the NRMP.
  • Programs cannot ask you to make a binding or verbal contract.

• You may express interest and intentions

  • You may tell a program that you plan to rank them highly or even first.
  • Programs may tell you that you are “ranked to match” or that they are “very interested.”
  • But nothing is binding until the Match results.

• No solicitation of ranking information

  • Programs should not ask you, “Where are you ranking us?”
  • Applicants should not ask programs, “Where am I on your list?”
  • You may voluntarily share your ranking intentions, but neither side should pressure the other.

• Misrepresentation is prohibited

  • You must not lie about how you plan to rank programs.
  • Programs must not mislead applicants about rank status.

Understanding these rules protects you if you face uncomfortable or aggressive pre-match communication.

1.3 Why Pre-Match Communication Matters for US Citizen IMGs

As a US citizen IMG (American studying abroad), your profile is often viewed differently than both US MD/DO and non-US IMGs:

• Many internal medicine programs value US citizenship because it avoids visa hurdles.
• Some still apply IMG filters (minimum scores, graduation year, US clinical experience).
• Programs might perceive you as a reliable, flexible candidate who is more likely to accept an offer.

Because of that, you may receive:

• More personalized emails after interviews.
• Strong hints that “we’d love to have you here.”
• Sometimes explicit or implicit pre-match style “commitment” requests (even if not formally called that).

Knowing how to handle this can significantly improve your chances of a successful IM match while keeping your integrity and compliance with NRMP rules.

---

2. Types of Pre-Match Communication You’ll Encounter

2.1 Routine, Appropriate Communication

These are normal and acceptable:

• Thank-you emails from you to interviewers or PDs
• Informational follow-ups from programs
  e.g., “Attached is a brochure about our city,” or “Here’s a list of our electives.”
• Logistical updates
  e.g., “We’ve added a second Q&A session with current residents.”
• General interest messages
  e.g., “We enjoyed meeting you and believe you would be a great fit for our program.”

These are safe and expected. They don’t imply ranking commitments.

2.2 Interest Signaling from Programs

Common phrases:

• “You are a strong candidate for our internal medicine residency.”
• “We believe you would be a good fit and hope to see you here next year.”
• “We will rank you highly.”
• “We think you are very competitive to match with us.”

These messages are not binding, but they’re usually genuine signals that:

• You’re on their rank list.
• You fit the kind of US citizen IMG they like: usually good USMLE scores, strong US clinical experience, good communication skills.

You can respond positively without making any binding promise.

2.3 Soft Pressure or “Code Language” for Early Commitment

Some programs may dance close to the line with NRMP rules, especially in IM programs that rely heavily on IMGs. Examples:

• “If you rank us number one, we are confident we will match.”
• “We’re only ranking candidates who are committed to us.”
• “We want to know if we can count on you ranking us first.”
• “Our program values loyalty; applicants who commit to us tend to be ranked to match.”

These are soft pressure tactics. They’re trying to:

• Predict their own match list security.
• Avoid going too far down their rank list.
• Secure reliable residents early, especially for less competitive or underserved locations.

As a US citizen IMG, you may be targeted with these messages because you are both eligible (citizen) and perceived as under more pressure to secure a position.

You must answer carefully and ethically, as discussed later.

2.4 Explicit, Inappropriate Pre-Match or Contract Requests

Much rarer in fully NRMP-participating IM programs, but important to recognize:

• “If you verbally commit to us now, we will withdraw from the Match for you.”
• “We want a written statement that you will rank us first and withdraw other applications.”
• “We need you to confirm that you will decline any other interview offers.”

These cross into NRMP violation territory, especially if the program participates in the Match. If this happens, you need a strategy (see Section 5).

---

3. Your Strategy: How to Communicate Before the Match

3.1 Principles for US Citizen IMGs

As an American studying abroad, you bring advantages to many internal medicine programs—especially:

• US citizenship (no visa costs or risk)
• Often strong English fluency and familiarity with US culture
• Willingness to live in smaller or community-based locations

Your communication strategy should:

1. Demonstrate professionalism and maturity
   Many PDs worry about how IMGs will communicate with patients and staff. Polished emails and clear, concise communication reassure them.

2. Express genuine interest—but avoid desperation
   Strong interest is a plus; sounding desperate can be a red flag.

3. Stay consistent with NRMP rules and personal integrity
   Never give promises you cannot keep just to “win” a spot.

4. Be targeted, not spammy
   Focus on programs where you’ve interviewed and realistically would be happy to train.

3.2 Pre-Interview and Interview-Week Communication

Most “pre-match communication” really starts during the interview process:

• Before your interview

  • Only logistical emails are expected (confirming date, asking about time zones or virtual links).
  • Do not send “please invite me” emails expecting invitations at this late stage—these usually have low yield.

• During the interview and social events

  • Make sure your verbal communication is clear, respectful, and concise.
  • When PDs or faculty ask, “Where do you see yourself training?” or “What are you looking for in a program?” answer with focus on your priorities, not ranking games.

• Immediately after the interview

  • A short thank-you email to the PD or PC is appropriate.
  • If a particular interviewer seemed especially invested in your story, a brief note to them is also acceptable.

