Essential SOAP Preparation Guide for US Citizen IMGs in Dermatology

Understanding SOAP for the US Citizen IMG in Dermatology

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) can feel especially stressful for an American studying abroad who is targeting a competitive specialty like dermatology. As a US citizen IMG, you may have applied broadly and still come out of Match Week without a preliminary or transitional year, or without any position at all.

Before talking strategy, you must clearly understand what is SOAP, what it can and cannot do for your derm match goals, and how it relates to your long‑term dermatology residency strategy.

What is SOAP?

SOAP is a structured, time‑limited process run by the NRMP during Match Week for eligible unmatched or partially matched applicants. Key points:

• It allows eligible applicants to apply to unfilled, NRMP-participating residency positions.
• It occurs over several days (Monday–Thursday of Match Week).
• Applicants submit applications through ERAS (even during SOAP), but offers are made in several “Rounds” through NRMP, not directly by email from programs.
• Communication with programs is tightly regulated—violations can have serious consequences.

For a US citizen IMG in dermatology, an important reality check:

• Dermatology positions almost never appear in SOAP.
• However, SOAP can be mission‑critical for securing:
  • A preliminary or transitional year if your derm program requires it and you matched only advanced derm, or
  • A categorical position in another specialty if you did not match and want to:
    • Re-route your career plan, or
    • Build a clinical foundation (e.g., in internal medicine) and re‑apply to dermatology later.

So, SOAP preparation for a dermatology‑focused US citizen IMG is about maximizing options, salvaging this match cycle, and protecting your long‑term derm match potential.

---

Pre‑SOAP Preparation: What to Do Months Before Match Week

You should start SOAP preparation well before Match Week—ideally during interview season or earlier. Think of this as your “emergency plan” that you hope you will never need, but are grateful to have.

1. Clarify Your Dermatology Strategy and Plan B

As an American studying abroad who wants dermatology residency, start by answering:

• If you don’t match dermatology this year, what is your priority?
  • A. Any US residency position, even in a different field?
  • B. A strong clinical base to strengthen a future derm application?
  • C. A research‑heavy or gap year to improve derm competitiveness?

Your SOAP decisions will differ depending on your answer:

• Priority A (Any residency):
  You will likely use SOAP aggressively to secure any categorical spot (FM, IM, psych, peds, etc.) and may be less focused on derm‑relevant programs specifically.

• Priority B (Stronger derm re-application):
  You might target:

  • Internal medicine, pediatrics, or surgery prelims, or
  • Categorical internal medicine in a program with established dermatology or strong academic affiliations.

• Priority C (Research/gap year):
  You may participate in SOAP more selectively or even choose not to, focusing on derm research, home rotations, and publications instead. But still prepare in case you decide at the last minute to pursue a position.

Write this strategy out in advance and review it with:

• A mentor in dermatology (if available)
• An advisor at your medical school or IMG support office
• A trusted US graduate or former SOAP participant

2. Understand Eligibility and Key Timelines

To participate in SOAP, you must:

• Be registered for the NRMP Main Residency Match
• Be eligible to start residency on July 1 (graduation, ECFMG certification timeline if applicable)
• Be unmatched or partially matched when the NRMP releases Match status on Monday of Match Week

Know these key steps:

1. Monday (11 AM ET): You learn whether you are Unmatched, Partially Matched, or Fully Matched.
2. Shortly after: The list of unfilled programs becomes available (through NRMP/R3).
3. ERAS opens for SOAP applications—this is when you start sending targeted applications.
4. Rounds of SOAP offers occur Tuesday–Thursday.

As a US citizen IMG:

• Ensure your ECFMG certification status will not block you from starting July 1.
• Keep a clear, updated email and phone number in ERAS.
• Make sure you understand NRMP SOAP rules—especially about communication and offer acceptance.

