Essential SOAP Preparation Guide for MD Graduates in Internal Medicine

Understanding SOAP in the Context of Internal Medicine

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is a structured process that allows unmatched or partially matched applicants to obtain residency positions that remain unfilled after the main allopathic medical school match. For an MD graduate targeting internal medicine residency, SOAP can be both a second chance and a high-pressure, time-compressed pathway.

Before thinking about SOAP preparation, it’s crucial to understand:

• Who is eligible
  You may participate in SOAP if:

  • You are registered for the NRMP Main Residency Match.
  • You are unmatched or partially matched at the start of Match Week.
  • You are ERAS-participating and have certified an application.
  • You are not withdrawn from the Match and not in violation of NRMP policies.

• What SOAP is (and is not)

  • SOAP is not a free-for-all scramble; it is a structured, rule-based system.
  • It is the only NRMP-sanctioned method to obtain unfilled positions during Match Week.
  • SOAP uses multiple “offer rounds” where programs review new applications and issue offers via the NRMP system.
  • You cannot “cold-call” or directly solicit programs outside approved communication channels.

• Why SOAP is particularly relevant to Internal Medicine
  Internal medicine (IM) is traditionally a larger specialty with many positions nationwide. While competitive academic or university-based programs may fill completely, community programs and some university-affiliated programs often have unfilled IM match positions, making internal medicine one of the more viable specialties to target during SOAP.

For a recent MD graduate, especially one from an allopathic medical school, being prepared for SOAP is part of a robust contingency plan. Even if you feel confident about your IM match prospects, planning for SOAP in advance protects you from having to improvise under intense time pressure.

---

Strategic Mindset: Planning for SOAP Before You Need It

SOAP preparation starts months before Match Week. The goal is not to assume failure, but to:

1. Protect your investment in medical school and USMLE/COMLEX.
2. Speed up your response if you are unmatched or partially matched.
3. Maximize your chances in the IM match or through SOAP if needed.

1. Know Your Risk Profile for Not Matching

As an MD graduate, your baseline odds are often better than many other applicant groups, but certain factors may increase your risk:

• USMLE Step 2 CK score below typical IM cutoffs (often ~220–230+; varies by program).
• Multiple exam attempts or failures.
• Limited or no U.S. clinical experience (if international MD).
• Few or non-specialty-specific internal medicine letters of recommendation.
• Red flags: professionalism issues, gaps in training, unremediated course failures.
• Very narrow rank list (e.g., <8–10 ranked IM programs, all highly competitive).

If you see yourself in any of these categories, you should treat SOAP preparation as an integral part of your application strategy.

2. Build a SOAP-Ready Application During the Regular Season

The ERAS application you submit for the main allopathic medical school match is essentially the same application you will use during SOAP. For internal medicine residency, ensure that your core materials are already optimized:

• Personal statement with IM focus
  Write a strong, general internal medicine-focused statement that:

  • Reflects genuine interest in IM as a career, not just a default specialty.
  • Highlights continuity of care, diagnostic reasoning, complex comorbidity management.
  • Mentions any IM-related research, QI projects, or scholarly work.

• Letters of Recommendation (LORs)
  Aim for:

  • 3–4 LORs, with at least 2 from internal medicine attendings.
  • One ideally from a Sub-I or Acting Internship in internal medicine.
  • One from a program director or clerkship director, if possible.

These same letters can be redistributed quickly during SOAP to new internal medicine programs, which is invaluable when time is limited.

3. Draft a SOAP-Specific Internal Medicine Personal Statement Early

During SOAP, you might need variant personal statements:

• A general IM statement (for primary applications and SOAP).
• An IM statement emphasizing:
  • Community-based practice and caring for underserved populations.
  • Hospitalist medicine or inpatient-focused careers.
  • Academic interests such as teaching or research (for academic/university-affiliated programs).

Create these variants well before Match Week. During SOAP, you won’t have time to write from scratch. You’ll only be able to customize minor details and program names.

