Essential SOAP Preparation Guide for MD Graduates in Urology Residency

Preparing for the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) as an MD graduate interested in urology residency is a high‑stakes, emotionally intense process—but it is also manageable and strategizable. The key is advance planning, clear decision‑making, and methodical execution so you can pivot quickly if the urology match does not go as planned.

Below is a comprehensive, practical guide tailored specifically to MD graduates from allopathic medical schools who are targeting urology but want a robust safety net and competitive strategy for SOAP in the main NRMP Match.

---

Understanding SOAP in the Context of Urology

How Urology and SOAP Intersect

Urology residency in the United States primarily participates in the AUA (American Urological Association) Match, which is separate from the NRMP Match. However, many MD graduates applying in urology also apply to the NRMP Match (often in general surgery, preliminary surgery, or a transitional year) as a backup.

This is where SOAP becomes relevant:

• If you match urology through the AUA:
  You’re done—no NRMP SOAP participation is necessary (and you should withdraw from the NRMP if instructed/appropriate based on your backup strategy and timing).

• If you do not match in urology and you:

  • Also ranked programs in the NRMP main residency match and do not match there → you may become SOAP-eligible.
  • Matched to a prelim or categorical program in the NRMP → you are not SOAP-eligible, even if you did not match urology.

Because of this dual‑match environment, every urology applicant should have a clear understanding of what SOAP is, how it works, and how to prepare.

What Is SOAP (Operationally)?

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is a structured, time‑limited process run by the NRMP to fill unfilled residency positions after the main Match algorithm runs.

Key operational features:

• Eligibility:
  You may be SOAP‑eligible if:

  • You are registered for the NRMP Match,
  • You are partially matched (e.g., advanced but not prelim) or fully unmatched,
  • You are not withdrawn, and
  • You hold a valid ECFMG certification if you are an IMG (for MD grads from US allopathic schools, you usually just need your expected graduation status).
    Your official SOAP status appears in your NRMP/R3 account on Monday of Match Week.

• Application platform:
  SOAP applications are submitted through ERAS, not directly via emails or cold calls.

• Communication rules:
  During SOAP, you cannot initiate contact with programs. Programs contact you. Unsolicited outreach can violate NRMP rules.

• Offer rounds:
  There are several rounds of offers (typically four) from Monday–Thursday of Match Week. You may:

  • Receive zero, one, or multiple offers.
  • Accept only one at a time.
  • Once accepted, that match is binding.

• Scope for urology‑interested applicants:
  There are typically few, if any, urology positions in SOAP. Most urology spots are already filled through the AUA match.
  Therefore, your SOAP plan should focus on:

  • Preliminary surgery (often preferred by urology aspirants),
  • Transitional year (if available and fits your long‑term plan),
  • Occasionally categorical general surgery or related fields depending on your goals and competitiveness.

---

Strategic Framework: Before, During, and After SOAP

1. Pre‑SOAP Strategy (6–9 Months Before Match Week)

Your SOAP preparation should start well before Match Week, particularly as an MD graduate targeting a competitive field like urology.

A. Clarify Your Backup Philosophy

Ask yourself:

• Is urology non‑negotiable, even if it takes an extra year?
• Are you open to another surgical specialty if urology doesn’t work out?
• Are you willing to do a prelim year, research year, or both to re‑apply?

Common strategies for MD graduates in urology:

1. Primary Urology + NRMP Backup (Prelim/Transitional/General Surgery)

   • Goal: Secure a PGY‑1 year that strengthens your urology candidacy if you need to re‑apply.
   • Implication: You may not be SOAP‑eligible if you match that backup. SOAP becomes Plan C.

2. Primary Urology Only (No NRMP Rank List, or minimal)

   • Goal: All‑in on urology.
   • Risk: If unmatched in urology and not registered/aligned appropriately with NRMP, SOAP is not an option. You may seek research positions and re‑apply next year.

3. Broader Surgical Interest (Urology or Other Surgical Fields)

   • Goal: Match into some surgical training even if not urology.
   • SOAP: You may accept categorical general surgery, prelim surgery, or other options.

Define early which model fits you—and discuss it with a urology mentor, program director, or advising dean.

B. Build a SOAP‑Ready Application From the Start

Even if you hope never to use SOAP, your initial ERAS application should be SOAP‑ready:

• USMLE/COMLEX scores clearly documented and passed.
• Strong letters of recommendation, ideally from:
  • Urologists,
  • General surgeons (for prelim backup),
  • Research mentors, if relevant.
• A flexible personal statement library:
  • Primary urology statement.
  • A more general surgery‑oriented or transitional year statement.
  • An adaptable SOAP‑specific version ready for rapid tailoring.
• Updated CV including:
  • Urology experiences,
  • Surgical rotations,
  • Research/quality improvement projects,
  • Leadership and teaching.

