Ultimate Guide to SOAP Preparation for MD Graduates in General Surgery

Understanding SOAP for the General Surgery–Bound MD Graduate

For an MD graduate targeting general surgery residency, the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) can feel like a high‑pressure, last‑chance scramble. In reality, the SOAP residency process is structured, rule‑bound, and highly winnable—if you prepare early and approach it strategically.

This article walks you step‑by‑step through SOAP preparation specifically for MD graduates who are aiming for general surgery residency. We’ll cover what SOAP is, how the allopathic medical school match interacts with SOAP, how to build a SOAP‑ready application for surgery, and how to navigate the interview and offer periods.

Throughout, you’ll see the keywords and concepts most relevant to your situation: MD graduate residency pathways, the surgery residency match, SOAP preparation timelines, and how to optimize your chances of landing a categorical or preliminary general surgery residency spot.

---

1. What is SOAP and How Does It Fit into the Match?

1.1 Defining SOAP in the Residency Match

SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) is the formal, NRMP‑run process that allows unmatched or partially matched applicants to obtain unfilled residency positions during Match Week.

In other words, if you’re an MD graduate who does not match on Monday of Match Week—either into any specialty or into your desired general surgery residency—you may be eligible to participate in SOAP.

Key points:

• SOAP is not a separate match. It is an extension of the main NRMP Match process.
• SOAP is structured and time‑limited. There are specific windows for:
  • Viewing unfilled positions
  • Submitting applications
  • Interviewing
  • Receiving and responding to offers (multiple rounds)
• All communication is regulated. Programs and applicants must follow strict NRMP rules to avoid violations.

1.2 Who Is Eligible for SOAP?

As an MD graduate, you are typically eligible for SOAP if:

• You registered for the NRMP Match.
• You are partially matched (e.g., matched to an advanced position but not a preliminary year) or unmatched when results are released Monday of Match Week.
• You are ERAS‑participating and meet all institutional and NRMP requirements.

Your NRMP status will explicitly state whether you are SOAP‑eligible. Check this immediately on Monday of Match Week.

1.3 How SOAP Interacts with the General Surgery Residency Match

For surgery residency match candidates, SOAP can affect you in a few different ways:

1. Unmatched categorical general surgery applicants

   • You may use SOAP to:
     • Target unfilled categorical general surgery positions (rare, but they exist).
     • Target preliminary general surgery positions, which can be valuable entry points into the field.

2. Matched to a preliminary surgery position but wanted categorical

   • If you are already matched into a preliminary general surgery residency, you typically cannot SOAP in the same year, even if you hoped for categorical.
   • In future cycles, you can re‑enter the allopathic medical school match or SOAP with a stronger application.

3. Matched to an advanced position (e.g., anesthesia, radiology) but no PGY‑1

   • You may participate in SOAP to secure a PGY‑1 preliminary year, possibly in surgery.

1.4 Categorical vs Preliminary General Surgery in SOAP

Understanding these categories is critical for your SOAP strategy:

• Categorical General Surgery

  • Designed to take you from PGY‑1 through completion of training.
  • Highly competitive; few spots remain unfilled by SOAP.
  • Excellent if available and you’re a strong candidate.

• Preliminary General Surgery

  • One‑year positions; do not guarantee progression in that program.
  • Serve as:
    • A bridge year for advanced specialties.
    • An on‑ramp to re‑apply to categorical general surgery or related fields with stronger credentials.
  • Commonly available in SOAP, especially in community or smaller academic programs.

For MD graduate residency applicants who are determined to pursue general surgery, a preliminary surgery position obtained through SOAP can be a powerful stepping stone, provided you go in with a clear plan to leverage it.

---

2. Pre‑Match SOAP Preparation: What to Do Before Results Day

The strongest SOAP candidates do most of their work before Match Week. You cannot predict the future, but you can be ready for all scenarios.

