Essential SOAP Preparation Guide for DO Graduates in Psychiatry Residency

Applying for residency is stressful; entering the SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) as a DO graduate pursuing psychiatry can feel overwhelming. With a clear strategy, though, SOAP can become a structured second chance rather than a panic-driven scramble.

This guide walks you step-by-step through SOAP preparation specifically for a DO graduate interested in psychiatry residency, with particular attention to the osteopathic residency match, DO-specific strengths, and the reality of the psychiatry residency market.

---

Understanding SOAP and Your Situation as a DO Psychiatry Applicant

What is SOAP?

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is a structured process run by NRMP during Match Week that allows eligible unmatched or partially matched applicants to apply to unfilled residency positions.

Key points:

• It happens during Match Week (Monday–Thursday).
• You can apply only to programs with unfilled positions released by NRMP.
• All communication with programs must follow strict NRMP rules (no cold calling, no back-channeling during the active SOAP period).
• There are up to four rounds of offers during SOAP.
• You submit applications via ERAS, not directly to programs.

Understanding what is SOAP early in the season gives you time to prepare documents, refine your strategy, and reduce last-minute anxiety.

Why SOAP Matters for DO Psychiatry Applicants

Psychiatry is a relatively competitive but still accessible specialty, and it has seen:

• Year-by-year growth in applicant numbers, including many DOs and IMGs.
• Increased interest due to good lifestyle, flexibility, and expanding job market.
• Programs becoming more selective, especially in urban and academic centers.

For a DO graduate in psychiatry, SOAP matters because:

• Some allopathic programs may still favor MDs, making the initial psych match tighter for DOs.
• Osteopathic candidates may have geographic or exam differences (COMLEX only vs. COMLEX + USMLE) influencing interview offers.
• SOAP opens up unfilled psychiatry positions and related specialties that can align with your long-term goals.

Being prepared for SOAP does not mean you expect to go unmatched—it means you’re realistic and strategic. The strongest applicants treat SOAP preparation like insurance: you hope you won’t need it, but you’re ready if you do.

---

Pre-Match Planning: Setting Up for a Strong SOAP Option

You cannot “cram” for SOAP in 24 hours. Effective SOAP preparation starts months before Match Week.

1. Assess Your Risk of Entering SOAP

As a DO graduate, consider:

• Step/COMLEX performance
  • Any exam failure?
  • Scores significantly below national psychiatry averages?
• Number and quality of interviews
  • Fewer than 8–10 interviews in psychiatry often increases match risk, especially at more competitive sites.
• Application profile
  • Gaps in training, professionalism concerns, weak letters, limited clinical psychiatry exposure.

If two or more of these raise concerns, assume you have a moderate risk of entering SOAP and prepare accordingly.

2. Update and SOAP-Proof Your ERAS Application

SOAP uses the same ERAS application platform, but you can modify certain elements before SOAP starts. Prior to Rank Order List (ROL) certification, make sure:

• Personal Statement

  • Have at least two versions:
    • A psychiatry-focused personal statement.
    • A flexible “backup” version you could adapt for related specialties (e.g., Internal Medicine, Transitional Year, Family Medicine) if your psych options are limited.
  • Highlight DO-specific strengths: holistic approach, OMM-informed understanding of the mind-body connection, communication skills, continuity of care.

• Experience Section

  • Ensure your psychiatry rotations, electives, and longitudinal experiences are clearly described.
  • Emphasize behavioral health, addiction medicine, primary care mental health, and any community or underserved work.
  • Clarify any pre-residency work: research, telepsychiatry scribe, case manager, etc.

• Letters of Recommendation

  • Aim for three letters, including at least:
    • 1–2 psychiatry faculty letters.
    • Possibly 1 from Internal Medicine or Family Medicine if you might SOAP into these.
  • If your letters are heavily academic, consider adding one from a clinical psychiatry mentor who can speak to your interpersonal skills and reliability.

• Exams and Transcripts

  • Ensure both COMLEX and USMLE (if taken) are uploaded correctly.
  • As a DO graduate, if you do not have USMLE scores, be ready to address this in your communication with programs, emphasizing your strong COMLEX performance and clinical evaluations.

3. Develop a SOAP Specialty Strategy

Your primary goal is still psychiatry residency, but your SOAP strategy should be realistic.

Ask yourself:

1. Is psychiatry your non-negotiable only specialty?
   • If yes, prepare to target all available psych positions—both categorical and prelim/TY if they align with future psych opportunities.
2. Are you open to related or stepping-stone paths?
   • Internal Medicine (with a later transfer to psychiatry when possible)
   • Family Medicine (behavioral health-focused practice)
   • Transitional Year (TY) that keeps the door open for a future psych match

As a DO graduate, you may also consider community-based programs and former osteopathic-centric sites that historically welcomed DOs.

