Mastering SOAP for Residency Match Success: Essential Insights for Graduates

Introduction: Turning SOAP into a Strategic Second Chance

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is one of the most intense weeks of a medical graduate’s life. For those who do not initially match in the main NRMP Residency Match, SOAP can feel like a high‑pressure, last‑minute scramble. But it does not have to be chaotic or purely reactive.

When approached strategically, SOAP becomes a structured opportunity—a carefully designed system that connects unmatched applicants with unfilled residency positions. Understanding that structure, and preparing for it in advance, can turn a disappointing Match Day into a viable path forward in your medical career.

This guide is written specifically for medical graduates and senior medical students who may face SOAP. It will help you:

• Understand how SOAP works and who is eligible
• Prepare documents and strategy before Match Week
• Navigate the SOAP timeline and offer rounds efficiently
• Communicate effectively with programs and mentors
• Make smart decisions that align with your long‑term career strategy in medicine

Whether you are a first-time applicant or a reapplicant, use this as a step‑by‑step roadmap to navigate SOAP like a pro and protect your future in the Residency Match system.

---

Understanding SOAP in the Residency Match: Core Concepts

What Is SOAP and Why Does It Exist?

SOAP is a structured component of the NRMP Residency Match designed to fill unfilled residency positions with eligible unmatched or partially matched applicants. It replaces what used to be an informal, sometimes chaotic “Scramble.”

During Match Week, programs with unfilled positions and eligible unmatched applicants are brought together through a confidential, rules-based process. The goals are:

• To fill as many accredited residency positions as possible
• To provide unmatched applicants with a fair, organized “second chance”
• To protect both programs and applicants from undue pressure or disorganized communication

SOAP is not a separate match; it is an extension of the same residency application ecosystem involving NRMP and ERAS.

Who Is Eligible for SOAP?

Eligibility is determined and announced by NRMP shortly before Match Week. In general, you may be SOAP-eligible if:

• You registered for the NRMP Main Residency Match
• You are unmatched or partially matched (e.g., matched to an advanced position but not a preliminary year, or vice versa)
• You are not withdrawn or ineligible due to NRMP violations
• You have certified a rank order list (except certain special cases defined by NRMP)

You will receive an official status notification on Monday of Match Week:

• Fully Matched – not eligible for SOAP
• Partially Matched – may be eligible depending on your situation
• Unmatched – eligible if you meet NRMP criteria

Always verify eligibility details with NRMP and your Dean’s Office; policies can change slightly from year to year.

The SOAP Timeline: A High‑Intensity Week

While exact times vary annually, the SOAP process follows a predictable structure throughout Match Week:

1. Monday (Match Status Day)

   • You learn whether you are matched, partially matched, or unmatched.
   • Unfilled positions list becomes available in ERAS (only to eligible applicants and advisors).
   • You begin preparing and targeting applications immediately.

2. Application Period (Early–Mid Week)

   • Using ERAS, you can submit up to a capped number of applications (often 45) to SOAP-participating programs.
   • You cannot directly email or call programs unless they contact you first, per NRMP rules.

3. Interview & Evaluation Period

   • Programs review applications, conduct brief phone or virtual interviews, or send written questions.
   • Programs create preference lists for SOAP offers.

4. Offer Rounds (Multiple Rounds Over Two Days)

   • NRMP runs a series of SOAP offer rounds.
   • Applicants may receive offers through the system and have a short, defined time window (often 2 hours) to accept or reject.
   • Once you accept an offer, the process ends for you, and you are committed to that program.

5. Post‑SOAP

   • Any positions still unfilled after SOAP are released publicly and may be filled outside the NRMP process, but for most graduating seniors, SOAP is the primary structured route during Match Week.

Understanding this cadence helps you prepare resources, plan communications, and make decisions under time pressure.

---

Strategic Preparation for SOAP: Laying the Groundwork Early

Start Before Match Week: Proactive Career Strategy

The best time to prepare for SOAP is before you know you need it. Smart medical graduates treat SOAP preparedness as a standard part of residency application planning, not as an admission of failure.

By February or early March, you should:

• Have an updated, SOAP-ready CV
• Have adaptable versions of your personal statement
• Identify mentors willing to quickly update letters if necessary
• Review your exam scores, clinical performance, and specialty interests honestly

This proactive approach reduces panic and allows you to think strategically if you learn you are unmatched.