2.1 Adopt a Dual‑Track Mindset

As an MD graduate, you should hope for a successful allopathic medical school match while also preparing for the possibility of SOAP. This dual‑track approach prevents panic and last‑minute scrambling.

Ask yourself early:

• If I don’t match in general surgery, am I:
  • Willing to accept a preliminary general surgery position?
  • Open to adjacent fields (e.g., internal medicine, transitional year, preliminary medicine) as a bridge to future surgery applications?
  • Willing to consider programs in broad geographic areas, including community hospitals and less familiar regions?

Write down a prioritized list of acceptable options—from most ideal (categorical GS) to least ideal but still acceptable (certain prelim options). You will refer back to this in SOAP.

2.2 Optimize Your ERAS Application for SOAP

Your ERAS file is the backbone of your SOAP residency applications. During SOAP, you cannot rewrite large sections in real time, so prepare now.

Key elements to review:

1. Personal Statement(s)

   • Draft:
     • A primary general surgery personal statement (if you haven’t already).
     • A flexible/backup statement that emphasizes:
       • Core clinical skills
       • Work ethic
       • Teamwork and communication
       • Open interest in broader clinical training environments
   • For SOAP, you may upload additional specialty‑specific PS if you anticipate applying outside general surgery (e.g., internal medicine, prelim medicine, transitional year).

2. CV and Experiences

   • Highlight:
     • General surgery rotations and sub‑I’s.
     • Research or QI projects related to surgery.
     • Procedural exposure or OR experiences.
     • Leadership roles that demonstrate resilience and responsibility.
   • Ensure all entries:
     • Are clearly written.
     • Include measurable outcomes where possible (e.g., “Presented at regional surgical conference”).

3. USMLE or COMLEX Scores

   • You can’t change these, but you can:
     • Make sure all passing attempts are available and correctly uploaded.
     • Be prepared to discuss any failures or gaps calmly and strategically in SOAP interviews.

4. Letters of Recommendation (LoRs)

   • Before rank list certification, obtain:
     • At least 2–3 strong surgery letters.
     • 1–2 additional letters that emphasize general clinical competency (from internal medicine, critical care, etc.), in case you need to SOAP into non‑surgical tracks.
   • Be sure all LoRs are uploaded in ERAS and assigned flexibly so you can quickly reassign them during SOAP.

2.3 Build a Targeted SOAP Program List in Advance

You won’t know exactly which programs will be unfilled, but you can build a preliminary target list to speed decisions.

For general surgery–focused SOAP preparation:

• Identify:

  • Programs historically offering prelim general surgery or categorical surgery positions in SOAP.
  • Institutions where your school or mentors have connections.
  • Regions you are willing to move to on short notice.

• For each program on your radar:

  • Note whether they typically:
    • Take MD graduates into prelim positions with the possibility of later categorical conversion.
    • Have robust mentorship and case volume.
    • Have graduated previous SOAP or prelim residents into categorical surgery or surgical subspecialties.

This research allows you to move quickly once the SOAP list of unfilled programs is released.

2.4 Prepare Documents Specifically for SOAP

In addition to your existing ERAS content, prepare:

• SOAP‑specific personal statement variants, for:

  • General surgery preliminary positions.
  • Transitional or prelim medicine (if these are acceptable backups).

• A short, adaptable “interest paragraph” you can turn into:

  • Email templates (if permitted).
  • Talking points in interviews (e.g., “Why our program?” in 60–90 seconds).

• A professional CV or one‑page summary:

  • Not always required, but can be handy if a program director or coordinator requests additional information within the rules.

---

3. Strategy for MD Graduates Targeting General Surgery in SOAP

Once you know you are SOAP‑eligible and see the list of unfilled positions, you have to rapidly convert planning into action.

3.1 Analyzing the Unfilled Positions List

On Monday of Match Week, after SOAP eligibility is released, you’ll gain access to the list of unfilled programs via NRMP.