Create tiers beforehand:

• Tier 1 – Psychiatry categorical programs (preferably ACGME-accredited, any region you’d genuinely attend)
• Tier 2 – Psychiatry prelim/PGY-1, Transitional Year, or Internal Medicine in psych-friendly institutions
• Tier 3 – Other primary care positions (FM, IM in less preferred regions) if your priority is any residency spot this year

---

Building Your SOAP Game Plan: Documents, Lists, and Communication

1. Create a Detailed Program Target List Before Match Week

You won’t know which programs will have unfilled positions, but you can anticipate categories:

• Community psychiatry programs
• Newer psychiatry programs or recent expansions
• Less competitive locations (rural, Rust Belt, deep South, non-coastal)
• Programs with a history of DO-friendly selection

Use sources such as:

• Past NRMP data on unfilled positions by specialty.
• Program websites: look at resident rosters (how many DOs?).
• Word-of-mouth from advisors, upper-level residents, or online forums.

Build a spreadsheet with:

• Program name and ACGME code
• Location and setting (university vs. community)
• Evidence of DO-friendliness (DO faculty or residents)
• Visa policies (if relevant)
• Notes on mission/fit (underserved focus, addiction, community psych, etc.)
• Contact information (for after SOAP period or if permitted by NRMP rules outside active periods)

This way, when NRMP releases the list of unfilled positions, you can quickly cross-reference and prioritize.

2. Tailor Personal Statements for SOAP Submissions

For SOAP, you may be applying to multiple specialties in a compressed timeframe.

Prepare:

• Psychiatry SOAP Personal Statement

  • Emphasize resilience, teachability, and clear understanding of psychiatric practice.
  • Highlight any continuity clinic experiences, addiction exposure, psychotherapy interest, emergency psychiatry, or rotations at psych facilities.
  • As a DO, briefly connect holistic philosophy, biopsychosocial model, and mind–body integration to psychiatry.

• Backup Specialty Statement(s) (e.g., IM, FM, Transitional Year)

  • Show you understand the specialty’s scope.
  • Explain why your psychiatry interest enhances your approach to primary care or inpatient medicine (e.g., managing depression, anxiety, substance use in primary care).

Keep these statements concise (around 600–750 words) and ready to upload or assign as needed.

3. Craft a Strong SOAP-Appropriate CV Summary

Programs will review your ERAS file quickly during SOAP; you want your story to be clear and coherent at a glance.

Ensure your application clearly communicates:

• You are a DO graduate with:
  • Proven ability to manage complex patients (OMM background can reinforce physical exam and pain management skills).
  • Strong communication and empathy.
  • Deep interest in psychiatric care and mental health across settings.

Use your ERAS Experience descriptions to emphasize:

• Specific psychiatric skills (e.g., risk assessment, motivational interviewing, psychopharm exposure).
• Interprofessional collaboration (social workers, psychologists, case managers).
• Any leadership or advocacy in mental health or wellness.

4. Coordinate with Your Medical School or Dean’s Office

Your school support is critical during SOAP:

• Identify a SOAP advisor (dean, faculty mentor, or GME specialist).
• Clarify how they will:
  • Review your SOAP program list.
  • Provide updated MSPE/Dean’s letters if needed.
  • Help you prioritize specialties and programs in real-time.
• Discuss realistic expectations as a DO psychiatry applicant:
  • Where previous DO graduates have matched in SOAP.
  • Whether prior osteopathic pipelines or affiliate hospitals might have psych or IM spots.

---

Execution During Match Week: Step-by-Step SOAP Strategy

1. Monday Morning: Unmatched Notification and Emotional Reset

If you learn you are unmatched or partially matched:

• Give yourself a defined window (30–60 minutes) to process emotions.
• Then switch into structured action mode.

Avoid:

• Blaming yourself or making impulsive decisions.
• Mass-sending frantic emails or calling programs (this is almost always restricted during SOAP).

Instead:

• Meet (virtually or in-person) with your advisor to confirm your plan.
• Review your pre-made program spreadsheet and modify based on real-time unfilled lists once released.

2. Reviewing the Unfilled Positions List

When NRMP releases the unfilled positions list:

• Filter by specialty = Psychiatry first.
• Identify:
  • Number of psych categorical vs. prelim PGY-1 positions.
  • Regions you are willing to move to.
  • Any DO-friendly institutions or those aligned with your interests (addiction, C/L, rural, underserved).

Next, evaluate:

• Are there enough psychiatry positions that fit your basic acceptability criteria (location, training quality, patient population) to focus purely on psych?
• If the list is limited or highly competitive, decide early whether to:
  • Apply only to psych (and risk remaining unmatched if offers don’t come).
  • Mix psych with primary care or TY positions to increase the chance of matching somewhere this year.

