Essential Questions Caribbean IMGs Should Ask for Preliminary Medicine Residency

Preparing smart, targeted questions to ask residency programs is one of the most underrated parts of interview season—especially if you’re a Caribbean IMG aiming for a Preliminary Medicine (Prelim IM) year. The questions you ask can:

• Signal that you understand the unique nature of a prelim year
• Show that you’ve done your homework on the program
• Help you decide if this is a place where you can succeed and be supported
• Clarify how this prelim year will fit into your long‑term specialty goals

This article is written specifically for Caribbean medical school residency applicants targeting Preliminary Medicine positions. You’ll find:

• Strategic frameworks for what to ask (and why)
• Tailored example questions for different people (PDs, residents, coordinators)
• Special considerations for SGU and other Caribbean IMGs
• Practical advice on how to ask questions professionally

---

Understanding Your Goals as a Caribbean IMG in a Preliminary Medicine Year

Before you decide what questions to ask residency programs, you need to be clear on what you’re actually trying to find out. As a Caribbean IMG going into a prelim IM year, your priorities may differ from categorical applicants.

Common Goals for Caribbean IMGs in Prelim Medicine

Most Caribbean IMGs seeking a preliminary medicine year are trying to:

1. Secure a strong clinical foundation

   • Build solid internal medicine skills that will serve you in any specialty.
   • Gain comfort managing complex inpatients in the U.S. system.

2. Position yourself for your ultimate specialty

   • Anesthesiology, Neurology, Radiology, PM&R, Dermatology, Ophthalmology, etc. often require or favor a prelim IM year.
   • You may already have an advanced spot, or you may be using the prelim year to strengthen your application.

3. Overcome common Caribbean IMG challenges

   • Possible Step score gaps, red flags, non‑US school perception.
   • Need for strong U.S. clinical experience and letters.

4. Avoid “toxic” or exploitative prelim years

   • Some programs see prelim residents as cheap labor with little investment in their growth.
   • You want a program that respects prelims, teaches them, and helps them reach their next step.

5. Maximize networking and mentorship opportunities

   • You’ll need advocates for future applications or fellowship.
   • You’ll want exposure to your target specialty if possible.

Your questions should be laser‑focused on whether a program helps or hurts these goals.

---

Core Question Themes Every Caribbean Prelim Applicant Should Cover

When planning your interview questions for them, think in themes, not just a random list. For a Caribbean IMG in Preliminary Medicine, the most important themes are:

1. Prelim vs. Categorical Experience
2. Education, Supervision, and Workload
3. Culture, Support, and Well‑being
4. Future Opportunities and Career Outcomes
5. IMG‑Friendliness and Caribbean Graduate Experience
6. Logistics (Schedules, Pay, Location, Contracts)

You won’t have time to ask everything in one session, so you’ll selectively choose from each theme depending on who you’re speaking with (PD vs resident vs coordinator).

---

High‑Impact Questions to Ask the Program Director (PD)

Program directors are the best people to address structure, philosophy, and outcomes. This is where you ask the highest‑level, big‑picture questions.

1. Questions About the Role and Value of Prelim Residents

Show that you understand the unique nature of a preliminary medicine year and want to be more than service labor.

Examples:

• “How would you describe the role of preliminary medicine residents in your program compared to categorical residents?”
• “What are some key differences in educational or clinical expectations between your prelim and categorical interns?”
• “How does your program ensure that preliminary residents are included in educational activities, not just clinical service needs?”

Why this matters:
You’re trying to learn whether prelims are treated as full members of the team or as expendable workhorses.

2. Questions About Year‑to‑Year Outcomes for Prelim Residents

As a Caribbean IMG, your career trajectory matters enormously. You need to know what happens after this year.

Examples:

• “Over the past few years, what have been the most common next steps for your preliminary medicine residents? For example, what specialties do they typically match into?”
• “Do you track where your prelim graduates go after their year here? Are there particular advanced specialties or programs where they’ve been especially successful?”
• “How has your program supported preliminary residents who needed to reapply or strengthen their application for their desired specialty?”