For a surgery‑focused MD graduate, filter and categorize quickly:

1. Categorical General Surgery Programs

   • High priority if:
     • You have strong clinical evaluations and solid letters.
     • Your Step scores are in a competitive range.
   • Expect very high competition.

2. Preliminary General Surgery Programs

   • Realistic and often abundant.
   • Prioritize:
     • Programs with a track record of converting strong prelims to categorical positions (in their own or partner institutions).
     • Places with strong operative volume and didactics.

3. Transitional Year / Prelim Medicine

   • Consider if:
     • You are open to a longer‑term path to surgery.
     • You want a broad PGY‑1 base year that keeps multiple options open.
   • Rank them below direct general surgery options but above having no position at all.

Create a tiered list (Tier 1: ideal, Tier 2: acceptable, Tier 3: last resort) based on your predetermined preferences and current list.

3.2 Application Allocation Strategy in SOAP

In SOAP, you have a limited number of applications per round (usually 45 total programs across the entire SOAP process, though check current NRMP rules).

For a general surgery–focused MD graduate, a typical allocation might be:

• Tier 1 (High Priority)
  • Categorical general surgery (if available)
  • Top‑fit prelim general surgery programs
• Tier 2
  • Additional prelim general surgery in a wide range of locations
• Tier 3
  • Transitional year and prelim internal medicine programs (if part of your backup plan)

Tips:

• Avoid casting your net too narrowly (e.g., only big‑name academic centers).
• Avoid the opposite extreme: applying to every unfilled spot without thought. Focus on places where you:
  • Realistically meet minimum criteria.
  • Could see yourself working hard for a full year.

3.3 Tailoring Your Application for General Surgery SOAP

Within ERAS, you can customize:

1. Personal Statement Assignment

   • Use your general surgery‑focused statement for:
     • Categorical and prelim general surgery programs.
   • Use your more general or medicine‑oriented statement for:
     • Transitional year or prelim medicine positions.

2. Letter Assignments

   • For general surgery programs:
     • Assign at least 2 strong surgery letters, plus:
       • A dean’s letter / MSPE.
       • Any additional letters that support your clinical skill and professionalism.
   • For non‑surgery prelims:
     • Include at least one letter from internal medicine, family medicine, or another broad discipline if available.

3. Program‑Specific Customization

   • Within the constraints of time, adjust:
     • Personal statements: a short added paragraph (if time permits) referencing specific program strengths (e.g., trauma exposure, community focus, academic affiliation).

---

4. Interviewing During SOAP: Presenting Yourself as a Strong General Surgery Candidate

Once your SOAP applications are submitted, programs can review files and schedule brief, often virtual interviews. These can be short—sometimes only 10–20 minutes—so you must be concise and focused.

4.1 Core Themes for General Surgery SOAP Interviews

As an MD graduate seeking general surgery residency, you should emphasize:

1. Preparedness for the Demands of Surgery

   • Long hours, high acuity, fast decision‑making.
   • Examples:
     • “During my surgery sub‑I, I consistently volunteered to stay late to follow post‑op patients and assist with emergency cases.”

2. Teamwork and Communication

   • Describe how you collaborate with:
     • Nurses
     • Anesthesia
     • OR staff
   • Example:
     • “In the SICU, I made it a point to update families daily and coordinate changes with the nursing team promptly.”

3. Coachability and Growth Mindset

   • Program directors want residents who:
     • Accept feedback.
     • Improve rapidly.
   • Example:
     • “After feedback on my handoff structure, I implemented a standardized format and saw fewer communication errors.”

4. Professionalism and Reliability

   • Stress:
     • On‑time performance.
     • Ownership of patients.
     • Integrity in documentation.

4.2 Addressing the Unmatched Status Honestly

You will almost certainly be asked: “Why do you think you went unmatched?” or “Tell us about your match outcome.”