Remember that you have a cap on the number of applications you can send during SOAP (historically 45 ERAS applications total; confirm the current year’s rules). Use them wisely.

3. Prioritizing Programs: DO-Friendly and Psychiatry-Oriented

As a DO graduate, your top targets should be:

1. Psychiatry programs that have historically taken DOs
2. Community and hybrid academic-community psych programs
3. Newer or expanding psych programs with more open positions
4. Programs stating interest in holistic care, community mental health, or primary care integration—areas where DO training is particularly valued

Your secondary targets might include:

• Transitional Year programs at institutions with psychiatry residencies (potential for networking and future internal transfer).
• Internal Medicine or Family Medicine programs with robust behavioral health or integrated psychiatry experiences.

---

4. Application Submission During SOAP

Within ERAS during SOAP:

• Assign:
  • Correct personal statements to each program.
  • Appropriate letters of recommendation (psych letters to psych programs; IM/FM letters to others where available).
• Verify:
  • USMLE/COMLEX score release.
  • MSPE attached.
  • No glaring typos or incomplete sections.

In your program-specific strategy:

• For psychiatry programs:
  • If ERAS allows, add brief customized notes in the program signals (if available) or make sure your psych interest is crystal clear in your PS and experience descriptions.
• For IM/FM/TY programs:
  • Frame your psychiatry interest as a value-add:
    • Skill with difficult conversations.
    • Comfort with mental health comorbidities common in primary care.

5. Communication Rules and Professionalism

SOAP has very strict rules regarding communication:

• Programs may contact you; you typically should not initiate unsolicited contact during active SOAP periods (check current NRMP rules).
• If contacted:
  • Be prepared with a 30–60 second pitch:
    • Confirm your strong interest in psychiatry (or their specialty).
    • Highlight DO strengths: patient-centered care, osteopathic principles, comfort with whole-person assessment.
    • Briefly address any red flags (exam failure, gap year) in calm, honest, solution-oriented language.

Example response if asked about a low COMLEX/USMLE score:

“During my second year I had difficulty balancing study strategies and clinical obligations, which contributed to my lower Step score. I’ve since implemented a structured study system and consistent self-assessment, as reflected by my improved shelf and COMAT performance and strong clinical evaluations. I’m confident in my ability to handle residency-level responsibilities.”

Never:

• Make negative remarks about other programs.
• Sound desperate or entitled.
• Misrepresent your intentions (“This is my top choice” when you’re telling that to every program).

6. Handling SOAP Offers and Rounds

SOAP usually has multiple offer rounds over Wednesday and Thursday.

Key principles:

• If you get an offer at a psychiatry program you find acceptable:
  • Strongly consider accepting, especially if psych is your clear long-term goal.
• If the offer is in a different specialty or location you’re unsure of:
  • Assess honestly:
    • Would you rather reapply next cycle to psychiatry?
    • Can you see yourself completing training there and building a fulfilling career?
  • Discuss with your advisor; you often have only a short time window to accept or reject offers.

Be cautious about declining offers without a backup plan; SOAP is unpredictable.

---

After SOAP: Outcomes and Next Steps for DO Psychiatry Graduates

1. If You Match into Psychiatry Through SOAP

Congratulations—now:

• Reach out to your Program Director and coordinator:
  • Express gratitude and enthusiasm.
  • Ask about:
    • Onboarding steps.
    • Any suggested pre-reading or orientation materials.
• Reflect on your match as a DO psych trainee:
  • You bring a unique perspective on mind–body integration and holistic care.
  • Seek out mentors in:
    • Consultation-liaison psychiatry.
    • Addiction.
    • Community mental health.
    • Osteopathic-informed psych practice (if available).

2. If You Match into a Different Specialty (IM/FM/TY)

If long-term psychiatry is still your goal:

• For Transitional Year:
  • Seek rotations in psychiatry, emergency psych, and behavioral health.
  • Build strong relationships and request letters for future psych match or transfer attempts.
• For IM or FM:
  • Focus on integrated behavioral health, chronic disease + mental health comorbidity, addiction medicine, pain management.
  • Over time, you may:
    • Apply for psych again.
    • Build a hybrid career (e.g., primary care with emphasis on mental health, addiction medicine, psychosomatic medicine).

Document your psych-related experiences thoroughly; these can help if you reapply to psych or pursue fellowships that emphasize behavioral health.

3. If You Remain Unmatched After SOAP

This outcome is painful, but it is not career-ending.

Immediate steps:

• Schedule a detailed post-SOAP debrief with:
  • Your dean’s office.
  • A psychiatry mentor and/or GME advisor.
• Analyze your application:
  • Exam scores and any failures.
  • Number and quality of interviews.
  • Strength and specificity of letters.
  • Quality and authenticity of your personal statement.