Researching SOAP Opportunities and Specialty Options

1. Understand Specialty Competitiveness

If you go into SOAP unmatched, you need rapid clarity on which specialties are realistic options:

• Historically SOAP-heavy specialties often include Internal Medicine (categorical and prelim), Family Medicine, Pediatrics, Psychiatry, Transitional Year, and preliminary Surgery or Medicine years.
• Highly competitive fields (e.g., Dermatology, Plastic Surgery, Neurosurgery, Orthopedics) rarely have significant SOAP positions.

Review NRMP’s annual data (Charting Outcomes, NRMP Results and Data) to see:

• Which specialties routinely have unfilled positions
• How US MDs, DOs, and IMGs perform in different fields
• Where your metrics (USMLE/COMLEX, clerkship grades, publications) fit relative to matched cohorts

This informs how broad and flexible you should be in SOAP.

2. Familiarize Yourself with the Unfilled List Structure

On Monday of Match Week, you will receive access (through ERAS) to the list of unfilled programs and positions. The list includes:

• Specialty and program type (categorical, preliminary, transitional, advanced)
• Program location and NRMP code
• Number of unfilled positions

Before Match Week, practice:

• Reviewing sample lists from prior years (if available from your Dean’s Office)
• Identifying which specialties and regions you would realistically consider
• Discussing potential backup specialties with advisors and mentors

Having a pre-defined “if SOAP, then consider X, Y, Z” list saves precious time.

Building a SOAP-Ready Application Package

1. Tailoring Your Curriculum Vitae (CV)

Your CV for SOAP should be:

• Up-to-date: Include all recent rotations, sub-internships, research, and volunteer work.
• Clear and organized: Use consistent headings (Education, Clinical Experience, Research, Leadership, Publications, Presentations).
• SOAP-focused: Emphasize strengths valuable to commonly available specialties, such as:
  • Continuity of care (for primary care fields)
  • Communication and teamwork skills
  • Procedural experiences (for prelim and surgical years)

Consider maintaining a master CV and then “lightly tailoring” it for primary care vs hospital-based programs.

2. Crafting Adaptable Personal Statements

Instead of a single, tightly specialized personal statement, create:

• A general clinical personal statement suitable for broad specialties such as Internal Medicine, Family Medicine, Pediatrics, or Psychiatry.
• A preliminary/transitional year statement focusing on your goals for a strong clinical foundation, procedural competence, and exposure to varied disciplines.
• If applicable, a brief addendum that addresses why you are participating in SOAP—keeping the tone forward-looking and professional, not apologetic.

Focus on:

• Concrete clinical experiences and patient stories
• Evidence of resilience, teachability, and professionalism
• Clear alignment between your goals and the specialty’s training

Avoid lengthy explanations or negativity about being unmatched; SOAP reviewers have limited time and prioritize fit and readiness.

3. Letters of Recommendation (LoRs) for SOAP

While you cannot change everything during Match Week, you can prepare ahead:

• Identify 2–3 strong clinical letter writers who:
  • Know you well
  • Can comment specifically on your work ethic, clinical skills, and teamwork
• Ask if they would be willing to update or slightly retarget letters quickly if you need to pivot specialties. Some may be able to remove specialty-specific language or refocus on general residency readiness.

If you anticipate a backup specialty (e.g., Family Medicine as backup for Internal Medicine or Surgery), try to have at least one letter relevant to that field.

Leveraging Your Network and Institutional Support

1. Use Your Dean’s Office and Career Advising

Most medical schools have:

• A SOAP support team or designated Dean for Student Affairs
• Access to the unfilled list and historical SOAP outcomes
• Templates, checklists, and sometimes dedicated physical or virtual “SOAP war rooms”

Ask specifically:

• Who will be available to you on Match Week, and how to reach them
• Whether they can reach out to program directors on your behalf (where appropriate and permitted)
• For honest feedback about realistic SOAP targets based on your record

2. Alumni and Resident Mentors

Graduates from your school who have:

• Gone through SOAP themselves
• Trained in your potential backup specialties
• Are current residents or chief residents

…can offer highly practical advice: which programs are supportive, how to frame your story, what to emphasize in brief SOAP interviews, and how to keep perspective during a stressful week.