Respond with:

• Honesty without self‑sabotage

  • Examples:
    • “I applied exclusively to highly competitive academic categorical general surgery programs and ranked relatively few community programs. In hindsight, I was too narrow in my strategy.”
    • “A Step 1 failure earlier in my training limited initial interview offers, despite steady improvement and a strong Step 2 score.”

• Reflection and growth

  • “This has pushed me to re‑evaluate my approach, seek additional feedback, and be more flexible in my path to general surgery.”

• Reassurance

  • Emphasize:
    • Strong clinical evaluations.
    • Improved performance across later rotations.
    • Concrete steps you’ve taken to address past weaknesses.

4.3 Questions You Should Ask Programs in SOAP

Even in SOAP, you are choosing a formative professional environment. Ask targeted, efficient questions such as:

• For prelim general surgery positions:

  • “What percentage of your prelims typically go on to categorical surgery, either here or elsewhere?”
  • “How is the prelim schedule structured compared to categorical residents?”
  • “What mentorship or advising is available to prelims seeking categorical positions?”

• For programs with heavy service loads:

  • “How do you balance service needs with resident education, particularly operative exposure for interns?”

• For all programs:

  • “What qualities have made your most successful residents stand out?”
  • “What support systems exist for resident wellness and burnout prevention?”

Record answers so that, when offers arrive, your decisions are grounded and not purely emotional.

---

5. Offers, Acceptances, and Post‑SOAP Planning

SOAP includes several offer rounds over Wednesday and Thursday of Match Week. Each round, programs issue offers via NRMP, and you must accept or decline within a short window.

5.1 Understanding SOAP Offer Rounds

General principles (always verify current NRMP rules):

• You may receive multiple offers across rounds.
• You can accept only one at a time.
• Once you accept a position:
  • You are contractually committed to that program.
  • You are effectively withdrawn from further SOAP activity.

For an MD graduate aiming at general surgery, decide in advance:

• Under what circumstances would you accept:
  • A categorical general surgery position?
  • A prelim general surgery position at a highly desirable institution?
  • A prelim general surgery position at a smaller or less known site?
  • A non‑surgery prelim or transitional spot?

Having a written hierarchy before offers start will help you avoid indecision under pressure.

5.2 Prioritizing Offers: Practical Examples

Imagine the following options arrive across SOAP rounds:

• Offer A: Categorical general surgery at a small community hospital in a region far from family.
• Offer B: Prelim general surgery at a respected academic center with a strong track record of moving prelims into categorical spots.
• Offer C: Transitional year at a well‑known academic institution, but with uncertain surgery pathways.

How you prioritize might depend on:

• Your long‑term certainty about general surgery.
• Your appetite for risk and delayed gratification.

Common approaches:

• If you are 100% committed to general surgery:
  • Categorical general surgery (Offer A) is usually the top choice, even if location is suboptimal.
• If you are willing to gamble on a stronger future outcome:
  • A highly connected prelim surgery position (Offer B) may, for a very strong candidate, be worth considering over a weaker categorical spot—though this is more risky.
• Transitional year (Offer C):
  • Often ranked below direct surgery options but can be an excellent choice if:
    • You are open to multiple specialties.
    • You want more time to clarify your ultimate direction while staying clinically active.

5.3 If You Do Not Secure a Surgery Position in SOAP

Not all MD graduates entering SOAP will secure general surgery–related positions. If that happens:

1. Finish SOAP with professionalism.

   • Do not send angry emails or burn bridges.
   • Program directors talk to each other; your behavior now affects future cycles.

2. Meet promptly with advisors and mentors.

   • Review your application with:
     • A surgery faculty mentor.
     • Your dean’s office or career advisor.
   • Identify specific weaknesses:
     • Limited interviews due to scores?
     • Poor narrative letters?
     • Narrow program list?