3. Polish SOAP‑Specific Application Materials Ahead of Time

Even if you’re optimistic about matching dermatology, prepare a SOAP-ready version of your application early:

a. A Flexible, Non‑Dermatology Personal Statement

Many SOAP positions will not be in dermatology. Have:

• One general personal statement adaptable to:
  • Internal medicine
  • Family medicine
  • Pediatrics
  • Psychiatry
  • Transitional/preliminary year positions

This statement should:

• Highlight your clinical skills, teamwork, reliability, and adaptability.
• Emphasize traits that are attractive across specialties, not only derm.
• Avoid sounding like you’re only interested in dermatology, even if that’s ultimately your goal.

Optional: prepare a short “IM-focused” or “FM-focused” version if you think those are your most likely SOAP targets.

b. Updated Experiences and CV

Before Rank Order List certification:

• Update ERAS with:
  • Any new US clinical experience, especially dermatology-relevant rotations
  • New publications, posters, derm research
  • Teaching, leadership, and volunteer work

This helps whether you match derm now or must re-apply later.

c. Letters of Recommendation (LoRs)

For SOAP, you usually cannot add new LoRs after ERAS closes for the cycle—but you can strategically assign existing letters.

As an American studying abroad, you should:

• Secure at least:
  • 1–2 US clinical letters (even if not in derm)
  • 1–2 dermatology letters (for your initial applications and future cycles)

Make sure the non‑derm letters are from:

• Internal medicine, family medicine, pediatrics, or surgery attendings who worked with you in US clinical settings and can speak to your clinical reliability and communication skills.

d. Program Preference List and Target Map

Well before SOAP:

• Create a spreadsheet of:
  • Specialties you are willing to join in SOAP
  • Geographic preferences you can realistically consider (be flexible)
  • Programs with known IMG‑friendliness and past SOAP participation (from forums, mentors, school data)

This will speed up decision‑making when the unfilled list appears.

---

Match Week: Tactical SOAP Preparation and Execution

Once Monday of Match Week arrives and you learn your status, you must act quickly and strategically. The emotional intensity can be high—especially after an unsuccessful derm match—but preparation lets you act with clarity.

1. Process the News, Then Switch to Action Mode

If you’re an American studying abroad who has invested heavily in dermatology, not matching can be devastating. Still:

• Take 30–60 minutes to process, call a trusted friend or family member, or talk to a mentor.
• Then pivot to problem‑solving:
  • Pull out your pre‑written SOAP strategy.
  • Remind yourself: securing some position can keep you clinically active, which is valuable for any future derm match attempt.

2. Analyze the Unfilled List with a Dermatology Lens

When the unfilled list becomes available:

• Filter by:
  • Specialty
  • State/region (if relevant)
  • Program type (categorical vs prelim/transitional)

There may not be any dermatology residency programs on the list. If there are, they are often:

• New programs,
• Programs with complex situations, or
• Very rare exceptions.

More realistically, focus on specialties that:

• Are open to US citizen IMG applicants
• Provide strong grounding for dermatology or long‑term flexibility, such as:
  • Internal Medicine (categorical)
  • Pediatrics
  • Family Medicine
  • Preliminary Internal Medicine or Surgery
  • Transitional Year programs

Ask:

• Will this position:
  • Keep me clinically engaged in the US?
  • Provide teaching, research, or networking opportunities to eventually connect back to dermatology?
  • Allow me to be happy enough living and training there for at least one year?

3. Targeted Program Selection (Within Specialty and Region)

You have a limited number of SOAP applications (typically 45 total). Do not waste them.

For each unfilled program you consider, quickly assess:

• IMG‑friendliness:

  • Check if they have IMGs on current resident rosters (online).
  • Use your school’s match list if available.
  • Ask upperclassmen or alumni networks.

• Training environment and reputation:

  • University vs community vs hybrid.
  • Robustness of teaching, patient volume, and subspecialties.

• Dermatology‑relevant features (bonus, not mandatory):

  • Existence of a dermatology department or nearby derm residency.
  • Emphasis on internal medicine or pediatrics with strong outpatient experience.
  • Possibility of electives in dermatology or skin clinics.

Rank your targets internally as:

• Tier 1: Programs you’d be genuinely happy at and that strongly support your future derm goals or overall career.
• Tier 2: Solid, acceptable programs.
• Tier 3: Backup options—consider only if needed to avoid going unmatched.

