Conquer SOAP: Inspiring Success Stories of Medical Graduates

Real Stories, Real Success: How These Graduates Conquered SOAP and Found Their Match

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is one of the most intense weeks in a medical graduate’s journey. For unmatched applicants, it can feel like everything is on the line: years of training, enormous debt, and dreams of a medical career. But SOAP is not just about salvaging a bad situation—it is a structured, strategic opportunity to secure a residency position and reset your trajectory.

This article shares real-world–inspired success stories of medical graduates who entered SOAP discouraged and uncertain, yet emerged with residency positions that aligned with their long-term goals. Along the way, you’ll find detailed strategies, concrete examples, and practical career strategies you can apply to your own SOAP experience.

Whether you are an unmatched US medical graduate, an international medical graduate (IMG), or a reapplicant, these success stories and lessons will help you approach SOAP with clarity, confidence, and a realistic plan for success.

---

Understanding the SOAP Process: Foundations for Success

A key theme in every SOAP success story is this: those who understood the process, came prepared, and stayed organized had a significant advantage.

What Is SOAP and Why Does It Matter?

SOAP is an NRMP-managed process that allows eligible unmatched or partially matched applicants to apply for and accept unfilled residency positions after the main Match algorithm runs. It is not a free-for-all scramble; it is a structured, time-sensitive sequence with clear rules and deadlines.

SOAP is especially important for:

• US MD and DO graduates who did not match but want to start residency the same year.
• International medical graduates seeking a foothold into US graduate medical education.
• Reapplicants who have refined their applications and are determined to enter residency.

For many, SOAP becomes the turning point—where an initial setback transforms into a real success story and a sustainable medical career.

Core Components of the SOAP Process

Understanding the mechanics of SOAP is critical before you can strategize.

1. SOAP Eligibility

You may be SOAP-eligible if:

• You registered for the NRMP Main Residency Match.
• You are unmatched or partially matched after the main Match algorithm.
• You are eligible for US GME (e.g., ECFMG certification for IMGs).
• NRMP designates you as SOAP-eligible when the Match status is released on Monday of Match Week.

Eligible applicants can:

• See the list of unfilled positions.
• Apply to those positions through ERAS during SOAP.
• Receive and accept offers only through NRMP’s official system.

2. Compressed Application Timeline

SOAP is fast and structured into multiple offer rounds:

• Monday (Match Week): You learn you are unmatched or partially matched. The list of unfilled positions is released. You can begin preparing and submitting applications through ERAS.
• Tuesday–Thursday: Programs review applications, conduct quick virtual interviews or phone calls, and submit their lists of ranked applicants.
• Offer Rounds (usually four): NRMP sends out offers in cycles. Applicants must accept or reject offers in a very short time frame (often just a couple of hours).
• End of Thursday: SOAP concludes. Any remaining unfilled positions enter the post-SOAP period, where communication rules differ.

This timeline means you must have your materials, mindset, and support system ready before SOAP begins.

3. Using ERAS and NRMP Strategically

During SOAP, you:

• Submit applications via ERAS to a limited number of programs (NRMP sets caps).
• Cannot directly contact programs unless they reach out first (strict communication rules apply).
• Respond to offers exclusively through NRMP’s system; accepting an offer is binding.

Those who succeed in SOAP:

• Know the rules thoroughly.
• Prepare materials in advance.
• Have a realistic list of targets aligned with their profiles and scores.

---

Success Stories from Graduate SOAP Candidates: How They Turned Setbacks into Wins

Below are three composite, realistic case stories based on common SOAP success patterns. Each graduate faced different obstacles—IMG status, low scores, or application gaps—but all ultimately secured a residency through strategic action.

---

1. Maria’s Relentless Pursuit of Residency: An IMG’s SOAP Victory

Maria, an international medical graduate, had strong clinical skills, solid letters of recommendation, and strong evaluations from US clinical experiences—but she did not match during the main cycle. The news on Monday of Match Week was devastating.

Instead of shutting down emotionally, she treated SOAP as an intensive, one-week “second application cycle.”

Maria’s SOAP Strategy and Actions

Early and Thorough Preparation

Maria had anticipated the possibility of not matching in this competitive landscape, so she:

• Updated her CV monthly throughout 4th year and post-graduation.
• Maintained multiple versions of her personal statement (e.g., for Family Medicine, Internal Medicine).
• Requested SOAP-specific letters of recommendation early, asking writers to emphasize adaptability, teamwork, and readiness to start residency immediately.
• Ensured all ECFMG and visa-related documents were complete, so programs would not see administrative barriers.