Example post-interview thank-you email (US citizen IMG, IM):

Subject: Thank you for the opportunity to interview

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

Thank you for the opportunity to interview with the [Program Name] Internal Medicine Residency Program on [date]. As a US citizen IMG with a strong interest in [community-based care/academic internal medicine/hospitalist medicine], I appreciated learning about your program’s emphasis on [specific strengths—mentorship, diverse pathology, research, etc.].

The welcoming environment from your residents and faculty reaffirmed my interest in training at [Hospital/Program Name]. I would be honored to continue my medical training in internal medicine at your institution.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
AAMC ID: [#######]

3.3 Post-Interview Communication: How Much Is Enough?

As a rule:

• One thank-you note per program is sufficient.
• A second, concise follow-up later in the season can be useful if:
  • The program is genuinely one of your top choices.
  • You have meaningful updates (new publication, USCE, Step 3 passed).

Example follow-up email (non-committal but strong interest):

Subject: Continued interest in [Program Name] Internal Medicine

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I hope you are well. I wanted to express my continued strong interest in the [Program Name] Internal Medicine Residency Program. Since my interview on [date], I have reflected on how well your program aligns with my goals as a US citizen IMG interested in [primary care, hospital medicine, cardiology, etc.].

Since we last spoke, I have [brief update: submitted a manuscript, begun a sub-internship in US internal medicine, passed Step 3, etc.]. This experience has further strengthened my commitment to a career in internal medicine within the US healthcare system.

Thank you again for considering my application.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
AAMC ID: [#######]

---

4. Expressing Interest vs. Early Commitment: What You Should Say

4.1 When a Program Is Truly Your First Choice

If a program is clearly your top choice for internal medicine, you may ethically communicate that—once you are confident in your decision.

Appropriate language:

• “Your program is my top choice for residency.”
• “I intend to rank [Program Name] first on my rank order list.”
• “If I match at [Program Name], I would be thrilled to begin my internal medicine training with you.”

Example “first-choice” email (ethical and clear):

Subject: My strong interest in [Program Name] Internal Medicine

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I hope this message finds you well. After completing all of my interviews and carefully considering what I value most in a training environment, I have decided that the [Program Name] Internal Medicine Residency Program is my top choice.

I plan to rank [Program Name] first on my rank order list. The combination of your program’s [specific strengths], supportive faculty, and strong preparation for [primary care/hospitalist fellowship/academic careers] makes it the best fit for me as a US citizen IMG eager to build a long-term career in the United States.

I understand that the Match process is binding and that neither of us can make guarantees, but I wanted to be transparent about my genuine interest and enthusiasm for joining your team.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
AAMC ID: [#######]

This message:

• Respects NRMP rules.
• States clear intent (ranking them first).
• Does not demand any reciprocal ranking information.

4.2 When a Program Is One of Your Top Choices (But Not Clearly #1)

If you have several programs you genuinely like, you are allowed to express that they are “among your top choices” without specifying rank:

• “Your program remains one of my top choices.”
• “I will be ranking your program highly.”
• “I would be delighted to match here and could see myself thriving under your training.”

Avoid sending conflicting “you are my #1” messages to multiple programs; that can be misleading and unethical.

Example: “Top choices” email:

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

I wanted to thank you again for the opportunity to interview at the [Program Name] Internal Medicine Residency Program. I was especially impressed by [specific detail—resident camaraderie, morning report structure, ICU training, etc.].

As the ranking period approaches, I remain very interested in your program and plan to rank it highly. I believe that your training environment would be an excellent fit for my goals as a US citizen IMG committed to a career in internal medicine in the United States.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
AAMC ID: [#######]

4.3 How Often Should You Email?

To avoid appearing pushy:

• 1–2 total emails to a given program after interview season is usually enough.
• Avoid mass, copy-paste emails; personalize them authentically.
• Do not email weekly or repeatedly ask, “Where am I on your list?”

---

5. Handling Pressure, Pre-Match Offers, and Awkward Requests

5.1 When a Program Asks: “Will You Rank Us First?”

This is not ideal behavior on their part, but it happens. Your response strategy:

1. Stay polite and appreciative.
2. Avoid making promises you are not ready to keep.
3. Use language that emphasizes strong interest without explicitly committing (unless you truly want to).

Possible verbal response (phone call or Zoom):

“I’m very impressed by your program and could absolutely see myself training here. I plan to rank your program highly, but I want to finalize my list after considering all interviews. I really appreciate your interest in me.”

Possible email response:

Dear Dr. [Last Name],

Thank you for your message and for your continued interest in my application. I was very impressed with [Program Name] and am strongly considering your program among my top choices.

I understand the importance of the Match process and plan to finalize my rank list after carefully reviewing all programs where I interviewed. I can assure you that your program will be ranked highly, as I believe it offers excellent training in internal medicine and aligns well with my career goals as a US citizen IMG.

Thank you again for your support and consideration.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]

You have:

• Expressed genuine enthusiasm.
• Avoided a binding promise.
• Remained ethical and NRMP-compliant.