Use your 45 applications strategically, with more weight on Tier 1 and Tier 2.

4. Tailoring Personal Statements and Application Assignments

When applying to SOAP positions:

• Assign the most appropriate personal statement to each specialty:

  • Internal medicine–focused for IM programs.
  • General for prelim/transitional or FM/peds if you only have one.

• Assign letters of recommendation that:

  • Preferably involve that specialty or at least inpatient US experience.
  • If all your strong letters are derm‑focused, still use them—but consider mixing with at least one general medicine/surgery letter when available.

Avoid:

• Using a highly dermatology‑exclusive personal statement for a categorical IM or FM program; it may signal you will leave at the first opportunity.

Instead, phrase your interest as:

I am particularly interested in complex chronic disease management, multidisciplinary care, and long-term patient relationships. My prior dermatology-focused experiences have strengthened my appreciation for systemic disease and the importance of collaborative care—perspectives I hope to bring to your residency.

This shows that your derm background enhances, rather than distracts from, your commitment to their specialty.

5. Communication Rules During SOAP

NRMP has strict rules about SOAP communication:

• Programs can reach out to you (email, phone, virtual meetings), but:

  • You must answer honestly.
  • You cannot solicit offers or pressure programs.

• You cannot initiate contact about unfilled positions outside what NRMP permits.

If a program contacts you:

• Be ready with a 30-second summary of who you are:
  • “I am a US citizen IMG trained at [school] with strong US clinical experience in [IM/FM/etc.]. I initially applied in dermatology and related fields, and I’m very interested in [their specialty] because…”
• Emphasize:
  • Reliability, teamwork, communication.
  • Willingness to commit to their program.
  • Genuine interest in the specialty and location.

Avoid sounding like you are using them only as a stepping stone, even if you still hope to re‑apply to derm later.

6. Handling SOAP Offers Strategically

SOAP offers come in rounds. For each round:

• You may receive:
  • No offers
  • One offer
  • Multiple offers (less common but possible)

You must:

• Accept or reject within the very limited NRMP time window (usually 2 hours).
• Once you accept, you are bound to that program (like the main Match).

As a US citizen IMG with a derm focus, think clearly:

• If you receive a prelim or transitional year:

  • This can be a good way to keep clinical momentum.
  • But you will need to re‑enter the Match for a categorical or advanced position later.

• If you receive a categorical in IM/FM/Peds/Psych:

  • This offers stability and a clear long‑term path.
  • Re‑applying to derm from a categorical program is possible but difficult and requires careful planning and program transparency.

Ask yourself, in advance:

• “If I get a categorical internal medicine spot at a decent program, will I accept it even if it means likely shifting away from dermatology permanently?”

Write down your answer now to avoid decision paralysis in the SOAP time crunch.

---

Post‑SOAP: If You Match vs If You Don’t

Your SOAP outcomes will dramatically shape your next moves, but for a US citizen IMG interested in dermatology, both scenarios require strategic planning.

1. If You Accept a SOAP Position

Once you match into a SOAP position:

• Commit fully and professionally.
  Programs invest in you; being perceived as “half‑in, half‑out” undermines your reputation.

• Build a strong foundation:

  • Show up early, be prepared, be reliable.
  • Seek feedback and actively grow.
  • Excel in ward performance and evaluations.

• Quietly and respectfully explore how this position could intersect with dermatology:

  • Ask about electives in dermatology or skin clinic.
  • Look for research opportunities (cutaneous manifestations of systemic disease, inpatient derm consults, etc.).
  • Network with any dermatologists affiliated with the hospital.

• If you still plan a future derm match attempt:

  • Be transparent but tactful with trusted faculty mentors, not with everyone.
  • Ensure you meet program obligations; burning bridges will harm you more than any additional derm publication can help.

2. If You Do Not Match in SOAP

If you emerge from SOAP without a position:

1. Take time to decompress.

   • Give yourself a few days to feel the disappointment.

2. Request specific feedback:

   • From your dermatology programs (some will respond, many will not).
   • From faculty mentors or your school’s dean’s office.
   • From trusted residents or advisors who know derm and IMG patterns.