---

Navigating the SOAP Process in Real Time: Execution Under Pressure

Treat SOAP Like a Full-Time Job

During Match Week, especially from Monday to Thursday, SOAP should be your primary professional focus. That means:

• Clearing your schedule of non-essential commitments
• Setting up a reliable workspace (good internet, quiet environment, backup devices or locations)
• Using a notebook or digital tracker to monitor:
  • Programs applied to
  • Contact attempts or interviews
  • Your impressions and priority level for each program

Think of yourself as a project manager for your own residency placement.

Application Strategy: Breadth, Depth, and Realism

With a limit on how many programs you can apply to via SOAP, you must balance:

• Breadth – applying to a range of specialties and locations to maximize chances
• Depth – applying to a reasonable number of programs within a given specialty or region
• Realism – targeting programs where your application is plausibly competitive

Example approach:

• 1–2 primary specialties (e.g., Internal Medicine and Family Medicine)
• 1–2 secondary options (e.g., Psychiatry, Pediatrics, Transitional Year, or prelim positions)
• Geographic flexibility unless you have immovable personal constraints

Aim to fill your application cap with programs where you would genuinely be willing to train, even if they are not ideal. SOAP is about securing a position and preserving your trajectory in medical education and residency training.

Communication Rules and Professionalism

During SOAP, there are strict NRMP rules:

• Applicants may not initiate contact with programs about SOAP positions unless invited.
• Programs may reach out to you for quick interviews or clarification.
• All offers must go through the NRMP SOAP system, not via private agreements.

If contacted:

• Respond promptly and professionally.
• Be ready with a concise “SOAP interview pitch”:
  • Who you are
  • Why you are interested in their specialty and program
  • What strengths you bring
  • How you have handled challenges (including not matching) constructively

Avoid asking directly for ranking or guarantees; focus on showing fit and readiness.

Flexibility and Open-Mindedness in Specialty and Location

Being unmatched is already a significant stressor. Insisting on a narrow specialty or geographic region during SOAP can dramatically reduce your options.

Consider:

• Fields you had some interest in but didn’t rank due to competitiveness or preference
• Preliminary or transitional positions that can keep you clinically active while you reapply for your dream specialty later
• Locations that are less competitive but may offer excellent training and mentorship

Many physicians ultimately flourish in specialties and locations that were not originally on their radar.

---

Evaluating and Accepting SOAP Offers: Making High-Stakes Decisions

Understanding SOAP Offers and Timing

During each SOAP offer round:

• You may receive zero, one, or multiple offers.
• Each offer comes with a short expiration window (often 2 hours).
• If you do not respond by the deadline, the offer expires.
• Once you accept an offer, you are automatically withdrawn from SOAP and committed to that program through the NRMP Match Participation Agreement.

Because of this compressed timeline, you should:

• Review your application list beforehand and rank programs in your own priority order.
• Discuss your preferences with trusted advisors so you are not making decisions in isolation.
• Be mentally prepared to make a binding commitment within a few hours.

Criteria to Evaluate SOAP Offers

When deciding whether to accept an offer, consider:

1. Accreditation and Program Stability

   • Is the program ACGME-accredited and in good standing?
   • Any known issues (probation, major instability) that you can verify?

2. Specialty Alignment and Future Options

   • Does this specialty fit your long-term or backup career strategy?
   • If it’s a preliminary or transitional year, will it support your goal to reapply in another field?

3. Clinical Training Environment

   • Variety and volume of cases
   • Level of supervision and teaching
   • Reputation for resident support and wellness

4. Location and Personal Circumstances

   • Cost of living, support systems, family constraints
   • Visa considerations for international medical graduates (IMGs)

5. Program Culture and Fit (as best you can tell)

   • Tone of communication during SOAP
   • Impressions from current residents, alumni, or your Dean’s Office

Remember: a SOAP position is still a competitive residency spot in medical education; many SOAP-accepted residents go on to fellowship training, leadership roles, and highly successful careers.

After Accepting an Offer: Transitioning Smoothly

Once you accept an offer:

1. Confirm Details Promptly

   • Expect formal communication from the program (welcome email, onboarding instructions).
   • Respond quickly, express appreciation, and confirm your understanding of start dates and next steps.