This structure makes SOAP preparation mostly about tailoring and rapid deployment, not starting from scratch.

---

2. Concrete SOAP Preparation Timeline

A. 3–4 Months Before Match Week

1. Learn the Rules Thoroughly

   • Review the official NRMP documentation on:
     • SOAP eligibility,
     • Communication rules,
     • Offer rounds, and
     • Technical details of using R3 during SOAP.
   • Ensure your ERAS account is active and up to date, even if you used it solely for urology and/or backup NRMP programs.

2. Draft SOAP‑Targeted Materials

   • Write a SOAP personal statement for:

     • Prelim general surgery,
     • Transitional year (if you might apply),
     • Categorical general surgery (if you’re open to it).

   • Template example (for prelim surgery):

     As an MD graduate with a strong commitment to urologic surgery, I am seeking a preliminary general surgery year that will provide intensive operative, perioperative, and critical care experience. My long‑term goal is to pursue urology residency, and I believe a rigorous prelim surgery year will strengthen both my clinical acumen and my competitiveness as a future surgical trainee…

   • Maintain a master PS document where you can rapidly swap paragraphs to emphasize:

     • Your urology interest (showing long‑term focus),
     • Your enthusiasm for surgical training in general, and
     • Your commitment to being a hard‑working, reliable intern, regardless of ultimate specialty.

3. Identify Likely SOAP Targets

   You will not know the actual unfilled programs until Match Week, but you can profile likely options:

   • Look historically at:
     • Programs that often have unfilled general surgery prelim or transitional year spots.
     • Regions where you are geographically flexible.
   • Make a list of:
     • Cities/states you’d accept offers in,
     • Hospital types (academic vs community),
     • Programs where you’d be realistically competitive.

   This list will guide rapid decision‑making once the unfilled list is published.

B. 1–2 Months Before Match Week

1. Meet With Advisors and Mentors

   Key people:

   • Urology faculty mentor,
   • Surgery faculty (especially if you might do a prelim),
   • Dean’s office or career advising staff.

   Discuss:

   • Your risk of going unmatched in urology,
   • Whether to include a robust NRMP backup list,
   • How aggressively to target surgery/transitional options in SOAP if needed,
   • Whether a research year in urology might be more beneficial than a prelim year in certain scenarios.

2. Update ERAS for a SOAP Scenario

   • Make sure all:
     • USMLE transcripts are uploaded and released.
     • MSPE and transcripts are final.
     • Publications/abstracts are current.
   • Ask letter writers:
     • If they’d be comfortable with you using their letters for surgery or transitional year programs through SOAP.
   • Have PDF copies or notes summarizing your experiences for quick reference during interviews.

3. Mental and Logistical Preparation

   • Block off Match Week on your schedule with flexibility:
     • Expect to spend Monday–Thursday engaged full‑time in SOAP if unmatched.
   • Ensure you have:
     • Reliable internet and a quiet place for phone/virtual interviews.
     • A professional appearance ready for video calls (if programs use them).

---

3. Match Week: Executing Your SOAP Plan

Match Week is intense. A calm, structured approach helps you take advantage of every opportunity.

A. Monday Morning: Confirm Your Status

On Monday of Match Week at 10 a.m. ET:

• Check the NRMP R3 system:
  • If you are “Unmatched” or “Partially Matched” and labeled SOAP-eligible, you may participate.
  • If you are matched in NRMP (even to a prelim or categorical program), you are not SOAP-eligible, regardless of urology outcome.

From a urology perspective:

• Unmatched in AUA + Unmatched in NRMP + SOAP‑eligible → This is your SOAP activation scenario.
• Unmatched in AUA but matched to prelim/categorical in NRMP → Consider future urology re‑application; SOAP is not an option.

B. Monday Noon: Reviewing the Unfilled Positions List

The List of Unfilled Programs appears in NRMP (and in ERAS) for SOAP‑eligible applicants:

1. Filter Strategically for a Urology‑Oriented Pathway

   Prioritize:

   • Preliminary General Surgery PGY‑1:
     • Provides broad surgical exposure,
     • Often respected by urology programs,
     • Keeps you in the OR and surgical culture.
   • Transitional Year:
     • Variety of rotations,
     • Good if you want a broad base or are considering other specialties.
   • Categorical General Surgery:
     • Only if you are genuinely open to completing general surgery if urology re‑application doesn’t work out. Don’t lock yourself into a categorical spot based on a “maybe” mindset.

