Essential SOAP Preparation Guide for US Citizen IMGs in EM-IM Residency

As a US citizen IMG and an American studying abroad, planning for the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) can feel intimidating—especially when your dream is a competitive pathway like Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine (EM IM combined). Yet, with the right strategy and early SOAP preparation, SOAP can become a powerful second chance rather than a last-minute scramble.

This guide focuses specifically on SOAP preparation for US citizen IMGs targeting Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine, with practical, step‑by‑step advice on how to plan, execute, and adapt if you find yourself going through SOAP.

---

Understanding SOAP: What It Is and Why It Matters

Before talking strategy, you must clearly understand: what is SOAP, how it works, and how it affects a US citizen IMG aiming for an EM IM combined program.

What is SOAP?

SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) is the structured, time‑limited process the NRMP uses to fill unfilled residency positions before the post‑Match “scramble.” Instead of chaotic cold-calling, SOAP gives unmatched applicants and unfilled programs a formal, organized way to connect.

Key elements:

• Who participates:
  • Applicants who registered for the Match, are eligible to start residency, and did not match (or are partially matched needing a categorical slot).
  • Programs with unfilled positions after the main Match algorithm.
• Where it happens: In the NRMP (Match) system and ERAS (applications/interviews) platforms.
• What it covers: Unfilled positions in ACGME-accredited programs across specialties—mostly prelims, transitional years, and some categorical spots.

As a US citizen IMG, SOAP is critical because:

• Some EM, IM, and combined EM-IM affiliated programs may SOAP into preliminary, categorical IM, or other related positions when their EM-IM tracks are full.
• Many IM programs that are EM-friendly or EM-adjacent may have unfilled spots you can leverage as a pathway toward your long‑term Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine goals.

Where Does Emergency Medicine-Internal Medicine Fit Into SOAP?

True EM IM combined residency positions almost never appear in SOAP. Combined programs typically fill in the main Match. However, SOAP can still be valuable for an EM IM–oriented US citizen IMG:

• Internal Medicine (categorical): Gives a strong base and potential for later fellowship, EM-based moonlighting, or second residency in EM (though complex and not guaranteed).
• Preliminary Medicine or Transitional Year: Stabilizes your CV and keeps you clinically active while you strengthen your next EM-IM or EM application.
• Emergency Medicine–friendly IM programs: IM programs with strong ED exposure, critical care, point‑of‑care ultrasound, or toxicology that align with EM interests.
• Community-based programs with EM-IM collaboration: These may not be labeled EM-IM but can offer robust ED rotations and EM-adjacent training opportunities.

SOAP is therefore a strategic safety net: if your EM IM combined pathway doesn’t work out on first attempt, SOAP positions can keep you in the system and help you build toward that eventual goal.

---

Pre‑SOAP Strategy: Preparation Before Rank Order List Deadline

The strongest SOAP outcomes are built months before SOAP even begins. As an American studying abroad, you must assume competition will be intense and prepare accordingly.

1. Be Realistic About Your EM-IM Competitiveness

EM IM combined is relatively niche and competitive. As a US citizen IMG, assess:

• USMLE performance
  • Step 1: P/F means emphasis shifts heavily to Step 2 CK.
  • Step 2 CK: For EM-IM interest, aim to be comfortably competitive (ideally at or above average of matched EM/IM applicants).
• Clinical experience
  • US clinical experience (USCE) in EM and IM is strongly valued.
  • Sub‑internships (sub‑Is) in EM, IM, or related fields at teaching hospitals help.
• Letters of Recommendation (LoRs)
  • Strong EM and IM letters, especially from US faculty, are vital.
  • SLOE-equivalent EM letters (if you rotated in US EM departments) are particularly powerful.
• Red flags
  • Exam failures, long gaps, professionalism concerns—be prepared to address these clearly and concisely in interviews and personal statements.

If your profile has multiple risks, SOAP is more likely to be relevant—so plan as if you might need it even while aiming to match outright.