Look specifically for:

• Consistent placement into advanced specialties
• Transparency about Caribbean and other IMGs
• Willingness to share actual data, not vague assurances

3. Questions About Mentorship and Career Support

Prelim years can be isolating. A strong program will actively invest in your future.

Examples:

• “How do you approach mentorship for preliminary residents, particularly those applying or reapplying for advanced specialties?”
• “Are preliminary residents formally paired with faculty mentors, or is it more informal?”
• “How do you help prelims who are still deciding on a specialty versus those who are firmly committed to, say, anesthesiology or neurology?”

If you’re from SGU or another Caribbean school, you might also ask:

• “As a Caribbean IMG, I know mentorship and advocacy can be critical. How does your program help international graduates build connections and obtain strong letters of recommendation?”

This subtly flags your background and tests how IMG‑friendly they really are.

4. Questions About Education and Supervision

You want to ensure you’ll learn, not just survive.

Examples:

• “How do you structure supervision for interns on busy inpatient rotations? What is the typical level of attending and senior resident involvement?”
• “Can you describe how you provide feedback to preliminary residents during the year?”
• “Are prelims able to attend all the same didactics and noon conferences as categorical residents, or are there times when service demands take priority?”

Look for:

• Clear structure
• Protected educational time
• Fair inclusion of prelims in conferences and teaching

5. Questions to Ask Program Director About Workload and Well‑Being

You want to ask about workload without sounding lazy. Frame it around safety, learning, and sustainability.

Examples:

• “How do you monitor workload and burnout among interns, especially in demanding rotations like the ICU or night float?”
• “Have there been any recent changes to call structure or schedules based on resident feedback?”
• “How does your program respond when residents raise concerns about fatigue, safety, or workload?”

Programs that genuinely care about you will have concrete examples.

---

Smart Questions to Ask Current Residents (Especially Prelims)

Residents will give you the unfiltered reality. This is often where you get your most valuable answers.

When you think about what to ask residents, focus on daily life, culture, and practical realities—not things the PD just told you.

1. Questions About Daily Life as a Prelim Intern

You need to know exactly what your year will feel like.

Examples:

• “Can you walk me through a typical day on your busiest ward rotation as a prelim?”
• “Roughly how many patients are you responsible for on average? How does that change between day team and night float?”
• “Do you usually leave on time post‑call, or are you often staying late to finish notes or tasks?”

Follow‑up if they’re vague:
“Could you give a recent example of a week that felt particularly busy?”

2. Questions About How Prelims Are Treated Socially and Academically

You want to find out: Are prelims second‑class citizens?

Examples:

• “As a preliminary resident, do you feel included in the program socially and academically?”
• “Are there things that categorical interns have access to that prelims typically don’t—like certain electives, committees, or leadership roles?”
• “Do you feel the attendings and seniors know who the prelim residents are and invest in teaching them?”

Red flags:

• Residents hesitating, laughing nervously, or warning you that “it’s fine as long as you don’t expect too much.”

3. Questions About Caribbean and IMG Experience

As a Caribbean IMG, it’s crucial to know how similar residents have been treated.

Examples:

• “Are there many current or recent residents from Caribbean medical schools, like SGU or AUC? How have they done here?”
• “Have you noticed any differences in how international graduates are perceived or evaluated compared with U.S. grads?”
• “If you’re comfortable sharing, what challenges did you face as an IMG here, and how supportive was the program in helping you overcome them?”

If you are from SGU and the program has a track record:

• “I’ve seen some SGU residency match outcomes linking alumni with your program. Do you know how SGU grads have generally fared here in terms of support and next steps?”

This connects your Caribbean medical school residency background to their actual history.

4. Questions About Learning, Autonomy, and Safety

You want a balance of autonomy with backup—critical during your first U.S. postgraduate year.

Examples:

• “Do you feel like you get the right amount of autonomy as an intern? Are there situations where you feel unsafe or unsupported?”
• “How easy is it to reach a senior or attending when you’re unsure about a management decision?”
• “Looking back, do you feel this program has made you a stronger, more confident physician?”

Listen not just to words, but to tone and body language.