---

Pre–Match Week Preparation: Building Your SOAP Toolkit

SOAP is fast-paced. To compete effectively for internal medicine residency positions, prepare a SOAP toolkit several weeks before Match Week.

1. Organize Key Documents and Templates

Have these files ready and easily accessible in a well-labeled cloud folder:

• Current CV (PDF and .docx).
• Core IM personal statement and 1–2 variants.
• Abstracted versions of your:
  • USMLE score report (for reference).
  • Medical school transcript.
  • MSPE (Dean’s letter).
• A master list of internal medicine programs with:
  • Program name and ACGME code.
  • Location (city, state).
  • Track (categorical, preliminary).
  • Setting (university, university-affiliated, community, community-based university).
  • Historical competitiveness (if known).
  • Notes about mission or specific strengths (to help customize communication).

While the NRMP and ERAS systems will centralize much of your data, your own organized files and notes will let you pivot quickly.

2. Understand SOAP Timelines and Rules

Spend time with the official NRMP and ERAS SOAP guides. Pay particular attention to:

• SOAP timeline

  • Monday of Match Week: You learn if you are matched/unmatched/partially matched.
  • Shortly after: List of unfilled programs is released (to eligible applicants).
  • Then: Multiple application and offer “rounds” occur during the week.

• Application limits
  You are allowed a maximum number of programs you can apply to during SOAP (historically 45; confirm each cycle). Plan how you will allocate those to:

  • Internal medicine categorical programs.
  • Internal medicine preliminary programs (if relevant to your path).

• Communication policies

  • You may not contact programs about unfilled positions outside NRMP/ERAS-approved channels.
  • Programs may reach out to you after receiving your SOAP application.
  • All offers and acceptances must occur through the NRMP system.

Knowing these rules avoids inadvertent violations that could jeopardize your IM match prospects.

3. Define Your SOAP Priorities for Internal Medicine

Not all internal medicine positions are the same. Before SOAP:

• Decide if your top priority is categorical IM over preliminary medicine.
• Clarify your geographic flexibility:
  • Are you willing to move to any region of the country?
  • Are there non-negotiable constraints (visa sponsorship, family obligations)?
• Decide how you weigh:
  • Academic vs community-based programs.
  • Fellowship opportunities vs immediate clinical experience.
  • Patient population (urban underserved, rural, suburban).

Write down your SOAP strategy tiers, for example:

• Tier 1: Categorical internal medicine programs in any region, community or university-affiliated, that sponsor required visa if applicable.
• Tier 2: Preliminary internal medicine programs, particularly at institutions where you might network for future interviews.
• Tier 3: Transitional year or closely related options (if you have a parallel plan); only if IM opportunities are exhausted.

Having pre-defined tiers prevents panic-driven, unfocused choices during Match Week.

---

Executing SOAP: Step-by-Step for Internal Medicine

Once Match Week starts and you discover you are unmatched or partially matched in the allopathic medical school match, you must immediately pivot to your SOAP plan.

1. Monday: Interpreting Your Match Status and Regrouping

Possible statuses:

• Unmatched: You did not secure any position.
• Partially matched: Often means you matched into an advanced position (e.g., PGY-2) but did not secure a preliminary year, or vice versa.

For internal medicine:

• If you are unmatched and IM is your primary goal, your SOAP strategy should concentrate heavily on IM categorical and IM preliminary positions.
• If you are partially matched (e.g., you have an advanced IM-related position starting PGY-2), you may prioritize preliminary internal medicine positions.

Immediately after learning your status:

• Alert your support network:
  • Medical school dean’s office or career advisors.
  • Mentors and IM faculty champions.
• Schedule emergency advising sessions:
  • Discuss your competitiveness for SOAP IM positions.
  • Refine your list of realistic target programs.

2. Reviewing the List of Unfilled Programs

Once the list of unfilled programs becomes available:

• Filter for:
  • Internal Medicine – Categorical (PGY-1).
  • Internal Medicine – Preliminary (PGY-1).
• Identify:
  • Program characteristics aligning with your profile:
    • USMLE cutoffs.
    • Visa policies (if applicable).
    • IMG/DO/MD mix (relevant if you’re an MD graduate from a non-U.S. medical school).
  • Geographic preferences, but be prepared to be flexible.