2. Plan Your SOAP Backup Specialties in Advance

SOAP week moves quickly. You cannot afford to waste hours deciding what to apply to. Decide now, before Rank List certification, what your realistic SOAP options will be.

For an EM-IM–oriented US citizen IMG, consider:

• Primary SOAP targets:
  • Categorical Internal Medicine (community or university-affiliated, IMG‑friendly)
  • Prelim Medicine
  • Transitional Year (TY)
• Secondary or broader options (if you are flexible):
  • Family Medicine (EM‑friendly; often more open to IMGs)
  • Preliminary Surgery (only if it aligns with your interests and you understand its limits)
  • Psychiatry or other fields if you have aligned experiences

Map these into tiers:

• Tier 1: Categorical IM (especially EM‑friendly environments, strong ICU/CCM exposure, robust ED rotations).
• Tier 2: Transitional Year and Prelim IM at IMG‑friendly hospitals.
• Tier 3: FM or other specialties if your main goal becomes “start any ACGME residency and remain clinically active.”

Write this out in a simple document titled “SOAP Targets – EM-IM Oriented Backup Plan” and keep it accessible.

3. Build an IMG‑Specific EM-IM SOAP Target List

Because you are a US citizen IMG, you must filter for IMG friendliness and visa independence:

• US citizen status means you don’t need visa sponsorship, which is a big plus.
• However, some programs still prefer US MD/DOs, so historical IMG intake matters.

Actions:

• Use sources like FREIDA, program websites, and IMG forums to identify:
  • Programs with a track record of taking IMGs in IM, TY, or Prelim Medicine.
  • Community and university-affiliated IM programs with strong ED exposure.
  • Programs that explicitly welcome US citizen IMG applicants.
• Note:
  • Program size (bigger programs often more likely to have unfilled spots).
  • Location flexibility: be open to less popular geographic regions.
  • EM exposure: ED rotations, EM electives, critical care emphasis, ultrasound, toxicology.

Compile this into a spreadsheet:

• Columns: Program, Specialty (IM/TY/Prelim), State, IMG-friendly (Y/N), US citizen IMG notes, EM exposure notes, website, contact.

This document becomes your SOAP application blueprint.

---

Core SOAP Preparation: Documents, Narratives, and Logistics

When SOAP begins, you will not have time for heavy rewriting. The goal is to have 80–90% of your materials ready in advance.

1. Prepare Multiple Tailored Personal Statements

You should not use the exact same EM-IM combined personal statement for every SOAP application. Prepare at least three versions:

1. Primary EM-IM/EM-focused IM Personal Statement

   • Emphasize your passion for acute care, continuity of care, and dual interests.
   • Make it appropriate for categorical Internal Medicine but highlight:
     • ED rotations or EM electives.
     • Experiences in resuscitation, critical care, rapid decision-making.
     • Desire to be an internist with strong acute care skills.
   • Avoid sounding like you are only using IM as a stepping stone; focus on how IM fits your long-term goals.

2. General IM SOAP Personal Statement

   • Less emphasis on EM, more on:
     • Breadth of internal medicine.
     • Long-term continuity care.
     • Academic interests (e.g., quality improvement, teaching).
   • This is safer for more traditional IM programs that might be suspicious of someone “too EM-focused.”

3. Transitional Year / Prelim Personal Statement

   • Focus on:
     • Desire for a strong clinical foundation.
     • Readiness to work hard, adapt, and support teams across specialties.
     • Commitment to gaining broad exposure while clarifying long-term plans.
   • Still mention your interest in acute care, but frame it as part of your growth, not a distraction.

Keep each at ~650–800 words, polished and proofread. Clearly label each file so you can attach them quickly in ERAS during SOAP.