3. Consider Gap‑Year Options That Strengthen a Future Application

   • Dedicated surgical research fellowships.
   • Clinical roles (e.g., surgical assistant, hospitalist scribe, or other clinical positions consistent with regulations).
   • Additional sub‑internships or observerships (where permitted) to gather stronger letters.

4. Plan for the Next Allopathic Medical School Match

   • Reapply with:
     • Updated experiences.
     • New letters.
     • Broader and more strategic program list.
   • Consider initial application to prelim surgery or related fields, with realistic expectations.

---

6. Long‑Term Perspective: Using SOAP as a Strategic Step, Not a Failure

For many MD graduates, not matching in general surgery on the first attempt feels devastating. Yet a significant number of practicing surgeons today:

• Started in prelim general surgery positions.
• Entered surgery pathways after initial matches in different specialties.
• Used research or transitory years to re‑strengthen their candidacy.

Key mindset shifts:

• SOAP is a structured opportunity, not a consolation prize.
  • It exists because unfilled positions need committed and capable residents—often in high‑functioning, busy surgical departments.
• A preliminary year is not “just service.”
  • With proactive mentorship and hard work, a prelim year can:
    • Build your reputation as a dependable surgical intern.
    • Lead to letters that are far more impactful than medical school references.
• You retain agency.
  • You control:
    • How professionally you conduct yourself in SOAP.
    • How you interpret feedback from this cycle.
    • How aggressively and thoughtfully you plan for long‑term surgical training.

---

FAQs About SOAP Preparation for MD Graduates in General Surgery

1. I’m an MD graduate who wants general surgery. Should I apply only to surgery programs in SOAP?

Usually no. While you should prioritize general surgery (categorical and prelim) if that is your goal, limiting yourself exclusively to surgery programs in SOAP can be risky if you:

• Have borderline exam scores.
• Have limited interview experience.
• See only a small number of unfilled surgery programs.

Most advisors recommend a tiered plan: target as many realistically attainable general surgery positions as possible, then add transitional year or prelim medicine programs as backups so you do not end up without any PGY‑1 position.

2. How competitive is it to get a general surgery residency through SOAP?

The surgery residency match is one of the more competitive fields, and categorical spots almost always fill in the main Match. Through SOAP:

• Categorical general surgery positions are rare and very competitive.
• Prelim general surgery positions are more commonly available but still attract many strong applicants.

As an MD graduate, your advantage is that many programs are comfortable with the training background from an allopathic medical school. Strong clinical evaluations, clear commitment to surgery, and professionalism during SOAP are crucial.

3. What should I say in my personal statement for SOAP if I already used a surgery PS during the main match?

You can re‑use your main general surgery personal statement in SOAP, especially if it’s strong and focused. Consider adding or preparing a slightly revised version that:

• Acknowledges your ongoing commitment to surgery.
• Emphasizes resilience and reflection after the initial match outcome.
• Highlights your flexibility in pursuing prelim general surgery or strong clinical training that keeps you surgery‑oriented.

For non‑surgery programs (e.g., transitional year), use a more general clinical statement emphasizing adaptability, teamwork, and broad internal medicine skills.

4. If I accept a prelim general surgery spot in SOAP, how can I maximize my chances of getting a categorical position later?

Use your prelim year strategically:

• Perform like a top categorical intern:
  • Be punctual, reliable, and proactive.
  • Own your patients and follow through on tasks.
• Seek mentorship early:
  • Meet with the program director and key faculty to express your desire for a categorical surgery position.
• Build a track record:
  • Aim for strong written evaluations and letters.
  • Participate in research or QI projects where feasible.
• Network externally:
  • Attend local or regional surgical meetings.
  • Build relationships that can support future applications.

Many surgeons have followed this path successfully; a strong prelim year can transform your profile in the next application cycle.

---

By approaching SOAP with early preparation, clear priorities, and realistic flexibility, an MD graduate can significantly improve their chances of securing a position connected to general surgery—and of ultimately achieving a long‑term career in the specialty.