Smart Program Research

Well before Match Week, she:

• Created a spreadsheet of community and university-affiliated programs that historically considered IMGs.
• Flagged programs with previous SOAP participation.
• Noted program characteristics (geography, visa sponsorship, patient population) and how they aligned with her experience and language skills.

Leveraging Faculty and Alumni Networks

Maria reached out to:

• Attendings from her US clinical rotations.
• Her medical school alumni who matched into US residency, especially in primary care specialties.
• IMGs from her country currently in US training.

She respectfully asked:

• “If your program participates in SOAP, may I list you as someone who can speak to my work ethic if your PD wants quick feedback?”
• “Are there programs that you know tend to consider IMGs during SOAP?”

These connections didn’t guarantee offers, but they helped programs quickly validate her professionalism and commitment when time was short.

Flexibility in Specialty and Setting

Initially, Maria’s dream was Family Medicine at a large academic center. But for SOAP, she:

• Applied to a mix of Family Medicine and Internal Medicine positions.
• Considered more community-based programs, including those in rural areas and underserved regions.
• Prioritized earning a US residency position over holding out for a “perfect” setting that might not materialize.

Maria’s Outcome

During SOAP week, Maria received several quick phone/virtual interviews. Ultimately, she:

• Earned three interviews.
• Matched into a Family Medicine residency at a community hospital in an underserved area.

Once there, she excelled, later becoming chief resident and securing a fellowship in her subspecialty of interest. Her story illustrates that a flexible, prepared, and networked IMG can absolutely generate a SOAP success story and build a strong long-term career.

---

2. Daniel’s Innovative Approach: Turning Low Scores into a Transitional Year and Beyond

Daniel, a US MD graduate, was heavily focused on a highly competitive specialty and had applied narrowly. His USMLE Step scores were below the typical average for that specialty, and on Monday of Match Week he found himself unmatched.

He knew his test scores might be a concern for programs, but he refused to let them define his future.

Daniel’s SOAP Strategy and Actions

Expanding Specialty Options

During SOAP, Daniel:

• Immediately broadened his target scope beyond his initial specialty.
• Considered Internal Medicine prelim years, Transitional Year programs, and even categorical programs in less competitive fields.
• Prioritized programs that valued well-rounded applicants with strong clinical evaluations, communication skills, and leadership experiences.

Authentic Networking Through Social Media and Professional Platforms

Daniel was already active on:

• Twitter/X, following program directors, residents, and medical education accounts.
• LinkedIn and professional forums where physicians shared advice about the residency application process.

In the months leading up to Match:

• He engaged thoughtfully in discussions on professionalism, wellness, and evidence-based medicine.
• He shared reflections on rotations and quality improvement projects (never violating HIPAA).
• He built a recognizable, professional online presence.

During SOAP week:

• Some programs recognized his name or profile.
• One program reached out to him after noticing his participation in a discussion thread and seeing that he had applied via ERAS.

Rigorous Interview Preparation—Fast

Knowing SOAP interviews are often short and focused, Daniel:

• Conducted multiple mock interviews with classmates and mentors on Sunday and Monday nights.
• Focused on behavioral and “red flag” questions:
  • “Tell me about a time you struggled academically and how you handled it.”
  • “How have you worked to improve since your Step scores?”
  • “Why are you applying to our program specifically during SOAP?”
• Practiced communicating his story clearly: acknowledging his lower scores, highlighting his improvements, and emphasizing strong clinical performance and teamwork.

Daniel’s Outcome

Midweek during SOAP, Daniel:

• Received an interview invite from a Transitional Year program whose PD had seen his thoughtful contributions on social media.
• Performed well in the interview, framed his journey honestly, and highlighted his strong clinical evaluations and work ethic.
• Accepted an offer for a Transitional Year position.

During his Transitional Year, he:

• Built strong relationships with faculty.
• Improved his application with additional US-based clinical letters and research output.
• Successfully re-entered the Match for his intended specialty, ultimately securing a categorical position.

Daniel’s journey underscores how creative career strategies, professional networking, and transparent self-improvement can transform lower test scores into a stepping-stone rather than a dead end.

---

3. Celine’s Determined Reboot: From Disappointment to Psychiatry Match

Celine entered SOAP after an initially unsuccessful Match despite having strong grades, research experience, and leadership roles. She suspected her application lacked a clear narrative and that her materials did not fully convey her passion for her chosen specialty: psychiatry.

Instead of reacting with panic, she made SOAP the start of a deliberate, data-driven overhaul.

Celine’s SOAP Strategy and Actions

Honest, Structured Self-Assessment

Within 24 hours of learning she was unmatched, Celine:

• Reviewed her entire application portfolio with a trusted mentor.
• Identified gaps:
  • Personal statement was generic and didn’t highlight her specific interest in mental health advocacy.
  • Letters of recommendation were solid but not specialty-specific.
  • She had applied somewhat broadly across specialties, which diluted her apparent focus.
• Reflected on interview feedback from the main cycle to identify patterns (e.g., seeming “uncertain” about her long-term goals).