2. Update and SOAP‑Optimize Your CV and ERAS Application

Your ERAS application is essentially your SOAP application. Before Rank List certification:

• Update all experiences:
  • Add any new rotations, research, audit projects, or volunteer activities.
  • Emphasize experiences that show:
    • Teamwork under pressure.
    • Multidisciplinary collaboration (ideal for EM-IM).
    • Leadership, teaching, or QI.
• Rewrite experience descriptions to be:
  • Specific: mention case volumes, responsibilities, outcomes.
  • Outcome-oriented: “Led…” “Improved…” “Developed…” etc.
• Highlight USCE and EM/IM experiences prominently.
• Double-check for errors—typos or inconsistent dates signal poor attention to detail.

Consider including a short, clear future goals statement within your ERAS sections that emphasizes your interest in internal medicine with robust acute care and ED exposure, avoiding language that sounds like you plan to leave the specialty.

3. Secure SOAP‑Ready Letters of Recommendation

You cannot upload new LoRs once SOAP starts, so you must anticipate:

• For an EM-IM oriented backup toward IM/TY:
  • At least 2 strong IM letters (US-based if possible).
  • 1–2 letters from EM or critical care that highlight your acute care skillset but also your reliability as an intern.
• Ask letter writers to:
  • Comment on your adaptability, clinical reasoning, communication, and work ethic.
  • Avoid referencing only EM if the letter may be used for IM programs.

If possible, politely update your letter writers that you may go through SOAP and would appreciate broadly applicable letters that support both IM and acute care interests.

4. Clarify Your Story: Why IM or TY Fits an EM-IM Applicant

Programs will often ask, “You were going for EM or EM-IM; why are you now applying to Internal Medicine/Transitional Year?”

Prepare a 2–3 sentence core narrative you can use in both written communication and interviews:

• Example (IM focus):
  “I’ve always been drawn to acute care, but what I value most is continuity of care and the opportunity to follow complex patients over time. Internal Medicine gives me the breadth and depth to manage acutely ill patients while building long-term relationships and working in multidisciplinary teams. My EM and critical care experiences have strengthened my skills in rapid decision-making, which I believe will make me a stronger internist.”

• Example (TY/Prelim focus):
  “My goal is to become a well-rounded physician capable of caring for acutely ill patients in any setting. A strong Transitional Year/Prelim Medicine position will give me intensive clinical exposure, help me refine my skills under supervision, and better clarify how to integrate my interests in emergency and internal medicine into a long-term career.”

Memorize a version that feels authentic and confident.

---

SOAP Week Tactics: Step‑by‑Step Game Plan

When SOAP begins, emotions run high. As a US citizen IMG, you must stay organized and pragmatic.

1. Monday: Unmatched Status and Unfilled List

On Monday of Match Week:

• At 11:00 a.m. ET, you learn if you are:
  • Matched, partially matched, or unmatched.
• If unmatched/partially matched and SOAP‑eligible:
  • The List of Unfilled Programs appears in NRMP (limited to SOAP-eligible applicants).

YOUR TASKS:

1. Pause and stabilize emotionally. Take 30–60 minutes away from your screen if needed.
2. Open your pre‑made SOAP target spreadsheet.
3. Compare your list with the official unfilled list:
   • Check for categorical IM, Prelim IM, Transitional Year, and any EM‑adjacent programs.
   • Highlight those in your spreadsheet.
4. Prioritize programs:
   • Tier 1: Categorical IM slots (especially IMG-friendly).
   • Tier 2: TY and Prelim Medicine at hospitals with strong ED/ICU.
   • Tier 3: Other fields only if you’re open to them.

Remember: you are limited in the number of programs you can apply to during SOAP (historically up to 45, but confirm the current cycle rules). Choose wisely.

2. Monday Afternoon: Submitting SOAP Applications in ERAS

You will typically be able to start applying around 3:00 p.m. ET Monday (check official NRMP/ERAS timelines each year).

Actions:

• Assign:
  • IM-focused personal statements to IM programs.
  • TY/Prelim personal statements for prelim/TY programs.
• Double-check:
  • LoRs alignment (e.g., at least 1 or 2 IM letters to IM programs).
  • US citizen status is correctly reflected; this is an asset.