2. Update Key Stakeholders

   • Inform your Dean’s Office or medical school administration.
   • Thank mentors and letter writers who supported you.
   • If you had other pending conversations (e.g., with faculty advisors), close the loop.

3. Begin Residency Preparation

   • Ask the program:
     • If there is a recommended reading list
     • What EMR system they use
     • Key logistics (housing, orientation dates, licensing paperwork)
   • Connect with current residents, especially interns, to learn about:
     • Call schedules and workflow
     • Tips for succeeding in that specific environment

The sooner you mentally pivot from “SOAP stress” to “internship readiness,” the better you will feel and perform.

---

Long-Term Perspective: SOAP, Resilience, and Career Growth

Participating in SOAP can feel like a setback, but in the broader context of a 30–40-year medical career, it is one intense week in a long journey.

Keep in mind:

• Many outstanding physicians—including fellowship-trained subspecialists and academic leaders—either matched via SOAP, re-applied after a preliminary year, or pivoted specialties mid-career.
• SOAP tests your resilience, adaptability, and professionalism—traits that are invaluable in clinical practice.
• What matters most is not that you used SOAP, but how you handle it, what you learn, and how you move forward.

Focus on:

• Building strong clinical foundations wherever you train
• Cultivating mentors in your program and specialty
• Continuing scholarly activity and professional development

SOAP is not the end of your ideal career path; it is one of several possible routes to it.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About SOAP and the Residency Match

1. What are the most common mistakes applicants make during SOAP?

Common missteps include:

• Waiting until Match Week to prepare CVs, personal statements, and letters
• Applying too narrowly, both in specialty and geography, severely limiting options
• Violating communication rules by contacting programs inappropriately, which can harm your reputation
• Letting emotions drive decisions, such as rejecting a reasonable offer in hopes of a “perfect” one that may never arrive
• Failing to seek honest feedback from advisors about realistic specialties and program tiers

Planning early, being flexible, and following NRMP rules mitigate most of these risks.

2. How can I stay organized and manage stress during SOAP?

To stay organized:

• Use a spreadsheet or project management tool to track programs, application status, and any communication.
• Have a written daily plan during Match Week (research, application review, interview prep, debrief).
• Appoint a support person (mentor, advisor, trusted friend) to help you process decisions calmly.

To manage stress:

• Maintain regular meals, short breaks, and sleep as much as possible.
• Limit doom-scrolling on social media and focus on actionable tasks.
• Remind yourself that many physicians have taken nonlinear paths and still built excellent careers.

3. What should I do if I didn’t match and have a weaker application (low scores, gaps, etc.)?

If your application is less competitive:

• During SOAP, highlight your strengths: strong clinical evaluations, communication skills, leadership, or unique experiences.
• Focus on specialties and programs that value holistic review and have historically accepted a broad range of applicants.
• Engage your Dean’s Office to advocate for you where appropriate.

If you still do not secure a position after SOAP:

• Meet with advisors to create a 12–24 month remediation and reapplication plan, which may include:
  • Additional clinical experience (research fellowships, observerships, preliminary years later, etc.)
  • Improved board scores if eligible to retake
  • New letters of recommendation and scholarly work

4. Can I apply to programs or specialties outside of my original preferences during SOAP?

Yes—and in many cases, you should. SOAP is a chance to broaden your options:

• You can apply to any participating programs for which you meet eligibility criteria, regardless of what you ranked originally.
• Many applicants successfully enter a different specialty through SOAP and later discover it suits them well.
• Others use a preliminary or transitional year obtained via SOAP as a platform to re-enter the Match in their primary field with stronger experience.

Just be honest with yourself and with programs about your interests and long-term goals.

5. How quickly must I respond to a SOAP offer, and can I hold multiple offers?

You cannot hold multiple offers:

• During a SOAP offer round, if you receive an offer, you typically have a short, defined timeframe (often around 2 hours) to accept or reject it.
• If you do not respond in time, the offer expires and moves to another applicant.
• Once you accept an offer, you are committed to that program and no longer participate in further SOAP rounds.

This is why having a pre-ranked personal list of programs and discussing your decision thresholds with advisors before offer rounds begin is crucial.

---

By approaching SOAP with preparation, flexibility, and a clear strategy, you transform a stressful contingency into a powerful tool in your residency and medical education journey. Even if your path looks different from what you initially imagined, you can still build a fulfilling, impactful career in medicine.