Targeted, Program-Specific Applications

For SOAP, Celine:

• Focused on psychiatry and a small number of closely related positions where her profile made sense.
• Tailored each personal statement to emphasize:
  • Her work with mental health advocacy groups.
  • Specific patient stories (de-identified) that shaped her interest.
  • Alignment with each program’s mission (e.g., community mental health, global psychiatry, integrated care).
• Mentioned program-specific features: research tracks, psychotherapy training, or underserved populations.

Maximizing Educational and Institutional Resources

Leading up to and during SOAP, Celine:

• Attended her medical school’s SOAP preparation workshops.
• Used career advising sessions to refine her elevator pitch and answer to “Why psychiatry?”
• Joined online SOAP webinars hosted by professional organizations and specialty societies.
• Practiced multiple rounds of mock interviews with faculty psychiatrists.

These efforts helped her deliver consistent, compelling messages during quick SOAP interviews.

Celine’s Outcome

Celine entered SOAP with a narrowed, refined focus and:

• Received interest from multiple psychiatry programs.
• Impressed interviewers with her clear narrative and evident dedication to mental health.
• Matched into a psychiatry residency program deeply aligned with her values and career goals.

Her case illustrates how reflective analysis, deliberate refinement, and targeted storytelling can transform a prior “near-miss” into a powerful SOAP success story.

---

Key Takeaways and Career Strategies from SOAP Success Stories

These real success stories reveal several recurring principles that can dramatically influence your chances of success in SOAP and beyond.

1. Preparation Is Non-Negotiable

The candidates who succeed in SOAP often started preparing before they knew whether they would match.

Actionable steps:

• Maintain an updated CV and draft specialty-specific personal statements during the regular application cycle.
• Identify mentors and letter writers early, letting them know you may need quick support if you enter SOAP.
• Understand SOAP rules, timelines, and ERAS limitations (e.g., application caps) in advance.

2. Networking and Relationships Truly Matter

Formal metrics (Step scores, grades) are critical, but human connections frequently open doors—especially when programs have only hours to decide whom to interview.

Strategies:

• Cultivate professional relationships with attendings, residents, and program coordinators during your rotations.
• Stay in contact with alumni, especially those with similar backgrounds (e.g., IMGs, non-traditional students).
• Use professional social media responsibly to engage in medical education conversations and showcase your professionalism.

3. Flexibility in Specialty and Geographic Choices Creates Opportunity

Being rigid about specialty and location can close off viable paths to a meaningful career.

Consider:

• Related specialties that align with your skills and interests (e.g., Internal Medicine vs. Family Medicine; Psychiatry vs. Neurology).
• Transitional and preliminary year positions as strategic stepping-stones.
• Community and rural programs that offer robust training and leadership opportunities.

4. Reflect, Adapt, and Own Your Narrative

SOAP success often comes when applicants transform perceived weaknesses into evidence of growth.

Practical approaches:

• Conduct a post-Match review of your application with mentors or advisors.
• Identify 2–3 clear improvement actions and articulate them in interviews:
  • “Here’s what went wrong, here’s what I changed, and here’s what I learned.”
• Practice explaining your journey honestly without sounding defensive or defeated.

5. Use Every Available Resource

Unmatched doesn’t mean unsupported. Many institutions and organizations invest heavily in helping their graduates navigate SOAP.

Resources to seek out:

• Your medical school’s career office and SOAP-specific workshops.
• Specialty societies’ guidance for unmatched applicants.
• Online webinars, podcasts, and guides on SOAP application strategy and interview skills.
• Peer groups—other unmatched graduates can share tips, moral support, and interview practice.

---

Practical SOAP Strategy Checklist for Medical Graduates

To translate these success stories into actionable steps, use this brief checklist as you prepare:

1. Before Match Week

   • Update CV and have multiple personal statement versions ready.
   • Identify mentors who can review your materials on short notice.
   • Research programs likely to participate in SOAP, especially those aligned with your profile.
   • Clarify visa, ECFMG, or licensing issues if you are an IMG.

2. On Monday of Match Week (Unmatched Notification)

   • Take a short time to process emotions, but move quickly into action.
   • Confirm SOAP eligibility and review the unfilled positions list.
   • Prioritize programs where you are a realistic candidate.
   • Finalize and assign tailored personal statements within ERAS.

3. Tuesday–Thursday (SOAP Active Period)

   • Keep your phone line and email open and professional.
   • Respond promptly and courteously to any contact from programs.
   • Be prepared for brief interviews at any time—keep notes on key talking points.
   • Track all applications, interviews, and interactions in a spreadsheet.