Consider a structured gap year strategy:

• Clinical work:
  • Psychiatry research assistant.
  • Case manager, mental health coordinator.
  • Telehealth scribe for psychiatrists.
• Academic or research pursuits:
  • Psych-related research projects.
  • Publications or posters at psychiatry meetings.
• Exam improvements:
  • If allowed, consider Step 3/COMLEX Level 3 to show academic readiness (especially helpful for DO graduates).

Plan your future osteopathic residency match / psych match attempt with improved metrics and a stronger psychiatry-specific profile.

---

Practical SOAP Preparation Checklist for DO Psychiatry Applicants

Use this as a summary to keep yourself organized:

3–6 Months Before Match

• Honestly assess your match risk.
• Update ERAS experiences with clear psych emphasis.
• Secure 3+ strong LORs (at least 2 in psychiatry).
• Draft:
  • Psychiatry personal statement.
  • Backup specialty PS (IM/FM/TY if needed).
• Build a program spreadsheet focused on:
  • DO-friendly psych programs.
  • Newer/community psych programs.
  • TY/IM/FM at psych-heavy institutions.

1–2 Months Before Match

• Meet with advisor to review SOAP risk and strategy.
• Confirm ERAS entries are complete and accurate.
• Rehearse a brief professional pitch for potential program calls.
• Set up a support network (mentor, friends, family) for Match Week.

Match Week: If Unmatched

• Allow brief emotional space; then activate your SOAP plan.
• Review NRMP unfilled list; cross-reference with your spreadsheet.
• Decide on specialty mix (psych only vs. psych + IM/FM/TY).
• Submit ERAS SOAP applications strategically within the application limit.
• Respond professionally to any program outreach.
• Evaluate SOAP offers realistically; accept a psych position you can see yourself completing.

---

FAQs: SOAP Preparation for DO Graduates in Psychiatry

1. As a DO graduate, do I need USMLE scores to be competitive in psychiatry SOAP?

Not necessarily. Many psychiatry programs, especially community and historically osteopathic-friendly ones, accept COMLEX-only DO graduates, including during SOAP. However:

• Some university or highly competitive programs strongly prefer or require USMLE scores.
• If you already took USMLE, ensure scores are released and visible in ERAS.
• If you did not take USMLE, emphasize:
  • Strong COMLEX performance.
  • Robust clinical evaluations.
  • Concrete evidence of psych interest (rotations, research, leadership).

In SOAP specifically, programs are often focused more on filling positions rapidly with safe, reliable candidates than on marginal score differences.

---

2. How many psychiatry programs should I apply to during SOAP?

You are limited by the ERAS SOAP application cap (commonly 45 applications, but verify for the current cycle). For a DO graduate focused on psychiatry:

• Aim to allocate the majority of your applications to psychiatry positions if a reasonable number are available.
• Reserve a portion (e.g., 10–15) for backup specialties (IM/FM/TY) if:
  • The number of psych vacancies is small.
  • Your risk profile is high (exam failures, few initial psych interviews, etc.).

Always prioritize programs where you are realistically competitive and where you would genuinely attend if matched.

---

3. How can I highlight my DO training as an advantage for psychiatry residency?

In your ERAS and interviews/calls, frame your DO background as a strength:

• Emphasize holistic, biopsychosocial training.
• Note experience with:
  • Chronic pain and somatic symptom disorders.
  • Whole-person assessments connecting physical and mental health.
  • Communication and patient-centered interviewing.
• Mention any exposure to OMM in mental health contexts (e.g., treating chronic pain, tension headaches, or anxiety-related somatic complaints).

Programs are seeking residents who understand the complex interplay of body, mind, and environment—a core of osteopathic philosophy and modern psychiatry.

---

4. Should I accept a non-psychiatry SOAP offer if my ultimate goal is psych?

This is a nuanced, personal decision. Consider:

• If you receive a psychiatry offer that is safe and acceptable, it is generally wise to accept.
• If the offer is IM/FM/TY:
  • Ask: Am I prepared to complete this residency if I never get into psychiatry?
  • Some applicants successfully reapply or transfer into psychiatry after a year in another specialty, but this is not guaranteed.
• Discuss with your advisor:
  • Your academic risk factors.
  • Your tolerance for waiting and reapplying next year.
  • Financial, personal, and visa-related constraints.

For many DO graduates, accepting a strong, stable primary care or TY position can be a pragmatic route while keeping psychiatry-related opportunities open.

---

By approaching SOAP with deliberate preparation—tailored to your identity as a DO graduate pursuing psychiatry—you turn a high-stress process into a structured set of decisions. You cannot control every outcome, but you can absolutely control your readiness, clarity, and professionalism, which are exactly the qualities psychiatry programs look for in a future colleague.