5. Questions About Applying/Reapplying During the Prelim Year

If you’re using this year to strengthen your application or if you don’t yet have an advanced spot, this is vital.

Examples:

• “How supportive has the program been of prelims who needed time off for interviews for their advanced specialty?”
• “Are prelims encouraged to take a light elective block during application season to accommodate interviews?”
• “Have you seen prelims successfully match into their desired specialty after doing a year here? What helped them the most?”

If your advanced spot is already secured, you might ask:

• “For those who already have an advanced position lined up, does the program coordinate with that specialty or help tailor electives?”

---

Questions for Coordinators and Support Staff

Program coordinators can be an amazing source of honest information about logistics, contracts, and visa/administrative issues—especially important for IMGs.

1. Questions About Contracts, Transition, and Logistics

Examples:

• “When are preliminary contract offers typically finalized, and what is the usual start date?”
• “How does onboarding work for prelims—are there special orientation sessions or bootcamps?”
• “Are there specific housing resources or neighborhood recommendations that past residents have found helpful?”

2. Questions About Visa and Documentation (If Applicable)

If you need a visa, ask directly and early.

Examples:

• “Do you sponsor visas for preliminary medicine residents, and if so, which types (J‑1, H‑1B)?”
• “Have Caribbean IMGs who required visas had any difficulties starting on time?”
• “Is there any difference in how you support visa‑requiring prelims versus categoricals?”

If the answer is vague, treat that as a warning sign.

---

Tailoring Questions to Caribbean IMGs and SGU Graduates

As a Caribbean IMG, you carry both unique challenges and unique strengths (adaptability, resilience, familiarity with high‑stakes testing). Your questions can quietly highlight both.

1. Addressing Perceptions About Caribbean Schools

You don’t need to be defensive, but you can be strategic.

Examples (for PDs or faculty):

• “Your program seems to have experience with international graduates. What qualities do you most value in successful IMGs in your program?”
• “Are there any specific gaps you commonly see in Caribbean graduates’ preparation that your program helps them close during the prelim year?”

Their answer tells you:

• Whether they’ve thought carefully about IMG training
• Whether they see you as teachable and capable, not a risk

2. Questions About Letters of Recommendation and Advocacy

You may need strong U.S. letters for your ultimate specialty.

Examples:

• “How often do your faculty write letters of recommendation for preliminary residents applying to advanced positions?”
• “Is there a process for helping prelims identify letter writers early in the year?”
• “Do you find that advanced programs or fellowships are receptive to letters from your attendings here?”

If they mention specific successes (e.g., “our prelims have matched anesthesia at X, neurology at Y”), that’s a strong sign.

3. Questions About How the Program Views a Prelim Year

You want to know whether they see this as:

• A serious training year, or
• Just a temporary workforce

Examples:

• “How do you measure success for a preliminary medicine resident by the end of the year?”
• “What qualities distinguish your most successful prelim graduates?”
• “Have any prelims transitioned into categorical positions within your program in past years?”

That last question is especially important if you’re open to converting to categorical IM down the line.

---

How to Ask Smart Questions Strategically (Not Just Recite a List)

Having a long list is helpful for preparation, but in the actual interview you should:

1. Prioritize 3–5 Key Questions for Each Person

For example:

• Program Director:

  • Role and treatment of prelims
  • Outcomes of prelim graduates
  • Mentorship and career support
  • Program philosophy on IMGs

• Residents:

  • Day‑to‑day workload and culture
  • Inclusion of prelims and IMGs
  • Real experience with support, burnout, and applications

• Coordinator:

  • Visas, logistics, start dates
  • Elective options and scheduling flexibility

2. Build on What They’ve Already Said

Instead of asking something they answered in their intro presentation, adapt your question:

• “You mentioned earlier that prelims rotate through the ICU. For a Caribbean IMG who’s new to U.S. clinical practice, how is support structured in that environment?”
• “You said many prelims match into advanced specialties afterward. Could you share examples from recent years or how the program helps them during application season?”

This shows you’re listening, not just reading from a script.