4. Offer Rounds

   • Understand that accepting an offer is binding—rank your preferences in advance.
   • Do not hold out for a hypothetical better option if you have a solid, acceptable offer in hand.
   • Consult quickly with mentors if you feel uncertain, but remember the timelines are short.

5. After SOAP

   • If matched: shift focus to preparing for residency (logistics, reading, wellness).
   • If unmatched: meet with advisors immediately to plan a structured gap year or alternative path, and revise your strategy for the next cycle.

---

Frequently Asked Questions About SOAP and Residency Success Stories

1. How common is it for unmatched medical graduates to secure positions through SOAP?

Many unmatched medical graduates do secure positions via SOAP each year, though exact numbers vary. The number of unfilled positions has generally increased over time, particularly in primary care and certain geographic regions. That said, SOAP is still highly competitive:

• Some specialties have few or no unfilled positions.
• Applicants with broader specialty and geographic flexibility fare better.
• Success is influenced by your credentials, preparation, and how strategically you apply.

Even if you do not secure a categorical position, obtaining a Transitional Year or preliminary spot can keep you moving forward clinically while you strengthen your application for a future Match.

2. What kinds of specialties are most realistic to target during SOAP?

Historically, more SOAP positions tend to appear in:

• Primary care fields: Family Medicine, Internal Medicine, Pediatrics (depending on the year).
• Certain community-based or rural programs.
• Transitional Year or preliminary positions in Internal Medicine or Surgery.

Highly competitive specialties (e.g., Dermatology, Orthopedics, Plastic Surgery) rarely have open SOAP positions. Applicants targeting these fields should usually:

• Consider a categorical position in a related field (e.g., Internal Medicine for Cardiology; General Surgery for some surgical subspecialties).
• Use a Transitional or preliminary year to build clinical and research credentials.

3. How can I talk about being unmatched during SOAP interviews without hurting my chances?

The key is to be honest, reflective, and future-focused:

Do:

• Briefly acknowledge what may have contributed (e.g., narrow specialty focus, late exam, weaker scores).
• Emphasize what you learned and what corrective steps you’ve taken.
• Highlight your strengths—clinical evaluations, professionalism, resilience, and growth.

Avoid:

• Blaming others (programs, advisors, the system) in a defensive way.
• Over-explaining; keep it concise and pivot to how you are better prepared now.
• Sounding defeated—programs want to see that you can handle adversity and still function effectively.

Example framing:

“I applied narrowly to a highly competitive specialty, and my Step scores were below their typical range. I’ve reflected on this with my mentors and broadened my focus to opportunities where I can excel clinically and serve patients right away. I’ve strengthened my application through [specific actions], and I’m excited about what I can contribute to your program.”

4. I’m an IMG. What additional steps can I take to improve my chances in SOAP?

For international medical graduates, additional success factors include:

• Documentation and Eligibility: Ensure ECFMG certification and visa-related paperwork are complete and visible to programs.
• US Clinical Experience: Highlight hands-on US clinical rotations, sub-internships, or observerships with strong letters.
• Targeted Program Selection: Prioritize programs with a history of accepting IMGs and, if applicable, sponsoring visas.
• Communication Skills: Demonstrate clear, professional English communication in interviews; consider mock interviews focused on US-style expectations.
• Mentorship from IMGs in Training: Connect with other IMGs who matched in the US; ask about programs, pitfalls, and best practices.

Many IMG SOAP success stories, like Maria’s, are built on preparation, strong clinical performance, and realistic program selection.

5. If I don’t match through SOAP, is my medical career over?

No. Not matching through SOAP is extremely difficult emotionally, but it does not end your medical career. Many physicians have:

• Taken a structured gap year to conduct research, obtain a master’s degree, or work in clinical or teaching roles.
• Improved exam scores, gained additional clinical experience, or strengthened their applications with new letters and projects.
• Successfully matched in a future cycle, often into specialties and programs that fit them better in the long term.

If you remain unmatched after SOAP:

• Meet promptly with your school’s advisors or trusted mentors.
• Develop a deliberate, year-long plan to strengthen your application.
• Consider diverse pathways (e.g., research tracks, public health, hospitalist support roles) that keep you connected to medicine.

With persistence, strategy, and support, many unmatched graduates eventually create their own real success stories in medicine.

---

SOAP is not just a safety net—it can be the start of a powerful, resilient chapter in your professional story. By learning from the experiences of graduates like Maria, Daniel, and Celine, and by applying the career strategies outlined here, you can approach SOAP not with fear, but with a focused, informed plan to secure a residency and build the medical career you’ve worked so hard to achieve.