2. Immediate Triage

   Make a quick three‑tier list:

   • Tier 1: Programs you strongly want and where you’re realistically competitive.
   • Tier 2: Acceptable programs with reasonable training but less ideal location or structure.
   • Tier 3: Programs you’d list only if options are otherwise extremely limited.

C. Monday–Wednesday: Submitting SOAP Applications and Interviewing

1. SOAP Application Limits

   The NRMP/ERAS impose a limit on the number of programs you can apply to during SOAP (historically 45, but always confirm the current rules). Use these slots intentionally.

   Strategy for MD graduates targeting urology:

   • Allocate a majority of applications to prelim general surgery and transitional year programs.
   • Consider a smaller number of categorical general surgery only if it aligns with your long‑term goals.

2. Tailoring Your Personal Statement and Program Signals

   For each type of program:

   • Prelim Surgery:

     • Emphasize:
       • Love of surgical patient care,
       • Desire for demanding OR and inpatient experience,
       • How your urology interest aligns with being an outstanding surgical intern.
     • Make it clear you'll be a fully committed intern, not just “biding time” until urology.

   • Transitional Year:

     • Emphasize:
       • Breadth of clinical training,
       • Desire to become a well‑rounded physician before specialty training,
       • Adaptability and work ethic.

   • Categorical General Surgery (if used):

     • Be honest:
       • You are drawn to surgery broadly,
       • You appreciate the scope and depth of general surgery,
       • If you still hope to pursue urology, describe it in a way that does not suggest you’d abandon your categorical program without cause.

3. SOAP Interview Preparation

   Programs may contact you very quickly after you apply:

   • Be ready for:
     • Short, focused phone or video interviews (10–20 minutes).
     • Same‑day scheduling.

   Common SOAP interview questions for urology‑oriented MD graduates:

   • “You initially applied in urology. Why are you now seeking a prelim/general surgery/transitional year position?”
   • “How committed will you be to our patients and team if you still plan to pursue urology?”
   • “What strengths do you bring as an intern from your urology and surgery experiences?”
   • “Can you describe a time you faced disappointment or a setback and how you responded?”

   Effective response approach:

   • Be forthcoming about your urology interest.
   • Emphasize:
     • Professionalism,
     • Teamwork,
     • Resilience,
     • Willingness to do hard work regardless of path.
   • Convey clear gratitude for the opportunity and a genuine interest in their program.

4. Ranking Your SOAP Preferences

   Before each offer round, clarify:

   • Which programs you would accept immediately if offered,
   • Which are second‑tier but still acceptable,
   • Which you might decline, anticipating a better fit later (but be cautious; future offers are not guaranteed).

---

4. Deciding Between SOAP Spots, Research Years, and Re‑Application

For many MD graduates targeting urology, SOAP is only part of a multi‑year journey. Your long‑term urology prospects depend on how you use the year after going unmatched.

A. When a Prelim Surgery Year Makes Sense

A prelim general surgery year is often ideal if:

• You are strongly committed to re‑applying in urology.
• You want:
  • Intensive operative experience,
  • Strong surgical letters of recommendation,
  • Direct interaction with urology departments at the same institution or region.
• You are prepared to:
  • Perform at a high level as an intern,
  • Network with urology faculty during your year,
  • Apply again early and strategically.

Advantages for urology re‑application:

• Real‑world surgical performance (attending surgeons can vouch for you).
• Evidence of resilience and commitment to a surgical career.
• Opportunities for urology electives and research within the same institution.

B. When a Transitional Year or Research Year Is Preferable

A transitional year or a dedicated research year may be better if:

• Your Step scores or academic record need strengthening with:
  • Additional exams or board scores,
  • Publications and academic productivity.
• You want more flexibility and exposure to internal medicine, ICU, and other rotations.
• You have access to a strong urology research mentor willing to work intensively with you.

You can also combine:

• A partial clinical schedule (e.g., transitional year)
  with
• Substantial urology research efforts at the same institution.

C. Deciding About Categorical General Surgery

Accept a categorical general surgery spot through SOAP only if:

• You can see yourself genuinely satisfied as a general surgeon if urology does not work out.
• You understand:
  • It’s not guaranteed you can switch into urology later,
  • Changing specialties mid‑training is complex and uncertain.

If your heart is set almost exclusively on urology, a prelim or research year plus re‑application may be more aligned with your goals than a categorical commitment you don’t truly want.