3. Avoid Questions You Could Easily Answer from the Website

For example, don’t ask:

• “Do you have an ICU rotation?” (if it’s clearly listed)
• “What EHR do you use?” (unless relevant to a larger point)

Instead, go deeper:

• “For the ICU rotation, how early in the year do prelims typically rotate there, and how is orientation handled for those without prior U.S. ICU exposure?”

4. Be Mindful of Tone

You can ask direct questions without sounding confrontational:

Instead of:

• “Do you overwork your prelims?”

Try:

• “How do you ensure that prelim residents have a manageable workload while still gaining the breadth of experience they need in a single year?”

---

Sample Question Bank: Pull‑and‑Use Phrases for Your Notebook

Here is a concise bank you can adapt for your interview questions for them, organized by theme. Choose the ones that fit you best.

Program Structure & Prelim Experience

• “How do preliminary medicine residents fit into the overall structure of your program?”
• “What do you see as the main strengths of your prelim year compared with other programs?”

Education & Supervision

• “What systems are in place to ensure that prelim residents receive regular feedback?”
• “Are there any specific teaching innovations or curricula you’re most proud of?”

Career Support & Outcomes

• “What has been the range of specialties your prelim graduates have entered in the last 3–5 years?”
• “How do you help prelims who are applying or reapplying during the year—for example, with letters, flexible rotations, or interview time?”

IMG / Caribbean‑Specific Questions

• “How have Caribbean or other international graduates historically done in your program?”
• “Are there any resources specifically aimed at helping IMGs adjust to U.S. hospital systems and documentation?”

Culture & Well‑Being

• “How would you describe the culture of the program, especially among interns?”
• “Can you share a recent example of resident feedback that led to a meaningful change?”

Logistics & Practical Matters

• “What does the night coverage system look like for preliminary residents?”
• “Are prelim rotations front‑loaded early in the year, or is the schedule evenly balanced?”

---

Putting It All Together: A Strategy for Caribbean IMGs on Interview Day

On each interview day:

1. Review the program website the night before and identify:

   • Unique features
   • Prelim structure
   • Evidence of IMG and Caribbean involvement

2. Select 8–10 priority questions adapted to that specific program.

3. During interviews:

   • Ask PDs about philosophy, outcomes, and career support.
   • Ask residents about daily life, culture, and how prelims/IMGs fare in reality.
   • Ask coordinators about visas and logistics if relevant.

4. Take brief notes right after each conversation:

   • How did they talk about prelims?
   • Did they mention Caribbean graduates (e.g., SGU, Ross, AUC) positively?
   • Do you feel you’d be supported, not exploited?

5. Use your notes later when building your rank list, especially to distinguish between multiple prelim IM options that may otherwise look similar on paper.

---

FAQs: Questions to Ask Programs for Caribbean IMG in Preliminary Medicine

1. How many questions should I ask in each residency interview session?
Aim for 2–3 thoughtful questions per interviewer. With a PD, you might ask 3–4; with residents in a group, you can ask 1–2 and listen to others. Quality and relevance matter more than quantity.

2. Are there any questions I should avoid as a Caribbean IMG?
Avoid questions that sound defensive (e.g., “Do you think Caribbean grads are as good as U.S. grads?”). Instead, frame them positively and constructively: “How have international or Caribbean graduates contributed to your program, and how do you support them?” Also avoid questions clearly answered on the website.

3. Should I ask directly about SGU residency match or specific Caribbean schools?
You can mention them strategically: “I’ve noticed that some SGU graduates have matched into your program. Do you have a sense of how they’ve done here and what paths they pursued afterward?” This shows you’ve done your research without making the conversation only about one school.

4. What’s the most important single question to ask about a prelim IM program?
If you have to pick just one, for a Caribbean IMG it might be:
“What have been the typical outcomes for your preliminary medicine residents over the last few years, and how does your program actively support them in reaching their next step?”
The answer to that question reveals a lot about how much the program truly values and invests in its prelims.

By preparing focused, thoughtful questions in advance—and tailoring them to your situation as a Caribbean IMG—you’ll gain the insight you need to choose the right Preliminary Medicine program and make your Caribbean medical school residency journey as successful and supported as possible.