Be broad but not reckless:

• If you are strongly EM-IM oriented, prioritize IM and TY that still allow future EM involvement.
• Avoid applying exclusively to ultra-competitive university IM programs with a reputation of rarely taking IMGs—balance with community or university-affiliated community programs.

Once submitted, you cannot modify applications, so triple-check everything.

3. Tuesday to Thursday: Interview Windows

Programs review SOAP applications and invite selected candidates for short, focused interviews—usually via phone or video.

To prepare:

• Have a quiet, professional environment ready.
• Dress professionally—even for phone calls; it affects your mindset.
• Keep your core narrative visible (printed or on a sticky note).
• Review each program’s website quickly before the call for 3–4 talking points (ED exposure, ICU, teaching culture, community served).

Common SOAP interview questions for EM-IM oriented applicants:

• “Tell me about yourself.”
• “Why Internal Medicine/Transitional Year now?”
• “What happened in the Match?” (Be honest but brief; don’t criticize other programs.)
• “How will you handle the workload and adapt to our environment?”
• “Where do you see yourself in 5–10 years?”

Always:

• Emphasize gratitude for the opportunity.
• Show flexibility about location and schedule.
• Reinforce long-term commitment to excellent patient care, regardless of specialty label.

4. Thursday: Offers Rounds and Acceptance Strategy

SOAP has multiple offer rounds (often two rounds per day over several days). During each round:

• Programs submit their ranked list of SOAP applicants.
• You may receive zero, one, or multiple offers.
• You must accept or reject within the short NRMP-specified window (usually 2 hours).

Strategy for US citizen IMGs with EM-IM goals:

• If you receive a categorical IM offer at a solid, IMG‑friendly program with decent ED/ICU exposure:
  • Strongly consider accepting. It is a stable training pathway that keeps EM‑IM doors partially open through future EM collaboration or ICU/ED-focused careers.
• If you receive a Transitional Year or Prelim IM offer but no categorical IM:
  • Weigh:
    • Strength and reputation of the program.
    • Your ability and willingness to reapply for EM, EM-IM, or IM after PGY‑1.
  • For someone strongly committed to EM-IM, an excellent TY/Prelim at an EM-strong institution can still be a powerful bridge.
• If you receive multiple offers:
  • Prioritize:
    • Categorical > TY/Prelim for long-term security.
    • Programs with strong ED/ICU and supportive teaching.
    • Geographic or family considerations if important—but avoid over‑prioritizing location over training quality and match stability.

Once you accept an offer, SOAP ends for you. You cannot pursue other SOAP positions.

---

Post‑SOAP: If You Match vs. If You Don’t

If You Accept a SOAP Position

If you secure a SOAP residency:

1. Confirm details in writing:
   • Start date, orientation, credentialing requirements.
2. Express professionalism and enthusiasm:
   • Email the PD and coordinator thanking them and reaffirming your commitment.
3. Leverage the position strategically:
   • If in categorical IM:
     • Focus on excelling clinically.
     • Seek ED, ICU, and acute care elective rotations.
     • Engage in research or QI in EM, ICU, sepsis, resuscitation, or hospitalist medicine.
   • If in TY/Prelim:
     • Build strong evaluation records.
     • Network with EM and IM faculty.
     • Start planning early if you intend to reapply to EM, IM, or EM-IM.

Even if your exact EM IM combined dream is delayed, you can still build a career trajectory that matches your clinical interests (e.g., ED hospitalist, IM + ED moonlighting, critical care, etc.).

If You Do Not Match Through SOAP

If SOAP concludes without an offer:

1. Allow yourself time to process.
2. Meet with an advisor (school dean, IMG advisor, or mentor) to:
   • Analyze your application: scores, LoRs, personal statement, interview skills.
   • Identify where you realistically fit in future cycles (EM, IM, FM, TY, etc.).
3. Stay clinically active:
   • Obtain observer- or externship roles in US hospitals if you are an American studying abroad.
   • Maintain or improve Step scores (e.g., Step 3 if appropriate).
4. Strengthen your EM/IM narrative:
   • Research, QI, publications in EM, IM, or critical care.
   • Volunteering in ED-related settings or prehospital medicine (if feasible).
5. Plan for next cycle early:
   • Reassess which specialty you most strongly desire and where your credentials fit.
   • Build a fresh application strategy that includes realistic backup specialties and, again, pre-planned SOAP preparation.