3. Strategize your re‑application or alternate path:

   • Consider:
     • A dermatology research fellowship (paid or unpaid) at a US academic center.
     • Additional US clinical experience (sub‑internships, observerships, visiting rotations).
     • Targeted improvement in USMLE performance (if applicable) via Step 3 or score communication.
   • Strengthen your US citizen IMG profile:
     • Aim for publications, posters, case reports, especially dermatology‑related.
     • Join dermatology organizations (e.g., AAD resident/medical student sections if eligible).

4. Reassess your risk tolerance for the next application cycle:

   • Apply dermatology only vs derm plus a backup specialty vs a backup specialty alone.
   • Many American studying abroad candidates ultimately match well outside derm and build satisfying careers.

---

Practical Tips Specific to US Citizen IMG Dermatology Aspirants

To align SOAP with a long‑term dermatology residency goal:

• Maximize US clinical exposure before Match Week:
  • Strong letters and US experience will help both in SOAP and future cycles.
• Use your derm background as a strength, not a limitation:
  • For non‑derm specialties, emphasize that dermatology taught you:
    • Detailed observation skills
    • Long‑term patient relationships
    • Attention to systemic manifestations of disease
• Stay realistic about derm match odds:
  • Dermatology is one of the most competitive specialties.
  • A SOAP categorical IM or FM position might represent a great, stable career path.
• Protect your professional reputation:
  • How you handle SOAP—your communication, honesty, and professionalism—will follow you.
  • Do not disparage programs or the process in emails or social media.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. As a US citizen IMG, how likely is it that I’ll find a dermatology residency position in SOAP?

Realistically, very unlikely. Dermatology programs almost always fill during the main Match. Your SOAP strategy should focus on:

• Preliminary or transitional year programs that keep you clinically active.
• Categorical positions in specialties like IM, FM, or pediatrics where you can cultivate skills and maybe develop dermatology‑related interests or research.

Treat any derm position that appears in SOAP as an extraordinary exception, not something to rely on.

2. If I accept an internal medicine categorical spot in SOAP, can I still re‑apply to dermatology later?

It is possible but challenging:

• You’ll need:
  • Exceptional performance as an IM resident.
  • Strong derm research and networking.
  • Honest, supportive program leadership.
• Some residents have transitioned, but:
  • It’s rare.
  • It may require giving up a secure track and starting training over.

If you are strongly derm‑committed, weigh this carefully before accepting a categorical spot; still, many physicians discover deep satisfaction in the specialty they ultimately pursue.

3. What is SOAP preparation I should prioritize if I’m short on time?

If you are near Match Week and time is limited, focus on:

1. A solid general personal statement suitable for IM/FM/Peds/Prelim/Transitional.
2. Updated ERAS entries with all US clinical experiences and any derm research.
3. Letters of recommendation from US attendings (any core specialty).
4. A personal priority list of:
   • Specialties you’re willing to join via SOAP.
   • Geographic areas you’d accept.
5. Basic knowledge of NRMP SOAP rules and timelines so you don’t violate policies or miss offers.

4. Is it ever reasonable to skip SOAP and re‑apply to dermatology next year instead?

Yes, in selected circumstances:

• If you have:
  • A strong plan for a derm research fellowship,
  • Robust funding or visa/financial stability, and
  • Clear mentorship at a US academic center.
• Or if you believe:
  • Available SOAP positions do not align with your long‑term goals or living constraints.

However:

• Skipping SOAP leaves you with no guaranteed clinical role for the coming year.
• For many US citizen IMG applicants, some US clinical position (even outside derm) is better than none, both for experience and for future applications.

Discuss this decision with advisors and mentors who know your full academic and personal context before finalizing your plan.

---

Preparing thoroughly for SOAP as a US citizen IMG in dermatology is less about “finding a derm spot” and more about protecting your career trajectory, preserving options, and setting up a strong platform—whether that leads back to dermatology or into another rewarding specialty. Thoughtful SOAP preparation now will make Match Week more controlled, more strategic, and far less chaotic.