5.2 When a Program Hints at Pre-Match Offers or Early Commitment

You might hear:

• “We reserve spots for applicants who commit early.”
• “We’re trying to make sure we don’t go far down our list.”

If the program is in the NRMP, these statements are questionable. Steps:

1. Clarify gently

   “Just to confirm, all positions will be filled through the NRMP Match, correct?”

2. If they say “yes”:

   • No true “pre-match offer” exists.
   • Everything is non-binding signaling.

3. If they say “no, we may offer outside the Match”:

   • Ask for written details.
   • Check whether they are ACGME-accredited but not in NRMP for that track.
   • Consider carefully how this aligns with your goals and risk tolerance.

As a US citizen IMG, early offers outside the Match often come from:

• Smaller or community internal medicine programs.
• Hospitals in less popular geographic areas.

They may be attractive if your CV is borderline, but you lose the protective structure of the Match.

5.3 True Pre-Match Positions (Non-NRMP Programs)

In rare cases, you may have an opportunity for a non-NRMP internal medicine position:

• Make sure the program is ACGME-accredited.
• Ask whether the position is:
  • Categorical vs. preliminary
  • GME-funded
  • Eligible for board certification in internal medicine

If you are comfortable:

• You can sign a contract before the NRMP rank deadline.
• If you sign such a contract, you must withdraw from the NRMP Match to avoid violation.

This is usually a backup path, not the default, for most US citizen IMGs.

5.4 If You Feel Pressured or See Possible NRMP Violations

If a program crosses lines—for example:

• Demanding a written rank promise
• Threatening not to rank you unless you commit
• Offering financial incentives conditional on ranking behavior

You can:

1. Keep all communication professional and non-committal.
2. Preserve written records (emails, message screenshots).
3. Consider contacting the NRMP only if there’s clear, serious misconduct and you are ready to escalate.

Reporting is a serious step; many applicants choose not to, but you should know it is an option.

---

6. Practical Tips and Common Mistakes to Avoid

6.1 Practical Tips for US Citizen IMGs in Internal Medicine

1. Track all communication

   • Simple spreadsheet: Program, date, contact (PD, PC), type of message, main points.
   • Helps you avoid duplicate or inconsistent messages.

2. Personalize your emails

   • Reference a specific aspect of the program: morning report, resident wellness, alumni outcomes.
   • Show that you remember details and genuinely engaged.

3. Leverage your advantages as a US citizen IMG

   • Subtly highlight:
     • No visa needed.
     • Commitment to living and working in the US long-term.
     • Experience or ties to underserved US communities, if applicable.

4. Polish your written communication

   • No grammar errors, texting abbreviations, or informal tone.
   • Use professional salutations and signatures.

5. Stay honest with yourself and with programs

   • Don’t call three different programs your “number one.”
   • You may say “top choice” to a few, but “I will rank you first” should be reserved for one.

6.2 Common Mistakes That Hurt IM Match Chances

1. Over-emailing or appearing desperate

   • Daily or weekly messages.
   • Asking repeatedly: “What are my chances?” or “Where am I ranked?”

2. Being vague when you are actually committed

   • If you are truly certain a program is your first choice, considerate PDs appreciate clarity—within NRMP rules.

3. Ignoring updates that could matter

   • If you pass Step 3, finish an IM sub-internship, or publish a paper, tell programs concisely.

4. Unprofessional tone or formatting

   • Unclear subject lines.
   • Casual phrases or slang.

5. Not understanding the difference between interest and commitment

   • You are allowed to show enthusiasm.
   • You are not allowed to make or demand guarantees.

---

FAQs: Pre-Match Communication for US Citizen IMGs in Internal Medicine

1. As a US citizen IMG, do I have to send “love letters” to match into internal medicine?

No. Many applicants match into internal medicine without sending any post-interview letters. However, well-crafted, limited communication can help solidify interest and keep you on a program’s radar, especially in mid-tier and IMG-friendly programs. It is a bonus, not a requirement.

2. Can I tell more than one internal medicine program that they are my “number one”?

You can, but you shouldn’t. Telling multiple programs they are your “first choice” or “ranked #1” is misleading and conflicts with the ethical spirit of the Match. It’s acceptable to tell several programs that they are “among your top choices” or that you “will rank them highly,” but reserve “I will rank you first” for one program.

3. What should I do if a program asks me directly, “Where are you ranking us?”

You are not required to answer. You can respond:

“I’m still finalizing my rank list, but I have a very strong interest in your program and plan to rank it highly.”

This keeps you NRMP-compliant, honest, and professional, without surrendering your autonomy.

4. Are pre-match offers still common in internal medicine?

Formal pre-match outside the NRMP is now uncommon among ACGME-accredited categorical internal medicine programs. Most IM positions go through the NRMP Match. You may still encounter aggressive pre-match communication or “early commitment” pressure, but these are usually non-binding and must remain within NRMP rules for NRMP-participating programs. Always verify whether a program is participating in the Match for the track you’re considering.

---

By understanding how pre-match communication works—and how to handle it confidently—you, as a US citizen IMG, can navigate the internal medicine residency application process with clarity, integrity, and strategy.