Create a spreadsheet prioritizing programs by:

1. Best fit with your credentials and goals.
2. Realistic chances of acceptance.
3. Program stability, reputation, and training quality (based on publicly available data, alumni, mentors).

Apply your Tier 1–2–3 strategy to this list.

3. Tailoring Your SOAP Applications in ERAS

When applying during SOAP:

• Use your internal medicine–focused personal statement as the default.
• For top-priority programs, quickly adjust:
  • Program name.
  • One or two sentences about:
    • Why their patient population or setting resonates with you.
    • Any known strengths (teaching, QI focus, underserved care, research).
• Assign your most relevant internal medicine LORs to these programs.
• Avoid excessive over-customization:
  • Time is limited.
  • Focus on clear, error-free applications to the maximum number of appropriate IM programs you are allowed.

4. Communication with Programs During SOAP

Programs may reach out by phone, email, or virtual interviews after they receive your SOAP application.

Prepare in advance:

• A 1–2 minute elevator pitch:

  • Who you are (MD graduate from X school).
  • Your interest in internal medicine.
  • What strengths you bring (teamwork, strong clinical evaluations, QI interest, underserved care).
  • Why their program aligns with your career goals.

• Key talking points:

  • Your understanding of internal medicine’s scope: chronic disease management, inpatient/outpatient balance, academic vs community practice.
  • Examples of IM rotations where you excelled: complex cases you helped manage, feedback from attendings.
  • Any remediation of past weaknesses: improved Step 2 CK performance, stronger clinical grades, new research or QI involvement.

Be prepared for rapid, same-day virtual interviews. Keep your schedule relatively open during SOAP week, maintain professional attire, and ensure reliable internet and a quiet environment.

5. Evaluating and Accepting SOAP Offers

When offers come:

• You may receive offers during specific SOAP rounds.
• Each round allows you to:
  • Accept one offer.
  • Or let offers expire if you’re waiting for a better fit (a calculated risk).

For internal medicine residency:

• A categorical IM position is usually more valuable than most alternatives if IM is your primary long-term goal.
• A preliminary IM position can still be a strong stepping stone if:
  • You are committed to reapplying with stronger credentials.
  • It’s at an institution with many IM categorical or subspecialty programs.

Balance:

• Geographic preferences vs securing any accredited IM training.
• Program prestige vs training environment where you can thrive and grow.

If you accept an offer:

• You are committed to that position.
• Immediately notify mentors and your institution.

---

Strengthening Your SOAP Competitiveness as an MD Graduate in IM

Even before Match Week, there are concrete steps you can take to make your application more SOAP-ready and appealing to internal medicine programs.

1. Optimize US Clinical Experience and Evaluations

Internal medicine residency programs rely heavily on clinical performance and letters:

• Prioritize sub-internships or acting internships in internal medicine.
• Seek feedback early in the rotation and adjust your performance based on it.
• Demonstrate:
  • Ownership of patient care.
  • Meticulous follow-up of labs and imaging.
  • Clear, concise oral and written communication.
  • Respectful interprofessional collaboration.

Your evaluations, summarized in your MSPE and LORs, will often matter more than marginal score differences once you meet basic thresholds.

2. Highlight IM-Relevant Research and Scholarly Activity

You don’t need a long publication list, but for IM:

• Emphasize:
  • Case reports or series in internal medicine subspecialties.
  • Quality improvement (QI) projects on hospital metrics, readmissions, safety.
  • Presentations at ACP, local IM conferences, or institutional research days.
• In your personal statement and ERAS entries:
  • Connect these activities to your interest in evidence-based medicine, QI, and life-long learning—values central to internal medicine.

3. Anticipate and Address Red Flags Proactively

SOAP programs will read your file carefully. If you have:

• A failed USMLE attempt.
• A gap in training.
• Academic remediation.