---

5. Practical Tips and Common Pitfalls for Urology‑Bound Applicants

A. Tips for a Strong SOAP Performance

1. Prepare concise talking points
   Have a 30–60 second summary ready that covers:

   • Who you are,
   • Your core strengths,
   • Your long‑term goal (urology, surgery),
   • Why their program is appealing.

2. Rehearse your “Why didn’t you match?” answer

   For an MD graduate in a competitive specialty like urology, a reasonable answer might be:

   Urology is extremely competitive, and although my application was strong in terms of clinical performance and letters, I recognize that my Step score and limited home program exposure may have been limiting factors. I’ve reflected on this and am fully committed to using this year productively—working hard clinically, strengthening my skills, and earning strong evaluations so that I can be an excellent intern and a stronger candidate for future opportunities.

3. Stay organized during fast‑paced communication

   Maintain:

   • A spreadsheet with:
     • Programs you applied to,
     • Interview times,
     • Notes from each call,
     • Tier ranking for your preferences.
   • A running list of questions to compare programs (OR exposure, call structure, relationship with urology department, etc.).

4. Lean on your network

   • Ask mentors:
     • To reach out (when permitted and within NRMP rules) to colleagues at prelim/transitional programs where you’re applying.
   • Many program directors value trusted recommendations during SOAP, when decisions move quickly.

B. Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Appearing uncommitted to the backup specialty

   Programs will hesitate to rank you highly if you seem to:

   • Only want urology and treat the backup year as an inconvenience.
   • Signal you might be disengaged or difficult if you don’t re‑match.

   Counter this by:

   • Expressing full commitment to doing an excellent job at their program,
   • Highlighting your genuine interest in gaining surgical experience.

2. Over‑ or underestimating your competitiveness

   • Overestimating can lead to applying only to highly competitive categorical spots, leaving you with no offers.
   • Underestimating can cause you to avoid strong prelim/transitional programs where you’d be an excellent fit.

   Use your advisors’ feedback to calibrate expectations.

3. Violating SOAP communication rules

   • Do not:
     • Cold‑email programs asking for interviews,
     • Have mentors reach out in ways that clearly violate NRMP guidelines.
   • Stick to permitted channels to avoid penalties.

4. Ignoring your mental health

   Match Week, especially if you are unmatched in a desired field like urology, can be emotionally intense.
   Make time to:

   • Talk to peers in similar situations,
   • Seek support from family or counseling services,
   • Acknowledge disappointment while staying action‑oriented.

---

FAQs: SOAP Preparation for MD Graduates in Urology

1. If I’m applying to urology through the AUA Match, do I still need to think about SOAP?

Yes. Many urology applicants also participate in the allopathic medical school match (NRMP) for prelim surgery, transitional year, or general surgery positions. If you go unmatched in both AUA and NRMP—or partially matched—you may be SOAP‑eligible, and having a plan in place protects you from scrambling under pressure.

---

2. What are the best SOAP options for someone who still wants urology long term?

For an MD graduate focused on a urology residency, the most strategically valuable SOAP options are usually:

• Preliminary General Surgery PGY‑1 positions (top choice for many, given OR exposure and strong letters),
• Transitional year spots with opportunities for urology or surgical electives,
• In some cases, urology‑focused research positions (outside SOAP) if you choose a non‑clinical year.

Categorical general surgery is appropriate only if you are truly open to a career in general surgery if urology doesn’t work out.

---

3. How can I talk about my interest in urology during SOAP interviews without scaring off programs?

Balance is key. You can say, in essence:

• You remain interested in urology long term,
• But right now your priority is to be the best possible intern at their program,
• And a strong prelim/transitional year will make you a better surgeon and physician, regardless of final specialty.

Make sure you repeatedly emphasize your commitment to their patients, their team, and their training environment for the full year.

---

4. Should I ever turn down a SOAP offer to wait for a potentially better one?

It depends on:

• How strong the current offer is (fit, training quality, location),
• Your risk tolerance,
• Advice from experienced mentors.

Because SOAP is short and uncertain, many advisors recommend accepting a solid, acceptable offer rather than gambling on a better one. Before Match Week, clarify your own hierarchy of acceptable outcomes so you can decide quickly if an offer meets your threshold.

---

Thoughtful SOAP preparation gives you leverage in an otherwise stressful process. As an MD graduate targeting urology, your overarching goal is to keep moving forward in surgical training, build your skills and reputation, and position yourself as a stronger candidate—whether for a future urology match or a fulfilling alternative pathway within surgery.