---

Special Considerations for US Citizen IMGs and Americans Studying Abroad

Being a US citizen IMG gives you both advantages and unique challenges:

Advantages

• No visa sponsorship needed: Many programs list “US citizenship or permanent residency preferred.”
• Cultural familiarity: You often better understand US patient expectations, communication norms, and healthcare culture.
• Flexibility to relocate: Fewer legal constraints on where you can train.

Challenges

• Perception issues: Some PDs may ask, “Why did you attend medical school abroad?” Have a clear, honest, concise answer.
• Lack of home institution in the US: Harder to secure home EM or IM audition rotations.
• Need for stronger USCE: You must proactively get US clinical experiences to offset time spent overseas.

To mitigate these:

• Prepare a confident, non-defensive answer to “Why abroad?”:
  Example:
  “I pursued my medical education abroad to gain early clinical exposure and experience a different healthcare system. Over time, I realized my long-term goal is to train and practice in the US, which is why I focused on US rotations in Internal Medicine and Emergency Medicine to prepare for residency here.”

• Maximize every US rotation:

  • Ask for high-quality letters.
  • Build relationships with EM, IM, and program leadership.

• Use your status as a US citizen IMG as a subtle but real asset in emails and interviews—programs often appreciate not needing to navigate visas.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a US citizen IMG interested in EM IM combined, should I still rank categorical IM programs in the main Match or rely on SOAP?

You should definitely rank categorical IM programs in the main Match if they align with your interests and you are willing to train in IM. SOAP is inherently uncertain. A realistic main Match rank list that includes EM-IM (if you interviewed), EM, and categorical IM backups gives you far better odds of securing a solid position than relying on SOAP alone.

2. Can I still become an emergency medicine–oriented physician if I SOAP into categorical Internal Medicine?

Yes. Many internists build careers heavily based in acute care:

• Hospital medicine with significant ED interface.
• ICU/critical care fellowship.
• ED-based observation units, rapid response, and code teams.
• Some regions allow IM-trained physicians to work in EDs, especially smaller or rural hospitals (regulations vary).

While you may not hold the formal EM board certification, you can still construct a career that includes substantial emergency or acute care responsibilities.

3. Is it better to SOAP into a transitional year or wait and reapply next cycle to EM-IM?

For most US citizen IMGs, a good Transitional Year or Prelim Medicine position is better than sitting out completely—if you are confident you can excel and secure strong evaluations. A year without clinical training can weaken your application. However, if the only TY options are extremely weak or misaligned with your goals, and you have strong support to improve your EM-IM application from outside (e.g., research, new exams, USCE), then reapplying without a TY can be considered, though it carries more risk.

4. How can I talk about not matching EM-IM or EM during SOAP interviews without sounding negative?

Keep it brief, neutral, and focused on growth. For example:

“I applied to EM-IM and EM because I’m passionate about acute care and internal medicine. These specialties are highly competitive, and while I received interviews, I ultimately did not match. I’ve spent time reflecting and I recognize that I can pursue many of my goals through a strong Internal Medicine program, where I can continue to care for acutely ill patients, build long-term relationships, and contribute to the healthcare team. I’m fully committed to excelling wherever I match.”

Avoid blaming programs, the system, or your school. Emphasize resilience, insight, and commitment to patient care.

---

By approaching SOAP preparation as a structured, proactive process—and by understanding how your EM-IM interests can align with Internal Medicine, Transitional Year, or related options—you, as a US citizen IMG and American studying abroad, can turn a stressful week into a strategic opportunity. The key is preparation now: clear backup plans, tailored documents, and a confident, coherent narrative that shows you are ready to contribute on July 1, wherever you train.