Work with advisors to:

• Craft a brief, honest explanation that:
  • Accepts responsibility.
  • Highlights specific steps taken to improve.
  • Demonstrates sustained performance since.

You may integrate this explanation in:

• The “Additional Information” section of ERAS.
• Your personal statement (if central to your story).
• Spoken form during SOAP interviews.

Programs will be reassured by clear improvement and insight.

4. Build Relationships with IM Faculty and Program Leadership

Even if they are not at SOAP-participating programs:

• IM faculty mentors can:
  • Provide meaningful, detailed LORs.
  • Give targeted feedback on your IM-focused personal statement.
  • Offer honest assessments of your competitiveness.
  • Sometimes connect you informally with colleagues at other institutions for advice (not for inappropriate solicitation).

Having knowledgeable advocates improves both your initial IM match chances and your performance during SOAP.

---

Long-Term Perspective: If You Still Don’t Secure an IM Position Through SOAP

Despite optimal SOAP preparation, some MD graduates may still not secure an internal medicine residency spot. While disappointing, there are structured next steps:

• Post-SOAP Unfilled Positions
  Occasionally, positions remain or open later due to unforeseen circumstances. Stay in close touch with:

  • Your dean’s office.
  • GME offices that may post late vacancies.

• Reapply with a Stronger Profile
  If you must wait a year:

  • Pursue clinical work consistent with your IM interests if allowed (e.g., research fellow, clinical research coordinator, IM-focused observerships).
  • Stay involved in internal medicine scholarship or QI to keep your application current.
  • Retake Step 2 CK only if advised and allowable, focusing on clear score improvement.

• Consider Preliminary or Transitional Options Next Cycle
  For some, a preliminary IM year followed by reapplication can demonstrate:

  • Strong inpatient IM performance.
  • Commitment to the specialty.
  • Fresh, powerful letters from U.S. IM faculty.

Throughout, maintain a realistic but hopeful mindset. Many excellent internists did not follow a perfectly linear IM match path.

---

FAQs: SOAP Preparation for MD Graduates in Internal Medicine

1. I’m an MD graduate from an allopathic medical school. Do I really need a SOAP plan if my IM application seems strong?
Yes. Even competitive candidates can go unmatched due to application errors, overly narrow rank lists, or shifts in program behavior. A basic SOAP preparation plan (IM-focused personal statement, organized documents, understanding of SOAP rules) is prudent insurance and can be completed without excessive time investment.

2. How many internal medicine programs should I target during SOAP?
You are limited by the NRMP maximum (often around 45 programs, subject to change). For an IM match focus:

• Allocate the majority to categorical IM programs.
• Use remaining slots for preliminary IM positions if:
  • You are partially matched into an advanced slot.
  • Or you want a strong clinical year to reapply.
    Aim to apply to as many appropriate IM programs as your limit allows, prioritizing fit and realistic competitiveness.

3. Should I change my personal statement specifically for SOAP?
You should not dramatically change your narrative last minute. Instead:

• Start with a well-written, general internal medicine statement.
• For SOAP, adjust only brief segments for top-priority programs:
  • Mention their patient population, mission, or training environment.
• Ensure your statement is positive, forward-looking, and concise, without sounding desperate or apologetic about being in SOAP.

4. What is SOAP vs. the old “scramble,” and why does it matter?
SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) replaced the old unregulated scramble:

• SOAP is an organized, rule-based process where:
  • Applicants apply through ERAS.
  • Programs review applications and submit preference lists.
  • Offers are extended in rounds through NRMP.
• The old scramble involved chaotic, simultaneous phone calls and offers.
  Understanding what SOAP is and its structure allows you to prepare strategically, avoid rule violations, and present a coherent, professional application to internal medicine programs.

---

Thoughtful SOAP preparation, especially for an MD graduate interested in internal medicine residency, is not pessimism—it is professionalism. By building a SOAP-ready application, understanding the IM match landscape, and planning your week-by-week actions, you place yourself in the strongest possible position—whether you match outright or must navigate the SOAP residency process to secure your spot in internal medicine.